Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MAXWELL’S
EQUATIONS
859
860 Chapter 40 Maxwell's Equations
physics and how it has often led to new insights or discov If you change an electric field (d^E/dt), you produce
eries. For example, if body A attracts body B with a force a magnetic field (fB'ds).
o f magnitude F, then we might expect from symmetry
that body B should attract body A with a force o f the same This supposition, which we discuss more fully in the next
magnitude. This expectation turns out to be correct. For section, provides us with the missing term in Eq. IV and
another example, the symmetry of the theory describing turns out to meet the test o f experiment.
ordinary negatively charged electrons suggests that the
electron should have a positively charged counterpart; the
later discovery o f the positron showed that this prediction
was correct. 40-2 INDUCED MAGNETIC
Let us examine Table 1 from the standpoint o f sym FIELDS AND TH E
metry. We ignore any lack o f symmetry in the equations DISPLACEM ENT CURRENT
that arises from Cqand Ho; these constants result from our
choice o f unit systems and play no role in considerations Here we discuss in detail the evidence for the supposition
o f symmetry. (There are, in fact, systems o f units in which of the previous section: namely, a changing electric field
€o = H o = \ .) induces a magnetic field. Although we are guided primar
With this in mind we see that the left sides o f the equa ily by considerations of symmetry, we also find direct
tions in Table 1 are completely symmetrical, in pairs. experimental verification.
Equations I and II are surface integrals o f E and B, respec Figure 1a shows a circular parallel-plate capacitor. A
tively, over closed surfaces. Equations III and IV are line current i enters the left-hand plate (which we assume to
integrals o f E and B, respectively, around closed loops. carry a positive charge), and an equal current i leaves the
The right sides of these equations, on the other hand, right-hand plate. An Amperian loop surrounds the wire in
are not symmetrical. There are two kinds o f asymmetries: Fig. \a and forms the boundary for a surface that is
pierced by the wire. The current in the wire sets up a
1. The first asymmetry, which is not really the concern of magnetic field; in Section 35-5 we saw that the magnetic
this chapter, deals with the apparent fact that there are no field and the current are related by Ampere’s law.
isolated centers of magnetic charge (magnetic monopoles;
see Section 37-1) analogous to isolated centers of electric B *ds = p o i, ( 2)
charge (electrons, for instance). Thus we account for the q
on the right side of Eq. I and for the 0 on the right side o f That is, the line integral of the magnetic field around the
Eq. II. In the same way, the term / (=dqldt), representing
the current o f electric charges, appears on the right side o f
Eq. IV, but there is no corresponding term representing a
current o f magnetic charges on the right of Eq. III. The
desire for symmetry in these equations has led to the pre
diction that magnetic monopoles should exist. Despite
many experimental searches for monopoles, there is as yet
no confirmation of their existence. Later in this chapter
we discuss how to symmetrize Maxwell’s equations if
magnetic monopoles are proved to exist.
2. The second asymmetry, which is more significant for
the discussions o f this chapter, is equally prominent. On
the right side o f Eq. Ill we find the term —d^B/dt. This
equation, also known as Faraday’s law of induction, can
be loosely interpreted by saying:
with Fig. 12 of Chapter 36, which illustrates the produc name displacement current* Th&displacement current
tion o f an electric field by a changing magnetic field. In is defined according to
each case the appropriate flux or is increasing.
However, experiment shows that the lines of E in Fig. 12 /n = €n ( 6)
o f Chapter 36 are counterclockwise, whereas those of B dt
in Fig. 2 are clockwise. This difference requires that the Thus we can say that a magnetic field can be set up either
minus sign of Eq. 3 be omitted from Eq. 4. by a conduction current / or by a displacement current i^.
and we can rewrite Eq. 5 as
/ = id-
= i(47rX 10-^T*m/AK8.9X IQ-^^CVN-m^)
X (5.0X 10-2 mX 10*2 V/m-s) Thus the displacement current in the gap equals the con
duction current in the wires, which shows that the current
= 2.8X 10-2 7 = 280 nT.
is continuous.
This shows that the induced magnetic fields in this example are When the capacitor is fully charged, the conduction
so small that they can scarcely be measured with simple appa current drops to zero (no current flows in the wires). The
ratus, in sharp contrast to induced electric fields (Faraday’s law), electric field between the plates becomes constant; thus
which can be demonstrated easily. This experimental difference
dE/dt = 0, and so the displacement current also drops to
is in part due to the fact that induced emfs can easily be multi
zero.
plied by using a coil of many turns. No technique of comparable
simplicity exists for magnetic fields. In experiments involving The displacement current i^, given by Eq. 6, has a direc
oscillations at very high frequencies, dE/dt can be very large, tion as well as a magnitude. The direction of the conduc
resulting in significantly larger values of the induced magnetic tion current i is that of the conduction current densit>
field. vector j. Similarly, the direction of the displacement
current i^ is that of the displacement current density vec
tor j^, which, as we deduce from Eq. 6, is just e^idB/dtX
Displacement Current
Equation 5 shows that the term € q d^^/dt has the dimen * The word “displacement” was introduced for historical rea
sions o f a current. Even though no motion of charge is sons. It has nothing to do with our previous use of displacement
involved, there are advantages in giving this term the to indicate the position of a particle.
Section 40-3 M axw ells Equations 863
ric, however. A completely symmetric set would result if formation, but Newton’s laws are not. (See Section 35-7
the existence of individual magnetic charges (monopoles) for a discussion of the relativistic transformation o f E and
were confirmed. If such magnetic charges were discov B fields.) —
ered, experiments with them would be possible. By anal
ogy with our previous development of electromagnetism,
two experiments come to mind. One experiment, similar 40-4 MAXWELL’S EQUATIONS AND
to Coulomb’s original experiment, would be to measure CAVITY OSCILLATIONS (Optional)
the force between monopoles to determine whether it There are many situations involving electromagnetic fields thai
obeyed an inverse-square law. If so, then Eq. II could be we can use as a demonstration of Maxwell’s equations. We dela>
written • t/A = . This form o f Gauss’ law for mag until Chapter 41 any discussion of tests involving electromag
netism would assert that the flux of the magnetic field netic waves. Here we discuss a resonant cavity, which can be
through any closed surface is proportional to the net mag considered to be an electromagnetic oscillator with distributed
netic charge enclosed by the surface. In this case Eqs. I elements.
and II would become more symmetric. By way of analogy, consider the acoustic resonant cavity of
The second experiment, similar to that of Oersted, Fig. 3. (An organ pipe, closed at both ends, is an example of such
would be to show that a current of magnetic charges pro an acoustic resonator.) In a simple oscillator, such as a block on a
spring or an L C circuit, we can “lump” the stored energy into
duces an electric field. In this case we would add to the
separate items: the kinetic energy of the block and the potential
right side of Eq. Ill a term involving = dq^/dt, the
energy of the spring, or the stored magnetic energy of the induc
current of magnetic charges. With this addition, Eqs. Ill tor and the stored electric energy of the capacitor. In the acoustic
and IV would become more symmetric. resonator, such a division is not possible. Every tiny element of
So far there is no conclusive evidence for magnetic the gas within the tube has both potential and kinetic energ>-.
monopoles, so the above experiments remain specula such a system is said to have distributed elements. The electro
tions, and the set of equations in Table 2 is our best de magnetic resonant cavity likewise has distributed elements.
scription o f the properties of electric and magnetic fields. One characteristic of a distributed system is that it has a laigt
However, note how easily a major discovery such as the number of resonant modes (the lumped system by contrast hav
magnetic monopole could be incorporated into the basic ing few, often just one). Figure 3 shows the fundamental mode of
equations of electromagnetism. the acoustic cavity. It illustrates a series of “snapshots” of the
pressure and velocity variations throughout one cycle. Note thai
2. Electrom agnetic waves. The four equations of Table the pressure and the velocity vary with time and with location
1 were o f course known long before Maxwell’s time (he along the tube. There is a pressure antinode at each end of a
was bom in the year that Faraday discovered the law of closed pipe. Where the pressure variation is greatest, the velocitv
induction). Taken together, they suggest no new effects is zero (Figs. 3a and 2>e\ in analogy with the block-spring s\v
beyond the original experiments they represent. It is only tern at its maximum displacement. When the pressure is uni
when the displacement current is added that new physics form, the velocities have their maximum values (Figs. 3c and
emerges. This new physics includes the prediction of the 3^)-
As shown by the bar graphs accompanying each “snapshot”
existence of electromagnetic waves, which were discov of Fig. 3, the energy of the resonator oscillates between the ki
ered experimentally by Heinrich Hertz in 1888, 15 years netic energy of the moving gas and the potential energy asso
after Maxwell’s Treatise v/diS published. In the next chap ciated with the compression and rarefaction of the gas. The
ter, we show how electromagnetic waves, which can trans energy may be all potential (Figs. 3a and 3c), all kinetic (Figs. 3c
port energy and momentum through empty space by and 3gX or a mixture of both.
means o f electromagnetic fields, follow from Maxwell’s By analogy with the acoustic cavity, we can consider a cyhn-
equations. drical electromagnetic resonant cavity. Instead of pressure and
velocity, we describe the state of the resonator by its electric and
3. E lectrom agnetism a n d relativity. We have already magnetic fields. Imagine the ends of the cavity to be a paralld-
suggested in the introduction to this chapter that Max plate capacitor. To start the field oscillations, we connect a sinu
well’s equations are for electromagnetism what Newton’s soidally varying source of emf. This gives rise to a changing
laws are for mechanics. There is, however, an important electric field in the cavity. As was the case in Fig. 2, the changing
difference. Einstein’s theory of relativity was presented in electric field causes a magnetic field, and thus within the cavin
1905, more than 30 years after Maxwell’s work and more there are magnetic and electric fields that vary with location and
than 200 years after Newton’s. Relativity necessitated with time.
Like the acoustic resonator, the electromagnetic resonator
major changes in Newton’s laws for motion at speeds near
stores its energy in two forms; in this case they are the energies
that o f light, but no changes whatever were required in
associated with the electric field and the magnetic field. Even
M axw ell's equations. Maxwell’s equations are totally con element of volume of the cavity contributes to both kinds cf
sistent with the special theory of relativity, and in fact energy, and thus the electromagnetic cavity has distributed de
Einstein’s theory grew out of his thinking about Max ments.
well’s equations. In the language of physics, we say that Figure 4 shows, in similar fashion to Fig. 3, a series of “snap
Maxwell’s equations are invariant under a Lorentz trans shots” of the cavity illustrating the electric and magnetic fields z
Section 40-4 M axw ells Equations and Cavity Oscillations (Optional) 865
KJ2 n u KH nu
K J U Z iU KH nu
(c)
Figure 4 Eight stages in a cycle of oscillation of
a cylindrical electromagnetic resonant cavity. The
bar graphs below each figure show the stored
electric energy 11^ and magnetic energy Ug. The
id) lines of B are circles concentric with the axis, and
the lines of E are parallel to the axis. Compare
with Fig. 3; both figures are examples of oscilla
n n^E U,b h n ^ E tions involving distributed elements.
(a) ie)
------ ;— t
n\ \^E ji Up
ih) (/■)
bH
866 Chapter 40 M axw ells Equations
Integrating over the volume of the cavity, we can find the total indeed points to the right, as shown, if the magnetic field is
energy in each of the two forms. decreasing.
Figure 5 shows a more detailed representation of the electric Let us apply Ampere’s law in the form
and magnetic fields at one particular instant of the oscillation, ¥» j •I d^£
corresponding to Fig. Ad. Note from Fig. Ad that the magnetic B *^/s= //o /+ //o € o “^ ,
field is decreasing, and the electric field is increasing. Let us
apply Faraday’s law. to the dashed circular path of radius r shown in the figure. No
charge is transported through the area bounded by the circular
path, so the conduction current / is zero. The line integral on the
left is (£X27rr), and so the equation reduces to
to the dashed rectangle of dimensions h and a — r. There is a // oCq
definite magnetic flux through this rectangular area, and this B(r) = (9)
In r dt
flux is decreasing with time because B is decreasing.
For a cavity made of conducting material, we can set E to zero Equation 9 shows that the magnetic field B(r) is proportional
for the upper leg of the integration path, which lies inside the to the rate at which the electric flux <I>£ through the ring is
cavity wall. Also, on the two side legs E and ds are at right angles, changing with time. The field B(r) has its maximum value when
so E • i/s = 0 on that part of the rectangular path. The only con d^E /d t is at its maximum; this occurs when E = 0, that is, when
tribution to the line integral of E around the perimeter of the E is reversing its direction. Thus we see that B has its maximum
rectangle comes from the lower segment, and so value when E is zero for all points in the cavity. This is consistent
with Figs. Ac and Ag and with the concept of the interchange of
E ‘t/s = h E {r\ energy between electric and magnetic forms. A comparison with
Fig. 2, which like Fig. 5 corresponds to an increasing electric
in which E(r) is the value of £ at a radius r from the axis of the field, shows that the lines of B are indeed clockwise, as viewed
cavity. Inserting this result for the line integral into Faraday’s along the direction of the electric field.
law, we obtain Comparison of Eqs. 8 and 9 suggests the complete interdepen
dence of B and E in the cavity. As the magnetic field changes
E(r) =- - ^ (8) with time, it induces the electric field in a way described by
h dt
Faraday’s law. The electric field, which also changes with time
Equation 8 shows that E(r) depends on the rate at which induces the magnetic field in a way described by Maxwell’s ex
through the path shown is changing with time and that it has its tension of Ampere’s law. The oscillations, once established, sus
maximum magnitude when d ^ g /d t is a maximum. This occurs tain each other and would continue indefinitely were it not for
when B is zero, that is, when B is changing its direction; recall losses due to production of internal energy in the conducting
that a sine or cosine is changing most rapidly (it has the steepest cavity walls or leakage of energy from openings that might be
slope) at the instant it crosses the axis between positive and present in the walls. In Chapter 41 we show that a similar inter
negative values. The electric field pattern in the cavity has its play of B and E occurs not only in standing electromagnetic
maximum value when the magnetic field is zero everywhere, waves in cavities but also in traveling electromagnetic waves
consistent with Figs. Aa and Ae and with the concept of the such as radio waves or visible light.
interchange of energy between electric and magnetic fields. You In a resonant acoustic cavity, such as an organ pipe, we pro
can show, by applying Lenz’ law, that the electric field in Fig. 5 vide a source of energy (for example, by directing a stream of air
Questions 867
against a sharp edge), allow the standing wave to be established the walls pointing from right to left in Fig. lb. These currents are
in the cavity with a frequency determined by the geometry of the also shown by the dots (representing the tips of arrows) near the
cavity, and arrange for a portion of the energy of the wave to cavity walls in Fig. la.
leave the pipe, where it is heard by the listener. In an electromag Bearing in mind that €qd ^E /d t is a displacement current, we
netic cavity, the sequence of events is similar. The oscillations can write Eq. 9 as
must be stimulated externally, such as by a current. A standing
electromagnetic wave is established, whose frequency depends
on the dimensions of the cylindrical cavity. A portion of the
wave is then permitted to leave the cavity. A common use of This equation stresses that B in the cavity is associated with
such resonant cavities is in accelerators that produce beams of a displacement current; compare Eq. 11 of Chapter 35, S =
charged particles with high energies. Figure 6 shows the interior ^iQi/lnr. Applying the right-hand rule in Fig. 5 shows that the
of the 2-mile electron accelerator at Stanford, in which a series of displacement current /<, must be directed into the plane of Fig.
hundreds of resonant cavities (called klystrons) feeds electromag la if it is to be associated with the clockwise lines of B that are
netic waves into the accelerator. The electrons travel along the present.
straight 2-mile path, subject to a sequence of accelerating electric The displacement current is represented in Fig. lb by arrows
fields, which boost the energies of the electrons to nearly 50 that point to the right and in Fig. la by crosses that represent
GeV. ■ arrows entering the page. Figure 7 shows that the current is
continuous, directed up the walls as a conduction current and
then back down through the volume of the cavity as a displace
ment current. Applying Ampere’s law as extended by Maxwell,
Sample Problem 3 In Fig. 5 analyze the currents (both con
duction and displacement) that occur in the cavity (both in its B-t/s = //o(/d + 0, ( 10)
conducting walls and within its volume). Show the relationship
between these currents and the electric and magnetic fields and to the circular path of radius r, in Fig. la, we see that B at that
also show that, considering both conduction and displacement path is due entirely to the displacement current, the conduction
currents together, it is reasonable to conclude that current is current / within the path being zero.
continuous around closed loops. For the path of radius r 2, the net current enclosed is zero
because the conduction current in the walls is exactly equal and
Solution Figure 7 shows two views of the cavity, at an instant opposite to the displacement current in the cavity volume. Since
corresponding to that of Fig. 5. For simplicity, we do not show /■equals i^ in magnitude, but is oppositely directed, it follows
the E and B fields; the arrows represent currents. Because E is from Eq. 10 that B must be zero for all points outside the cavity,
increasing in Figs. 5 and 7, the positive charge on the left end cap in agreement with observation.
must be increasing. Thus there must be conduction currents in
QUESTIONS
1. In your own words explain why Faraday’s law of induction 4. Compare Tables 1 and 2. Is it enough to rely on the principle
(see TaWe2) can be interpreted by saying “a changing mag of symmetry alone or do we really need experimental verifi
netic field generates an electric field.” cation for the “missing” term in Eq. IV?
2. If a uniform flux through a plane circular ring decreases 5. Why is it so easy to show that “a changing magnetic field
with time, is the induced magnetic field (as viewed along the produces an electric field” but so hard to show in a simple
direction of E) clockwise or counterclockwise? way that “a changing electric field produces a magnetic
3. If (as is true) there are unit systems in which €© and Pq do field” ?
not appear, how can Eq. 1 be true? 6. In Fig. 2 consider a circle with r> R. How can a magnetic
868 Chapter 40 M axwell’s Equations
field be induced around this circle, as Sample Problem 1 quency without attaching it to an external capacitor. Is this a
shows? After all, there is no electric field at the location of case of distributed elements? Do you suppose that it can
this circle and dE/dt = 0 here. oscillate at more than one frequency? Discuss.
7. In Fig. 2, E is into the figure and is increasing in magnitude. 17. Can a given circuit element (a capacitor, say) behave like a
Find the direction of B if, instead, {a) E is into the figure and “lumped” element under some circumstances and like a
decreasing, (b) E is out of the figure and increasing, (c) E is “distributed” element under others?
out of the figure and decreasing, and (d) E remains constant. 18. Are oscillating systems (mechanical, say) eitH^ lumped or
8. In Fig. 9c of Chapter 38, a displacement current is needed distributed? That is, is there no middle ground? (a) Consider
to maintain continuity of current in the capacitor. How can a lumped system such as an idealized block-spring arrange
one exist, considering that there is no charge on the capaci ment. How might you change it physically to make it more
tor? distributed? (b) Consider a distributed system such as a vi
9. (a) In Fig. 2 what is the direction of the displacement current brating string. How might you change it physically to make
/‘d? In this same figure, can you find a rule relating the direc it more lumped?
tions (b) of B and E and (c) of B and d E /d tl 19. Discuss the periodic flow of energy, if any, from point to
10. What advantages are there in calling the term eod^E/dt in point in an acoustic resonant cavity.
Eq. IV, Table 2, a displacement current? 20. An air-filled acoustic resonant cavity and an electromag
11. Can a displacement current be measured with an ammeter? netic resonant cavity of the same size have resonant fre
Explain. quencies that are in the ratio of 10^ or so. Which has the
12. Why are the magnetic fields of conduction currents in wires higher frequency and why?
so easy to detect but the magnetic effects of displacement 21. Electromagnetic cavities are often silver-plated on the in
current in capacitors so hard to detect? side. Why?
13. In Table 2 there are three kinds of apparent lack of sym 22. At what parts of the cycle will (a) the conduction current and
metry in Maxwell’s equations, (a) The quantities €©and/or (b) the displacement current in the cavity of Fig. 4 be zero?
Po appear in I and IV but not in II and III. (b) There is a
minus sign in III but no minus sign in IV. (c) There are 23. Discuss the time variation during one complete cycle of the
missing “magnetic pole terms” in II and III. Which of these charges that appear at various points on the inner walls of
represent genuine lack of symmetry? If magnetic mono the oscillating electromagnetic cavity of Fig. 4.
poles were discovered, how would you rewrite these equa 24. Would you expect that the arrangement of the magnetic and
tions to include them? (Hint: Let be the magnetic pole electric fields in Fig. 5 is the only possible arrangement? If
strength, analogous to the quantum of charge e\ what SI there are other arrangements, would you expect them to
units would have?) have higher or lower frequencies than that shown in Fig. 5?
14. Maxwell’s equations as displayed in Table 2 are written on 25. In connection with Fig. 7, in what sense can the end caps be
the assumption that no dielectric materials are present. How considered as capacitor plates? In what sense can the cylin
should the equations be written if this restriction is re drical walls be considered as an inductor? (Note: Figure 7 is
moved? clearly a case of distributed elements but there must be a
15. List as many (a) lumped and (b) distributed mechanical smooth transition between distributed and lumped ele
oscillating systems as you can. ments.)
16. A coil has a measured inductance L. In a practical case it also 26. (a) In Fig. 5 is it possible to apply Faraday’s law usefully to
has a capacitance C, adjacent windings behaving as the dashed circle? (b) Is it possible to apply Ampere’s law
“plates.” The coil can be made to oscillate at a certain fre usefully to the dashed rectangle? Discuss.
PROBLEMS
Section 40-1 The Basic Equations o f Electromagnetism Section 40-2 Induced Magnetic Fields and the Displacement
1. By substituting numerical values of ۩ and used in Current
previous chapters, verify the numerical value of the speed of 3. For the situation of Sample Problem 1, where is the induced
light from Eq. 1 and show that the equation is dimensionally magnetic field equal to one-half of its maximum value?
correct. 4. Prove that the displacement current in a parallel-plate capac
itor can be written
2. (a) Show that = 377 Q. (called the “impedance of free
space”), (b) Show that the angular frequency of ordinary 60
^ dt '
Hz AC is 377 rad/s. (c) Compare (a) with (b). Do you think
that this coincidence is the reason that 60 Hz was originally 5. You are given a 1.0-pF parallel-plate capacitor. How would
chosen as the frequency for AC generators? Recall that, in you establish an (instantaneous) displacement current of 1.0
Europe, 50 Hz is used. mA in the space between its plates?
Problems 869
6. In Sample Problem 1 show that the displacement current shown in Fig. 10. Calculate the displacement current,
density is given, for r < R , by through a 1.9-m^ region perpendicular to the field, during
each of the time intervals (a), (b \ and (c) shown on the
_ dE graph. (Ignore the behavior at the ends of the intervals.)
Jd -C o •
10. In Sample Problem 1 show that the expressions derived for
7. A parallel-plate capacitor has square plates 1.22 m on a side B{r) can be written
as in Fig. 8. There is a chaiging current of 1.84 A flowing into
(and out oO the capacitor, (a) What is the displacement
current through the region between the plates? (b) What is
dE/dt in this region? (c) What is the displacement current
through the square dashed path between the plates? = ir .R ) .
{d) What is around this square dashed path?
(6 = 8m sin o)t)
is the separation d between the plates? (d) Find the maxi Show that, from this alone, Eq. I is automatically satisfied
mum value of the magnitude of B between the plates at a for the composite closed surface, (b) Repeat using Eq. II. See
distance r = 11.0 cm from the center. Problem 17.
(j+i< i)-^A = o,
- f f
=1+
Figure 15 Problem 21.
Figure 13 Problem 17.
22. Sketch diagrams like those shown in Fig. 4 showing a c>ck
18. Two adjacent closed parallelepipeds share a common face as of oscillation of a cylindrical electromagnetic resonant cav
shown in Fig. 14. (a) We may apply #E • i/A = q/e^ (Eq. I in ity operating, not in the fundamental mode as in that figure:
Table 2) to each of these two closed surfaces separately. but in the first overtone.