Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Illinois lawmakers have been patting themselves on the back for supposedly holding the line on spending and getting rid of wasteful projects. Should taxpayers buy into this newfound fiscal responsibility? No. A review by the Illinois Policy Institute found that the budget passed by the House left overall spending levels largely unchanged from last year. Additionally, many low-priority projects are slated to receive millions of dollars dollars that deficitplagued state government doesnt have to spare. The ball is now in Gov. Quinns court. In his budget address earlier this year, Gov. Quinn promised taxpayers we will only use tax dollars to provide necessary servicesall unnecessary state spending will be eliminated. Will the ink in Gov. Quinns veto pen run dry from the many line-item budget reductions that will be needed to honor his pledge? Taxpayers are waiting and watching.
Low Priority State Spending in Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Passed by the General Assembly
2. $1,057,500: DuQuoin State Fair and Illinois State Fair entertainment and award costs
Department of Agriculture (HB124, General Revenue Fund) Fairs may be fun, but theyre not high up on the public funding priority list especially when the state is billions of dollars behind in paying service providers. The budget appropriates $652,100 for entertainment and other expenses from the DuQuoin State Fair, and $405,400 for awards and premiums at the Illinois State Fair.
The DuQuoin State Fair and the Illinois State Fair have a long record of incurring expenditures that outweigh their revenues. Between fiscal years 2001 and 2009, the two fairs lost a combined total that exceeded $41.8 million. While turning a profit may not be the purpose of the state fairs, it is unacceptable for the state fairs to lose millions of dollars each year. States such as South Dakota, Ohio, Colorado and Kansas have reduced their fair spending to deal with budget shortages, while Michigan recently shut down its government-run state fair. Meanwhile, Texas has shown that a privately-run state fair that operates without government subsidy can be successful.
4
4. $365,400: Urban Fishing Program
Department of Natural Resources (HB124, Wildlife and Fish Fund)
The Illinois Urban Fishing Program was created in Chicago in 1985 to teach individuals of all ages to fish, to provide better local fishing opportunities, and to give participants an understanding of and a greater appreciation for natural resources. The program provides free summer fishing clinics at stocked ponds and other fishing outreach events. Although the program started in Chicago, it now provides free fishing clinics throughout the state. While the program may have good intentions, teaching fishing skills is not a core government service. There are higher priorities for state money than a fishing program meant to counteract the ills of urban living, such as welfare-to-work programs. Ending state support for a low-priority program does not necessarily mean the underlying activities will cease to exist. According to the Urban Fishing Program website, volunteers and volunteer organizations have become more involved to both conduct and to assist with programs and have held numerous volunteer fishing clinics. This demonstrates that there are individuals and nonprofits willing to address the demand for this type of social good.
Illinois Legislative Research Unit and Central Management Services (HB123, HB124, General Revenue Fund)
The Illinois Legislative Research unit was appropriated $694,700 to cover internships for 24 persons, or approximately $28,946 per person. Participants in the Governors and Vito Marzullos internship programs receive $31,332 annually and full state benefits. These internship salaries are well above the norm in the private sector, as well as the starting wages for many college graduates. Additionally, an Illinoisan earning minimum wage at a full-time job would only receive $17,160 annually well below the internship salary.
The state shouldnt pick winners and losers based on demographic characteristics; financial aid should be awarded generally and for merit. Illinoiss institutions of higher education offer competitive compensation packages and an opportunity to pursue an academic passion; these rewards provide strong incentives for applicants of every color to matriculate and apply for positions.
10. $9,000,000: Renewable Energy Resources Program and the Illinois Renewable Fuels Development Program
Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity (HB124, Renewable Energy Resources Trust Fund)
Illinoiss wealth of energy resources should be utilized to provide Illinoiss families and businesses with reliable sources of power. However, Illinois state government is distorting energy prices and driving up overall government spending by awarding tax dollars to certain energy sectors via special government programs. In recent years, solar, wind, and biomass/biogas grants from the Renewable Energy Resources Program have included: $450,000 for the University of Illinois to implement the Biogas and Biomass to Energy program. $253,350 for solar thermal hot water systems to heat Northern Illinois Universitys swimming pools. $132,198 for the Pacific Garden Mission to install a solar thermal hot water system at its new facility in Chicago. $82,006 for six grants to individuals for small-scale wind energy conversion systems. $32,000 to the Illinois Solar Energy Association to promote solar energy in Illinois through the Illinois Solar Tour, the Heliographs newsletter, and by studying the potential to aggregate renewable energy credits for small-scale solar photovoltaic energy systems. $13,358 to the Phi Kappa Theta fraternity house at Northern Illinois University for a solar thermal energy system in order to increase the utilization of alternative energy technology in Illinois. New subsidies for energy projects should not be enacted, and current subsides need to be removed. Across Illinois, private companies provide funding for their own marketing, promotion, and research and development; firms in the energy industry should be treated in the same way. Kristina Rasmussen is the Executive Vice President of the Illinois Policy Institute and Amanda Griffin-Johnson is a policy analyst with the Illinois Policy Institute.
10