Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Objective- Traditional systems of medicine are mostly based on the
use of herbs for the treatment of various diseases. Studies reveal that
herbal products are more popular among the common people due to
its fewer side effects, easy availability and low cost. Hence, these
herbs are used throughout the world as preventive and curative
medicines. However, these important herbs possess active chemical
moiety that are responsible for their medicinal property. Thus, in
reality, there remains a possibility of herb drug interactions when
these are consumed along with other medicines. Unfortunately the
concept of herb drug interaction is poorly known among the
clinicians as well as common population. Even the scientific world
was unable to explore the clinical relevance of herb drug interaction.
Studies are being conducted throughout the world to investigate the
effects of herb drug interaction, to ensure safety of therapy. In this
present article effect of garlic was evaluated when used concurrently
with other medicines.
Method- Documentations from original articles and case reports
were obtained from various databases and were compiled for this
Address for
present article.
Correspondence Result- Total 24 articles documented various interactions of garlic
Department of
with other synthetic medicines. Anticoagulants, antihypertensives,
Pharmacology, R. G. antiviral, anticancer, antidiabetic, antitubercular drugs were the major
Kar Medical College, classes of drugs that were found to interact with garlic.
Kolkata, West Bengal, Conclusion- Therefore, case reports on adverse reactions due to the
India-700004 intake of garlic posed a threat to the safety of this herb. These
findings initiated for exploration of the drugs that may interact with
E-mail: garlic and cause adverse reactions in patients.
dradhikarianjankolkata
@gmail.com Keywords: Adverse Drug Reactions, Garlic, Herb-drug interactions.
INTRODUCTION
Any plant or plant product with in garlic, γ-glutamyl-S-allyl-L-cysteines and
medicinal value, used as food or as flavoring S-allyl-L-cysteine sulfoxides (alliin), allicin,
agent or medicine are referred to as herbs.1 diallyl sulfide, ajoenes owe antibiotic,
Herbs have been known to be used as antimycotic and antibacterial properties.
traditional medicines, in various diseases, Allicin and other garlic components also
from ancient times, in many parts of the possess antihypertensive, hypolipidaemic
world including India. The use of herbal and hypocholesterolemic properties. Anti-
medicine is cost effective with fewer side thrombotic effect has been shown by
effects as compared to the modern ajoenes. These sulfur compounds in garlic
medicines. According to the estimate given also have anticarcinogenic properties.5
by World Health Organization (WHO), 80% These active chemical ingredients present in
of the world population is dependent on these herbs increase the possibility of
alternate system of medicine and natural interaction of these herbs with the
health products.2 One United States (US) conventional medications, leading to herb
based survey depicted more than 50% US drug interactions, thereby causing serious
adults, on a regular basis, consume herbal adverse reactions. Drug interaction is
medicines and dietary supplements.3 The defined as “the pharmacologic or clinical
anticancer, antimicrobial, antidiabetic, response to the administration of a drug
hepatoprotective, nephroprotective effect of combination different from that anticipated
various herbs like neem, tulsi, turmeric, from the known effects of the two agents
ashwagandha, garlic, etc., is well known and when given alone”.6 Thus garlic drug
has been established through various interaction refers to the effect of the active
scientific researches. molecules in garlic on commonly used
Garlic (Allium sativum) is used by synthetic drugs. In 1979, it was reported that
many populations to impart flavor and milk and various dairy products interfere
aroma in food. Apart from this, garlic also with the absorption of tetracyclines.7 In
has numerous health benefits and is used in 1989, clinicians found grape juice impairs
the prevention and treatment of different the metabolism of calcium channel blockers,
ailments since ancient times. Garlic was felodipine and nifedipine.8 Thereafter, case
used in the treatment of diarrhea by the early reports from different parts of the world
Egyptians and its medicinal importance was suggested that herb drug interactions may be
portrayed on the walls of ancient temples responsible for altering the efficacy of the
and papyrus, dating back to 1500 BC. Greek synthetic medicines.
physicians Hippocrates and Galen also used Knowledge on herb drug interactions
this herb for the treatment of intestinal is thus essential to optimize the therapeutic
disorders. Since 2700 BC, Chinese use success. The present article evaluated the
garlic to treat headache, flu, sore throat and evidences of garlic drug interactions
fever. Use of garlic in weakness, cough, skin documented as publications. This review
disease, rheumatism, haemorrhoids etc., was evaluated the reports on garlic drug
also mentioned in the Vedas, the Indian holy interactions, the proposed mechanism of
book.4 these interactions and the consequences of
Recent in vitro and in vivo researches the interactions in brief. Awareness in the
have highlighted the active components in society among the common people is very
garlic responsible for these medicinal essential in order to reduce the sufferings
values. Different sulphur compounds present
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
from the adverse effects of these herb drug Figure 2 depicted the distribution of
interactions. different forms of garlic used in these
studies. The most commonly reported form
METHODS was garlic as supplement, in the form of
tablets (44%), while others were garlic
Evidences were obtained from homogenate or aqueous extract (16%) and
various original articles and case reports in allicin (allyl 2-propenethiosulfinate or
English language, utilizing different diallyl thiosulfinate) (8%). 12% of these
databases and search tools Google/Pubmed studies used aged garlic extracts (AGE), i.e.,
from last twelve years. The keywords used raw garlic dipped in 15-20% ethanol for
for searching were garlic interactions/garlic about 20 months. Garlic oil, used in few
drug interactions/herb drug interactions. The studies, is prepared by steam-distillation
data obtained from these documentations method and composed of the different sulfur
were classified based on the models of compounds present in garlic.
studies, on the different classes of drugs Eight different classes of drugs were
involved in interaction and on the different found to interact with garlic (Figure 3).
forms of garlic that were investigated. The Among the different classes of drugs that
proposed mechanisms of these interactions interacted with garlic, most significant were
were also covered and the severity of these anticoagulants, 32% followed by
interactions was highlighted. antihypertensives, 28%.
The proposed mechanism of garlic
RESULTS drug interaction can be classified as
pharmacodynamic or pharmacokinetic or
Total 24 articles were obtained that
both. 72% of the garlic drug interactions
reported on interaction of garlic with
were pharmacokinetic in nature whereas
different drugs, in vivo, in vitro or in human.
pharmacodynamic interaction accounted for
Table 1 revealed the list of different drugs,
28% (Figure 4).
along with their classifications that were
reported in human to interact with different
forms of garlic. Tables 2 and 3 enlisted the DISCUSSION
different reports documented in vivo and in Adverse reactions of synthetic
vitro systems respectively. Various forms of medications are often encountered by the
garlic were used in different studies and clinicians.32-33 Though in alternative
several classes of drugs were found to treatment herbs and dietary supplements are
interact with garlic. The proposed utilized by the common people, but till more
mechanisms of these interactions were also information require for their safety issues.34
enlisted. The possible mechanisms of Apart from its use as spices, the health-
interaction were found to be either promoting and medicinal values of garlic
pharmacodynamic or pharmacokinetic or encouraged its use throughout the world.35
both. The effects of these interactions were Anti-tumour, anti-microbial, cardio-
also documented in the tables 1, 2 & 3. protective, immunomodulatory effects of
Most of these reported articles (44%) garlic was established and thus it is used as a
were based on in vivo investigations, preventive and curative medicine in various
followed by 32% case reports. Figure 1 diseases.36-38 Because of these beneficial
highlighted the distribution of different effects often garlic is consumed along with
types of reports that were documented as other synthetic drugs prescribed by
publications. physicians.39 Adverse effects of garlic when
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
the therapeutic regimens of these interacting American Coll Cardiology. 2010; 55:515-
drugs. The safe dosage range for garlic also 525.
needs to be examined to avoid unwanted 4. Petrovska BB, Cekovska S. Extracts from the
affects. Clinicians should document any history and medical properties of garlic.
herb drug interactions they witness, for the Pharmacogn Rev. 2010; 4:106-110.
5. Amagase H. Clarifying the real bioactive
benefit of therapy. constituents of garlic. J Nutrition. 2005;
136:S716-725.
CONCLUSION 6. Tatro DS. Drug Interaction Facts. J.B.
Lippincott Co. St. Louis; 1992.
Use of various herbal medications, 7. Neuvonen PJ. Interactions with the absorption
known since ancient times, is popular of tetracycline. Drugs. 1976; 11:45-54.
among different populations for treatment of 8. Ameer B, Weintraub RA. Drug interactions
diseases. But often patients are unaware with grapefruit juice. Clinical
about the combined effect of herbs and Pharmacokinetics. 1997; 33:103-121.
synthetic drugs. Effects of garlic on 9. Chen XW, Sneed KB, Pan SY, Cao C,
synthetic drug actions were elaborated in Kanwar JR, Chew H, et al. Herb-drug
this article. Creating awareness among the interactions and mechanistic and clinical
common people about interactions of drugs considerations. Curr Drug Metab. 2012;
and garlic is very essential and justified as 13:640-651.
10. Djuv A, Nilsen OG, Steinsbekk A. The co-use
this would not only lower the chance of
of conventional drugs and herbs among
adverse events but also enhance the patients in Norwegian general practice: a
therapeutic success ensuring safe and cross-sectional study. BMC Complementary
effective medication. Alternative Medicine. 2013; 13:1-11.
11. Graham RE, Gandhi TK, Borus J, Seger AC,
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Burdick E, Bates DW, et al. Risk of
concurrent use of prescription drugs with
We take immense pleasure in herbal and dietary supplements in ambulatory
thanking Prof. (Dr.) Suddhodhan Batabyal, care. Advances Patient Safety: Research
Principal, R.G. Kar Medical College, Implementation. 2008; 4:1-13.
Kolkata, for permitting us to conduct this 12. Peng CC, Glassman PA, Trilli LE, Hayes-
research in this esteemed Institution. Hunter J, Good CB. Incidence and severity of
potential drug-dietary supplement interactions
Conflict of Interest in primary care patients: an exploratory study
of 2 outpatient practices. Arch Intern Med.
Authors declare they have no
2004; 164:630-636.
conflict of interest 13. Elmer GW, Lafferty WE, Tyree PT, Lind BK.
Potential interactions between
REFERENCES complementary/alternative products and
conventional medicines in a medicare
1. Bent S. Herbal medicine in the United States:
population. Ann Pharmacother. 2007;
review of efficacy, safety, and regulation:
41:1617-1624.
grand rounds at University of California, San
14. Pathak A, Leger P, Bagheri H, Senard JM,
Francisco Medical Center. J Gen Intern
Boccalon H, Montastruc JL. Garlic interaction
Med. 2008; 23:854–59.
with fluindione: a case report. Therapie. 2003;
2. Kamboj VP. Herbal Medicine. Current
58:380-381.
Science. 2000; 78:35-9.
15. Gallicano K, Foster B, Choudhri S. Effect of
3. Tachjian A, Maria V, Jahangir A. Use of
short-term administration of garlic
herbal products and potential interactions in
supplements on single-dose ritonavir
patients with cardiovascular diseases. J
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
37. And Spices. American Journal of dysfunction from excessive garlic ingestion: a
Phytomedicine and Clinical Therapeutics. case report. Neurosurgery. 1990; 26:880-882.
2013; 1(3): 351-369. 42. Ogu CC, Maxa JL. Drug interactions due to
38. Hindi NKK. In Vitro Antibacterial Activity cytochrome P450. Proc. Bayl Univ Med Cent.
Of Aquatic Garlic Extract, Apple Vinegar 2000; 13:421-423
And Apple Vinegar - Garlic Extract 43. Sharom FJ. The P-glycoprotein multidrug
Combination. American Journal of transporter. Essays Biochem. 2011; 50:161-
Phytomedicine and Clinical Therapeutics.. 178.
2013; 1(1): 42-51. 44. Berginc K, Kristl A. The mechanisms
39. Mikaili P, Maadirad S, Moloudizargari M, responsible for garlic - drug interactions and
Aghajanshakeri S, Sarahroodi S. Therapeutic their in vivo relevance. Curr Drug Metab.
uses and pharmacological properties of garlic, 2013; 14:90-101.
shallot, and their biologically active 45. Shi S, Klotz U. Drug Interactions with Herbal
compounds. Iran J Basic Med Sci. 2013; Medicines. Clin Pharmacokinet. 2012; 51:77-
16:1031-1048. 104.
40. Indu R, Adhikari A, Chakraborty A, 46. Reddy GD, Reddy AG, Rao GS, Kumar MV.
Chakraborty P, Das AK. A review on drug Pharmacokinetic interaction of garlic and
interaction: A burning problem, 1st Atorvastatin in dyslipidemic rats. Indian J
Convention of SFE India, 2014, Abstract No.- Pharmacol. 2012; 44:246-252.
SFE/SNPSJU/135, Page-71. 47. Greenblatt DJ, von Moltke LL. Interaction of
41. Rose KD, Croissant PD, Parliament CF, Warfarin with drugs, natural substances, and
Levin MB. Spontaneous spinal epidural foods. J Clinical Pharmacol. 2005; 45:127-
hematoma with associated platelet 132.
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
Table- 1: Garlic drug interactions with their proposed mechanism and effect in human
ATC Year of
Sl. Proposed Study Model
Drugs Classification Garlic-drug interaction Publication
No. Mechanism (Human)
[Code] [Reference]
Antithrombotic Pharmacokinetic Human 9
1. Warfarin Increased clotting time 2012
[B01AA03] interaction (case reports)
Antithrombotic Pharmacokinetic Human 10
2. Warfarin Increased clotting time 2013
[B01AA03] interaction (case reports)
Antithrombotic Pharmacokinetic Human 11
3. Warfarin Increased clotting time 2008
[B01AA03] interaction (case reports)
Antithrombotic Pharmacokinetic Human Increased clotting time, 12
4. Warfarin 2004
[B01AA03] interaction (case reports) Low platelet aggregation
Antithrombotic Pharmacokinetic Human 13
5. Warfarin Increased clotting time 2007
[B01AA03] interaction (case reports)
Analgesic Pharmacokinetic Human 13
6. Aspirin Increased clotting time 2007
[N02BA01] interaction (case reports)
Antithrombotic Human 14
7. Fluindione Unknown Increased clotting time 2003
[B01AA03] (case reports)
Antiviral Pharmacokinetic Human 15
8. Ritonavir GI toxicity 2003
[J05AE03] interaction (case reports)
Antiviral Pharmacokinetic Human Decreased plasma 16
9. Saquinavir 2002
[J05AE03] interaction (Clinical trial) concentration
Antineoplastic Pharmacokinetic Human Reduction in the 17
10. Docetaxel 2010
[L01CD02] interaction (Clinical trial) clearance of docetaxol
Muscle relaxant Pharmacokinetic Human Increased serum 18
11. Chlorzoxazone 2005
[M03BB03] interaction (Clinical trial) concentration
Table-2: Garlic drug interactions with their proposed mechanism and effect in vivo
Study Year of
Sl. ATC Classification Proposed
Drugs Model Garlic-drug interaction Publication
No. [Code] Mechanism
(Animal) [Reference]
Anticoagulant Pharmacokinetic In vivo Decreased plasma 19
1. Dipyridamole 2011
[B01AC07] interaction (Rats) concentration
Pharmacodynamic In vivo 20
2. Atenolol Beta blocker [C07AB03] Cardioprotection 2014
interaction (Rats)
Calcium channel Blocker Pharmacokinetic In vivo Increased plasma 21
3. Nifedipine 2011
[C08CA05] interaction (Rats) concentration
Angiotensin-converting-
Pharmacodynamic In vivo At low dose synergistic 22
4. Captopril enzyme inhibitor 2010
interaction (Rats) effect
[C09AA01]
Pharmacodynamic In vivo At low dose synergistic 23
5. Propanolol Beta Blocker [C07AA05] 2010
interaction (Rats) effect
Increase in bioavailability
Pharmacokinetic, and half-life, decrease in
Hydrochlorothi In vivo 24
6. Diuretics [C03AA03] Pharmacodynamic clearance and 2009
azide (Rats)
interaction elimination rate,
Synergistic effect
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
Table- 3: Garlic drug interactions with their proposed mechanism and effect in vitro
ATC Year of
Sl. Proposed Study Model
Drugs Classification Garlic-drug interaction Publication
No. Mechanism (Animal)
[Code] [Reference]
Saquinavir Antiviral
Pharmacokinetic In vitro 29
1. and [J05AE01 & Decreased absorption 2010
interaction (Caco-2 cell)
darunavir J05AR14]
Saquinavir Antiviral In vitro Inhibition of saquinavir
Pharmacokinetic 30
2. and [J05AE01 & (Rat efflux, increase in 2010
interaction
Darunavir J05AR14] hepatocytes) darunavir efflux
In vitro
Antiviral Pharmacokinetic Inhibition of ritonavir 31
3. Ritonavir (MDR1-MDCK 2004
[J05AE03] interaction efflux
cells)
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632
Adhikari et al_______________________________________________ ISSN 2321 – 2748
AJPCT[3][10][2015] 622-632