Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AD 277803
K !R
TC'LA ,tAl IED
t
4
NOTICE: When government or other drawings, speci-
fications or other data are used for any purpose
other than in connection with a definitely related
government procurement operation, the U. S.
iv-1bVrdi icreby incurs rio rcsponsibilLty, nor any
()TbII g~t~ti whiLn1o5%~vr~r; fi~rl flir f'R'-t that the Govern-
ment may htv,- formulated., Airnished, or In any way
smpplied the said drawings, specifications, or other
tUjLa it nuiL Lu blt ,'=gurd.,d by iuiplL(ation or other-
wJ.ie an in any manner licensing the holder or any
other person or corporation, or conveying any rights
or permLssi.on to manufacture, use or sell any
pIatented invention that may in any way be related
tbereto.
Ce',
(• WADD-TR-61-75
I *_
" .1 ,.
MAIICII 1962
0
z
A,,
When Government drawings, specifications, or other data are used for any
purpose other than in connection with a definitely related Government procure-
ment operation, the United States Government thereby incurs no responsibility
nor any obligation whatsoever; and the fact that the Government may have
formulated, furnished, or in any way supplied the said drawings, specifications,
or other data, is n~ot to be regarded by implication or otherwise as in any
manner licensing the holder or any other person or corporation, or conveying
any rights or permission to manufacture, use, or sell any patented invention
that may in any way be related thereto.
Qualified requesters may obtain copies of this report from the Armed
Services Technical Information Agency, (ASTIA), Arlington Hall Station,
Arlington 12, Virginia.
This report has been released to the Office of Technical Services, U.S.
Department of Commerce, Washington 25, D.C., in stock quantities for sale
to the general public.
FOREWORD
I ABSTRACT
PUBLICATION REVIEW
aIIiiv*',. l'L
•oLnc.,toe UJ.AiF
Chief, Fliht ~Dyna..ic La'soa'x'
Ii. THEORY 2
A. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS 2
B. RADIATION IMPEDANCE 3
1. STATIONARY MEDIUM 3
2. MOVING MEDIUM 7
a. Subsonic Velocities 7
b. Supersonic Velocities 11
C. PRESSURE RESPONSE 21
III. EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES 25
TEST ARTICLES 25
A.
1. EXPLORATORY 25
2. WIND-TUNNEL MODEL 25
a. General 25
b. Model Mechanism 25
B. INSTRUMENTATION AND TEST PROCEDURES 26
I. SOUND PRESSURE 26
2. STATIC PRESSURE 26
3. OPTICAL 26
4. DATA REDUCTION 26
IV. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS - EXPLORATORY 34
A. EFFECT OF MACH NUMBER 34
B. SUPERSONIC FLOW 34
C. EFFECT OF LENGTH 35
V. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS - AEDC 40
A. BOUNDARY-LAYER CHARACTERISTICS 40
I. VELOCITY PROFILES 40
2. TURBULENCE SPECTRA 40
3. AERODYNAMIC NOISE 40
B. CAVITY RESPONSE 41
WADD TR 61-75 iv
I
SECTION PAGE
1. FLOW STUDIES 41
a. Schlieren Indications 41
b. Oil-Flow Movies 43
c. Static-Pressure Indications 43
2. CHARACTERISTIC FREQUENCIES 44
a. Effect of Dimensions 44
b. Effect of Mach Number 45
3. AMPLITUDE RESPONSE 46
a. Buffet Response 46
b. Resonant Response 46
A. SHORT CAVITIES 78
I. SUBSONIC 78
a. Frequency 78
b. Amplitude Response 79
2. SUPERSONIC 80
a. Frequency 80
Amplitude Response 81
B. LONG CAVITIES 81
VII. CONCLUSIONS 98
WADD TR 61-75 v
...-..
.... . "tA.iO -- N6.-
2. x: y: InRegion 1
Illustrating Preusure Point x', Y in Region I
12
12
() Illustrating Pressure Point (x,yE) in Region 11 12
3. (a) Illustrating Limits of Integration for the Supersonic
Pressure Equation 13
(b) Illustrating Limits of Integration for the Supersonic
Pressure Equation 13
10. Frequency Spectra of 1" Length x 1" Width x 1" Depth Cavity
In Subsonic Flow 36
11. Frequency Spectra of 1" Length x 1" Width x 1" Depth Cavity
In Supersonic Flow 38
12. Effect of Cavity Length On Spectral Response 39
WADD TR 61-75 vi
!I
FIGURE TITLE PAGE
--- ~4L--1undary-Lay..r-Flvcuations Above A long-Cavtty -3--- -
a fNLzX/c(R2 + X2)
A simple source strength
b fNLzR/C(R2 + X2)
c velocity of sound
D "Amplitude" radius, subsonic
f frequency, cps
fN natural frequency of cavity
F total force on piston
9n defined by gn = ."n
-L cavity length
L cavity width
y
L cavity depth
M Mach number, uf/c
n length mode number
fn width mode number
N n, nx, n
WADD TR 61-75 ix
~~ - -pre"usre at open end-of =ovtty (p4=k)
- modef ocl static pressure
R radiation resistance
Rx streamwise correlation coefficient
S area of piston
t time
u dummy variable
Uf forward velocity
Up particle velocity (peak)
v dummy variable
V cavity volume
X radiation reactance
x, y, z coordinates of source
x yZ' coordinates of field point
X. wavelength
;N cavity normalizing constant
el n normalizing number
Cn normalizing number
Y
I•c characteristic acoustic impedance
WADD TR 61-75 x
w Angular frequency
8 tan1 (y6/x'1)
tani (vI/u')
Y normalized frequency, kL~
dummy variable
ýN characteristic equation
Q~r cylindrical coordinates
WADD TR 61-75 xi
I I - INTRODUCTION
Manuscript released by the authors 14 January 1961 for publication as a WADD Technical
Report.
WADD TR 61-75 1
I .
t!
II. THEORY
A. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS
The objective of the theoretical treatment discussed herein is to develop expressions
for the characteristic resonant response of a cavity, since it is hypothesized that this is
the predominant phenomenon Involved.
As shown by Morse (Ref. 3), the response of an enclosure is a function of:
1. The dimensions of the enclosure
2. The impedance of the boundaries
3. The location, distribution, and strength of the forcing source functions.
Previous work given in the classical literature provide the basis for the work
reported herein. It is hypothesized that the phenomenon of sound generation in a
cavity is basically that of an enclosure responding in its normal acoustic modes.
On this premise, the problem evolves into one of deriving the characteristic
response function of a cavity from which its natural modes become evident. The model
selected for the mathematics is a rectangular cavity of arbitrary dimensions, having
five walls terminated in an infinite impedance and the sixth terminated in the radiation
impedance of the cavity opening.
Toward this end, the major concern becomes that of deriving the radiation impe-
dance of the rectangular cavity. A literature search reveals that Swenson and Johnson
(Ref. 4) have indicated the form of such a derivation but do not give the derivation
itself. Stenzel (Ref. 5) presents a study of this impedance for the static case. Although
both of these reported results are of considerable help, it still remains to document more
completely the impedance for the static case and to extend the results to include the
effects of radiation into a medium which may be moving with either subsonic or super-
sonic velocity.
When considering the case of a moving medium, the fact that speed of the wave
front is altered by motion of the medium must be taken into account. The upstream
ropagation velocityof a source disturbance is the s eed of sound less the boundary-
lyer velocity. Therefore, at supersonic velocity there is no upstream propagation,
except that which occurs in the subsonic region of the boundary layer. Garrick
(Ref. 6) has shown the effect of a moving medium on radiation patterns and field
strength of an acoustic source; and Garrick and Watkins (Ref. 7) have included the
effect of forward velocity on the sound generation of a propeller. The retarded
potential theory of the above references has been applied to the present impedance
derivation, which considers the total effect of an assemblage of in-phase simple
sources evenly distributed on the outer surface of a weightless piston of air in the
mouth of the cavity.
Finally, the response of a simple cavity, as treated by Morse (Ref. 3) is discussed.
This theory is appropriate for use if the depth is not very much less than the streamwise
length of the cavity.
WADD TR 61-75 2
B. RADIATION IMPEDANCE
1. STATIONARY MEDIUM
The radiation impedance of the cavity in a stationary medium is assumed to be that
of a rectangular piston set in a flat wall, very large with respect to the dimensions of
!the piston. The piston is assumed to be vibrating with velocity ' and radiating
into the space on one side of the wall only.
The radiation impedance, Z, is
i Z~~r
Z •t/pe£
.F/u e8"
where F is the total force exerted on the piston. The force, F, is equal to the integral
of pressure, pp (x' y'), over the area of the piston S, that is
The differential pressure at (x', y') on the piston due to radiation from d simple source
at (x, y) is (Ref. 1),
where
The total pressure at (x', y') assuming equal radiation intensity from all sources on the
piston iq:
=
22n dr dy (4 )
Zr -T', (.s
Since Eq. (5) has r in the denominator, it is seen that a singularity will exist when
x = x' and y = y', and Eq. (4) will yield infinite pressure. In order to circumvent
this difficulty it is expedient to subdivide the piston into four areas whose common point
is the locus of the singularity. The integration can then be curried out in four steps as
shown on the following page.
WADD TR 61-75 3
0, Ly LX, Ly
IIIII
FIGURE 1a.
FIELD POINT CONNOTATION
4
(x, y')
I IV
0, Lx, 0
X
From examination of Fig. la, it can be seen that Eq. (5) can be expressed as the sum
of the integrals over the four indicated areas.
I I I
zj .[f -'3r dx dy
Z -r f X f i+
(6)
f e dx dy f+ dx dy]dx dy
y x oX J
The four integrals obtained by integrating Eq. ( 6 ) with respect to x' and y' over
the indicated limits are equal, since the inner limits are the variables for the (x', y')
integration and will vary over all the cavity area; therefore,
I I
Zi . Y •oxi
X ikr
r R d d dx Y'
- ,(8)
there results,
Zr -- J ffý
j jdx
f d, dy (9)
0 0 90
where
r -7
WADD TR 61-75 4
By changing order of integration, the radiation impedance can be expressed as follows:
z f t[ n dydtdn
d (10)
y x -
-1,t)( (11)9
Zr it jj
0 0
Vi.Z+ di
I Itis of interest to note that Eq. (11 ) can be written in generalized form. The
normalizing factors used are:
k3 1
Zr n f '1/ut +v2 dudv (13)
0 0
W6
WADD IR 61-75 5
'r- ~Go$9_0 U r sina -
du dv - r dr dO 16)
(17)
icL 3 cot 1
s8cC 9
(18)
(-i
-r iwV?? _7 Ii-it y. 1 2+ inY
(
WADD TR 61-75 6
R- o- 9 sfe (ysee 9) dS + fccn o osi(ty sec 9) d9
(21)
"19 aln y" + si-n y six Yy + y(I
The above equations for R and X could be written in terms of a series as was
done in Ref. 2, but in the present case this would not result in any simplicity of
calculation, since a digilal computer wa- used in obtaining numerical results.
2. MOVING MEDIUM
For the case of a simple source in a moving medium of uniform subsonic velocity
uf (uf < c), the wave equation for small pressure disturbancos is
ýa~ 2 t ý (22)
The solution of Eq. (22 ) for the differential pressure at a field point (x', y') from
a simple source at (x, y) is as follows:
where
f 2 *i- i 2
Du-•(x -x) 2
. • 2
(,' ¥) 2 (24)
WADD TR 61-75 7
_-' (1 ) and (2) from the-prceding seitfon and th, Aeiult of EI. (23),
7• sEUi,
"theImpedancefoa vibrating piston-b IFho-a- on;c flow is
I Zr 2 JIL L
r 211 (28)
+ d-'k[PZ
dt (28
Since a generalized solution for any Mach number, cavity length, and. cavity
width is desired, it is convenient at this point in the derivation to make the
normalizing substitutions of Eq. (12) again. The generalized equation for
impedance then can be written in the following double integral form:
WADD TR 61-75 8
--1-nUR--h".due (q9) to single 1i sncsayt a
the transformation to cylindrical coordinates, as indicated in Eqs. (14), (15),
coordinates is then:
and (16). The normalized Impedance equation in cylindrical 11
ztn'tiý. -1. se__ -iy(. + McosO)i/P 2
i Mcosi)I/vfP 2]
)Y-iy(1-
+ (1- DsinQ)(r- dD dO
integrating Eq. (30) with respect to D, and separating into its real and (Upon
..f~si1-os
~ + in44)c(Pt- DcosWn)/A
Dcs[ c['se I dD1
Mn ]d8
(31)
"f;ly (Be+ W?,)•+•.1 - M)?
( + 'se 9•:
cot'l•
3 3
0o i. (3)itre sin d) e (p-arng
i ne e)
r2oL[so--.
1(0ADR17 -- + +
4)/P.2]sco_.s[nLy(,77 '- M-l jd @
[ TR ( s 9 (1 -
(1 + (L., Ji)e. LiM 1M
2 4 cos[y(sec"O
X j seC + L)/] i.Sec9 co:L(:ec@~)$ dt)
so.irM c
Cc- os][cIyýSeC.(i1. P'iwen)/O] + Cos L's.ec9(1- MsinR)/j d@
(
(I .5r
h 0) sin (9)-
~
+ i~(F-ýi-2V + i)/D21] r- -iky VIn)/B
T
YL('5 (-'fj7Y M)2I
1,1)2 -+pý) (321
-i+ Li 1')/p
+
r(
y
in 1
211 + 2.1 + 1
1~i
+
.2
As a matter of interest, the above equations for Rand X are equal to Eqs.
(20) and (21) if zero Mach number is substituted.
WADD TR 61-75 10
T sma-------
u.,____________________ - ...... ra -anreactance---- be-en.
developed in terms of three parameters; (1), the ratio of cavity width to length,
(2) the normalized frequency parameter, kLx, and (3) Mach number. Calcula-
tions for R and X were performed on a digital computer using numerical inte-
gration routines.
b. Supersoni c Velocities
(1) The effect of a source at (x, y) is felt only at points (x', y') within the
Mach cone with origin at (x, y). The enclosed half-angle, "y , of this
cone is sin 1 1/M. Outside the conical region the effect of the source
at (x, y) is zero.
(2) The pressure at field point (x', y') has a double solutlion, instead of the
single solution for the subsonic case. The field point, (x', y') at a
particular instant of time, t , is influenced by two wave fronts which
originated at time t1 and t 2 earlier. A wave generated at (x, y) at t
radiates spherically with velocity of sound c and is carried down-
stream with supersonic velocity u . The spherical wave is therefore
traveling downstream at a velocity greater than the speed of sound, so
that the field point (x', y') will both enter and leave a particular wave,
which is not possible in the subsonic case. Therefore at time t, the
field point will be erniigintg FIom a wave generated at time t 1 and
penetrating a wave front generated at time t2 (t> t2 > ti).
The equation for differential pressure at x', y' with sourcc cit x, y is
where
/1;2Q 1 2 2
- xx)2 - (34)
The next step in deriving the radiation impedance is to determine the limits
It is seen From Fig. 2a that if sin y= 1/M, then tan ý = 1'M/7= fs
of integration.
The pressure at (x', y') is the sum of differential pressures received from sources
bounded by the Mach cone opening in the negative x direction with origin at
(x', y') and the upstream boundarys of the cavity. By examination of Fig. 2a
and Fig. 2b it is seen that the integral equation for pressure at a point (x', y')
in region I, from sources in the shaded area, will have different limits than the
integration for pressure at (x', y') in region II. The dotted I ne in Figs. 2 a and
2b separate region I and II. The angle ,Abetween the line separating the two
WADD TR 61-75 11
FIGURE 2g.
ILLUSTRATING PRESSURE We Y1)
POINT (x', y') IN REGION I Y **...**
VI **~* I
Y y
(X, Y')
FIGURE 2b./
ILLUSTRATING PRESSURE YI
POINT (x',y') IN REGION 11
0,0 -1--L.Lx, 0
and the angle 6 , separating the radial vector from 0 to Wx, y') and the x axis
is defined by
6 a t~an -1(y /i
Therefore if 6 < a , the point (x', y') is in region I and if 8 > e4, (X1, Y') is
in region 11.
The pressure at (x', y') for (x', yE) in region 1, using Fig. 3a, is as
follIows. The limits for the x integration, holding yKconstant, will be from
0 to the intersection point of the Mach cone along te x axis which is
I
X - (y'- y)tan -x -(y. ~
WAD TR 61~-75 12
the >'Ititfrn thn~g~ r led region A are from 0 to y'. T60refore the
pressure at (x', y) Is---
II I .(yB- Y)1
O(X#y ) 0 fJ (%
oxI y
0,0LyL1L
B
FIGURE 36. (x, YB1
ILLUSTRATING LIMITS OF :
SUPERSONIC PRESSURE T L
EQUATION :..
0,0v LX1 0
x -
WADD TR 61-75 13
11
A~Infl~ipi~tn t~diedarvt~uIonce -.8ti~~rw*pti1(, )
--- -,+h,
ui...... , ,,•hv,,a,-,
tH r W b.ulc.uu'w. I w u Vrv, I thns Uus rFIw under
',jr
Ptifderotlon there are same problems. Regions I and II defined in the derivation of
pressure each may have two differentgeometric shapes as seen In Figs. 4a and 4b. In
Pig. 4o A> tan1 (Ly/Lx) or I]A > .y/,x) and In Fij. 4b. A < tanl1(L/Lx) or
I/ps < L/Lx. OxLy
1 dy'
FIGURE 4b.
SHOWING LIMITS OF Y
INTEGRATION FOR THE
SUPERSONIC FORCE INTEGRAL p(x ', y)
0,0 Lx, 0
First, the force on area LxLy will be derived for A_ tan- 1 (Ly/1.x). In
3 and
region I, the x' limits of integration are from a to L where a = y'/tan A ;y'1
the y' limits are 0 to L . For region l1 the x' limits of integration are 0 to
a= 'y5aand the y' limits are 0 to Ly. Using these limits, the force integral is
Ly 1x reLo
F f YfPP(region I) dx dy
PS
.fPp(region
ii) ix'c)
0 Y pa 0 0
or, noting that the force from region B is equal to the force from re ion A
when integrating pressure over the total area LxL , with respect to dx',dy',
the force is
WADD TR 61-75 14
i
I I
L y y(y- (35)
+2 (dp) d dy dz'dy,
x L L
F f p (region 1) dylx +±X' P (region II) dy dxl
L V X (Y' - Yi P.
F fa f (d) dx dy cLy dx
00
+f
0
fY f3' -x/ 8 f 0
dx dydy dx
(di?,
Now that the limits of integration have been established the radiation
impedance Zr can be set up and solved.
"rkw- fj F(xyx,"
t) dx dydxdy
d
0 0 0
(37)
WADD TR 61-75 15
IW
Fy,,,,,,). "/ ,[-X x) ) D.]/,,] -)_+_ _
By changing variables, the function -. (x, y, x', y') can be made dependent upon
two variables instead of four as stated above. The following Indicated changes
I are therefore made-
IIx-x-•: pe(y"-y')"
I X
S~~Then (3
where
.2
I I
Zr no "feff fiyq dt dn dx dy
0 ny
(39)
L YI xI x
ns J JJ F(tin) dt dn cx'dd'
0 0 0 n
Zr f "k 3LYI x
jF(t,,)
(40)
WADD TR 61-75 16
AIr• tAf ~rflgt,, wIfhliupeet to x' and y', Eq. (40) reducas to'
The next step In solving for supersonic impedance is to use the normalizing
Factors of Eq. ( 12 ), requiring the following form:
where
(/
F(1v 2 (iy(14U 4- -~~/u =-v 32 _y(Mu u-2
From Fig. 5, the area of integration is bounded by (0, 1, ps, A). For simplicity
the angle 6S is used in setting limits. The integration is to be divided into two
triangles, one bounded by (0, 1,ps?) and the other bounded by (0,ps•, A). In
the lower triangle the limits on 68 are from 0 to tan-( e. ). The variable
D Vu - can be visualized by rotating the vector u' about the point
(u', 0) until it intersects a line parallel to the u-axis that also intersects the
point (u', v'). The variable Ds is the distance between (u', v') and the inter-
section of the vector u' with the parallel. The relationship between g and 6s
is sin9= (v'/u')= tan ( 6). When a point (u = 1, v) isconsidered tan 6.
v = sin 0. With the relationship Ds =4u7- v2 the upper limit for Ds is
i/ cos 9 and the lower limit is 0.
=in9 The upper limit for 9 is 0=
1
sin- (v/u) sin-1(Ps)
WADD TR 61-75 17
FIGURE 5.
ILLUSTRATING CHANGE FROM .*V
~cAN-OULAR 10 CYLINDRICAL v
CORIDINTS IfOR SUPERSONIC A *,
For the upper triangle, 8 varies from tan- Pat to it /4. When the point
(u, v =Pat ) is considered tan O- /uIand D5 = ~( ) 2 cot2 ~-( )
Pt5 cotG. Using these limits, the equation for Impedance is
where
Integrating Eq. ( 45 ) with respect to Ds and separating the real and imaginary
parts as was done in Eqs. ( 32 ) and (33 ), for the subsonic medium, the equation
for normalized radiation resistance, R , becomes
WADD TR 61-75 18
4. ~ I ~ K a(6
u/2
+1
f sin 9 2 -- gnt(an o /a ai0eg
--
2~
sny(11 1)/i~ aY~m -1)/~ 2,
TR
WADD 61-72 19
rR f f ix0YOX Sy') dx 4ydxd
* (48)
"A',' g
R at0 8o9 dO
f(Of + os 6)2 (tCos
(49)
(50)
[Yr(M + )/p2] 2~ [Y i)/p21 2
- +) I• ( • -
'r(M.1 _1
It is of particular Interest to note that Eqs. (49) and (50 ) are equal to
Eqs. (46) and (47) If the sin -Ip 1 - n/2. In other words, for Pg2ý greater
than 1 the sin- 1 p•lis always equal to 900. This fact Is helpful when the
impedance is to be calculated using a digital computer.
WADD TR 61-75 20
I •C. PRESSURE RESPONSE
i Experimentally, the results Indicate (as will be shown) that for short cavities,
I or perhaps more inclusively for cavities of length-to-depth ratio of the order of or
less than one, the response Is almost exclusively in the depth modes. On the other
hand, the longer cavities - where lenth >1.0 - show definite experimental evi-
!I dence of response in the length modes.
Mathematically, it is desirable to effect a general solution which accounts
for response In any mode, whether it be length, depth, or transverse. At the same
time, it is recognized that a theoretical simplification can be realized if the
assumption of a depth-mode predominance is justifiable. Thus the following is con-
cerned with both developments, First the general case and then the simplified case.
1. GENERAL SOLUTION
To effect the general solution, it is hypothesized that the problem comprises one
of determining the characteristic response of a rectangular enclosure. The enclosure
is assumed to be bounded on five sides by walls of infinite impedance (i.e., rigid
walls) and on the sixth by a finite complex impedance which is the radiation impe-
dance determined in the preceding section.
As shown by Morse (Ref. 3), the characteristic response function of the
anclosure is
COBg Co I•sf IA;
. I I)
" h1 - C08I(, ! (5I )
g1 th(trg 1 (52)
WADD TR 61-75 21
!t
The roots 4[ are calculated from Eq. ( 52 ) using Iterative methods. Upon
separating Eq, (w2 )Into real and imaginary the fulIow.
(ompongnts oquo,,ins are
obtained.
J
• oou((! yL X
cot("%) rLcu(#~
4n n J
~ - 4rLX/n~(R. x2 ooeh(n4~
% 2
I/nx((R x)
an0 YL "csK+
2 oe)n
From the above equations, an expression for i in Ivterms of vl can be
obtained and Is
5)tefllwn
Using2 q )t(53a)o
yL R coth(2n or sasodrvd
iRL (R2 )
Ro~tk(
o 2%4~)~ 24rLZX~nooth(2n4) u~ +y (53b)
3
12n1.(R2+
n~x('+ X) L(Rt+ XI)
Using the first of Eq. (53a) the following form is also derived.
In order to numerically obtain a root from Eqs. (53b) and (53c), a value of C.
is chosen and substituted into the equation for rv., This gives two values for -qn
which are used in Eq-. (53c) to solve for values ofi:+ and F-, F4- denoting the
results using the positive radical and F- using the negative radical . When a pair
of values trn, T~n give a zero valtie of F± a solution isobtained.
WADD TR 61-75 22
I{
2 2 2
M
io¶i~tJ r1 (54)
which yields the resonant frequencies of the cavity b iteration. The iterative
process is necessary because of the frequency-dependent nature of gn.
The magnitude of the response is determined on the premise that the cavity
is forced by a simple source positioned randomly over the cavity opening. The
equation for pressure at a point (x, y, z,) can then be written, after Morse
(Ref. 3), as
where
,
0) n > (56)
x
*Oi%
fly ny O ny -2; ny >.0, en -y
It is convenient to normalize Eq. (56) for more general results. Thus, let
f - yc/2•lL x (57)
after which, leaving out the time vaiations, Eq. ( 56) can be written in the
normalized form
WADD-TR 61-75 23
2. SIMPLIFIED SOLUTION I
If the response of the cavity is entirely that which arises from excitation of
of less than approximately one, it is more convenient to write the cavity pressure as
LIP (59)
where :.o is the specific acoustic impedance of the cavity at the open end, and
WADO TR 61-75 24
III - EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES
A. TEST ARTICLES
1. EXPLORATORY
2. WIND-TUNNEL MODEL
a. General
Supersonic tests were performed in the 40 X 40 inch tunnel at AEDC, Tullahoma,
Tennessee, through a range of Mach numbers from 1.75 to 5.0. The model comprised
a cylindrical body of revolution having a 15-calibre ogive nose section, and a rectan-
gular recess of variable dimensions located near the front of the cylindrical section,
as shown in Figures 7(a), 7(b), & 7(c). Cavities with lengths of .5 to 8.0 Inches,
depths of 1.0 to 3.5 inches and widths of 2.0 and 4.0 inches were tested. Sound data
wore obtained with thirteen flush-mounted high-intensity microphones and recorded on
tape for subsequent analysis. Figure 8 gives a schematic diagram of the instrumentation
used. Static pressure, Mach number, and temperature data were recorded automatically
and printed out by a computer. Schlieren movies were taken of the flow in the vicinity
of the cavity. Boundary layer profiles along the model exterior surface (90' away from
the cavity but at the same longitudinal location as the leading edge of the cavity) were
measured with a pressure rake. Further definition of the boundary layer was obtained
throu h a limited number of hot-wire measurements of the longitudinal component of
turbulece
b. Model Mechanism
The variable cavity mechanism made it possible to change cavity size without
opening the tunnel repeatedly. The cavity floor was designed to permit depths of 1 .0"
and 2.5". Motor - controlled slugs allowed any desired cavity length for either depth.
A third slug was also provided so that cavities with a depth of 4.5 inches could be tested;
however, due to a malfunction shortly before the test, this feature could not be used.
Control circuitry was varied during certain phases of the test program so that a wider
range of depths could be investigated at 8" cavity length.
Widths of 2.0" and 4.0" were tested over comparable length and depth ranges.
The basic mechanism involved the 4" width, with provisions for inserts and a different
floor and movable slugs to convert to u 2" width. A remote motor control permitted
cavity dimensions to be varied from outside the tunnel. All data cables, tubes and
control wires were run through the model sting and then out of tunnel. Microphone
and pressure tubes had flexible cabling and tubing to permit movement of the various
parts.
WADD TR 61-75 25
i
j B.
INSTRUMENTATION AND TEST PROCEDURES
1. SOUND PRESSURE
Sound pressure levels were measured with 13 high intensity Altec BR-180 and
BR-200 probe microphones. Ten microphones were mounted in the cavity floor for the
4-inch-width configuration, 2 in the rear wall and one on the model surface 1 inch
upstream of the cavity. In the 2-inch-width configuration four microphones were
mounted in the floor. Figure 9(a) gives a location diagram for the microphones, and
illustrates the mounting procedure used. The probe tip in each installation was isolated
from metal-to-metal contact by means of a layer of resilient tape, as indicated in
Figure 9(b).
Microphone outputs were carried from the model to decade amplifiers where
necessary. The signals then went to a C. E.C. 14 channel recorder, on which half
the channels were recorded by frequency-modulation techniques and the remaining
half by direct-record techniques. Daily field calibrations of microphones and system
were made as a matter of operating routine.
2. STATIC PRESSURE
3. OPTICAL
High-speed Schlieren movies at 8000 frames per second were made of the flow in
the vicinity of the cavity for every condition tested. These movies were taken with a
Fastax 16 mm movie camera, modified to take 8 mm exposures in order to achieve the
desired frame speed. All pholographs were taken with the Schlieren knife edge in the
horizontal position. In some cases regular-speed movies were taken from direct views
into the cavity, which was coated with ultraviolet sensitive oil, These pictures show
flow patterns on the model surface and cavity interiors.
4. DATA REDUCTION
In the 40" by 40" supersonic tests, simultaneous tape recording of all microphones
used required only about one minute total tunnel time for a given condition. One
WADD TR 61-75 26
al
minute was considered the necessary time to obtain a good sample of noise data.
tomatlie reado-ut-and-printwt-of pressure, temperature, and rAhnumch.r r.re!red S
only a few seconds. Thus data for a given run was back in the control booth usually
in about five minutes. In this way close check was kept on the data for unusual
occurrences.
WADD TR 61-75 27
....
...
0 8
0 L.
(D U
LL
U
0
C., u
0) 0)
0 a
LU
0
00
0~
CLU
'0
W
I C,
0 o%
IC) 4
wj C6 0
CL~
WADDI TR 61-75 28
I Ah
UL
0 1-
W Ii
LjI
16v
wn--
WADD IR 6] -75 29
------
1211
WADD TR 61-75 3
Ilk-
211
iif
Fl7 CUE
c) CAITY RONFIURATPIONU
WADDTY TR 61-L)3
Irk.
CL
cI
"TI
-u
46 4
0 0
I- -
L. L.
0G 0 fn
A1u .2
o3cc-
0 z
0 u z
I, a EJ
UAD U.61753
Sleeve -Rubber Isolator
4"1 Width
Rear WallI
(Located 1.0"
Apart) (Typical)
004
01C.25" Dia. Microphone
Probe (typical)
WADD TR 61 -75 33
IV - EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS - EXPLORATORY
to gain
In ordertests
exploratory
of cavity response, a series of
better Insight into the problem
wa~s performed with the arrangement shown in Figure 6. Three
cavity sizes, comprising lengths of 0.5", 1.0", and 1.5" were tested over a range of
subsonic Mach numbers from 0.2 to 0.9 and at a single supersonic Mach number of
3.0.. In ol cases cavity width and depth were held constant at 1.0". As discussed
areviously, sound pressure levels were observed at either one or two points in the
cavity floor, depending upon cavity length, and at a point 1.0" forwaid of the cavity
in the tunnel wall. As a matter of interest, levels were also observed at a point in
the tunnel wall approximately 1.0", downstream of the cavity. Data were recorded on
a two-channel tape recorder for later spectral analysis with a 1/3 octave spectrometer.
A. EFFECT OF MACH NUMB ER
Figure 10 illustrates the spectra of sound pressure observed in the cavity of 1.0"
length ut each subsonic Mach number tested. The first clearly-discernible sign of
resonant response occured at approximately 0.2 Mach number, at which point the 1/3-
octave analyses exhibit a pronounced peak in the spectrum in the vicinity of 2000 cps,
and a lesser peak at about 8000 cps. The same peaks appear at a lower level in the
upstream spectrum, indicating that radiation from the cavity is taking place.
As Mach number is increased, there is a rapid rise in the sound pressure level
associated with the lower mode, such that a maximum level of 152 db occured at Mach
0.665. Further increase of Mach number results in decrease of response In this mode up
to the limit of the tests, or Mach 0.86.
It is noted that the same Mach number which maximizes this lower=modc response
also represents the clear onset of response in another mode of higher frequency. This
response, at approximately 8,500 cps, is visable in the spectrum at all Mach numbers,
but is of considerably lower level than that of the lower mode up through a Mach num-
ber of 0. 665. Above that Mach number, however, a rapid increase in level of this
higher-frequency response occurs, such that at Mach 0. 835 it is the predominant res-
ponse, with a SPLof 161 db.
Insofar as the frequency of response is concerned, an increase in Mach number
produces an increase in frequency of the lower-mode response, although the proportion-
ality is not a direct one. For example, an increase of Mach number by a factor of
approximately 4.0 produces a frequency increase of approximately 60%. The high-
frequency mode is noted to change still less with Moch number.
On the basis of these results and some indications of the early, simplified theory
(to be discussed subsequently), it was concluded that the response of this particular
cavity is more nearly that of acoustic resonance than of any other phenomena.
B. SUPERSONIC FLOW
Figure 11 gives the response spectrum of the configuration just discussed at a Mach
number of 3.0. It is interesting to note that essentially the same frequencies characte-
rize this response as characterized the high-subsonic response. The magnitude of the
response is quite different, however. The higher mode is not predominant, as it was
at 0. 835 Mach number; and neither response exceeds 132 db. Of course the static
WADD TR 61-75 34
I
pressure existing in the cavity is appreciably lower in the supersonic test. The level
of the boundary layer noise is also observed to be reduced, but not to nearly the extent
that SPL in the cavity is.
C. EFFECT OF LENGTH
The effect of cavity length is illustrated by Figure 12 which shows the spectra ob-
tained from cavities of 0.5", 1 *0" ,1.5" length at approximately 0.60 Mach number. Cer-
tain significant similarities appear. All three cavities, tar example, exhibit a peak in
the 2700-3200 cps range, which is hypothesized to be the depth mode. The 1.5" cavity
appears to involve a more complex response. It contains a very highly predominan-tpeak
at 1700 cps which appears in no other case.
..2[(rLxK)2
[ nX 11,nr
+(r")2 (\!)J
From this the primary length and width modes are calculated as shown below:
Configuration nx y f (cps)
In addition to the depth modes, if might be expected that the above modes should
appear. The 0.5" cavity exhibits none of these frequencies, and its response is assumed
to be entirely that of the first two depth modes. Although the 1 .0" cavity appears to
have essentially the same kind of response, it will be noted that the peak occurs at about
2800 cps instead of 3200 cps, as it does in the 0.5" cavity. This corresponds to both the
firot length and first width mode as tabulated above and may actually be that mode. The
results with the 1.5" length seem to support this since the predominant response is at 1700
cps, which is clearly the frequency of the first length mode. The peak at 5200 cps appears
to be tl'he third length mode.
The sound speeds in the AEDC supersonic wind-tunnel for the various test Mach
numbers are tabulated below:
WADD TR 61-75 35
zI
C*4
1 0
-L - -L t.
0 0 g-
o 0
u U.~
oO U u
-- 0
LM
E-
0
0 x
_t;=
u U -I
--
*
-p I- qp -d d 0d
WADD TR 61-75 36
ILI
0 0
-Ui)
C) C)0 3 C c
U.. I
-p - A- - - -
U) U)If
(E
o 0 0 -
- -) U)) C04t U) F 0
V - 9P -d V-d US
WAD
TR61-5 3
UPSTREAM MICROPHONE
LOCATION
Cavity Configuration
Length: 1.0 In.
Width: 1.0 in.
Depth: 1.0 in. --
L
"4130
. 12 0 - - - "
110
100
Microphone
Location:
Cavity Bottom 160 - ----
I
"Mj130
IFl
110 ' ; • .I L
100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K
Frequency - cps
FIGURE 11. SPECTRAL RESPONSE OF A 1" LENGTH X 1" WIDTH X I" DEPTH CAVITY IN
SUPERSONIC FLOW
WADD TR 61-75 38
00
CLt
- - - II LI
-4 - -
wI
80
10 -4
U)uU
I - U z
in 10o i 04
-- 0
0 0'
C4-
-J ~l t, -~ LU
LL
OA Lt).m
2 V
WADD TR 61-75 39
V - EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS - AEDC
"Themore detailed tests were performed In the 40" X 40" supersonic tunnel at
AEDC, using the model of Figure 7. The procedure followed in the test program was
to obtain data at various Mach numbers at as nearly constant tunnel "q" as possible, and
then to evaluate the effect of "q" at one particular Mach number. Thus, unless other-
wise identified, all data presented were obtained at the maximum"q" of 5.00 psi with
one exception. At a Mach number of 5.0, it was not possible to obtain full "q" without
condensation, hence all data at 5.0 Mach number were obtained at q = 2.68 psi.
1. VELOCITY PROFILES
In order to define the conditions under which the data were taken, boundary
layer profiles were obtained for each tunnel condition. Figure 13 gives the results ob-
tained for Mach numbers of 2.0, 3.0, 4.0 and 5.0. The data points are plotted along
with two theoretical profiles. The solid curve in each case gives the conventional 7th
power law; the broken curve giv6s the profile calculated by the theory of Reference 8
or compressible flow. The indications are that the profiles existing on the model agree
reasonably well with those for fully-developed turbulent flow.
2. TURBULENCE SPECTRA
To further catalog the flow field in which the data were taken, a limited number
of hot-wire measurements of the spectrum of turbulence in the boundary layer ahead of
the cavity were attempted. The measurements were successful at Mach numbers of 2.0
and 5.0; at other Mach numbers wire attrition precluded taking of the data In a reason-
able length of time.
Figure 14 gives the dimensionless spectra of the longitudinal component which
were obtained in each case. At Mach 5.0, the spectrum was found to be typically ran-
dom. At Mach 2, on the other hand, the spectrum contains a very pronounced discrete
frequency, at 2580 cps. The origin of this periodicity is not known conclusively, but it
is assumed to be associated with the tunnel itself.
3. AERODYNAMIC NOISE
The indications are that Mach number plays a large part in determining the
pressure level of aerodynamic noise. As shown in Figure. 16, spectral levels of three
typical frequencies varied from around 110 db at Mach 1.75 to around 68 db at Mach
5, a range of 42 db.
WADD TR 61-75 40
.-Figure 17 *IoWtheo-vera.I Leve-I terms ofIts ratio to dynamic pressure as a
function of Mach number. It is observed that again a la~re effect of Mach number Is
indicated. Implicit in the above mentioned figures is a decrease in static pressure with
increasing Mach number. This may be as much a controlling factor in the reduction of
sound pressure as the effect of Mach number. For this reason the static pressures corre-
sponding to the test Mach numbers are included on Figures 16 and 17.
The numerical values obtained for FT7 q are somewhat disconcerting in that they
are appreciably lower than those obtainedin other investigations. This difference may
reflect the lower-frequency limitation in the present case, which for convenience of
analysis was 200 cps. The analyzer used had the capability of continuous analysis through
two decades, either 20 - 2000 cps or 200 - 20,000 cps. To obtain the full range from
20 - 10,000 cps required twice the analysis time; therefore, the analyses were limited
to a lower cutoff frequency of 200 cps. In view of the rising spectrum envelope at the
low frequencies, it would be expected that the overall SPL may be appreciably higher
when frequencies down to, say,20 cps are considered.
B. CAVITY RESPONSE
The results of the test program indicate that the pressure response of a cavity can
be categorized broadly as a dual phenomenon - a discrete frequency resonant response
and a random buffet response. The former is hypothesized to result from excitation of
the normal acoustic modes of the cavity; the latter results from the unstable nature of
the separated flow in some cases, which tends to permit an intermittent direct impinge-
ment of flow on the rear face of the cavity- As might be expected, the buffet response
is greatest for the larger cavities.
The discussion to follow considers three aspects of the responsc, i. e.
1) The flow characteristics
2) The frequency response
3) The magnitude response
1. FLOW STUDIES
The characteristics of the flow associated with a cavity were investigated in de-
tail by means of high-speed Schlieren movies and static pressure measurements, and to a
lesser extent by oil-flow movies which permit visualization of flow conditions on the
floor of the cavity.
a. Schlieren Indications
Schlierenmovies taken at 8000 frames/sec indicate that the cavity induces a
highly unstable flow condition in some cases. A typical case is shown in Figure 18
which presents 12 consecutive frames from the movie of an 8" length 2" width and 2 5"
depth cavity at a Mach number of 2.0. Each frame comprises the view shown by the
dotted lines in the insert and the boundary layer is identified as the white band in the
right corner of each figure.
The instantaneous displacement profile of the separated boundary layer is seen
to assume a variety of shapes, reflecting an unstable, rapidly fluctuating flow state.
Although not clearly shown in this figure, the movie itself indicates that such extremes
are encountered at the front of the cavity and thiot there is sor-ctimes a shock rather than
the expected expansion fan.
WADD TR 61-75 41
Further investigation of the fluctuating boundary-layer displacement was conducted
-to deyermTre the tNme history of displacement at certain representative lengthwise statlens
along-the cavity. Figure 19 shows a sample of the results at Mach 2.0 for an 8" L X 2"
W X 1 .5" D cavity. Here the locus of the free-stream side of the boundary layer (as de-
I
fined by Schileren pictures) with reference to an arbitrary zero Is plotted against time to
give the wave shape of displacement.
a pronounced increase in amplitude at the rear of the cavity as well. The maximum ex-
cursion Is observed to vary from 0.18" at the 2" station to 0.6" at the 6" station. Simi-
larly, the rms value of displacement varies from .052" at the 2" station to .161" at the
6" station.
T2 TN
S~Ng
were determined numerically from the time history records for a cavity of length 8",
width 2", and depth 1 .5" at Mach .2.0. Figure 19b gives the correlation diagram which
was obtained therefrom. The curve is very similar to that associated with a periodic wave,
especially in the rather high degree of negative correlation obtained. On the premise of
periodicity, indications are that the wavelength is of the order of 4.8 inches (taking the
average of positive and negative abscissae intercepts). This corresponds to a frequency of
2
f = c = 1100x12 = 750cps
These fluctuations of the boundary layer show a strong correlation with cavity
dimensions. At a given Mach number, the fluctuations become very small when cavity
depth is decreased to 1". Conversely, they become larger as depth Is increased. Figure
20 Illustrates this tendency for depths of 1.0", 1.5" and 2" at stations 2." and 5" from
the cavity leading edge. The change in maximum excursion between a depth of 1.5"
and 1" is quite apparent, particuldrly in the rear of the cavity. Where a maximum ex-
cursion of 0.6" occured at the 5" station for 1.5" depth, the maximum is only 0.3" for
1" depth. At 2" depth, the maximum excursion is 0.7".
As would be expected short cavities do not show nearly the instabilities that are
shown for the 8" cavity, the separated flow being able to bridge the gap. The Schlieren
movies reveal that there are fluctuating displacements in the case of a short cavilty, but
these appear to be more in the nature of an inphase motion throughout the cavity length.
WADD TR 61-75 42
I!
CertaJn other features of the flow over a cavIly become evident in the pictures however,
as shown in Flgure 21. Here the cavity is short en•vgh (1w length)thaftke field .of tew
-of thi-camera permits observation of the flow for some distance downstream of the cavity.
Clear evidence of a periodic disturbance In the boundary layer is seen. Presumably this
Is a travellng-wave disturbance) which Is probably also present with long cavities as well.
A sample time history for the 4" cavity length is shown in Figure 22 in the interest
of completeness. Comparison of this figure with Figure 19 shows that the fluctuations are
greatly reduced at the 4"' length.
b. Oil-Flow Movies
Model-fabrication considerations precluded the possibility of direct Schlieren
view of flow conditions inside the cavity. Therefore in an effort to gain insight into flow
conditions therein, a limited number of movies were made with the floor of the cavity
covered with a film of oil containing luminescent particles in suspension. Illumination of
the model with black light then made the oil clearly visible. These were not particularly
revealing, although there was definite indication of a vortex within the cavity in some
cases. Figure 23 shows the photographs for lengths of 0", 1/2", I", 2", 3", 4", 5", 6",
7", and 8". The view shown is almost directly into the cavity, with flow from left to
right at a Mach nuniber of 2.0. At length 1,/2" the oil tends to collect in a lateral line
about halfway back in the cavity. The same pattern is evideni" in the I" cavity. In the
2" cavity there is clear Indication of a vortex formation which seems to have a vertical
axis. At longer length there is some slight indication of the some sort of formation, al-
though it is not as c early defined.
c. Static-Pressure IndicaHions
Static pressures were measured along the cavity floor in all cases. Some runs also
had pressure pick-ups on the front and rear waifs. Rear wall pressures were usually of the
same magnitude as the rearmost floor pressure for a given configuration whereas front .Va!l
pressures were usually from zero t ten percent higher than front floor pressure. Due to
the scatter and Incomplete wall data, the following discussion Is concerned mainly with
floor data. The model local static pressure Is given In all figures In this section, and Its
relation to cavity pressures can be seen.
(1) Effect of Depth: The depth of an 8" long cavity was varied In half-inch steps from
I " to J.5" of all Mach numbers. The data obtained at Mach 2 is typical of that
for the entire program (Figure 24). A trend of increasing cavity pressure with in-
creasing depth is shown. Pressure profile shape does not change appreciably but is
a little flatter for shallow cavities.
(2) Effect of Length: Variation of length has several effects, as Indicated in Figure 25.
The front floor pressure decreases with increasing cavity length to a point and then
rises again. For cavities greater than 4" length, the rearmost floor pressure is con-
siderably higher than that anywhere else in the cavity. At high Mach numbers this
wus not true, however, the floor profile being almost flat. Lowest floor pressure
occured approximately two-thirds of the way back on the floor regardless of actual
length.
WADD TR 61-75 43
1
(3. Effect of Width: Variation of width from 4" to 2" did not change floor pressures, but
-•id rodue thhgher pres•ores measured on the front wall which were mentioned
previously. No other effects of width changes were observed.
(4) Effect of Mach Number: Increasing Mach number in general gave more scatter in data
tor a given location, and length and depth effects do not show up as well. The floor
rofile becomes flatter with Increasing Mach number (Figure 26). At low Mach num-
bers, the rear wall pressures were slightly less than rear floor pressures while at high
Mach numbers, the rear wall had slightly higher pressures.
(5) Effect of "q": Increasing "q" from .77 to 5.1 psi at Mach 2.5 produces a general in-
crease in all cavity pressures. Floor profiles tend to be flotter at very low "q"L and
assume the typical shape at high "q".
2. CHARACTERISTIC FREQUENCIES
The typical response obtained in both the exploratory and AEDC tests is a discrete
frequency response containing several peaks. Some of these are harmonic, or nearly so,
and some are not. Additionally, the spectrum may contain a random low frequency
response which is referred to herein as "cavity buffeting". To illustrate a set of typIca
responses, Figure 27-a gives the spectra for allI lengths tested at a particular Ma numt-
ber, in this case M = 2. Figure 27-b illustrates the effect of "q" on the spectrum of res-
ponse.
a. Effect of Dimensions
Figure 28 gives a cormposite plot of all discrete frequency components which are dis-
cernible from the spectra obtained at Mach 2.0. In the sense of a preliminary or!enta-
tion as to the response frequencies, a family at harmonic curves is shown along with the
data. To obtain these curves, a single curve was faired through all data points relating
to the second lowest discernible component (selected instead of the lowest component
because of its sharpness). The harmonic curves were thus normalized on this as a base.
This figure illustrates the point just made. For any length the frequencies observed
are nearly harmonic, but not quite so, and there are usually one or two extra points. It
is apparent that there are so many frequencies excited that almost any hypothesis can be
supported, depending upon how the data are viewed. For that reason, the final analysis
of the entire response spectrum will be discussed in that section of the report wherein
theoretical and experimental comparisons are drawn.
For the present, certain conclusions seem warranted by the data for the first four
response frequencies. First, the trend of the lowest-frequency response, hereafter re-
ferred to as "1st mode," is suggestive of an inverse relationship between frequency and
cavity length. Also, the 1st mode and the 2nd mode frequencies are almost exactly
harmonic. Thus it might be concluded from these experimental data that at least for the
first few modes
f Cx n/L where n 1,2, 3, etc.
Lx cavity length
WADD TR 61-75 44
Figure 29 gives a comparison of the experimental dat6 for each of the first four modeA
with he-curve deptcttig-this relationship. In order to broaden the scope of the results and
perhaps bring Into perspective other parameters, data are plotted for the 1" depth along
with the 2.5" depth, and for a 4" width and 2.5"' depth as well.
I
For lengths from 4" to 8" the 1st mode data seems to follow the f o( n/L. curve
very well, regardless of cavity width or cavity depth. For lengths of 2" and less, how-
ever, the lowest observed experimental frequency is appreciably less than indicated by the
f cX n/L curve. The same trend appears in the 2nd mode comparisons. For the 3rd
xI
mode, the divergence between the fc(n/L curve and the data is perhaps not as great,
but there is a markedly higher degree of scatter.
These results seem to indicate three broad conclusions:
1. The cavity response for long lengths is a different phenomena from that for
short lengths, perhaps corresponding to the difference between length modes
in the former case and depth modes in the latter.
The observed effect of Mach number is shown in Figure 30. Here the 1st mode is
selected for study, and data for Mach numbers of 2.0, 3.0, and 4.0 are plotted together
to determine if any systematic effects occur.
In general, the indications are that the effect of Mach number is small. With the
exception of the data at 2" length and at 4" length, in every case the points at different
Mach numbers are almost coincident.
As discussed previously, the 2" length was found to produce clear indication of a
vortex within the cavity. This factor, which suggests that a different flow regime exists
at that length, may be the cause of the wide spread in response frequencies shown in
Figure 30 at the 2" length.
WADD TR 61-75 45
Ii
3. AMPLITUDE RESPONSE
In consideration of the amplitude response both the buffet and resonant contributions
must be considered, These are discussed individually in the following:
A
a. BUFFET RESPONSE
The buffet response of the cavity is characterized by a random spectrum which
reaches its maximum value in every instance at the lower limiting frequency of the
analyses. Thus, there is some uncertainty as to what the true maximum may be. Some
few analyses made with 100 cps as the lower limiting frequency still showed a rising
spectrum envelope. Thus, in view of the uncertaintyregarding overall level, all dis-
cussion of this facet of the response will be confined to representative spectrum-level
variations.
(1) Effect of Cavity Dimensions: Figure 31 illustrates the effect of cavity length and
:avity width on the levels observed in 50-cps bands centered at 200 cps and 400
cps. The upper giaph gives the results obtained at Mach 2.0 for a 2" width; the
lower graph gives corresponding results for the 4" width. The indiuatons are that
there is approximately a 10: 1 (20 db) increase in buffet level over the length range
tested. The buffet response reaches a maximum at the 6" length and remains con-
stant for greater lengths.
The 4" width exhibits about the same response, both in maximum value and minimum
value. There is one notable difference, however; the maximum response is reached
with a shorter lcngth of 4" in the wider cavity.
(2) Effect of Depth: Although the 2" and 4" widths show very similar buffet response at
5. • depth, they show markedly different levels of response as depth is system-
atically varied. Or more precisely, the good agreement shown in the preceeding
figure is perhaps only a fortuitous result, for Figure 32 indicates that as depth is
varied in an 8" cavity the width becomes an important factor. The 2" width cavity
produced a buffet response which increased continuously throughout the range of
depths tested, whereas the buffet response of the 4" width cavity reached its maxi-
mum at 1.5" depth and decreased thereafter. This result suggests that cavity vol-
ume, as well as length may be a controlling parameter in buffet response.
(3) Effect of Mach Number: Figure 33 depicts the effect of Mach number on the buffet
response at a given caity. Sound levels decrease rather uniformly with increasing
Mach number.
(4) Spatial Distribution: The streamwise variation of buffet levels in an 8" cavity are
shown in Fiure67.4. The highest levels occur in the rear of the cavity, as might
be expected. A difference in level of the order of 15 db. exists between front and
rear of the cavity.
b. RESONANT RESPONSE
WADD TR 61-75 46
The distribution of sound pressure inside a given ;avity is, of course, a matter of
interest. Thts facet of the response is best studied with a long-cavity configuration,
where data are available from a rnumber of microphones. Figure 35 shows the distri-
butions of pressure in the first fur modes as observed in the streamwise direction on the
centerline of the floor in a cavity of length 7" and depth 2.5". The Mach number for
this example is 2.0.
The most general result indicated is that, regardless of the shape of the distribution
curve, there is a pronounced tendency for the response to be greatest near the upstream
a• end of the cavity. Or, stated another way, it appears that whatever typical response
exists, it is subject to the superposition of what is probably an exponential decrease of
intensity in the streamwise direction. It is observed that this is directly opposite to the
buffet distributions.
Now consider the individual responses. In the first and third modes there is a
definite tendency for a standing-wove type of distribution, perhaps as shown by the
curves which have somewhat arbitrarily been drawn through the data. On the other
hand, the distribution for the second mode has very little tendency toward periodicity
but accentuates the exponential decrease.
The same sort of cyclica I response as that just discussed for a given length occurs
at a given point as the length of the cavity is varied. For example, Figure 36 (a) shows
the response at a point 1/2" from the leading edge of a cavity whose length was system-
atically increased from 0.625" to 7" at a Mach number of 2.0. Cavity depth was held
constant at 1" and width at 2". Extremely wide variations of pressure are found to occur
in each of the first three modes. The pressure at this particular point was found to reach
a maximum when the length was adjusted to 2", and to decrease sharply as length was
further increased. At the 5" length a minimum was recorded, and at still greater lengths
another substartial increase in level occured. Perhaps it should be noted that two un-
usual conditions are associated with the 2" length. First, at this Mach number, both
the hot-wire tý.rbulence spectrum and the upstream boundary-layer-noise spectrum showed
a strong periodic component. In the turbulence spectrum this occured at about 2580 cps.
In some cases the cavity response has a peak very close to this frequency. This may
only reflect cavity response off-resonance to discrete-frequency forcing, but it may also
reflect coincidence of the discrete input with a cavity resonance in which case a very
large response would be expected.
Secondly, the oil-flow movies revealed that the 2" length permitted a pronounced
vortex formation in the cavity, which could also change the response greatly.
Further indication of the possible uniqueness of this response is afforded by the set
of partial curves at the right of Figure 36 (a). Those were obtained under precisely the
same conditions as the other data,* except that the depth was held constant at 2.5" in-
stead of 1". Unfortunately malfunction of the cavity drive mechanism precluded the -
setting up of lengths less than 3", so that the response of the 2" length was not obtained
at this depth. Even so, from the data at lengths greater than 2" it Is apparent that this
deeper cavity represents a quite different situation. It is also clear that over most of the
common range of lengths of the two sets of data, pressure response in the 2.5" depth is
several orders of magnitude greater than that in the 1" depth. This result is certainly
consistent with the indications of Figure 21, which led to the conclusion that the bound-
ary-layer fluctuations of the 1" deep ccavity were considerably less than those of the 2.5"
cavi ty.
WADD TR 61-75 47
to that of Figure 36 ( a) but a Mach
Figure 36 (b)-Twogives
numyer-of-3-.O. thtngs are evdent.plot
a comparable -First, the maximum levels are of the order
of 30 db. lower than those at Mach 2.0, a result which is compatible with the re-
duction of boundary-layer noise between these same two Mach numbers. Secondly,
there is no evidence of the extremely high levels at the 2" length. Rather the
levels in that vicinity tend to exhibit a more cyclical variation of the type that would
be expected of a resonant response.
WADD TR 61-75 48
I .i
' ~Mach 2 •
S~.4
aI
S 1.0
.6A UI
S0
.8 _ __ _ _
Mach 3
Z. 1.0 _
.8
.4 ,,4 _ _ _h_*
.4
1.0
.62)
.4__Mach 5
0 .2 .4 .6 .8 .0
WADD TR 61-75 49
S--Peak 2.57
",Mach
% 5 . . .
- .) ,
.4.
Mach 2
0 .6--
.4
1.0
.50 "7 - N - - -
.30
i X
20
.210
WADD TR 61-75 50
I
i
140 I
Symbol Frequency
-z 100
E 90
80
70
60
WADD TR 61-75 51
UI
Ix0- 3 __ __ __
. . ..... - --
•lxlO-
••
o
5x104
2x10
4 S1x10.
5x 10-5
10-5 S2x
vii
2xI
WADD TR 61-75 52
LENGTH 8 INCHES
WIDTH 2 INCHES
DEPTH 2.5 INCHES
MACH 2
CAMERA VIEW
I--
1/8000 SECOND
FIGURE 18
BOUNDARY LAYER
FLUCTUATIONS ABOVE
A LONG CAVITY
AIR FLOW
WADD TR 61-75 53
L4I
00
0 1*
7 x
L U..
)
C-4
0 ýo,0 VN04 00010 V C46
soou - .uw ols( .oo uno .
WAD TR 617 54
I" Depth
.4
.3
1 .6 .
.4.
5.2
.7
.6
.5
.4 2 et
.3
.21
.1
10.
Time In Soc x 2.0
FIGURE 20 (a.EFFECT OF CAVITY DEPTH ON BOUNDARY-LAYER
FLUCTUATIONS, M =2.0,
(Measured At x =2.0")
Length =8.0", Width =2.0",
WADD TR 61-75 56
.7
.44
.6 1.0" Depth
I I
4 .
. ... . . . ..
""+. .4
.3
.2
1,
.9 , 2.0" Depth
o8 ,
.1 ,
S .7
.6
.4 -
.3
.2
01.0 2.0
Time - See x 103
WADD TR 61-75 57
-. LENGTH 1 INCH
WIDTH 4 INCHES
DEPTH 2.5 INCHES
MACH 2
-" I
S~CAMERA VIEW
r 1
1/8000 SECOND
FIGURE 21
BOUNDARY LAYER
FLUCTUATIONS DUE TO
A SHORT CAVITY
•- AIR FLOW
WADD TR 61-75 58
| - Length - 4"
5• . .. . - " .......
P
.4
.3 -
.2
.5
S.4
.2
is
.5 x 2.0"
.3
.4
.2
. Ir
.3
.2
1 2
WADD TR 61-75 59
Length FLOW
MACH 2_
WIDTH 2"DPH .
Length FLOW -
5..... ..........
L 3"
WADD TR 61-75 60
I ~Length FLOW -
j ~MACH 2
Length FL OW -
'
..........
WADD TR 61-75 61
-_ _
coN
-C 5~0
kz
I.S
I~ ~ ~ u I____ >___ L___
aw
00
C4 C
u U U U E%4 *.i1
NO]o
Isd oJflflOJd
WADD IR 61-75 62
1" Cavity 5" Cavity
1.6
1.4
O0
I I
1i.4., .
.2"
Cavity 6" Cavity 0
1.6
0 0
1.6
0 0 0
S1.84-
1.8
02 4 0 2 4 6 8
Distance Along.Cavity Floor (0 =Upstream End) - inches
Model Local Static Pressure 1 .49 psi
* Cavity Width 2 Inches, Depth 2.5 Inches
Mach 2
WADD TR 61-75 63
I .8 - - _ __ _ _
16
1.6 Mach 2 (Ps 1 .49
• psi)
0 0
0
1.4 - Q
1.2
1.0
0 psi)- 0
Mach 3(Ps =0.82
8Q
0 0
.6
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
02 4 6 8
WADD TR 61-75 64
I0
U.U r4
2z
>I
S U. U
LU
____ z
LL.
CN U
II 0~0
C)~~~~~C 0 Cw C C) 0 0 0
0 1.1O O
CN0, 0 i.
~issi ~ uo
qp~~~ U.D
WADD R 6175u6
I0 U
C A
. It
___ 0
9p InA3 - -~ss~ 0u
UU
(N U
-4-
C~
N~ 0 -
TR
0AD 617 66
u4
00
-C
z, v
E~ 0
6. LA
C14C
-
ZZ
00
Lin
-~ * z
UU
0 0
U-i
o U.
Ln I-
Cp CO
0 C,
C :)
C- 0L 0 c% LUO
q P
C - 2
WAD_ R 61756
12, OWHarmonic Curves
Experi mental
10,000
8, 0009th
8- 8th
ýC-6, 000 t
0. 6th
U-
5th
4, 000k":
4t
3rd
Fund.
WADD TR 61-75 68
|
4000 -
-x
3000
20
2000
I2nt Mode
4000
3000
7 2000 E
] ,• L_
10!00 2n r Mode ]
1000
3000
4th Mode
30001
30 1 24 5 6 1 7
Cavity Length-in.
WADD TR 61-75 69
z
o z
0000
o
~f~flv)
z
lP% N
.0% o I K
I-4
wia
0
uZ.
0 N
sdc) Auenboi
WiJ'TR6-57
130
8 400 cps
120
110
/ •2 •'I 4 Width
-J 110 ••S '2.5" Depth
a.
"uv 130
C
Lu100
120 [
0 2 4 6 8
Cavity Length - inches
FIGURE 31. EFFECT OF CAVITY LENGTH AND WIDTH ON
BUFFET RESPONSE
Mach 2
WADD TR 61-75 71
V
130
120
115
S105
me
13
44 Width
125 _____
120
115
110
.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
Cavity Depth - in.
FIGURE 32. EFFECT OF CAVITY DEPTH AND WIDTH ON TYPICAL BUFFET
RESPONSES
Length 8"
M = 2.0
WADD TR 61-75 72
I.
LEGEND.
110 0 Cavity Length 1.0"
200 cps & Cavity Length 4.0"
10
10j
-j
90
0
70
60
120
110
-• 100
-' 400 cps
go
7~0 _____
0
70
2 3 4 5
Mach Number
WDD TR 61-75 73
Sz
04
CLT
u U.
0
Jj z
U-
_ _ _ _ ___ I
qp -IVA9 Olm$G~dpuno
WADD R 6175 7
z A
0.
z
0
-e~cc
-I
0))
mo
N A tn
".4
En
Ln
U-
0 0 0 0
C% - 0
- ~lV)9fl~SJ~j
j~ej
WADD TRI-7~ 7
N
0I
- -
_0
_______ .4-
LUJ
43. 0
0.-.
o 0-
uA0
O~f) ccI
z U.'
0
z
-g z
LL
CO
U-
UU
- LU
0
U-
WADD TR 61-75 76
- *0
0-
I
2 z~ N
00
z U
- - 0
-Ni
uuc
LU
P,,
qp JODI aiss~ldPuLL
WAD L61757
I VI - COMPARISON OF THEORY & EXPERIMENT
WADD IR 61-75 78
Sbetween
Now consider the situation with a longer cavity. Figure 40 gives a comparison
calculated and experimental response frequencies for the .1" legt.h X.1"
width X 1" depth cavity at subsonic Mach numbers. Unlike Figure 39, this does not
give a depiction of all experimentally-observed frequencies for it is apparent from
Figure 12 that there are frequencies in the response of this cavity which are not repre-
sentative of depth modes. The intent here is to show that the simplified theory does
account adequately for a part of the total response. This is evident from Figure 12,
which indicates that the theory accounts reasonably well for most of the response fre-
quencies.
A pertinent analytical result can now be considered; that is, the effect of cavity
length on frequency of the depth modes. For the present this will be confined to the sub-
sonic flow regime. Figure 41 gives the calculated variation of frequency of the first two
modes of the cavities used in the exploratory tests, as cavity length is increased. A Mach
number of 0.6 is considered. As a matter of interest the experimental frequencies from
Figure 12 are included for comparison with theory at 0.6 Mach number.
It is observed that the first-mode frequency decreases with cavity length throughout
the range of lengths considered, and this is ver!fied by experimental results. Theoretical
results for the second mode show the same trend.
b. Amplitude Response:
In the present case, however, difficulty arises in definition of the input. The
boundary-layer noise existing in the flow could conceivably be viewed as the input.
On the other hand, any instability of the separated boundary layer which results in
time-variant displacements of the separated layer may well constitute Co velocity input.
In the practical case, much more convenience is assoiciated with assessing the boundary-
layer noise than the fluctuating boundary-layer displacements. For that reason it was
decided to explore first the possibility of obtaining satisfactory results using bour,dary-
layer noise as the forcing fun-tion.
WADD TR 61-75 79
For purposes of compai;son let the amplification p/p 0 be defined as:
P/Po = P f/Pspect.
where
Let it further be assumed that the 1/ 3 -octave response level for the output is entirely
composed of P &f, having no contributions from frequencies outside these limits. The
theoretical results can then be put on a comparable basis with experimental results and
plotted. Figure 42 gives such a plot for the first and second modes of the 1/2" X 1" X
1" cavity, where the amplifications shown are (1/3 octave)/Pspect).
The indications of this figure are quite encouraging. For both the first mode and the
second mode the agreement between theory and experiment is quite good. Actually,
it would appear that the implications of this agreement are of more consequence than the
agreement itself, for the use of boundary-layer noise as the forcing function seems to be
a realistic and satisfactory practice. As mentioned above, this will permit much better
utilization of the results since both the characteristic spectrum and intensity variations
of boundary-layer noise are now fairly well catalogued in the literature.
It should be noted that because the simplified theory considers only depth modes,
the streamwise distribution of pressure within the cavity is constant, That is, the pressure
al any point on the cavity floor is theoretically the same. Of course, pressure will vary
on ai Ivertical surfacbs, with a maximum occurring at the bottom of the cavity ,nd a
minimum at the top.
2. SUPERSONIC
a. Frequency
The data points indicated by squares are seen to follow the theory cur es very
closely. Several interesting points arise in this regard. For example, the theory pre-
dicts the first mode to occur in the vicinity of 1800 to 2000 cps, but no resonant res-
ponse was observed at this mode. The reason apparently lies in the amplification;
although the theory indicates the presence of the mode, it also indicates extremely
small amplifications. The calculated amplification was only of the order of 0.5db as a
maximum. In view of this, it is not surprising that the experimental response spectra do
not show such a resonance.
WADD TR 61-75 80
It is interesting to note also that for this cavity not only are all depth modes pre-
dicted accurately by the theory, but these ore the only responses which appear in the
measured spectrum. Thus the theory adequately pre'-Th's the entire frequency response
of this cavity at all Mach numbers.
b. Amplitude Response
Figure 44 indicates the measured and calculated cnmplitude response of the 2" length
X 2" width X 2.5" depth cavity at all Mach numbers tested. In general, the calculated
spectrum of amplification shows agreement with the experimental spectrum in its fre-
quencies, as was indicated by Figure 43, but the agreement in amplification is rather
poor except for the Mach 3 case. In this case the amplifications.are in fair agreement
for the 1st and 3rd modes. The experimental amplification of the 2nd mode is much
higher than calculated, but judging from the sharpness of the response curve, a part of
ihis may be due to the filter bandwidth used in analysis. The spectrum shape is indicated
correctly only if the width of the resonant peak is large relative to the bandwidth of the
filter used in analysis (50 cps). This does not appear to hold for the second mode, hence
the filter output may be taken as indicative of the response integrated over its own band-
width.
Further comparison of theory and experiment is afforded by Figure 45, which con-
siders shorter cavities at a Mach number of 2.0. Cavities of 1" length and 0.5" length
are considered for a constant width of 2" and depth 1". In both of these cases the
agreement is considered to be rather good, particularly for the 1" length.
The results of Figures 44 and 45 tend to add further confirmation to the conclusion
that the simplified theory is adequate only for cases wherein length/depth is less than
unity.
B. LONG CAVITIES
Consider the cavity of 8" length, 2" width, and 3.5" depth. Figure 46 gives a
comparison of the calculated and measured sound-pressure spectra at a point on the
bottom of the cavity 0.5 inches from the leading edge at a Mach number of 2.0. The
theoretical spectrum is calculated from Eq. (58). In order to obtain absolute values
for the calculated pressure spectrum, it is necessary to obtain either a theoretical or an
empirical value of source strength A. In the present case A was evaluated empirically
as follows:
At distances r >> ,%.from the source, the sound pressure can be written as
p • .~s§
-iwt
W T~ 615 P rms1
WADD TR 61-75 81
The spectr-um of pressure response at the point of interest in the cavity was
observed at a high frequencyK (6000 cps), which was off resonance. At such a
frequency the reqluirement that r >-> is at least approximated, since A
2.2 inches and ()r) avg. -5 .2 inches, assuming the source to be located at
random in the plane of the cavity opening. From the spectrum - level pressure at
6000 cps and th~e average r ,the source strength was computed as 600
46.8 cm3 /Sec.cp
A (w ) constant =46.8
Within the limitations of the assumptions made regordthg source strength and
characteristics, Figure 46 indicates reasonably good agreement between calculated and
measured spectra .While there are some appreciable differences between theoretical
and experimental amplitudcs, it .seern5 clear that the phenomenon of cavity response is
correctly defined by the theory.
Some further insight into the phenomena is afforded by the tabulation below,
which compares calculated anid measured resonant frequencies and identifies the nature
of each by its modal descriptian
WADO TR 61-75 82
An interesting point arises in connection with the first two calculated frequencies.
Theoretically, two resonances should occur, at 600 cps and at 800 cps. In this case
on|y one resonance is Indicated. However, Figure 27 shows that In many cases the
anclyses are made with sufficient definition (50 cps) to distinguish between the two
modes in the way of a double-peaked curve.
Figure 47 gives a similar comparison of theory and experiment for a 4" length X 2"
width X(2.5" depth configuration. In this case, the resonant frequencies may be iden-
tified as follows:
RESONANT FREQUENCIES, 4" L X 2" W X 2.5" D
fcal. fmeas. Modal Description
1250 1325 nx =I ny =0
1800 -- nx =0,1 ny =0, 0 gn =go
2450 2700 nx = fly =0
3950 3850 nx 2 n =0=0 gn
4400 4250 n. 1,2 fly =0 gng 2 ' go
5250 5750 nx I fly =0 gn= 2
6000 6500 n2 n0
7600 7600 n =2 ny =0
On the other hand, the envelope of sound pressure measured in the boundary layer
follows more nearly a /1w type of variation. Thus the assumption that A (w) a I/1
may well be a better approximation to the actual conditions. Certainly this would yield
a more representative response envelope as judged from the measured envelopes.
A further paint regarding the higher-order modes is that appreciable air dissipation
will increase the damping at the frequencies involved here. Since this is not accounted
for theoretically, some overestimation of the higher order modes Is probably to be ex-
pected.
WADD TR 61-75 83
25
20_
Width 1.0"
Depth 1.0" M=0
Length 0,5"
15 M=0.5
C
E<•~ 0.9M: .
U
a.M 0.9
E
-a M Av..)
M 0
0
100020 001O
-5 _________ _______
WADD TR 61-75 84
C2a
14A
I-
UCD
*1~Iu ?6
- I-
Lo oz
00.
C C I -
... g0 CQ
4-IA~~LL a-- * - -a.
0
qp-lV) cv)1Sqpld
WADD R61-7
C4
0 C00
0 LL ' Lo LL
C).- Cl
>. >
o '0
-ro C %_
LL
C)
0.
-U-
-u u-
- -C) CD C 0 CD C) a0 .0
'20
WADD TR 61-75 8
IL
- 09
upu
q 9
WADD TR 61-75 87
12,000
0 Experiment
- Theory
10,000
8000
U,
0)
U.." 6000
1st Mode
4000
2000
0 .2 .4 .6 .8 1.0
Mach Number
FIGURE 39. COMPARISON OF THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL
RESPONSE FREQUENCIES FOR SHORT CAVITY
Length : 0.5"
Width 1.0"
Depth 1.0"
WADD TR 61-75 88
Ii
Ii
12,000
STheory
(1 Experiment
10,000
2nd Mode
-.u 8000
U
U-
" 6000
0
U,oo
'2))
4000
2000 -)
WADD TR 61-75 89
12,000 1
-M M0.6 Calculated
) M=0.6 Experiment
10,000
2nd Mode
8000
u 6000
U-
4000
I1st Mode
2000
0
0 .5 1.0 1.5 2.0
Width z 1.0"
Depth = 1.0"
WADD TR 61-75 90
60
E 2
-: a Ist Mode
U
Theory
a Experiment
60
"x340
04-
E 20
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Mach Number
FIGURE 42. COMPARISON OF THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL
AMPLITUDE RESPONSE
Length = .5
Width = 1 .0"
Depth 1 0."
WADD TR 61-75 91
j 12000
Experiment
....-. ..
Theory
10000 ..
ifi
8000
S6000
2000
Mach Number
WADD TR 61-75 92
+30__- - - - - - -
Mach 2
+2 . -..Theoretical
Depth = 2.5"
Length = 2.0"
Width =2.0"
+10
C/
0
v -10 1 -- A v
Mach 3
+10
Depth = 2.5"/
U Length = 2.0" I \
Width = 2.0" / \ \
0 -7 "
-10
/
/ / \j
-20
WADD TR 61-75 93
+20
Mach 5
- Experimental
- - - Theoretical
+10 _ _ _.___
Depth = 2.511
Length
Width == 2.0."
2.0" \I
-20
-30 •
-40
1000 2000 4000 7000 10,000
Frequency - cps
WADD TR 61-75 94
+20 --
Mach 2
IA
+10
Depth = 1.0"1
Length = 0.5"
Width = 2.0"
0
a-10
/
.
i _.....Experimental
1!dIII~I~i //
Theoretical /
..- 20 /-
Mach 2
U +10
Depth = 1.0"
Length = 1.0"//
Width = 2.0" -/
/ \ r
0/
-10 1
--
/
-20 /- .0 0
1000 2000 4000 7000 10000
Frequency - cps
FIGURE 45. FURTHER COMPARISON OF CALCULATED AND
MEASURED RESPONSE SPECTRA
WADD TR 61-75 95
LLI
CDJ
C:)uI
LU
0~
CL
l- 0d
.E U LU
I,
I-LUn
U LU
L.. _ _ _ _ _ 0 c
0
(ND
.
0s
0
- - o c
ri ~1;Jf$a~pfo
WAD R61759
ctl
_ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
z
Lu
LU
V)
LA
L' 0
CLi
12) (A
LL
.(j.
LU
CI: 0=
<Lu
CN
CLU
qp - aa aissj puflO U
WADD IR 61-75 9
VII - CONCLUSIONS
. .. The analytical and experimental investigation reported herein indicates the follow-
ing conclusions:
1. The acoustic response of cavities in either subsonic or supersonic airflow corm-
prises dual phenomena involving
2. For short cavities the total response is primarily resonant; for long cavities the
buffet and resonant responses are of equal importance.
3. The resonant response can be categorized as almost entirely the depth mode
for cavities of length-to-depth ratio of one or less, and predominately the
lengthwise modes for cavities wherein length is 2 to 3 times depth.
6. The theory can be simplified in ýhe form of a design approach that will permit
fairly rapid assessment of the approximate response of a given cavity, as given
in the following section.
WADD TR 61-75 98
VIII. DESIGN SUMMARY
The following is in the nature of a summary intended to enable a designer to
assess the frequencies and dynamic pressure loading to be expected on the
structural surface of a given cavity.
A. CAVITY LENGTH/DEPTH<1 .0
Both the amplification factor and the resonant frequencies are obtained from
Eq. (62) below.
where:
f is frequency in cps.
L is streamwise cavity length
Lxis cavity depth
Rzis the radiation resistance, given in Figure 48 for both subsonic
and supersonic cases at width/length ratios for . 125 to 2.0.
X is the radiation reactance, given in Figure 48 for the same Mach
numbers and width/length ratios.
B. CAVITY LENGTH/DEPTH>1.0
In these cases the length modes are predominant, and it is necessary to employ
the more general theory. Frequencies may be determined from the characteristic
frequency equation
2
2 ( ) H-
1. (63)
On the basis of experimensal evidence, the transverse modes are not normally excited,
thus the resonant frequencies may be reasonably approximated by
2 - rL 2- . CL in) 2 (64)
fN "2 2 L +(6'~1
+ (65)
(2) Enter the impedance tables of Appendix Bor C and determine values of R and X.
WADD TR 61-75 99
(3) Calculate the constants a and b as follows:
2fNLf 21LZR (66)1
c(R + X))
(4) Take the values of a and b calculated in step 3 and using figure 49 read the
values of °t n and ri for the desired mode. If the value of b is negative, treat
it as positive in determining P the
words, -n always carriosn
and sidA m
11, ofbutb.record as a negative number. In
other
(5) With the values of k and 6 from step 4 a second approximation of natural
frequency, f can be calculated as follows (neglecting damping):
N
IA nn t (67)
It is also observed that some modes may have a resonant frequency in the vicinity
of the crossover point, where radiation resistance changes from negative to
positive. In such cases two distinct resonances may be calculated.
(7) Once correct values of fnn b and have been determined the resonant response
for the mode in question can be calculated from the following equations.
FPPN 1
where (68)
p ±89fNLZA(xjy,,z') JNXYZý(""'
L L r~nh(ng) + 2ng]CrL
The coordinates (x, y, z) are 1he location of the point in the cavity where sound
pressure is desired and (x', y', z') is the location of the sound source of strength
A(x', y', z').
The above calculations should be made for all combinatlions of n and n. It is
recommended that n range from 0 to 6 and n be 0, 1, and 2.
PN : 94 db
In order to compare with the value of SPL from figure 46, a value of 17 db must be
added to account for the 50 cps bandwidth used for presenting SPL in figure 46. This
gives a value of p N of 111 db which is approximately tihe same as round with the more
complicated machine calculation.
a-
LU
0
a-
-]
c! Cl )C
C!~~t' C)
C%4 D C: _ _ C0
xN
f'N
U~C)
L.
I II
(z
00
-V)
caa
x Ix
LU x
z-.4
l0
C)
C3 17 Cý C
7 - c-, C3 C
WDDT61710
V).
C4 In M 00 :
to0 ý -- 0 4 0 C)00
too
0 0
-00
00
--
- 1 .
0 0 O 0 to ClJ* (N - C) C
N -- C;~ C; ; 0
C 0 0
U H
0 - j
cn'
0Z0
0a o
Cf; C; c;0 c-a. o :0C
* oC0 0 0 0
____~~1 __ C__
4
ii iiCI
z__ N X\__ R
0K
LC4 ~~ C1 , 0 0n 0t M 0 0
2.3
n rTor,,
2.2 [- '-,-- I - 2.2
THIRD MODE
2.1 n 2
2.0 7
4H, -i= ==N::-
1.
1.0
1.8
1.7 2-0
1.6
-- 44
1.5 Q
SECOND MODE
M= I
1.3 gm 'tanh Tgn =a+ ib
*n where On 4n +
1.2
1.0 - - -----
f
.7 dL
.6
.5 F-1
PRINCIPAL MO E
--A n = 0
.3
41
.2
-0 .05 .1 .15 .2 .25 .3 .35 .4 .45 .5 .55 .6 .65 .7 .75 .8 .85 .9 .95 1.0
6n
4. Swenson, George W., Jr., and Johnson, Wallace E.: "Radiation Impedance of
A Rigid Square Piston in An Infinite Baffle," Journal of the Acoustical Society
of America, Vol. 24, January 1952.
5. Stenzel, Heinrich: "The Acoustic Radiation of the Rectangular Vibrating
Membrane." ACUSTICA, Vol. 2, No. 6, 1952.
HELMHOLTZ RESONATORS
the radiation impedance as given by Eqs. ( 32 ) and ( 33) for a subsonic medium and by
Eqs. ( 46) and (47) for a supersonic medium. ZH, the impedance of the Helmholtz
cavity, comprises the inductive reactance of the air piston in the mouth and the capa-
citive reactance of the volume of the resonator. It can be written as
)L -c2
ZH - + i (.---- )
S V
Combination of this equation with Fq. ( 47 ) gives the total reactive impedance of the
Helmholtz configuration and yields the resonant frequency when X = X.
Figure 50 gives a plot of the calculated resonant frequency of the resonator shown in
the inset.
Amplification calculations for this resonator indicated that an appreciable attenua-
tion, rather than amplification, should occur. This configuration was tested at all
Mach numbers of the AEDC test program, but in no case was the response of sufficient
magnitude to be observed over the buffet or microphone self--noisc. This result may
be construed as evidence of very low response.
~411
Width = 4"
1000
wi 9W
700
6000-
50 2 3 4 5
Mach Number
FIGURE 50. CALCULATED FREQUENCY RESPONSE
OF TEST RESONATOR
1.00
9 0.21169 1). 3,024
Qi', I7
0.14800 ~I
0. 21(1.85976 0.516V
I 5.0 t 0.1.1. 0. 1,21 j 01.,23o 1.0121 0.210031
111.00 0..1 W1iII 0'. 5,2 1 0. 51306 1.0(56 0.21.1.0
16.50 0.)5 0.O .o, 1-( 0.53910 1.9(1.2 0.40683
11.00 c1. 19/1 1 .120. 1510 U."1002u )I 1u5 0.4841
11.50 0_.03351 0. 111
39" 6i 061.991 I.o22 0.7
111.5 8.49 0. 4I1o1 V1. 9041 0.112
O~, 1.096 0.11.00
19.00 ~ ~ ~ I.''. 2's 1.I14510
.
1,11,1
2 30 1 1 0.51 12,(
1651.
I.o129b
.21
0.31 39
12:50 1 1 1 11
20.00 u.3761, 0.1.621 039.6W U.-.1.11 I.o39/ U.3395
20.50 0189soO 0.,16141 0.717,11 __ I..9
U-IOt21 0.31062
211.00.'3 - 0.1
551 .13w, 0. !,3
39. Io053 0.10016
21.s l.l,2lIl , 0l 1001. 0s 52,01. 1 . t61.50.9
22.0:10 I
1.71 15 11 0.961'. 01. In3? 1.0219 0.0941
1..04? I.u 1".. 1.5109 1.Uf00b 0.0205
230 41`0113) 0.* 0..0vl10f 0."1010 0.09(9 U.2064
23011.,1 8 0..' d140:1 I.-1,02: .1.051l 0.0850
2" 0 ' .n1,W) .57,I*0? 01,90/10 003
26.0
b. .1.9 Ith _ 1.0110320.
.11931 923 0.1002
29.1I 0.6)11 11.5 11 1~' 0.1161 o.0vlO 0'.0836l
u : -;,VI. I.17
w. 0 2) 0. 5961 0.108 0
I2at 10
26.100 v. :1122
4 1511 1.1 0.41,64 l.u1618 0.1284
3 ,.0 .1.1?
10.111 * 004: 0.1.901..9(2 0.0121
21.0 SOs9. Io( 06900 0.1129I 1J.Is16 0.1010
36.Ou i.l? 0.,.
r96/ U.1?3Is5 1.40051 0.1057
- t.,
36.) le,1,(9
0. 1.0161. 0. b120. I00 - -I0.11:14
2Y0 .'I 4~~I½82J0.1' 11.01 I.16
2)'()5 C./251.O I.1.41:5 1.5 11.:21A0~ 1).012k 0.:10.,
1 .O .212M. ).', P0 1.15121 0.2134 U.0118 0.1013
11.96 'I...2 1.0512 0.100 I4I3 0.09180
31.0V .... . 91.in
1. "...6101..u , 0.02. 1'.0161 0.09111
39.50 1.9; 0. .016%.9 1.85v16 0.10496 1).0095 6.1928
231.00 3.3'.',16 V
11.90, 0l. 110M 01.110.%U Y, 0. u033
U
33.0 113 12
P.11) 0".:113
0:1 1
Q.1L. 011035
30.0 3.0"3 1.0) r,30' 0.0 (1.0 0.02960
30.00 .011,
)W.02I
f (l. 1, ON 10. 4, O
.01? 0.0321
36.00cr 1', 9I.00 1111 f6 , t 4'11;: (300 -3
"1.31/70 0.9900 3.0'9130j .3293
50.00u 3.()010 0. 1.112 11.000,lf G.0Ž0 ('000 .0250t
1.00 1.;1117 0 .l1-ol 0.'13 1)0.13 0.198t, 9.0252
39.0 1.1.11040. II, 0 10,u, I'413 L Y1. 70 9:.0261
140.00 3.01,
U.__________ 0. 1.-W. I1.1,01.y _ 31.0,140 1.1-0231 0.0228
.0 .4 ý13
02S 1.00 -S 0.02031 60431 3.0379
149.00 11.901,q11 1. 1111 1.0, '.11.11 1.00146 0.0166
AD 10 61.754 31223
MAfH NU'Dtg U-10 MACH NVMBER 0.10
WIDTH TO LENOTH RATIO U-1250 WIQTHTQUN9jHMjIQ JLUAA--
2. !O ~ 0.-1
13.9521
0.62
S9 Ito9055
0.6780
9 . 9
0:067".0
. 0 i
1.035
O.b155
.30
.00 162 70
1lVII T3 _ .90 0.4105
4.00 1j.0211 0.601901 0.966 0.41061 0,9',6 0.12',9
4.50 O.d36dt 0*31101? I .9ft10 U.303$ I.1609 0.2201
S.60 U.9031 052 .74 U 41t38 0 11
11.50 10.95.11 0.4720.231.0333 0.16101..20H
0.:11 0.1308
6.0i97 -. 11Z29U 14 1.TI6~0 0(.y996 0.1098
9.50 1.0114 11.1020 U.0Y51;5 0.1102 0.99964 0.1107
0. 00 1 . v? r 01. 5310 .0.?34 0.14613 .0005 0. 124?
10.00 (J.0260 0.11,0 1.0u6 ,o
0.121 0.016111 0.0900
11.0 .036 1).2 .0
9302 0.15 .1100b6 0.09
9~I00o6 0-4 094ýFna 0.11991, u.oo I .00-
-9914 0.1089
12.50 104 3l6 0.*102911 1.01.12 0.16820 0. 996, 0.1017
110 6
9021.01,5 0.991 0 66 82
13.00~~' ( . 6 29
10. 0 (1.9,9 0:."1(02 02479 0.091,11:U 00!.991 0.07150
11.00 1(.0134 (1.12',2 0.901, 0.1(!)50 1, 995(( 0.0800%
_____________ (0.9599h 0 11"12' 0. ()11) 0.0916 0.91.0856
12.50
-
13.00
0.14
o . y!,
1.1fi__
t.1
ii 1 I ~ :
9124
0. 0.
.Ohh .9_
0.4y991
.06
0.06826
16.S0 0.9690 to. 1.1(,( 0. 4 9y 0.0040 0.9966 0,0759
16.00 0(.961h. 11.1 99so 1.01 0. 019',D Y.91'1 0.6001
16.50 (19!,,y V.12 Vi 0.906, 0.0916 .99001
17.0 ((.9031 16 .1',0 0.6?62
(j11(
..
39.:00 0926
0 0. 1,46,9 0. I-1(1 0.03132 o. 9O 'f 0.02611
39.5, _______ (1.9
: :w"15 ' '.1,);l.9' 0.0 20 100 0.0290
(1 .
11.90 I.,.,~ .. "----- 092 0
3.1
0012U .10 0.0299
361.0 0t9 .1. 1
f.0111 0 031.10 1111
t,020
31.00 (1.91;o fb 1.111. 1.61 G.311.9500279
62.00 0.9061, 11.1:510.,941 0.0321090 .21
it.50 1109 lv.1 .2 .00 1.19 . 599.
i_____ 0.0266
63. 00 I .'#vo. I .52 (.011011.01 0.021181591'30
U1u14 :P v t . 9
WA)4 3 61-7
F.A I NMI
W E.13 0. 2L. MACH- NUMbt:R U.20 90011NUMBECR Q.?0
WIDTH TO LENGTH RATIO U.0605 WIDTH TO LENGTH RATIO 0. 1250.. WIDTH TO L9NOTLI RATIQot,?0oQ .
"-". 88IAiLAL1L6 'A
RAr| II,;F P.•ITO "1 •,HT~; .•1~N"RADIATIOIIIA1tN RA0 " "?
... • "'. v~- ..4o~q 0.......
0261'iZ: iltiI
RLAC
EY"•• - ~T~t~'
S....... _- '0!I
,.--.• .0.QQAI -- .0.gk•oL.
W1T04C .."'N________
i
..... t ISA40I _' -cA"I'
'L.KI.M4E ........
.7.50
0.5o (1,2110
0'.08114 0 0220
O1,02 *2 0O.9150
176U 0.0926
0.3500 0,--.t533
0.91 -O0.9130
__005
8.00 1,.28110 'I. .10 0.0431 0.5030 0,1921 005625
Z.00 0.4414? 0.02 0.5119 0.0280 0.5197
V20.62 f-. 0.4172 1.02 5J125
S9.00
S10.00 0I.2723
21IG
O.310
l),901O
.hl1
0.022?
0.000.
0.52611
.o3)23
0HI
0.11912
0.9191
,i0.9...
0.11(26
41100 0. l..2o0
001J6 0.2099. 0.5391.9 0929 0.5216"
11.50 0,37 1 .,'lZ 0.02202 0.0,3.1 O:v920 .91408
13900O
30.co0 l;.
1, t'l,,l
.t ,,l'. '.I'I.
11.01211 0121I
0.09206 0.213
0.1211 1 . 9602
O.U132 0,.1121
0.119?
31. 50 o.llf h..',102 1.01113 0.2451 01.652 0.1145
2031.'00 L.',IX!! o..',l1h 1.0O1 0.2060 06,108 0.1202
"" 5V 00."l U. 0.0,16, 0.19?, 1.0.32 0.122064
ll'Il0
11,01,10 1 . 0006, 0.1092 .97250 0.t292
33.50 ',. IM,211 4)0.91 0. loll 0.9Y01 0,91250
31. __U 11.OU. I Q. S1.Y 1.0.1
. 9 0. O2tt , 0.9010 0.01908
3i0.100
- 1. :71; , 1., 101, 1.t77', 2,. I1000 0. o09'l 0. 123?
0.1221
ul0 11.5.1 0i1.04,1 0.1968 0 .'O3
S,.00 ').1,11? " iiii'; 1.01/ 0.1 0 0G...91 0.110 ---
00.0, 1.ll0*3I ili 1 01511 0.|022 . 1.009 0,|175
09.00U
200 "O I.uO2
Illll I'.
0.u191,0
1 ~ I.9)11
1,03 0.Ot91
.
0.0(2 1 .0169
. V6 1.9 0.0593.
0.1046
28•'l.
,.11 0.3. I. O,22 0.026'. I. II-I 0..03 -
i29,00 I.*u )I. ;'2b 11.00 () . 1 0 . .204•08
O 0 0.00.-0
i'6.0, I..'. 1.U051 1i.U(U9 0.0509
It,',1U..,21 0."1211.2
3 0.02'91,, o.. I . 0.00 .o .
9l1.00 1.01' ,I'I1 11.9 'i.0911.' "1O.0(•11 1. 0003 0.0502
9_.s 0 I.ow'', '. O's.IT011 . 0.9900 0.0501
99.00 I.111' I. 011,
$' 1.91:21 0.20"9 0.Y960 (.J002
i0.UU I .1154. I ml.
"1,10. Oo l'0l,: 0.0.(0 0.9900 0.0199
0".011 3f U.(
'1,2t9 14 1. 0.It u.N929 0,.91!0 0.0290
0s. I .1.' 1)0 I •. 1 '.0109 11.07. ".9922 0.00.97
.I , 1. 1201, ....
1. N 0.012 [- 0. 0.0 92
"WADIOI
11 61-25 1U5
MAGH9NIJIIOOR 0.20 RACGl5014801 0.20 14"H0 NV1SbK01 0.20
yIDTIýIjO LNGTH.W1 -mISqoI.QOUo
jo- -- Ta VNOTS RATIO
ijm WIDTH TO LENTH RATIO 2.0000
.9 a .$0
SQ.3a43
0.517b
a.5 702
0.651l2
0 118
0111$67
0.621S
0 . 61?
2.600.11055 0, (06 t.9 4.65?. G,1b9?5 04
"1.0060 ,6.I .04096 0.ll0Ii
.3.50 06419
0. __. 1219 0.910.! 0.51 U 0.Y952 0.331?
11.00 o.9Or Ob2 1.0424 0.4012 1.0121 0.2805
0.15 ... 38 1.0Otis 0.3111 1.0261 0.4361
1.91) 0.090-- 0.52(2 1.053.4 0.2350 1.V512 M.919
5.50 QO.94U5 0.4018 .0? 0.1045 __ _ .u222 0.1537
6.00 0.85 0.0rj 0.90 UTF .f,0.8 0.1305
56.601~.. 1.0159 0.30193 0.9y34 0.14,97 0.9816 0.1237
5 7.00 - 6167~. 0.11,Ia 0.9ii9l 0.152(1 0.7020 o.1253
1.50 1.00098 0.3015 0.945L5 0.15B0 0.4060 0.1244o
8.00 1.0549 O.215-
.959, 0.1629 (1.VV13 0.11a1
0.50 1.65312 1).225? 0.96114 2 ... V~*1
.912 0.105?
9.00 1.0460 0.1953 0.1IMU U. 1613 V.1605m2 0.09011
9.01.0351 0.1711 OV9 .140.9792 0.09,15
9.0 .025 -P S415 -0.9910 0. 1.19 0.1049
0.100
1 0.00 1 11.979
- 1m.0105 0. 14 1- 0011 0.12311 0.91.1090
0 9499m .13i .01 0.12341 0.'905 0.1069
11.50 099n5
u 0.123Y 1.0079 U1.1124 __ 1.0068.. 0.0988
1.00610 0 .I 2f 1.(1I10 0.0880o
12.50 :196040 3.121h.- 1.0032 0.094? 1.0110 0.01(84
10,9ýi161 U.120 0.9900y .011911.00u0 0.0(I
Z; 13.50 1).9
1 61 0.110 0.9941 0:.086" lUO?6 0.006',
14.00 0.0,9 1 11 0.9916 0.06119 1.4,051 0.0591
111.50 0.96211 0.1196 ____ 0.9096 _ 0.001A ____ 1.(005 0.0538
15.00 0.60 77-i,099 0.V999 0.0513
1.50o 11.Y,93 0.1290 01.99 11 0.01564 U. 115 0.0532
16.00 0.).2 .1 1,0 0. 4'A- 0.00t,6 484115 0.050?
L716.50 1).96013 0.11,10n 0.q971 0.0633 0 . Y115 0.0*06
I ?.00 0.9(15 0. 14i32 1.0002 0.0(96 0.920 0.0*15
17.501 0,981100 0.1',61 1.0016 0.0752 __6.992 0.0058
12.0v 11#9j5 o1. 19 .000.03
1.005 0.0610
18.110 1 .00(fn .1331 1.0003 0.06(2 1.U045 0.0558
19.00 1.01,10 0. UNA1 0. 09114 0.066t0 1.11036 O.002l
I Y..l.09 0.1 1141, 0.99166, 0.0630 1. "32 0.00.99
20.00 1.02 It, 01616 0(91.991 0.06435 1.1130 0 0010
20.0 1.01 5111 0.9901 0.60 ___'13 31, 0.0050 -
2.01091 l.l. U.1.', 0.0602 1 .l0022 0.001Y
2 05ou 10)1,121 ""q,
U( 0.-9y9? 0.06S1 0.9998 0.0399
22.00 1.013411 0.10137 1.0013 0.0601 0.9913 0.049?
225 1.00Y11 0.01100 1.00136 010M1 0.V961 U.G0108
21.00 I..6. ' Wl I I. u~,
C.'.. G.1,.1960 U.6017
23.50__
2 01.9911 0.00103 1.0,11 0.0,01I .V910 0,61 J
24.00. . . . y9 1.l1, ').oi it fl. PII ().01.11.0901 0.91 11.0171,
24 M10 .98 I, c026 6.99',, 0.0111/b u. 910 U.0391
25.00 11911,61 0. 1,11:1 0I. 933ý 0:01.1an (I.9959 0.0395
25.50' I . IN;'. i ". '6 fuI 0. 4'" o.0,1v V. vi,1 0 .0411
26 .031 11.9 10 8.81111 II. 90, 0.0533 1.. 02 0.60'24
26.5,0 ('.911112 0.1 (2b (1. 91160 0.0",'.? 1 * uo~l 0.0420
21.00 1.16 .1(,11.010-, 0. 0,1.I I. L11'l 0. 0394
2 .50 V. 90W.1 0(.,29 t112 0.0520 1. 8051 6.0 3!,1
29.00 .1?0161, 0190o.0194 00U1,2 0.0324
2,1.'50 8192 1 11,1
"::' 01. U.8l1 "I 1.620ii.0300
29.00 0.991,2 0,Y50
0.111
fill,, 1.60301 0.02m;5
2o.00 96 0.35
M,611 99.01 0.1191,y G.0993 0.029
0.00 0.9P6? 1112 0.9Y'16 0.019 U. V91.7 0.028?
f--l-. 0- ------ VIVO&
006. - -- .96 . 0 .Y99113 0. 02911
31.50 1.0021 10 fil 0.0)Y29-1 .0:
09 V.999 61.0518
32.00 1.01 I 600.93 001 0.991 0,033?
32.00 10901 j1.61 y 6 VY50 0 .0435 .00 SS!10
33 .0so09 n.02 6.1 0 01U0.090 0.032
0.1
315010111, 8.:10109 .1101.02 o0.03
1.16 UlI, 0102!. 0. 0,21-l (.011:21.1 0.0281
36.50 11051
(1109 100%1; 01.039Y 1. 1,01 q 0.0212
3. 00 11113 0:116 1 .00101, 0.0312 1 . 0 10 0.0266
551.650 1. 1045 11.CO? 1. 0(06U 0.054b 1.0006 01.0264
30.00 1015 V.:V1.26 .02 1 0:0121, 0,u01 0.629
u
36.5 1199.1,ho (t.001
0002 0.011 U0.601t5 0.026
37.00 10y*fOi 1 Y99z0 0.06 -~u l990
1, 0.021a2
3?.s0 0.993? 012 0. 997m, 0.036?1 0.99111 00.2400
30.00 0).Y9919 01.6411 0.091,3 0.0311, .96 0.0244
30.5"0.99001 1. P 51 0. 99,., 0.0126 0).0900 0.0251
39.00 6-7.989f 11.04t'9 fl.yq95 0.0330i 1). 4905 0.02!53
39 .0SO.9096q 0. (1481 l1.'-961 0.03510 U .9909 u.o251
400.00 0. 001 Ma35 0.0999 3.9961 0.02166
401.50 0995 0. "Z0 1.01(21 0.0336 6.9999 0.0259
2.00 l,.S0 0.06 '001, (. 0.03(6 I. iYM 0.1,254
cm . . . '910 0 4440
4.0224 0.1136 0.0440 0. 1"13 Q.UB94
2 GO q u BTJ 0. 14" 0.0?44 0.2311 .0.1479 0.3m
2:4. .-.0.0431 0.1011
'. Ulu u urbT- 0 400
3.so ila0875 1).2 2 15 0:!742 0.3473 U. skiIs 0.6016
4 00 0 040 0 2421 0 2060 0 3W 0 1025 0 !;256
4: SO : 11202 D:2612 0:231ij 0:39,j 2 0:1.061 0:54 30
cl 00 k1:1462 A..2? 9 2 0 . 26" 0 . 4 19b u . 51 7 0 . 5551
U. , 522 2.962 0.3005 0.4390 1).
6.QU 6.1m F3 rFq 0.3313 r.MT-- - -- "0.b230 M634'
6mS0 a4 .1 0.120 0,3410 0.4698 U.023 0.$604
7 99f 0 31100 h.-.sVQV 0.4011 0.7180 0.5s24
7 0,00 1117 :3526 0 *410D OAVIB .0.1592 0.5411
1144511 0 b,001 0 Y900 0.4all
8..00sp "92
C. ý1134 . 31,11
0.3161, a 0:4111 D: ý)okly .0:8289 C.blSdi
9-.-00 II.2W4 11.3004 0. viii-i - 115 Y64-- U. U5ýiq 6 4996
9 SO u : V'i'6 0 11000 0 11212 5244 0.68TJ 0:4855
28 2
0 . 301
(1: 4 113 0:!,466 1.: S 312 0 9146 0 4709
.0 ob. 10, 0 4 .1 1.72,, S36 0 V 12 0 455
11.00 U.316h % -1J.,1) 0. 0.540Y 0.4665 0.4571
11.50 0 3 3 1a 0.4412 002 '1 0.5431 O.V897 0.4170
V. 3622 U:Wý I I U:4 42
VO 0 s4jf 'F.-(j102
12.,Jo 0 t,42u 1.02TS 0:3.110
13.00 0.3769 O.4oli I O.bYc. 0.5409 1.1,414 U.3465
0.11 fol 0.1200 O.Ll38 1 I.u525 0.3253
r4ll 0 5346 0 3027
114:50
4 Ou 0 40"13
0:4201 1) h7fgj
0:4A211 0: 76 O:')S04 'u)
'(10 V Q.:2806
6-XJW 11.hub 0.1, 4
SO 4 1' 2 (1.4932 0.902S 0.5191. 1.0737 0.2388
16.0t, r? 0.1121" 0."1"1 1 .('131 0.2190
OAPI 3 0. m!bil 0. SN' I I.U117 0..2005
If.OU O.IiBbl 0.5kibc, 0. US O.4yOy obrtj 0.11838
II.So 0.5010 0. UO 0.4916 IM692
I --- - - "W- fft- n 11fici 6.481,3 osby 6. Isiilr--
18.50 c ý.210 0 "16 0: 902 1 0,41011 I.US12 0.1460
19.00 O:SI4 1 1 0: 2OU O.qI11 0. 4 WIV 1. U458 u.1367
19 Ili 0 . 'I IS o. 2 SP. 0. V i 10 0. 1661)" I.u4OB u.1281
20:Ou 0. 16M) ol. '5261 O.V1.62 U.4SI2 I.UJ56 0.11yg
20 . u..'" I S U."Int, 0.9.,9. 0,W2 n.1121
1-.Linli7- 0.1046-
21 0: CIO
I1 0 0. Y1311
Z 0: 4 IT, I.uI7fl o.0984
2 :Ou 0111 Y!, 0 ýOV 0.9941 0.4083 I.UI06 U.0933
2200
2 j.ýno cC, 51
C. "S"S 0."314
O."Isr 1.004f
1.0131 0.3911 1.0032 0.0095
d. 3879 O.V961 0.081`1
2 4. SO_ V. -1 I.UM 0.5141 U.UOS9
24 . 00 0.61.69 o. v ti-pu3 5 0.1,855
24 "u I;. i I (b C.01J56
2S:UO (Ili f L" 21 1 . Of. 3 0. 341 1 0. v 124 0.01,169
2". 10 " . IOt -1 'J. I 1 .044; O.SSGO u V616 0. 068 ?
26 ou u. 111-1 G. "'."N 1.01,111. 0.31,11 u Y6 5S o.0914
26: SO L . 127 1) Ii. 112,11 9(! U.3011" U V602 0.094a
27 . 06 G.- I I it, !.- .0 14, O'l,3 0- MJ2 0: YSU1 0. 09k1k;
2r SO U. 11.4li u. Wmi I . 96 1 0:21,uo U.Yýlj In In
26:00 u . IY' I Ww I.Ofli o. 2 f IA 1). V.,76 U.1069
28 "u 26f4 0.4,92 0.1 102
29:00 1) Of 1 0. 256 '? 0.4611 o.112Y
29 SO L . r 8 14 o. IV S I. 0 fy r 0.2462 U.V633 011 146
10:00 0.0`414 . I. I"'. I . LIP I 1 0.2,1"1 U . VAL,4 0.1159
3O.SO 0 . tio to 1,. 12S 1 . oil., 1 0. 2 71A 0 . 46 A 0,1170
0 .,0694 V.
31:50 0 : U?',4 'l.S0('3 I:UO1 I 0:206U 0.4116 0.1193
32 00 1) .1134 4 ".1,012 1 .081 3 0. IV to 1). Y 14 2 0.1204
52:110 1 . t.4 S? V. '160 1 1.0.01 0. 10114 O.Y111 0.11"Is
00
50 41
1; 0 C. 04 0:,121"
'g
4.;J, I : C)f 9, 01q)
a G Yy
TI-21,90 0. : V9711
to,
34.0. o. ý10(' I . u /I,It 0 IblI 0.1215
34 "o 1):'ý t I j 0. 4H64 i.urii, 0: IS',. U.YYOV 0.12011
35: 00 C .. B"S 0. WQ F 1.0?14 0.1496 0. YVI. 4 O.IIY9
3 ": SO (I a9s 0: 4 '110 0 29 0 VvuO 0
36 00 0:)Oil' (I I, ý I ý : 00('ý"";V O:ý'361 1:0010 0:""'72'
36 . 5 u 11. 409 m 0.1,110 1.065ý 0. 1 Job 1.00s? O.IISI
17 00- n-9177 0-hPob- -1 . OM! -0.12,A I.Uoyb 0.1123
3 1:110 4 2S4 'ý: ht,?(. I . O"u;) 0.11y" I.V132 U.1088
58 Ou 0. hS F2 1 . O"Su 0.1140 1 U 162 0 ý 1046
1q: So U. 4*0 1 1.0"If 0. 1011 f I u IBLI 0.1000
39 0c 0 .94 W) P. %I"y I . 04 it 1 0. 1031 1 . u 191 0.09S3
39: )U v .1" 34 11.41. It I . 0442 0.0992 1.0203 U.U907
40. oil L 459-6 16 1 , U204 -d. 0866
40."0 0 : 16.", 6 s I. C iG 1 0.0914 1.U201 0.0829
4 1 .- )u u V7 14 1. (.12u 0.011,52 I.UI91 0.0194
4 1.,,9 1 1. VIM 0.0"A 1.092 0.0761
42. no It- I I. 0.1h 1, 0. U'U'll 1.0186 0.0729
4 2. "u Y IsUU I. uz 0 1 0 . UMOL, :.Ulrf 0.0698
6-.066
4 5. "0 4 nu I I . 0 12.; U. D I WJ I . L,151 0.0640
114.00 1 14 1.001, 0. 0 rt." I oIj? U.U616
44.',(p 1 .;An 5 1ý. sO4 1 .004Y O.OW, 1.021 0.0594
4 S. OU 1.0151 0. 1-"" 1 . U014 U.OfjH 1.010s 0.0514
4 1. 11) Ird Q. 91ML O.OfJ2 k'0c9 0.05ss
ýý.%U-2s
3"o.) O.U t2fl .65
-IT-
h 6. SO I D:I6 ; 0. VY2" p utli
4 I.OSI? o. snj" (1.449' 0:Of2c 055
Ili,0 33 ":00,0"2
0 5
14.? U. 3%fit 1). 41.6 ý.Ollh 1-00013 0.0488
4B.00 I J-10 0. U. Y!, S., 0.0110 U. -MO 0.0479
'-.0 - D 1:12 0 . Y9 t, 2 0.04?6
1 AI -0 . V30 -
4 Q 66 u vi.(I
11.0426 o. w 1ý 0 Oyeh (I. 40TV 0.0480
49.',(' 1:114,11, si"Is 0. 1140 (;:013b U.V90Z 0.0488
110.00 1 . U".'I' S I'd U.9124 O.U (4y U.Y1305 U.0500
]WU.053
2S.6 (.911 0-101
V1
01I 0:046 '1t
26 .00U :.9. 10.0361
Y.900 0:.0002 0.9(199 0.01,116 tI.Y992 11.0300
26 .50 ():9195 0.0102 09190c,____ 0.0',2H U.o960 0.039Y
1.966 U00
32/.50 t. 0104 0. 00 3I,.9901 0.0"19 13.9911 0.0405
33. 00 1.00136 (1.1,1111.01 0. 0""1
".0002 0.90 .3209
33.50 1.V006 0.C.150- 0.9963 0.0009, 1.(;02U 0.038H
290.60o (Y1.01 0 (1h.1.51 100911 U.0U005
35.00 0,9960 0.02119
p.00920 0.i0910 0.9991 0.04331 "4969
35.0 0.0329
10021 (.010 lul00 0.0,o 0.030
0.97
36000 0999 110 1 1.0(10 0. 31 0299a.
OU W.12 0.307 0.0215
37.50 U062f 0.1063 0:106Y1 0.03-19 1.YY99 U.0275
38.0so f2 0 0.10.?U 990001 0:.03JOY 91.0 0.0289
3.50
39.00" .0, a090
.10 0.022 1.9007 0.02a1
U.CY0.993$ 0.00,4.000.39 U.99791 O.0229
"396 P.:'5911,1o
0.92
)U,
-.--o0 ).V9l 0.0469 1.1VIP0 002 0
0c...0:998ts (104052 0?9699 0.:02168
60.5 0291 0.00
V.109 0.322
35.00 :'o.,9 U: 0.63 0.91 0.30 0V9 91 0.20
0.9.6.022
35 !u 1.00 0.91, U.(1.63 ((.9000 0 .0 31E5 1099V 0. 02If
32.00 ).Y9991 0 . 1410.99 .11696 0. 202
02.50 .9975 .1.5120.999 0.03F7 . (.90 0.0210
036.50100 0 .(111.9986
D241 0.0366 0.990.0237
05.00 '1.05?)v
I.06 0.9 0.3r,--
37 so 1..0241 0.0201
1.0011 11.11,1 0.9990 0.0.41 (.1.013
380 0.0233
.9961 O.CkiT1 Til .~1.000L
U03)Iu29 0.0255
301so G V941 '1141)3
U .0. .0322 1.1 0 024 1
00.3950 01.9920 0.C 12 l,.1.lH 0.0231 ___ _ _ 0.00 U.0220
19.0 634921 a.IFi~ D.9qo9 0.0320 10.4990 0.0228
09.650 (-.4936 n.(.526 0.9991 0.0SP01b
460.0 0 11.9,11
10.990 0.U123
u L.' 32 0.99yj 0.609o 0.19807 0.0192
0: 0 .1 -Q •0•-
-0i1
-1A 0.993
.... 3.. 0.61b"2•5 . 1. .od.365 0.1620
- .Jd&L 0.3123 0. 1080 0.2761
5.900 I0M, 0.1972 0.139! 0.1126 0.2138
3.50 0.0860 0.2202 0.1712 0.3445 0.J352 0.49159
4.00 0;1010 0.241? 0.2•02 0.3734 0..443 0...532 --
5 3
4.50 U.1184 0.2109 0.234 t 039 -2.0 3 - 0.52.64
5.00 0.1352 0.2H0.6 0.2675 0.42A 0.5122 0.5601
5.50 0.1522 0.2916 0.3400 0.14418 0.5700 0.5616?)
6.00' D.0W899 . 0.332b 0.456(6o~ir -~~r
640 0. 0s0 0.3209 0.3631 0.4 ?011 0.611 0.113)
1.00 73V9
".04 s14
000T
0.66141
:o13
1.50 0°21-0 0.3521 .0.4.192 U.4912 0.1589 0.o398 ,
8.00 0.2293 0.3640 .. 44.,: 0.6006 051949 0.b2?T
8.30 00.2430 0..V769 0.474• 0.50Y3 0.8283 0- S-
40.O0
50.450r'Th~ry.1.341
I, .V 1,
~ I0?
1o ":. 01)21
7073u201
0.. Ill
0.0906
0.0861
41.00 (.r71? 0,42( 1.0522 0.0904 3.021 0.08"6
43
1.5•0 Ž
t:. 11 Q. 4.'21 02t4
104I 1.a,23 o.o7L2
42.00 U.VOS3 U.3
41T3 1. U. 4, 0.00342 1.0206 0.0132
42.50 2,.qV0 r I.I01
h'i39 .0 3. f94 ....... ..... 0.0694
.. I"It 179 0.06 O0
4 3.',0 o. 4y '.tit: 30 1.01.06 0.011t 1.L.162 0.k)627
44.00 1.0066 0.19,•5 3.0093 G.0757 I.1,14O 0.0598
440 3).0093 0.
VrS191 005' (;.'V(4 1.0115 oo53 3
45.00 I3 G 3.3241 of I.0031 0.01 33 13.,Oo0 0.06
45. I.I1- 0. S30ub D.Y014 0.0120 1.0061 0.0642
-11.62 15 173.71 ........... 99( -.... -i0126 1.0038 0.0536
46.50 4...265 h. q.11.'190a 0.0721 1.0olb 0.0531
47 .0345 0 !,,.4 2.9(4 ('.0730 (.oU002 u,052C
35r(.0 P Y144 0 0.074 0. 9u0 u.0523
0.00 4 S$, 1.
v.3•,2 0.941, u.1•3 0o.v973 0.0518
__0, ______ .4,,,1, "0. '4. 979.. 0.0143 0.9y50 0.0534
-- T~~w1)6
W7~o 0.74 -- -0.09OW r .99390 .03
479.s.. .0.':
6440 2-. 0.91's 0.Of1 0.9 922 0.0513
"•20.0Ou 1 ,1 . 74', 0.973. 0.0760 (1.'901 0.0517
18. SO U.Y992
"(.96I 1',0
o1.12(1),
.-9 4611
0.9801
-0 .010t;2
0.060h1
(1.9929
0.9097
0.04.82
0.04.94
19.001 1.01016 01.1169 0.9)11.1. 0.061,2 0.900j2 U1.0525
19.1.W 1.001.3 U.I 1151 0.903!p 0.0641) 0.90(11 0.0!)59
20.00 1.0016 0I. 10W', 0.9009 0.0 $10 11.9127 U.05110
20.1. .110 .1.1111. 0.9 '
91,(-~po 0.0460
0.991 1.051`9
21.0u, 1 L)136 U. Cv,12 0.9966 0.01011 1. 001. 0.0558
2 1.0)0 1.011.1 01.0911 11.001 v 0.0130 1.u0026 0.01.20
22.00 0.1410 0 (134.0 oo0110 0 0636 1.0036 0.0.949
22.50 (.011I . -r 0.011 .!0011 0.0(,35 10041 0.04r11
23.00 I.0flK 11.6171 1. bo)91.000,16 04052
0.0
--- 23.,0 (T.0000 0.619 1.00OD,. .0:0531 4"(".06 0.01227
24-. 60 (0., .10 .01.99
U.1) I .6,O0 U.0398
211', 0 (1.39(1 0I.1V631 1.003? 0.01.66 1.01.1.1 0.0369
25:,06 I,.4v31 :. .6e 1 (.11010t ,.t;41, 1-0o21 " .0631.1
25.')0 U . v914 '. 161 B 0. 916,1 0.04.39 0."990 0.0350
26,00 k. .9V,11 u..91,.
vq111 0.04419 0.917 0.0 529
u
26.1 1-1821 1.11
U.- III11 0.01.11 0.99S2 0.03A?
27.01) 0.90 0: W.9, 0 019r,411 0.9962 0.05
2.
?:0 c' :911 1'.CF 18.
DI 0.3v493',1, , 0.0"1I 0.991,l1 00)36N
2e.013 0.9')?)) 11.1rt U1.9960u 0.021l 0.9340 0.0300
20.50 0.9060 0(. C194 0. 99)10 0.00(1 G.'960 0.0305
29.o11r 9m.)(1
I 101C1'" 1.000S 0. 01.9' 0.y9310 0.01.00
29 I'D DlJ9' '.0.118 0.073
0.0 (1.9Y03 0.00
30.00 9"s
011y 0. 17911.0010 ;u 0.0601 (.:000)1 0.00372.
30.00 1.0011 0.111 (tl
______ .o00, -u.1210 1.u011 0.03(11
fllO' 00'~1. 1.00.b (T.064.3- i..,6P21 0.0131.
31.0Lj0 1..003 11.112 ()0001 0.04.26 1.0031 0.03611
32.00 (161!.61,
0:10 1.00 0.0. U.039 0.0323
32.500.12 11.8;,31 1.,001 0.10 1.00641 0.0000
331.
_______ .101 4 l 1 . 1 I 00111 0.)1 - 1.9010 0 02591
00*
N.1i IfouDO I.o.0711 1.0001 O.OS? 0.y999 0.0252
I -W,21, I). bl, 19 01. q391 0. 0 3(,1 C(4.301 0.02 1..
314. ,o
30.00 1001 1 ( 0.0166 0.9991, 0.0362 0.991 0.0263
PI: I,u I .0000 0.1.l' 0I 99q.: 0.03,I0 6.099 0.021)
36.00 039q111 1I,,,I 0.97861 0.031.? l,.vgyl o.0275
36.0011.99',6 n.w.,, 0.9911 0.034, 0.v912 0.0276
37.0 .90 i I.
D1.C., 0.9161 U.39 ).011 0.0218
31.010 .331
1 0.111(to .9901 0 .03-'dto.9971 0,0281.
581.00 .i.t,
v 6-46.d T.o vv'J o036.) 0.9376
u 0.Z29
30 .0'0 1
.91 n.100 0.996o. 0.0316 V.vv909 0.0297
39.00 (1.9( y.1,1 11.12
D190 0029b
0.00
19.00O '.3I,932 1).1,71h 1:000, 0:010 _o 1.0)021 0.0284
605.00 0.3.? 11.103
'N!, o.0022 0.0367 U.029 0:0267
1.0.50 011.
Vyv u
13U,7 1.LIU11, 0.0360S 1.0030 0.0269
4 1 D00( V6.991 l.1',13 1.001
1. 0 032f 1024. 0.02361
!,,1.006 C),491. 0.,1 ,1 1.031 0.1 .o60(7Oo
u,, 0.022r
42.00 c .1901 o.11,1, 1. 012', U.0291 1.Q0(1 0.0122.1
1.2.10 8.3990l 1110: 1.001-, 0.021v -- .L006 V0.216
41 00 1.00119 o.0,001 (0002 0-.-02l1 (.000(1 0.0211
6 3.00 1.0019i 099601
"':111 0.1121. 0.9993 0.0200
44.00 1 .oo,' 0.0613 (6.99 1. 0.0264 .91 0.0201
44.',10 (.0021 0. (:4.09 C. 1)96 ; C.0??? 0.q971 0.0211
4.', l00 1.0o(11' 0,. 1)..99', 1 0.0209 G.99(I7 1. 0218
4 Li. .0 1.002( 0.11.3( n. 990 0.030-$ ____ .v-91 0.0226
66.00 1.021 0.121 .991.? -0 6-I..03' 0.097 0.v233
1.6.1.0 1.1) 101.(14
1.199 0.0321 0.y9H13 0.0238
47.00 .101 6, r1.41 1.0000 0 03(19 B.9993 0.0239
61.00I' ý:(.0,30 , '.811 (.110(1. 0.031, (.1000 1 0.0236
6100 "192', 0.81.102 0029
T.301 0.02209
.8.0 1.9, '.111.
I ____ l.t'1.___ 0-20,1.01b 0.0 220
69.00u 1.u0001 I,.(1, I.02
t'00,10 0.0211
119.00. . . 1).99Y92 t7.1 " 1,0 .00111 0.02,1, 1.1.0) 0.0203
00.00 1.Y9301 0.) 396 1.0001. 6.02, 1 1.001IL 0.0196
Ž6
-ii.... 30 .12
01,10.0064
0.I~30.
.. . II. ..
.. l0;)40
1;I~-R460%;
0.230 77- ~
0.0992
L0,2909
o
"-ae 007til3W 0..12 0050
OU4610.108
3.090 0..2
0 9 0.1077 0.1053 0.0929 0.2092
0.0o.1639 0.1.2020 0.199 0.2320 0.3000 0.45663
uoo60i0.11'a 0I's2 1.23 0.0600 0.20291
.6.0 0. 0.45437
0.1911
2195 0.2o71 0.0232 0.o192Co 1l
4.00 G'10
1.2420 0.613 .70 .09
.0 . 9 60 061
7.60 3 90.90 0.031`4 0.61161 0.0524
0.21",7 0.3626 0.2331 0.4090 0.449D 0.5415
0.00 Q. M 1 3.."b I 0.2017 0.4232 0.!9110 0;5611
0.50. ____ .201 0.27163000 0.6016 b.32 ___
.09 -Ati00.0975
617 V.Ž1
144 1.121.08
14009 NUMB861 0.50 MACH ,aUK6I:R0.3 84031 NW4BOR 9.60.
LWLDL-TQ-iRM07HATIO. 0.50.00 WIDT1112UNCTM PAT165 1.000 0 WIDTH TO LEN&TH RATIO 2.0000
OBSIAUg ArIATION IOAUOATIQON94
RATIOa1' t4.IADIiA10l2 . 10604110 RADIATION
_____77 - -LaU~
- - ~ .Uuiak ~ 1 .Z11 0.1001. 01
_______ 00.0967 a'. 3'T4? ___.__ Bo.
o 0.14jos V.3314 6'
511.50
1011(,V
(.010f
~ ~(.01'
11 1.0I'1
001',
0.01,62
0.(0114f
1.0(1t1
1.u60U3
0.0308
031120
10001I00 9.1,1 10017- - 0806 1 . V)10 0.U021
It
3150 .1( d044 n.k, . 51oou mr O.ts 01.9916
9.00.2711.! 0.3909 0.S262 0.52 !,j 0:0922 -0.14803 .
10. 00 3.:?801 0.1.088 tl.U 055 .919 0.4610a
30.50 ('.3026 0.1.6i1 0.5141.. 0.5295 0.9309 0.4.423
r31.00 0.316? 0.1.4
Ifb 0.53 .992 01.
13.110 0.3310 0.1.1( 0.62116 0.5351. 0.97110 0.1.050
2.00T115. i'..o 0.641.19 056330911 .81
12.40 0.5.90b 0. "56 0.66hp o L.s13 1.001.! 0.3660
1000,5142 0.'i626 0.6961 0.5371. 3.u232 0.34.12
33.. Solid11 0.14.t03 0.7(26 0.5,565 I.U328 0.328?
14.90. 0.4.031. 0.1114.) 0.1.150 0.31.01.32 U.3096
3-4.!50- 0.4.1(R0 0.101 It 0. 7'.oo 0.5333 1 .o'.11 _ 0.2898 _
1155
5-00 -0.1.3 11114 011 .526? .01 0.2702
1-:1,1461 0. i1903 0:1900 0."231 I.U622 0.25133
10.00 u..61,61 0.1'i9V3 0.1111to 0.53510 I .0652 0.2330
16.50 ('.4.1V1. 0.5036t 0.1'Oio 0.5009l I(.0661 0.231.?
31.00 l.I.B.119 0.5,( 1( 0.0US552 0.5009 1.0662 0.346?
31.. *1.05 0.32 0.8(23 -- 0.1I.92 2 3.0165 0.1198
13:O 0. 5161 0.1. . .0070 .0"91
1..(1 0-.3i61.
30o5'1.2/ 0.,1 .9020 0.4141,.1 1.0558 0.35(11
19.00 .'.? 11.n 0.4111 0.4651 1.041.7 0.3389
37.%0 .'2 05
'I.50,I 0.910-j 0.4T,41 3.01.06 0.1218
*20.06 0.56ff 0.'?' 0.9513 0.1.1. 1 (. 032, 0.1186
20.,.0 01. ' 1 Y 0."21." 1.91.V/
0 0.45160 1.o241 0.1116 -
24.5 ..
-, ( ,1 41 1. 01111 111.. .5(02 0.0981.
375
r:" 1.';2Sit (01.
Ow,.11 0.3226 3.0(10 0.1016
it.O0( .1306 0.65, .02 01369 1.0(1.3 0.1034.
0051"06,1 0.37
,ii',4 I 1 U011(1 3.0163 0.0953
035 1.14.31
1.51
.1151 0. 3o~l2 3.0310b 0.0913
1401 - 1.P 1ffo0Y2t-oh
2~,6hi~ ule
60.5'", P0.61/ 1.3(1 0111 0.09,46 3.0371 0.08(7T
h1.:.00 0(q1.9fill 0
'.241.
6.0; 1'.oUIt.I 165b 0.00
I,1.sO~~~1
6v' .. 23(02,-2 0.o)13 1.0160 007
2.10 6. I3L,2 b3 i
0.63, .621, 0.01.1.I 3.035113 0.0150
1.2.10 11.405'l 01.6(10 (.031," 0.01:14- (.0161. 0.0724.
03' 749 0.14e.59 1b.
61 "i _0 1:u3s- -0.0100 -
9631
t)I 1., 1). 400-1 1.0(110.l 0.110)0U0(V21. 1 0.061`9
49.00u 1.01W ".195 1.(I) 0.0306 1. Q1-1. U.0657
61..,0306 .210',10) 0.0145 30101. 0.0635
60 .13
uOs II. Ia?3016 000 o92 0.0614.
41.50 _______ 1.0.0 IIV
0l.19 0.9v'II (0.0?of
(4_ 1.ool. 0.0595
-46.00- -- - Iipi ¾'fSc,-,4 -- - 11.9/4.A. 0.6,60 (.0"20 0.0579-
1..5 1.uZ11 1ht1~ 16
'19'( 0.(6 .006 0.0563
41l.11.29 I 6/ 0.11 0.1, 10032 0.05466
1.:.,. 50 W.1I 01
0.16 ,... I.u-,12 0.0533
1.0.0 P.0,
. 0..?
llV/54 0.0,57 0.99V09 0.0520
4 8.511 - (.01.0 (). .-
fl9 o 0.Or,9 0.9960u 0.0514
11 6 -S12.?09"
'T. 0.0104 0.1446 0.05(3
"61;10
5110.0I.5.
'b.1,
IS06I
119
U.9q1[57
0.1311
0.016
0.0716
0.99V2/
0.4930
U.05113
o.0511.
2H0. 06 0.90
1)62
2It,*
.I1 101965 0.086
29.0 6.11, 0.?' l0I~s 0.096
21.0 L 1966 002
..
3*.0 1. ' 0'?I 1.11Io
I0 001 .1500
620 .01 0. 15(1 I.22 .023L; I.u1114 0.01660
62.0so11IV '.05 1.001110 02005 I.oI'0 0.0113
3143.50 0.9623 0."019' 1. I la 0.20c11 1.0122 0.0691
66.0 It.0 051 1,1Y4 1.06 0.011 110 0.0638
19
614(1 In"54 I 1309 :1.01 0.16lu02 00
65.00 1..00-1 fI Il 091', 0.1i1 I.Yu06 0.1218
34 nu.5 G.011641' 0 1,096 ./11015 00
uZ Im,. In U7 l1 , i1723 T I 1'Y" 1.002 - 0.012891
66.50 21.02 01?1005 0I "22/ 00
0.900
61.60I 00 I.11 910 C.o 1V.00 20.01
61.00 0. ;,1 09.5 s.3: 0.1a 0 .0"1 .06
1&10
16.01 0990q 1 .06 0.0161
36. 1---- uc401A '-o~-~--r9;-
1------ 9 - .rir
U029 0.1=5
31492 I
0./1 009
f):1,1 .Uu3o 0.1155
50.0t.'6) 041, C. 1.911446 0.30
10.99251;11 0.0951*
WADO09
' 61-q2q56 10 1I 125 t f.I r a1U 0 5
MACH)NUIIIOR 0.10 14ACH tURBER 0.70 140611NU14BER 0.10
WIIDTH.TO LENGTH RATIO 0.5000 WITH TO LENGTH RATIO 1.0000 WM T19.Q HRATIO 2.0000
- E~ ZED IATION
11AD RAAIATION A TO oLAI1
RjAIT0lW M -- k -.
RADAtI?01N - RAO1IATIOI __
-'fb 0.056I, - do
174i! .Q0T I. R.5~
0.91', .911
0.19 .670.512i __ 0.1,703 0.6520 002105
WADI2 TR 1- 126
MACH NtUMBEsR .UO, MACH NUMBER 0.00
NUMDLIA 0.,1W Uo••
WIDTHmilA0i
TOULNGTHRA1 v•TI w WIDTH TO L.ENGTH-RATIO 3. 125o WIDTHTO _LENGTHRATIO0 0.2500_.
G-ENERGAhl|EtýI RADIATION RADIATIOIN tKAU11 IQ A•U KAUIA ! q!L AI•A11A|U KA01AT ION.
0.1Uv 6drt
0,kJVO U ý.312 1- 61-16 0.3430
1 5.00 V50• 1:0210 0.3246
-:5•,0 . hh P/,
0,J/ 0. 1090 O0 5-302
S14. UO 11*hopo 0.*4II/1.1 0. 09f,
0 . V•0j
U*52611
3.5202
1.0288
! .03!)
0.3070
0.2900
14.',U 0.4161. 0. 1ti 1
-- '10•- •••'• O•- 0, r~ot U I•Jv I •.0451• 0.2569
1 '* 0I hlh i~ l V lS0, 9 01 U b 5131I*U~ 0 2 406
1I 0 . 0 .41/ I .• 0 . • .- U1 1. h0
16 bUI•h 51 .'00 . l112o 0.:011•b I (U)1912 0.22419
I1 .00U!ki 106 1) 0Jlt.101112 0.50313 1.052', 0.:2099
I1 0,) 1).101
,
I0l1 0.
O 4k) f.1:4 9 VI,0!324 __ 0 1_
Q
I OU U ll4'1. 0.' U ~ UI(.;31
allI b54- 9 1. V5' 10 0 .fad?
189.00
18* ~ ''12 3
C ,"•1!
0, 5•a1.I
U*
0.' 1'1
1 0 U 91,0
O
0 ' 1J 3
0.1
0 t.h t
lH
I : U'iU,
4O4l0:154
0 * 673
r,
If I$1
s/'. ,l u,,, s U. 10d., (0* VO0 O*.1193
•)l '10
,1•. 0 C'.118I1, O -h'1 1,U65Y U.0. 1•.? - - Y-24 U.1183
3',% 0.1SH99 i.4h160
0 I *061J 0. I149!) U *VY49 0. I I 3
36 00 G-*31106I o~itPI*;pIoH 1, %|. .,• 6.9975 0.1160
35 O. 'UO13 4he 3 1 0',52 O. Isto 1.0000 0.:11 5
4 'J) I• I. tryh•1
ll~t I.*012 0.01111 I .U I02 0.0620
GEiN6RAL(,UD ATN
((0111(01 AkI
((1T(0N1 (AIAII) KAUI33J G _1(09 1610
960(10Jf ___ RAITO
FRE(Qualicy kt
9L1STANGE AIIOAC AtIfAM
KEtNC K S5
1h2fA'46 RkACIAI(CE
s .34 0.09
512 091 0.41581 1) 1 032
4~0101.21 6n-f Q. 14 Q 49 036
O001 O~lD092 -. 0.11342 ~ 6 023
116.00 0.92506 0.4192 F
6.11 0.10-57--U. 4.(1. 01.0(6
1(1.50 0.0(9h1
0.r6 0.10
0.1,
q.fs
$.140 .9001' V. 0264ro
1?11
I.u016 0.22.56
(26 2.61 0-579( 095 6.2410j-2 1. 9110 0.08915
?3.to 9 ( 0.27
220356 10251o 0.2124 1J.C. 4 0.01&18
360 0.96(1 036109s 0.9.90 0.1264 ('91.240 0.0136
1(.00 .0.9(1 0.164 3 10.921 0.1(654 I.9122 0.01.16
1.6-0 104M605 1.16 0. T597 F 1 -0 ¶. 141
C.9C 0.10911
(.00V1.042 0.210 0.9121. 0.11(0 .0.416 0.0968
-f66
0.962 0..3166 0.9110F 0.-11653 1 0. ;02 0.04
(6.00 1'9087 0 15416 0.9910Y 0.110h O.YM6 0.09(1
16.60 .0.9?? 0.13YU (.00( 0. l0(00 9b0011 0.0718
(1.00 0.981B5 0.16611 1.0064 0.10,16 (0112 0.0809
12.C60 0.9966 0.1268 0. 1.0090 0.06(16 ___(.010 0.0811
(9.00 0.00651 0.1,141 (.0104 0.010'2 .(0 .11
(9.00 0.0(61- 0.C0 (.0T0430 102 00
(9.601.014 0:1392 1.009 0.,1 1 ,90 0.0800
20.00(.(9 0.109 0.9yo( 0.0110 (-.9142 0.0969
20.6 (0 909 0.100 (.0006 0.0164., IL,_9.002 0.0943 _
4AD
0. v1-7 ),11OOY 1281 1w 1 000
MACH1NU1316 0.0Yo8ACH11 IUPOII6R 0.91 14ACIINUMBER 0.90
WIDTH TO LENGTH RA710 0. C'625 WIDTH TO LENGTH RATIO 0. 1250 WIT OLNT AI.0.2500
GENERIALIZED0 5ýIIKTXUN
1 IlAIIA"11 81108(10
K31401T10,' 81&TO AIA~TION
I 0, ROOUEOCYFAN
IT6rLLC9L 137180
18CAIEKSSAC3 RACTANCE
0.50 0.0076 0.04119 0.0153 0.01of 0.0305 0."13
1,-DO 0-.01-lIs 0.3041,....................0.1262 0.0686- 6.I9of
- - 0.0.7ly
ý13907
4, .21 0243 a
16. t50026 020 0. 123y 0
.35 0.016 0.42t_1
11.00 oGu 0 ae0.19430 0.3660 002 0.2016
4:5 U 14.0719 0.2259, 0 .3953 1.0429 _ 0.5291
00
58. 0.01310 UV9.,2 0.2174, 0.4161 0.4855 0.5117
30.50 11 (54 3.29169 0.2U199 0.8718 10,541 0.1552
6:500 0.l0 Pl'l90 0.35u9 0.V24---- 0.08051 0:563
7 .0l 0": ,9 U:11,291 0.9220 0415V6 0.60312 0.1J592
20.!000 213906 0. s 55 0.9.16Y 0.496b 7.385 0.5509
2a.00 110
229 0.06,0 0.961 0.45150 61.7062 0.1240
011,
245 4,, 1) .5'94, 892' 081 20 011.06301 0
22.0 ,o6O 0.0110.02 0.8701.090 0.1105
22.50 0.26:33 0.,1.00 0.59263 o.5190 6.0023 0.4865
10.00 0.9.41 0.40 0;1.01111 0.31149 0.y1191 0.4663
M 03 o .1 011759, 0.5203 0.9326 0.4455
24.'," 0.3109 0-4262102. .1 0.11912 0.5266 070.424
25.-,o 0.01128 10: '.- 0.6221 0.529 0.Y912 0.4005
12.5.0 U. S61 0.1.511 0.665o .3 0.529 71vr U.3629
16.001011, 0. Wih, 0.64663 0.520 I.C9071 0.34137
33.5:0__ 300.3
my 011 _____ .03100,3 U :30.0101
26.500 0110011.3 (.,11 0.(99111" 0.0)09. 0.?91*I .0.119f
26.00 0.911*10 1). (;f ,? U3.-lly1 0.0399 '10.9903 0.0299
35.00 0.91993 0.611410 -0.49111 01i f 2ol ('.9920 0.0523
231.0 0).9h12o 0. (In 5 U."199 0.0641* ). v2', 1 0.0!290
36.?0 ______ 0:9;411 (.330 ______ 0.911___ 0.0u9 Y_ 0.0309
v.0
2 , 00 3, : (y"ý,()0 9y93ob 0139
'O,,0333l 0.93 UOt2
391.50 0.9900 (
0.01 -9 1O.v93l, 0.01139y IU31.0 0.0394
30.00 I .0.93311 41.OpF?' (1.004 0.0U51*20 0.O09 0.04113
38.0 0.o1
I L . C1.0"5I 0.99331 0.01*101 0.9911, 3 0.0300
Io
c913
I,09 .I,1
0.9950 0.0U.,?1, 0.11951 0.0235
39.S'U 0.905H 0.L Ml1 .0.9962 0.01*911 0.9369 0.0393
-20 100 0 .99201?6 1,06". 0011 0.99o1 0.0.696
5z. 10 1.0493 0-.1.601, 1 0.990 0.0531, 0.1199 0.03095
93.00 1.11961- - 003 1 .0031-0 0.01129 13. L047 0.0032
93.110 1.9101 -0.3)3,13I 1.oo"1 0.00.39 3.0021 0.03092
92.50 3.0039 0.05110 ____ .O9l 0 .319 VU.00* 3 0.0393r
110,0( 1.1111h, 0. "" 0 T. 9 v b 0.03.4 -) -q .03IV U .02199
1*0.50 .001914 U.30.,, 3.0039 0.0156 .0.3ý65 0.0283
3,6.00 - 30:9Y62 0. .2,........ .....
01* 0.011*3 G.0w)1*2 0.0268
3*6.50 - .Y915 0.0503 0.994S '.0114? 3.0011 0.0308
95.00 0.90S, 0.I'* 1 .31' 0.0336 (). 409 U03029
380(.0094 '(. 644, ________ 0.9953 0.01.m - G. 3.V3 0.0241
3 : l12U 914f)~s 1.0430 b.00
Y04I .0350
3 96.o 0 (.01 1"_ -6-, ?.31,2 0.V950 03. 02"i, 0.3995" 0.0352
39'o .10 .0"1.0 0.9962 0.
__-4 I9 ((.116y 0.0221
-4.0 o 0.9999 0-.09000911 - .0W29 (1.991 0.0i26
40:3.00 .Y9937 0.D031 0. 11901 0.0495 U.9997 U.000
41.0.0 63.991,1 0.0)m16 100096 0.043011' 6. 191 0.0211
41.,,U0.9y, 03. ,0119. 0020 0.040Y 0.99
1 0ý_
.03211
420 1.9ei*nl 330.901.
ft1. u,3 30.041. 1.9,,03 0.033(
40.0,0 10.9'. 3l.3 (9M 10.995 0.0(13Y1.01 0.190 314'2
WA .11
T.04
66.71 13001) 00- .uu4 .28
11001 1430113.3 0'. 1% MALI]1.9UIOLII U.V5 MACHlNUIIOEI1 0.96
WIDTI-l [ LENGTH RATIO U.b~ WIDTH TO LENGTH RATIO 0.1250 WIDTH TO LENGTH RATIO....o25n.......
31.0 39 3.0,Y/
1.31
.. 0.;?z I 0.0114 0.12y&
513.10,111 1313 3.3110 0.2103 0.9114Y -0.13.00..__
32.00 *.,7 ff II 1 ,1 . .31"11 0.2093 0.9183 0.1298
32. 31 (,.I, i h, 3.310
1., L3 0.2008 U03921 0.1292..
33.0ULI .1f. I U.111f 3.3 '3 . U.1920 0.91356 0.3283
WADDI TR 63.2513
N'UMBIII
MACH8 0f.95 MACH0(IU14BLK ( 0.9YS)1109
WIDTH TO .LEJ'JTH RATIO 0.5000 WIDTH TO LENGTH RATIO I.UOOo WI DTHTMLR4GITUH
RtATIO02.00 00
FREIJONLY
-- JAI)IAYIII.
RkhI% A N40l,
. .AUIATION.
lIerANLc
A
.. ~ 1.41034.
141SIOTANC t;
KAIIAtIUII 0018UI1106
91 RA01ATION
HECAN630 ;.55 1AN
O. (lo'0I4Il00
0.s0 0.0629 .0 ~30.120? 0.2371 0.z072 0.2748
20.!10 -- . 10 )1
.. %.I't?,v( 0.8V111( I. .u b2 0.04082
23U.0?8 1. 100 1!8,,
U1.1,y 0.96
2, 51) 4t11111 .1. '?II. 0.093
U.0 0
fOO
05020
9,,',."0
12.00 .0 2 1.1';
()11.1.8 0.0'6,3Y 0.00
0.,7
32U.:0 1.0I)? 0.172 00
Po. 0.0841, (q.002 .00
33.00 1.-.1)190 1((l08 G. It.:V60'0 1l.8001 0.05360
31.50 t..Y (10 '.0' 1.019L 0.000 (.01 0.0300
30.t90 1.()()? ".0,81I o). o~, (.1H1U0427 (.U4131i
3 15.0 'o
,'1, .11' 0.,9U543.1 lo 1 0.02961
12.O0 10 0., 19? .32019 0.019
0g),)
33.00 v.I9('V0U ,11 I, .9? 3) 000
.. 631/
336.0 . . 0,9'~
4 0 .,.
(o '0. 41 . I 0.3 0.29
U.
3 4. u I::;1 '119' (..'-1, U 043
3. (,.9 1.,.0.0 500
375.00 0.2) .890.0
JYZ.1 1113 0 0.030
18.00 (.06 l(,( .Y901 1-0'.0i- G.i793 0.0290
36.9,0 (1.99(1? 0ll9I,..19"11 P.U.0.?11 0.1131 0.03291
39.00 "l. Y1 S4l 1.%,
I0. ' .19P3 0.0u, 331
" 0.030
38.90 (1. 9000Y UI. 9,2b8.1902 f .0-' 130 6-.194 0.0320
00 .00f (.6.111 11 ".l9' 8121S 0.061.1 0 ."350 0.U332
30.50o .11114 0.).1 99 ;.19 8.04802 ".' yi 0.0214
31?.00 1). 92AV 9.111 91
"29?2. J01.00394 00 0.0052
40 0.'0 (,9'9 1115.2 '1"91 0.06 11 0. '??'. 0.01351
02.50o.29 0.1.1 y.0)1 0.04,Y L(. 902 0.-365
0,1.00 6 )(I I .1(2
.11),0,, (.0'-,.0409 1.8031 0.1)356
42.(10 1.011 (.01
I.,1 0.03913 I.UO01 0 .'1349
4 100 1.1U 11,?1021, 0.011 1.1.01 0.305
4 4.910 1.0"1 ".1' 4 (.00 5" 0.03o2 1.0006 0.32ti9
40.00 1.1101,11 l f I1. 0.:
uS 0).0U0
$4(.8044 0.0273
5.9
S 'o . 3.001,0 . 0.03
1I2 0J.9333 1.0039 0.U259
46.0 .01., 0111, (0-2 b.O:o .833 0.024o
46.9W.110,1 "o 18? 0.8302 1.UU23 0.0L2310
07.1100 j'L '4111
1.01h.1Gel 0.030t .01 .02
475-.
,u .1( .00 .19 I.LOOO 0.0229
08.00 lll31,3040 3 1 . 020!.029 98.9.9 3.6223
- jy 02090.9900 0.020t 0.9980 U-0225
49.80 r.10
5.010 0.9971 0.02-12 U.9911 0.0228
49.50 0.499,, 0,.."i P1.2016 6'.029i, V.99Y04 0.1,233
50 .00u 0.19? (15110 (19', .0302 .9999 0.0239
1a
WACI _1_4_3
MACH 3034660 1.50 34666NU333O34 1.50 3'0643
N43J3306,3.5v, -
4
0. 5 133 34.3 3',3. 0 3.. 3 3'I 4l.b 3 , 'f3 5 3
5 . 0 0 0 .6 3 316
3.duC 10 1___
!.3.3
336231_ 3.33331s - V.,.413 4.0III,
f 5 _ 1,
V ./ I ____--
5 7
8.30 3.0256 0.3663 30:2 ".'. -t:119,931 3993 : - -I
03.0795 0 .3 2 0 :3.33656 0.3 3 3 3I,,333 0 .2 0 3011
6 .200
6:U1 O- ,S 1,32
1. h~36 0.~oY, 0,i 11 jZ1). 1. 4 U
303946 0.33001 U.3353U.,19 U.691120. 0.S;9N
.6 0
6.50j _U.014 U:44t 0.9233.56 03.4103 3.33(62 0.25430
6 .60 02 0.9423:73'11 3.57 U43.2(3 3.066, 0.,in60
6.701) 3.0Ills095f00 4459 -_ o.4161 3.v6666 . 62266 ____
6.60 3.0676 0.4.066 D.06132 33.Tv06I 3.60v - 0 (.2636
3.33632
U.0 0.23 3.06? 0.23 .Qb12 0.23304
1. U
1.0-4511
'-1. ------
-8.3.2v03
20.40
-10.57611
-79.1O,
0.
w-
025
014
0.10"3
9-214.1
j2210.1
-lI..6389
-t.2226
-5.21139
14 0.1 02
0,1912
0.2112
0.2408
0.2500
-;1.2.1510
-971.1
-2.110
-. 1902
-3.469H1
0 254S
0.2M4
0-.10119 -
0.2581
2.20
2.1 -0.8vZJ....
-0.6597
0.30yo
0. 3if0
1
~
-U.20V5
.S996
O~9
0.8A135
111.
0. 11
-0.0503
001.3Wk
0.44890
2.30l -01.1171 0.4525 -0.10S9 0.1.263 0.02401623
2.40 -0.31by 0. 34.014 -0.0198 0.43.6(8 0.0901. 0.4(419
9.07-851
~~ 0.7909 ..- 5 L-.----------.
0.5s7ru
41!~*L__
o.v9s(7
5
072)LJ697
0.%.105 0,919V 0.21.251
__
0Ra-PL.lr CM1414.0
0 108IAT10I 1.16iht!
AT 9.4 'IsL,
t1101RDAIN
A R~AI'
3 0.80 .20
4011.3199
9.420
- 0.0201
0.93Il
40 tjl
.66007
-16. 0 .063 --
_28.79d
-2M119.080
0;0302J
0.0611
0.4011100 .9L-1. 4 0.2.-178.0000 1.102313 -
0.40 -'011.0140 0.0560 -8.40 a 0109 -72.6210 0.0163
- :4813,8270 0.0MID -24 1.9090 0.01805 -111.0 0.0T952
0.620 - -274.0940) 0.0839 -137.0410 0.060 MAIN56 9.14 t
110.00.-615.250 0 .i; i -S5.3165 0.140? - 061
6 0.It,12
.51.Q93
0I3I6 -,.0l~ 0,1sr8 -25.08 0.07
. 1679
'4911 0. 1521 -1 9.819? l'19 16 -IA.19VI 0.2068i
I.21) -29.818; 0.16S4 -14.86154. 0.2032 -'1.90i U..2 210
--. 0 2 2.Bb42 0 "' 7- I1140 4 5 0 -?2 6 "a.680 0.21.11
1.40 -11.8326 0:1417 -81.6841 0.2408 -:-1. 900I 0.2"l4
2.0 5r I
S3. 0.290? -1.11196 0.0601 -1.0011 11.185116
2.10) ..3.0044 0. W22 - L.'I 9j 0.31492 -13,Y119 0. 391
2.410 -2.6366 0.3136 -1.17116 0.31116 -U1.124 3 0:.1131
2.60
2.0-__ ~ -2. 1612
- 1.81W6
- .3241
0. '3364
- 0-15Y
-0.HI046
_9 -A .4304
0.4 129
-U.13'"4 11
-0.46S5
- 0 .41
0. 4400l
-.? _O- 1. s80 0.4462 - ___A.' 043 -0. 01.2i A _____
2.80 -1.3011 0.0P64? -u.5328 0. li 611 -0.2140 0.464U
-1.909 0.3469 -U44 141 OI6 0.4166
3.0 09: 0.10 0.ý46 -1. 1214 0.48rtl
3.10 _____ -0160 116h 0.61?f
4, -0.01 u46
3.20 -0.0446. 0.0460 1 00.4199 -0.01;, 0.6011
0. 30 jý,, i0 0.41163 061? .31
QUIlll 0.51H8 -
AfirAERAL
t 2 ED RAOI Atl ON OUT IONt kADIAT I a 15
All 1A, al-In
11 Ohl, I
FReguMv RE 5 14 1ANCE .11.111 All 1 5 15 TANC
H1911.41190 U. 08 U0911. 211
0.20 01 llý -1004.6600 0.0416 O.M6.
.. 1. 0.06311
O.R. 0 0.0850 0. on"
- so, '140a 0. 10M. -io.2
0
61.5H L.,
-6tl.5144 .0,
0. 0,1Itio -3b.pslo 0.1240 -.1 1it
-42.2104 0.131A 11Q!tý. ýO OA19Y a. Il.?B
-1 .0124 0.104 -6.052 0.1664
-18 :4:1211 O.IhOd
-13.49ur 0.1041 - 3 3491 0.21JU4
7 00 -V.8hVA 0.21?9 -4.9240 22AN -2.4 Iý Lls 2118,
2 2 M2
-1.4163 -3.6847 0.
1.20 0.2313 U.21128
1. 3sk 5 "1 0,2494 3151, 0.2b 1.1
1.40 -Z459I 0.26T2 .. 1.01)21 0.2urill
4j. 71 ? -o'bi I L).J 0ý5t
-- ----
1.60 -?.Ibwf 044019 3306-I
: ;:0-Yu u - evik I
U.,116? ý-,J.bn5 0.3ylu
Wo -2.2111 IRH -1.0hos 0. AM, i -U.41122 0. 34;10
I.UO -I.FY0 0 3354 -0. BLI16 0.551ý -0.3612 U.3syb
1.90 1. US? 1 6:4516 'Ut6km- 0.16fill -U.M4 u. 17bd
-1,1mal 0. Wil -U.52415 0.1(346 -0.1,000 U.3YSS
-- zk.-NOIlk- -_A. 4 QUO - U- ! 42ý- 0.409H
2.20 -0.1?65 0.3918 40Y9 0.11164 -0.066 U. w W
2.10 -0.62ho 0.412h 11.ki Is 0.114 It
2.111J -0.4y7w -U.ISbb 0.'ýW 0. 111
U.,sif, i
7:60 0.45ib -0.04 11 0-tuo 0.08-1 ; U. 4M4;1
2 ?o 70.21,11 0.4665 o.006S -. 0.411 12 U. I I f i U. 4 11"
2ollo -0. 11441 0.478ts 0.04Y4 0.11,64 -0.-5105-
2 ýO U,0863 1). Mr 0,10et.
3 00 -0:2HI,21 0 ')021 u 5i4l
011;2ý5 0 !:-5--1 .-L5,68 U, 14 r
2 0.0674 0.5234 0. 1it 15. 0. 114W O.W416 U. h5b I
--- 3.30 0. ION3 0."344 - I yiv !).I rui -.
--- A Zlk
bV 0.124213 11.245" U.',641 0.21)?;,
U0
0, 5t 50,__ u.m( u* jfj4 J
3:60 0. ,
1,
Is"," 0.131,01 0,26ys
O.?9k.O U.SU19 1146 sq2d
3 10 0.2432 -O.SbHo - - -- -- -- - - u. 5H9? 6OWY
3.60 0* 2fif 0.51S., 0.34U6 U. 514(0 0. 11,, 1 u. 6o I f
4.,40 Ll.M6 illb -- - -- u.,-iy4q
4.00 0.5242 0.1)888 0.5843 0.60ya 0.4141 U.6410S
4-10 0.3486 -2-LI-916 L- 0 '20"', (). 1, Pý4 ý41 0-62S.3
4.20 0.3fly O.buol O.."'S U. e,.,U I, (; 6wi U.6401
0-4944 '0 D.L." u U:4 M) 0. A-t" Q
4.40 0.4160 0.60yu 0.1164V -U-.62vo U.40104 -6-.45sda
4. So Pahl 44_ ý40 W_, 0', u 5U(5 0 - L-42-1
4.bu U.."ll U.6111h Q. 5(1/ (.. !. i"'. 1 0.64,.,s
0.4rflr - - 9a 0,5210 0.611Y k-, S I iUAll FIf
0.49"1 0.0ý4 (). ý, Still U. 1,, 91) 0. "6W, 0.6-011
4-92- -- 1)a S L4-L 1). "SM, U. 1,4 14 U."I its
ý ou 0. " v 1 0.6?61 U..,? sb u f,,.?u (). 'IVh r u. 6
%:to U. 62( -L) , u 0. 61 1 0. 611, 1
13.62fu U. 6'ý04
(1.114 to
ýO "o M,
56", o0 Do1 1,61,14
0,62 sl 6 1,1 e. b 44
5.uu u SYY!l a lj:eW
U b., 6 U. ý.hb 4
U.6 Wki 0.62rh -0 .b-i®r t,
V. ') I " Qý 020? 0:40"t 63iýAG
rIj Q I.-FFjT I.h 1,
Ho 0.61.06 O."h f (I took U. 6 S4 T 0: 6"'1,
S.90 0.1111,v ---
0.61ilib U.620H M208 U. filuh U. 14 Of
6.10 0.7021, U.6111i U, 6Z "L.
6:20 0.115F 0 . (, I 0.1s.6 0.1,211 1 i-,,,
6 30 0.721lb 016-1 ?S 1601 0. Illou hýoi
6 0 0'ri,11 O.hu92 U.fBI4 0.61J4 o.hul, 0.61ý."
6:4,0 0.6056 0.79it ul 1ý008 ti I U.Ili-ý4
6 60 U:16lz 0 m0ljb 0 6114(1 0. 112ýlb 1).Cu., 1
6 0 fillf 0 : bip)"1"I u u I 1ý ". -ý u, "i ?" U. Is
6 0 0 54ic- 0 8,111" 0 "M (J.IIUUI 0
6: Vou 0:11fly I U:tssqi 0
3 j. 04 i,)
00 0 804 0. Sol, 5 0. Sliz I u. " I Uj 0. 1
- -- ?. to A-81Y-5- 1115-rVy 01mbol U. " tc, I W10. 0.1,1%1
1 70 0.8294 0. 5 ruT if. iii6 14 0. '00 r hq U., 0. 11646
7:30 0. R 0.11696 U. 0 r 04 0. "fit. 5 L";;'; 1 -!L.-5-,) i u
7 0 0 S6Lk u 1311M 0: "'M i U.Yotid
0 0 : Ru's, 0:s5yl o:"914 v Y. 19 "10
cb- -- -, . I ----
675`6ý.6 U.I'll 16 v. vol'y G.'W.4 U. WOO U."., I i
7:6"u -v-9-4 ll-L-- -0. 53 4z
0.6tilly 0.1ý424 0111ý11-0 U.% U12 (1.941,1 O.Swil
iauO O.HU96 - 0.5mr (',YYN (). 4hq;? ji. L)I yq
8.00 U.11910 U. ý)i 10 U.,p i (." O.S1.1 U. Y" s G. tl I ýb
I U-9434 -Q.-fA J I -AlktW?ý
7 100 U."U0 U.V69-, 0. 448 1
9115- QY562 0,42.0-4 0. 1, Jujý-
U.40 O.V2 In 0.ý1016 0.962ý D.uYI5 u. YmIh U.40 15
ki. -,Q 0.9?1)8 0.110 1F (). 9 6 [If 0. 4H4 1 U.91i6v t', I-W
0.4911H 0.9155 0.4tiv U.YY"l O.Ualou
0.910t. A M()UUo -U.YY(l 0.4ý.I-l -
13.fjo 0.9465 0.4840 U.98si U.U64S I.buld
-- 8. 99 - - - 9. 1S 4 f B2 -9-118V ---- Y,.4 5 (d I.M.,
9.06 0.9564 0.1. US 0.991*5 u.l,ý.12 1.0101 0.441)(1
,:2 III I 0.".2,68
a , 9096 0!45w-
9.40 0.97il 5.44ys 1.0ort, 9.4?-,4 1.1,166 u.b I S'.
9.50 -0.9trIj 01 440 1_(- iuy U.419?
98 12 0. 4-OB-4 :-0 14 o so l.uio4 0 4003
V.10 fi.9841 1,41 i.0 It'y 4"ll I, U 1
9 80 0 9tsliu 41111
9:90 A:-gq I ? -.- Oo42?i---- - J12a -,.u so 16
fo. ou 0.9941 n.4111 1.024t o. smq4 ity,
U~~ ~
GENEI2ALIJL0
V0002C
..BAIAT14ON
0STSTA9CU
12A06IATIO
6GA~
HADIAT ION
25E51$1A'4t
IOAUIAI
ION
602,l~ CAC.
AOIION
Ao1I10
",-2'IL2~ FC6
1I30 4@Fa
56 -- --.
A.159_2 _ -?3.W6[18 0.198 -15.5002 0.202V
1.D-36.725? 0.1711 -1I6.A4 11 0.?060 -12.2156 0.2118
S~. 2-29.398r20 -Y.1611 0.2326
1.60 -23.81A22 0.9O-103 .M59 -I.9106 0.2473
-19.66.16 0. 061 -Y.flilf 0. 2m7F T77 0.2618
I *.70
-- 10-16.20114 0.21 -0.0613 0.2615 -5.55U 0.27621
1.9i0 _ - 11.5441 -0.229 -6. tiY. 0.276r7 -. 65'- - U0.2902
2.00 -2161, 1u 0.260;1 -5.6b11 0.2879 - I.764b 0.4062
2.0-.91 - 0.2bi16 -'1.7949 0.3010 -3,1666 0. 1111
2.20 - A. 2 6L. 0.2621, -6.0815 0.3139 -2.6866 D.351
2.30 -7.0969 0.2M5 -14.91V 22.4266 -2.2906 0.3461
2.60 -6.1?10 0.2040 -3.000? ,33091 -0.5!f 0.3578
2.50 _ -5.0045 0.2967 8 1-u252 22.5 14 - 129- 0.570,
2.60 46.6146 0.,1051 -?.Pill 0.11615 -2563 03832
2.70~~ 0.914 -60,
;608A,#922
4215 0.A3956
2.80 -352?P,
1. 0.5257 -1.61131 .1. 1,310 - 1.0679. 0.62011
2.90 -3.0969 O.i357 2 -.- - -...-..-..-.-..
0j Sv098 -Q.9110 0.6152.
3.00 -20724Y U.3456 -1.2767 0.4095 -0.7855i 0.6011
5.9 U. 45 0.46-
0t,971 0.IV6 0V20 0.oI.
5.0 0.0050 0.4u 0.55 0.6t,1 0."261 55.66'.
5.90 0.nI) 0 .4461 -1 - kŽ i.
j "I3"U. b.,AI - - 5 .. -i 1 601,6346 _
3 23 .- U.6104.
6.0 9.455'y - U16A4V
1.2 0.675 0.44
h2 0f.1( 21 0. 6657 U.1105S V. 6011
7.1.0 0.6005 0.6050 4.7415 0.52 C.11.
b.0
4.5040.1v- 0.442ý;11 0j.710M 0.5.09
() 3 1f74I _
7.00.6125 0.3U60 6.16,4. 0.6-101 6.1 0.6503--
1.01_-__QfL
v.1 0.64177 .U..21t0O s U.654U______Qy
L
.00745 0.6459 0).184 M 0.06106 0. 16109 U. b"n
0.00 0.1721,1 0.6040 0.016'. 0.64111 1). 136/ 0.0140
-- -0. 7316 -.- .425 - -- -- ,L02 L A &-o62M3I ffi7 -05 L Qx646t
0.0 .7Y39 0.6250 0.81514 610104 O.Bo5, U0.64ZH
04.514 v65 11
7.10
0.5(1
U.5
.161
0.5(190
.9,55' ~ q.37o
.18
0.13
L1.......
to
0.U566 0. 65 32
1.30:2056 0.5b56 0.5050 0.6m7 0.5713 0.6555
71)02256 U.518H7 - 0162 17 0. 6196 0.5815 0. 6, 1%
1.60 0.2458 0.59(6 0.5379 U.6414. 0.50o;, 0. 65 1
______ 0 ------
______5Y4 sr9
U.5L.0.4 0. ..5 1 kv 0.511
1.60 0. 2L32 0.59(0 0.U6531 0.5558 11.S312 0.6500
7J~ ___.L0I U..-539h_.~- ~ U
0.68,9 (166. 0.551111
moot106 L.
-------------
0.6612
7.57 .5(90 0.6011
WADD to 61-75(1
MACHNUMbER 3.40 M.C0 MAMBE40330 .5
MIC_____
TO2N ~ mQL-f-HR!0;.0000 -I01II '0 ILEN40tH
RAIlS 4.U03Vk
"RSDIIIJ IIIIOO tDAlIO lU R040)4130 - tIN 'l
0SITANGE RHACTAICrOM ,
- 21---ti---rfT Ai#"-- 001"T9 ."01146600 00291 a0 Olv
0 10.90 0919
0o :903. 60S0 -41.8:j20 0 0540
-15180 0.05 -56 il."'20 -lb 731*
1T
0.0 zj~l240 406937 -9.90 0.0720 9.105 0.0132
0.6 -29.770 .OoS_109.H560 S.0k-4.,21 007
- 0.0 -51.010 0.0974 ...... 6,26k9 10.1006 -34.359 0.1023
0.80 -90.9u656 0.1111 -45.4679 0.1149 -22.1290 0.1161
0.9Q-.27 0 li. j pj , 1291 - 0,10
i.t e -
2.00 -45.6610 0.1.385 -P22.U261 0. 1452 -11.4044 U.115
---- .10 -03.9665 0.1521 -16.9?40 0.1512 -8.477? 0.1598
1.20 -24.89Q19 0.16Sf -12.941Y 0.1712 -6-807 0.1'140
Apy~J51 0.17 1 -10.0166b .15 --. 0203 U.liiIts
1.4.0 -15.9696 0. 19W25 -?.V698 0."N0 -3.96990 0.7021
2.0-0.4636
~~~0 0_____J.3j..2051
0.2189
-6..0i
-',.2121
0 232
0.2.262
-3.1849
-2.5066
0.21160
0.22911
2
1.70 -:1,6221 0.200 -o 0.2097 -2. 12;6 U.241 it
1.80 - '. I163 0.2450 -i.5616 0.2530 -1I. 1%fl D.25,11
1 ,10 .. -6,0252 0.5j-.82 026t. 1.64.7%
2.:0,0, -5. 0918 0.270 -. 55 0.2744 -1.W291 0. 2030
h. 20 -4. 1026 0. 2M9 1 -2.314116 03.2224 -5057 f 0.7970r
2.20 -3.7215 0.2956 -1.11241 M.OW6 -0.01,31 0.3101
2.30 -. 0) 0.3079 1. S60Vi 0.3119 -0.1414 u. 3? 29
2.40 42.19H 0.5201 -3.48S0115 -0.6290 0.531%
2.40 - 2.410 0.352A -. 50 0.3429 -D.SS21 0.34"2
2.60 -2.1019 0.3040 -1.0004 0.55%)1 -0.4499 0.656u
2.10 - 1.45)6
I 0. 050 0.66 0. it-12 00.578210.01d
2.0-1.6101 0.3613 -6.7140 0.3190 -0.35 0.50441
2.0-1.4111 0,0781 --1J.644,5 0.0901 V..05,; AI
3.00 -. 4% 0.3899 -0.,54% 0.4023 -0.2110 0.41004I
3.10 -109413 0.4010 :U.4 M1 .4336 0.6L1 0. 41 w9
3 1)2 -090 0.4110 - (. 4-04 0.424? -0.1274 0. 4 1)
1.50 0:.9419 04425 -0M416 0.4 05? -0.0925 0.L4722
0.6 -0k31 .43 -0.28,10 0.44641 -1..0506 0.4il1
3.50 -4 .6 0 0L44L3301- . 2jk1iL3 3.1)?. 0. 028Is1 0.461l
3.()0 -W.6613 0.46136 -0.1075 0.6h[2 -0.0002 (1.041U
3.70o -0.4860 0.4632 -0.1441 0.or77 0.025/ 0.4844
3.0 -0.4111 0.4 129 -: 0u.3-0% L,1 0.41;072 0.0504 0 4944
5:.90 - 0.556?b 0.4H224 -0.0696 __ 0.4969 0:013, 0:5.51161
46.00 -0.-190 U.4916 -u.0361 0.-.064 0. Ovsu C.S130
- ls0A2..11)
16, 10 Z-l.IA .0A01
. -0.00460 055 0,1162 u"5221
5.20 -0.1940 0.509S 0.0264 0.5245 0.156 0.5520
4.4 I0.116 0.26 .0700 0.541? 0.I107 0.954Y
4,.50____ 0.0153ý 0.4246
1) 0.1026 0-.5600 0.191c) k54
U ____ 0.5L.. 060 0.16061 011fl0fS'
Q 1.0
4.00 0.0258 .5516 0.170? U."152 0. 12 0.'I IV1
4.90 ____ 0.0551I, __ 0: st~v -u. I O_ 0.1/4 0410' 1.251,ý.- D.NI 4
I-
s 00 U.oo~iif 0. f I1o Saloq -- 0.511 0.7. ,y45%
5.1 0 0.1110 -0.50 0,2hO.o4w. 0.56,,.2011 0. 6021 _
5-.20 0.1161 0.50,42- 02.v
?0 ý .610 305
0bbOis . 0.0
S.00 D0-_D .261r2 0.60/0 0. 3202IJ a45-blu......
5.40 0.161,0 0.$VIM 0.2050O 0.63140 0.5151 0.'v
-,(I1-lI 91 0.60
h31 1I.3iut 0.6141 0. tl4/j-0-74
5.60 0.2?291 0.60066009 0.6622 U.3.6401 0.02
5.0 U 1104 0.6 109 0.50 06%11 0.5921 U. 64211
6.9 ______ 0.-200 062,37
o ___ ",.46H 0.ntVI -- 0.071I -9. 64660
6.00, 0.5092 0.42312 0.3850S 0.661S 0.4211 12.6612,
6. 10 0.1271 0.6(125p 0.3992 0 .6671r u.6550 0.65S5
6.20 U.5550. 0.6565 0. 414!1 0.65,16 0.448b 01.6591
6.40 U.100U6 0.6439 0.4465 0.65803 0.4761 0). 666
6.50 0.4094 D.6412 _ _ 045"9 0A4100.84 .60
6.00 0.4138 0.6,505 o.41il 0.6646 0.501.; 0.6130
61.70 0.1099 0.6%45 0.8/ __%..66l Q.5164 0.6144
6.6 0.1.451 Q2.615 0.5016 0.6696 0.5291. 0.064b
6-"0 0.4612 pdgŽ10 05I5 S6I
1.00 0.1.763 0.6603 0.52v0 0.6016 o.641.n 0.6004
7.10 - - - . 491 4- Q.(0.'29 5______SL U 5,
7.20 0.6049 0.6436 0.55,64 0.6166 0.5"3I 0.6051
1.00(1 6.20
S26650 0.6691 0.6ft..... 0.59U4 0 0041
7.4 0 0.36 0.666 0.5818 0.6786 0.6000 0.6d40
7.0 0.5485 0.6611 5 -- L 0.6792 --- __ O-kL2n...0-t....
7.00.5620c 0.6070 0.60311 0.6796 0.6520 0.613s6
AL.A its 17- --- 1 _ __0.621n 0.4bL9iL- ___Qk.& 064 k6110x -
3.0 .5890 0.6686 U.6561 0.6191 0.6566 0.685lý3
7.90 0.602 0.6481 0.6465 0.691.6 0.6681 0.6000L
0.00 K.65 0.6685i! 0.65091 0.6169 0.6000 :1.6841
11.3) 1362 8 0.6810.6110 .067MI
0 0.0926 61)101 _
8.00.6400 0.6416 0.6833 0.671? 0.7044 Oh.ý
0.1 0652?r 0. 666? 3 64 hri 0.1161.QIt. .J±414..
8.4 0.648 0 .65 0.1067 0.16071 .. 3
0.50___________ .66 0,6645 o7o .70019
0.4W 0.6h"6 0.6631 0.7291r 0.6733 0.75902 U.6151
1,7 - .1 0.66Q1 Q.Q k 0 2±4~l I 0 5 f
0.80 0.7336 0.650? 0.7521 0.6669 0.7123 U.670s
8.90 __ ~ l 06-12h8-
-,j D.4331 0.664 5 0....,±&432____.65(df.........
0.665u
a00
9. "a1340 0.6656' 0..79
U 0.661,9 .19,?31?
9.20 0.7Y,6 0. 650H 0.16 '.530.)0658
9.30 0.1661 0.64131 0._B4v14 0.652?t....... ,s3Z0k i .054.
9.4.0 0s74 0.45 .81L,6 0.6496 0.051. 0.15)1.
9.54: 604.LL
-2 3- Vut&O& - QA.L-----S04b
9tA ; 10 6481
9.60 0019161 0.6093 0.8154 -).6425 0. f"548 D.64L.2
0___ 2.06 0.6375 .. Iis46~,I~AL 0.8444 A11.1403 01:II
9.80 0. 62 063 0.U4 0I,0 0.io 0.60
10.00
9.9__ ~ 0.926,
0.85140
0.6207
0.6250U
-______064UjAL. 9..3ak.
0.0133 6.62e.3
- -0i~lI
0.012
0.6315
0.6210
~0.00
-
1.0o
~ ___UM-___ ~ -5.64.99s0 0.0800'
9l._3.,~A0L-9.0.~
Of (W.90-
-2 a . 1900 0.1003
-282.4940
-142 .5.350
.01
,qjQ 00
6.16-5.11'
-
11157
I i L.lJjj.
006
0. OF?~~
0.11100
03
-212.791WO19 (i.,. ..
I.21
-0.03 10I
1.20 -16P.6H 10 0.10 -81.3121 0.1468 SS
-5A. W.I 0.Wll1
1.40
1.40
. -LS21
-10006550 0. 1390
~0,1300l 614ý
-',0.4661S
14--'2*
0.15.92
tk
-33.6162
_ 0.11.41 -
0.1651
,, 1.i ,__
:,L-
-121 .',Lk") ,-3,-61
%,I5 -__ - . 0.ai.1. .. 0
N .0(0 1.0.2' o.. -05,63
A.117 ,10 -0.4101 0.5.101
11.0 5P.
-1.25 0.13 -h. 01.1',U0 -0.22511 0.60215.
6.030 -1). fe,36 0. 1.71t13 -I. 19'. 1.450 -0.u010 01. 5.716
1.60 - 0. 66V, -Q,1',Qh Il.11 U.Jl1.5L 0.0___15__.
6.00 -0.61(2, 0.5.091 -u.1?16 0.53661) 0.0587
0 0 11.118si
6.10 -0.'A05.2 01.."1',0-"1l 0575.06- 1 64( 0. 1100
6.20 -0.6313 0.11WO1 r.5l 0.1759 0.01196 0.S662
t.1iv - .115k
01.1,11 .00t". ALO- 1136
09L- -
6 0.0 L 9, 0%I U.C0"3.0 3111161 n- I100'. 0.6004%
6.5. -0 360 - a 315AL-- ---
L25.s .xt9I 0.15 Li-.kLj-
66-0. S0446 0.116 I1 0.05.73 U.1171050 0. !tit,1 0.614U
f,:6".7) -1. 760 l - 37111 0,0046 -- 2.~69
q0.- 200f VGIL.
6.00 -0.225.7 0.U11 .1062 0.6041 0.2201 0.6228
6.90 - -0, Uj181, %ý6fl W~tU
1.011 - U. I 53f U. 5,04 .I'1 0.6150 0.15.0 if. 650,0
-- 7-19 0O11,506 - 3 11 rfL- ___0,fjts -- rl rL72 -0-fri
0. 60W
".20 7.0-0.050"1
-0.01180 0.11677
0, 11111
U.19300
t.2116
0.6206
0.6242
0.2660u
0 X12t 0,0,41.61
1.60 -0.032965 0.511113 0.2065. 0.6271s 0.32Y2 0.60611
1.110..-5.0011 3,13i
,_ - -sY1"
-9.61 OL OS511,V66
f.60 0.02110 A.I028 0.2fl6 0.60Si6 0. 361Io 0.65.1.11
7.70 Q0v-5.1i6. Q.29-20._ 3Q~utd- 0 IMI6Al.6124,
7.80 0.01111 1). ,,16 1.S1516 0.6066 0.5600 u. s6116
07.98 0.11 9,18 - L..SS6B Q. G0 11
3,juaz 0.6,156
1103 0.1216 0.1161 1). 0'. 76 0.6441 O.620 0.66116
810:l 0.1434. - 9-Q65fth . 0
2.3j60
1
0AA. 0 2M. fr,~ ___-4
8.20 0. Iwo 0.601J] 0.30 6.6005.~d 0. W,16 03.66.01
IJ~iL O.Ot?.
Q. - - - 6
Q.46s 5 105.b51A
6s
8U0 .20,11 0.6,06? u.41 ID 0.65.1 0.6714,), 0667
8.6 0.2;02.6 1.6096 1..6 .51 0,41.5.001 1 0.61016
8.70 __ _ __ __
.. 0.,22f,IS1..... .61355 ---- _-k-549 A _0 9,. nf -- Q___
8s.00 0. -?05. U.61-111 0.4660 U. W,I6 0.11021 0.6111,
110 &26) -0.&LL -- - 1..06S18 3~d0 ---- Q. ___5__ 0,611Y
'1.00 0. 1121 0 .6bP)2 11.4V661 0.6,961 0.5"5I71 0.6124
_____9 jJ.. 0.L0,10215 0.6200 u.6066 u0.6161 13.1.10 13.hf,1
5..01,1 ":h,6/ 0.11126 U. 6z'.1.1 0.612?
6.0-.S666 U.62
i* 0289
1b- 0.'4.01' -003 .1.8(16
.J.d611 UhR.401132 06 2
6.60-.14 -0.3386
.. 0.446 .11 .102 -0.1702 0.42it
6.80~~ 8.11 8 (1
.011
?j00' 011 " 0. 1tt13
6.90_o __ -0.2012 0.4219 -u.lt~
ib,) 4__
6.08 -0. 18-3 9./n -.0.0_Q
1. Hf.3.61 61P 0..3
___U_ U1,ljf 0.040 1,243 1Ah1
-0.09(0 0.0.1 0.0I90L It66 10810 .
:1900 46.'
~A
1 L 1 aV 6.aLj5S2- - -. ht.19 002 070049
4.40 -0.03,6 0.466
fY0.13101 0.66108 01.041S ((.6!',
6.60 ()1209 0.660163 06/ 0.0665) 0.'.304
t0.3Inu ~ 0u.445H 6. 1916.4
11____ - U.S06 t. V
U.23.f & 6 n1 .
6.90)
6.00
-. 0.94
-0.110u
mt13t
0.5.192
_____
0.0391
~ P0Al-
0.66 1.
-islio
2
111Z5 0
0.6(S
5.10 I0II6i21834
6.Q6 -- 1Q.kAO 11 --- 0--.3126.4 _ L5
S..2 -0.0916H 0.603
1. .09081 0.',',4 0. 526)6 0.6261ý
6.4.0 6O.ŽuI .6( 0.30,,2 a;.?0I
U161 f"
6.0
cM 6.39"I98 0I(6
t_ 4
61? 1; ; , O266
0.60( 0u63. 0.6101
WAIYI)~ (06-2 -
_ _ __jf_ L_ _ _In_1
010-07
W85I 11
MACH WJ1488 3..50 MACH N124BER 3.-A.. MAChtNUMI1.1.0
WIDTH To LONqj" RATIO .000 801 00LolOT wAL9-.W2,00 ...o)fJ1 TO L.ENGTH1
RAJIV 4..000U
01 ,8 '
93.12", 0. L t . . . . 22 - 0.0,25
00 70 lg61 ,70.12 9
-23.15b :7?.462 ----
-k3o.2561 0.10h5 -103.619 0.5 -bi.3100 0. 0090
1.00:" -26.66I'll 0.l1115 Z,2.30 0915 - .1048 0.1100Y
1.0-104.500 o.1921. 533329 0.191? -26.12b1 0.912
!A.O-- -~.1L.Z12L
___ l.0shQ___ U.5fl6 -. 5221
19__ 0.12301
2.0 -12.3218 101.290 -29.912-2-.0. 13136 --9..quql r0.2,10
nolg -46.798__ 0.2UL9 Z Ld 9VL Q10 11, &do 5 0.2145
2.0 -37.2-54 0.2305 -16..6191 0.2]!)3 9.500.'2
2.3014 0. I IV216-
.3
".3.. 0.1621
-211.668.31 0.2?56 -.1.2.3229 0.2759 -161.65 U.2I031
2.60-6.915 0,1632. -19.089i4 U. Tau2___ -_$.91.12 0.21k3.
2.80 -. 1910 0.243 -13.b441 0.2805 -. 29;IV1 0.2191
2.010 -61.3230 0.2930 a..81
20.900 -5.0061. 0.2200
2-10 -10-5745 02Q.220 03 ..- 0.130
3.00 -9.1351 0.2315 -k.61.91 0.292(3 --
2.L1520 0.V.I3
2. 10 i.32j1 0,24,L -S.fi..9 M 3. 929 -0.6456 U.2521
1.20 -2.123.5 0.32556 -3.5)11 A.35-.6935 U.32611
2.5.0 -6.20915 0.§A6 -4.1.0 14219 1.41.820 33.M111
2.60 -5.8719 0.36155 -0.8,3.1 0.517 01.2YY1 0.3111
3.10 0-1.40 052932 -2.D1123 0.591.3 ..1.l0 __ 6.J90 __
3.90 -7-.I.991 0.3062 --0.6011 .35 -0 12 9.01
3.00 -3.2961 0.1.021 -0.6513 0.61185 0 1032 3.318
____.Jo.JA11 ______3Jl!~li22.3. 1. 0ZL-L- . k0 -u. 64o u ,±
3..20 -?. F24!) 0.31420 -01.61 5 U.69134 -0.16,14 01.3.151
6.30 - Z, 5-
----- 0.3.291 .O.;121 0..." 190 -U .51,l U.
0.'1.3i
4.:40 -0.1181.8 0.1.9 , -0.14211 0.35661.10fi 0. SO2
6.60-200693 0155-0.21.03 0.1,61.31 0) 01.693
3.11
60511 0.3663 0019
0.302 -0.Jill 0.3.31,
M O0 -0.,."10 :118.
-0. 8.95
121 01:.369 0 .019
3. 1 ___ -0..121 0.61
ADA -- ~ bl I .- iq-0.2826
__ 0.4(1 11 .001
. :1
...... 1A 3
4.40 -0.2090 0.4035 -0.02t19 0.1.35 -0. 20H? U.5401H1
-4,
10--,2-------- I "', 19 4ZfAL- -)1?51 AkS.3L8__
5.60 - ;1509u 2015' 0.022'l I 1.6 -0. 141,V 0.53.1.
5.1 0 __ _ _ 0. 4? 0 L?1 r 02 A.. Sl,-..
5.401 -0.03.13 0. h 03. 1..4422
o.39 0.16v 11 0.452
6.00 -0.0690 0.45.50 0.1609 0.4640 01.W330I .51131
610 -0.063.- U.4611, 0.j 1200z t0.U51112.1.r
6.2V.65 -000
U.9, 0.11 MOW 0.1.11"'
6.19
-0.06 ~~ -1ý ~. I ~ .. ~
1J6. ~ 4 .45 01192
-. 9,021A1.~lL _____0A3 _____----22- - - U.6113
thR01111CC
1 1Q10 ll t, 1 111A03"10R IKkES
15TAniC" ttA
I t
AC~11l 1
11IANI.111 103691.Elm
0.0-t:0.11, . t 0.216
i*.) ?11? 0.212-.1190.219
i.1.116
Au
P.1 ____ -4,i. 1193 0. 1 i9o -2w.6161 (0.?106 -915 9.IO 0. 21 f I
P.4011-',.1 0. 1.11. -9.0205i U. I] 0 --. ý121 1 0. 2966
1 tit)
1.1 1). ý0.
61 ____ 1.21101. 0. M1. -i 11.6ktit) 0.462
2.111 - 11.Yf1., 0.?1491 0.11
U.1)1 - 10. 51910 I. 24139
- S 12
Ill 0
9 1.51. f i4
4.0O- h0. 491 1). 50. 6 -9.02101 0.21.91 4H 14 0ý 0. 214 1 _ _
0.0 ý0 I, yoos V. NS I -1.09
0 0.1V127 -. 11101 0 21111
I Ou25 -19.111-, 0.2)46-.110 11.790 2. .926Y 0.9.w
%:o-11.H155 _ _ -6,J~
112t,1 0.10o6. 3196 - 1.2911 0.5111 2.11?is 0.2191b
S1.4oI 1.,2111). 01.11121 9.11 4h .141. ____ . V5_11 0.11 i1
1.11 .1?,1 6 6.24'19 -6.0142 01.4919 -3,9134 -0. SP24-
11.90~~l .9. 9111 -. - u.1.91. ___ _ -1966;,V 1
o.619
4:W
0 0 . r0 -4.19 0.111
W2-. is 0.3111's
-it L13 Vl 1. L I ____.LIIL2 u.' I-. to 0 -. 4551-L.
1..1 -11.911 1- t. 4?11 *3. 1JU34 G. s119 0.11296o
11.911 __ -;,. f I I'd U. 1li'
5,5611 _ .101. 11i W.I "it 1 01.119.,
4.10) 6-
.3.191 -S Il9J)11 ".b1
I 1%1U l -- 30I
4.1 -9.1616 0,.119 1.',', 0).1"19 I 0.11591.2
4-4d S.0991S 0.01.6 1 0 u. iv 153 1.' b.)I 0401
!.. 1.(U -2.0.96V1 0.11 1,1 1.951 0.1,9 0.02,1 0.161
4,91 U /6111 L,-- 1) 3 1, -
31 tI., . .
I,9 j - I2j-L1. .
9.60. -. 1411 U.110
S"IV11 0.,111 0.1101 u.11M
co - -. . (410, 11.131
o. . to, .'1 11.11193 -s I..14 0.1100
,.110 -2 2111 511.11 -ý0.9, 4.114 j' 1 - 99-,)
ki.
5.4u 3. OSY1111 - 0L L .1111
-1,23 - 19Iil -- Jýjy1 -39.4 d
9. 60 - 1.1,' 0.1.1,
?-B11. PS0 1.06.-.Ml 0. f Out 0.9u2H111
6L. 11 __ -i
-1111PAO. 1035 -- L. Q 1ý - 0.4j'9
1`53j 11 Q.41311(
6.. 1.9121f 0.441119 -0.11- 0 1.91111 01. ,By1 0. 44W1
0.0 _ -111' 06Jh---------0-43--11
0111 ljZ~ 1L30
6.10-1.11 1..1.1-9.911, 0. 4V4 - 4 1i 0. .1.1,
6.10~~~- .192 4411,0 11.51191
1.0-.111.21. 4 M9,
Q..2 3,)911 0.'6111 12.,tQ1 0.91111l
1
--- ',~~~LhL.
-0llj.L j 50, __ it.I0 119
6. SO -ýD. P, fo _M454
60 0 -4.- a 15 1?ILL
U."6113 U. I IW. U. 'If.I/
_ b: I 1 0. UY r? 0. 1_11lqH ______UA1Lf4v Y.-.ofn
-0.01;ou o. bo? 3 u. I I ; I u.,,lq2 O.ýloio U.Stht,
-C.041Y O.S610 u. 12 1 O.!pIab_ q I.
0."040
-00:%,ý,l 0.5141
,:0,.
I 0.5f i IILIJQ
7 20 0,019i O.Soll, 0 ý If., I U .- 14 4 0.14v.. U."lil
1: 31) 9 - 2.4-0_CL- 0, "OH4 11" ý4 _ __u -?bilb 0,604 1
?.40 0.011ni 11.1-44 0.604 1 11 U.6(040
__k.om - 0. -wtl I __QLI I D 0.(,Oyl LI -V
U.09wu- I. ho? 1 6.220,> U.h I I/ U. (I Ivi
I: 6NU u,5
0.6221 0.514o 0. 6;? H.)
o.li44 0.6 Ill
0.0160 u..541
t, . ? 6 1 " 1). &2 10 C., 12 .14 0. 1, 1, :, i
00
11:90 _U1 ll.L6
8 Oil G. I ,d4 1J.6wol 0.2BW U.6112 iiý,(j U.Oih( :
_ 906.2 0.2-4P4 U.0 W 6ýp,
H:lu 0. 1154b
a , 7G 01 2008 0.6M U 5046 0 :1) ivol u. 51.b" o. e.44 1
h.SU I -21-6s &Ve 0:31 " 6 0 030 __ UbtLn
8.40 0.2516 0.6551 l2tsh 0.6467 U.516) D. 6',21
8.1lu 0.21.65 _15L6 514L__ _ it, u 1 0.6592 U. to IQ o, to"'I
R. 611 (;. 2 6 11 0.642h 5ý. I I u . iq Iu U. Wy I
-- U,3&a
13.10 G.;? 154 . . w tL
M. 6 0. 2byL. O.64yl, U. W44 0.6602 0-ti1v U. 66 ',b
0 %Oil-- 0.652'j jfljl4_ _ _JLjZ'LL 0
U.tlbb? 1).kih! 0.6?16
1*1166
3.1 0.65sj5
0.bmt, 0. Syt, I
0,4016 O,ý&20 (1.44hý 0,6144
v 20 U.i4io 0.6611 0.6rif U.4%0.1 I'm
9: io- -.- 0. P,5a U 041
0. Wit, 0.6661 0.4iVy U. 6 I&s h r5b 0.66"
U, sucy Q.bbul U, otyl V. bit %3
O.SY52 0.6110 U.hb()Y o.bdli 0.494,t 0. 6664
0,4055 0 0.5044
bo u
V:qO 0: 'U" I'D, 0:.111 0'.4''. ly
1 1' ul: 1MV 0' 0.641.-
10.00 C. 4 4.06 0.6ray U. ',UZ 1 U.1-84 0. sa(d U.64id
11
at 4
54 V A104
U_ 46""
kjokCýA111CV
-400264.0000
$I
.4U
of
0.008S -0 21 F6. OOOQ
A
ARNIM.:
6.81.79 00,0
OIII1",l.101) 0.1,10W -It0 055
0..12 - 1,06,
at- rail)0 -;- I,;,0-H'..1002 ___l7ol [so
1.8 0 -2.9110 V.155 0r0 0.6119,4 -1,07 8.51
W 7.
Yi.) 8'-7 15 -21 10 a 01.
- I1ArH .00MACH1-
N11411114 NUMBE4IR1).00 1611 NUMI1.k 6.100
_______________j- 43 LWQ~ IjIj~ mW-1tALL0I,&~uQ-- RA 0.
14fL14&W'I .00010
-
t.gi59
.61.?90.16 .g0166..D9
OJJ... -49011-0500 0. 22.9 5290
0.40 -41130.0699 0.0526 -2065,0300 0.03A2 -110T52.0 0.
000a -190.900 00
0.60 Ouse 690 0.3.4-1240 0.0669
79.
1649uo . - 111 0"H .9100yk 0.01116
0 10 -5109.2880 0.6 -9.110 0.06111' -12.1.617 0.06619
1.20 .19120-25.6 0 .0713 -129.6607 0.0928 -61.1',11 0.Ot02
.0.117 1. 01
e A, o . ____.bh1 ,4 L-_ 14(1j it
-0.4114 V) 16
- ~ C I
I
=~Z 0
tot
tat I
0 bO
i ti
4." 0 -9 1
I zo