Professional Documents
Culture Documents
US T.Bond
US T.Bill
Real Estate
Inflation Rate
Real Returns
Arithmetic Average Return
Risk Premium
FAQ
How precise are the
annual numbers?
I use the 3-month US treasury bill, again choosing it over the 6-month because of
longevity. I get the T.Bill rate at the end of each year from FRED and use it as my
erturn, since there should be no price change in this security. I use the average T.Bill
rate over the course of the year.
I obtain the yield on a Moody's Aaa and Baa corporate bond yields from FRED and
then compute the return on the bond, using the same approach that I use for the US
T.Bond.
I use the home price data that Robert Shiller reports on his webpage to compute a real
estate return on residential real estate. That series has now morphed into the Case-
Shiller Index.
I use the CPI for all urban consumers, reported on FRED.
For each of the data series. I computre a real return by removing the inflatin for the
year from the nominal return, using (1+ Nominal Rate)/ (1+Inflation Rate) -1.
A simple average of the annual returns over the specified period (10 yrs, 50 yrs etc.)
A compounded average of the returns over the period. This is most simply computed
by dividing the value you would have at the end of the period by the value at the
beginning and then computing the compouded average. To compute the cumulated
value on both stocks and bonds, I assume that dividends/coupons get reinvested back.
The risk premium is the difference in the annualized return on stocks and the
annualized return on T.Bonds and on T.Bills over the specified period.
FAQ
Since the S&P and US treasuries are liquid and the underlying data is widely dispersed,
the annual numbers are reliable.
The returns, especially on stocks and bonds, are noisy, with up years and down years.
The averages that have been computed come with error, and I have computed standard
errros in each of the numbers (especially the risk premiums). Note that even with the
longest data series, there is substantial standard error and it becomes explosively large
for shorter periods.
Normally, when you buy a 10-year bond and hold it for a year, you will end up with a
9-year bond. While I could compute the return using a 9-year maturity, and the answer
will be fairly close to what I report, I want to keep the 10-year rmaturity going for
consistency in my risk premium computation. Put simply, think of the return on the 10-
year bond as the one you would have if the coupon changed, but the maturity is reset to
10 year at the end of the year.
Returns by year
S&P
500
(include
s Baa S&P 500
dividen 3-month Corporate (includes
Year ds) T.Bill US T. Bond Bond Real Estate dividends)3
1928 43.81% 3.08% 0.84% 3.22% 1.49% $ 143.81
1929 -8.30% 3.16% 4.20% 3.02% -2.06% $ 131.88
1930 ### 4.55% 4.54% 0.54% -4.30% $ 98.75
1931 ### 2.31% -2.56% -15.68% -8.15% $ 55.46
1932 -8.64% 1.07% 8.79% 23.59% -10.47% $ 50.66
1933 49.98% 0.96% 1.86% 12.97% -3.81% $ 75.99
1934 -1.19% 0.28% 7.96% 18.82% 2.91% $ 75.09
1935 46.74% 0.17% 4.47% 13.31% 9.77% $ 110.18
1936 31.94% 0.17% 5.02% 11.38% 3.22% $ 145.38
1937 ### 0.28% 1.38% -4.42% 2.56% $ 94.00
1938 29.28% 0.07% 4.21% 9.24% -0.87% $ 121.53
1939 -1.10% 0.05% 4.41% 7.98% -1.30% $ 120.20
1940 ### 0.04% 5.40% 8.65% 3.31% $ 107.37
1941 ### 0.13% -2.02% 5.01% -8.38% $ 93.66
1942 19.17% 0.34% 2.29% 5.18% 3.33% $ 111.61
1943 25.06% 0.38% 2.49% 8.04% 11.45% $ 139.59
1944 19.03% 0.38% 2.58% 6.57% 16.58% $ 166.15
Page 5
Returns by year
Page 6
Returns by year
Page 7
Returns by year
Page 8
Returns by year
US companies
Estimates of risk premiums from 1928, over the last 50 years and over the last 10 years
are provided at the bottom of this table.
Page 9
Returns by year
Page 10
Returns by year
Page 11
Returns by year
Page 12
Returns by year
S&P 500
(includes 3-month
Inflation dividends T. Bill !0-year Baa Corp Real
Rate )2 (Real) T.Bonds Bonds Estate3
-1.16% 45.49% 4.29% 2.01% 4.43% 2.68%
0.58% -8.83% 2.56% 3.60% 2.42% -2.63%
-6.40% -20.01% 11.69% 11.68% 7.41% 2.24%
-9.32% -38.07% 12.82% 7.45% -7.02% 1.29%
-10.27% 1.82% 12.64% 21.25% 37.74% -0.21%
0.76% 48.85% 0.20% 1.08% 12.11% -4.54%
1.52% -2.66% -1.22% 6.35% 17.04% 1.37%
2.99% 42.49% -2.74% 1.44% 10.02% 6.58%
1.45% 30.06% -1.26% 3.52% 9.79% 1.74%
2.86% -37.13% -2.51% -1.44% -7.07% -0.29%
-2.78% 32.98% 2.92% 7.19% 12.36% 1.96%
0.00% -1.10% 0.05% 4.41% 7.98% -1.30%
0.71% -11.31% -0.67% 4.65% 7.88% 2.57%
9.93% -20.65% -8.91% -10.87% -4.48% -16.66%
9.03% 9.30% -7.97% -6.18% -3.53% -5.23%
2.96% 21.47% -2.50% -0.46% 4.94% 8.24%
2.30% 16.36% -1.88% 0.27% 4.17% 13.96%
Page 13
Returns by year
Page 14
Returns by year
Page 15
Returns by year
Page 16
Year Real Estate Source of data: http://www.econ.yale.edu//~shiller/data.htm
1927 5.83791228
1928 5.92495868
1929 5.80309371
1930 5.55356068
1931 5.10091937
1932 4.56703475
1933 4.39294194
1934 4.52061
1935 4.96208526
1936 5.12179501
1937 5.25308665
1938 5.20719141
1939 5.13941423
1940 5.3093545
1941 4.86418489
1942 5.02631018
1943 5.60163471
1944 6.53062255
1945 7.29975855
1946 9.05912341
1947 10.9854446
1948 11.2115817
1949 11.2215991
1950 11.6301093
1951 12.3334574
1952 12.8769537
1953 14.3599369
1954 14.4924392
1955 14.4924392
1956 14.6249415
1957 15.0224484
1958 15.1218251
1959 15.1383879
1960 15.2543274
1961 15.4033925
1962 15.4530809
1963 15.7843366
1964 15.9830901
1965 16.2480947
1966 16.4468481
1967 16.8277922
1968 17.5234293
1969 18.7490756
1970 20.2894149
1971 21.1506798
1972 21.7800657
1973 22.5253912
1974 24.7944931
1975 26.47
1976 28.64
1977 32.84
1978 38.00
1979 43.22
1980 46.42
1981 48.78
1982 49.06
1983 51.39
1984 53.79
1985 57.81
1986 63.37
1987 68.36
1988 73.29
1989 76.50
1990 75.97
1991 75.85
1992 76.47
1993 78.12
1994 80.08
1995 81.52
1996 83.49
1997 86.85
1998 92.45
1999 99.55
2000 108.79
2001 116.05
2002 127.15
2003 139.63
2004 158.67
2005 180.11
2006 183.23
2007 173.34
2008 152.54
2009 146.67
2010 140.63
2011 135.17
2012 143.87
2013 159.29
2014 166.48
2015 175.15
2016 184.45
2017 195.91
2018 204.79
2019 212.35
2020 234.32
2021 273.76 As of October
S&P 500 & Raw Data
Page 19
S&P 500 & Raw Data
Page 20
S&P 500 & Raw Data
Page 21
S&P 500 & Raw Data
Return on
Returns
Baa on Real Estate Jan 1 notes
3.22% 1.49%
3.02% -2.06%
0.54% -4.30%
-15.68% -8.15%
23.59% -10.47%
12.97% -3.81%
18.82% 2.91%
13.31% 9.77%
11.38% 3.22%
-4.42% 2.56%
9.24% -0.87%
7.98% -1.30%
8.65% 3.31%
5.01% -8.38%
5.18% 3.33%
8.04% 11.45%
6.57% 16.58%
6.80% 11.78%
2.51% 24.10%
0.26% 21.26%
3.44% 2.06%
5.38% 0.09%
4.24% 3.64%
-0.19% 6.05%
4.44% 4.41%
1.62% 11.52%
6.16% 0.92%
2.04% 0.00%
-2.35% 0.91%
-0.72% 2.72%
6.43% 0.66%
1.57% 0.11%
6.66% 0.77%
5.10% 0.98%
6.50% 0.32%
5.46% 2.14%
5.16% 1.26%
3.19% 1.66%
Page 22
S&P 500 & Raw Data
-3.45% 1.22%
0.90% 2.32%
4.85% 4.13%
-2.03% 6.99%
5.65% 8.22%
14.00% 4.24%
11.41% 2.98%
4.32% 3.42%
-4.38% 10.07%
11.05% 6.76%
19.75% 8.20%
9.95% 14.66%
3.14% 15.71%
-2.01% 13.74%
-3.32% 7.40%
8.46% 5.08%
29.05% 0.57%
16.19% 4.75%
15.62% 4.67%
23.86% 7.47%
21.49% 9.62%
2.29% 7.87%
15.12% 7.21%
15.79% 4.38%
6.14% -0.69%
17.85% -0.18%
12.17% 0.84%
16.43% 2.16%
-1.32% 2.51%
20.16% 1.81%
4.79% 2.43%
11.83% 4.04%
7.95% 6.43%
0.84% 7.69%
9.33% 9.25%
7.82% 6.68%
12.18% 9.56%
13.53% 9.82%
9.89% 13.64%
4.92% 13.51%
7.05% 1.74%
Page 23
S&P 500 & Raw Data
3.15% -5.40%
-5.07% -12.00%
23.33% -3.85%
8.35% -4.11%
12.58% -3.90%
10.12% 6.45%
-1.06% 10.71%
10.38% 4.52%
-0.70% 5.22%
10.37% 5.33%
9.72% 6.23%
-2.76% 4.55%
15.33% 3.44%
10.41% 10.62%
0.93% 16.76% Used indicated dividend
Page 24
T. Bond yield & return
Page 25
T. Bond yield & return
Page 26
T. Bond yield & return
Page 27
T. Bond yield & return
promised coupon at the start of the year and the price change due to interest rate changes.
end of 1927) - Price change on a bond with a coupon rate of 3.17%, when the interest rate goes to 3.45%.
Page 28
T. Bill rates
TB3MS 3-Month Treasury Bill: Secondary Market Rate, Percent, Annual, Not Seasonally Adjusted
Frequency: Annual
observation_date TB3MS
1934-01-01 0.28 0.28%
1935-01-01 0.17 0.17%
1936-01-01 0.17 0.17%
1937-01-01 0.28 0.28%
1938-01-01 0.07 0.07%
1939-01-01 0.05 0.05%
1940-01-01 0.04 0.04%
1941-01-01 0.13 0.13%
1942-01-01 0.34 0.34%
1943-01-01 0.38 0.38%
1944-01-01 0.38 0.38%
1945-01-01 0.38 0.38%
1946-01-01 0.38 0.38%
1947-01-01 0.60 0.60%
1948-01-01 1.05 1.05%
1949-01-01 1.12 1.12%
1950-01-01 1.20 1.20%
1951-01-01 1.52 1.52%
1952-01-01 1.72 1.72%
1953-01-01 1.89 1.89%
1954-01-01 0.94 0.94%
1955-01-01 1.73 1.73%
1956-01-01 2.63 2.63%
1957-01-01 3.23 3.23%
1958-01-01 1.77 1.77%
1959-01-01 3.39 3.39%
1960-01-01 2.88 2.88%
1961-01-01 2.35 2.35%
1962-01-01 2.77 2.77%
1963-01-01 3.16 3.16%
1964-01-01 3.55 3.55%
1965-01-01 3.95 3.95%
1966-01-01 4.86 4.86%
1967-01-01 4.31 4.31%
1968-01-01 5.34 5.34%
1969-01-01 6.67 6.67%
1970-01-01 6.39 6.39%
1971-01-01 4.33 4.33%
1972-01-01 4.07 4.07%
Page 29
T. Bill rates
Page 30
T. Bill rates
ally Adjusted
Page 31
Inflation Rate
CPIAUCNS Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers: All Items in U.S. City Average, Percent Change from Year Ago of (Index 19
Frequency: Annual
observation_ CPIAUCNS
1914 1.0 1.00%
1915 2.0 1.98%
1916 12.6 12.62%
1917 18.1 18.10%
1918 20.4 20.44%
1919 14.5 14.55%
1920 2.6 2.65%
1921 -10.8 -10.82%
1922 -2.3 -2.31%
1923 2.4 2.37%
1924 0.0 0.00%
1925 3.5 3.47%
1926 -1.1 -1.12%
1927 -2.3 -2.26%
1928 -1.2 -1.16%
1929 0.6 0.58%
1930 -6.4 -6.40%
1931 -9.3 -9.32%
1932 -10.3 -10.27%
1933 0.8 0.76%
1934 1.5 1.52%
1935 3.0 2.99%
1936 1.4 1.45%
1937 2.9 2.86%
1938 -2.8 -2.78%
1939 0.0 0.00%
1940 0.7 0.71%
1941 9.9 9.93%
1942 9.0 9.03%
1943 3.0 2.96%
1944 2.3 2.30%
1945 2.2 2.25%
1946 18.1 18.13%
1947 8.8 8.84%
1948 3.0 2.99%
1949 -2.1 -2.07%
1950 5.9 5.93%
1951 6.0 6.00%
1952 0.8 0.75%
Page 32
Inflation Rate
Page 33
Inflation Rate
Page 34
Inflation Rate
Page 35
Summary for ppt
Page 36
Home Prices (Raw Data)
Home Price data from Robert Shiller's website. FRED Graph Observations
Federal Reserve Economic Data
Link: https://fred.stlouisfed.org
Help: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/help-faq
Economic Research Division
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
Page 37
Home Prices (Raw Data)
Page 38
Home Prices (Raw Data)
Page 39
Home Prices (Raw Data)
ional Home Price Index, Percent Change from Year Ago of (Index Jan 2000=100), Annual, Not Seasonally Adjusted
Page 40
Moody's Rates
AAA Moody's Seasoned Aaa Corporate Bond Yield, Percent, Annual, Not Seasonally Adjusted
Frequency: Annual
observation_dAAA % Rate
1919-01-01 5.73 5.73%
1920-01-01 6.26 6.26%
1921-01-01 5.50 5.50%
1922-01-01 5.08 5.08%
1923-01-01 5.09 5.09%
1924-01-01 4.95 4.95%
1925-01-01 4.85 4.85%
1926-01-01 4.68 4.68%
1927-01-01 4.46 4.46%
1928-01-01 4.61 4.61%
1929-01-01 4.67 4.67%
1930-01-01 4.52 4.52%
1931-01-01 5.32 5.32%
1932-01-01 4.59 4.59%
1933-01-01 4.50 4.50%
1934-01-01 3.81 3.81%
1935-01-01 3.44 3.44%
1936-01-01 3.10 3.10%
1937-01-01 3.21 3.21%
1938-01-01 3.08 3.08%
1939-01-01 2.94 2.94%
1940-01-01 2.71 2.71%
1941-01-01 2.80 2.80%
1942-01-01 2.81 2.81%
1943-01-01 2.74 2.74%
1944-01-01 2.70 2.70%
1945-01-01 2.61 2.61%
1946-01-01 2.61 2.61%
1947-01-01 2.86 2.86%
1948-01-01 2.79 2.79%
1949-01-01 2.58 2.58%
1950-01-01 2.67 2.67%
1951-01-01 3.01 3.01%
1952-01-01 2.97 2.97%
1953-01-01 3.13 3.13%
1954-01-01 2.90 2.90%
1955-01-01 3.15 3.15%
1956-01-01 3.75 3.75%
1957-01-01 3.81 3.81%
Page 41
Moody's Rates
Page 42
Moody's Rates
Page 43
Moody's Rates
BAA Moody's Seasoned Baa Corporate Bond Yield, Percent, Annual, Not Seasonally Adjusted
Frequency: Annual
observation_date BAA
1919-01-01 7.77 7.77%
1920-01-01 8.56 8.56%
1921-01-01 7.61 7.61%
1922-01-01 7.02 7.02%
1923-01-01 7.38 7.38%
1924-01-01 6.46 6.46%
1925-01-01 6.15 6.15%
1926-01-01 5.68 5.68%
1927-01-01 5.32 5.32%
1928-01-01 5.60 5.60%
1929-01-01 5.95 5.95%
1930-01-01 6.71 6.71%
1931-01-01 10.42 10.42%
1932-01-01 8.42 8.42%
1933-01-01 7.75 7.75%
1934-01-01 6.23 6.23%
1935-01-01 5.30 5.30%
1936-01-01 4.53 4.53%
1937-01-01 5.73 5.73%
1938-01-01 5.27 5.27%
1939-01-01 4.92 4.92%
1940-01-01 4.45 4.45%
1941-01-01 4.38 4.38%
1942-01-01 4.28 4.28%
1943-01-01 3.82 3.82%
1944-01-01 3.49 3.49%
1945-01-01 3.10 3.10%
1946-01-01 3.17 3.17%
1947-01-01 3.52 3.52%
1948-01-01 3.53 3.53%
1949-01-01 3.31 3.31%
1950-01-01 3.20 3.20%
1951-01-01 3.61 3.61%
1952-01-01 3.51 3.51%
1953-01-01 3.74 3.74%
1954-01-01 3.45 3.45%
1955-01-01 3.62 3.62%
1956-01-01 4.37 4.37%
1957-01-01 5.03 5.03%
Page 44
Moody's Rates
Page 45
Moody's Rates
Page 46