Professional Documents
Culture Documents
B.W. Kemppainen*
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
ABSTRACT
Airborne occurrence of mycotoxins in agricultural and
residential environments has generated concern that these toxins
may be absorbed via the skin and respiratory tract. This paper
summarizes information available on the h viva and vitro
cutaneous permeability of several mycotoxins (aflatoxin, T-2 toxin
[T-21, diacetoxyscirpenol, and verrucarin A).
Published data is used to calculate the dose absorbed during
cutaneous exposure to fungal toxins in hypothetical agricultural
and research 1 aboratory environments. These estimated doses of
T-2 (0.004 and 0.041 pg/kg, respectively) were 25,000 and 2,439
times less than a reported oral dose (100 pg T-2/kg/day) which
caused immunosuppression in monkeys.
In general, exposure of human skin to aflatoxin and tricho-
thecenes results in slow absorption. The risk of systemic
toxicity resulting from dermal exposure increases in the presence
o f high toxin concentrations, occlusion, and vehicles which
enhance penetration.
95
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION 96
11. METHODOLOGY USED TO STUDY PERCUTANEOUS ABSORPTION OF
FUNGAL TOXINS 98
A. In Vivo Studies 98
B. In Vitro Studies 98
I I I. RESULTS FROM STUDIES ON PERCUTANEOUS ABSORPTION OF FUNGAL
TOXINS 99
A. In Vivo Cutaneous Absorption 99
B. In Vitro Cutaneous Absorption 101
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
I. INTRODUCTION
The presence of mycotoxins on grain dusts and other small
particulate materials indicates that people living or working in
agricultural environments are routinely exposed to mycotoxins via
the respiratory and dermal routes. Consumption of mycotoxin
contaminated foods and feeds has been a recognized problem for
many years. In 1960 the outbreak of Turkey "X" disease was found
to be due to ingestion o f peanuts contaminated with aflatoxins (1)
and perhaps other mycotoxins (2). Since that time a multitude of
symptoms have been observed in association with the consumption of
moldy feeds. Epidemiological studies in Africa, Asia and else-
where, have suggested a correlation between aflatoxin contamina-
tion of foods and liver cancer ( 3 , 4 ) . In the United States,
environmental monitoring during grain harvesting (5) and during
post-harvest grain management (6) has indicated that dust parti-
cles contain relatively high levels of aflatoxins. The respira-
tory route has received some attention as a possible route of ex-
posure to aflatoxins in industrial settings (7). The dermal route
has also been considered, but the results of the early studies in
rats were contradictory. Purchase and Steyn (8) reported that
SKIN ABSORPTION 97
TABLE 1
-
In -
Vitro Absorption of Fungal Toxins in Human Skin
(Vehi c l e:Methanol ) .
Fungal Toxin Percent Dose Absorbed
T-2a 1.0
DASa 0.8
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
VCAa 0.2
AFB+ 0.05
TABLE 2
Effect of Skin Preparation on T-2 Penetration Through Excised
Human Skin.
Absorption of T-2
Skin preparation Method of Storage (Percent of Dose)
Isolated epidermisa Frozen ( -20°C) 1.12
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
TABLE 3
Effect of Applied Concentration of T-2 on It! Vitro Cutaneous
Absorption in Humans.a
Concentration Absorption of T-2°
TABLE 4
Effect of Occlusion on In Vitro Absorption of Fungal Toxins.
Percent dose absorbed
Fungal toxin Nonoccl uded Occl udedC Factor increase
T-2d 0.37 1.55 4.2
AFB+ 0.05 3.41 68
"Discs of full-thickness human skin were exposed to 0.58 ug/cmL
T-2 for 48 hr (unpublished data).
bDiscs of isolated human epidermis were exposed to 4.2 - 5.3
ug/cm2 for 46 hr (28).
CThe epidermal surfaces were occluded by placing a glass coverslip
over the top of the donar chamber of the diffusion cell (28).
104 KEMPPAINEN, RILEY, AND PACE
quantities of fungal toxins and then purify these toxins for use
in experiments. Cutaneous exposure to T-2, DAS, or VCA dissolved
in DMSO resulted in 29, 37, or 10% of the dose, respectively,
being absorbed after 48 hr. DMSO, which is frequently used in
laboratories because of its solvent properties, is a well known
enhancer of cutaneous penetration (35).
In order to relate in vivo studies with laboratory animals t o
-
in -vitro studies using human skin it is necessary t o compare &I
For personal use only.
TABLE 5
E f f e c t o f Vehicle on In Vitro Penetration o f Trichothecenes
Through Human Skin.
Percent dose absorbed
Trichothecene Corn dusta Methanol DMSOD
TABLE 6
I n V i t r o Absorption o f Trichothecenes i n Human, Monkey, Rabbit,
Guinea Pig and Rat Skin.
Percent dose absorbedC
Trichothecene Human Monkey Rabbit Guinea Pig Rat
T-2d 1.0 2.5 3.0 2.0 9.7
DAS~ 0.8 ---d --- 6.8 ---
“From Kemppainen e t a l . (32).
bFrom Kemppainen u.
(27).
‘%iscs o f never-frozen, f u l l - t h i c k n e s s s k i n where exposed t o 0.6
ug/cm2 trichothecene i n methanol f o r 48 hr.
dNot done.
3. D i s t r i b u t i o n o f T-2 i n s k i n f o l l o w i n a t o o i c a l a w l i c a t i o n .
The d i s t r i b u t i o n o f T-2 i n t o once-frozen human s k i n and r e c e p t o r
f l u i d was studied by Maxwell e t a l . (38). The r e s u l t s are
summarized i n Table 7. I n Maxwell’s study (38) 7-10% o f a p p l i e d
r a d i o a c t i v i t y was recovered i n receptor f l u i d bathing t h e skin.
I n t h e s t u d i e s conducted i n our l a b o r a t o r y using never-frozen s k i n
d i s c s (27) t h e absorption o f T-2 was found t o be considerably l e s s
(approximately 1%o f applied dose penetrated i n 48 h r ) . It has
106 KEMPPAINEN, RILEY, AND PACE
been shown (Table 2) that T-2 penetrates skin which has been
stored frozen faster than skin stored at 4OC (29). At the
termination of Maxwell et ale's T-2 penetration study, the skin
surface was blotted with filter paper to remove unadsorbed T-2.
The top 10 layers of stratum corneum were removed by stripping the
surface with tape and the layers analyzed for radioactivity to
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
days and even weeks after the initial exposure period (39). A
cutaneous reservoir of T-2 could play an important role in chronic
toxicity following cutaneous exposure.
4. Metabolism of mvcotoxins followinq topical application.
Cutaneous metabolism is important in determining the toxicity of
surface-applied chemicals (40,41). It was therefore important to
evaluate the extent to which fungal toxins are metabolized during
TABLE 7
-
In -
Vitro Distribution of T-2 in Human Skin and Receptor Fluid
After 48 hr Penetration (Vehicle: Ethanol) .a
% Applied dose recovered in skin and receptor fluid
TABLE 8
P u r i t y o f [JH]T-2 preparation 0 1 96
H y d r o l y s i s by receptor f l u i d 0 5 88
H y d r o l y s i s by enzymes 0 2 92
leaching o u t o f s k i n i n t o
receptor f l u i d
Hydrolysis by enzymes 10 31 39
d u r i n g cutaneous p e n e t r a t i o n
“Expressed as percent o f r a d i o a c t i v i t y i n substance analyzed.
From Kemppainen e t a1 (42). .
TABLE 9
s
aDisc o f never-frozen, f u l l - t h i c k n e s s s k i n were exposed t o 0.6
g/cm trichothecene f o r 48 h r (27,42).
!Discs o f once-frozen i s o l a t e d epidermis were exposed t o 4 - 5
ug/cm2 AFBl f o r 46 h r (28).
CExpressed as percent o f r a d i o a c t i v i t y i n r e c e p t o r f l u i d .
108 KEMPPAINEN, RILEY, AND PAGE
TABLE 10
Comparison of Cutaneous Metabolism of 1 - 2 in Animals and Humans
(Vehicle: Methanol) .a
Metabolites in receDtor fluid (% radioactivity)
Species T-2 tetraol T-2 trio1 HT-2 T-2
Human 2 1 78 6
Rabbit 3 16 73 0
Monkey 0 0 10 85
Guinea pig 0 0 14 82
Rat 4 0 62 28
“Discs of never-frozen, full-thickness skin were exposed to 0.6
ug/cm2 T-2 for 48 hr (32).
SKIN ABSORPTION 109
TABLE 1 1
In Vitro and In Vivo Absorption of T-2 Through Guinea Pig Skin.a
Percent dose absorbedD
Static F1 ow-through
Vehicle -
In -
vivo --
in vitro --
in vitro
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
1.4 and 1.2 times greater than in vitro absorption in the static
and flow-through cells, respectively, when DMSO was the vehicle.
In each group the u viva absorption was greater than in vitro
absorption, however the relative effect of vehicles on absorption
was similar in viva and for both of the in vitro systems. In
vitro techniques do not precisely predict in viva absorption
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
absorption (53). The applied dose in the large dose study was
more than 1000 times larger than the dose used in the low dose
study (1.2 ug/cm2, see Table 11). The large dose would further
increase the potential for problems with the limited solubility of
the penetrant in the aqueous receptor fluid, and could result in a
much smaller percent of the dose penetrating in vitro. The larger
discrepancy between in vivo and in vitro absorption in the large
dose study demonstrates that the size of the dose can be an
important factor when designing vitro cutaneous absorption
studies intended to correlate with in vivo absorption. Marzulli,
Brown & Maibach (54) reported that the degree of correlation
between in viva and in vitro cutaneous absorption in humans was
dose dependent.
The systemic toxicity which results from cutaneous absorption
of a compound depends on its rate o f absorption and the intrinsic
toxicity of the compound and its metabolites. In vivo studies
have indicated that the relative local and systemic toxicity of
trichothecenes (measured by skin irritation and lethality,
respectively, after dermal exposure) is T-2 > DAS ;=: VCA (55,56).
The results of the in vitro penetration studies (T-2 > DAS > VCA)
and in y&@ dermal toxicity studies are fairly consistent,
SKIN ABSORPTION 111
TABLE 12
Estimate of Absorbed Dose Under Hypothetical Conditions (Expressed
as Total ug Absorbed).
Dose Body Surface
Level Area xposed
Compound ( ug/cm2) 5
(cm 1 Case la Case 2b Case 3c
-
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
IV. CONCLUSION
It is important to determine the amount of risk associated
with dermal exposure to fungal toxins because millions of people
all over the world are environmentally and/or occupationally
exposed to these toxins. Relative to other chemicals, mycotoxins
penetrate slowly through excised skin. However, this may not be
the case in vivo. The in vitro methods underestimate the in vivo
penetration, nonetheless the data that has been gathered provides
a point of departure for discussion and for designing future
studies. Considering the ability of mycotoxins to penetrate human
skin and their inherent toxicity and in some cases
114 KEMPPAINEN, R I L E Y , AND PACE
V. REFERENCES
1. Sargeant, K., Sheridan, A., O'Kelly, J. and Carnaghan,
R.B.A., T o x i c i t y Associated w i t h C e r t a i n Samples o f
Groundnuts, Nature, 192: 1096, 1961.
2. Cole, R.J., E t i l o l g y o f Turkey "X" Disease i n Retrospect: A
Case f o r t h e Involvement o f Cylcopiazonic Acid, Mycotoxin
Res., 2:3, 1986.
3. Keen, P. and Martin, P., I s A f l a t o x i n Carcinogenic i n Man?
The Evidence i n Swaziland, Trop. geogr. Med., 23:44, 1971.
4. Oettl'e, A.G., Cancer i n A f r i c a , E s p e c i a l l y i n Regions South
o f t h e Sahara, J. Natn. Cancer Inst., 33:383, 1964.
5. Burg, W.R., Shotwell, O.L. and Saltzman, B.E., Measurements
o f Airborne A f l a t o x i n s During t h e Handling o f 1979
Contaminated Corn, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J . , 43:580, 1982.
6. Zennie, T.M., Identification o f Aflatoxin B i n Grain
Elevator Dusts i n Central I l l i n o i s , J. Toxico\. Environ.
Health, 13:589, 1984.
SKIN ABSORPTION 115
22. Pang, V.F., Felsburg, P.J., Beasley, V.R., Buck, W.B. and
Hascek, W.M., The Toxicity of T-2 Toxin in Swine Following
Topical Application, Fundam. appl. Toxic., 9:50, 1987.
23. Pace, J.G., Cant rbury, W.J. and Matson C., Fate and
Distribution of [fH]T-2 Toxin in Topically Exposed Guinea
Pigs, Toxicologist, 6:246, 1986.
24. Llewellyn, G.C., Toxic Responses in Gerbils Treated Topically
with Aflatoxin B and Dimethylformamide, Bull. Environm.
Contam. Toxicol, 14: 747, 1978.
For personal use only.
32. Kemppainen, B.W., Riley, R.T., Joyave, J.L. and Hoer F.J
-
In -
V i t r o Percutaneous Penetration and Metabolism o f f5H] T:i
Toxin: Comparison o f Human, Rabbit, Guinea P i g and Rat,
Toxicon, 25:185, 1987.
33. Scheuplein, R.J. and Ross, L.W., Mechanism o f Percutaneous
Absorption. V. Percutaneous Absorption o f Solvent Deposited
Solids, J. I n v e s t . Derm., 62:353, 1974.
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
41. Kao, J., Patterson, F.K. and H a l l J., Skin Penetration and
Metabolism o f T o p i c a l l y Applied Chemicals i n S i x Mammalian
Species, I n c l u d i n g Man: an I n V i t r o Study w i t h Benzo(a)pyrene
and Testosterone, Toxic. appl. Pharmac., 81:502, 1985.
42. Kemppainen, B.W., Riley, R.T., Pace., J. G., Hoerr, F.J. and
L -
Joyave, J., Evaluation o f Monkey Skin as a Mo e l f o r I n V i t r o
Percutaneous Penetration and Metabolism o f [ HIT 2 Toxin i n
Human Skin, Fund. appl. Toxic., 7:367, 1986.
44. Cole, R. J., Dorner, J. W., Cox, R.H., Cunfer, B.M., Cut1 er,
H.G. and Stuart, B.P., The Isolation and Identification o f
Several Trichothecene Mycotoxins from Fusarium heterosporum,
J. Nat. Prod., 44:324, 1981.
45. Loden, M., The Vitro Hydrolysis of Diisopropyl
Fluorophosphate During Penetration Through Human Full -
Thickness Skin and Isolated Epidermis, J. Invest. Dermatol.,
85:335, 1985.
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
68. Vidal, D., Creach, O., Genton, A., Beaudry, Y. and Fontages,
R., D e s t r u c t i o n and Cutaneous Decontamination o f
Toxin Reviews Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Kainan University on 04/03/15
.
Dermatol , 52:504, 1969.
FOOTNOTES
A F B l = a f l a t o x i n B1
AFB2 = a f l a t o x i n B2
DAS = diacetoxyscirpenol
DMSO = d i m e t h y l s u l f o x i d e
T-2 = T-2 t o x i n
VCA = v e r r u c a r i n A