Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com/cr
Cell Research www.cell-research.com
ARTICLE OPEN
It is challenging to derive totipotent stem cells in vitro that functionally and molecularly resemble cells from totipotent embryos.
Here, we report that a chemical cocktail enables the derivation of totipotent-like stem cells, designated as totipotent potential stem
(TPS) cells, from 2-cell mouse embryos and extended pluripotent stem cells, and that these TPS cells can be stably maintained long
term in vitro. TPS cells shared features with 2-cell mouse embryos in terms of totipotency markers, transcriptome, chromatin
accessibility and DNA methylation patterns. In vivo chimera formation assays show that these cells have embryonic and
extraembryonic developmental potentials at the single-cell level. Moreover, TPS cells can be induced into blastocyst-like structures
resembling preimplantation mouse blastocysts. Mechanistically, inhibition of HDAC1/2 and DOT1L activity and activation of RARγ
signaling are important for inducing and maintaining totipotent features of TPS cells. Our study opens up a new path toward fully
1234567890();,:
INTRODUCTION The major limitation of 2C-like cells is that they are only a minor
During development, early-stage blastomeres are totipotent cells population from mouse ES cell cultures and reside in a transient
that have the potential to generate an entire individual, including intermediate state, and thus these cells cannot be stabilized
both embryonic and extraembryonic components, at the single- in vitro.13 In recent years, our group and others have shown that
cell level.1,2 The totipotent potential of early-stage blastomeres is small molecule combinations can expand the developmental
gradually restricted at the blastocyst stage, when differentiation potentials of pluripotent stem cells toward extraembryonic
into epiblast, trophectoderm and primitive endoderm occurs.3–5 lineages.16,17 Importantly, extended pluripotent stem (EPS) cells
Different self-renewing stem cells, including pluripotent stem cells, can be induced into blastocyst-like structures.18 Despite their
trophoblast stem cells and extraembryonic endoderm cells, can be expanded developmental potentials, these cells are still transcrip-
derived from the blastocyst,6–9 which preserve the developmental tomically distinct from 2-cell embryos.19 In addition, their
potentials of epiblast, trophectoderm and primitive endoderm, extraembryonic differentiation potentials are still limited com-
respectively. Importantly, the developmental potentials of these pared to totipotent embryos.19 Therefore, it remains a major
stem cell types are lineage restricted in that they have difficulties in challenge to capture and maintain bona fide totipotent stem cells
crossing the embryonic and extraembryonic lineage boundaries in vitro. In principle, such stem cells should be derived directly
especially in vivo.10–12 Compared to these blastocyst-derived stem from totipotent embryos, which represents the gold criterion to
cell types, totipotent embryonic cells harbor the greatest devel- capture authentic totipotency.
opmental potency, and there has been great scientific interest in In this study, through chemical screening and combination, we
capturing such stem cells from totipotent embryos in vitro,13 identified a chemical cocktail that can directly establish totipotent-
whose unrestricted potency would have broad applications for like stem cells from 2-cell embryos in vitro, as well as convert from
stem cell biology and regenerative medicine. EPS cells. The induced totipotent-like stem cells can be stably
Previous studies have shown that a rare 2-cell embryo (2C)-like maintained long term in vitro, with molecular features resembling
subpopulation exists in mouse embryonic stem (ES) cell cultures 2–4-cell blastomeres. Moreover, they can generate both embryo-
that express 2-cell blastomere molecular markers and have nic and extraembryonic lineages in vivo at the single-cell level and
embryonic and extraembryonic developmental potentials.14,15 form blastocyst-like structures in vitro.
1
MOE Engineering Research Center of Regenerative Medicine, School of Basic Medical Sciences, State Key Laboratory of Natural and Biomimetic Drugs, Peking University Health
Science Center and the MOE Key Laboratory of Cell Proliferation and Differentiation, College of Life Sciences, Peking-Tsinghua Center for Life Sciences, Peking University, Beijing, China.
2
School of Life Sciences, Center for Bioinformatics, Center for Statistical Science, Peking University, Beijing, China. 3Department of Rheumatology and Immunology, Peking University
Third Hospital, Beijing, China. 4Beijing Vitalstar Biotechnology Co., Ltd, Beijing, China. 5Program for Cancer and Cell Biology, Department of Human Anatomy, Histology and
Embryology, School of Basic Medical Sciences, PKU International Cancer Institute; MOE Key Laboratory of Carcinogenesis and Translational Research and State Key Laboratory of
Natural and Biomimetic Drugs, Peking University Health Science Center, Beijing, China. 6Department of Cell Biology, School of Basic Medical Sciences, Peking University Stem Cell
Research Center, Peking University Health Science Center, Peking University, Beijing, China. 7These authors contributed equally: Yaxing Xu, Jingru Zhao, Yixuan Ren, Xuyang Wang,
Yulin Lyu. ✉email: cheng_li@pku.edu.cn; jun_xu@bjmu.edu.cn; hongkui_deng@pku.edu.cn
5
2C-TPS #2
EPS-TPS #2 P11
0
-5
52
v1
v3
ux
VL
n4
1a
40
og
4
z4
x2
al
al
ct
st
st
D
po
So
p3
ca
ub
43
an
ER
f1
f1
O
Tc
Tc
Zs
Ei
Ei
Td
Zf
N
M
G
d e
CDX2 anti-TD Merge
Utf1
Tcf15
Nr0b1
Tet1
H2az1
Pou5f1
Dppa5a OCT4 anti-TD Merge
Zfp42
Tdgf1
Upp1
Sox2
Mafk z score
Tgfbr3 2
Nrp1 1
Bmpr2 0 f
Trp53inp2 −1 BF Td
Zscan4d −2
Gm5662
Sp110
Gm8300
Egfr
Rab43
Snai1
Zscan4c g
Plk2 ZSCAN4 Td DAPI
Zfp352
Ddit4l
Cdkn1a
EPS-TPS #1-1
EPS-TPS #1-2
EPS-TPS #4-1
EPS-TPS #4-2
EPS-TPS #2-1
EPS-TPS #2-2
EPS #4-1
EPS #4-2
EPS #1-1
EPS #1-2
EPS #2-1
EPS #2-2
Fig. 1 Identification of a chemical cocktail that induce totipotent stem-like cells in vitro. a Representative images showing induction of TPS
cells from EPS cells under the CPEC condition. Scale bar, 100 μm. Similar images were obtained in at least 5 independent experiments.
b Karyotype analysis of TPS cells after long-term culturing under the CPEC condition. Similar images were obtained in 3 independent
experiments. c qPCR analysis of expression of totipotency and pluripotency marker genes in TPS cells converted from EPS cells (EPS-TPS #1)
and TPS cells derived from 2-cell embryos (2C-TPS #1 and #2). n = 3 biological replicates. Similar results were obtained in at least 2
independent experiments. Relative expressions were normalized to EPS #1. d Heatmap showing the relative expression of representative
totipotency and pluripotency genes in TPS and EPS cells. e Representative immunofluorescent analysis showing expression of trophectoderm
(CDX2) and epiblast (OCT4) markers in TPS derivatives in the chimeric blastocysts. These images showed different focal planes of the same
embryo. Scale bar, 20 μm. anti-TD, immuno-staining of tdTomato protein. Similar images were obtained in at least 2 independent experiments.
f Representative morphology of CPEC-treated outgrowth derived from 2-cell embryos expressing tdTomato. Scale bar, 100 μm. BF, bright field.
Td, tdTomato. Similar images were obtained in at least 2 independent experiments. g Representative immunofluorescent analysis of ZSCAN4
expression in TPS cells derived from 2-cell embryos expressing tdTomato. Scale bar, 50 μm. Td, endogenous tdTomato. Similar images were
obtained in at least 2 independent experiments.
information, Fig. S4e). These data suggest that TPS cells possess 14.75% (of 8364 cells), respectively. Notably, the varied expression
transcriptomic features that are specific to 2-cell embryos. of totipotency marker genes was also observed in TBLCs
To further explore the transcriptomic features of TPS cells, we (Supplementary information, Fig. S5a), which is consistent with a
performed single-cell RNA-seq using TPS cells. As controls, the recent report.22 We further compared the transcriptome of these
single-cell RNA-seq data of mouse EPS cells, ES cells, 2C-like cells in vitro cell types with those of early embryos from 2-cell to
and recently reported totipotent blastomere-like cells (TBLCs) E7.5 stages (Fig. 2b), and applied an analytical technique based on
were also analyzed.14,21 Consistent with bulk RNA-seq analysis, the quadratic programming to quantify the transcriptomic similarity of
majority of TPS cells expressed multiple totipotency marker genes these cell types to 2-cell embryos.23 The identity score of TPS cells
(Fig. 2a), and their expression levels varied among the population. was higher than those of other cell types (Fig. 2c), suggesting that
Among the two TPS cell lines analyzed, the percentage of Zscan4/ TPS cells transcriptomically more resemble 2-cell embryos
MERVL double positive cells are 16.70% (of 10,302 cells) and compared to other cell types.
Because the expression of totipotency marker genes varied embryos (Fig. 2b). Importantly, the identity score of this TPS
among the TPS cell population, we further explored the subpopulation (TPS 2C-subpopulation) is the highest among all
subpopulations that reside in the TPS cell population, and the in vitro cell types and subpopulations analyzed (Fig. 2c), which
identified a portion of cells (on average 9.14%) in the TPS cell was also supported by single sample gene set enrichment analysis
population that transcriptomically resembled middle-to-late 2-cell (ssGSEA) (Fig. 2d). We also analyzed the transcriptomic difference
between the TPS 2C-subpopulation and 2-cell embryos. GO information, Fig. S6a, b). Next, we examined the in vivo chimera-
analysis revealed that genes differently expressed between this forming ability of TPS cells, and found that TPS cells after 5
TPS 2C-subpopulation and 2-cell embryos are majorly involved in passages showed relatively higher chimera-forming ability (Sup-
the regulation of mitotic cell cycle, proteasomal protein catabo- plementary information, Table S1). We also tested the germline
lism, nucleoside triphosphate metabolism, and oxidative phos- competence of TPS cells by injecting them into 8-cell embryos and
phorylation (Supplementary information, Table S2). Using Single- transplanting the injected embryos in vivo to generate chimeric
Cell rEgulatory Network Inference and Clustering (SCENIC), we embryos. Analysis of the E13.5 chimeric embryos showed that
further analyzed the regulatory network of the TPS 2C- derivatives of these cells can efficiently form chimeras in the fetal
subpopulation and compared it with that of EPS cells. Notably, gonads, which expressed OCT4-EGFP (Supplementary information,
the activities of totipotency regulators were upregulated in this Fig. S6c). In addition, chimeric mice were also generated
population, whereas those of pluripotency regulators were (Supplementary information, Fig. S6c).
downregulated (Fig. 2e, f). Collectively, these data suggest that To rigorously analyze the developmental potentials of TPS cells,
TPS cells shared totipotent transcriptional features with 2-cell we tested their ability of generating embryonic and extraem-
embryos and a TPS cell subpopulation transcriptomically bryonic lineages in E7.5 mouse embryos in vivo. To this end, TPS
resembled middle-to-late 2C embryos. cells that continuously expressed tdTomato were injected into
8-cell embryos which were transferred in vivo. As a control, single
TPS cells share epigenetic features with 2-cell blastomeres 8-cell blastomeres were also injected. Notably, we observed the
To characterize the epigenetic features of TPS cells, we first contribution of single TPS derivative cells to both embryonic and
performed ATAC-seq for transposase-accessible chromatin on extraembryonic regions in E7.5 mouse chimeric embryos (Supple-
these cells at the single-cell level. As controls, EPS cells and ES cells mentary information, Table S1). Immunofluorescent analysis
were also analyzed. Compared to EPS and ES cells, we identified further confirmed that chimeric extraembryonic cells expressed
1857 open and 8903 closed peaks that were uniquely enriched at EOMES in the region of extraembryonic ectoderm (ExE) (Fig. 3a, b),
annotated or putative enhancers and promoters in TPS cells suggesting that they adopted an extraembryonic trophoblast fate.
(Fig. 2g). We further analyzed the distribution of TPS-specific open Meanwhile, we also noticed that cells that integrated into the
and closed peaks in 2-cell embryos and mouse ES cells. Notably, visceral endoderm (VE) region expressed the VE markers SOX17
TPS-specific open loci were also highly opened in 2-cell embryos, (Supplementary information, Fig. S7a), suggesting their VE
whereas TPS-specific closed loci were in a more closed state in identity.
2-cell embryos (Fig. 2h). We further analyzed the global DNA Next, we analyzed the developmental potentials of single TPS
methylation profiles of TPS, EPS and ES cells using whole-genome cells in E10.5 mouse conceptuses (Supplementary information,
bisulfite sequencing (WGBS). The global DNA methylation level in Table S1). The injected mouse embryos were transferred in vivo
TPS cells was greatly reduced compared to those in EPS and ES and recovered at E10.5 stage. Notably, similar to blastomere of
cells (Fig. 2i), but similar to that in 2-cell embryos. In addition, we 8-cell embryos (Supplementary information, Fig. S7b), chimeric
also observed that the DNA methylation levels were reduced in contribution of single TPS derivative cells to embryo, placenta and
the loci of representative totipotency genes, such as Zfp352, yolk sac was observed (Fig. 3c), which was also confirmed by FACS
Zscan4d, and Tcstv1 (Supplementary information, Fig. S5b). Taken analysis (Supplementary information, Fig. S7c). To further confirm
together, these results suggest that TPS cells share epigenetic the trophoblast identity of chimeric cells in the placenta, we
features with 2-cell blastomeres in the aspects of accessible performed immunofluorescent analysis. Similar to the positive
chromatin landscape and DNA methylation profiles. control of single 8-cell blastomere (Supplementary information,
Fig. S7e), derivatives of TPS cells integrated into the trophoblast
TPS cells can generate both embryonic and extraembryonic layers of the chimeric placentas and expressed the trophoblast
lineages in vivo markers CK8, MCT4 and TFAP2C (Fig. 3d; Supplementary informa-
To explore the developmental potentials of TPS cells in vivo, we tion, Fig. S7d), suggesting that these chimeric cells can further
first injected these cells into immune-deficient mice and obtained differentiate into trophoblast lineages. As the negative control, we
teratomas, and analyzed these teratomas using single-cell RNA- did not detect the expression of tdTomato in the non-injected
seq. Notably, in addition to the presence of multiple embryonic placentas (Supplementary information, Fig. S7f).
lineages in the teratomas, we found that teratomas derived from To further analyze the trophoblast identity of chimeric cells in
TPS cells also contained extraembryonic lineages (Supplementary the placenta at late developmental stages, we generated E17.5
c BF Td BF Td BF Td
d
DAPI anti-TD CK8 Merge DAPI anti-TD CK8 Merge
e f
1_B cell
2_DC
16 3_Macrophage
4_Monocyte
5_Neutrophil
14 6_Proliferating
13 7_T cell
8_Endothelial
9_Mesench
12
11 10_Muscle Td-
3
10 11_Stromal Td+
6 9
8 12_Epithelial
1 13_ExE endode
2 15
14_Parietal endode
7
15_GC
UMAP_2
18
UMAP_2
4 16_LaTP
17
5 19 17_SpT
18_SynTI
19_TGC UMAP_1
UMAP_1
g
B cell
DC
Macrophage
Monocyte
Neutrophil
Proliferating
T cell
Endothelial
Mesenchymal
Muscle
Stromal
Epithelial
ExE endoderm
Parietal endoderm
GC
LaTP max
Relative expression
SpT
SynTI
TGC
Ptprc
Cd79b
Iglc2
Cd74
Cd209a
C1qa
C1qb
Ms4a4c
Col1a2
Acta2
Myl9
Ly6c2
Gsr
Stfa2
Top2a
Mki67
Cd3e
Cd69
Pecam1
Plvap
Tmem100
Dcn
Prl8a2
Inhba
Epcam
Wfdc2
Foxa2
Krt8
Krt18
Gkn2
Apoa1
Pga5
Lama1
Tfap2c
Pla2g4d
Prl2a1
Lgr5
S100g
Prl3a1
Psg23
Ceacam14
Gjb2
Rhox9
Serpinb9e
Amot
Ctsr
Ctsq
min
chimeric conceptuses using TPS cells (Supplementary information, Notably, these TPS derivatives contained extraembryonic lineages
Fig. S8a). We performed single-cell RNA-seq analysis using cells expressing trophoblast subtype markers such as Ctsq (trophoblast
from the chimeric E17.5 placenta (Fig. 3e). Among the 9765 giant cells), Prl3a1 (spongiotrophoblasts), Pla2g4d (glycogen
analyzed cells from the chimeric placenta, 1924 cells expressed trophoblast cells), and Lgr5 (labyrinth trophoblast progenitor)
tdTomato (Fig. 3f), indicating that they are derivatives of TPS cells. (Fig. 3g). Moreover, these TPS-derived trophoblast cells are
transcriptomically similar to their in vivo counterparts (Fig. 3e, f). trophectoderm-like cells from TPS-blastoids, there are significant
These results were further supported by qPCR analysis using FACS- transcriptomic differences between trophectoderm-like cells from
purified chimeric TPS derivatives from E18.5 placenta (Supple- previously reported blastoids and in vivo trophectoderm (Fig. 4f).
mentary information, Fig. S8b, c). To exclude the potential artifact These results were further supported by ssGSEA and quadratic
of cell fusion in the placenta, we injected tdTomato reporter- programming-based identity score calculation (Fig. 4g, h).
labeled TPS cells into mouse 8-cell embryos that expressed EGFP. Collectively, these data suggest that TPS-blastoids contain the
Importantly, the majority of chimeric tdTomato+ cells in the three lineages of blastocysts, transcriptomically resembling E4.5
placenta did not show EGFP signal (Supplementary information, blastocyst.
Fig. S8b). Collectively, the chimeric analyses provide strong We further evaluated the in vivo developmental potentials of
evidence that TPS cells have extraembryonic and embryonic TPS-blastoids. To this end, tdTomato reporter-labeled TPS-
developmental potentials in vivo at the single-cell level. blastoids were transferred into pseudopregnant mice at 2.5 days
post coitum (dpc). At 6.5 dpc, decidualization was induced by TPS-
Induction of blastocyst-like structures from TPS cells in vitro blastoids (Fig. 4i, j), which was further evidenced by the induction
Because TPS cells have embryonic and extraembryonic develop- of PTGS2 expression in the deciduae. These results suggest that
mental potentials, we explored whether they can be induced into TPS-blastoids can implant and trigger decidualization in vivo.
blastocyst-like structures (blastoids) in vitro. FGF, BMP and Yap
signalings are important for preimplantation development espe- Mechanistic exploration of totipotency induction and
cially for extraembryonic lineage development,24–27 and we maintenance in TPS cells
attempted to treat TPS cells with bFGF, FGF4, BMP4 and LPA. We attempted to explore the mechanism of totipotency regula-
TPS cells were seeded onto AggreWell microwell plate and treated tion by the CPEC condition. Because VPA, CD1530 and
with these factors, resulting in small aggregates. Notably, these EPZ004777 showed synergistic effects on induction of totipotency
aggregates could further form cavity and morphologically marker gene expression, we first focused on analyzing the
resemble preimplantation blastocysts (Fig. 4a; Supplementary molecular targets of these three compounds. Among the 3 small
information, Table S1). Immunofluorescent analysis showed that molecules, VPA is reported to be an HDAC inhibitor, CD1530 an
blastoids induced from TPS cells expressed trophectoderm (CDX2) RARγ agonist, and EPZ004777 a Dot1L inhibitor. To test whether
and epiblast (OCT4) markers (Fig. 4b). these small molecules indeed target these molecular targets in
To analyze the transcriptome features of TPS-blastoids, we TPS cells, we first analyzed the levels of histone acetylation and
performed single-cell RNA-seq analysis. Cluster analysis divided H3K79 methylations in TPS cells by western blotting. Compared to
the analyzed 914 cells into 3 clusters, and these 3 clusters that in EPS cells, we found that the histone H3 acetylation level
expressed markers of epiblast, primitive endoderm and trophec- was increased whereas the H3K79 methylation level was
toderm, respectively, including Oct4 (epiblast), Sox17 (primitive decreased (Fig. 5a). In addition, upregulation of classical RAR
endoderm) and Gata2 (trophectoderm) (Fig. 4c). Among 914 downstream target genes in TPS cells was observed (Fig. 5b).
analyzed cells from the blastoids, 424 cells are Cdx2 positive Interestingly, we found that the chromatin accessibility of RARγ-
(46.4%) and 176 cells are Oct4 positive (19.2%). It is also notable binding loci in TPS cells is reduced compared to that in EPS cells,
that the expression of totipotency marker genes was nearly absent and a similar result was observed in 2-cell embryos (Supplemen-
in the 3 clusters (Fig. 4c), suggesting that cells in the TPS-blastoids tary information, Fig. S9a).
lose totipotent features. Next, a panel of 262 representative To confirm that these small molecules indeed induce totipo-
lineages markers of epiblast, primitive endoderm and trophecto- tency by targeting these reported targets, we first replaced VPA,
derm were analyzed in the TPS-blastoid cells. Consistent with EPZ004777 and CD1530 respectively with other small molecules
cluster analysis, the three clusters clustered well into epiblast-, targeting the same molecular targets, including HDAC, DOT1L,
primitive endoderm- and trophectoderm-like lineage, respectively and RAR. We found that these replacements can also support the
(Fig. 4d). We further compared the transcriptomic features of induction of totipotency marker gene expression (Fig. 5c;
these TPS-blastoid cells with those of E4.5 blastocyst, and found Supplementary information, Fig. S9b). Consistent with these
that most of the TPS-blastoid cells clustered together with results, knockdown of Hdac1/2 and Dot1l could also replace VPA
blastocyst cells assigned to the same lineage (Fig. 4e). and EPZ004777 in induction of totipotency markers, respectively
We further analyzed the transcriptomic similarity between TPS- (Fig. 5d–g), and inhibition of RARγ signaling by small molecules
blastoid cells and blastocyst cells. Epiblast cells (E4.5–E7.5) and greatly reduced the expression of totipotency markers during TPS
extraembryonic ectoderm cells from the post-implantation stages induction and maintenance (Fig. 5h). Interestingly, qPCR analysis
(E5.25–E6.5) were also included in the analysis. As controls, we also showed that the CPEC treatment of preimplantation embryos
analyzed blastoids generated by combining mouse TS cells with could facilitate the maintenance of totipotency marker gene
mouse ES or EPS cells.28,29 Importantly, cells resembling the expression in preimplantation mouse embryos beyond the 2-cell
epiblast, primitive endoderm and trophectoderm in the TPS- embryo stage (Fig. 5i). Taken together, these data suggest that
blastoids were transcriptionally similar to the three lineages from inhibition of HDAC1/2 and DOT1L activity and activation of RARγ
the E4.5 blastocyst stage (Fig. 4f). Notably, compared to signaling are important for inducing totipotency in TPS cells.
Next, we sought to analyze the role of CHIR 99021 in the chemical cocktail during culturing of TPS cells. The omission of
induction and maintenance of TPS cells. Consistent with its CHIR 99021 led to reduced proliferation during the first few
reported role of activating Wnt signaling by inhibiting GSK3β,30 passages (~3–5 passages). After further passaging, we found that
TPS cells expressed β-catenin at the protein level (Supplementary CHIR 99021 is not required for the proliferation of TPS cells (data
information, Fig. S9c). To examine whether CHIR 99021 is required not shown). qPCR analysis further showed that the expression of
for maintaining TPS cells, we removed CHIR 99021 from the totipotency marker genes in TPS cells is not affected by the
omission of CHIR 99021 after long-term culturing (Supplementary maintaining totipotent features of TPS cells. These results
information, Fig. S9d). However, we also found that the omission demonstrate the feasibility of deriving and maintaining
of CHIR 99021 can greatly reduce the in vivo chimera-forming totipotent-like stem cells in vitro.
potential of TPS cells (Supplementary information, Table S1). The derivation of TPS cells from 2-cell mouse embryos
Therefore, CHIR 99021 is beneficial for promoting proliferation represents an important step toward capturing authentic totipo-
during TPS conversion and important for maintaining the in vivo tency in vitro. A long-standing scientific question in the stem cell
developmental potency of TPS cells. field is whether totipotent stem cells can be captured from
Finally, we attempted to explore the roles of known key totipotent embryos,13 which has not been achieved. Efforts to
totipotency and pluripotency regulators in the induction and generate totipotent-like cells, including 2C-like cells and
maintenance of TPS cells. Dux is an important regulator in TBLCs,14,21 rely solely on the conversion from pluripotent stem
induction of 2C-like cells,31,32 and p53 is reported to be a key cells and have not been made on totipotent embryos. In contrast,
upstream activator of Dux in induction of 2C-like cells.33 During our results showed that the treatment of 4 small molecules (CPEC)
the maintenance and induction of TPS cells, we found that on preimplantation embryos could facilitate the maintenance of
knockdown of Dux expression led to downregulation of several totipotency marker gene expression in preimplantation mouse
totipotency marker genes (MERVL, Zfp352, Tcstv3), whereas embryos beyond the 2-cell embryo stage (Fig. 5i). Moreover, the
expression of other totipotency marker genes (Tcstv1, Zscan4) CPEC condition permitted establishment of 2-cell embryo-derived
was not significantly affected (Fig. 5j, k). On the other hand, p53 TPS cells, which highly expressed totipotency marker genes
knockdown did not cause decreased expression of totipotency (Fig. 1c), shared transcriptomic and epigenetic features with 2-cell
marker genes during the induction of TPS cells (Fig. 5l). Next, we embryos (Fig. 2), and have bi-directional developmental potentials
examined the role of Oct4 and LIF signaling, the key pluripotency which enables formation of blastoids (Figs. 3d, 4). These findings
regulators,34 in the maintenance of TPS cells. Knockout of Oct4 in provide the proof-of-principle evidence that it is possible to
TPS cells did not significantly affect the expression of totipotency directly derive totipotent-like stem cells from totipotent embryos,
marker genes (Supplementary information, Fig. S10a), whereas the which represents an important step toward capturing bona fide
proliferation of TPS cells was reduced (Supplementary informa- 2-cell totipotent embryos in vitro.
tion, Fig. S10b). Similar to Oct4, inhibition of LIF signaling by small Another key unique feature of TPS cells is their ability to self-
molecules also led to an impaired proliferation of TPS cells organize to generate blastocyst-like structures, mimicking the
(Supplementary information, Fig. S10c), and the expression of natural developmental process. Upon the stimulation of natural
totipotency marker genes was not affected (Supplementary signaling molecules that drive early preimplantation development,
information, Fig. S10d). Collectively, these data suggest that the TPS cells can self-organize into blastoids which transcriptomically
mechanism of totipotency regulation in TPS cells is unique and resemble in vivo E4.5 blastocyst (Fig. 4a–g). Moreover, these
distinct from that in 2C-like cells, which requires further blastoids can implant and induce decidualization in vivo (Fig. 4i, j).
exploration. Previous efforts on generation of synthetic blastocysts using
pluripotent cells rely on the combined use of TS cells or
reprogramming from epiblast stem cells.28,35 The major limitation
DISCUSSION of using TS cells is that TS-derived blastoids transcriptionally
In this study, we reported a chemical cocktail that can support the resemble postimplantation extraembryonic ectoderm (ExE) but
derivation of totipotent-like stem cells from 2-cell mouse embryos not preimplantation trophectoderm,36–38 therefore the induction
and EPS cells. TPS cells showed transcriptomic and epigenetic process is artificial and unnatural, leading to the significant
features that resemble 2-cell mouse embryos. Importantly, TPS transcriptomic differences between in vivo trophectoderm and
cells have the capacity to generate both embryonic and trophectoderm-like cells from the TS-derived blastoids (Fig. 4f–h).
extraembryonic lineages in vivo at the single-cell level. When Likewise, induction of blastocyst-like cysts (iBLCs) from epiblast
self-organizing in vitro, TPS cells can form blastocyst-like stem cells by reprogramming does not mimic the natural
structures, which transcriptomically resemble E4.5 blastocysts developmental process.35 In contrast, the generation of TPS-
and can implant and trigger decidualization in vivo. Mechanistic blastoids relied on the differentiation of totipotent-like stem cells
studies showed that HDAC1/2 and DOT1L inhibition as well as to the blastocyst lineages (Fig. 4c), which more closely resembles
RARγ signaling activation are important for inducing and the process of blastocyst formation in vivo. On the other hand,
#2
#2
a b
S- 1
S- 1
#
#
S
S
TP
TP
PS
PS
2C 2
#1
2C 2
10 EPS #1
#
-T
-T
S
S
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
EPS #2
EPS-TPS #1
to EPS 1#)
Ace H3 H3K79me2 5
2C-TPS #2
Ace H4 H3 0
c Zscan4 Zfp352
Relative expression
Relative expression
15000
VPA rep
to EPS
200
to EPS
CD1530 rep
10000
100 CHIR rep
5000
0 0
S sal EC 76 46 A 75 id 03 80 55 ne 54 A 58 14 IO 14 63
S G Z 5 EC
E P CP a l
BaPS
46
C 76
M TSA
ro 5 5
D ne
SB -98BIO
90 58
G r ip 5
D id
3
lo c580
A Z 54
63
20 28 A
IR 14
67 4
EPBa CP 56 09 TS S2 ipta 01 M5 ch ote 32 R 28 03 B 80 67
M Sc 2 7
AM10
21 01
LY D R
s
C ta
6
09
C te
va h
32
3
E
0
S
Z C M cr CD A r D D 09 -9 2 1
EP SG S G va C A Z Y2 IR B
lo H S
H
L
M Pa
Pa
C
C
d e
Relative expression to EPS
Relative expression to
Hdac1 1.5
Hdac2 Tcstv1 Tcstv3 MERVL Zfp352 Zscan4
1.5 200 60 15 80 1000
800
scramble
1.0 150 60
1.0 40 10
600
100 40
0.5 0.5 20 400
5
50 20 200
0.0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0
c
sh ble
c
sh ble
hH C
hH C
hH C
hH C
hH C
c
c
c
C S
C S
C S
C S
C S
da
da
da
da
da
da
da
+s PE
+s PE
+s PE
+s PE
+s PE
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
m
m
H
H
ra
ra
Sc
Sc
-V
-V
-V
-V
-V
C
C
C
PE
PE
PE
PE
PE
Relative expression to EPS
g
C
C
f
Relative expression to
Dot1l
1.5 Tcstv1 25 Tcstv3 MERVL Zfp352 Zscan4
80 5 30 150
scramble
1.0 20 4
60
15 20 100
3
0.5 40
10 2
10 50
20 5 1
0.0
0 0 0 0 0
1l
sh ble
ot
+s C
+s C
+s C
+s C
+s C
ot
m
ot
ot
ot
ot
S
C S
S
C S
D
-E E
-E E
- E PE
-E E
-E PE
EP
EP
EP
EP
EP
hD
ra
hD
hD
hD
hD
C CP
C CP
C CP
Sc
C
C
PE
PE
PE
PE
PE
C
C
C
h EPS EPS
Log2 expression (normalized to EPS) Log2 expression (normalized
20 15
CPEC TPS
15 RARγi RARγi
10
RARα/βi RARα/βi
to EPS)
to EPS)
10
RXRi 5 RXRi
5
0
0
Tcstv1 Tcstv3 Zfp352 Zscan4 MERVL Tcstv1 Tcstv3 Zfp352 Zscan4 MERVL
-5 -5
i j EPS 1#
Log2 expression (normalized
15
20 Dux
Relative expression
1.5 2C-TPS 1#
DMSO
10 DuxKD-TPS
to TPS #1
CPEC
to EPS #1)
1.0
10
2C
5
0.5
0 0.0 0
PS
-T 1
KD #
52
v1
v3
VL
n4
40
ux S
-5
D -TP
ct
ct
p3
ca
43
ER
52
x2
VL
v1
v3
4
z4
n4
1a
l6
l9
40
og
Ts
Ts
-10
Zs
ct
Zf
m
a
2C
M
st
st
So
po
p3
ca
43
ub
an
ER
O
f1
f1
G
Tc
Tc
Zs
Td
Ei
Ei
Zf
N
M
k
Log2 expression (normalized
l 15
Log2 expression (normalized
15
EPS #3 p53 EPS #3
Relative expression
Dux
Relative expression
1.5 1.5
CPEC CPEC
to CPEC
10 10
to EPS #3)
to CPEC
1.0 p53KD-CPEC
5 5
0.5 0.5
0.0 0 0.0 0
C
-C C
-C E C
C
PE
D E
PE
3 K CP
KD CP
52
1
v3
VL
n4
-5 Sox2 Oct4
ct
p3
ca
ER
c
Ts
Ts
Zs
Zf
M
ux
p5
D
unlike EPS-blastoids that contain a significant portion of process of blastocyst formation in vitro. It is also important to
intermediates and mesodermal cells,18 the majority of TPS- further optimize the TPS-based blastoid induction approach and
blastoids contained the three blastocyst lineages and intermedi- explore whether they can develop into conceptuses in vivo.
ates were nearly absent (Fig. 4c, d). Therefore, TPS-blastoids avoid Importantly, TPS cells provide a valuable in vitro platform to
the limitations of previously reported synthetic blastocysts and explore the regulation of totipotency, and clarifying the molecular
could serve as a powerful model to recapitulate the in vivo targets of the small molecules used in the CPEC condition could
provide a novel mechanistic insight into the regulation of Figs. S7 and S8). Second, unlike our study (Fig. 5i), the work by
totipotency.13 Importantly, we found that inhibition of HDAC1/2 Yang et al. lacks important information of how their chemical
and DOT1L activities and activation of RARγ signaling are cocktail impacted on totipotency marker genes in embryos
important for inducing totipotency in TPS cells (Fig. 5a–h). beyond the 2-cell embryo stage, and it is unclear whether the
Interestingly, the role of RARγ signaling in totipotency regulation process of generating TLSCs from the embryos reflected the
is supported by a recent study showing that RA signaling is critical nature of capturing totipotent cells, or inducing totipotency from
during the totipotency window in early development.39 It would be embryonic cells. Third, despite the finding that blastoids were
important to further explore the synergetic effect of these targets generated from the TLSCs, the transcriptomic similarity between
on maintenance of totipotency in embryos. Recent studies suggest TLSC-blastoids and in vivo blastocysts remains unknown. As a
that 2C-like cells do not fully recapitulate 2-cell embryos in terms of comparison, we performed single-cell RNA-seq analysis showing
regulation of 2-cell embryo-specific genes and cautions should be that TPS-blastoids transcriptomically resembled preimplantation
taken when studying totipotency using 2C-like cells as the model mouse blastocysts. This study, together with our study, highlights
system,40 highlighting the demand for establishing new in vitro the importance and utility of using the chemical approach to
model systems to study totipotency. Although one recent study establish totipotent stem cells.
showed the induction of TBLCs by spliceosome inhibition,21 this In summary, our study demonstrates the feasibility of deriving
approach only enabled their conversion from pluripotent stem totipotent-like stem cells from early embryos. TPS cells would
cells but not capturing from totipotent embryos, whereas our CPEC provide a useful tool for studying the mechanism of totipotency
condition permits derivation of TPS cells from 2C embryos. In regulation as well as early preimplantation embryogenesis. Our
addition, the transcriptomic profiles of the TPS 2C-subpopulation study also opens up a new path toward capturing totipotent stem
are significantly closer to that of middle-to-late 2C embryos cells from other mammalian species including humans.
compared to that of TBLCs (Fig. 2b–d). Moreover, our CPEC
condition also bypasses potential safety concerns associated with
spliceosome inhibition, such as tumor induction or proliferation MATERIALS AND METHODS
difficulty.41–44 Therefore, TPS cells have wide application potentials Mice
as a new platform favorable for studying totipotency in vitro. The mouse strain B6-Tg (C57BL/6-tdTomato) was bought from Beijing
While our study was being submitted for publication, a study Vitalstar Biotechnology Co., Ltd. Other mouse strains ICR and EGFP were
related to this work was published,45 which reported an purchased from Peking University Health Science Center Department of
alternative chemical cocktail to support the generation of Laboratory Animal Science. All animal experiments were performed in
accordance with the NIH guidelines. All mouse experiments were approved
totipotent-like stem cells (TLSCs). Compared to our CPEC by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Peking University.
condition, the chemical cocktail reported by Yang et al.45 for The mice were housed in a temperature controlled room (22 ± 1 °C) with
generating TLSCs also included a DOT1L inhibitor, which further 40%–60% humidity, under a 12-h light/dark cycle between 06:00 and 18:00.
supports our finding that DOT1L inhibition is critical for
totipotency regulation. Their chemical cocktail also contained
Culture of mouse TPS cells
other small molecules, such as A366 and AS8351. Nevertheless, All cell lines were cultured under 20% O2 and 5% CO2 at 37 °C. Mouse TPS
targets of these small molecules and mechanistic roles in cells were cultured in CPEC medium containing N2B27 basal medium (50%
totipotency regulation were not studied. Most importantly, there DMEM/F12 (Gibco, 11330-032), 50% Neurobasal (Gibco, 21103-049), 0.5%
are major differences between the study by Yang et al. and our N2 supplement (Gibco, 17502-048), 1% B27 supplement (Gibco, 12587-
work. First, Yang et al. developed a relatively complicated protocol 010), 1% GlutaMAX (Gibco, 35050-061), 1% nonessential amino acids
to derive TLSCs from mouse preimplantation embryos. It is unclear (Gibco, 11140-050)) which promoted cell proliferation, or 1640 basal
whether the developmental potentials of these embryo-derived medium (RPMI Medium 1640 basic (Gibco, 22400-089), 0.5%
TLSCs were rigorously evaluated at the single-cell level or using N2 supplement (Gibco, 17502-048), 1% B27 supplement (Gibco, 12587-
the blastoid induction assay. In contrast, our CPEC condition 010), 1% GlutaMAX (Gibco, 35050-061), 1% nonessential amino acids
(Gibco, 11140-050)) which enhanced totipotent molecular features,
supports derivation of TPS cells from both pluripotent cell lines supplemented with 5% knockout serum replacement (Gibco, 10828-028),
and 2-cell embryos, and their developmental potentials have been 0.2% sodium pyruvate (Gibco, 11360-070), 0.14% sodium DL-lactate
extensively characterized (Figs. 3, 4; Supplementary information, solution (Sigma, L7900) and 0.1% Chemically Defined Lipid Concentrate
COMPETING INTERESTS
The authors declare no competing interests. © The Author(s) 2022