You are on page 1of 5

Original Research Ar cle Singh M et al

STUDY OF PERIPHERAL BLOOD SMEAR FINDINGS IN


PATIENTS OF ANEMIA AND TO COMPARE IT WITH
AUTOMATED HEMATOLOGY ANALYZER GENERATED
RED CELL PARAMETERS
1* 2 3 4
Singh M
, Kafle SU , Shaukin SH , Pokhrel S

Affilia on ABSTRACT
1. Assistant Professor, Department of Pathology, Birat Medical Introduc on
College and teaching Hospital Anemia is one of the common medical condi ons prevalent
2. Professor, Department of Pathology, Birat Medical College and in our society. The correct categoriza on of varying types of
teaching Hospital anemia is essen al for therapeu c purposes. Various
3. Lecturer, Department of Pathology, Birat Medical College and laboratory tests are done to find out its underlying cause,
teaching Hospital but peripheral blood smear (PBS) study of red blood cells
4. Lecturer, Department of Physiology, Birat Medical College and (RBCs) morphology is important along with study of red
teaching Hospital blood cell indices in the classifica on of anemia.

Objec ves
ARTICLE INFO
This study was done to evaluate RBC morphology on
Received : 5 October, 2020 peripheral blood smear examina on in pa ents of anemia
Accepted : 26 November, 2020 and to compare these findings with cell counter generated
Published : 22 December, 2020 red blood cells indices comprising of Mean Corpuscular Volume
(MCV), Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin Concentra on
© Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first (MCHC) and Mean Corpuscular Hemoglobin (MCH).
publica on with the work simultaneously licensed under
Crea ve Commons A ribu on License CC - BY 4.0 that allows
others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the Methodology
work's authorship and ini al publica on in this journal. Red blood cell morphology on peripheral blood smear was
studied in 350 pa ents of anemia irrespec ve of age and
gender received under six months dura on from January to
June, 2019 and findings were compared with cell counter
generated red cell parameters generated by automated
hematology analyzer.

Result
Most common anemia seen on smear examina on was
ORA 213 microcy c hypochromic anemia which accounted for 210
(60%) cases followed by dimorphic anemia in 73 (20.86%)
DOI: h ps://doi.org/10.3126/bjhs.v5i3.33704 cases. Most of the pa ents were female, comprising of 227
(64.85%) cases. Highest numbers of pa ents were in the age
group of 21-30 years (20.30%). Sensi vity of MCV, MCHC
and MCH was 78%, 14% and 80% respec vely in detec on
* Corresponding Author of microcy c hypochromic anemia.The sensi vity of MCV
Dr. Mrinalini Singh and MCH was found to be 100 % in detec on of macrocy c
Assistant Professor anemia. Sensi vity of MCHC was only 10% for detec on of
Department of Pathology macrocy c anemia. The sensi vity of MCV, MCHC and MCH
Birat Medical College & Teaching Hospital, Nepal was 78%, 100% and 67% respec vely in detec on of
Email ID: sdrmrinalini@gmail.com normocy c normochromic anemia.
ORCID ID: h ps://orcid.org/0000-0001-5482-0192
Conclusion
The peripheral blood smear examina on should always be
Cita on
interpreted along with the red blood cell indices generated by
Singh M, Kafle SU, Shaukin SH, Pokhrel S. Study of Peripheral Blood
an automated analyzer in order to classify various types of anemia.
Smear Findings in Pa ents of Anemia and to Compare it with
Automated Hematology Analyzer Generated Red Cell Parameters. BJHS
2020;5(3)13. 1231-1235. KEYWORDS
Anemia, peripheral blood smear, RBC morphology
Birat Journal of Health Sciences
1231 Vol.5/No.3/Issue 13/Sept.-Dec., 2020 ISSN: 2542-2758 (Print) 2542-2804 (Online)
Original Research Ar cle Singh M et al

INTRODUCTION
Teaching Hospital (BMCTH), Morang, Nepal of pa ents who
Anemia is a common medical problem faced by Nepalese
were diagnosed anemic on hemoglobin es ma on were
popula on which is o en ignored. Anemia leads to ssue
studied irrespec ve of age and sex. Taking all asep c
hypoxia due to reduced oxygen-carrying capacity of the
blood. In anemic pa ents red blood cell mass is decreased. precau ons blood samples were collected from the
Anemia affects 1.62 billion people worldwide which peripheral veins in an an coagulant vial in the right
correspond to 24.8% of the world popula on. The preschool propor on. Ethylene diamine tetra-ace c Acid (EDTA) was
age group children show high prevalence of anemia (47.4%) the an coagulant used. Both Peripheral smear and CBC by
1 the automated analyzer were analyzed within 2 to 3 hours of
followed by pregnant women (41.8%).
The most common cause of anemia is nutri onal deficiency blood collec on because delay in prepara on of blood
of iron, vitamin B12 or folic acid. But many clinical condi ons smear may lead to ar factual changes in WBC, RBC and
can also lead to anemia like decreased produc on of RBCs in pseudo-thrombocytopenia may occur due to forma on of
6
disease causing bone marrow failure and increased platelet aggregates. Peripheral blood smear slides of
destruc on of RBCs in clinical condi ons leading to anemia were studied for the morphological abnormali es in
hemolysis. Anemia also could be mul factorial in origin. So, the red blood cells associated with different types of anemia
every pa ent of anemia should be inves gated to find out and the findings were noted down.
the cause and the type for proper medical treatment. By studying the hemoglobin level on the automated analyzer
However there is lack of consistency in the protocols for the criteria for defining anemia was undertaken according to
guidelines as given by the World Health Organiza on
proper screening for anemia. 2-4
7 Anemia was diagnosed in Children (6 - 59 months of
(WHO).
The commonest laboratory test for diagnosis of anemia is age) with Hemoglobin ( Hb ) < 11gm/dl , Children (5 - 11
hemoglobin es ma on. In clinical prac ce, anemia is years of age) with Hb< 11.5gm/dl, Children (12-14 years of
diagnosed by reduced hemoglobin concentra on of the
age) with Hb< 12gm/dl, Non-pregnant women (15 years of
blood below the normal range and reduced hematocrit level age and above) with Hb< 12gm/dl, Pregnant women with
5
(the ra o of packed red cells to total blood volume). Hb<11gm /dl and Men (15 years of age and above) with Hb<
Peripheral blood smear (PBS) examina on is a cheap and 13gm/dl .
quick method for categorizing different types of anemias by The morphological changes in the red blood cells like
studying the RBCs morphology. Smear examina on can also hypochromia, microcytosis, macrocytosis, polychromatophilia,
iden fy abnormal, atypical WBCs, any abnormality in elliptocytosis, target cell changes, tear drop changes,
platelets and can give an assump on of total WBCs count fragmented - red blood cell change, any red blood cell
and platelet counts. Peripheral blood smear examina on in inclusion bodies or presence of any nucleated red blood cell
addi on with complete blood count (CBC) by the automated
were observed by microscopic examina on. The PBS
hematology analyzers can provide a more accurate report
reported by one of the pathologists was also counter
on categorizing different types of anemia. Smear examina on checked by another pathologist involved in this research
also helps in cross checking the results of RBCs indices work. These findings were correlated with the findings
generated by the analyzer. Moreover, the pa ent doesn't observed by the automated analyzer (Benesphera H33s).
need to give a separate blood sample for smear examina on.
Differen al values of MCV between 80fl and 100fl were
The smear slides are immediately made from the blood
categorized as normocy c normochromic. Values of MCV
sample collected for CBC. The reports are also dispatched on <80fl and >100fl were categorized as microcy c hypochromic
the same day within a few hours a er collec on. So, the and macrocy c normochromic respec vely. Normal value
technique is simple and cheap. Both the pa ent, as well as, for MCH was considered as 29±2 picogram, values below
the trea ng physician does not need to wait a long for the
and above this were categorized as microcy c and
reports. macrocy c anemia respec vely. Similarly normal value for
Therefore, the study was undertaken to study the morphological
MCHCis 34 ± 2 g/dl. Values below and above this were
findings of the red blood cells (RBCs) in peripheral blood categorized as microcy c and macrocy c anemia respec vely.
smear in order to categorize different types of anemia and The data were entered in Microso excel sheet and were
to compare it with RBC indices measured with an
analyzed in terms of sensi vity and age distribu on.
automated hematology analyzer.
RESULTS
METHODOLOGY
The peripheral blood smear and RBCs indices of 350 pa ents
This prospec ve study was conducted from January to June
of anemia were analyzed and correlated. The age group of
2019 in the Department of Pathology, Birat Medical College
pa ents ranged from 6 months to 90 years. Highest number
& Teaching Hospital (BMCTH), Morang, Nepal a er the
of the pa ents were in the age group 21-30 years (20.30%)
approval obtained from the Ins tu onal Review
followed by 31-40 years (15.71%). Out of 350 pa ents, 227
Commi ee. Peripheral smear examina on of the blood
(64.85%) were female and 123(35.16%) were male. (Table 1)
samples received in laboratory Birat Medical College &
Birat Journal of Health Sciences
ISSN: 2542-2758 (Print) 2542-2804 (Online) 1232
Vol.5/No.3/Issue 13/Sept.-Dec., 2020
Original Research Ar cle Singh M et al

Table 1: Age distribu on


Out of 350 cases of anemia on peripheral blood smear
examina on, 210 (60%) cases showed microcy c
hypochromic anemia, followed by dimorphic, normocy c
normochromic, macrocy c and hemoly c anemia
respec vely. (Table 2)

Table 2: Categoriza on of anemia on peripheral


smear examina on

Most common anemia in our study on smear examina on


was microcy c hypochromic anemia(Figure 1) and the least
common anemia observed was hemoly c anemia (Figure 2).

Among 210 cases of microcy c hypochromic anemia on PBS,


a total of 164 cases revealed a similar picture on a cell
counter with MCV value <80fl. Rest, all 46 cases on the cell
counter showed normal MCV value sugges ng normocy c
normochromic anemia. None of the cases of microcy c
hypochromic anemia on the cell counter showed high MCV
value. Similarly, the number of cases of dimorphic and other
anemias values correla ng with cell counter are demonstrated
in the Table 3:
Table 3: Comparison of findings of peripheral blood smear
examina on and cell counter generated parameters

Figure 1 : Peripheral blood smear of microcy c hypochromic


anemia showing microcytes, teardrop cells and elliptocytes.

Correla ng with peripheral blood smear examina on, the


sensi vity of MCV was 78%, MCHC was 14% and of MCH was
80% in detec on of microcy c hypochromic anemia.The
sensi vity of MCV and MCH was found to be 100 % in
detec on of macrocy c anemia. Sensi vity of MCHC was
only 10% for detec on of macrocy c anemia. The sensi vity
of MCV, MCHC and MCH was 78%, 100% and 67 %
Figure 2: Peripheral blood smear of hemoly c anemia respec vely in detec on of normocy c normochromic
showing microcytes, target cells, polychromatophils, anemia. The sensi vity of MCV, MCH was 60% each and
acanthocytes and fragmented red blood cells. MCHC was found to be 0% in detec on of hemoly c anemia
respec vely. (Table 4)

1233 Birat Journal of Health Sciences


Vol.5/No.3/Issue 13/Sept.-Dec., 2020 ISSN: 2542-2758 (Print) 2542-2804 (Online)
Original Research Ar cle Singh M et al

Table 4: Comparison of findings of Peripheral Smear


examina on and sensi vity on cell counter generated dimorphic anemia, normal MCH value in all cases and
parameters normal MCHC value in 39.72% cases. This anemia shows a
mixed deficiency of both iron and vitamin B12. RBCs
morphology in smear reveals both microcy c and
macrocy c pictures. Therefore in such cases peripheral
blood smear examina on becomes very important. Study
done by Deepthi A et al showed that red blood cell
parameters are not reliable for combined deficiencies of
iron and folic acid or vitamin B12. Because here one type of
deficiency may be dominant and it may mask the
parameters of other deficiency. 17
Constan no et al have suggested that we can diagnose
dimorphic anemia on a cell counter by correla ng red cell
parameters with red blood cell distribu on width and
histogram. 18 However this correla on was not the aim of our
DISCUSSION study and was not done. In dimorphic anemia serum assays
In this study we have enrolled all age groups diagnosed as of vitamin B12 or folate or iron is more reliable to confirm
the cause and establish the diagnosis.
anemia on hemoglobin es ma on. It was seen that, out of
350 cases, the majority of cases 171 (48.85%) fall in the Normocy c anemia is anemia with low hemoglobin and
hematocrit range but MCV, MCH and MCHC are in the
adult age group of 21 to 50 years. Among them 227 (64.86%)
were female pa ents and 123 were male (35.14%). These normal range. We found the sensi vity of MCV, MCHC and
results were in concordance with the studies conducted by MCH as 78%, 100% and 67 % respec vely in detec on of
8,9 normocy c normochromic anemia. Normocy c
Kumar et al and Japheth et al. Among female pa ents the
majority fall in the reproduc ve age group. Blood loss normochromic anemias are seen commonly in pa ents who
during menstrual cycle and high nutrient demands during suffer from chronic infec ons or certain systemic disorders.
pregnancy and lacta on can lead to nutri onal anemia The prevalence of normocy c normochromic anemia varies
in different studies done in different parts of the world.
among women in reproduc ve age group.
The most common morphological type of anemia on smear Alwar et al 19 found normocy c normochromic anemia as
20

examina on was microcy c hypochromic anemia predominant finding comprising 66% and Rao et al found
comprising 210 (60%) of all cases. This was almost similar to 62%cases as normocy c anemia. Study done in Nepal by
Mishra et al found prevalence of normocy c normochromic
study done by Verma et al, Kumari et al, Mishra et al and 21

Jain A et al.
10-13
They also found microcy c hypochromic anemia as 22%. We found a li le less cases of normocy c
anemia as the commonest anemia comprising of 55.4%, anemia comprising of 14.85% . Study done by American
53.33% , 47% and 40% respec vely. family Physician found that if we diagnose earlier even
classic cause of any type of anemia either macrocy c or
As it is known that MCV denotes the volume of the microcy c or hemoly c can show features of normocy c
“average” red blood cell (RBC) in a sample and MCH is the 22

amount of hemoglobin per red blood cell. MCH value is anemia. The reason for the above men oned studies
showing higher percentage of normocy c normochromic
affected by both microcytosis and hypochromia. A decrease
in value of MCH is associated with microcy c anemia and an anemia could be that in these studies anemia cases might
have been diagnosed earlier.
increase in value of MCH is associated with macrocy c
14 In megaloblas c anemia there is defec ve nuclear
anemia. Out of 210 cases which showed microcy c
hypochromic anemia on smear examina on, value of MCV matura on which leads to forma on of macroovalocytes.
and MCH were 78% and 80% sensi ve respec vely. So, in such cases MCH and MCV are increased, but MCHC
may remain normal. In this study we have noted that in
However MCH and MCV were seen normal in many other 91.2% cases of anemiaMCHC value was normal. As we know
cases. The reason for this could be that the microcytosis is that the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentra on
seen on the smear much earlier than decrease in red blood
indices value. But none of our cases revealed a falsely (MCHC) measures the average amount of hemoglobin in the
RBCs. It is measured by the hemogram analyzer. MCHC can
elevated MCV or MCH value in cases of microcy c anemia.
15 show normal value even if hemoglobin is low due to a
Kafle S et al found that out of 100 peripheral smears of calcula on ar fact, so MCHC values are not sensi ve for
pa ents with microcy c, hypochromic anemia 49% were of diagnos c purposes. It is difficult to detect types of anemia
iron deficiency anemia. Similarly another study conducted
by correla ng with MCHC value. In a person suffering from a
by Al alimi et al showed that the overall prevalence of iron
16 combina on of two or more types of anemia the MCHC
deficiency anemia was 30.4%. In our study also the value may remain normal. A erblood transfusion the MCHC
majority of anemia cases were of microcy c type. Iron value will reflect a person's own MCHC value along with the
deficiency is the main cause of anemia; so an iron profile MCHC value of the transfused RBCs. Studies have shown
should be done in pa ents of microcy c anemia to confirm that MCHC values are mainly used for diagnos c purposes in
iron deficiency anemia. Red blood cell indices values are not 23-24

helpful in diagnosis of dimorphic anemia. It may remain congenital disorders like Hereditary Spherocytosis. In this
study we did not receive any case of Hereditary Spherocytosis
normal. We found normal MCV value in 43% cases of
Birat Journal of Health Sciences
ISSN: 2542-2758 (Print) 2542-2804 (Online) 1234
Vol.5/No.3/Issue 13/Sept.-Dec., 2020
Original Research Ar cle Singh M et al

and most of the cases showed normal value. We had only


five cases which showed features of hemolysis on smear. RECOMMENDATIONS
The reason for such low numbers could be that we did not If red cell distribu on width is also studied along with red
study specific tests like re culocyte count, enzyme assay and blood cell indices, it would be more helpful especially in
hemoglobin electrophoresis for confirma on and cases of dimorphic anemia.
categoriza on of hemolysis.
We therefore found that study of anemia is never complete without the LIMITATION OF THE STUDY
careful examina on of a well-prepared peripheral blood We have not correlated the findings of anemia with other
smear which can reveal features of hypochromia in RBCs biochemical parameters like serum iron studies in iron
even before it is observed on cell counter values. deficiency anemia, vitamin B-12 studies in megaloblas c
anemia and re culocyte count and hemoglobin
CONCLUSION electrophoresis in hemoly c anemia.
The most common anemia on peripheral blood smear was
microcy c hypochromic anemia which correlated well with ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
automated cell counter generated parameters. In cases of The authors would like to thank the Ins tu onal Review
combined deficiency anemia, peripheral blood smear Commi ee (IRC) of BMCTH, Morang, Nepal for giving
examina on is mandatory as cell counter parameters only permission for this study and all the laboratory staffs for
showed features of the most severe types of anemia among their contribu ons throughout the data collec on.
them, the other deficiency remains hidden. This study thus
showed that peripheral blood smear examina on should be CONFLICT OF INTEREST
considered along with automated cell counter as a reliable
None
method to categorize anemia.

REFERENCES
1. World Health Organiza on.(2008). Worldwide prevalence of anaemia
1993-2005 : WHO global database on anaemia. / Edited by Bruno de 13. Aseem Jain, Arvind Bhake1, MalvikaTripathi Co-Rela ve Study on
Benoist, Erin McLean, Ines Egli and Mary Cogswell. World Health Peripheral Blood Smears in Anemia with Automated Cell Counter
Organiza on.h ps://apps.who.int/iris/handle/ 10665/ 43894 Generated Red Cell Parameters. IOSR Journal of Dental and Medical
2. Lin, T.F., Huang, J.N. & Cash, H.L. Inves ga on of Pediatric Anemia in the Sciences Volume 17, Issue 3 Ver.16 March. (2018), PP 80-83 Corpus ID:
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands.Matern Child Health J 202607385
23, 416-421 (2019). DOI.org/10.1007/s10995-018-02713-0 14. Jolobe OM. Mean corpuscular haemoglobin, referenced and
3. Dhabangi, A., Idro, R., John, C.C. et al. Risk factors for recurrent severe anemia resurrected. Journal of Clinical Pathology. 2011; 64(9):833-834
among previously transfused children in Uganda: an age-matched case - 15. Kafle S, Lakhey M E ological study of microcy c hypochromic anemia
control study. BMC Pediatr 19, 27 (2019).DOI.org/10.1186/s12887-019-1398-6 Journal of Pathology of Nepal (2016) Vol. 6, 994-997
4. Karakochuk CD, Hess SY, Moorthy D, et al. Measurement and 16. Abdullah Ahmed Al-alimi, Salem Bashanfer, and Mohammed
interpreta on of hemoglobin concentra on in clinical and field se AbdoMorish Anemia Prevalence of Iron Deficiency Anemia among
ngs: a narra ve review. Annals of the New York Academy of University Students in Hodeida Province, Yemen Volume 2018, Ar cle ID
Sciences. 2019 Aug;1450(1):126-146. DOI: 10.1111/nyas.14003. 4157876, 7 pages
5. Kumar V, Abbas AK, Fausto N, Aster JC. Robbins and Cotran Pathologic Basis of 17. Deepthi. A1, CSBR Prasad2, Raghavendra Prasad B. N.3Study of
Disease. 8th ed. Ch. 14. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders Elsevier; 2010. dimorphic anemia in adults with reference to basic e ology DOI:
h ps://www.elsevier.com/books/robbins-and-cotran-pathologic- 10.18231/2394-6792.2018.0012.
basis-of-disease-professional-edi on/ kumar/ 978-1-4377-0792-2
18. Benie T Constan no.The Red Cell Histogram and The Dimorphic Red
6. Bain BJ.Diagnosis from the blood Smear. N Engl J Med. 2005;353: Cell Popula on Laboratory Medicine, Volume 42, Issue 5, May 2011,
498-507. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMra043442 Pages 300-308. h ps://doi.org/10.1309/LMF1UY85HEKBMIWO
7. WHO. Haemoglobin concentra ons for the diagnosis of anaemia and 19. VanamalaAlwar ,K. Reethi and KarunaRameshkumar Indian journal of
assessment of severity.Vitamin and Mineral Nutri on Informa on Hematology and blood transfusion Geriatric Anemia: An Indian
System. Geneva, World Health Organiza on, 2011 (WHO/NMH/ Perspec ve2013 June;29(2):126-127. file:///C:/Users/DELL/
NHD/MNM/ 11.1) (h p://www.who.int/vmnis/ indicators/ AppData/Local/Temp/4-4-12-484-2.pdf
haemoglobin.pdf, accessed [date]).
20. Bhasin A, Rao MY. Characteris cs of anemia in elderly: a hospital based
8. Kumar A,Kushwaha R, Gupta C, Singh US. An analy cal study on study in South India. Indian J Hematol Blood Transfus. 2011;21(1) : 26-32.
peripheral blood smears in anemia and correla on with cell counter doi: 10.1007/s12288-011-0056-4.doi: 10.1007/s12288-011-0056-4
generated red cell parameters. J Applhematol 2013; 4(4):137-144. DOI:
21 Satyendra Kumar Mishra, SurendraMarasini, Badri Kumar Gupta,
10.4103/1658-5127.127896
Krishna Kumar Agrawal, Narayan Gautam . Prevalence of Iron
9. Japeth E Mukaya, Henry Ddungu, francisSsali, Tim O’Shea, Mark A deficiency anemia in anemic pa ents: A hospital based study. Journal of
Crowther. Prevalence and morphological types of anaemia and Universal College of Medical Sciences (2018) Vol.06 No.02 Issue 18 h
hookworm infesta on in the medical emergency ward, Mulago ps://doi.org/10.3126/jucms.v6i2.22494
Hospital, Uganda. South African Medical Journal2009;99(12):881-886. h
22. American Family Physician, Normocy c Anemia, JOHN R. BRILL, M.D.,
p://www.samj.org.za/index.php/samj/ar cle/view/3375
and DENNIS J. BAUMGARDNER, M.D., University of Wisconsin Medical
10. Verma M, Chhatwal J, Kaur G. Prevalence of anemia among urban School, Milwaukee Clinical Campus, Milwaukee, Wisconsin2000 Nov
school children of Punjab. Indian Pediatr. 1998 Dec;35(12):1181-6. 15;62(10):2255-2263. h ps://www.aafp. org/afp/2000/ 1115/
PMID: 10216692. p2255.html
11. Kumari S, Choudhary AK, Negi G. Prevalence of anemia among the 23 Hillman R, Ault K, Leporrier M. Red blood cell disorders. In: Hillman R,
general popula on of Bihar, India. Ind Med Gaz. 2009;11:418-21. editor. Hematology in Clinical Prac ce. 5th ed. USA: McGraw-Hill
12. Mishra, S., Marasini, S., Gupta, B., Agrawal, K., &Gautam, N. (2018). Educa on; 2010. pp. 10-26. DOI: 978001766531
Prevalence of Iron Deficiency Anemia in Anemic Pa ents: A Hospital 24 Coyer SM. Anemia: Diagnosis and management. Journal of Pediatric
Based Study. Journal of Universal College of Medical Sciences, 6(2), 41- Health Care. 2005; 19(6):380-385 DOI: 10.1016/j.pedhc. 2005.07.014
45. DOI: 10.3126/jucms.v6i2.22494

Birat Journal of Health Sciences


1235 Vol.5/No.3/Issue 13/Sept.-Dec., 2020 ISSN: 2542-2758 (Print) 2542-2804 (Online)

You might also like