Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Yifang Xu
Question
Sub-question: What are obstacles you face in the way to your success?
I think if you ask a person: “Do you want to succeed?” Everyone’s answer will be
“YES!” We all want to succeed. However, only few of people know what success means to them
— the definition that only suitable for themselves. We are always chasing for success, and
usually the process of being successful is struggling, confusing, and even misleading.
Throughout history, on the one hand, the popular definition of success, to some extent, is simple
and narrow: Fame and Gain. On the other hand, if you are rich or have power, people will label
you as a successful person. Therefore, there are lots of people spending their whole lives chasing
for these two things, only to find that actually there is no the other shore for them to reach. As a
result, when they reflect their lives, they mostly complain that if they were as lucky as those
celebrities, they should succeed. What makes them mediocrity is simply because of their bad
luck.
made by yourself. Set myself as an example. My definition for success is always changing with
my growing up. When I was in middle school, my success means I can get over my fear toward
running. When I was in high school, my success means I can go to a top university in the future.
When I was in university, my success means I can make more people know me. Gradually, I
found that success is a kind of goal that you are going to chasing for, and at different periods,
you have different goals. Before, I used to attach great importance to the result, like if I did not
win the prize, it means that I fail. After, I realized that the more significant thing is the process of
3
working for it, rather than the mere result. I enjoyed the process of chasing and working for my
success, and when I get there, I will be comfortable and happy, but not extremely excited,
because to some extent, I can anticipate the outcome as my process progressing. I enjoy more on
the progressing process than the determining result. I am working for the success defined by
When we talk about the success, it comes up with a question that how to define our own
success? I once talked about it with my professor Curt Smith when I was an exchange student in
the University of Rochester. I appreciated his answers very much. He said: “Well, I did lots of
different jobs in my previous life — a speechwriter for George H.W. Bush Administration, a
reporter, numerous books’ writer, an editor, a host, and now a professor. I feel so fortunate that I
am always doing the thing that I wanted to do when I was 7-year-old, which is READING and
WRITING.” It makes me think that a person’s success originates from his/her/they self-
motivation, his/her/they interest, and his/her/they love for doing a thing. Unfortunately, in
contemporary society, there are lots of people knowing exactly the aspects that they are bad at,
but cannot tell the one that they love, adept at, or what society needs. Therefore, they live a life
of idling, always looking for the success which defined by the secular world, but gradually losing
I hope by exploring this inquiry “What does success mean to you?”, students can find
their interests and goals at different life periods, chasing for it with a determined mind without
any hesitation. Besides, by reading children’s literatures in finding success, they can also develop
their diverse critical thinking. And finally, they will find that they realize a kind of success that
could not be duplicated but recognized by others. In my view, we are always in the way of
achieving success, and in the process of living a peaceful and meaningful inner world.
4
Curated Booklist
Alexander, K., & Anyabwile, D. (2014). The crossover. Boston; New York: Houghton Mifflin
Harcourt.
Alexander, K., & Nelson, K. (2019). The undefeated. Boston; New York: Houghton Mifflin
Harcourt.
Brown, D. (2018). The unwanted: Stories of the Syrian refugees. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers.
Lindstrom, C., & Goade, M. We are water protectors. Roaring Brook Press.
Méndez, Y. Saied, & Kim, J. Where are you from?. An Imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers.
Muhammad, I. (2019). The proudest blue: A story of hijab and family. Little, Brown Books for
Young Readers.
General introduction
My potential audience are children ranging from 3rd grade in elementary school to 6th
grade in middle school. The 12 books I selected here have multiple genres: picturebooks, poetry,
historical fictions, wordless books, imagination and fantasy, and books including self-biography.
Besides, these books include multiple theoretical lenses: bilingual literacies, critical multicultural
broad age span with deep-meaning texts, discussing with children that “success” is always
meaningful and have diverse understanding at different ages in different social contexts.
Rationales
HarperCollinsPublishers.
Genre Picturebook
Invites students to build confidence and trust themselves at the beginning of chasing for
success. This is a picturebook suitable for children aged between 4 to 8. It talks about a question
that a little brown girl at the beginning was questioned by her peers and adults that she does not
belong to here. After asking her grandpa (Abuelo), she finds her own answer: She comes from
“all of us”.
To begin with, when talking about the educational pedagogy, I stand from the perspective
of bilingual literacies. This book offers two version—both Spanish and English. According to
García (2020), “[B]ilingual readers leverage all of their meaning-making resources and all of
themselves as they engage with text (p.557)”. It means that while students are learning, they will
use multimodal tools, such as verbal, visual, audio, and body gestures to be fully engaged into
the classroom. As a teacher, I will build my classroom as a social practice place for them, not
only to link their past experiences, but also find their self-identity by working and negotiating in
multimodalities. Secondly, even in the English version, there are some Spanish words in the
book. Since the relationship between pictures and verbal is expanding, which means that not only
6
visual support the verbal, but also verbal depends on visual (Sipe, 2012). The illustration will
help children to understand and imagine the world that writer described in the book. Thirdly, the
characters in the book have different color skins. I think this can provide students a multicultural
lens that they not only see themselves in the book, but also being inspired to be more engaged in
this world with a critical and sensitive discernment (Thomas, 2016). And by cooperating and
interconnecting with other people from different races and ethnicities, they will finally find their
own self-identity and feel that they are an integral part of this country.
Secondly, the reason that I select it as a book to discuss the inquiry question is that I think
chasing for our own success firstly can invite students to find their own “true” identity. This
book tells children that no matter which race, ethnicity, or country you are from, you are the
unique and special one. By finding and identifying themselves in the society, children may feel
that they are recognized by both themselves and others, building a strong confidence—basic
2. Lindstrom, C., & Goade, M. We are water protectors. Roaring Brook Press.
Genre Picturebook
Invites students to think about the good characteristics in chasing for success and the
relationship between success and environment. Inspired by the many Indigenous-led movements
across North America, this book talks about the indigenous people’s affection with the earth.
And water is a sacred source for them to relate themselves with the nature. While reading this
book, it not only discusses the critical problem about protecting environment, but also honors the
7
community, spirit, and diversity of the indigenous people. Generally, this book is more suitable
As for illustration, the colorful watercolors, such as the repetitive page, which talks about
“We stand, with our songs, and our drums. We are still here.”, involves an act of re-reading
(Moebius, 1986). The scenes appear many times, making children reflect the book back and
forth, deepening the impression of the children, and thus they will be able to better understand
the rich culture of indigenous people. Besides, the symbolism which makes snack represent the
evil behaviors that human did to nature, and the theme color blue, all leading children into the
scene and feeling that they are a certain character relative to the story (Sipe, 1998).
As for the interwoven between success and theoretical lenses, firstly starting from critical
indigenous literacy, students can directly feel the deep affection that indigenous people have with
the nature. Their great attachment to the nature, their perseverance in protecting the nature, and
their solidarity among the community, these are all the values that usually being neglected, but
should be valued and respected. I think these characteristics are also important factors that could
enhance a person’s success, like how to collaborate with others in a group, how to have mutual
respecting and understanding, and the insistency and perseverance while facing difficulties.
Secondly, this book also talks about the environment protection, which allows children to go into
the nature physically (Harju & Rouse, 2017), foster a connection with it, and then understand the
meaning of living together. Reflecting history, we had so many successes that built on the
sacrificing of environment. By reading this book, it will stimulate children’s thinking about the
importance of concerning for all well-beings, because human beings is a small but inalienable
part of it.
Undocumented talks about a story centered on a Mexican man Juan who came to U.S. with
chasing for more job opportunities. After arriving America, Juan lived in a poor community and
worked hard to make a living. He did lots of different jobs, such as dishwasher, shop assistance,
He is struggling between being reported of his undocumented paper with fighting against unfair
treatment.
This is a problem that is tricky and controversial, especially after the building of the border wall
by previous president administration, and the new immigration policy toward Mexicans. As
Nodelman (1996) defined, children’s books usually assume children are naïve and innocent, thus
protecting them from the “sins of a corrupt world (p.75)”. Therefore, sometimes adults neglect
attaching importance to how children understand this world by themselves. Beckett (2017)
suggested that Crossover books can provide children with “a new relationship to childhood, an
openness to new modes of expression, and a critical view of the world. (p.6)”
In Undocumented, when parents and teachers use them as a resource for talking about the
success, they can lead children think from others’ perspectives: What does success count to
them? By reading this book together, adults can guide children to broaden the definition of
success, let children jump out of their personal definition in success and stand in others’ points.
In this way, children may know that success is not a personal decided concept, and could
9
critically absorb others’ understandings in success. In this book, we can explore various
4. Brown, D. (2018). The unwanted: Stories of the Syrian refugees. Houghton Mifflin
Harcourt.
subjects
Invites students to think about success in the multidimensional sociology. The unwanted
is also a book argues about the Refugee problems. Starting from 2011, lots of Syrian refugees
flood out of their own countries, running to other countries for seeking for a better life. The
author describes the problems they faced during the fleeing way, and the courage and resilience
This graphic/comic book has a rich topic based on refugee and worth exploring, such as
background narration. In my views, I think this setting introduction is helpful for children to
learn history through a graphic/comic book, because it offers children more information about
history, facilitating them a comprehensive understanding of manners, values, and general cultural
environment (Nikolajeva, 2002). Therefore, following the previous book Undocumented, this
As for the connection to success, this book is a good example to explore success in a
multidimensional society. It shows kids how they can critically leverage their “identities,
multiliteracies, and lived experiences (Thakurta, 2021, p,654)” to look the definition of success.
10
In children’s world, sometimes they presumably assume that efforts will eventually be paid off.
However, other components and factor which originate from society may impact their
hardworking to success, and are even hard to handle or control. This book gives a way for
Invites disabled students to discuss success. This book revolves around four children.
Virgil Salinas is a kind and introvert boy who feels himself is an outsider of a crazy-about-sports
family. Valencia Somerset is a clever, smart, and brave girl, but unfortunately with disability
deaf. Compared with being friends with others, she would like to stay alone and make friends
with animals. She loves nature very much. Kaori Tanaks self-defined as a psychic, but her little
sister Gen is her only client. And Chet Bullens is the biggest bully in the neighborhood. They are
not friends and even do not know each other at the beginning. However, when Chet throws
Virgil’s backpack into a dry well, where Virgil’s Gulliver was inside, four children’s lives
I think this book manifest a main topic — disability. Since Valencia is deaf, Chet bullied
her without any shame. In our daily lives, we usually see children with disabilities are shy, timid,
and always forbearing when they face difficulties and inequity. And in classroom, teachers
11
usually label them as disabled children when they come in, directly making this group kids feel
the “emotions of loose, shock, and pity at how dreadful it is to be disabled. (Sievers, 2008, p.30)”
In teaching pedagogy with success, it is a book that can be used to challenge the deficit
definition, making all children have a more inclusive, respectful, and understandable attitude in
the teamwork, not only toward themselves, but also for others. In addition, specifically standing
from the perspective of physically disabled children, this book could give them huge courage in
the way for looking for their own success. Sometimes, success is not something big one, but for
example the one that you are confident to express yourself and work with others.
Genre Novel
introducing George, who was regarded by rest of the world as boy, but she defined herself as
a girl — Melissa. With her supportive friend Kelly, Melissa used the play Charlotte’s Web
not only find her “true” self, but also confidently showed it to others.
Hermann-Wilmarth and Ryan (2019) described that “we are always becoming
through negotiated interactions. (p.7)” I think George is a book that can facilitate kids in
LGBTQ+ group to find and define themselves. As teachers and educators, this will be a
productive book to talk about transgender topic in success. For example, what kind of
attitudes are you going to have if there are transgender group members in your team? If you
are a transgender kid, what is the way for you to achieve your success? I think for
transgender students, this book is helpful for them to build up their confidence and be
12
integrated with other group students. It will help transgender students feel at ease that they
are treated equally and being protected in their way for chasing success.
Invites students to think about family relationship in success. This book talks about the
boy Josh, who is a 12-year-old student at Reggie Lewis Middle School. He has a twin brother
Jordan “JB” Bell, and both love playing basketball and are professional basketball players.
However, with JB starts to spend more time with girls and their father’s hiding health issue, the
Firstly, I think it is hard to make a definition for genre of this book. All the words in the
book are capitalized and written in verse. Vivid illustrations help children better understand the
plot. There is no boundary between the verbal and the visual. There are some collage forms
manifested in the book. The reason I define it as multimodal is that readers need to combine
images, written language, and other semiotic features to understand and construct the meanings
(Serafini, Kachorsky & Reid, 2018). Secondly, I appreciate the color selection of this book, for
that there is only two colors — orange and grey, and orange symbolize the basketball dream that
Josh always has. Between the sharp contrast, it further highlights the theme — the relationship
In the definition of success, sometimes we are so obsessed with success that we ignore
the inside relationships. In this book, Father Chuck Bell fully supported his son's dream, even
13
neglecting his own health. Also, the brotherhood between JB and Josh starting from bonding,
and then resulting in unraveling. Josh thinks that he is more successful than JB for that he won
the basketball games but found that he is further in affection with his brother. It is a meaningful
book to talk about success from the point of relationship and emotion. As teachers, we can lead
kids to discuss that is it a kind of success at the expense of sacrificing affections? How to balance
In addition, there are lots of allusions in the book, such as alluding famous basketball
player Michael Jordan, famous rappers Kanye West, and jazz musicians John Coltrane. These
elements could attract children’s eyes and build a bridge between their lives and the book,
8. Alexander, K., & Nelson, K. (2019). The undefeated. Boston; New York: Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt.
Genre Picturebook
African American history, talking about slavery, the civil rights movement, and Black Lives
Matter. Besides, it emphasizes the African American achievements in numerous fields, such
as sports, literatures, music, and politics. The author not only extol the famous people that
known by public, but also those who are ordinary yet selfless dedication. The painful history
should not be forgotten. At the end of the book, there is an introductory endnote for
Usually, young children’s’ literatures do not frequently deal with the dense history,
not only because adults think that children are too naïve to receive these heavy topics, but
also they do not know how to teach them in a way that children are likely to understand and
accept. I think this book discusses history with children in both narrative and acceptable way.
By reading this book, children can learn history about African American from a critical
perspective, know about their courage and persistency while facing adversity, and gradually
develop their own historical judgment. One of the goals of learning history by reading
picturebook is that children can interpret and involve moral issues by searching for “truth”
(Levstik, 1993). And in this book, the “truth” is connected with “success”, because standing
at the perspective of storytelling about African American, students can learn good
Invites students to think about success in feminism. The connection between Sylvia
and Aki started from Aki’s doll. After the attack on Pearl Harbour, Aki’s family were sent to
a relocation camp. Sylvia’s family moved to Aki’s previous home, but only told to be that
Sylvia could only go to the “Mexican” schools. Sylvia’s father finally filed a lawsuit for this
racial segregation and won. At the end the story, two girls became best lifelong friends.
In my view, I think by telling stories about two girls’ courage and brevity in fighting
against inequities, such as social discrimination, race segregation, it will allow girls to be
empowered and tenacious while facing difficulties, either at work or in school. As a book of
15
counter-storytelling, on the one hand it is useful for teens of color-girl actively explore their
race and ethnic identity in social context, engage in the problem solving, and emphasize their
other hand, for white-girl students, it is a window for them to view the experiences of others
Topic Be grateful
Genre Picturebook
Invite students to know that be grateful to what we have had is a kind of success.
Otsaliheliga is the word that Cherokee people say to express the gratitude. Starting from the
perspective of indigenous people, this book invites reader to “go for a journey through the
year with a Cherokee family and their tribal nation as they express thanks for celebrations big
This book is written in bilingual, which are English and Tsalagi Gawonihisdi. Setting
the background in Cherokee people’s tribal and life, on the one hand, for indigenous
students, I hope by reading this book, they will strengthen pride in identity of their tribal
nation and also a citizenship of America; On the other hand, for other students, it gives them
a stage to learn about indigenous people’s values and knowledge, thus having a more
As for connection to success, taking is always much more than giving in people’s life.
We usually think more about what we can get rather than what we can devote. However, it
does not mean that setting a goal and then work hard for it is wrong, I just want students to
16
have a more peaceful mind when facing the gains and losses. In the way of chasing our own
success, sometimes students forget their original intention, for that they are so anxious for
reaching quick success and immediate benefit. I hope this book will invite students to be
grateful for what they have and reflect their struggles in the way of being success.
11. Muhammad, I. (2019). The proudest blue: A story of hijab and family. Little,
Genre Picturebook
Invite students who have religious beliefs to think about success. This book starts
from two sisters’ first day in the school. And it’s also the first day that older sister Asiya
wears her hijab. However, not every student knows the meaning of the hijab, and some of
them even make fun of it. In the process of exploring, two sisters find the new strong way to
In El-Haj’s (2006) article, she talks about the struggling dilemma that lots of Arab
students face in the America, especially after the 9/11 incident. Wearing the hijab is a way
for Muslim students to express their religious beliefs. However, since children are sometimes
just too naïve to understand religion, but after reading this book, they will be able to learn
more about religion and then treat other people's religion in a more respectful way.
As for connection to success, for students who have religious beliefs, this book is a
good start in educational literatures to make their peers and teachers learn about their
religious practices, cultural traditions, and political perspectives, thus being treated more
equally. For students who have no religious beliefs, this book offers a way for them to get rid
17
of their stereotypes and give more understandings for their peers who have religious beliefs.
Chasing for equity and being proud to express the religion is a kind of success for children
Invites students to learn about the characteristic of curiosity in exploring success. This
book is a wordless book, focusing on a girl who has a magic pen. With this magical red marker,
In wordless books, children could take the co-authoring (Arizpe, 2013) role while
they are reading. It requires them to activate their previous experiences, imagination, and
intertextual knowledge to make their own understandings for the book. In the process of
wordless books are helpful for stimulating children’s imagination and creativity.
As for connection to the success, I hope this book can allow student to know about
curiosity, and always be curious about the life. In the lifelong journey while they are chasing
for success, taking with curiosity, they may always have a positive attitude toward the life
and look forward for every unexpected thing. As a result, optimism could triumph over fear.
18
References:
Arizpe, E. (2013). Meaning-making from wordless (or nearly wordless) picturebooks: what
Education, 43(2), 163-176.
Picturebooks.
El-Haj, T. R. A. (2006). Race, politics, and Arab American youth: Shifting frameworks for
557-562.
Harju, M. L., & Rouse, D. (2018). “Keeping some wildness always alive”: Posthumanism and
447-466.
14.
Nikolajeva, M. (2002). The verbal and the visual. The picturebook as a medium. Children's
Education, 4(2), 59-72.
Serafini, F., Kachorsky, D., & Reid, S. (2018). Revisiting the multimodal nature of children's
Literature, 24(2), 66-75.
Sipe, L. R. (2012). Revisiting the relationships between text and pictures. Children's literature in
education, 43(1), 4-21.
Thakurta, A. G. (2021). “The Door Was Always There”: Transnational Youth Leveraging Their
Thomas, E. E. (2016). Stories still matter: Rethinking the role of diverse children's literature