Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C
linical supervision should be an important part
of the nurse’s clinical routine, but is one that ABSTRACT
realistically is often neglected owing to the pressures Clinical supervision involves a supportive relationship between supervisor
of work.This article aims to raise awareness of this and supervisee that facilitates reflective learning and is part of professional
important practice and to encourage nurses to socialisation. Clinical supervision can take many different forms and may
embrace clinical supervision, both for themselves and their be adapted to suit local circumstances. A working agreement is required
professional development, but also, importantly, for their patients between the parties to the supervision and issues surrounding confidentiality
and the quality of the care they deliver. must be understood. High-quality clinical supervision leads to greater job
satisfaction and less stress. When it is absent or inadequate, however, the
Definitions results can be serious and it is particularly important that student nurses are
Lyth (2000) defined clinical supervision as: well supported in this way. Further research in this area is necessary.
‘A support mechanism through which Key words: Clinical supervision ■ Accountability ■ Confidentiality ■ Reflective
they (mentor/mentee) can share clinical, practice ■ Professional socialisation ■ Staff development ■ Leadership
organizational, developmental and emotional
experiences with another professional in a
between the supervisor and supervisee (Udlis, 2008). However,
secure, confidential environment in order to
there appears to be inconsistency and confusion about the
enhance knowledge and skills. This process will
purpose of clinical supervision in nursing (Winstanley, 2000).
lead to an increased awareness of other concepts
Fowler (2013: 786) argued that, despite the existence of clinical
including accountability and reflective practice.’
supervision in the domain of nursing in the UK, nursing
Lyth, 2000: 728
practitioners ‘seem to be unaware of either its existence or
Arguably, clinical supervision could be mistaken for an its purpose’.
appraisal; however, Livewell Southwest, for example, stipulated
clearly that: Benefits
Certain benefits have been attributed to high-quality clinical
‘In essence it [clinical supervision] can be
supervision. These include job satisfaction, increased depth of
described as a professional conversation to
knowledge, reduced emotional stress and burnout, and increased
facilitate reflective learning, through a
self-awareness. It also enables reflective practice, provides support
non-judgmental process, which is separate
and encouragement and develops self-confidence and self-
from appraisal.’
esteem (Baylis, 2014). The principles of clinical supervision
Livewell Southwest, 2016: 8
facilitate the development of nursing leadership, together with
Supervision aids accountability, which is necessary for the opportunity to critique clinical and cultural practices within
effective practice, and it ensures delivery of quality care (Zutshi a safe environment (Blishen, 2016).
et al, 2007). Accountability is one of the prominent factors that
has influenced research on supervision (Harris, 1994; Bernard Reflective practice
and Goodyear, 2014). Clinical supervision in nursing requires Owing to the nature of nursing, clinical supervision takes place
an active engagement as well as a reciprocated relationship in a variety of settings. Irrespective of this, it is important to
note that the fundamental principles of clinical supervision
Oladayo Bifarin, Mental Health Nursing Student, MSc must not be compromised (Nursing and Midwifery Council
Pre-registration Pathway, Faculty of Health and Social Care, (NMC), 2006) (Box 1). It is evident that clinical supervision
© 2017 MA Healthcare Ltd
Edge Hill University, Ormskirk has a key role to play in positive professional socialisation and,
David Stonehouse, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Health and Social in order to achieve this, reflective practice must be encouraged.
Care, Edge Hill University, Ormskirk, stonehod@edgehill.ac.uk Professional socialisation is defined as identifying oneself
Accepted for publication: March 2017 within a profession through the acquisition of knowledge and
skills (Becker, 2013). McColgan and Rice (2012) highlighted
NMC, 2015: 8
time and then taking any action that comes out of the session.
Through clinical supervision, nurses and clinical teams Finally, the supervisee needs to keep written records, taking an
can look back and evaluate care given, then look forward active role in their own professional and personal development.
to identify where improvements can be made. Section 19.1 Supervisees should be open about the positives and negatives
states that nurses need to: of their practice, and be ready to share their ideas and thoughts
with their supervisor and other members of the group (Zutshi what they say will remain confidential. However, it must be
et al, 2007). understood that there may be times when confidentiality will
not be absolute, such as if unsafe practice has been highlighted,
The supervisor’s role or a patient is at risk (Peniket and Lillyman, 2007). Power
Van Ooijen (2013) identified the qualities of a good supervisor. (2007) went further and stated that if anything is deemed illegal,
The main qualities are the ability to develop relationships, being breaches codes of conduct, or infringes policies and procedures,
open and ‘not pretending to be more or less experienced or confidentiality may be broken. This needs to be stated at the
knowledgeable than you are’ (van Ooijen, 2013: 79). Skills outset and may form part of the working agreement.
required are those of questioning, active listening, and the ability
to focus and summarise (van Ooijen, 2013: 81). Discussion and recommendations
The CQC (2013) stated that supervisors should adopt a In contemporary nursing, nurses work in fast-paced
facilitative and supportive approach, but when there are concerns environments, which can be complex, highly charged and
regarding the competence or conduct of a supervisee, they must emotionally driven. It is therefore essential that in-depth clinical
act appropriately. They must also keep their own professional knowledge and skills guide the provision of health care (Ross,
development up to date and have their own supervisor. 2012). However, concerns continue to arise about the quality
Wherever possible the supervisor should not have line of care provided by nurses in the UK (Roberts and Ion, 2014;
management responsibility for the supervisee.Where this does Rolfe and Gardner, 2014).
occur there is the risk that clinical supervision can become an It appears that newly qualified nurses are leaving the
appraisal function with the supervisee acting as subordinate, profession (Cowin and Hengstberger-Sims, 2006; Gaynor et
and the supervisor behaving in a managerial way (Sloan, 2005). al, 2006; Health Education England, 2013) and, arguably, this
could be owing to the absence of a sufficient support system.
Managers/organisation It is therefore crucial for leaders in nursing to ensure that
Managers need to recognise the valuable contribution that the concept of clinical supervision is made known and made
clinical supervision brings to professional development and feasible for all nurses.
the delivery of quality care. Managers should enable staff to Emphasis has been placed on the link between lack of
take time out to attend regular supervision meetings. Both resources and its negative impact on quality of service as indicated
supervisees and supervisors need to be supported to attend by a survey by Dods Research (2015). However, the absence
training to prepare them for their distinct roles. of clinical supervision can arguably result in negative patient
Zutshi et al (2007) stated that organisations need to have a outcomes as seen at Mid Staffordshire hospital and described
‘clear supervision policy, with practice that supports the policy’. in the Francis report (Francis, 2013). Clinical supervision could
They also stated that senior managers need to lead by example. be a significant tool for staff expected to provide high-quality
There needs to be monitoring of the quality and frequency care to vulnerable patients.
of supervision, giving performance objectives to supervisors. Having established that clinical supervision is an important
feature in nursing practice, it is important to state that there
Importance of a contract/working are times when it will not be successful. Barriers to successful
agreement clinical supervision may include the personalities of the people
Having a contract between supervisor and supervisee makes involved, skill mix, staffing levels and nurse caseloads. Clinical
the arrangement explicit and avoids ambiguity about the role supervision is multifaceted and dynamic and its outcome is
of both parties (Freeman, 2006). However, van Ooijen (2013) dependent on many factors (Ali and Panther, 2008). However,
disliked the use of the term ‘contract’ in relation to clinical Lyth (2000) argued that there is increasing evidence suggesting
supervision, preferring the idea of a working agreement. This that advantages can be achieved when quality clinical supervision
implies more flexibility and freedom to change if the process is is encouraged.
not working. van Ooijen (2013) advocated a three-step model The quality of the bond established between the supervisor
for the development of working agreements: What, How and and supervisee can dictate the outcome of clinical supervision.
What now?: It is important to note that, establishing a good quality bond can
■■ The ‘What’ stage sets the scene: what is clinical supervision be stressful (Watson et al, 2009) and may act as an impediment
all about? What expectations do both parties have? to the processes of learning (Watson et al, 2002). It is therefore
■■ The ‘How’ stage asks: how is this actually going to work? imperative to ensure that there is a conducive environment
At this stage the practicalities, such as how often the parties to facilitate a successful bond, with the aim of encouraging
will meet, are worked out and issues around confidentiality learning (Kilcullen, 2007).
and accountability are stated and discussed According to Butterworth et al (2008), there is little
■■ The ‘What Now?’ stage focuses on goal setting and taking information on the negative impacts/experiences of clinical
© 2017 MA Healthcare Ltd
things forward for future practice. supervision. However, Edwards et al (2005) argued that nurses
do not benefit from short and occasional clinical supervision
Confidentiality and highlighted the need for consistent and long-term clinical
At the beginning of clinical supervision the subject of supervision.This can potentially help eliminate concerns relating
confidentiality needs to be raised. Participants need to know to nurse supervisees working through reflective practice ‘in a
Approach for the Helping Professions. 2nd edn. PCCS Books, Monmouth Winstanley J (2000) Manchester clinical supervision scale. Nurs Stand 14(19):
Watson R, Calman L, Norman I, Redfern S, Murrells T (2002) Assessing 31-2. http://dx.doi.org/10.7748/ns.14.19.31.s54
clinical competence in student nurses. J Clin Nurs 11(4): 554–5. https:// Zutshi H, McDonnell F, Leay D for Children’s Workforce Development
dx.doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2702.2002.00590.x
Watson R, Gardiner E, Hogston R et al (2009) A longitudinal study of stress Council and Skills for Care (2007) Providing Effective Supervision: A
and psychological distress in nurses and nursing students. J Clin Nurs Workforce Development Tool, Including a Unit of Competence and Supporting
18(2): 270–8. https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2702.2008.02555.x Guidance. http://tinyurl.com/pppzqk3 (accessed 8 March 2017)
Working in a team
Integrating new members
What goes on •inEnhancin
a team g the team’s effectiveness to enhance patient care
About
What makes for the author
effective teamwork and what are the obstacles?
Jean Bayliss is a counsellor, counsellor trainer, clinical
supervisor, and former Head of Adult
Leadership and
and management
Community Education of a team
A workbook to successful dynamics
Working with conflict
Effective negotiation
Developing as an individual
*Low cost for landlines and mobiles