You are on page 1of 5

The Development of a New Type of

Repulsion-Induction Motor
Aurelian Crăciunescu
Electrical Engineering Faculty
University Politehnica of Bucharest
Bucharest, Romania
aurelian.craciunescu@upb.ro

Abstract— This paper deals with the development of a new be built yet for high power single-phase above-mentioned
type of repulsion-start induction motor for application to single- applications.
phase distribution networks. A description is given of the
derivation of this new type of motor from the plain repulsion In this paper, a new electromechanical energy converter is
motor. The novel feature lies in the using of the D.C. brush proposed – the A.C. brushless commutator – which, like well-
commutator principle to realize an A.C. brushless commutator known D.C. brush commutator, realize a pseudo stationary
which allows to obtain a pseudo-stationary winding and has, in coil, this means a coil whose axis is permanently in the same
the same time, the role of induction motor squirrel cage. The direction, given by the direction of the brushes. Then, based
changing over from the repulsion to the induction type is on the A.C. brushless commutator, a new repulsion-induction
accomplished without the use of any devices, this change tacking
motor is introduced. A physical model of the new type of
place due to the inherent qualities of the new motor. According
to the developed new motor’s topology, an experimental model
repulsion-induction motor was built and the results of some
has been built and the results of some experimental experimental investigations are given. The physical model
investigations are given. was built with components from the current induction motor
production and was designed to demonstrate the operating
Keywords— rotating electrical machines, squirrel cage single- principle of the new electric motor topology and not to gain
phase induction motors, repulsion electric motors some competitiveness results with other electric motors. With
PSIM software, a simulation circuit model of the brushless
I. INTRODUCTION
repulsion-induction motor was realized and speed and current
In many industrial activities, like rural manufacturing, staring characteristics, for various favourable circuit
mining, oil and natural gas, electric utilities rely on single- parameter values of the model, were investigated.
phase line to deliver power to customers. Often, the cost of
three-phase line extension in these areas is cost prohibitive. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section II
For those activities, with limited access to three-phase provide an overview of existing high-power single-phase
infrastructure, high-power single-phase motors cold be a induction motors. Sections III introduces the A.C. brushless
cost-effective solution to drive the large horsepower outputs, commutator and the repulsion-induction motor with a
to 100 kW, from 230 V or 460 V single-phase lines. topology based on this commutator. Section IV describe the
physical model which was built for the brushless repulsion-
The first electric motor that could be considered for the induction motor and give some experimental results obtained
above-mentioned applications is the single-phase induction with this model. Section V looks at circuit simulation models
motor due to its high reliability and low manufacturing cost. realized in PSIM for the brushless repulsion-induction motor
But, unfortunately, this electric motor has a big drawback – no for various set of motor parameters. Finally, conclusions are
inherent starting torque, because it develops a stationary and given in Section VI.
not a revolving magnetic field. Different solutions are
currently being used to start the single-phase induction II. THE STATE OF ART
motors: reluctance start, shaded pole start, split phase resistor
or capacitor start, and repulsion start. For technological A. Induction motor with single-phase supply
reasons, reluctance start is used for motors with powers of A low-cost large induction motor drive for about 75 kW,
several watts, split phase resistor start is used for motors with with single-phase supply, was realized by Professor O. J. M.
powers of several tens of watts, shaded pole start is used for Smith for rural pumps [1-3]. This electric drive system uses a
motors with powers of several hundred watts, split phase squirrel cage three-phase induction motor and circuits with
capacitor start and repulsion start are used for motors with capacitors which connect the motor windings to single-phase
powers of several kilowatts. Repulsion start could be used in supply, as is shown in Fig. 1. Several investigations of the
developing high power single-phase induction motors, but it Smith connections have been carried out. These investigations
has the drawback to use a brushes commutator and a have demonstrated that motors with single-phase connections
complicate mechanism to drive this commutator during can have the same efficiency and a high-power factor when
starting process. Therefore, although the single-phase the motors are fed by a three-phase power supply. It has also
induction motor is cheap and reliable, because the been shown that Smith connections have approximately
technological limitations of the starting procedures, it cannot symmetrical winding currents [4] – [14].

978-1-5386-9350-6/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE 1447


a) b)
Fig. 2 Repulsion-start-induction-run motor (a) and Repulsion-induction
a) b) motor (b).
Fig.1 Smith connection with three capacitors (a) and SEMIHEX Smith 3) Repulsion-induction motor: referred, also, as squirrel
connection with two capacitors.
cage repulsion motor, consists of: (a) stator winding, (b) two
rotor windings: one usual D.C. winding connected to the
B. Written pole motor
commutator and the other squirrel cage, and (c) a short-
In the 1990’s, with support from the Electric Power circuited set of two brushes. It works on the combined
Research Institute (EPRI), the Precise Power Corporation of principle of repulsion and induction and, hence, it combines
Bradenton, Florida, developed a new concept in electric the desirable starting characteristics of repulsion motor and
motors called the Written Pole electric motor. This new motor constant speed characteristics of an induction motor. The
type allows the design of single-phase motors up to 75 kW as biggest advantage in such type of motors is that they don’t
compared to conventional single-phase motors, which are need a separate centrifugal short-circuit system as in
generally limited to units of 9 kW and smaller. The Written- Repulsion-start Induction-run motors. As soon as the motor
Pole motor, uses an innovative approach of controlling the is started, the commutator winding supplies most of the
magnetic field of the motor. The Written-Po1e machine torque. But during normal running condition, the squirrel
technology consists of a rotor design that has a layer of cage winding supplies most of the torque.
magnetic material that can be changed magnetically to any
desired pole pattern while the machine is operating. The III. THE A.C. BRUSHLESS COMMUTATOR AND THE NEW
result is a motor that has starting current requirements of only REPULSION-INDUCTION MOTOR TYPE
about twice the normal running current and, as an added Fig. 3 shown Professor Elihu Thomson’s well-known
benefit, the motors have efficiencies of 90% or better repulsion motor. This motor uses D.C. brush commutator to
compared to conventional motors, which have efficiencies of realize a pseudo-stationary coil, that is, a coil whose axis is
around 85%. Written-Pole single-phase electric motors are permanently in the same direction, given by the direction of
the most energy efficient single-phase motors available in the the brushes. When this pseudo-stationary rotor’s coil is
market, with operating efficiencies comparable to those of powered, it will produce a stationary magnetic flux which can
energy-efficient three-phase induction motors. The interest of interact with a stator’s magnetic flux to develop an electro-
these motors is growing rapidly in rural areas of North and mechanical torque if the angle between the two magnetic
South America where large motors are needed for irrigation fluxes are nonzero.
and pumping operations, crop processing, grain drying and
other similar needs, and where only single-phase electricity Fig. 4 shown the proposed brushless replica to the plain
is available. [15] – [19]. repulsion motor. The magnetic core’s topology of the new
repulsion motor is derived from the magnetic core’s topology
C. Hybrid repulsion-induction motors of the single-phase squirrel cage induction motor, in which
Repulsion type motors, which can be associate with the stator’s magnetic core was splitted into two parts. On the
single-phase induction motors, can been built for more as 100 left stator’s magnetic core is disposed the energizing coil, and
kW. These electric motors can be divided into several distinct on the right stator’s magnetic core is disposed a short-
categories: circuited coil. The directions of the axes of the two stator’s
1) Plain repulsion motor: It consists of: (a) one stator coils make an angle between them.
winding, (b) one rotor which is wound like a D.C. armature,
(c) a classical commutator, and (d) a set of brushes, which are
short-circuited and remain in contact with the commutator at
all times. It operates continuously on the ‘repulsion’
principle.
2) Repulsion-start-induction-run motor: This motor starts
as a plain repulsion motor, but normally runs as an induction
motor. It consists of: (a) one stator winding, (b) one rotor
which is similar to the wire-wound D.C. armature, (c) a
classical D.C. commutator, and (d) a centrifugal mechanism
which short-circuits the commutator bars all the way round
(with the help of a short-circuiting necklace) when the motor
has reached nearly 75 per cent of full speed. Fig. 3 The plain repulsion motor

1448
The main advantages of the self-starting single-phase
induction motor shown in Fig. 5, in comparison with others
single-phase induction motors could the following: a) the
possibility to be built for high powers, more as 100 kW; b) a
high reliability, in comparison with all types of brush
commutator repulsion starting induction motors and with
single-phase capacitor motors; c) simply changing the
direction of rotation by inverting the W3 winding terminals.
Also, the motors have low starting inrush, and rugged design.
The motors do not have the harmonic distortion issues
associated with VFDs and phase converters.
IV. THE PHYSICAL MODEL OF THE SELF-STARTING
BRUSHLESS REPULSION-INDUCTION MOTOR
Fig. 4 The proposed brushless replica to the plain repulsion motor In order to demonstrate the viability of the new topology
proposed in Fig. 5, an appropriate squirrel cage self starting
The energizing coil induces a magnetic flux in the squirrel sigle-phase induction motor was build using available
cage, magnetic flux whose direction is imposed by the common components of usual induction motors. An
inductor flux, and therefore it does not change when the explanatory longitudinal section of this motor is given in Fig.
squirrel cage rotates. In this way, the left side of the motor of 6 and the physical model of stator and rotor of new repulsion-
Fig. 4 accomplishes the role of a commutator, namely, to induction are shown in Fig. 7. The results of the first
create the conditions for producing a stationary magnetic experimental investigations are given in Fig. 8 and in Fig. 9.
flux. Electrical currents of the squirrel cage will carry the
induced magnetic flux under the right stator’s magnetic core.
Here, this carried flux will interact with the induced magnetic
flux of the short-circuited coil disposed on the stator. This
interaction is similarly with the magnetic fluxes’ interaction
of the plain repulsion motor. In this way, the motor of Fig. 4
accomplishes the role of an inverted construction of the plain
repulsion motor – a motor which has a pseudo-stationary
energizing coil and a stationary short-circuited coil.
It is very important to note that in the squirrel cage
brushless repulsion motor of Fig. 4, first half of the motor is
used to perform the commutator task and second half is used
to realize the electromechanical energy conversion. For a Fig. 6 A longitudinal section of the new repulsion-induction motor
higher motor power density, it would be good as the two
halves of the motor to participate in both commutator task
and in the energy conversion process.
In Fig. 5 is proposed a new topology of the squirrel cage
single-phase induction motor with assisted starting realized
by brushless repulsion motors, in which the two halves of the
motor participate in both commutator task and in the energy
conversion process. The development of the starting torque
for the motor with the topology shown in Fig. 5, can be
explained using the brushless repulsion motor topology
shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 7 The new repulsion-induction motor main components

Fig. 5 A new topology of the squirrel cage repulsion-induction motor Fig. 8 Speed-torque characteristic

1449
Efficiency characteristic
42

40

38

36

34

32

30

28

26
60 80 100 120 140 160 180
P2 (W)
Fig. 9 Efficiency characteristic

V. CIRCUIT SIMULATION MODELS FOR THE SELF-STARTING


BRUSHLESS REPULSION-INDUCTION MOTOR Fig. 14 Speed and current starting characteristics for U = 6 kV,
T = 175 Nm, Rs = 0.2, Ls = 1mH, Rr = 0.3, Lr = 0.4mH, Lm = 40 mH,
The circuit model of the proposed self-starting repulsion- J = 0.04 kgm2.
induction motor from Fig. 5 is shown in Fig. 10. The
simulation for this circuit model was made with PSIM As it is shown from simulation results, the inrush current
software using two poles wound rotor induction machine as it of the proposed motor is very close to permanent current.
is shown in Fig. 11. Simulations have been made, for several Also, speed has ripples dependent of the load torque values,
parameters’ combinations, to illustrate the potential of the new which have to be analysed in a future work.
electric motor topology given in Fig. 5. The results of some
VI. CONCLUSIONS
simulations are given in Figs. 12, 13 and 14.
The brushless single-phase repulsion-induction motor,
proposed in this paper, with topology shown in Fig. 5, could
be used in areas where only single-phase power is available to
provide a large horsepower as Smith drive systems or Written
pole motors. It can be built for high power and its structure is
similar to that of induction motors and can be manufactured
with the usual technologies. It does not require VFDs or phase
converters and produce no harmonic distortion. This
eliminates the need for three-phase line extension, replaces
costly diesel, propane and natural gas generators.
The physical model (Fig. 7) was built with components
from the current induction motor production and was designed
to demonstrate the operating principle of the new electric
motor topology and not to gain some competitiveness results
with other electric motors. Also, the PSIM circuit simulations
have been made for several favourable circuit parameter
Fig. 12 Speed and current starting characteristics for U = 400 V, T = 0 values as a first investigations of the potential performances
Nm, Rs = Rr = 0.18 , Ls = Lr = 0.60mH, Lm = 40mH, J = 0.03 kgm2. of the proposed new topology for repulsion-induction hybrid
electric motor. More simulations and experimental
investigations are in progress.
REFERENCES
[1] O. J. M. Smith,” Three-phase induction motor with single-phase
supply”, U. S. Patent No. 4,792,740, issued 20 December 1988.
[2] O. J. M. Smith, ”Three-phase motor operated from a single-phase
supply and phase converter”, U. S. Patent No. 5,545,965 issued 13
August 1996.
[3] O. J. M. Smith, “Large low-cost single-phase SEMIHEXTH motors,”
IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 1353–1358, Dec.
1999.
[4] T. F. Chan and L. L. Lai, “Single-phase operation of a three-phase
induction motor with the Smith connection,” in Proc. IEEE Power Eng.
Soc. Summer Meeting, 2000, vol. 4, pp. 2453–2458.
[5] T. F. Chan, and L. L. Lai, “Steady-state analysis of a three-phase
induction motor with the Smith connection,” IEEE Power Eng. Rev.,
Fig. 13 Speed and current starting characteristics for U = 6 kV, vol.20, no.10, pp. 45–46, Oct. 2000.
T = 22 Nm, Rs = 0.2 , Ls = 1mH, Rr = 0.3,
Lr = 0.4mH, Lm = 40 mH, J = 0.04 kgm2.

1450
[6] T. F. Chan and L. L. Lai, “Single-phase operation of a three-phase Motor Fed by a Single-Phase Power Supply”, IEEE Transactions on
induction generator with Smith connection,” IEEE Trans. Energy Energy Conversion, vol. 29, no. 2, June 2014, pp. 269-277.
Convers., vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 47–54, Mar. 2002. [14] D. Spirov, „The Operation of a Three-Phase Induction Motor in Single-
[7] D. Fu, X. Wang, P. Ji, and R. Tang, “Experimental research of a novel Phase Power Supply under Smith's Scheme”, The 20th International
efficient single-phase induction motor,” in Proc. 6th Int. Conf. Elect. Symposium on Electrical Apparatus and Technologies (SIELA),
Mach. Syst., 2003, vol. 1, pp. 1–3. Bourgas, Bulgaria, 3-6 June, 2018.
[8] P. Vladimirov, D. Petrov, St. Genchev and D. Spirov, „Operation of a [15] ***” Single-Phase Written-Pole Motor, High Horse Power, Efficient
three-phase induction motor in single-phase power supply under Motor Opens up Rural Market to Electric Utilities”, EPRI Broschure
Smith's scheme.” Annals of Technical University – Varna, 2004, pp. BR-106507, 1996.
569-576. (in Bulgarian) [16] R. Lawrence,” Applications and Markets for Written-Pole Single-
[9] T. F. Chan, L. L. Lai, and L. T. Yan, “A coupled circuit and field Phase Motors to 100 Horse Power”, Proceedings of Wescon’96
analysis of a three-phase induction motor with the Smith connection,” Conference, Anaheim, CA, October, 1996, pp. 142-148.
IEEE Trans. Magnetics, vol. 42, no. 4, pp. 1315–1318, Apr. 2006. [17] S. Hoffman, B. Banerjee and M. Samory, „Written-Pole Revolution”,
[10] T. F. Chan, L. L. Lai, and L. T. Yan, “Starting performance of a three- IEEE Power Engineering Review, December 1997, pp. 6-9.
phase induction motor with the Smith connection on a single-phase [18] R. Morash, J. Roesel, and D. Friesen,” Written-Pole Motor has Very
supply,” presented at the IEEE 12th Biennial Conf., Electromagnetic Low Starting Current and Very High Efficiency”, Proceedings of
Field Computation, Miami, FL, USA, 2006. ICEM 2000, Espoo, Finland, 28-30 August, 2000, pp. 1327-1330
[11] H. Zhong, X. Wang, X. Leng, and D. Wang, “Steady-state performance [19] H. Zabet Khosousi and M. Mirsalim, „Dynamic Modeling of a 20-
analysis of three-phase induction motor with SEMIHEX connection,” Horsepower Single-Phase Written Pole Motor”, IEEE Transactions on
in Proc. IEEE 2nd Conf. Ind. Electron. Appl., 2007, pp. 269–272. Magnetics, vol. 40, no. 4, July 2004, pp. 1901-1904.
[12] L. Wendi, L. Longfu, L. Derong, and D. Jianguo, “Starting process [20] J. Zeng, Z. Luo and W. Yang, “Simulation and Modeling of Single-
simulation of Smith single-phase capacitance motor,” in Proc. Int. Phase Written Pole Motor”, ICITEE’18 Proceedings of the Int. Conf.
Conf. Electron., Commun., Control, 2011, pp. 1040–1043. on Information Technology and Electrical Engineering, Xiamen,
[13] A. Gonzalez, C. Hernandez, and M. A. Arjona, “A Novel High- Fujian, China, December, 07-08, 2018.
Efficiency Parallel-Winding Connection for a Three-Phase Induction

1451

You might also like