Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CH 03
However, putting limitations aside, BCG matrix is a very useful tool for
strategic planners
GE Matrix
Aims of GE Model:
• This model aims to evaluate the existing portfolios of strategic
business units and to develop strategies to achieve growth by
addition of new products and businesses to this portfolio and further,
to analyze which business units to invest in and which ones to sell off.
• The GE McKinsey matrix is a nine-box matrix which is used as a
strategy tool.
• It helps multi-business corporations evaluate business portfolios and
prioritize investments among different business units in a systematic
manner.
• This technique is used in brand marketing and product management.
• The analysis helps companies decide what products need to be added
to a product portfolio as well as what other opportunities should
continue to receive investments.
• Though similar to the BCG matrix, the GE version is a lot more
complex.
• The analysis begins as a two-dimensional portfolio matrix but the
dimensions are multifactorial with industry attractiveness measures
and business strength measures.
• The business world is becoming increasingly focused on its
investment decisions as resources become more and more scarce.
• Each decision needs to be the best use of investments and aim to
bring in the most return on this investment.
• For diversified businesses, the fight for resource allocation becomes
even more complex because multiple products, brands and portfolios
need to be managed.
• This matrix helps companies make these decisions in a more
systematic and informed manner.
• The matrix is a 3×3 grid.
• The Y-axis measures market attractiveness while the x-axis measures
the business strength.
• The scale is high, medium and low.
• List the entire range of products created or sold by a particular
strategic business unit.
• Identify the factors that make a specific market attractive.
• Evaluate the strategic business unit’s position in the market.
• Calculate the business strength and market attractiveness.
• Determine the strategic business unit’s category: High, Medium or
low.
1) Market Attractiveness
• This dimension helps determine the attractiveness of the market by
analyzing the benefits a company is likely to get by entering and competing
within the market.
• A number of factors are studied within this analysis.
• These include the size of the market, its rate of growth, profit potential,
and the nature, size and weaknesses of the competition within the
industry.
Some factors used to determine market attractiveness include:
a. Long term growth rate
b. Size of the industry
c. Industry Profitability
d. Structure of the industry
e. Product life cycle
f. Demand
2) Business Unit /Competitive Strength
• The other main dimension that makes up this grid is the competitive
or business strength of the company itself.
• An assessment along this dimension helps understand whether a
company has the required competence to compete in a particular
market.
• This can be determined by internal factors such as assets, market
share and development of this market share, brand position and
loyalty, creativity, and handling of market changes and fluctuations.
• This can also be determined by external factors such as
environmental concerns, government regulations and laws, energy
consumption etc.
• Some factors that can determine this business/competitive strength
include:
a. Total market share
b. Market share growth compared to competitors
c. Strength of the brand
d. Company profitability
e. Customer loyalty
f. Value chain
g. Product differentiation
• Grow – Business units that fall within this category attract investment
by the corporation because they are in a position to bring high
returns in the future.
• Investments include those in research and development, acquisitions,
advertisement and brand expansion as well as an expansion in
production capacity.
• Hold/Selectivity – These business units are in a more ambiguous
position and it is unclear whether they will grow in the future or
become stagnant.
• Investments in this category may happen after money has already
been put into ‘grow’ units and if there is a strategic purpose for these
units.
• Harvest – Units in this category may be poor performers and in less
attractive industries and markets.
• Investment will be put into these if they generate revenues to equal
this investment.
• If this does not happen, then these units may be liquidated.
How To Apply The GE Matrix
1. Porter's Four Corners tool has been around for a long time and it's
earned a place for itself as a useful and respected management tool.
The real advantage of this approach is:
2. Try to get inside the mind of the opposition
3. Explore the beliefs and assumptions of your competitors.
4. Use past behavior to predict future action, but actively tries to see if
there is likely to be a shift in their strategy.
Components of Four Corners Analysis
• The four corners refer to the four elements that are critical in analyzing
a market rival, including independently and collectively assessing its:
Drivers / future goals, Management Assumptions, Strategy and
Capabilities.
• Unlike the other static models (i.e. SWOT Analysis) that they don't
actually help the analyst understand what would motivate a competitor
to take particular actions, the four corners method was developed to
capture insights about what competitors plan to do from the present
forward.
• Now, let's take a look of the four component of the analysis:
Drivers
• The perceptions and assumptions that a competitor has about itself, the
industry and other companies will influence its strategic decisions.
Analyzing these assumptions can help identify the competitor's biases
and blind spots. We may brainstorm by considering the following
points:
• What do they believe about themselves and the world in which they
operate?
• What assumptions have they made about their own strengths and
weaknesses in relation to their competitors?
• Is this likely to make their strategy proactive or reactive? Aggressive, or
defensive?
Current Strategy
• A company's strategy determines how a competitor competes in the
market.
• However, there can be a difference between 'intended strategy' (the
strategy as stated in annual reports, interviews and public statements)
and the 'realised strategy' (the strategy that the company is following in
practice, as evidenced by acquisitions, capital expenditure and new
product development).
• Where the current strategy is yielding satisfactory results, it is reasonable
to assume that an organisation will continue to compete in the same way
as it currently does.
• We may brainstorm by considering the following points:
• How do your competitors actually act and are they happy will they be
with the efficacy of their actions?
• Is there a gap between intended strategy and realized strategy?
• Is there likely to be a sea-change in their strategy due to current lack of
success or are they likely to keep moving in the same direction?
Capabilities
• It has been a curious battle because, for many years, Microsoft went
ahead of Apple but, finally, Apple overtook Microsoft.
• What would the Four Corners of Microsoft have been like?
• Drivers: Be the World leader in Software systems.
• Management Assumptions: They assume they can copy or improve any
competitor.
• Strategy: They offer their software pre-installed to hardware companies.
• Capabilities: They have the best programmers and also, they can buy any
competitor.
• This strategy didn’t work very good for many years… Until they
presented their iPhone to the world.
Result
• Apple’s revenue is 260 billion USD.
• Microsoft’s revenue is 143 billion USD.
• However, consider Microsoft a much more stable company than Apple is.
• Microsoft has a highly diversified revenue, while Apple depends on one single
product: the iPhone.
The iPhone represents the 55% of total Apple’s revenues.
If I were a major shareholder in Apple… I’d be very worried.