Professional Documents
Culture Documents
php/njmsr/index
NJMSR
Nepalese Journal of Management Science and Research
(NEPJOL INDEXED)
Published by
© Copyright:
Managing Editor
All rights reserved. No part of this publication
Dr. Karan Singh Thagunna in general may be reproduced or transmitted,
in any form or by any means, electronic,
Chief Editor mechanical, photocopying and recording or
any information storage system without the
Dr. Dev Raj Paneru prior permission of the Nepalese Journal of
Management Science and Research. Nepalese
Editor Journal of Management Science and Research
Dr. Subash Shrestha is published bi-annually and distributed by
Global College International. The statements or
Mr. Manoj Bhatta
opinions expressed in the journal are personal
Mr. Biraj Ghimire views of authors and do not represent the
official views of NJMSR editorial board or
Advisory Board Global College International.
Prof. Prem Raj Pant
Prof. Pushkar Bajracharya
Publisher:
Prof. Radheshyam Pradhan
Global College International
Dr. Khagendra P. Ojha
Mid-Baneshwor, Kathmandu, Nepal
Dr. Gangadhar Dahal Tel: 0977-01-4465186 / 4488410
Dr. Drona Lal Puri www.gci.edu.np, E-mail: njmsr@gci.edu.np
International Advisors
Principal Contact:
P Prof. Dr. Himachalam Dasaraju
Commonwealth Visiting Fellow UK Dr. Karan Singh Thagunna
Sri Venkateswara University, Tirupati, India. Nepalese Journal of Management Science and
Research
Prof. Dr. Sanjay Satapathy, Vice Chancellor,
Global College International
Kalahandi University Odisha, india
Mid-Baneshwor, Kathmandu, Nepal
Tel: 0977-01-4465186 / 4488410
Publishers Team www.gci.edu.np, E-mail: njmsr@gci.edu.np
Mr. Sushant Marasini
Subscription
Mr. Anurag Gaire
Mr. Navin Duwadi See the preliminary page for detail information
Mr. Surendra Joshi
Mr. Ram Prasad Nyaupane
Within the transformative design of education, a number of context relevant core and extra-curricular
engagements are integrated that become instrumental to building the academic system of GCI a very
interactive and experiential platform when research is automatized to enter as a key tool. This lends space
for the aspirant communities of scholars not only receive subject-based information passively from the
one way delivery drills but also it enables practitioners to create knowledge by undertaking plentiful
research projects and accomplishments on achieving learning excellence that is claimed to result in
education from action of innovation.
Following the research blended academic concept, GCI has embraced the policy to publish scientific
journal as a research tool integrated with the international conference participated by researchers, scholarly
practitioners, professors, business leaders, and intellectual persons of national and international repute
making dissemination of research knowledge relating to the diverse key areas of business management,
development and economics. NJMSR allows research minds to come together and make tangible
contribution in developing research practice as a medium to innovation. It lends space to the selected
researchers who get their projects and research papers published in scientifically generating knowledge
and add to management discourse. It is therefore, NJMSR contributes positively to expand intellectual
thought process that will be instrumental for learning to happen at the nexus of theory and practice.
Since the publication of NJMSR first in the year 2018, this manuscript has been endorsed as vital medium
not only in involving the academic communities in research but also pushing further education as a
whole to connect with processes that could develop new capabilities resulting from learning at the nexus
of theory and practice that the scholarly circles are required to substantiate in thinking and action both.
NJMSR includes for scientific publication systematically selected works that foster critical thinking,
creativity, academic and professional skill in practitioners. This publication has been very helpful to
connecting partner institutions, international academia, faculty and students together in research action
and dissemination of knowledge as constructive channels and tools to achieving academic excellence.
This third volume of NJMSR has selected twelve research papers contributed by the researchers
from national and international repute. The selected works are recognized for updating with research
knowledge validated by means of statistical analyses of empirical findings together with qualitatively
Keeping with the key premiers of a scientific publication, 4th volume of NJMSR has with priority
selected primary data based research papers. Selection of secondary sources of analysis based papers has
been decided in recognition to quality the papers have stood true to. There are mostly primary data based
papers in this volume together with a few ones based on their secondary analyses that too bring insights
on a diverse issues that fall in the concern of management discourse. In addition to the analytical aspects,
selection of each manuscript has been decided at the virtue of content, research design, and structure of
content organizing that essentially comply with the standard criteria of academic writing. The papers in
this issue as based on empirical research in addition to secondary sources analyses have touch upon and
communicate research insights that have been briefly highlighted from each work as given here:
In the paper titled; Fintech, Regtech and Suptech: Three Dimensional Approaches to Digital Finance,
G.V.Satya Sekhar explores some special dynamics regarding how Fintech, Regtech, and Suptech as three
stage approach to digital finance work and will become the better substitute of banks and other financial
systems. Based on review of secondary sources, this paper highlights: 1. the problems and obstacles faced
by corporate entities in digital finance and 2. the interdependency of three dimensions of technology viz.,
Fintech, Regtech and Suptech.
In his primary data based survey research; An Assessment of Personality-Type of Managers in Nepalese
Hotel Industries, Analysis, Kapil Khanal sheds light on the female managers generally with participative
style while governing people, whereas, male managers are argued to be induced toward an autocratic
or directive style in their daily performance. The study articulates extraversion dimension for having a
more significant effect than the openness dimension. It is reported to have negative effect on extrinsic job
satisfaction, while the openness dimension is reported for positive effect.
Using the three industry standard risk-adjusted returns parameters such as Sharpe ratio, Treynor Ratio
and Jensen’s alpha in their paper titled; COVID-19 The Global Pandemic: Learning & Take Out for
National Pension System (NPS), Linking the case pension, the authors Haladhara Sahu and Ritu Sapra
investigate the impacts of pandemic on fund manager’s risk returns profile. As such the study evaluates
the performance of selected NPS pension fund managers and has also explored the learning from such
unexpected crisis for the policy makers for future preparedness. On the basis of finding, it has suggested
some measures for long run sustainability of schemes for the national organizations such as NPS.
Using quantitative analytical methodological procedures, Dhundi Raj Bhattarai has investigated the Impact
of Capital and Deposit on Financial Performance of Commercial Banks in Nepal. The descriptive, causal
comparative analyses show relationships of characteristics of core capital ratio, bank capital, deposit, net
profit after tax, and earnings per share. These also measure the individual impact of core capital ratio,
bank capital, and deposit on financial performance i.e., net profit after tax (NPAT) and earnings per share
(EPS). As such the study suggests that the banks should adopt the policy that helps practicing healthy and
progressive ways to inject capital and deposits for better financial performance in conclusion.
Linking the banking issue, in his study titled; Impact of Firm Specific Factors on the Profitability and
Stock Price of Nepalese Commercial Banks, Manoj Kumar Bhatta examines firm specific factors for
their relation with profitability and stock price of the Nepalese commercial banks. The study has relays
significant relationship between bonus share and stock price of the commercial banks whereas other
Machindra Thapa in his paper; Impact of Porter’s Generic Strategy on Firm Performance with reference
to Nepalese Retail Banking Sector draws on the concept propounded by Porter called generic strategies
as being the proven and pervasive strategic options in achieving competitiveness and better firm
performance. On a causal and comparative design, this study examines the effect of Porter’s generic
strategies (low-cost, differentiation, and focus) on firm performance in the context of Nepalese retail
banks, a more competitive service industry. The empirical results inform the consistent results indicating
positive associations between generic strategies and firm performance. The regression results declare
higher positive and significant impact of low-cost on firm performance. The findings suggest pursuing
low-cost strategy as instrumental to provide more financial returns with comparison to differentiation
and focus strategies. The study thus suggests combination of low-cost and differentiation (and focus)
strategies that could provide better competitiveness and firm performance.
Using Banking sub-index and index relative of different periods analysis, Joginder Goet in his paper titled
Impact of Right Share Issue on Share Price of Commercial Banks in Nepal examines the effect of issue
of right share on share price movement in the banking sector in that share price and price relative are
used as the predictors of share price movement. The correlation and regression analyses reveal that right
share announcements have the signaling effect on share price movement. The share prices and banking
indices of selected banks have decreased after the announcement of right share. As such the study results
suggest information irregularity behavior as the key tempters of negative change in share price after the
announcement of rights share. The implication is that investors can forestall the nature of change in share
price after rights issue announcement and develop strategic plans to expand the trading activity.
Embracing the issue of human resource, in his paper titled; Conceptualizing Intersectionality between
Work-family Conflict and Career Progress of Married Women Employed in Nepalese Financial Sector,
Gaurav Ojha examines the intersectional relationship between work-family conflict and career progress of
married women employed in the financial sector within Kathmandu Valley. It conceptualizes work-family
conflict by examining the intersectional relationship between socio-demographic factors, antecedents
of work-family conflict and career progress of married women employees in the context of Nepalese
Financial Sector. Results of both descriptive and inferential statistics indicate that asymmetry still remains
prevalent and permeable among married women employees regarding their work-family interfaces and
involvements. As such, it maintains that the antecedents of work family conflict intersect a predictive
association with subsequent existential experiences, ambition gaps and perceptions that negatively
influences career progress of married women. In conclusion, this study recommends a sustainable
corporate culture and human resources management practices that remains sensitive to gender issues and
also assimilates complex and conflicting necessities of both work and family involvements.
Concerning the women entrepreneurship as an emerging topic, in their study titled; Empowerment of
Women through Entrepreneurship Development in Emerging Economies: A Case of India, Siby Abraham,
Himachalam Dasaraju, and Jency Treesa bring an overview on women empowerment through women
entrepreneurship development in the emerging economies. It reviews women empowerment, female
entrepreneurship, gender equity, institutional support and problems of women in rural areas. As part of
practical solutions this study suggests physical, material and technical supports to be extended to the
women entrepreneurs in order to get success and empower the women themselves. In conclusion, the
study provides further insights on the relationship between women empowerment and entrepreneurship
and needs to focus special attention on promoting women empowerment as a part of UN sustainable
development goals.
Concerning consumer knowledge and awareness about the commodities that fall in the cosmetic
categories, Seeprata Parajuli , Bhawana Thapa , Niranjan Devkota , Udaya Raj Paudel, and Saraswati
Gautam in their paper titled; Female Consumers Awareness Level on Purchasing Online Beauty Products
in Kathmandu Valley, highlight some new insights. The study reveals that mostly females are aware
about the online purchase of cosmetic products. Likewise, both literate and illiterate women use online
platforms to buy cosmetic products, though the ratio of literate women is higher. Also, the trend to buy
cosmetics product is higher in unmarried compared to married females. Thus, the study concludes that
effectiveness of online beauty products can be enhanced if the online sites focus on delivering quality
products in reliable price to customers.
Finally focusing on the IT role in our developmental endeavors such as education, in his review based
study titled; A Systematic Review on Blockchain in Education: Opportunities and Challenges, Navin
Duwadi discusse Bloackchain as an emerging technology regarding its use to restructure the systems and
advance education upon quality outcomes. The study introduces some intriguing questions that need to
be answered on the research level. This is the most highlighted question e.g.; What are the benefits of
integrating blockchain in education concerning system reformation and advancement in developing better
educational process for all encompassing learning outcomes?
To conclude, with the incorporation of empirical and secondary sources of literature and data based
research papers, it has come out that this 4th Volume of NJMSR claims its scientific status also validated
with peer reviews of each submission selected and included in this issue. As such, this very academic
manuscript is expected to make an intellectual contribution with the strength of research knowledge
disseminated in conveyance of a number of areas and issues that are of major concern for management
science that seeks to reinforce real management and leadership practices with the lenses of research based
discourses. As this scientific publication wouldn’t have come into the form as here without substantial
support and contribution of researchers, peer reviewers and scientific and academic writing experts, we
would like to express our sincere acknowledgement to each and all whose papers are included in this
volume. We would like to express our special thanks to the advisory members of scientific committee
including international advisors, committee members, managing editor, publishing team, designers and
all who shall be beneficiaries of this 4th volume of NJMSR. Constructive feedback, comments and
corrections are welcome from the readers.
COVID-19 The Global Pandemic: Learning & Take Out for National Pension
System (NPS)
Haladhara Sahu, Ritu Sapra 30
Impact of Firm Specific Factors on the Profitability and Stock Price of Nepalese
Commercial Banks
Manoj Kumar Bhatta 66
Subscription information
Nepalese Journal of Management Science and Research (NJMSR) is a journal published
annually by Global College International. The publication is for the benefit of the
management experts, economists, planners, professionals as well those interested in the
field of management and development. Copies of the journal may be purchased from
Global College International. The subscription rates are as follows:
Library and
Individuals Per Copy
InstitutionPer Copy
Nepal Rs. 500 Rs. 900
SAARC Countries US$ 10.0 US$ 15.0
Other Countries US$ 15.0 US$ 22.0
Mailing Charge to be paid extra Claims for the missing numbers should be made within the
month following the regular month of publication. The publisher will supply the missing
numbers free of cost only when it is confirmed and when the reserve stock permits.
Dear Sir/Madam,
I would like to subscribe Nepalese Journal of Management Science and Research
(NJMSR) bi-annual publication of Global College International, Mid-Baneshwor, Kath-
mandu, Nepal.
Designation: ………………………………………………………..............................................
Institution: ………………………………………………………….............................................
................................................................................................................................................................
Telephone: ............................................................................................................
Email: ……………………….............................................................................
Fax: ........................................................................................................................
Sincerely, …………………………....................................................................
Abstract
Every institution is now doing business transactions through digital financing system. Digital
financing solutions offer great potential to overcome challenges and contribute toward
achieving universal access to financial services. However, it is noticed that insufficiency
of technological up-gradation and various issues created by hackers that might include
fraudulent online transactions as an example, hampers people who are not aware of the other
side of technology.
There are three stages in the implementation of digital finance viz., Fintech, Regtech and
Suptech. ‘Fintech’ is an application of Technology for financial services that include; digital
payments and e-money, international remittances, personal and business loans, peer-to-
peer lending platforms, crowd funding platforms, Robo-advisors, Crypto currencies like
Bitcoin, Altcoin, etc. ‘Regtech’ is a contraction of the terms ‘regulatory' and 'technology'
and it describes the context of regulatory monitoring, reporting, and compliance. ‘Suptech’
is derived from ‘Supervision’ and ‘Technology’, which monitors ‘Fintech' and ‘Regtech’.
The rise of Fintech will undermine the widespread assumption that the primary source of
systemic risk in the financial sector is the domination of large, “systemically important”
banks and other financial institutions. On this backdrop, this paper aimed to explore the
importance of Fintech, Regtech, and Suptech as three stage approach to digital finance.
This paper makes a focus as the special dynamics regarding how Fintech, Regtech, and
Suptech as three stage approach to digital finance work and will become the better substitute
of banks and other financial systems. Based on review of secondary sources, this paper
highlights: 1. the problems and obstacles faced by corporate entities in digital finance and 2.
the interdependency of three dimensions of technology viz., Fintech, Regtech and Suptech.
1 G.V.Satya Sekhar is the Associate Professor for GITAM Deemed to be University, Visakhapatnam-India.
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
Every institution is now doing business transactions through digital financing system. Digital
technological solutions offer great potential to overcome challenges and contribute toward
achieving universal access to financial services. But, it is noticed that various issues created
by hackers, fraudulent online transactions, insufficiency of technological up-gradation
hampers people who are not aware of the other side of technology.
There are three stages in implementation of digital finance viz., Fintech, Regtech and Suptech.
Whereas, ‘Fintech’ is an application of Technology for financial services, for instance: digital
payments and e-money, international remittances, personal and business loans, peer-to-peer
lending platforms, crowd funding platforms, Robo-advisors, Crypto currencies like Bitcoin,
Altcoin, etc. The word ‘Regtech’ is a contraction of the terms ‘regulatory' and 'technology'
and describes the context of regulatory monitoring, reporting, and compliance. The word
‘Suptech’ is derived from ‘Supervision’ and ‘Technology’, which regulates ‘Fintech' and
'Regtech’. The rise of Fintechwill undermine the widespread assumption that the primary
source of systemic risk in the financial sector is the domination of large, “systemically
important” banks and other financial institutions.
1.3 Objectives
1.3.1 General objective
To understand the problems concerning in the digitalization of financial transactions.
2. Review of Literature
The growing need of financial innovation and use of technology in stimulating economic
growth and businesses operations indeed can be viewed by explaining functions it has
performed (Miller & Merton, 1992).It is necessary to take a close look at the main features
of the current wave of financial innovation and evaluate objectively. It is also essential to
identify the lessons that are learned from the economic change and innovation (Verghese,
1990).The factors primarily responsible for technological advancement are: innovation in
financial instruments, financial processes, financial strategies based on the tax advantages,
reduction of risk of volatility in interest rates, reallocation of risk, increase in liquidity, etc
(Finnerty, 2002).
What financial product and process changes have occurred over the last twenty to twenty-five
years in international financial markets? What is the assessment of the recent developments
surrounding financial innovation, including their financial stability and national policy-
making impact? These questions are addressed in a study conducted by Richard Levich
et al., (1988).The innovated financial technology has created various business models as
well as new customer needs. They affect different aspects of the economics, including the
payment services, the banking industry, and the financial regulations (Salmony, 2014). The
internet was able to connect and be widely used in most countries around the world, and so
it became an invaluable support tool for the ongoing development of Fintech (Desai, 2015).
The Indian exchanges of the digital money are gearing up to launch Bitcoin futures; but first,
they want to integrate other crypto-currencies such as Ethereum, Ripple, and Bitcoin Cash
(BCH) on their platform (Kurup, 2017). Other than bitcoins, there are about 1,000 alternative
coins (Altcoins) in the global market, with Ethereum being the most popular. Altcoins are
crypto-currencies that were launched after the success of Bitcoin. In India, Bitcoins have
been available since 2012, and now have 8-9 trading platforms and over a million users”.
Fintech poses a set of unique challenges to financial regulation, challenges that require us
to question many of our fundamental understandings about the creation and propagation of
systemic risk in the economy. In particular, the rise of Fintech will undermine the widespread
assumption that the primary source of systemic risk in the financial sector is the domination
of large, “systemically important” banks and other financial institutions (William, 2018).” It
was found that regulations tend to spur a series of financial innovations. There exists a positive
relationship between education and income and use of the new financial Technology by
consumers. Financial innovators tend to gain by first mover advantages and re compensated
well for their efforts (Frame et al.,2004).
Vasanth and Stein (2017) mentioned that “we examine the potential trajectories and impacts
of Fintech innovation on incumbent and new business models in the finance industry. We
provide a framework for understanding the value created through various types of platforms
in financial services. This framework provides a natural mechanism for thinking about
Fintech winners and losers and for predicting the trajectory of changes in the industry. It
also provides a description of the possible strategies that innovators, incumbents, and the
currently dominant Internet players can pursue.”
Arner et al., (2015) examined the evolution of Fintech using a broad definition of the term
that proposed that all incumbent and new financial companies and industry participants
could be regarded as Fintech, regardless of their size, business model or product portfolio.
Legislators are currently struggling to fit Fintech into existing legal frameworks, as
these were designed for a different environment consisting of large, traditional financial
institutions. Too much regulation can burden innovation efforts, while under-regulation can
impose an unfair advantage on new entrants due to their lower legal costs and overheads,
and create higher social costs due to fraudulent activity and non-existent customer protection
(Douglas, 2016).
The 2008 global financial crisis represented a pivotal moment that separated prior phases of
the development of financial Technology (Fintech) and regulatory Technology (Regtech) from
the current paradigm (Douglas et al., 2017). In addition to this, the recent pandemic situation
and phase-wise lockdown during 2020-2021, also necessitated the Regtech mechanism to
monitor Fintech and Suptech systems. The following diagram shows interrelation between
these stages.
RegTech to date has focused on the digitization of manual reporting and compliance
processes, for example in the context of know-your-customer requirements. This offers
tremendous cost savings to the financial services industry and regulators. However, the
potential of RegTech is far greater – it could enable a close to real-time and proportionate
regulatory regime that identifies and addresses risk while also facilitating more efficient
regulatory compliance (Arner et al., 2016).
DIGITAL FINANCE
IMPLEMENTATION
SUPTECH
REG TECH
FINTECH
3. Methodology
This review paper is addressed various issues like: i) organized literature, ii) evaluate relevant
literature, iii) identified patterns and trends in the literature, iv) synthesized literature and v)
finally research gaps and recommend new research areas.
The studies reveal that the smartcards are slowly replaced by mobile wallets even though
there are hackers and fraudulent call centre operators are cheating people. At the same time,
crowd funding is becoming popular tool for venture finance.
This paper made focus of literature on genesis of financial innovation, digital currency,
fintech, regtech and suptech. The following insights are found:
i. There is a dire need for financial innovation and secured financial products for
implementation of digital finance in corporate sector (Finnerty, 2002).
ii. There are many doubts about legal sanctity for Bitcoins for business operation in India
( Kurup, 2017).
iii. The lapses in implementation of fintech, Regtech and Suptech lead to huge amount of
loss to corporate entities (Vasanth, & Stein 2017).
iv. Financial innovators tend to gain by first mover advantages and re compensated well
for their efforts (Frame et al., 2004).
v. Too much regulation can burden innovation efforts, while under-regulation can impose
an unfair advantage on new entrants due to their lower legal costs and overheads,
and create higher social costs due to fraudulent activity and non-existent customer
protection (Douglas, 2016).
vi. RegTech solutions can be designed to paint a 360-degree view of compliance and risk in
real-time, while single-rule solutions are aimed at one specific area.2
2 https://www.ncontracts.com/nsight-blog/what-you-need-to-know-regtech-vs-suptech
or 'currency' that can be transferred between parties; and (ii) the way in which value is
transferred from a payer to a payee. Bitcoin is a popular example of Digital Currency. It helps
to facilitate peer-to-peer exchange at low transactional costs and faster transaction time. D.C.
schemes are also known as 'crypto currencies' as it uses cryptographic techniques. Crypto
currencies derive their value from the expectation that others will be willing to exchange it
for sovereign currency or goods and services. The inferences of D.C.s for financial firms,
markets and system will depend on the extent of its acceptability among users.
Regtech is used to regulate and monitor transactions relating to digital finance. Banking and
financial institutions today have a lot to gain from Regtech. Keeping in mind the growing list
of regulatory obligations financial organizations have to comply with, and the consequences
of noncompliance and the large fines associated with this.
RegTech's ability to deliver tools to reach compliance more quickly, and at a lower cost,
is a huge benefit for organizations and will give early adopters a competitive advantage.
Early adopters and organizations who implement Regtech into their governance, risk and
compliance strategies will be the beneficiaries. For many processes, especially those that
heavily involve client data like Know Your Customer (KYC) requirements, the end customer
also receives an enhanced experience by having a more streamlined process in place.
Organizations that use Technology to safeguard against breaches and protect client data will
also benefit the client. The following are various applications used in Regtech.
4.5.8 Chatboats
Chatboats are also implemented by financial institutions to help customers navigate through
products and feel they matter. For simple operations, most people wouldn't be able to
tell if they are talking to a real person following a script or a boat driven by A.I. From
simple customer service interactions to analyzing legal contracts, A.I. chatboats are rapidly
becoming more and more prevalent in our day-to-day lives.
4.5.14 Blockchain
Blockchain is a list of records called as blocks which are linked with cryptography. It is used
by crypto currencies. Blockchain provides a network that enables various stakeholders to
transact with trust, security and anonymity. Blockchain is essentially a distributed database
that contains a chronological order of all transactions or digital events that happened among
the participatory parties. All transactions in the network are represented in terms of block
and broadcasted to participants in the network, verified, time stamped and linked with the
prior blocks in the network to form a sequence of blocks known as Blockchain.
data into meaningful pictures or graphics which could help the banks to easily track
troublesome digital footprints.
• Behavioral Analytics: This is helping the banks identify fraudsters disguised as
customers. The data analytics implemented by the banks to understand customer
behavior, preferences, etc are also helping in the detection of fraudulent activity either
in real-time.
• Deep Learning: Internet payment companies providing alternatives to traditional money
transfer methods are using deep machine learning, a new approach to machine learning
and artificial intelligence that is great at identifying complex patterns and characteristics
of cybercrime and online fraud.
4.7 Summary
This paper deals with three dimensional approaches viz., Fintech, Regtech and Suptech.
Everyone needs to understand technological concepts and tools involved in digital financial
world. As Fintech helps corporate entities to connect with customers via Technology,
Regtech helps them meet regulatory requirements via Technology. Regtech utilizes various
technologies such as machine learning and artificial intelligence to establish enterprise-
wide data governance and reporting. These new technologies replace the current manual
processes for modeling and reporting. With the ever-changing regulatory landscape, Regtech
enhances the ability for institutions to remain compliant with critical regulations such as
the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA), including know-your-customer (KYC) and suspicious activity
reporting. Regtech also simplifies the data-reporting requirements under a number of
regulations including such as Basel-3, CCAR, and MIFID II to name a few. Hence, it can be
concluded that ‘Fintech’. ‘Regtech’ and ‘Suptech’ should go hand-in-hand.
3. https://www.centralbanking.com/fintech/regtech-suptech/7869496/haldane-warns-against-blind-trust-in-ais
References
Arner, Douglas W. and Arner, Douglas W. and Barberis, Janos Nathan and Buckley, Ross P (2016). The
Emergence of Regtech 2.0: From Know Your Customer to Know Your Dat. Journal of Financial
Transformation, Available at http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3044280 .
Arner, D. W., Barberis, J. N., & Buckley, R. P(2015). The Evolution of Fintech: A New Post-Crisis
Paradigm? Available at SSRN 2676553.
David LEE KuoChuen(2016). Emergence of Fintech and the LASIC Principles. Electronic copy
available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2668049.
Desai, F.(2015). The Evolution of Fintech. Forbes. Available: http://www.forbes.com/sites/
falgunidesai/2015/12/13/the-evolution-of-Fintech/#349c7f184ccb.
Douglas W. Arner, JànosBarberis, and Ross P. Buckley (2016).Fintech, Regtech and the
Reconceptualization of Financial Regulation. Source: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2847806.
DouglasW. ArnerJanos Barberiseds.RossP.Buckley (2017).Fintech and Regtech in a Nutshell, and the
Future in a Sandbox ,Research Foundation Briefs,3(4).
Douglas, J. L. (2016). New Wine Into Old Bottles: Fintech Meets the Bank Regulatory World. North
Carolina Banking Institute, 20 (1), p. 17.
Dushnitsky, G., Guerini, M., Piva, E. and Rossi-Lamastra, C(2016). Crowd Funding in Europe:
Determinants of platform Creation Across Countries. California Management Review,58, 44–71.
Gilbert. C., Bower, J.(2002). Disruptive Change: When trying harder is part of the Problem. Harvard
Business Review May, 94-101.
Gonzalez, A. G. (2004). PayPal: The Legal Status of C2C Payment Systems. Computer Law & Security
Review, 20(7), 293–299.
IoannisAnagnostopoulos (2018).Fintech and Regtech: Impact on Regulators and Banks. Journal of
Economics and Business. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconbus.2018.07.003
McGrath, R. G (2010). Business models: A discovery driven approach. Long Range Planning, 43,
247-261.
Magretta, J (2002). Why business models matter. Harvard Business Review, 80, 86-92.
Megha Jain and Prof. (Dr.) G.S. Popli (2015).Role of Information Technology in the development of
Banking Sector in India. Source: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2151162.
Sanmugam, A (2012).Factors determining consumer adoption of Internet Banking. Electronic copy
available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1021484.
Santiago Fernandez De Lis, et al (2016). Regtech-The new Magic Word. Fintech, March.
Salmony, M (2014). Access to accounts: Why Banks Should Embrace an Open Future. Journal of
Payments Strategy &Systems, 8 (2), 169–170.
‘Fintech, Regtech and Suptech: What they Mean for Financial Supervision’, Toronto Centre, TC
Notes-practical leadership and technical guidance from Toronto centre, Aug, 2017.
Institute of International Finance, Regtech: Exploring Solutions for Regulatory Challenges, 02 Oct
2015.
Vasant Dhar and Roger M. Stein (2017). Fintech Platforms and Strategy. MIT Sloan School Working
Paper 5183-16.
FINTECH-
OVERVIEW
4. Digital
5.Crowd Funding
Currencies-
Crypto Currencies
Source: Diagram prepared by author.
4. Data analytics
Suptech
-Supervisory technology 5. Cognitive analysis
6. Augmented Reality
7. Internet of Things
9. Block Chain
Source: Diagram prepared by author.
Abstract
Hospitality industry is one of the most profitable industries with a high potential for increase,
thus being a hospitality manager is one of the most trendy and prestigious jobs of today.
It is also a challenging job since, being an effective one is quite complex due to recorded
industrial higher heart burn effects, rapid industrial changes in demand, constant trends
and severe industrial competition. The purpose of the study is to evaluate the performance
variance of the top managers of the five-star hotels of Nepal in respect with their gender.
The primary data were received from employees on different level, line-managers of five-
star hotels. Descriptive and explanatory research designs were used. Composite means and
correlation coefficients models were used to analyze and interpret the data.
Analysis showed that the female managers generally tend to adopt democratic or participative
style while governing people, whereas, male managers induce an autocratic or directive
style in their daily performance. Based on the regression analysis, it was determined that
the extraversion dimension had a more significant effect than the openness dimension. The
extraversion dimension had a negative effect on extrinsic job satisfaction, while the openness
dimension had a positive effect. The extraversion and openness dimensions had a weak but
statistically significant effect on general job satisfaction. The extraversion dimension had
a negative effect on general job satisfaction, while the openness dimension had a positive
effect.
1. Introduction
Personality has been perceived differently by different scholars. The term personality is
derived from the Latin word persona meaning a mask. Personality is a patterned body of
habits, traits, attitudes and ideas of an individual as these are organized externally into roles
and statuses and as they relate internally to motivation, goals and various aspects of selfhood.
For example, Robbins and Judge (2005) have stated that personality refers to the sum total
of ways in which an individual reacts and interacts with others. Similarly, Luthans (2011)
has claimed personality as a means how a person affects others and how he understands and
views himself as well as the pattern of inner and outer measurable traits and person-situation
interaction. According to Robert and Burgess, personality is the sum and organization of
those traits which determine the role of an individual in group/s.
The present researcher observed from the works of different scholars in this respect so
as to confirm the relevance of taking up an idea whether considering varying leadership
styles across the different managers working in the field of hospitality in the present
Nepalese context. In this discourse, the present researcher could not be confirmed if there
was significant difference of the styles opted by the different managers as the past studies
provided with mixed findings in this respect. For example, Keer, Bogaert and Trbovic (2009)
have concluded that there exists a very narrow difference of the personality traits opted
by the male and female executives whereby the female managers were found to be more
conscious on people related matters.
In contrary, Kadyrkulova (2008) has identified that the gender of the respective managers
was not a strong determinant of their managerial approaches and the male and female lead-
managers were differently superior in different aspects of their leadership traits.
The relationships of the Big Five personality traits to turnover intention are another area of
research interest; studies on the topic however have focused on one or two traits, and their
results have been incongruous (Timmerman, 2006; Zimmerman, 2008). Whereas positive
traits such as extraversion and openness to experience were related to turnover among call
center employees (Timmerman, 2006), other positive traits such as emotional stability best
predicted negatively employees’ intentions to quit, and conscientiousness and agreeableness
best predicted negatively actual turnover decisions (Zimmerman, 2008). There seems to be
a need for a research to clarify the role of the Big Five personality traits as a set to predict
turnover intention.
The above discussions are enough to come to a conclusion that there is still a big room to
explore whether the gender of the lead-managers is an instrumental element to determine the
personality type indicators of their managerial approaches and also it is equally undecided
whether the personality type of these managers is dependent on their gender. In this respect,
the present researcher decided to conduct a systematic observation to confirm the role of
gender difference in the process of determining leadership styles possessed by the lead-
managers serving in the fore-front of the hospitality institutions in Nepal, specifically
in the five-star hotels located in the Kathmandu Valley. As a result, a study entitled "
An Assessment of Personality-Type of Managers in Nepalese Hotel Industries" was
visualized to address the concern.
practices. Thus, the present researcher was quite concerned to know if the gender of respective
manager was really important while raising the professionals in responsible positions in
the hospitality industry. As a result, the present researcher devised a single statement of
problem that reads as – Can the personality type of the key people leading five-star hotels be
measured in respect with their gender?
In other words, the present study was concerned with examining the roles of female
managers on the lead as compared to that of male managers. Similarly, this study aimed to
assess the gender-wise display of managerial personality traits and compare them with the
vested personality type indicators. On the other hand, the study was focused on the trend of
placement and status of female managers working in the five-star hotels.
2. Review of Literature
The main aim of performing review of literature was to get acquainted with the concept of
personality and specifically personality traits of the managers serving in the leading 5-star
hotels of Nepal. This chapter has been guided by the purpose of getting depth knowledge of
personality type indicators in lead-managers of the hotels.
All individuals who have a bachelor degree may guess the first lecture's topic. If the lecture is
on philosophy, the first question would be "what is philosophy?" In other words, psychology
professors traditionally start their lectures with the following question: What is personality?
(Burger, 2006, p.22). Personality may be defined as emotional, interpersonal, experiential and
motivational forms that explain behaviors in different situations. It points to psychological traits
which are constant in time and which provides reasons for the behaviors of the individual, and
these traits constitute a unified combination that shows who the person is while determining
his/her emotional, behavioral and cognitive forms (Mount et al., 2005, p. 447).
“Personality” comes from the Latin term “persona.” In antique Greece and Rome, actors
had masks called “persona” which emphasized the traits they represent on the stage. Later,
this term has been used to mean both the person and his/her role in society (Luthans, 1992,
p. 85). In many cases, five orthogonal characteristics result from measurement of many
people’s personality traits and factor analysis as a covariance structure and these are named
If we are to conclude from these definitions related to personality, it comes out as a unique
image of the factors affecting a person’s perception, thinking and behaving modes. Being
under the constant impact of stimulants coming from inside and outside, personality includes
all biological, psychological, hereditary and acquired abilities, motives, feelings, wants,
habits and all other behaviors of the individual. In sum, it is possible to see hereditary traits
and environmental impacts in the constitution of personality. One may conclude from this
that if environment's impact is taken into account, personality reflects to some extent traits
common to the community, and to some extent traits common in all humans, and not only
traits unique to individual (Yelboga, 2006, p. 198).
Again, Costa and McCrae (1992, as cited in Robbins, & Judge, 2014) have emphasized on five
factor model to assess the personality traits of an individual in any setting. These factors include
extraversion, neuroticism, agreeableness, conscientiousness and openness to experience.
The concept and definition of any management term is quiet vague. Meaning, an exact and
universally accepted definition of discipline like personality is a challenging task. Moreover,
different scholars opt it in their own way and perspectives. For example, Mikulincer and
Shaver (2015) stated that ‘personality refers to individual differences in characteristic
patterns of thinking, feeling and behaving.’ Similarly, “Personality” derived from the Latin
term “Persona” which means (1) a mask worn by theater actors to represent their role and
personality in the play; (2) the authentic self, which includes one’s intrinsic motivations,
emotions, habits, and ideas (Chan, 1996).
Ellis (2008) stated that, personality falls under the heading of things that most people believe
they understand. In fact, there is probably no domain within any field of knowledge in which
more people think they have achieved some expertise. Simply put, most people believe they
can know or understand other people. We all try to predict behavior, interpret conversations,
and make inferences about others’ actions. If someone offends us, acts strangely, or seems
excessively kind, we will quickly try to understand their motives. In addition, we often
draw inferences about what kind of people they are; that is, what personality traits they may
possess. Most of us regard ourselves as competent judges of personality. We make use of our
skills in personality assessment on a daily basis; however, most of us would have a difficult
time explaining exactly how we draw our conclusions about others.
The Big Five personality traits (Goldberg, 1992; John & Srivastava, 1999), or the Five-Factor
personality traits (McCrae & Costa, 1987) is a widely researched model of personality that
consists of five dimensions: neuroticism (or conversely emotional stability), extraversion,
openness to experience, conscientiousness, and agreeableness. Emotional stability
refers to the capability of an individual to respond well to stress; extraversion represents
outgoingness and sociability; openness to experience is the degree to which one is open-
minded; consciousness represents the extent to which one performs tasks accurately and
thoroughly; and agreeableness refers to one’s cooperativeness and consideration (Kyllonen,
Walters, & Kaufman, 2005).
Researchers have attempted to establish the validity of the Big Five personality traits in
predicting employee behaviors. Thus, agreeableness predicted hotel employees’ job burnout
(Kim, Shin, & Umbreit, 2007), and extroversion was negatively associated, and neuroticism
was positively associated with emotional exhaustion among hotel managers (O'Neill & Xiao,
2010). Studies of the relationships of the Big Five personality traits to employees’ turnover
intention have produced incongruous results; whereas positive traits such as extraversion
and openness to experience were related to turnover intention (Timmerman, 2006), positive
traits such as emotional stability, conscientiousness and agreeableness were negatively
predictive of turnover intention, and actual turnover (Zimmerman, 2008). We therefore seek
to clarify the relationships of the Big Five personality traits as a set to turnover intention.
We believe that studying the Big Five personality traits as a set would enhance its validity
in predicting turnover intention. The Big Five personality traits as a set had a multiple
correlation of .41 with job satisfaction (Judge, Heller, & Mount, 2002), and .49 with the
motivational criteria (Judge & Ilies, 2002). The effect sizes of the full set of Big Five
personality traits was multiple R = .36 on entrepreneurial intentions, and multiple R = .31 on
entrepreneurial performance (H. Zhao, Seibert, & Lumpkin, 2010). Also, a test among hotel
employees would support the utility of the Big Five personality traits as a set in hospitality
work and suggest their use in the selection of hotel employees. Results of our study would
support the Big Five theory hypothesis of the effects of personality traits on self-concept
(hospitality competency) and characteristics adaptations (turnover intention). As the Big
Five personality traits are related to positive work behavior, we expect them to negatively
relate to negative behavior such as turnover intention, and hypothesized that:
Hypothesis 1: Thai hotel staff’s Big Five personality traits as a set would negatively predict
their turnover intention.
Job satisfaction also mediates to reduce negative job behaviors such as counterproductive
work behavior and turnover intention. Thus, job satisfaction partially mediated the relationship
of agreeableness to organizational and interpersonal counterproductive work behaviors
(Mount, Ilies, & Johnson, 2006). Job satisfaction mediated the relationship of organizational
identification to turnover intention (Van Dick et al., 2004), of leader-member exchange to
turnover intention (Han & Jekel, 2011), and of polychronicity to turnover intention (Jang &
George, 2012). There is strong evidence that job satisfaction is dispositionally based (Judge
& Larsen, 2001), and the Big Five personality traits as a set have a multiple correlation of .41
with job satisfaction (Judge et al., 2002). There has yet to be a study on the mediating effect
of job satisfaction on the relationship of Big Five personality traits to turnover intention, and
support for the role of job satisfaction in this relationship would point to its importance in
reducing turnover and organizational costs. We believe that job satisfaction would mediate
to reduce turnover intention, and therefore hypothesized that:
Hypothesis 3: Job satisfaction would mediate the relationship of the Big Five personality
traits to turnover intention.
Further, this scholar has claimed that, everyday conceptions of personality traits make
two key assumptions. First, traits are stable over time. Most people would accept that an
individual’s behavior naturally varies somewhat from occasion to occasion, but would
maintain also that there is a core of consistency which defines the individual’s ‘true nature’:
unchangeable spots of the leopard. In other words, there are differences between individuals
that are apparent across a variety of situations. We might expect several different contexts
such as examinations, social occasions and group discussions. Stability distinguishes traits
from more transient properties of the person, such as temporary mood states. Second, it is
generally believed that traits directly influence behavior. If a person spontaneously breaks
into cheerful song, we might ‘explain’ the behavior by saying that he or she has a happy
disposition. Such lay explanations are, of course, on shaky ground because of the circularity.
There are amply variables which are used to describe personality. Many of these words
have rather similar meanings: precise, careful, meticulous and painstaking would all seem to
relate to some common quality of conscientiousness. Such overlapping traits can be grouped
together as a broad aspect or dimension of personality. The present research in basic is
concerned to a question as: what is the number of such broad dimensions that are needed to
describe the main elements of any individual personality. Numerous research efforts have
been devoted to drawing up classificatory schemes of fundamental personality dimensions:
estimates of the number required range from three to thirty and so on.
Professionalism
Emotional stability
Personality
Extraversion
Openness Male Female
Altruism
Conscientiousness
As presented in above figure, the research work holds an assumption that the comparison
between the personality traits of male and female managers of 5 star hotels of Nepal is based
on independent variables like: Professionalism, Emotional stability, Extraversion, Openness,
Altruism, and Conscientiousness. This means, the personality traits of either male or female
is differentiated with reference to these mentioned variables. Furthermore, the variation in
these variables is the main source to observe and measure the differences in the personality
attributes and managerial competencies of genders.
3. Methodology Used
3.1. Research design
Descriptive and explanatory research designs were applied to meet the objectives of the
present research through both quantitative and qualitative methodology as there are limited
numbers of 5-star category hotels to be observed and also that simple survey approach will
not be sufficient to meet the objective of the study.
The present research comprises of 320 total respondents taken from four 5-star hotels
located in the Kathmandu Valley. Among total respondents, 158 are male and 162 are female
whereby, in the 20 to 30 year’s age group, 98 are male and 102 are female. 60 male and
60 female are interviewed of age group above 30 years. This fact reveals that the female
between 20 to 30 years of age are extensively employed in 5-star hotels of Nepal.
Work experience is also examined in course of conducting this research. Among which, 118
respondents had their work experience of up-to 5 years, including 60 i.e. 50.8% male and
58 i.e. 48.2% female. Likewise, among 202 respondents having work experience above 5
years, 98 i.e. 48.5% were male and 104 i.e. 51.5% were female. Similarly, the above figure
concludes that female with work experience above 5 years are dominant in the compared to
male employees.
Hence, the table 2 draws a conclusion that male managers are professional compared to
the female managers. Comparatively, male lead-managers seems to be competent than the
female lead-manages in terms of emotional stability. Similarly, female managers are seen
more ahead than male when it’s a concern of extraversion. In terms of openness also, female
seems to be dominant than male lead-mangers. The above total figure reveals that male
managers are a little more proficient than female lead- mangers while considering their
altruism character. While considering the conscientiousness among the male and female
managers, male are seen more conscientious compared to female.
Emotional Stability
Conscientiousness
Personality Traits
Professionalism
Extraversion
Openness
Altruism
Professionalism 1 0.296** 0.197* 0.385** 0.290** 0.140
Emotional Stability 1 0.297** 0.312** 0.217** 0.186*
In table 3, the relationships among the variables are analyzed as: Professionalism is
significantly related with emotional stability, openness and altruism under 1% level of
significance. Similarly, the relation between professionalism and extraversion is significant
under 5% level of significance. There is no significant relationship between professionalism
and conscientiousness.
Likewise, emotional stability is significantly related with extraversion, openness and
altruism under 1% level of significance, and relation that with conscientiousness is under
5% level of significance. In such, extraversion is related significantly with openness and
altruism under 1% level of significance whereas; extraversion is significantly related with
conscientiousness at 5% level of significance. Openness has significant relationship with
both altruism and conscientiousness under 1% level of significance. Lastly, altruism and
conscientiousness are observed to be significantly related under 1% level of significance.
4. Discussion
The concept of hospitality competency includes skills, abilities, and attitudes that enable
hospitality workers to successfully discharge their duties (Tesone & Ricci, 2005, 2006).
We operationally defined hospitality competency to include attitude, communication skills,
human relation skills, self-discipline and hospitality technical skills (Zopiatis, 2007),
and developed a scale to assess its mediating effect on the Big Five personality traits and
turnover intention relationship. Factor analysis of the hospitality competency data revealed a
five-factor structure corresponding to the hypothesized dimensions; the scale also exhibited
satisfactory reliability. Our results showed that the Big Five personality traits predicted
hospitality competency, indicating that hotel employees who scored high in the Big Five
traits were also competent in their hospitality tasks. The Big Five personality traits and
hospitality competency scales we developed may be used in tandem to select hospitality
employees.
Results of our study add to the literature on the role of job satisfaction as a mediator, and
increase our understanding of hotel employees’ turnover intention. Job satisfaction mediates
the relationship of the Big Five personality traits to turnover intention; the Big Five
personality traits as a set seem to increase the level of job satisfaction to negatively predict
turnover intention. The relationship of the Big Five personality traits to job satisfaction
relationship found in our study seems to support the suggestion that job satisfaction might be
dispositionally based (Judge & Larsen, 2001). The mediation effect of job satisfaction on the
relationship of the Big Five personality traits to turnover intention has important implication
for hotels; it may be beneficial for hotels to recruit employees who are high in the Big Five
personality traits as they tend to be satisfied with their jobs and are unlikely to quit.
5. Conclusions
There exists some differences in the personality traits of male and female lead-managers, but
they are small. Female employees between age-group 20 to 30 and having work experience
above 5 years are extensively employed in 5-star hotels of Nepal. Relation among various
personality traits is experienced significant under respective level of significance, except
relationship between professionalism and conscientiousness, which is observed to be
significantly different. Female generally tend to adopt democratic or participative style
while governing people, whereas, male induce an autocratic or directive style in their daily
performance. Female managers are more concerned towards people-related issues and
quality performance; while male managers seem to attach more importance to an effective
performance, control of emotions, concern towards others welfare and specific and careful
at works. Female lead-managers basically confront a double bind situation: If they act like
a leader, using typically male characteristics, they are perceived as being hard, because they
act against the typical female personality profile. If they act like a female, they are perceived
as being inefficient, since typically male personality traits are perceived as more effective
in terms of performance. Male managers seem to be competent in characteristics like:
concerned, careful, helpful, socially confident, organized and meticulous. Contrarily, female
are more proficient when it comes to teamwork, communicative and methodological works.
This research study is based on an exploratory and descriptive research design to meet the
objectives of the present research through qualitative and quantitative methodology. This
observation based methodology was applied due to less number of 5-star category hotels in
Kathmandu Valley, and in Nepal as a whole. Moreover, simply the survey approach would
not have been adequate to meet the objectives of the study.
This study concluded that the female managers were reported to confront a double-bind
situation in most of the cases where they were blamed to be acting with more harsh attitude
towards the people if they acted being practically strict. At the same time, they were again
blamed for being inefficient and motherly-loyal towards the employees if they acted with
liberal attitude. However the general observation towards the male managers remained more
biased in such respects, meaning that the male managers level of strictness, no matter how
soft or strict it be, received little concern of the fellow workers.
References
Babakus, E., Yavas, U., & Karatepe, O. M. (2008). The effects of job demands, job resources and
intrinsic motivation on emotional exhaustion and turnover intentions: A study in the turkish hotel
industry. [Article]. International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration, 9(4), 384-404.
Burger J. M. (2006). Personality, Istanbul: Kaknus Publications.
Carver C. S. & Scheier M. F. (2004). Perspectives On Personality, Fifth Edition, Pearson Allyn and
Bacon Inc.: New York.
Chan, G. (1996). Images of organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. construct of
emotional stability in relation to job performance, job satisfaction,
Cook, V. D. (2005). An investigation of the construct validity of the Big Five
Costa, A. H., & McCrae, B. T. (1992). Gender and leadership style: a meta-analysis. Psychological
Bulletin, Sep Vol 108(2), pp. 233 – 256.
Eagly A. H., & Karau S. J. (2002), “Role congruity theory of prejudice towards female leaders”,
Psychological Review, 2002, vol. 109, n°3, pp. 573 – 598.
Ellis, F. M. (2008). The study of personality. Sage Publications.
Goldberg, L. R. (1992). The development of markers for the Big-Five factor structure. Psychological
Assessment, 4(1), 26-42. doi: 10.1037/1040-3590.4.1.26
Han, G., & Jekel, M. (2011). The mediating role of job satisfaction between leader‐member exchange
and turnover intentions. Journal of Nursing Management, 19(1), 41-49. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-
2834.2010.01184.x
Hemdi, M. A., & Nasurdin, A. M. (2006). Predicting turnover intentions of hotel employees: The
influence of employee eevelopment human resource management practices and trust in
organization. [Article]. Gadjah Mada International Journal of Business, 8(1), 21-42.
Hemdi, M. A., & Nasurdin, A. M. (2008). Investigating the influence of organizational justice on
hotel employees' organizational citizenship behavior intentions and turnover intentions. [Article].
Journal of Human Resources in Hospitality & Tourism, 7(1), 1-23. Homewood, IL: Richard D.
Irwin. Retrived on -26th July 2015 Incelenmesi. Is, Guc Endustri Iliskileri ve Insan Kaynaklari
Dergisi, 8(2),
Jang, J., & George, R. T. (2012). Understanding the influence of polychronicity on job satisfaction
and turnover intention: A study of non-supervisory hotel employees. International Journal of
Hospitality Management, 31(2), 588-595. doi: 10.1016/j.ijhm.2011.08.004
Judge, T. A., & Ilies, R. (2002). Relationship of personality to performance motivation: A meta-analytic
review. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(4), 797-807. doi: 10.1037/0021-9010.87.4.797
Judge, T. A., & Larsen, R. J. (2001). Dispositional affect and job satisfaction: A review and theoretical
extension. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 86(1), 67-98. doi: 10.1006/
obhd.2001.2973
Judge, T. A., Heller, D., & Mount, M. K. (2002). Five-factor model of personality and job satisfaction:
A meta-analysis. [Article]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(3), 530-541. doi: 10.1037//0021-
9010.873.3.530
Judge, T. A., Heller, D., & Mount, M. K. (2002). Five-factor model of personality and job satisfaction:
Steel, R. P., & Ovalle, N. K. (1984). A review and meta-analysis of research on the relationship between
behavioral intentions and employee turnover. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69(4), 673-686. doi:
10.1037/0021-9010.69.4.673
Taggar, S., Hackew, R., & Saha, S. (1999). Leadership emergence in autonomous
Tesone, D. V., & Ricci, P. (2005). Job competency expectations for hospitality and tourism employees:
Perceptions of educational preparation. Journal of Human Resources in Hospitality & Tourism,
4(2), 53-64. doi: 10.1300/J171v04n02_03
Tesone, D. V., & Ricci, P. (2006). Toward a definition of entry-level job competencies: Hospitality
manager perspectives. International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration, 7(4), 65-
80. doi: 10.1300/J149v07n04_04
Tett, R. P., & Meyer, J. P. (1993). Job satisfaction, organizational commitment, turnover intention, and
turnover: Path analyses based on meta-analytic findings. Personnel Psychology, 46(2), 259-293.
Timmerman, T. A. (2006). Predicting turnover with broad and narrow personality traits. International
Journal of Selection and Assessment, 14(4), 392-399. types. Personnel Psychology, 58(2), 447-
478.
Van Dick, R., Christ, O., Stellmacher, J., Wagner, U., Ahlswede, O., Grubba, C., . . . Tissington, P.
A. (2004). Should I stay or should I go? Explaining turnover intentions with organizational
identification and job satisfaction. British Journal of Management, 15(4), 351-360. doi:
10.1111/j.1467-8551.2004.00424.x
Wexley, K., and Yukl, G. (1984). Organizational Behavior and Personnel Psychology.
Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. (November, 2015).
Yelboga, A. (2006). Kisilik Ozellikleri ve Is Performansi Arasindaki Iliskinin
Zimmerman, R. D. (2008). Understanding the impact of personality traits on individuals' turnover
decisions: A meta-analytic path model. Personnel Psychology, 61(2), 309-348. doi: 10.1111/j.1744-
6570.2008.00115.x
Zopiatis, A. (2007). Hospitality internships in Cyprus: A genuine academic experience or a continuing
frustration? International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 19(1), 65-77. doi:
10.1108/09596110710724170
Abstract
The SARS Cov-2 (Covid 19) pandemic has shaken the whole world; it has brought the
business, education, industry, transport, communications, travel, hospitality almost all
the economic activities to a standstill. Accordingly, it has adversely affected the financial
markets and stock exchanges across the globe. The stock exchanges, may it be New York
Stock Exchange, Dow Jones, London Stock Exchange, Nikkei, Bombay Stock Exchange
or National Stock Exchange experienced an unprecedented plunge of 40 to 50% in a period
few weeks. This new dynamic of volatility possesses serious questions about the market
driven National Pension System (NPS) which endeavor to ensure smooth retirement life for
Indian elderly. The volatility in security market will significantly impact the fund managers’
performance and accordingly the retirement benefit of the subscriber. This article has
investigated the impacts of pandemic on fund manager’s risk returns profile. We have used
three industry standard risk-adjusted returns parameters such as Sharpe ratio, Treynor Ratio
and Jensen’s alpha to evaluate the performance of NPS pension fund managers selected under
study. The study has also explored the learning from such unexpected crisis for the policy
makers for future preparedness. On the basis of finding, it has suggested some measures for
long run sustainability of schemes under NPS.
Keywords : NPS, PFRDA, Defined benefit, Defined contribution, Pension fund managers,
Risk adjusted returns, COVID-19.
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
Investment guidelines of PFRDA (Pension Fund Regulatory & Development Authority of
India) permit the fund managers of National Pension System (NPS) to invest in different
categories of financial instruments like government bonds, corporate debts, money market
instruments, assets backed securities, equity and derivatives of companies listed in NSE
and/or BSE to ensure better market-based returns to the subscribers of NPS. Since 2016,
PFRDA’s investment approach has been shifting towards equity from government securities
and corporate debts. The new investment norms permit up to 75% investment in equity
1 Doctoral Fellow at Department of Commerce, Delhi School of Economics. University of Delhi. Assistant
Professor (HoD), Department of Commerce. Kalahandi University, Bhawanipatna.
2 Associate Professor, Department of Commerce, Delhi School of Economics. University of Delhi.
and equity related financial instruments. Investments in equity carry higher component risk
that is the downward deviation from the expectation which could reduce the benefit to the
subscriber substantially.
The prime objective of retirement saving is to ensure income security at old age when all
other sources of income stop. Putting such huge corpus under equity ambit seems like putting
the very notion of retirement security at risk. We have somehow established the notion that
in the long run equity investment is going to provide higher positive returns compared to
other investment avenues. However, the recent experience in stock market particularly after
the spread of Corona Virus Disease (COVID-19) (SARS-CoV-2: Severe Acute Respiratory
Syndrome Coronavirus 2), equity markets in India witnessed an unprecedented fall, it dips
around 40% in a month. The nationwide lockdown put all the business houses, factories,
industries, transport and communication to a standstill. The COVID-19 is one instance
of such incidence, there could be many more unforeseen future possibilities of war, bio-
chemical attack, external aggression, economic crisis or any other unforeseen event which
could bring surprising turn of event in a security market. As a consequence, the return
may dip down well below the contribution. What will happen to the retirement saving of
people who are approaching retirement during such dive without any contribution protection
insurance? Contribution made under NPS is public retirement saving entrusted with the hope
of decent retirement life in future and the decent retirement life of elderly is conditional upon
the performance of NPS’s fund managers. Are we ready to put our retirement saving to such
high volatility without any protection mechanism?
In this article we have tried to study the impacts of such volatility on retirement savings. We
have also tried to explore the protection, options and flexibility to be incorporated in NPS to
tackle such volatility and make it sustainable in the long-run.
The Project OASIS Expert Committee submitted its report to the Ministry in January 2000,
the committee recommended, defined contributory pension, where the individual will open
an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) at early working stages of life and make some
periodical monetary contribution to IRA. The contributed sum in the IRA would be managed
by professional pension fund managers through investment in the security market. Pension
benefit under the scheme would depend upon the accumulated balance in the account of
subscribers at the time of retirement. Better the investment return and performance of fund
managers better would be the retirement benefit and vice versa. Retirement benefit would be
provided in form annuities by annuity service provider companies.
The committee recommended the defined contribution is the only option for pension
assurance, given the financial health of the economy it is not possible to continue the exiting
defined benefit pension scheme. It also recommended for a strong independent pension
sector regulator to control and regulate the industry and intermediaries. OASIS committee’s
main focus was to include the excluded unorganized sector workers in the new pension
system; even if their saving is modest but the long-term saving could give a decent retirement
security, if the saving being properly managed. (OASIS Committee Report, 1999)
OASIS recommendation also suggested a contribution protection insurance, when the final
value at retirement falls short to the subscriber accumulated contribution made in the past,
the government will ensure the difference between the contribution and final value by
purchasing insurance from insurance companies. Now it has been more than one and half
decade since the reforms of pension sector there is no mention of contribution protection
insurance in any of the pension scheme.
Pressure on the fiscal front, increasing pension pay-outs obligated the government to change
the pension system for government employees from defined benefit to a defined contribution
system. In the year 2003, Government of India established Pension Fund Regulatory and
Development Authority (PFRDA) as an interim regulator and assigned the duty of reforms,
promotion, regulation and development of pension architecture of the country. In 2004,
PFRDA introduced New Pension Scheme (NPS), which replaced the existing defined
benefit pension model with the defined contribution pension model for government sector
employee. Later in 2009, NPS was extended to private sector all citizen and renamed as
National Pension System.
Under the defined benefit pension scheme employee is entitled to a fixed sum of pension
benefit after retirement(Normally 50% of last drawn salary indexed to DA). On the other
hand, under the new defined contribution scheme, the subscriber has to contribute a specific
sum of money from monthly salary or income for future income security. The periodical
specific sum of money so contributed would be managed by the professional Fund Managers
appointed by the PFRDA and the retirement benefit of the subscriber would depend upon the
returns generated by the fund managers through investment in security markets.
Investment norms of NPS permit the fund managers (registered with PFRDA) to invest in
different class of financial assets like government bonds, corporate debts, money market
instruments, assets backed securities, equity of companies and derivatives of companies
registered under NSE (National Stock Exchange) or/and BSE (Bombay Stock Exchange) to
ensure better market returns to the subscriber registered under NPS.
Contribution in the hand fund managers is public retirement saving entrusted with the hope
of decent retirement life in future. It is essential to note that, decent retirement life of elderly
is conditional upon the performance of NPS fund managers. And performance of fund
manager is subject to market returns. Therefore, it is also essential to evaluate the portfolio
risk-returns, investment norms, investment practices, performance and regulation of pension
fund managers, to check whether the national pension system is in right direction to deliver
retirement income security to the elderly or otherwise.
In this article we have tried to assess intent and reality. The intent of PFRDA is to ensure a
smooth retirement life through market-based returns to the subscribers. Does the intent and
reality in the same direction? Are the NPS fund managers generating market-based return
for subscriber of NPS without putting retirement saving at substantial risk? Or is it a case of
otherwise?
Benefit under the CG&SG scheme depends upon the investment returns of the fund
managers over the years. The employee would get the benefit at the time of retirement in
form of lumpsum withdrawal of 60% accumulated corpus in the retirement account and the
subscriber has to purchase an annuity worth minimum of 40% of corpus, from the insurance
companies registered under the PFRDA. The annuity service provider would give monthly
pension to the retiree according to the purchase price and terms of annuity chosen.
Private Sector (All Citizen): All Citizen is a defined contribution, covers all the subscribers
enrolled under NPS through their corporate employer, individual registration or professional
subscribers from unorganized sector. All citizen subscribers have both the option to choose
the fund managers of their own and also have the option to choose the class of securities and
portion of contribution to be invested in those securities from the three classes of securities
such as Government Securities, Corporate debts and equity. Investment exposure is capped at
100% for government securities, 100% for corporate debts and 75% for equity of companies.
There are two investment options in the all-citizen scheme first one is Active Choice second
one is Auto Choice Life cycle funds. In active choice the subscriber would decide what
would be the percentage investment in three different classes of securities such as G-Sec,
Corporate Debts and Equity, subject to maximum ceiling of investment of 75% in equity. If
a subscriber does not make active choice, then his contribution would be invested according
to the life cycle fund (auto choice). Under life cycle fund the subscriber investment and
risk exposure would be decided on the basis of his age, in the early stage of working more
money would be in invested in Equity and Corporate debts and less would be invested in
government securities and as the subscriber grow older, investment exposure to equity and
corporate debt would be gradually reduced by fund managers.
In All Citizen Scheme, there might be co-contribution from employer otherwise sole
contribution from the employee or subscriber who is self-employed. This is also a defined
contribution scheme; the contribution amount is managed by both public and private sector
fund managers. At present there are 7 pension fund managers operating under NPS All
Citizen Scheme to manage the contribution. Following are the seven Pension Fund managers
1. SBI Pension Funds Pvt. Ltd., 2.UTI Retirement Solutions Ltd., 3. LIC Pension Fund
Ltd., 4. Kotak Mahindra Pension Fund Ltd., 5. Birla Sunlife Pension Management
Ltd., 6. ICICI Prudential Pension Funds Management Co. Ltd. and 7. HDFC Pension
Management Co. Ltd.
Benefit to the subscriber would be the accumulated money in PRAN (Permanent Retirement
Account Number) through investment returns generated by the fund managers. The
subscriber could withdraw maximum of 60% of accumulated corpus in the retirement
account, remaining 40% would be utilized to buy annuity from the insurance company who
would provide the monthly pension to the retiree.
There are two types of account namely Tier-1 and Tier-2 for both the government and private
sector employees. Tier-1 account which a compulsory retirement account and no withdrawal
could be made from this account before retirement (except limited 3 premature withdrawal
permitted with a gap of 5 years for each subsequent withdrawal for specified purpose). Tier-
2 account is optional, just like a saving account where deposit and withdrawal could be made
anytime. The benefit of tier-2 account is that contribution in this account is managed by NPS
fund managers at lower fund management fees.
Recently some of the committee appointed by the PFRDA are advocating for more active
equity leaning strategy for pension fund managers.
In 2014, PFRDA set up an expert committee under the chairmanship of former SEBI and
LIC chief G N Bajpai to review the investment norms for NPS schemes in the private sector.
The committee recommended additional scope and freedom for pension fund managers in
diversifying investment portfolio under NPS scheme.
Introduction of new assets classes like Covered notes, Commercial papers, Certificate of
Deposits, Repo, Reverse Repo, Collateralised Borrowing and Lending Obligations (CBLO),
derivatives for the purpose of hedging etc. The Committee also advocated for assets backed
securities, private equity and Venture capital funds. The committee expressed concern about
low risk -low return government sector assets class by NPS funds managers and suggested
reforms will orient fund managers towards equity and other non-government securities.
Providing scope for private sector pension funds to manage the funds of the government
sector employees. Equating the investment guidelines of the government and private sector
employees. Shifting the orientation of pension fund manager’s investment practice from
fixed low return government securities to high risk-high return equity investment.
Increasing the ceiling of Equity investment of government sector employees from 15% to
50%. Gradually improving the ceiling to 75%. Allowing the life cycle funds equity cap up
to 75%. The Committee also proposed active fund management strategy instead of passive
fund management strategy. Allowing for participation of pension fund managers in both
primary and secondary market equity investment. In addition, recommendations were made
to remove the investment limits in government securities. There should not be ceiling on
investment on any assets class and there may be a negative list of assets on the basis of past
experience. (G.N.Bajpai Committee Report, 2015)
Accordingly in 2015-16 PFRDA has allowed following exposure, in active choice for
corporate sector employees/subscribers. Exposure in Equity Assets Class (E) is raised up
to 75%, Corporate Bonds Asset Class (C) is up to 100%,Government Securities Asset Class
(G) is up to 100% and Alternate Asset Class (A) is up to 5% respectively.
There is also talk of harmonization of investment pattern of corporate sector employees and
government sector employees and accordingly increasing the ceiling of equity exposure
of government sector employees from 15% to 50%. Gradually equity ceiling would be
increased to 75% in active choice.
2. Research Methodology
2.1 Descriptive statistics
Descriptive statistics quantitatively summarize the patterns and general trends of a data set
in a single representative value. It enables a reader to quickly understand and interpret vast
set of data by describing its main features. Following are some of the descriptive statistics
which have been used in study.
Mean return (annual average return): has been used to calculate average return of pension
fund managers.
Holding period return could be calculated by considering one day, week, month, quarter or
year as one period. For example, NAV per unit on 1/4/2008 is 10 rupees of SBI PF Managers
invested in Corporate Debt Tier-1 scheme, suppose the NAV per unit has grown to 11.23 on
31/3/2009 after one year then periodic return would be as follows
(11.23-10)
= *100 = 12.3%
(10) )
Geometric mean (GM): is used to calculate the (CAGR) Compound Annual Growth Rate or
Compound Annual returns of fund managers.
For example, in the initial starting year, on 1/4/2008 TIER-1 Equity NAV of UTI retirement
solutions Pension Fund Managers was 10 rupee per unit, let suppose it has grown to 20 rupee
per unit as on 31/3/2015 then the CAGR would be as follows
(1/n)
Terminal NAV Valu)
CAGR/GM= -1 *100
Intial NAV Valu)
In this equation the ‘n’ is number of periods; in our example 1/4/2008 to 31/3/2015 is 7
periods considering the compounding happens annually.
(1/7
20
CAGR/GM= -1 *100 =10.40 %
10
In some of the earlier research works of performance evaluation it was found that sometime
investors misguidedly assume that, the success of their portfolio depends on the returns
alone but very few consider that the risk they undertook to achieve those returns. In the
present day, we have three sets of popular performance measurement tools to assist the fund
managers and individual investors in the evaluation of portfolio. The Treynor, Sharpe and
Jensen ratios which combine risk and return performance into a single value, but they are
different from each other in some aspects. All these measures derive their basic principle
from the Capital Assets Pricing Model (CAPM). These measures are industry standard since
nineteen-sixties. I have found that these measures have been used in several literatures to
study the performance of institutional fund managers. (Treynor, 1965), (Sharpe, 1966),
(Jensen, 1968), (Panigrahi, 1996), (Sias & W., 1996), (P. A. Gompers, 2001) have used
these ratio to compare the performance of mutual funds with the benchmark and the
competitors.
Treynor measure
The present-day portfolio evaluation technique could be traced back to the Jack L. Treynor,
who introduced Reward to Volatility Ratio as performance measures for any fund managers’
performance ranking. Excess returns of the portfolio over the risk-free return is expressed in
relation to portfolio’s systematic risk is the Treynor ratio (TR). Higher the TR higher is the
relative performance of fund manager. (Treynor, 1965).
Treynor suggested, there were two components of risk: the risk produced by fluctuations
in the market and the risk arising from the volatility of individual securities. He advocates
the unsystematic risk that is the fluctuation arising out of volatility of individual security in
the portfolio could be minimized to nothing with proper diversification. While the Treynor
Measures only consider the systematic risk β as the risk measures which capture market risk
arising out of relative volatility between the portfolio and the market.
The Treynor measure, also known as the reward to volatility ratio, defined as:
The numerator identifies the excess returns or risk premium and the denominator with
the risk of the portfolio. The resulting value represents the portfolio's return per unit risk.
The TR (Treynor Ratio) is a relative measure. Therefore, Treynor Ratio is used to evaluate
comparative performance of fund manager or with index benchmark performance, greater
the Treynor ratio higher the efficiency of fund manager.
To better understand how this works, suppose that the 10-year average annual return for the
S&P BSE 100 (market portfolio) is 10%, while the average annual return on Government of
India 364 days Treasury bills (a good proxy for the risk-free rate) let say 5%. Then assume
we are evaluating three distinct pension funds port-folio managers, with the following 10-
year results:
The higher the Treynor measure, the better the portfolio. If you had been evaluating the
portfolio manager (or port-folio) on returns alone, you may have inadvertently identified
pension fund manager C as having yielded the highest results. However, when considering
the risks that each manager took to attain their respective returns, pension fund manager B
demonstrated the better outcome. In this example, pension fund managers B and C have
outperformed the market index with the higher Treynor value, pension fund managers A is
the underperformer among three with lowest Treynor ratio/value.
CovJ,m covariance of portfolio returns and market returns
Calculation of Beta, β = =
Varm market variance
In our study for the purpose of calculation Beta, (β), by observing the assets allocation and
portfolio disclosure of pension fund managers following market indices have been selected
for Beta, (β) calculation.
For Risk free Rate we have considered 364 days RBI T-bills rate in 2019-20 that is 5.16%.
Treynor measure considers the systematic risk only, it assumes that the fund managers have
already has adequately diversified the portfolio and, therefore, unsystematic risk is not
considered. As a result, this performance measure should only be used by investors who
hold diversified portfolios. (Treynor, 1965)
Sharpe ratio
Later in (Sharpe, 1966) came up with little variation to the Treynor majors. In order to avoid
the problem of risk calculation under Treynor measures, the Sharpe measures considered
both systematic and unsystematic risk in calculating risk. The Sharpe ratio just like Treynor
ratio the only difference was the denominator in the equation, Treynor has used portfolio
beta (βp) as risk of portfolio whereas Sharpe has used Portfolio standard (σp) deviation
(which includes both systematic and unsystematic risk) as a risk measure.
In his study Willium Sharpe attempted to predict future performance of fund managers by
applying this Sharpe ratio. He collected the data of actual returns and calculated standard
deviation of 34 fund managers for last 20 years and divided the period into 10 years each.
Thereafter he calculated Sharpe ratio differently for each 10-years period for all those fund
managers. In the study he found that, the fund managers whose Sharpe ratio was higher in
the first 10 years, it was also high in the last 10 years period for most of the fund managers.
To check the validity of his finding, he also used Treynor ratio and found the same result.
Sharpe conclusion was fund managers performed better in the past would more likely to
perform better in future. Sharpe himself believes that no methods and model could predict
the future performance perfectly.
The Sharpe ratio is similar to the Treynor measure, but there is a difference in the denominator
of the Sharpe ratio which consider portfolio standard deviation as measures of risk which
combine both systematic risk and unsystematic risk whereas Treynor measures only consider
systematic or market risk β.
Assuming that the S&P BSE 100 had an average return of 10% and standard deviation of 15%
over a 10-year period, let's determine the Sharpe ratios for the following portfolio managers:
Once again, we find that the best portfolio is not necessarily the one with the highest return.
Instead, it's the one with the most superior risk-adjusted return, or in this case the fund
managed by pension fund manager Y had been efficient in the 10-year period. In the above
example of Sharpe ratio of all the pension fund managers have outperformed the benchmark
S&P BSE 100 index.
Likewise, Treynor ratio the Sharpe ratio is also a relative measure hence a single Sharpe
value has no interpretation.
Unlike the Treynor measure, the Sharpe ratio evaluates the portfolio manager on the basis
of both rate of return and diversification (as it considers total portfolio risk as measured by
standard deviation in its denominator). Therefore, the Sharpe ratio is more appropriate for
well diversified portfolios, because it more accurately considers the risks of the portfolio.
(Sharpe, 1966)
Jensen alpha
Like the previous performance measures discussed, the Jensen measure is also based on
CAPM. The Jensen measures calculates the excess return that a portfolio generates over
its expected return, it may give positive or negative value called Alpha. If the Alpha is
positive and higher than other, it indicates that the fund a manager has performed better and
a negative Alpha indicate bad performance. Unlike the Treynor Measure and Sharpe ratio,
Jensen Alpha is an absolute measure of performance.
The Jensen ratio measures how much of the portfolio's rate of return is attributable to the
manager's ability to deliver above-average returns, adjusted for market risk. The higher the
alpha, the better the risk-adjusted returns. A portfolio with a consistently positive excess
return will have a positive alpha, while a portfolio with a consistently negative excess return
will have a negative alpha. (Jensen, 1968)
Jensen’s Alpha= (Actual Portfolio Return – Expected Portfolio Return with given Beta)
E(r)= Risk Free Rate + Beta (Return of Market – Risk Free Rate of Return)
Average
Manager Annual Beta(β) ER of PF Alpha
Return
Pension Fund D 11% 0.90 5 + 0.90 (10-5) = 9.5% 11%- 9.5% = 1.5%
Pension Fund E 16% 1.14 5 + 1.14 (10-5) = 10.7% 16%- 10.7% = 5.3%
Pension Fund F 18% 1.26 5 + 1.26 (10-5) = 11.3% 18%- 11.3% = 6.7%
First, we calculate the portfolio's expected return then we calculate the portfolio's alpha by
subtracting the expected return of the portfolio from the actual return.
Pension Fund managers F did better instead of high beta, because it has provided better
return given the higher market risk of portfolio.
Portfolio performance measures should be a key aspect of the investment decision process.
These tools provide the necessary information for investors to assess how effectively their
money has been invested (or may be invested). Remember, portfolio returns are only part of
the story, without evaluating risk-adjusted returns, an investor cannot possibly see the whole
investment picture, which may inadvertently lead to clouded investment decisions.
Historical NAV data and Port-folio information have been collected from respective pension
fund manager’s website.
Indices Value and Historical figures were collected from BSE and NSE websites.
Scheme and investment norms, fund managers information have been collected from
PFRDA Website, Annual Reports, Master circular and Monthly bulletin of PFRDA.
Period of study is from 1st April 2008 to 31st March 2020 (twelve years). Though NPS was
roll out in 2004 actual investment started taking place since 2008.
For the purpose of this study the following four fund managers have been selected on the
basis of their long periods of operation as pension fund managers under NPS architecture.
The following four fund managers have been managing NPS corpus since the inception of
investment.
Two (PFs) for government sectors employees. (Government Sector Pension Fund Managers)
1. SBI Pension Funds Pvt. Ltd.
2. UTI Retirement Solutions Ltd.
Four (PFs) for private sectors employees and self-employed. (Private Sector Pension Fund
Managers)
1. SBI Pension Funds Pvt. Ltd.
2. UTI Retirement Solutions Ltd.
3. ICICI Prudential Pension Funds Management Co. Ltd.
4. Kotak Mahindra Pension Funds Ltd.
CORP.DEBT- GOV.SEC
SCHEMES CG SCHEME SG SCHEME EQUITY TIER-1
TIER-1 TIER-1
CAGR (%)
CAGR (%)
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
ANNUAL
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
RETURN
2009-10 13.04 16.7 6.33 6.33 7.95 7.95 9.94 9.94 10.02 10.02
2010-11 11.35 8.12 8.09 9.92 8 8.1 11.29 12.7 11.13 12.27
2011-12 9.94 5.89 7.67 6.86 2.73 -7.01 11.22 11.14 9.22 5.49
2012-13 10.5 12.76 8.98 13.03 4.08 8.27 11.97 14.27 10.27 13.54
2013-14 9.37 3.92 7.92 3.85 7.23 20.88 10.58 5.18 8.18 0.26
2014-15 10.74 19.38 9.81 19.79 10.48 28.33 11.41 15.74 10.17 20.74
2015-16 10.19 6.5 9.35 6.66 7.77 -7.14 11.03 8.73 9.74 7.17
2016-17 10.52 13.17 9.83 13.29 9.43 21.84 11.14 11.96 10.07 12.46
2017-18 10.06 6.1 9.39 5.96 9.53 10.36 10.6 6.4 9.52 5.22
2018-19 9.96 8.98 9.33 8.84 9.88 13.1 10.34 8.06 9.47 9.04
2019-20 9.82 8.33 9.27 8.63 6.13 -25.01 10.42 11.19 9.94 14.86
All the schemes seem to have stable Annual Returns except Equity Scheme, volatility in
equity return could be visualized in the diagram. One striking observation in the table as
well as in the diagram, that CAGR of Equity Tier -1 as on 31st March 2020 is 6.13%.
CAGR SBI PF has Come down to 6.13% because of negative 25.1% returns in financial
year 2019-20. This reduced CAGR indicate substantial variation in pension benefit between
two subscribers provided significant portion is invested in equity. One who is retiring during
March 2020 will get much less benefit compare to one who is retiring during March 2019.
The fall in CAGR in March 2020 in Equity Scheme was because of nationwide lockdown to
curb the spread of Covid-19. In the past one-decade equity scheme has generated negative
returns across the fund managers for three financial years (2011-12,2015-16, and 2019-20).
CAGR (%)
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
ANNUAL
RETURN
2008-09 11.53 11.53
2009-10 11.06 10.63 5.93 5.93 25.93 25.93 4.01 4.01 1.97 1.97
2010-11 10.14 8.38 8.51 11.19 16.29 7.42 6.56 9.18 7.04 12.45
2011-12 9.02 5.75 7.76 6.34 7.46 -8.19 7.77 10.3 5.93 3.84
2012-13 9.65 12.3 9.1 13.25 7.45 7.43 9.15 13.46 7.79 13.64
2013-14 8.87 5.06 8.2 4.73 9.97 20.66 8.53 6.15 6.38 0.93
2014-15 10.2 18.57 9.89 18.79 13.04 29.76 9.59 15.07 8.56 20.21
2015-16 9.7 6.25 9.37 6.34 9.98 -6.68 9.48 8.83 8.36 7.17
2016-17 10.13 13.65 9.89 13.59 11.15 22.95 9.8 12.04 8.76 11.68
2017-18 9.73 6.26 9.45 6.07 11.48 11.12 9.36 5.95 8.25 4.26
2018-19 9.63 8.61 9.36 8.59 11.57 12.37 9.12 6.99 8.28 8.6
2019-20 9.43 7.24 9.18 7.37 7.29 -27.44 9.28 10.87 8.82 14.42
Similar observation could be made for the returns of UTI retirement solutions. In the
financial year 2019-2020 all the fund managers have provided negative returns in equity
scheme in the range of 25 to 30%. Equity CAGR is in the similar range of 6 to 7% ,lagging
behind current wholesale price index.
Equity, Corporate debt and G-Sec scheme have similar CAGR in previous years, however
the volatility in equity returns is considerably high.
Performance of the private fund managers, ICICI Prudential Pension Funds Management
Co. Ltd. and Kotak Mahindra Pension Funds Ltd is also similar to the public sector fund
managers that could be witnessed from similar diagrams depicting all the schemes. Returns
of Corporate Debt and G-Sec schemes are subject to interest rate and credit default risk.
Returns from the Corporate Debt and G-Sec schemes are inversely related to market interest
rate. Rise in interest rate could reduce the value of such debt securities and vice versa. In
2013-14 RBI raised repo rates to 8 percentage points, accordingly market interest rates were
high, as a consequence all the fund managers have reported returns less than 2% in G-Sec
scheme, G-Sec returns of SBI was as low as 0.26% in 2013-14. Accordingly in 2020 RBI
reduced policy repo rate to 4% to ease businesses, which resulted in lower interest rate in the
market as a result all the fund managers have reported around 15% return in G-sec Schemes.
Corporate debt seems to have relatively lesser impact of interest rate change compare to
G-sec. Corporate debt has provided relatively stable returns in comparison to other schemes
in past 12 years with less volatility.
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
ANNUAL
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
RETURN
All the schemes operating under NPS across fund managers have delivered a CAGR of 9 to
11% in the past 12 years of operations. All the fund managers seem to have similar range of
Annual returns and CAGR across the schemes. Close inspection reveals that, fund managers
are investing in almost similar portfolio with minor variation. Moreover, they have same
investment guidelines from the pension fund regulator (PFRDA).
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
CAGR(%)
ANNUAL RETURN
AR(%)
AR(%)
AR(%)
2009-10 14.20 14.20 10.00 10.00 3.50 3.50
Like all other pension fund managers, we could observe volatility in equity schemes and
stable returns for Corporate debt scheme in the Kotak Mahindra PF. It is also visible in the
diagram that G sec scheme returns are relatively more volatile compare to corporate debts
and relatively less volatile compare to equity scheme across fund managers.
The following tables contains the CAGR, average returns, standard deviation, coefficient of
variation, Sharpe Ratio (S.R), Treynor Ratio (T.R) and Jensen’s Alpha (J.A) of four pension
fund managers for different schemes under NPS.
The following tables are author’s self-calculation and compilation, from the NAV data of
fund managers and Indexes. The following tables are based on data up to 31 March 2020.
Given above calculations and analysis we came to the following finding and implications
that, in the past 12 years CAGR returns from Equity Scheme were 6.13% for SBI Pension
Funds, 7.2% for UTI Retirement Solutions,7.44 % for ICICI Prudential Pension Funds and
6.76% for Kotak Mahindra Pension Funds respectively, which are just above the RBI’s
inflation targeting upper range of 6%. And the average annual periodic returns of these four
fund managers for Equity scheme were 7.24%, 8.67%, 8. 73 %, 7.91% along with coefficient
of variation of 201.39%, 188.55%, 178.95% ,198.96 % respectively. These coefficients of
variation indicate a very high degree of volatility for the given level of returns generated
under equity scheme, across the fund managers. All the risk adjusted measures also indicate
the underperformance of equity scheme. Sharpe Ratio for the Equity Scheme is the lowest
in comparison to all other scheme of NPS across all fund managers selected for the study,
which implicates equity portfolio are not generating the justified desired return for the given
amount risk undertaken.
Here someone may argue that, it is quite immature to generalize the underperformance of
equity scheme because of an unprecedented dip in the stock market in a given year. An event
like COVID-19, nationwide lockdown, ban on export import which brings business to a
standstill could very well bring the stock market to a sudden plunge. However, one counter
argument to this could be, the return under equity scheme before the Covid-19, was not so
impressive given the risk undertaken under equity scheme. Both the Corporate Debt and
G-Sec schemes were generating similar range of 9% to 11% CAGR and Average Annual
Returns with considerably less volatility. In the past one decade of experience in equity
investment, we have seen in three different years, equity investment has generated negative
returns. In spite of better positive return in many years average returns is not so high for
equity because of the negative returns in some years are dragging the average down.
One may further argue that, are we protected from such kind risk in future? There may be
many unforeseen events in future which may bring surprising turns of events and dive in
the stock market, accordingly in the equity scheme. Event like Covid-19 lays foundation
for another layer of protection of old age income security like contribution insurance. If
the invested money falls short to the contribution, then what is the sense of investment
for retirement protection. The COVID-19 crisis revealed one more thing that, the equity
investment could plunge up to 25% to 40% in a span 10 to 15 days. From the above diagram
it is visible that, from April 2019 to March 2020 the Equity scheme has generated a negative
return of 25% to 28% with sufficient diversification by fund managers. All the major indices
like NSE Nifty 50, S&P BSE SENSEX, NSE Nifty 100, S&P BSE 100 took a dive of almost
40% in March 2020. Alternatively, it means someone’s retirement saving could very well
reduce by 25 % to 40% in a given month. If I put it in a more simplified terms, someone’s
retirement account had a 2 crore rupees balance in equity segment two week ago which has
become 1.2 crore two weeks after and he/ she could do nothing about it. Over reliance on
equity could reduce the retirement benefit significantly.
Almost all the risk adjusted measures are indicating the performance of Corporate Debt is
better than Government Securities and Equity Scheme.
One who is a firm believers of Equity investment will argue that, short term volatility is a
persistent features of equity investment, equity investment gives better returns in the long
run. Hence, one should not be worried about short term volatility. Then, my argument would
be, what if someone is retiring in the month March of 2020 and he is an active choice investor
with 75% allocation in Equity scheme. His retirement saving will reduce remarkably. And
we do not decide our retirement date.
The CG & SG schemes applicable for government employees have also delivered relatively
better return in comparison to exclusive investment in equity for the same fund managers
with less volatility. The CG& SG schemes have less than 15% fund allocation to equity
instruments.
We also know corporate debts and G-sec are not the safest investment they are also subject
to credit and interest rate risk. However, in the past these securities seem to have generated
moderate returns with less volatility.
3. Concluding Remarks
The fall of CAGR in March 2020 in Equity Scheme was because of nationwide lockdown
to curb the spread of Covid-19. There could be many more surprising turns of event may
it be war, bio chemical attack, banking crisis, financial crisis, financial scams or any other
unprecedented adverse event which could bring very high volatility in the short run. Which
could reduce the benefit to the subscriber retiring in the same period of crisis. Could we
avoid such kind of plunge in security market altogether? The answer is, no? What could be
possible solution?
Firstly, excessive reliance on equity investment and generous equity investment guidelines
needs to be reconsidered. Equity has the potential to reduce the benefit of the subscriber
significantly as witnessed in March 2020. The CAGR of equity was around 6 to 7% in
12 years which is similar to the inflation rate in the economy. From the above analysis
we have observed that equity is generating the CAGR in the similar range like corporate
debts, in some cases less than CAGR of Corporate debt scheme. However, volatility is quite
higher for the equity scheme as depicted by coefficient of variations for the given levels of
returns generated. Equity investment ceiling needs to be brought down to around 30 to 35%,
otherwise the concept of retirement security would be at risk. This 30 to 35% is a substantial
allocation in one assets class, this portion of investment could give a desired push to the
returns of subscriber. The return may not be significantly high but it will secure the purpose
retirement security.
Another solution, the policy maker could make the exit window flexible. The subscribers
shall have the flexibility of 10 years of exit window from NPS system, i.e., from 55 to 65
years. So that impact of short-term volatility could be minimized. The subscriber will exercise
his exit option when the retirement corpus and market returns suit him. For example, on 31
March 2020, equity scheme has negative 30% annual returns, if the subscriber is retiring in
the same month and making the withdrawal in the same period, his/her benefit would be very
low. If this flexibility of exit window be there, he/she may postpone or prepone his exit from
NPS considering the optimum benefit for self. Subscriber will choose a time period when the
benefits and corpus seem to be favorable, and accordingly apply for exit from NPS.
Third option could be protection through insurance purchase, but it will be expensive. In
period of crisis or pandemic honoring insurance contract is also quite questionable and
contingent.
All the schemes have generated CAGR in the range of 9 to 11%, why to put much emphasis
on equity by inviting additional risk component. Thirteen year of experience in equity scheme
under NPS architecture has indicated one thing, for similar range of returns the Corporate
Debts and Government Securities have undertaken relatively lesser risk. Even average
returns and CAGR of Corporate Debts and G-Sec are stable and higher in some years. In
our study we have seen that, the equity scheme is not generating substantially higher returns
for the substantially higher risk undertaken. Inviting additional risk to generate lower or
similar range of average returns or CAGR does not brings lot of financial sense. Excessive
dependence on equity has the potential to reduce the benefits to the subscriber substantially
too. Are we ready to put our retirement saving to such risk or shall we settle for moderate
returns? The policy makers need to reconsider the intention of aggressive expansion in the
ceiling of equity investment, when there is no layer of protection for downward deviation
under NPS architecture. Moreover, short term crisis or volatility are persistent to Equity
Market which seems to have lots of impact on equity scheme.
Limitations: Study could include a greater number of fund managers. Study could be
undertaken for tier-2 schemes of NPS.
References
OASIS Committee Report. (1999). Old Age Social and Income Security. Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment .
G.N. Bajpai Committee Report. (2015). INVESTMENT GUIDELINES FOR NATIONAL PENSION
SYSTEM (NPS) SCHEMES IN PRIVATE SECTOR. PFRDA.
Treynor, J. (1965). How to rate management of investment funds’, Harvard Business Review. Harvard
Business Review, 43, 63-75.
Sharpe, W. (1966, January). Performance of Mutual Funds. The Journal of Business, 39, 119-138.
Jensen, M. (1968). The Performance of Mutual Funds in the period 1945-1964. Journal of Finance,
23(2).
Panigrahi, M. S. (1996). Mutual Funds: Growth, Performance and Prospects. Economic and Political
Weekly, 31(12).
Sias, & W., R. (1996). Volatility and the Institutional Investor. Financial Analysts Journal, 52(2), 13-
20.
P. A. Gompers, A. M. (2001). Institutional Investors and Equity Prices. The Quarterly Journal of
Economics, 216-259.
Bombay Stock Exchange. (2020, may 25). BSE India. Retrieved from https://www.bseindia.com:
https://www.bseindia.com/sensex/IndicesWatch_Weight.aspx?iname=BSE100&index_Code=22
ASIA INDEX Pvt. Ltd. (2020, May 6). Retrieved from https://www.asiaindex.co.in: https://www.
asiaindex.co.in/indices/fixed-income/sp-bse-india-corporate-bond-index
ASIA INDEX Pvt. Ltd. (2020, June 7). Retrieved from www.asiaindex.co.in: https://www.asiaindex.
co.in/indices/fixed-income/sp-bse-india-government-bond-index
Pension Fund Rgulatory and Development Authority. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.pfrda.org.in
ICICI PRUDENTIAL PENSION FUND LTD. (2020, JULY 1, 5, 6). Retrieved from www.
iciciprupensionfund.com/: https://www.iciciprupensionfund.com/NPS/#/public-disclosure/nav-
history
SBI PENSION FUND Pvt. Ltd. (2020, August 2,4,6,7,8). Retrieved from https://www.sbipensionfunds.
com: https://www.sbipensionfunds.com/historical-nav/
UTI Retirement Solutions . (2020, August 1,2,3,4,6). UTI Mutual Fund. Retrieved from www.utimf.
com: https://www.utimf.com/retirement-solutions/historical-nav/
Abstract
Purpose of this study is to measure characteristics of core capital ratio, bank capital, deposit,
net profit after tax, and earnings per share and their separate relationship and measure the
individual impact of core capital ratio, bank capital, and deposit on financial performance
i.e., net profit after tax (NPAT) and earnings per share (EPS). Descriptive, correlational,
and casual comparative research design has been used in this study. This study analyzed
secondary data of twenty-six commercial banks from fiscal year 2012/13 to 2018/19 out of
twenty-seven. Descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, and regression analysis statistical
tools were used in this study. According to its findings, earnings per share is highly dispersed
in comparison to net profit after tax as well as core capital ratio than bank capital. There is
high degree of positive relationship in between net profit after tax and deposit. Low degree
of positive relation in NPAT and core capital ratio and moderate degree of positive relation in
NPAT and Bank capital. Low degree of positive relation of EPS with deposit and low degree
of inverse relation of EPS with core capital. Core capital ratio, bank capital, and deposit
positive effects for increasing NPAT. Out of its, deposit highly effect. Deposit positive effects
for increase on EPS. High contribution of deposit and core capital to increase net profit. The
results of this study have relevance and probable generalizability about the impact of capital
adequacy ratio and deposit to increase financial performance of commercial banks in Nepal.
1. Introduction
Bank deposits consist of money placed into the Bank by its customers. These deposits are
made to deposit accounts such as fixed deposit accounts, savings accounts, margin deposit
accounts, call deposit accounts and current accounts. Deposits and borrowings (debt
securities issued) are the source of funds of the bank in addition to its reserves.
European Banks with higher deposits and loans ratio tend to be more profitable but the
effects on profitability are statistically insignificant in some cases (Menicucci & Paolucci,
2016). Deposits and borrowings (including debts securities issued) are initially measured
at fair value minus incremental direct transaction cost and subsequently measured at their
amortized cost using the effective interest method, except where the Bank designates
liabilities at fair value through profit or loss. a significant and negative correlation between
the liquidity creation and performance of Islamic banks, using return on average equity
measure (Sahyouni & Wang, 2019). Need for improving capital adequacy and reducing the
ratio of non-interest assets as a way to improve profitability (Husain & Abdullah, 2008).
Tier-1 Capital has a negative effect to profitability in Indonesian Commercial Banks (Sari,
Suhadak, Rahayu, & Solimun). The capital adequacy ratio (CAR) is a measurement of a
bank's available capital expressed as a percentage of a bank's risk-weighted credit exposures.
The capital adequacy ratio, also known as capital-to-risk weighted assets ratio (CRAR),
is used to protect depositors and promote the stability and efficiency of financial systems
around the world. Two types of capital are measured: tier-1 capital, which can absorb losses
without a bank being required to cease trading, and tier-2 capital, which can absorb losses
in the event of a winding-up and so provides a lesser degree of protection to depositors. The
study also revealed that GDP per capita, market capitalization and banks size have no impact
on profitability (Ahamad, 2019). perhaps
For two decades, the capital adequacy ratio (CAR) requirement has been one of the primary
regulatory mechanisms used to monitor banks. Presently, most regulators around the world
follow the Basel Accord, under which CARs are calculated by dividing a firm’s regulatory
capital (Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3) by the firm’s risk-weighted assets (RWAs). However,
many banking practitioners and researchers have argued that CARs now have less relevance
due to the change from the historical-cost-based accounting regime to the fair-value-based
system (Anagnostopoulos and Buckland, 2005). Credit deposit ratio (CRDR) reduced the
profitability of private banks and public banks in India (Bansal, Singh, Kumar, & Gupta,
2018). Specifically, under the former system, balance sheet items were based on the book
values of assets and liabilities, while under the latter regime a great portion of financial assets
and liabilities (and hence, the regulatory capital) are determined on a marked-to-market
basis. As a result, the introduction of fair-value reporting may cause increased “unnecessary”
volatility of earnings and thus lead to the decreased relevance of CARs (Chisnall, 2000;
Allen and Carletti, 2008; Heaton et al., 2010).
Return on assets, the loans to deposit ratio, the logarithm of personnel, and the logarithm
of income of per capita, all have a positive and statistically significant impact on overall
efficiency change (Gaganis, Liadaki, Doumpos & Zopounidis (2009). Application of fair-
value accounting in the Taiwan banking industry is fairly similar to that of international or
US GAAP, and using Taiwan data also offers empirical advantages (as mentioned in the
previous paragraph), these results also yield insights into other standard-setters (Liao, 2013).
Second, a clear policy implication is related to the urgent need to seek feasible measures
for mitigating possible negative effects (Liao, 2013). More specifically, since as-if cost-
based CARs convey superior information at least under some circumstances, requiring
the explicit disclosure of cost-based CARs may aid users in assessing banks’ insolvency
risks. Additionally, users should evaluate banks’ disclosure quality before basing economic
decisions on fair-value-based CARs. Regulators and standard-setters should make more
effort to enhance the reporting quality if a full, fair-value application is still the eventual
goal for the near future (Liao, 2013).
Capital regulation is an effective tool in enhancing the stability and the profitability of the
financial services sector. In addition, the paper finds a positive relationship between regulatory
pressure in terms of restrictions on deposits and non-bank financial institutions profitability
(Ofoeda, Gariba, & Amoah, 2016). Risk management is crucial to the banking industry.
Since the Basel Accord was introduced, the minimum CAR requirement has become a major
regulatory tool in various jurisdictions. By definition, a CAR is the ratio of a bank’s total
regulatory capital divided by the total amount of RWAs. Regulatory capital consists of three
types of capital – Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 – while RWAs refer to a bank’s assets weighted
according to credit, interest, and operational risk. Previous studies on CARs mainly center
on the influence of the capital requirement on the riskiness of banks. For instance, Shrieves
and Dahl (1992) shows that, for banks that were undercapitalized according to regulatory
standards, the minimum capital regulation was at least partially effective in forcing banks to
increase their capital or to decrease risks. Profitability is positively affected by banks’ cost-
effectiveness, asset quality and level of capitalization in Islamic bank (Zarrouk, Jedidia, &
Moualhi, 2016).
Konishi and Yasudab (2004) finds that implementing the capital adequacy requirement reduced
risk taking in Japanese commercial banks; the authors also found that a bank’s capital was
negatively related to risk taking. Recently, in 2009 in the aftermath of the financial crisis, the
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) proposed major revisions and additions
to the existing Basel II capital adequacy regime. The resultant proposed framework is termed
“Basel III,” and the G20 endorsed the new Basel III capital and liquidity requirements at the
November 2010 Summit in Seoul. In detail, several important amendments were endorsed.
First, banks are required to hold 4.5 percent of common equity (up from 2 percent in Basel
II) and 6 percent of Tier 1 capital (up from 4 percent in Basel II) as RWAs, while Tier 3
capital will be phased out completely. Second, Basel III introduces additional capital buffers:
a mandatory capital conservation buffer of 2.5 percent; and a discretionary counter cyclical
buffer, which allows national regulators to require up to another 2.5 percent of capital during
periods of high credit growth.
The liquidity coverage ratio requires a bank to hold sufficient high-quality liquid assets
to cover its total net cash outflows over 30 days; the net stable funding ratio requires the
available amount of stable funding to exceed the required amount of stable funding over
a one-year period of extended stress. Overall, the new requirements under Basel III seek
to improve the quality of the capital, increase risk weightings for derivatives and repos,
introduce a leverage ratio, and address pro-cyclicality. Therefore, Basel III is expected to
have a major impact on the financial institutions, such as: weaker banks being crowded out;
significant pressure on banks’ profitability; changes in demand from short-term to long-term
funding; reduced risk of a systematic banking crisis; and a decrease in lending capacity
(Shearman and Sterling, 2011; KPMG, 2012). Capital regulations are complementary and
significantly impact on European bank performance (Ayadi, Ayadi, & Trabelsi, 2019).
Based on above international studies comparative study of impact of core capital, bank
capital, and deposit on financial performance is still remaining. So, this is the research gap
of the study.
Based on this research gap, following research question has been developed.
1. What is the average value and disperse value of different study variables: like net
profit after tax, earning per share, core capital ratio i.e. Common Equity (Tier 1 to Risk
Weighted Exposure Ratio), bank capital, and deposit as well as their relationship?
2. What is the impact of core capital ratio, bank capital, and deposit on financial
performance?
This study provides contributions in two ways. First one is impact of core capital, bank
capital, and deposit on financial performance and second one is which highly effect on
financial performance.
2. Review of Literature
Recent theory on capital structure is based on the Modigliani and Miller’s (1958) influential
work on the effect of capital structure on the value of the firm. Their theory assumes perfect
markets and perfect competition in which firms operate without taxes or transaction cost and
where all relevant information is available without cost. However, these assumptions do not
hold in the real world or in practice and factors such as taxes, agency cost, cost of financial
distress and information asymmetry are important in explaining the capital structure of firms.
Hutchinson (1995) approved that in more general terms, financial leverage positive effect
on the firm’s return on equity provided that earnings’ power of the firm's assets (the ratio of
earnings before interest and taxes is divided by total assets) exceeds the average interest cost
of debt to the firm. He justified that the extent to which a firm’s earnings’ power is likely
to remain above the breakeven point and the potential speed or flexibility with which it can
adjust its debt usage, if its earnings’ power falls below average interest costs, should help to
determine the level of debt that the firm is willing to commit itself to at a given point in time.
CR
NPAT Deposit
Dependent Independent
Varibales Varibales
3. Methodology
Financial performance was measured through net profit after tax (NFAT) and earning per
share (EPS). Secondary sources of data were used in this study. This study occupied twenty-
six commercial banks out of twenty-seven. Rastriya Banijya Bank was excluded in this
study due to lack of annual audit report. Data were collected through annual audit report
of respective bank from fiscal year 2012/13 to 2018/19. So, total number of observations
were 182. Data were collected from annual audit report of concern bank. Mean, Range,
standard deviation, and coefficient of variation statistical tools were used in this study to
know individual characteristics of mention variables. So, this study used descriptive research
design. Correlation analysis statistical tool was used to understand relationship between
different mention variables. Multiple regression analysis statistical tools were used to
measure the impact of core capital ratio, bank capital, and deposit on financial performance.
So, this study also used correlational and casual comparative research design .
Dependent variable is net profit after (NPAT) tax of a firm i in a year t in regression (i) and
earning per share (EPS) of a firm i in a year t in regression (ii). Independent variables are
core capital ratio (CR) i.e. Common Equity (Tier 1 to Risk Weighted Exposure Ratio, bank
capital (BC), and deposit (DPT) of a firm i in a year t in both regression model.
Table one has presented that coefficient of variation of earning per share is greater than net
profit after tax. Bank capital is highly dispersed than core capital ratio i.e. Common Equity
(Tier 1 to Risk Weighted Exposure Ratio). Deposit highly dispersed than core capital ratio
and less dispersed than bank capital.
NPAT 1.000
EPS 0.424** 1.0000
CC 0.235** -0.229** 1.000
BC 0.61** 0.119 0.37** 1.000
Deposit 0.86 ** 0.27** 0.028 0.516** 1.000
Table two has presented: Pearson correlation analysis has approved that there is moderate
degree of positive relationship in between net profit after tax and bank capital at 1 % LOS.
High degree of positive relationship between net profit after tax and deposit at 1 % LOS.
Similarly, low degree of positive relationship at 1 % LOS in between net profit after tax and
earning per share as well as net profit after tax and core capital ratio. There is low degree of
inverse relationship between earning per share and core capital ratio but low degree of direct
relationship in between earning per share and deposit at 1 % LOS. Low degree of positive
relationship in between core capital ratio and bank capital ratio at 1 % LOS and moderate
degree of positive relationship in between bank capital and deposit at 1 % LOS.
Table three has showed: all regression models are statistically significant at 1 % LOS. Value
of variation inflation factor (VIF) of each independent variable of three regression models
is less than 10 approved that all regression models are free from multicollinearity problem.
Value of D.W. at 182 no. of observations approved that all regression models are free from
autocorrelation problem. Similarly, all regression models are free from heteroscedasticity
problem. More than 78 % area has explained each regression model. Coefficient value of
independent variable of each regression model is positive and statistically significant at 1 %
LOS. In regression model 1, coefficient value of Deposit 0.854 indicates that, when Deposit
variable will be increased by one unit under the condition of other thing will remain the same
on an average net profit after tax will be increased by 0.854 unit. Out of three independent
variables base on analysis of three regression models Deposit highly positive effect, core
capital ratio medium positive effect, and bank capital low positive effect for increasing net
profit after tax.
Table four has presented that all regression models are statistically significant at 1 % LOS.
All regression models are free from multicollinearity, autocorrelation, and heteroscedasticity
problem. All models are statistically significant at 1% LOS. According to regression result,
deposit positive effect for increasing earnings per share but core capital negative effect on
earnings per share.
This research findings supported on existing theory capital adequacy ratio and deposit effect
on financial performance on financial institution. This study has provided the knowledge of
commercial banks about impact of different capital as well as deposit. This study based on
seven fiscal years from fiscal years 2012/13 to 2018/19 of twenty-six commercial banks.
Number of observations are 182. No. of observation should be increased to measure the
impact of bank capital on earnings per share. Dimension of financial performance should
be increased i.e., to measure the impact of core capital ratio, bank capital, deposit on return
on assets, return on equity, net profit divided by total income, price earning ration etc.
Core capital ratio should be increased for decreasing risk and increase net profit margin.
Commercial banks of Nepal should be focused on deposit amount.
References
Ahmad, A. (2019). The determinants of conventional banks profitability in developing and
underdeveloped OIC countries. Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Science,
https:// doi.org/10.1108/JEFAS-05-2018-0043
Allen, F. and Carletti, E. (2008). Mark-to-market accounting and liquidity pricing. Journal of
Accounting and Economics, 45 (2/3), pp. 358-78.
Anagnostopoulos, Y. and Buckland, R. (2005). Historical cost vs. fair value accounting in banking.
Journal of Banking Regulation, Vol. 6 No. 4, pp. 109-27.
Athanasoglou, P.P., Brissmis, S.N. and Delis, M.D. (2008). Bank-specific, industry-specific and
macroeconomic determinants of bank profitability. Journal of International Financial Markets,
Institutions and Money, Vol. 18 No. 2, pp. 121-36.
Ayadi, A. Ayadi, N. and Trabelsi, S. (2019). Corporate governance, European bank performance and
the financial crisis. Managerial Auditing Journal, https://doi.org/10.1108/ MAJ-11-2017-1704
Permanent link to this document: https://doi.org/10.1108/MAJ-11-2017-1704
Bansal, R. Singh, A. Kumar, S. Gupta, R. (2018). Evaluating factors of profitability for Indian banking
sector: a panel regression. Asian Journal of Accounting Research, https:// doi.org/10.1108/AJAR-
08-2018-0026
Chisnall, P. (2000). Fair value accounting: an industry view. British Bankers’ Association, Balance
Sheet, Vol. 9 No. 1, pp. 27-33.
Gaganis, C. Liadaki, A. Doumpos, M. and Zopounidis, C. (2009). Estimating and analyzing the
efficiency and productivity of bank branches. Managerial Finance, Vol. 35 Iss 2 pp. 202 - 218
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/03074350910923518
Gautam, R. (2018). Determinants of financial performance: An evidence from Nepalese commercial
bank. Amity Journal of Strategic Management, 1(2), 7-13.
Heaton, J.C., Lucas, D. and McDonald, R.L. (2010). Is mark-to-market accounting destabilizing?
Analysis and implications for policy. Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 57 No. 1, pp. 64-75.
Husain, A. Abdullah, A. (2008). Bank-Specific Determinants of Profitability: The case of Kuwait.
Journal of Economic and Administrative Sciences, Vol. 24 Iss 2 pp. 20 - 34 http://dx.doi.
org/10.1108/10264116200800006
Hutchinson, R.W. (1995). The capital structure and investment decisions of the small owner-managed
firm: some explanatory issues. Small Business Economics, Vol. 7, p. 231.
Konishi, M. and Yasudab, Y. (2004). Factors affecting bank risk taking: evidence from Japan. Journal
of Banking & Finance, Vol. 28 No. 1, pp. 215-32.
KPMG (2012). Basel III: issues and implications”, available at: www.kpmg.com/global/en/
issuesandinsights/articlespublications/frontiers-in finance/ publishingimages/ february 2012/
february2012/ 21010.html
Liao, Y (2013). The impact of fair-value-accounting on the relevance of capital adequacy ratios
Evidence from Taiwan. Managerial Finance, Vol. 39 No. 2, 2013 pp. 133-154 q Emerald Group
Publishing Limited 0307-4358 DOI 10.1108/03074351311293990
Menicucci, E. Paolucci, G. (2016). The determinants of bank profitability: empirical evidence from
European banking sector. Journal of Financial Reporting and Accounting, Vol. 14 Issue: 1, pp.86-
115, https://doi.org/10.1108/JFRA-05-2015-0060
Ofoeda, I. Gariba, P. Amoah, L. (2016). Regulation and performance of non bank financial institutions
in Ghana. International Journal of Law and Management, Vol. 58 Iss 1 pp. 108 - 125 http://
dx.doi.org/10.1108/IJLMA-11-2014-0060
Modigliani, F. and Miller, M. (1958). The cost of capital, corporation finance and the theory of
investment. The American Economic Review. Vol. 48 No. 3, pp. 261-97.
Shearman and Sterling (2011). The new Basel III framework: implications for banking organizations.
Financial Institutions Advisory & Financial Regulatory.
Shrieves, R.E. and Dahl, D. (1992). The relationship between risk and capital in commercial banks.
Journal of Banking & Finance, Vol. 16 No. 2, pp. 439-57.
Sahyouni, A. and Wang, M. (2019). Liquidity creation and bank performance: evidence from MENA.
ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, https://doi.org/10.1108/IJIF-01-2018-0009
Permanent link to this document: https://doi.org/10.1108/IJIF-01-2018-0009
Sari, E. Suhadak, S. Rahayu, S. M. and Solimun, S. The effects of Tier-1 capital, risk management, and
profitability on performance of Indonesian commercial banks. International Journal of Law and
Management, https:// doi.org/10.1108/IJLMA-05-2017-0109
Zarrouk, H. Jedidia, K. B. Moualhi, M. (2016). Is Islamic bank profitability driven by same forces
as conventional banks? International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and
Management, Vol. 9 Iss 1 pp. 46 - 66 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/IMEFM-12-2014-0120
Appendix
EPS (Rupees)
Bank Capital
Core Capital
Ratio (%)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
Name of Bank
Deposit
NPAT
Nepal Bank F/Y
2075/76 26.99 2,596,736,045 15.87 22,244,812,860 118,275,000,000
Limited
2074/75 39.98 3,215,681,985 10.29 11,039,740,000 99,831,000,000
2073/74 38.77 1,747,123,778 13.37 12,158,918,000 93,944,000,000
2072/73 44.59 2,882,978,165 9.01 7,439,635,000 89,410,000,000
2071/72 7.48 483,848,520 6.32 4,398,193 77,999,000,000
2070/71 18.08 716,958,108 3.92 3,593,123,000 69,338,000,000
2069/70 198.53 755,180,353 -0.59 143,625,000 62,984,000,000
Agriculture 2075/76 42.88 4,191,590,635 19.27 140,232,067,893 118,884,922,831
Development Bank
2074/75 36.91 3,653,519,099 19.28 25,269,454,724 104,178,959,617
Limited
2073/74 31.59 2,973,280,536 18.61 23,448,862,000 99,816,272,142
2072/73 52.79 2,464,683,088 15.19 20,213,274,000 87,387,154,947
2071/72 78.83 3,603,370,808 15.17 18,654,158,000 77,035,056,186
2070/71 35.19 1,520,806,289 12.49 17,881,568,000 65,898,412,646
2069/70 59.03 2,289,319,963 13.61 16,950,972,000 54,477,651,530
Bank of 2075/76 23.53 1,896,956,036 13.22 13,712,689,915 83,327,700,000
Kathmandu
2074/75 19.46 1,321,187,647 13.39 12,821,881,661 76,913,800,000
Limited
2073/74 20.69 1,336,244,335 11.50 10,276,150,559 72,922,300,000
2072/73 14.86 655,275,698 10.64 9,303,246,256 68,066,100,000
2071/72 15.78 334,569,082 9.43 5,178,563,510 59,769,000,000
2070/71 13.25 254,441,782 8.77 34,116,000,000
2069/70 36.64 617,000,000 13.22 13,712,689,915 27,701,000,000
Citizens Bank 2075/76 17.49 1,463,218,780 13.22 11,980,895,685 74,136,000,000
Limited
2074/75 15.37 1,234,103,897 13.39 10,138,933,475 61,481,000,000
2073/74 20.27 1,634,917,774 11.50 9,987,371,000 52,719,000,000
2072/73 35.25 1,091,766,423 10.64 6,006,846,000 47,394,000,000
2071/72 30.94 720,308,502 9.43 4,479,702,000 35,782,000,000
2070/71 23.7 498,092,716 8.77 3,466,695,000 27,963,455,000
EPS (Rupees)
Bank Capital
Core Capital
Ratio (%)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
Name of Bank
Deposit
NPAT
F/Y
Global IME Bank 2075/76 26.79 2,761,953,667 10.56 17,350,622,000 124,499,000,000
Limited
2074/75 23.64 2,101,363,149 10.32 106,510,000,000
2073/74 25.51 2,006,159,460 10.23 11,543,265,922 101,910,000,000
2072/73 19.33 1,382,223,998 11.01 9,381,257,819 74,683,000,000
2071/72 15.58 960,608,067 11.24 7,908,636,000 60,176,000,000
2070/71 19.57 974,037,010 10.94 6,805,535,114 52,292,000,000
2069/70 16.15 449,218,454 9.17 3,874,581,100 34,111,000,000
Himalayan Bank 2075/76 32.44 2,763,848,475 11.63 15,871,587,201 113,090,000,000
Limited
2074/75 23.11 1,875,610,467 11.40 14,349,498,457 99,743,000,000
2073/74 33.55 2,178,234,893 10.93 12,613,817,027 92,881,114,255
2072/73 43.03 1,935,907,634 10.93 9,815,198,969 87,335,785,849
2071/72 33.37 1,112,285,716 9.43 8,041,967,083 73,538,200,185
2070/71 33.1 959,107,241 9.48 7,155,579,476 64,674,848,295
2069/70 34.19 943,697,990 8.96 6,414,437,452 53,072,319,487
Kumari Bank 2075/76 14.81 1,230,378,260 10.89 11,432,900,000 84,403,000,000
Limited
2074/75 14.54 1,046,488,403 12.48 10,462,927,000 69,651,000,000
2073/74 13.29 793,142,994 13.55 52,037,000,000
2072/73 26.53 716,064,646 10.75 4,259,079,000 37,951,000,000
2071/72 16.24 394,788,376 9.89 3,525,690,000 33,422,000,000
2070/71 18.69 341,654,966 10.85 3,185,508,000 27,578,000,000
2069/70 18.17 291,448,365 11.24 2,850,138,000 25,319,000,000
Laxmi Bank 2075/76 17.82 1,590,074,275 11.01 12,269,000,000 84,403,000,000
Limited
2074/75 14.37 1,181,090,925 11.32 10,987,000,000 69,651,000,000
2073/74 21.77 1,006,624,170 12.43 9,986,117,000 52,037,000,000
2072/73 27.15 677,127,177 9.79 6,075,527,000 37,951,000,000
2071/72 19.42 416,195,924 9.17 4,634,659,000 33,422,000,000
2070/71 26.07 474,856,488 10.85 3,697,912,000 27,578,000,000
2069/70 24.78 419,842,579 11.24 3,262,640,000 25,319,000,000
Machhapuchchhre 2075/76 21.07 1,697,088,243 11.88 11,308,458,000 91,560,200,000.00
Bank Limited
2074/75 15.81 1,249,688,316 14.38 10,623,725,000 72,474,719,641
2073/74 24 1,302,483,429 15.78 9,091,177,000 58,629,076,680
2072/73 25.04 898,222,681 11.32 5,726,052,792 52,291,877,270
2071/72 22.2 616,372,739 11.14 4,351,914,904 44,205,637,252
2070/71 18.34 454,687,791 9.69 3,456,483,000 37,132,092,928
2069/70 5.98 148,599,200 11.59 2,923,876,000 27,136,654,448
Megha Bank 2075/76 15.69 1,629,689,787 14.34 13,598,590,000 81,859,000,000
Limited
2074/75 12.81 1,317,351,773 16.97 12,568,650,000 62,965,000,000
2073/74 17.31 793,006,074 13.8 6,195,945,544 38,937,000,000
2072/73 17 551,043,663 11.94 4,469,681,000 30,750,000,000
2071/72 13.27 346,296,108 13.98 3,254,691,000 21,131,000,000
2070/71 13.11 305,537,370 15.24 2,888,264,000 17,148,000,000
2069/70 7.61 177,355,953 17.24 2,566,849,000 12,533,000,000
EPS (Rupees)
Bank Capital
Core Capital
Ratio (%)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
Name of Bank
Deposit
NPAT
F/Y
Nabil Bank 2075/76 50.57 4,238,853,581 11.40 21,245,470,606 164,373,041,697
Limited
2074/75 49.51 3,981,892,950 11.51 18,710,876,440 135,979,364,610
2073/74 59.86 3,613,200,322 11.21 14,752,638,819 118,684,419,344
2072/73 59.27 2,819,333,752 10.51 12,203,615,000 110,210,927,524
2071/72 57.24 2,093,813,608 10.18 10,154,006,000 104,237,910,083
2070/71 83.68 2,319,557,472 9.68 8,302,904,000 75,388,790,862
2069/70 91.05 2,226,686,260 9.98 7,366,908,000 63,506,102,707
Nepal Bangladesh 2075/76 19.63 1,587,960,145 11.06 14,202,230,000.00 59,764,707,000
Bank Limited
2074/75 14.95 1,144,035,276 13.31 11,628,900,000 47,982,823,000
2073/74 28.05 1,200,381,901 14.39 10,715,863,000 43,713,193,739
2072/73 39.43 1,198,297,230 10.21 6,042,450,000 39,874,233,993
2071/72 33.48 813,976,568 10.6 4,848,885,000 33,832,696,025
2070/71 36.94 742,342,538 10.64 3,612,011,000 25,706,915,697
2069/70 38.75 778,645,431 10.76 2,664,288,000 17,845,158,014
Nepal Credit and 2075/76 15.77 1,021,232,240 13.38 11,887,310,000
Commerce Bank
2074/75 23.51 1,341,516,334 10.29 7,571,000,000 63,430,544,471
Limited
2073/74 14.02 505,867,992 9.75 6,273,732,729 58,795,094,314
2072/73 30.08 707,840,700 11.08 3,927,019,409 30,363,555,060
2071/72 17.17 348,254,007 10.45 3,019,711,175 26,661,129,863
2070/71 26.67 392,111,964 10.70 2,562,362,682 22,256,871,407
2069/70 24.14 354,827,828 10.90 2,297,805,464 21,651,267,380
Nepal Investment 2075/76 26.4 3,324,112,936 11.39 26,235,893,404 152,183,000,000
Bank Limited
2074/75 35.7 3,659,322,725 11.58 22,695,798,460 140,328,000,000
2073/74 29.3 3,114,131,140 11.58 20,367,202,860 125,669,000,000
2072/73 29.3 2,550,883,563 13.05 18,182,543,651 108,626,000,000
2071/72 30.9 1,961,852,380 9.54 11,754,293,710 90,631,000,000
2070/71 40.7 1,939,612,344 9.52 8,993,849,000 73,831,000,000
2069/70 46.2 1,915,027,932 10.01 7,813,057,000 62,429,000,000
NIC Asia Bank 2075/76 34.22 3,023,282,666 8.24 21,804,000,000 180,575,000,000
Limited
2074/75 16.62 1,334,861,927 8.66 15,350,010,000 151,219,000,000
2073/74 23.06 1,473,465,967 12.38 10,912,194,316 86,679,102,631
2072/73 28.31 1,066,906,232 10.69 9,193,013,294 69,487,997,265
2071/72 25.59 680,317,101 10.53 6,059,261,071 53,477,184,239
2070/71 35.98 831,588,872 11.84 5,725,861,568 44,984,218,467
2069/70 47.41 642,136,406 12.21 4,693,288,345 39,908,774,213
NMB Bank 2075/76 23.54 2,257,276,027 13.09 19,061,375,000 98,516,667,000
2074/75 21.86 1,853,792,753 14.78 16,851,254,000 84,507,136,000
2073/74 22.24 1,467,347,467 12.39 11,393,685,000 73,224,063,000
2072/73 22.1 1,115,064,628 9.34 7,790,514,000 64,781,464,000
2071/72 21.48 500,989,608 8.84 3,982,873,000 36,723,000,000
2070/71 20.5 409,922,982 9.91 2,918,892,000 27,087,000,000
2069/70 18.02 360,393,624 10.42 2,489,383,000 22,186,000,000
EPS (Rupees)
Bank Capital
Core Capital
Ratio (%)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
Name of Bank
Deposit
NPAT
F/Y
Prabhu Bank 2075/76 21.03 1,783,592,538 10.22 13,148,762,968 112,393,448,000
Limited
2074/75 12.58 967,034,844 10.82 11,430,641,456 97,259,665,000
2073/74 27.17 1,597,952,553 9.45 8,504,116,199 81,349,540,000
2072/73 26.75 1,117,363,714 10.62 6,985,571,384 60,940,868,000
2071/72 31.73 1,018,245,374 9.44 583,725,263 42,142,974,000
2070/71 -15.24 -304,851,936 7.65 1,088,499,748 19,835,166,000
2069/70 -40.23 -804,628,575 7.62 1,571,695,000 21,093,025,000
Prime Bank 2075/76 23.6 2,198,792,243 11.97 13,644,465,572 86,257,837,697
Limited
2074/75 21.49 1,726,246,109 11.43 11,659,258,818 81,304,476,188
2073/74 23.21 1,467,942,925 12.45 9,937,824,828 65,855,880,385
2072/73 30.11 1,115,759,677 10.76 5,776,701,505 48,342,121,058
2071/72 23.74 745,589,121 11.29 4,624,956,603 41,005,754,566
2070/71 20.97 553,447,114 11.53 3,888,556,422 34,045,262,660
2069/70 18.55 477,566,263 11.88 3,164,222,000 28,798,028,030
Sanima Bank 2075/76 28.22 2,258,067,506 10.63 13,364,410,000 92,140,000,000
Limited
2074/75 21.22 1,697,503,224 11.14 10,889,090,000 79,139,000,000
2073/74 26.31 1,304,103,406 14.07 9,870,186,114 57,754,000,000
2072/73 32.55 996,054,127 10.69 6,039,446,132 46,344,000,000
2071/72 24.47 624,141,298 10.13 3,734,498,766 34,045,316,000
2070/71 19.28 427,595,604 11.52 3,072,172,121 24,873,849,000
2069/70 15.13 305,061,132 13.91 2,565,034,704 17,789,329,000
SBI Bank Limited 2075/76 27.13 2,292,524,396 12.72 14,804,827,617 97,924,400,000
2074/75 25.16 2,023,511,124 13.38 13,728,773,698 84,269,200,000
2073/74 33.46 1,523,237,401 13.53 11,692,078,000 81,664,548,665
2072/73 36.78 1,331,881,801 10.98 8,169,663,000 65,213,519,724
2071/72 34.48 1,065,436,141 11.18 7,063,688,000 51,628,221,954
2070/71 34.83 922,984,007 10.19 5,892,028,000 54,492,993,606
2069/70 32.75 771,471,129 9.59 4,888,637,991 58,920,455,656
Standard Char- 2075/76 30.39 2,434,664,521 18.31 14,971,059,954 75,731,527,432.00
tered Bank Limited
2074/75 27.33 2,189,898,090 21.41 13,986,845,583 67,061,046,522.00
2073/74 35.49 1,421,596,136 19.58 11,975,101,524 63,872,885,000.00
2072/73 45.96 1,292,494,632 14.08 7,779,409,000 55,727,178,000.00
2071/72 57.38 1,290,025,348 11.67 6,111,788,000 57,286,482,000.00
2070/71 65.47 1,336,589,187 10.83 5,333,516,000 46,298,532,000
2069/70 65.7 1,217,940,751 11.03 4,828,551,000 39,466,453,000
Siddhartha Bank 2075/76 26 2,257,688,323 10.19 16,953,951,000 122,527,700,000
Limited
2074/75 26.45 1,904,061,504 10.99 13,187,005,000 101,748,200,000
2073/74 26.6 1,386,175,502 11.02 10,717,460,000 77,316,600,000
2072/73 41.53 1,254,918,004 8.78 7,708,558,000 64,934,400,000
2071/72 37.77 767,080,512 7.58 5,244,638,000 44,740,730,000.00
2070/71 38.63 700,534,999 8.39 3,995,774,000 35,414,010,000.00
2069/70 29.8 482,556,447 8.21 3,513,565,000 28,392,820,000.00
EPS (Rupees)
Bank Capital
Core Capital
Ratio (%)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
(Rupees)
Name of Bank
Deposit
NPAT
F/Y
Sunrise Bank 2075/76 20.94 1,706,102,088 11.37 12,722,042,072 78,740,000,000
Limited
2074/75 18.13 1,476,971,853 12.59 10,925,126,067 69,480,000,000
2073/74 16.76 1,112,851,929 13.39 9,854,712,000 61,013,263,534
2072/73 23.93 951,378,476 11.13 6,541,746,000 51,650,280,064
2071/72 19.27 470,857,056 10.11 3,612,062,000 33,486,669,059
2070/71 11.03 246,772,655 10.69 2,874,243,000 26,616,667,279
2069/70 15.46 311,609,037 10.96 2,600,252,000 23,270,603,296
Century Bank 2075/76 8.04 676,407,831 13.46 10,170,770,000 65,488,597,980
Limited
2074/75 11.31 912,283,372 13.65 9,586,970,000 61,321,550,155
2073/74 9.18 501,365,807 13.91 6,665,547,473 42,593,653,750
2072/73 14.56 413,533,271 11.90 3,648,392,000 28,967,846,551
2071/72 12.3 260,864,190 10.35 2,603,332,000 24,948,567,976
2070/71 6.15 86,927,673 13.17 2,305,815,000 18,393,723,078
2069/70 0.09 66,371,596 11.78 1,309,096,335 11,396,473,762
Abstract
This study aimed to find the impact of firm specific factors on the profitability and stock
price of the Nepalese commercial banks. Out of 27 commercial banks, 15 were taken as
sample for the study and 8 years data from 2013 to 2020 were analyzed. Descriptive and
cross sectional research design has lent this study a framework for analysis. Correlation and
regression analysis with multicolliniarity test was conducted to analyze the effect of the
variables. The study found that there is significant but negative relationship between non-
performing loan (NPL) and profitability and significant but positive relationship between
reserve and profitability. The study has also found significant relationship between bonus
share and stock price of the commercial banks. Other variables under this study show
insignificant relation with the stock price. It has been concluded that profitability can be
increased by reducing the NPL. Likewise, stock price has been majorly dependent on the
bonus share declaration of the banks.
Keywords: Profitability, Stock price, Non-performing loan, Reserve, Capital, Bonus share
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
There are two approaches namely the fundamental approach and technical approach for
predicting share prices (Sharma, 2011). The former predicts share price on the basis of
financial, environmental and managerial factors, whereas the latter studies the past trends in
predicting future share price. However, a number of empirical studies have been conducted
on the determinants of stock prices. Some of these studies looked at the relationships between
stock prices and the factors that could impact on it. The link between fundamental factors
(e.g. firm earnings, dividends and book-value per share) and stock price changes has always
remained as the focus area of interest for market analysts, fund managers, and investors.
Investors take decisions to invest in particular shares of companies, keeping in view their
share prices. Theories suggest that there is an association between changes in share prices
and changes in financial fundamental variables (Nisa, & Nishat, 2011). Adhikari (2010)
1 Manoj Kumar Bhatta is a Faculty at Global College International (GCI) and currently also pursuing MPhil
in Management at Kathmandu University School of Management (KUSOM), Nepal.
concluded that there are differences in financial position of high dividend paying and low
dividend paying companies. The stocks with longer ratio of dividend per share to book value
per share have higher liquidity. Sharma (2011) observed that earning per share is positively
significant to market price per share. Menike and Prabath, (2014) concluded that the internal
factors, firm specific factors such as dividend per share (DPS), earnings per share (EPS)
and book value per share (BVPS) affect positively and significant impact on the stock price.
With financial deregulation and market integration, the scope of activities, financial
institutions have been completely reshaped ranging from traditional intermediation products
to an array of new businesses. Poudel and Shrestha (2014) highlighted the research on the
basic objective of the study are to examine whether MPS of listed companies, especially for
selected companies under the study and to what extent the risk is involved in the investment
of common stocks of those. Shrestha (2013) found that the firm size and stock return have
positive relation. Book to market was found to have strong explanatory power to explain the
stock returns, which impacted the stock returns negatively. It was further concluded that both
the earnings yield and cash flow yield have negative relationship with stock return. As cited
by Dangol (2020), Sejuwal (2015) concluded that the firm size, book to market and earnings
yield have the explanatory power to explain the cross sectional stock returns. Firm size was
found to have positive impact and book-to-market was found to have negative relation with
stock returns respectively. Returns from investment are subjected to variations owing to the
movement of stock price, which depends on various factors which could be internal or bank
specific such as earning per share, bank size, and book to market equity (Shafana, 2013).
Nazir et al. (2010) examined the relationship between share price volatility and dividend
policy for the period of 2003 to 2008 in 73 firms listed in Karachi Stock Exchange (KSE).
The study applied fixed effect and random effect models on panel data. They found that
share price volatility has significant negative association with dividend yield and dividend
payout. The cross sectional regression is used to analyze the relationship of share price
with dividend yield and payout ratio. This study also proposed that signaling effect is also
relevant in determining the share price volatility. Gabriel et al. (2012) investigated the
relationship between volatility and stock price in Nigerian Stock Market. The study used
month end stock price of four major companies from the period January 2005 to December,
2009 data. The results revealed that out of the four companies, only two companies’ stock
price was predicted by volatility in their stock prices The major result of the study showed
stock price volatility could not predict their current stock price and hence volatility was
insignificant and negatively correlated. In this context, this study tries to analyze the impact
of firm specific factors on the profitability and the stock price determination of the Nepalese
commercial banks.
It is important to know the firm specific factors that impact the profitability of the firm.
Firm's profitability is linked to the stock price determination. In this study, both the factors
that impact firm profitability and the factors that impact the stock price of the firms are
analyzed. The share market is making the records each day and commercial banks are not
performing as expected. Therefore it is important to know the firm specific factors that
impact on the profitability and share price of the banks in the Nepalese context. The above
discussion shows that the studies dealing with impact of firms specific variables on share
price volatility and stock return are of greater significance. Though there are findings in the
context of different countries, no such findings using more recent data exist in the context
of Nepal. Hence, this study focuses on analyzing the relationship of firm’s specific variables
with profitability and share price in Nepalese commercial banks.
2. Literature Review
Khan (2020) findings of the study indicated Non-performing loan has negative effect on
Market Price of Stock and Earning per share has positive effect on Market stock prices. As
cited by Khan (2020), Menke and prabahat (2014) found that earnings per share has less
effect on stock prices in the Colombo Stock Exchange. Also, Book value per share and
dividend per share showed a positive effect on the stock price. Modigliani (1961), study
showed that in assessing the merits of a company's dividend, investors calculate the dividend
yield and this shows how much a company pays out in dividends each year relative to its
share price. Azhagaiah and Priya (2008) results indicated that higher dividend per Share
creates positive reaction to market price of the share and there is an increase of price of share
in market on shareholders wealth. Ajanthan (2013) findings of the study were that there is
a positive relationship between the dividend policy and profitability of the company in Sri
Lanka. As cited by Ajanthan (2013), Sijolnur and Abdul Basit (2013) demonstrated that the
dividend policy did not have a consistent pattern of influencing the financial performance
of companies in the US. Wasfi and Maysa (2013) found that the relationship of dividend per
share and market price of stock found a positive and significant relationship, non-performing
loan and Market price of stock have negative and insignificant relationship. With the help
of Panel data approach concluded that there is positive correlation between dividend and
market price of stock considering EPS, BVPS, Retention Ratio; while dividend yield and
profit after tax have negative relation with market price of stock.
Paudel (2014) studied the MPS of financial institutions and found that there is higher positive
correlation with major financial indicators such as Earning yield, NWPS and DPS and such
relationship in significant. It also concluded that the market price of share in Nepal is not
indicative of a company's financial performance in stock market. The study also found that
there is the largest fluctuation in EPS and DPR, the relationship between DPS and EPS is
positive; however, it is not significant. There may be various other factors besides EPS to
affects MPS and the growth rate of dividend is inconsistent
Reserve
Capital
Net profit Stock price
Non Performing loan
Bonus Share
The reserve, capital and non-performing independent variable for the dependent variable Net
profit. Reserve capital, Non-performing loan, bonus share and net profit are the independent
variables.
3. Research Methodology
Research designs namely cross sectional research have been used for the purpose. This study
has employed cross sectional research design to deal with the fact-finding and searching
adequate information associated. Under cross sectional research design, correlation and
regression analysis has been carried out. Multiple regression models have been used to
understand the directions, magnitudes and forms of observed relationship.
Though there were 27 commercial banks in Nepal till 2020, all of them did not provided
scope for the study. Out of 27, 15 were taken as sample for the study for the period of 8
years from 2013 to 2020 making total of 150 observations. The data collected for the study
are quantitative and based on fact. The quantitative data were taken from the annual reports
of the studied banks. These data were then analyzed using different tools and technique to
produce understandable results. Both the statistical and econometric models are used for
analyzing of secondary data.
a. The model
The econometric models employed in this study intends to analyze the relationship between
independent variables which are capital, reserve, Non-performing loan, bonus share and net
profit and dependent variables which are net profit and stock price. The equation is estimated
in the form of:
In Table above, Non-performing Loan (NPL) has variation of 5.34 (min 0.0 and max 5.34).
This suggests that banks are having maximum of 5.34 percent of non-performing loan of
their total assets at maximum. The average NPL is 1.45 percent in the last 8 years. Few of
the banks have far above the average NPL. It is also noteworthy to analyze the statistics
related to net profit which mean value is 6.13 percent and where maximum value is 9.09
percent. Here also we can find a respectable difference in the minimum and maximum
values of capital which has been increased from 10.81 to 24.27 due to the fact that there is
the provision of increasing the capital base of the banks by Nepal Rastra Bank. The values
reported for Log capital (min=10.81, max=24.21). The stock price minimum value is 125
and maximum value is 3600. Bonus share has been declared up to 68 percent. This reveals
that majority of the banks studied have relatively the less bonus payment as shown by the
mean value of 15.58 percent. The reserve ratio is minimum 3.75 percent and maximum 7.15
percent with average of 6.3 percent.
The correlation matrix shows that there is negative but significant relationship between
net profit and non-performing loan (-0.232*). It means that with increase in the NPL net
profit decreases.Net profit is significant and have positive relation with capital (0.259*)
and indicates that rise of capital increase the net profit of the banks. Bonus share and stock
price are positively correlated and has significant relationship. It means that whenever banks
declare the bonus share price increases. The studied banks reserve is significantly related to
the net profit, capital and stock price and are positively correlated as well. In an attempt to
detect multicollinearity, a correlation matrix was constructed to infer the extent of correlation
among the variables studied.
Model 1
Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate
Model 2
Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate
A close examination of the results presented above indicates that the R2 value of 0.319
indicates that about 31.9% of the total systematic variations in the Stock price (dependent
variable) were due to the variations in independent variables. This means that about 68.1%
of the systematic variations in the stock price are left unexplained hence captured by the
external factors.
Also, the adjusted R-square of 0.289 shows that after adjusting for the degree of freedom the
entire variables taken together could still explain about 28.9% of the systematic variations
in Stock price. This implies that the regression line has average fit and thus a minimum
forecasting power.
Coefficientsa
Unstandardized Standardized
Collinearity Statistics
Coefficients Coefficients
Model t Sig.
Std.
B Beta Tolerance VIF
Error
Coefficientsa
Model Unstandardized Standardized t Sig. Collinearity
Coefficients Coefficients Statistics
in one percent capital increases net profit by 14.42 percent on average if the other variables
remain constant. Similarly the regression coefficient of Reserve (b3) is 187.65 which implies
that an increase of one percent in reserve increases net profit by 187.65 percent and similar
to bonus share and net profit with 60.23 and 26.33 percent. But the estimates of b1, b2, b3,
b4 and b5 may vary by 47.328, 18.39, 111.1, 115.3, and 4.02 respectively as indicated by
standard error.
Collinearity Diagnosticsa
Variance Proportions
(Constant)
Model Dimension Eigenvalue Condition Index
Reserve
Capital
NPL
1 1 3.658 1.000 .00 .02 .00 .00
2 .314 3.415 .00 .94 .01 .00
3 .025 12.121 .07 .03 .95 .04
4 .004 30.882 .93 .01 .04 .96
Bonus share
Condition
(Constant)
Net Profit
Drury (2008) documents that if the muticollinearity among two variables is 70% and above,
then it is a case of concern. In the present study, we find cases of multicollinearity as percent
of capital and Reserve where Eigen value is less than he maximum correlation is above
and condition index is greater than 10. A VIF test conducted to further check the extent of
multicollinearity among the independent variables revealed a mean VIF of 1.17 which thus
confirm the presence of multicollinearity.
Graph shows that data are scattered with the diagonal line. It means there is higher Skewness
distribution and data sets are not close enough to support each other.
H2: There is a significant relationship between net profit and Capital. On the basis of the
individual statistic, Capital passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance under
the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.460 is greater than α of 0.05. This shows it is not
statistically significant. This means there is no significant relationship between net profit and
capital of the studied banks.
H3: There is a significant relationship between net profit and reserve. On the basis of the
individual statistic, reserve passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance under
the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.00 is less than α of 0.05. This shows it is statistically
significant. This means there is significant relationship between net profit and reserve of the
studied banks.
H4: There is a significant relationship between Stock price and Non-performing loan. On the
basis of the individual statistic, NPL passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance
under the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.630 is greater than α of 0.05. This shows it is not
statistically significant. This means there is no significant relationship between Stock price
and NPL of the studied banks.
H5: There is a significant relationship between Stock price and capital. On the basis of the
individual statistic, Capital passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance under
the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.435 is greater than α of 0.05. This shows it is not
statistically significant. This means there is no significant relationship between Stock price
and capital of the studied banks.
H6: There is a significant relationship between Stock price and reserve. On the basis of the
individual statistic, reserve passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance under
the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.094 is greater than α of 0.05. This shows it is not
statistically significant. This means there is no significant relationship between stock price
and reserve of the studied banks.
H7: There is a significant relationship between Stock price and Bonus share. On the basis of
the individual statistic, bonus share passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance
under the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.00 is less than α of 0.05. This shows it is
statistically significant. This means there is significant relationship between stock price and
bonus share of the studied banks.
H8: There is a significant relationship between net profit and Stock price. On the basis of
the individual statistic, net profit passed the test of statistics at 5% level of significance
under the two-tailed test. The ρ- value of 0.602 is greater than α of 0.05. This shows it is not
statistically significant. This means there is no significant relationship between net profit and
stock price of the studied banks.
5. Conclusion
This study aims to find the relationship between the firms' specific factors in determining
the profitability and stock price of the commercial banks in Nepal. It analyze the impact of
reserve, Non-performing loan, and capital on the profitability of the bank and net profitability
and bonus share relation with the stock price. The study shows that Non-performing loan
and reserve impact profitability of the bank and bonus share impact on the stock price of
the commercial banks under study. This means there is significant relationship between
reserve and net profit and NPL and net profit of the studied banks. This means banks need
to maintain the adequate reserve and lower non-performing loan to increase the profitability
of the studied banks. Also, there is significant relationship between stock price and bonus
share of the studied banks. This means stock price is significantly impacted by the bonus
declared by the studied banks. Other factors have no such significant impact in determining
the stock price.
References
Adhikari, G.M. (2010). Entry of foreign banks in Nepal: Opportunities and challenges. Journal of the
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nepal, 13(1), 213-223.
Ahmed, H. Z., Ali, K., & Akhtar, M. F. (2011). Bank specific and macroeconomic indicators
profitability-Empirical evidence from the commercials banks of Pakistan. International Journal
of Business and Social Science, 2(6), 235-242.
Ajanthan, Alagathurai. (2013). The Relationship Between Dividend Payout and Firm Profitability:
A Study of Selected Hotels and Restaurant companies in Sri Lanka.. International Journal of
Scientific and Research Publications, 3, 1-6.
Al-Khouri, R. (2011). Assessing the Risk and Performance of the GCC Banking Sector. International
Journal of Finance and Economics, 6 (5), 72-78.
Athanasoglou, P., Brissmis, S., & Delis, M. (2008). Bank-specific, industry-specific and macroeconomic
determinants of bank profitability. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and
Money, 18 (2), 121-136.
Azam, M., & Siddhiqui, S. (2012). Domestic and foreign banks profitability: Difference and their
determinants. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 2 (1), 33-40.
Azhagaiah, R., & Priya, N.S. (2008) The Impact of Dividend Policy on Shareholders’ Wealth. International
Research Journal of Finance and Economics, 20, 180-187.
Berger, A. N., & Humphrey, D. B. (1997). The effects of Megamergers on efficiency and prices:
evidences from a bank profit function. Review of International Organization, 12(1), 95-139.
Bhandari, B., Adhikari, B., Pandey, B., & Shrestha, B. (2016). The effect of ownership structure, board
size, board composition on bank performance. A case of Nepalese commercial banks. Nepalese
Journal of Finance, 3(2), 96-106.
Menike, D., & Prabath, U.. (2014). The Impact of Accounting Variables on Stock Price: Evidence from
the Colombo Stock Exchange, Sri Lanka. International Journal of Business and Management, 9.
10.5539/ijbm.v9n5p125.
Demsetz, H. (1983). The structure of ownership and the theory of the firm. Journal of Law and
Economics, 26 (2), 375-390.
Demsetz, H., & Lehn, K. (1985). The structure of corporate ownership: causes and consequences.
Journal of Political Economy, 44, 1155-1177
Gabriel, A., & Ugochukwu, Wemambu. (2012). Volatility Estimation and Stock Price Prediction in
the Nigerian Stock Market. International Journal of Financial Research, 3. 10.5430/ijfr.v3n1p2.
Irshad, F., Gul, S., & Zaman, K. (2011). Factors affecting banks profitability in Pakistan. The Romanian
Economic Journal, 14 (39), 16-87.
Khan, M.A., Siddique, A., & Sarwar, Z. (2020), "Determinants of non-performing loans in the banking
sector in developing state", Asian Journal of Accounting Research, l (5-1), 135-145. https://doi.
org/10.1108/AJAR-10-2019-0080.
Micco. A, Panizza, U., & Yanez .M (2004) Bank ownership and performance. IDB Working Paper,
429, 3-48.
Miller, M., & Modigliani, Franco. (1961). Dividend Policy, Growth, and the Valuation of Shares. The
Journal of Business, 34, 411-411. 10.1086/294442.
Nazir, M. S., & Nawaz, M., Anwar, W., & Ahmed, F. (2010). Determinants of Stock Price Volatility
in Karachi Stock Exchange: The Mediating Role of Corporate Dividend Policy. International
Research Journal of Finance and Economics, 55, 100-107.
Nishat, M. (2011). The Determinants of Stock Prices in Pakistan. Asian Economic and Financial
Review, 1(4), 276.
Poudel, R. B. & Shrestha, S. R. (2014). Stock return and trading volume relation in Nepalese stock
market: AN ARDL approach, 17-32.
Rai, P. Ojha, P. Singh, P. Gyawali, R., & Gupta, R. (2015). Determinants of financial performance in
Nepalese financial institutions. Nepalese Journal of Business, 2(1), 131-143.
Rajesh, M., & Reddy. (2011). Impact of Working Capital Management on Firms Profitability. Global
Journal of Finance and Management, 3(1), 151-158.
Sambasivam, Y., & Ayele, A. G. (2013). A study on the performance of insurance companies in
Ethiopia. International Journal of Marketing, Financial Services & Management Research, 2
(3), 138-150.
Samiloglu, F., & Demirgunes. (2008). The effect of working capital management on firm profitability:
Evidence from Turkey. Int. J. Appl. Econ. Finance, 2 (1), 44-50.
Sejuwal, N. (2015). The effect of firm specific variables on stock return: A case of Nepal. An
Unpublished Mphil’s Degree Dissertation. FOM, TU, Kirtipur.
Shafana, M. (2014). Macroeconomic variables effect on financial sector performance in Emerging Sri
Lankan Stock Market. International Journal of Science and Research, 3 (10), 227-231.
Sharma, S. (2011), Determinants of equity share prices in India. Journal of Arts, Science & Commerce,
2 (4): 51-60.
Srinivasan, P. (2013). Causality between Public Expenditure and Economic Growth: The Indian Case.
International Journal of Economics and Management, 7(2): 335 – 347.
Wasfi A.T, Maysa .M, (2013). Cash Dividends, Retained Earnings, and Stock Prices. Interdisciplinary
Journal of Contemporary Research in Business. 4(12).
Zeitun, R. (2012). Determinants of Islamic and Conventional Banks Performance in GCC Countries
Using Panel Data Analysis. Global Economy and Finance Journal, 5 (1), 53-72.
Zhang, X., & Daly, k. (2013). The impact of Bank specific and Macroeconomic Factors on China's
Bank Performance. Global Economy and Finance Journal, 6 (2), 1-25.
Abstract
Porter’s generic strategies are the proven and pervasive strategic options in achieving
competitiveness and better firm performance. This paper aims in examining the effect of
Porter’s generic strategies (low-cost, differentiation, and focus) on firm performance in the
context of Nepalese retail banks, a more competitive service industry. This study applies
casual comparative research design and the data have been collected through administering
questionnaire survey from 75 senior bank managers of 18 Nepalese commercial banks who
being engaged in strategic affairs. The econometric model has been constructed to measure
the expected effect of the strategies on firm performance. The descriptive analysis, Pearson’s
correlation analysis, and multivariate regression analysis were conducted. The empirical
results of correlation analysis and multiple regression analysis produced consistent results
indicating positive associations between generic strategies and firm performance. The
empirical results from regression analysis declared higher positive and significant impact
of low-cost on firm performance. Similarly, positive effect of differentiation strategy and
focus strategy on firm performance was reported. The findings suggested that pursuing low-
cost strategy provides more financial returns with comparison to differentiation and focus
strategies. The finding also suggested for combination of low-cost and differentiation (and
focus) strategies could provide better competitiveness and firm performance.
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
The contemporary business environment is highly dynamic and competitive, those bring
many challenges in managing operations. The fast growing globalization and technological
developments, managers face more turbulent and unstable market. Managing business
in conventional tradition lead business towards ultimate failure, rather managers have to
understand dynamic environment and creating a competitive advantage by management of
1 Makshindra Thapa, PhD is the Lecturer of Management at Tribhuvan University Patan Multiple Campus,
Lalitpur
various strategies. Varadarajan and Clark (1994) argue that business strategy is generally
explained in terms of achievement and maintenance of competitive advantage in specific
product-market domains. Cannon (1968) thus has defined strategies as the directional action
decisions which are required competitively to achieve the company’s purpose
Strategy is the primary means of reaching a focal objective, and recent planning techniques
suitable in dealing in dynamic and turbulent business environment. The assessment of a
company’s success potentials should include criteria focused on the market aspects and
criteria focused on competitive strength. Therefore, Schendel and Hofer (1979) have
stated that strategy provides directional cues to the organization that permit it to achieve its
objectives, while responding to the opportunities and threats in its environment. Thus, with
strategies, firms achieve competitive advantages through best utilization of the resources.
As Nepalese retail banking sector has faced various quantum changes after 1990s with
response to many policy reforms and initiations taken in financial liberalization and
privatization by Nepalese government. Such policies resulted in the entry of many domestic
and foreign investments in many industries, including the retail banking sector. Due to
growing competition from national and foreign competitors, the sector then become one
of the fast growing and more competitive in terms of technological developments and
innovations of service processes that led the market more competitive and turbulent. The
bank managers adopted many strategic initiatives to defend and grow their business market,
ensuring competitive advantages. Similarly, application of the generic strategies of Porter’s
(1980) including; low-cost, differentiation, and focus seen common and imperative within
this industry.
Research in business strategy development has come a long way since the early work in
the 1960s. Andrews (1998) explains that economic strategy is viewed as the purposive
development and utilization of the firm’s capabilities to exploit existing or evolving
opportunities in the business’s competitive environment at an acceptable level of risk.
Porter's (1980) model of generic strategies is the dominant paradigm in the literature on
corporate strategy (Hill, 1988; Miller and Dess, 1993). According to Porter's framework,
a business can maximize performance either by striving to be the low-cost producer in an
industry or by differentiating its line of products or services from those of other businesses;
either of these two approaches can be accompanied by & focus of organizational efforts on a
given segment of the market. many previous studies (Rasheed et al., 2020, Muji et al., 2019,
Potjanajaruwit, 2018, Luliya, et al., 2013, Walker, & Ruekert ,1987, Miller, & Friesen, 1986,
Yamin et al., 1999, Murray, 1988, Woo, & Cooper, 1982) have noted that organizations
pursuing Porter's generic strategies achieve better performance.
long-term periods they are destructing their industry and their business as well. This study
aim is to examine the impact of Porter’s generic strategies (low-cost, differentiation, and
focus) on firm performance in the context of Nepalese retail banking sector.
H1 (A): The low-cost strategy has positive and significant impact on firm performance of
the banks.
H1 (B): The differentiation strategy has positive and significant impact on firm performance
of the banks.
H1(C): The focus strategy has positive and significant impact on firm performance of the
banks.
2. Literature Review
2.1 Strategy
Pearce & Robinson (2007) have defined strategy as the game plan. Strategy is the direction and
scope of an organization over the long term which enables the firm to achieve an advantage
in a changing environment through its configuration of resources and competencies with
the objective of fulfilling stakeholder’s expectations (Johnson et al. 2005). According to
Porter (1998), the purpose of formulating a strategy is to relate the firm to its environment.
Competitive strategy therefore means being different, deliberately choosing to perform
activities differently or to perform different activities from those of competitors in order
to deliver a unique mix of value (Porter, 1930). Firms pursue various strategies to achieve
competitive advantages through more market shares. The strategies related to business in
relation to compete with competitors are often known as competitive strategy. A competitive
strategy includes all the activities that a firm is doing to attract customers, withstand
competitive pressure and improve its market positions resulting in a competitive advantage.
customer service. When they are focused on a market niche, they are called cost focus and
focused differentiation.
Porter (1985) also proposed that a firm’s competitive advantage in an industry would be
determined by its competitive scope, that is, the breadth of the company’s target market.
This strategy typology was a dominant theory in the 80s to explain the major forces in
the market which affected firm competitive advantage and performance? These strategies
in responding to dynamic and risky product market within the industry settings are more
relevant in existing globalized economy. Thus, managers worldwide apply these strategies
as basic means in achieving competitive advantages and sustainable operations.
2.2.2 Differentiation
Differentiation strategy is the other basic competitive strategy propounded by Porter. A
firm’s differentiation refers to the development of a unique product or service (Porter, 1985).
Porter (1985) argues that if the product or service is unique, this strategy provides high
customer satisfaction and loyalty. In addition, Porter (19985) showed the relationship with
firm performance and the advantages that firms earn from pursuing differentiation strategy
referring to realizing higher incomes compared with competitors because of mark trust,
quality, and perception that clients have for the company product. Therefore, if customers
perceive the product or service as unique, they are loyal to the company and willing to pay
the higher price for its products (Venu, 2001). David (2017) has suggested that a successful
differentiation can mean greater product flexibility, greater compatibility, lower costs,
improved service, less maintenance, greater convenience, or more features. In contrast,
differentiation does not guarantee competitive advantage, especially if standard products
sufficiently meet customer needs or if rapid imitation by competitors is possible (David,
2017).
2.2.3 Focus
Focus strategy is a generic strategy proposed by Porter (19985) in which firms concentrate
on a particular group of customers, geographic markets, or product line segments. Focus
strategy is a strategy in which an organization concentrates on a specific regional market,
product line, or group of buyers (Griffin, 2005). The focuser’s basis for competitive
advantage is either lower costs than competitors serving that market segment or an ability to
offer niche members something different from competitors. In focus strategy, a firm either
can introduce low-cost and priced products to specific market or differentiated products are
sold in specific niche of the market.
A successful focus strategy depends on an industry segment that is of sufficient size, has good
growth potential, and is not crucial to the success of other major competitors. Strategies such
as market penetration and market development offer substantial focusing advantages (David,
2011). Similarly, According to David (2017) focus strategy has two alternative types; low-
cost-focus and focus differentiation. The low-cost focus strategy offers products or services
to a small range (niche group) of customers at the lowest price available on the market.
The focus differentiation is a best-value focus strategy that offers products or services to a
small range of customers at the best price value available on the market. Consistently, banks
that adopt this strategy usually provide interest rates above the market price (Berman et
al., 1999). As for the focus strategy, in contrast to the other strategies, it emphasizes on the
narrow market segment to compete in the industry. This strategy is based on the premise that
the firm will be able to serve narrow strategy targets more effectively and efficiently than
competitors that serve a wider target (Devlin, 1995).
The empirical results of Karyani and Rossieta (2018) indicated that although both low-cost
and differentiation strategies have positive effects on contemporaneous performance, only
a low-cost strategy allows a bank to have persistent superior performance in the following
period. Further empirical test which considered bank characteristics provide consistent
empirical results with the primary empirical model, suggesting that the empirical test
results are robust (Karyani, & Rossieta, 2018). The study Wanjiku, & Deya (2021) found
out that low-cost strategy, differentiation strategy, focus strategy, and innovation Strategy
significantly and positively affected the performance of Microfinance institutions in Kenya.
In addition, the study recommends that low-cost strategy is an important strategy embraced
by MFIs to enable them to survive competition in the market (Wanjiku, & Deya, 2021).
Rasheed et al. (2020) highlighted the role of business strategy to create a competitive
advantage. They found the business strategy has a vital role in the competitive advantages to
gain the market. Similarly, Muji et al. (2019) examined the effect of competitive strategies
and performance of construction organizations in the large construction industry in
Indonesia. Their found that competitive strategies positively impacted on the organizational
performance. In addition, Potjanajaruwit (2018) studied impact of strategic factors on
performance in case of startups of Thailand. He obtained direct positive effect of the factors
on the competitive advantage of startups, and competitive advantage had a direct positive
effect on the performance of startups in Thailand. Luliya, et al. (2013) also found that Porter’s
competitive strategies positively and significantly enhance firm performance through
performance measurement. Consequently, Kinyuira (2014) examined the effects of porter’s
generic competitive strategies on the performance of savings and credit cooperative societies
in Murang’a, Kenya and found significant positive effects of low-cost, differentiation and
focus strategies on the performance of the Saccos. Hahn and Powers (2004) did a study to
examine the impact of generic strategies on banks. Their Findings indicated that performance
of banks using low-cost was significantly higher than that of banks using stuck in the middle
strategy.
Yamin et al. (1999) found that companies utilizing both cost-leadership and differentiation
strategies are effectively more likely to enhance their firm performance and financial
management compared with other companies pursuing a single generic strategy. In addition,
Murray (1988) also suggests that firms using either low-cost or differentiation strategies
outperform stuck in the middle competitors, firms using both strategies simultaneously
should be able to outperform rivals using only one or the other. However, Walker and
Ruekert (1987) found that differentiation strategy has a stronger influence on performance
as compared to a low-cost strategy. Miller and Friesen (1986) also revealed that the cluster
of business units that show distinct competencies in the areas of differentiation, low-cost and
focus dramatically outperform all the others.
The empirical results of these studies have confirmed that Porter’s generic strategies
provide competitive advantages. The application of all three strategies provides short term
and long term competencies and hence better firm performance. The effectiveness of each
of these strategies depends upon the environment of the particular industrial context. The
current study aims in filling the gap with examining impact of the generic strategies on firm
performance in service industry context, taking account of Nepalese retail banks.
Focus strategy
3. Research Methods
3.1 Research design and data
This study applied casual comparative design of research as the basic objective of the study
strives to examine the impact of competitive strategy variables on banking performance.
The primary source of information collected from questionnaire survey is the source of data.
The dimensions used for measuring the constructs postulated in this study had been explicitly
tested in the literature and found to be valid and reliable measures. First, a large pool of
items for each construct was generated from a thorough review of the literature on generic
strategy. Consistent with the conventional process, the questionnaire was pre-tested with
some managers that were asked to indicate ambiguities or difficulties with the instruments
and to make any suggestions for improvement. After modifications were carried out, the
revised instrument was tested on four academics and, after further revisions; a pilot test with
potential respondents was carried out.
4. Results
4.1 Descriptive analysis of the study variables
Table 2 reports descriptive statistics of the study variables including low-cost, differentiation,
focus, and performance status of the banks.
Low-cost strategy
Aim for cost reduction 4.18 .85962
Strive to achieve operating efficiency 4.45 .71916
Attempt to achieve economies of scale 4.05 .69079
Strive to achieve competitive prices 4.29 .66964
Group mean score 4.24
Differentiation strategy
Having strong differential advantage relative to competitors 4.16 .65427
Differential advantage lies in bank's service 3.99 .80818
Differential advantage lies in bank's reputation 3.96 .91565
Differential advantage lies in wide service range 4.25 .76811
Group mean score 4.34
Focus strategy
Bank performance
Higher Return on investment [PROI] 4.23 .70934
Increased earnings per share [PEPS] 4.20 .67369
Higher shareholder value [PSVA] 4.11 .75858
Increased cash flow [PCFL] 3.88 .67351
Higher revenue growth [PRGR] 4.22 .64459
Group mean score 4.13
Among three generic strategies analyzed, the low-cost strategy has found commonly favored
by the bank managers (mean score=4.24). All four items of this strategy; cost reduction,
operating efficiency, economies of scale and competitive prices have mean values exceeding
4 clearly indicate that application of these low-cost strategies are advantageous to banking
firms. In addition, the managers have emphasized more on achieving operating efficiency
and achieving competitive prices (interest rates and processing costs) as to become cost
leader in the industry. In response to four strategies concerned to differentiation strategy,
the managers perceived that those banks could achieve differentiation advantage through
providing wider range of services to customers and presence of differential advantages
relative to competitors also valued highly. The results also suggested that bank managers
have perceived differentiation strategy as the most significant one in achieving competitive
advantages (mean score= 4.34).
In contrast to low-cost and differentiation strategies, the focus strategy has found to be less
preferred by managers in the process of gaining strategic advantage. The focus strategy
has obtained a mean score of 3.71. The mean scores for all five used measures found to be
below than four. Similarly, the managers have rated overall performance of theirs banks as
satisfactory (mean score= 4.13). They mean scores of four performance items; higher rate on
investment, earnings per share, higher shareholder’s values and higher revenue growth are
exceeding four suggested better firm performance status of the banks.
The results have indicated to positive relations of three generic strategies low-cost,
differentiation, and focus with firm performance. The correlation coefficient of low-cost
and performance is .293 (.009) indicating a statistically significant relationship between the
variables. The result declares that low-cost strategy would increase firm performance of the
banks. Similarly, the correlation coefficient of firm performance and differentiation strategy
is .225 (.051). The focus strategy has a correlation coefficient of .195 with performance,
declaring the positive effect of focus on performance. Both of these correlations are
significant at 0.10 level only.
The results have indicated to mixed impact of generic strategies on firm performance. The
low-cost strategy is positively connected with firm performance (B= .284, p = .011). The
impact of low-cost on performance is statistically significant. The differentiation strategy also
seemed to have positive impact on the dependent variable but, the relation is not significant
(B= .147, p = .175). Similarly, beta coefficient of focus strategy indicates possible positive
impact on performance however the result is not statistically significant (B= .091, p = .336).
5. Discussions
Porter (1985) has stated that all of his three generic strategies have a positive impact on firm
performance, and careful application of these strategies is required. The empirical result
of this study has revealed that the low-cost strategy has relatively stronger and significant
impact on bank performance. The differentiation and focus strategies have positive but
statistically insignificant effects on firm performance. The result supports previous literature
(Karyani, & Rossieta ,2019; Wanjiku, & Deya ,2021; Kinyuira, 2014; Rasheed et al., 2020;
Muji et al., 2019; Potjanajaruwit, 2018; Luliya, et al., 2013; Walker, & Ruekert ,1987; Miller,
& Friesen, 1986; Yamin et al., 1999; Murray, 1988; Woo, & Cooper, 1982).
The regression outputs have provided results for research hypotheses. The first hypothesis
“the low-cost strategy has positive and significant impact on firm performance of the banks”
has been accepted. The result has declared that low-cost strategy has a positive relationship
with firm performance.
Thus, the bank pursuing the low-cost strategy will increase its performance. The result has
indicated that the banks adopting low-cost strategy will have higher firm performance in
comparison to the competitors. As Nepalese retail banks passes through intense competition
and ability of banks to control costs leads to economical operations, thus more market share
and financial benefits are possible in competition.
The regression result related to second hypothesis stated as “the differentiation strategy
has positive and significant impact on firm performance of the banks” has been rejected.
The positive influence of differentiation on firm performance existed, but the result is no
statistically significant. The result implies that Nepalese banks offering unique schemes
and facilities attain good financial returns. The technological advancement and intense
application of digitalization in banking products has led banks to be innovative and introduce
unique banking products getting more customer attention. This strategy enables banks to
adopt market dynamics and meet customer aspirations.
Similarly, the third hypothesis stating “the focus strategy has positive and significant impact
on firm performance of the banks’ has been rejected as influence of focus strategy failed
to prove statistically significant result. Thus, among three generic strategies, the low-cost
strategy found to be relatively strong and significant impact on firm performance of the banks.
The result supports findings of Wanjiku and Deya, (2021) as well as Hahn and Powers (2004).
Fürth more, the result has suggested that banks concerned with segmentation of market and
applying “low-cost” and/or “differentiation” strategies as per nature and requirement of a
“niche” market. In addition, focus strategy also gives a competitive advantage to firms in
condition when no competitors exist, which is also termed as the first mover advantage.
6. Conclusion
This paper sought to examine the impact of Porter’s three generic strategies namely; low-
cost, differentiation, and focus on firm performance specified to firm performance. The
conceptual framework and research hypotheses were based on the existing literature, which
provided sufficient empirical evidence to show a strong link between the porter’s generic
strategy types and firm performance. The Pearson’s correlation and multiple regression
analysis applied test relation of three generic strategies on firm performance of the banks.
The results of both inferential analyses found to be more consistent and declared to the
positive relationship between firm performance and generic strategies. The empirical results
of this research have declared that three of Porter’s generic strategies are done positive
influences in bank firm performance. The impact of low-cost strategy is significant and
higher impact on firm performance than differentiation and focus strategies. However,
differentiation and focus strategies also are important in achieving more financial returns
thus, the managers could pursue combination of these strategies as to achieve more market
and financial returns.
References
Andrews, K. R. (1971). The concept of corporate strategy. Journal of Marketing, 58, 46–55.
Barney, J. B. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management.
17(1): 99-120.
Barney, J. B. (2002). Gaining and sustaining competitive advantage. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Berman, S.L., Wicks, A.C., Kotha, S., & Jones, T. M. (1999). Does stakeholder orientation matter?
The relationship between stakeholder management models. Academy of Management Journal,
42, 488-506.
Cannon, J. T. (1968). Business strategy and policy. Harcourt, Brace & World, New York.
Chakravarthy, B. S. (1986). Measuring strategic performance. Strategic Management Journal, 7, 437-
458.
Datta, D. K. (1991). Organization fit and acquisition performance: Effects of post-acquisition
integration.Strategic Management Journal, 12(4):281–297. doi: 10.1002/smj.4250120404
Datta, D. K., & Grant, J. H. (1990). Relationships between type of acquisition, the autonomy given
to the acquired firm, and acquisition success: an empirical analysis. Journal of Management,
16(1):29-44. doi: 10.1177/014920639001600103
David, F. R. (2017). Strategic management: Concepts and cases. Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle
River.
David, F.R. (2011) Strategic management: Concepts and cases. Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle
River.
David, F.R. (2017). Strategic management: Concepts and cases. Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle
River.
Dess, G. G., & Robinson, R. B. (1995). The case of the privately-held firm and conglomerate business
unit. Strategic Management Journal, 5(3), 265-273. doi: 10.1108/17410401311295722.
Dess, G. G., & Davis, P. S. (1984). Porter’s generic strategies as determinants of strategic group
membership and organizational performance .The Academy of Management Journal, 27(3), 467-
488.
Devlin, J. F. (1995). Technology and innovation in retail banking distribution. International Journal of
Bank Marketing, 13(4), 19-25.
Farrance, C., (1993). Can banks succeed in the current marketplace? International Journal of Bank
Marketing, 11(2), 3-9.
Govindarajan, V., & Fisher, J. (1990). Strategy, control systems, and resource sharing: Effects on business-
unit performance. Academy of Management Journal, 33(2), 259–285. doi.10.2307/256325
Griffin, R.W. (2005) Management (8th ed). Indian adaptation. Biztantra, New Delhi.
Hahn, W. Powers, T. L. (2010). Strategic plan quality implementation capabilities and firm performance.
Academy of Strategic Management Journal, 9(1) 63 – 81.
Hill, C. W. L. (1988). Differentiation versus low-cost or differentiation and low-cost: A contingency
framework. Academy of Management Review, 13 (3), 401-412.
Karyani, E, & Rossieta, H. (2018). Generic strategies and firm performance persistence in the banking
Rustamblin, D., Thoyib, A., & Zain, D. (2013). Pengaruh strategi generik terhadap kinerja perusahaan:
Studipada Bank Umum. Jurnal Aplikasi Manajemen, 11(1), 15-21.
Schendel, D., & Hofer, C. W. (1979). Strategic management: a new view of business policy and
planning. Little, Brown, Boston.
Stone, R. A., (1995). The business strategy game: faculty experiences and student perceptions. Journal
of Management Education, 19(2), 281-290. doi.10.1177/105256299501900216.
Varadarajan, P. R., & Clark, T. (1994). Delineating the scope of corporate, business, and marketing
strategy. Journal of Business Research, 31 (2-3), 93-105.
Venu, S. (2001). India: competitive advantage—alternative scenarios. Business Line, 12(1), 76–89.
Walker Jr., O.C., & Ruekert, R. (1987) Marketing’s role in the implementation of business strategies:
a critical review and conceptual framework. Journal of Marketing, 51, 15-34.
Wanjiku, M. L., & Deya, J. (2021). Effect of Competitive Strategies on Performance of Micro-Finance
Institutions in Kenya. International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and
Management Sciences, 11(1), 407- 422.
WOO, C. Y., & Cooper, A. C. (1981). Strategies of effective low share business. Strategic Management
Journal, 2(3), 301-318, https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.4250020307.
Yamin, S., Gunasekaran, A., & Mavondo, F. T. (1999). Relationship between generic strategies,
competitive advantage and organizational performance: an empirical analysis. Technovation, 19,
507–518.
Young, M. (1999), Market structure analysis: a foundation for developing and accessing bank strategy.
The International Journal of Bank Marketing, 17(1), 20-5.
Abstract
This study has examined the effect of issue of right share on share price movement in the
banking sector using share price and price relative as the predictors of share price movement.
Banking sub-index and index relative of different periods were used for analysis. Five
different periods of time were selected to observe the share price movement considering
the announcement date as the reference point of time. Based on the secondary sources of
data, a correctional analysis was administered to examine whether the share price and price
relative (banking index) has any relationship with the share price change in case of Nepalese
commercial banks.
Coefficient of determination and probable error were used to find how much percentage of
the variation in the share price could be explained by the occurrence of right share issue and
likewise, whether or not the relationship was significant. The results reveal that right share
announcements have the signaling effect on share price movement. The share prices and
banking indices of selected banks have decreased after the announcement of right share. The
results suggest that the information irregularity behavior tempts a negative change in share
price after the announcement of rights share. The implication of the results is that investors
can forestall the nature of change in share price after rights issue announcement and develop
strategic plans to expand the trading activity.
Keywords: NCC Bank., Right announcement, Right share issue, Price relative, Index
relative.
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
Capital is needed for every organization for various purposes and varies from one to another,
depending upon the types of companies and its peculiarities. Most of the companies need
capital for expansion, diversification and to cope with various financial dearth situations.
Right share is an option-based financing approach where existing shareholders are given
the right, but not the obligation, to purchase the proportionate number of shares that is equal
to the fraction of their current holding (Holderness, & Pontiff, 2016). Company uses long
term financing to finance in the long-term assets like land and investment, which remain
1 Joginder Goet is Asst. Professor at Shanker Dev Campus, Trubhuvan University, Nepal.
permanently with the company. Under the situation of under-capitalization, there may be
loss of various opportunities because of financial crisis and under the situation of over-
capitalization; most of the funds may remain idle, it can result in occasional over liquidity
which will definitely affect the profitability of the company. Both situations are harmful for
a company and may not be able to sustain for a longer period of time (Van Horne, 2002).
Encouraging stock price movements are detected in the case of seasoned equity issue (Barns,
& Walker, 2006; Kang, & Stulz, 1996). However, the long run response to seasoned capital
issues is stated to be mostly negative in the United States (Allen, & Soucik, 2008; Bayless, &
Jay, 2003). But, in the Asian countries the response to seasoned capital issues is observed to
be positive (Barns, & Walker, 2006; Kang, , & Stulz, 1996). According to the theory of rights
share offering, the price of shares increases after the announcement date and the price again
decrease after the allotment of shares to the extent of value of rights. So, if the same things
happen in the share market scenario, then the research like this seems to be an unnecessary
one. But, in practical life, the theory is not being followed. Problems regarding rights offering
in Nepal like, no company can issue their rights share at discount and premium, thus, all
companies are issuing rights share at par value. It causes vast deviation between market price
per share and subscription price per share. The main objective of this study is to examine the
rights share practice and its impact on share price movement of commercial banks in Nepal.
1.2 Objective
The primary and major objective of this study is to examine how the provisions and
announcement of rights share have been related regarding the difference in share price in the
case of Nepalese commercial banks.
2. Review of literature
Modigliani and Miller (1958) disclosed that in the absence of information irregularities and
taxes, the manner in which firms finance their investments is irrelevant. They also found
that when managers believe that the capital market undervalues equity of the firm, the
optimal financing choice is to issue risk- free debt or use a pre-emptive stock issue. White
and Luszting (1980) examined the result of the pooled regression provides more definitive
information on the price behavior associated with the announcement of rights offering. Since
the t-statistics on the announcement date dummy variables were statistically significant at the
1% level or better. The first hypothesis that average investors believe that there is negative
information associated with a right offering and cannot be rejected.
The second hypothesis, capital markets in this instance are inefficient, assumes that
management and investors’ expectations differ and that investors require time to assimilate
information. Since the coefficient on the dummy variables for the five days subsequent
to the announcement of the rights offering were not statistically different from zero to
5% confidence level, the null hypothesis that prices adjust quickly and unbiased to new
information cannot be rejected.
Marsh (1980) stated that UK companies raise virtually all of their new equity capital via
the rights issue. Companies can guarantee the subscription of their issue having them
underwritten and in recent years, this procedure has been adapted for 90% of UK rights
issues. Underwriting is usually carried out on a fixed fee basis representing at least 1.25%
of the total money raised, and hence it is clear that quite substantial sums of money are
involved.
Hansen (1988) concluded that the underwritten right offerings are associated with a price
decline of more than four percent just prior to the sale. This is opposing to the public offering
where there is little price concession. He contends that this price dip is due to the transaction
costs for placing new securities. For an underwritten right offering, transaction costs that
include flotation cost and price concession are higher than public offerings. So, he advocates,
it is not surprising that companies prefer public offerings than right offerings.
Lukose and Rao (2003) and Heron and Lie. (2004) specified management issue new shares
only when the market overvalues the shares. They exposed record of firms that have greater
stock price performance prior to the declaration of equity offerings. This finding is similar
to the finding of Thenmozhi, Malhotra, and Gopalaswamy (2007), who concluded that the
share price should not decrease if the firm issues safe debt (default and risk free) to finance
investment. This is because, based on the assumption that managers act on behalf of existing
shareholders, rational investors assume that managers issue new shares only when they
believe the stock is overvalued. In contrast to the above, Holderness and Pontiff (2013),
stated that, if the major reason for issuing shares is to take advantage of overvalued equity,
this would explain the rather limited use of rights offerings.
Paudel (2015) concluded that rights share was the major source of capital increment for
the listed companies in Nepal and the right share of commercial banks enclosed maximum
portion in total right issuance. Finance companies and development banks ranked the second
and third position regarding the coverage in the total rights issuance. About 96 percent of
the total rights issue of listed companies was subscribed. Holderness and Pontiff (2016)
found that on an average only 64 percent of the existing shareholders participated in
valuable domestic rights offerings in the U.S. They noted that the stock market responds
more negatively to the higher wealth transfers. Their findings suggest that agency conflicts
influence the use of rights offers.
Bist (2017) examined the empirical relationship between stock market development and
economic growth in Nepal over a period of 22 years from 1993 to 2014. Findings of this
study represent that the market capitalization has a positive impact on economic growth both
in the long as well as in the short run period of time. The result presented that inflation has
a negative and significant impact on GDP per capita in the long as well as in the short run.
Karanja (2006) recommended that firms that announce rights issue must consider information
asymmetry as this highly determines the firm’s share prices after successful rights issue and
also examined whether post offer price share performance is related to the decision to issue
rights instead of a firm’s commitment offering, if market offering is an important factor
affecting post issue stock returns. Olesaaya (2010) observed negative abnormal returns
prior to announcement of rights issue, positive abnormal returns during the announcement
and negative results thereafter, Miglani (2011) observed positive excess returns of 32 right
issues from India. They reported a gain of 1.42% in the shareholders’ wealth on the day of
announcement of right issue. Bashir (2013) investigated the market reaction to rights issue
announcement news by employing an event study methodology. The study found evidence
of existence of positive abnormal returns on event date. However, this gain in shareholders’
wealth was statistically insignificant. The study concluded that the reaction of Karachi
Stock Market is an indication of no rights issue announcement affects that is no wealth
maximization for investors.
Sakwa (2013) examined the results of the study that stock returns react positively to rights
issue announcements. A positive mean abnormal return was recorded over the event period
with the highest abnormal returns being on day t+2. There was a statistical difference
between mean abnormal returns observed during the event period and estimation period for
eighteen events and no statistical significance for one event. It was recommended that the
Capital market intensifies supervision of market participants to enforce compliance with
market regulations and also implement education programs to raise awareness among market
participants and reduce information asymmetry. Otieno and Ochieng (2015) concluded the
stock prices and returns changes significantly in the post announcement period than in the
preannouncement period. Based on the cumulative average abnormal return, the study
concluded that rights issue announcement results into a negative abnormal stock return for
the listed firms.
Kendirli and Elmali (2016) observed that finding of the study concluded that the investors
of deposit banks can yield abnormal returns in the period of ten days after right share
announcement. Even if it is not statically significant, the another finding of study is that
100% of abnormal returns of six days; 80% of abnormal returns of ten days and 60% of
abnormal returns of twelve days are negative. Pathak and Gupta (2018) conducted a research
on rights offering and its effect on share price movements taking five commercial banks
as sample size. In his research, he found that the right share offering announcement has
the signaling effect on the share price of the commercial banks. The market price of share
is influenced by right offerings. The share price of Nepalese commercial banks decreases
after the announcement of right share in spite of the increase in the market index in the
corresponding period. This in not consistent with the theory of right offering.
NJMSR Volume IV Issue I
99
https://www.nepjol.info/index.php/njmsr/index ISSN (Print) : 2467-9356, ISSN (Electronic) : 2795-1545
Impact of Right Share Issue on Share Price of Commercial Banks in Nepal
3. Research Methodology
The purpose of the study is to answer “Does issue of right share of the banks change the
share price movement?” It also explores the effect of issue of right share on market price of
share of the banks by using different indexes. For this purpose, share price, price relative,
banking sub-index and index relative have been considered as the most reliable and efficient
to check the market price of the share of the bank. These indexes also help in making rational
decisions and future planning about the issue of right share for the betterment of the market
price of the banks.
For measuring the share price movement of issue of right share, different indexes have been
considered to evaluate the impact of issue of right share. In this study, it deals with the
issue of right share of selected three banks. In order to analyze the market price movement
of banks before and after issue of right share, the different variables like share price, price
relative, banking sub-index and index relative etc. have been used.
The share price movement before and after the rights issue along with the movement of
market index simultaneously. The price relative shown in the third column is calculated
by either adding the percent increase in the price or subtracting the percent decrease in the
price of the share from 100 base value. Here, the base value 100 is considered as beginning
index value which is established for the price 90 days before the right announcement date.
Percentage change in the price, in the column four, is calculated by differentiating the
announcement date price from price of the share on each relative point of time and dividing
it by the price on 90 days before the announcement. The same method is followed for the
calculation of values for market index in columns six and seven. These changes are shown
in tables.
Note. I = 90 days before the announcement date (base date); II = 10 days before the
announcement date; III = The day of announcement; IV = 7 days after the announcement
date; V = 180 days after the announcement date.
Table 1 : Analysis of Share Price Movement of Nepal Credit and Commerce Bank
Selected Share Price % Change Banking Index % Change
Points of Price (Rs.) Relative from Base Sub-Index Relative from Base
Time 1 2 3 4 5 6
I 245 100 - 1152.81 100 -
II 235 95.92 -4.08 1016.74 88.20 -11.80
III 250 102.04 2.04 1036.82 89.94 -10.06
IV 241 98.37 -1.63 1017.51 88.26 -11.74
V 218 88.98 -11.02 1013.15 87.88 -12.12
Source: http://merolagani.com/CompanyDetail
Table 1 shows the share price movement of NCC Bank before and after the rights issue along
with the movement of market index simultaneously. According to the theory, the share price
increases after the right share announcement date until the book close date. Second column
of table shows the actual prices have fallen after the seven days and hundred eighty days of
announcement. On the other hand, the banking sub-indices have decreased after seven and
hundred eighty days of right announcement. While looking column 3, percentage change in
price relative from its base price has decreased by 4.08 percent in between periods I and II
but has increased by 2.04 percent in between periods II and III. In between periods III and
IV, the percentage in price relative has again decreased by 1.63 percent however, it has also
decreased by 11.02 percent in between IV and V. On the other hand, in the column 6, the
percentage change in index relative of all the periods have decreased by 11.80 percent,10.06
percent, 11.74 percent, 12.12 percent respectively from its base index. The fluctuation in
share price is not consistent with market. Thus, we can say that, the fluctuation in price of
share is not only due to general market movement. There must be some signalling effect of
right share offering.
Theoretically, the price of share should increase after the rights announcement for few days
and then after the price should decrease by the value of right. However, in the case of NCC
Bank, instead of increasing price, it has decreased after seven days of right announcement to
Rs. 241 and after hundred eighty days to Rs. 218 from Rs. 250. So, it has not met the theory.
Source: http://merolagani.com/CompanyDetail
Table 2 shows that the share price has been in decreasing trend from the base date till the
hundred eighty days of announcement. According to the theory, the share price increases
after the right share announcement date until the book close date. While analyzing the
percentage change in price relative and index relative, both have been in fluctuating trend.
Percentage change in price relative after seven days of announcement has decreased by
10.55 percent. However, percentage change in banking index has decreased by 3.58 percent
only. Thus, we can say that, general market movement along with right share offering has
been responsible for the price decrease. Theoretically, the price of share should increase after
the rights announcement for few days and then after the price should decrease by the value
of right. However, in the case of Kumari Bank, instead of increasing price, it has decreased
after seven days of right announcement to Rs. 246 and after hundred eighty days to Rs. 257
from Rs. 261. So, it has not met the theory.
Source: http://merolagani.com/CompanyDetail
Table 2 shows that the share price has been in decreasing trend from the base date till the
hundred eighty days of announcement. According to the theory, the share price increases
after the right share announcement date until the book close date. The percentage change
in price relative has been in decreasing trend from the base but index relative has been in
fluctuating trend. Percentage change in price relative after seven days of announcement has
decreased by 32.37 percent. However, percentage change in banking index has decreased by
7.94 percent only. Thus, we can say that, general market movement along with right share
offering has been responsible for the price decrease. Theoretically, the price of share should
increase after the rights announcement for few days and then after the price should decrease
by the value of right. However, in the case of Prabhu Bank, instead of increasing price, it has
decreased after seven days of right announcement to Rs. 305 and after hundred eighty days
to Rs. 278 from Rs. 314. So, it has not met the theory.
In case of NCC Bank, there has been a medium degree of positive correlation (r = 0.440). The
coefficient determination (r2) = 0.1936, which means that about 19.36 percent of variation in
the share price is explained by the general market movement. The coefficient of correlation
is greater than P.E. (P.E. = 0.243) which proves that correlation is significant. So, we can
conclude that the share price behavior of NCC Bank is due to general market movement.
While analyzing the correlation coefficient of Kumari Bank Ltd., there has been a moderate
positive correlation (r = 0.554) between share price and general market movement. This
relation has been further provided by the coefficient of determination which is 0.307 that is
30.70 percent, which means 30.70 percent of the price of KBL has been explained by general
market movement. The correlation coefficient (r) is greater than P.E. Thus, correlation is
significant which implies that the share price behavior of KBL is due to general market
movement.
In case of Prabhu Bank Limited, there has been a high degree of positive correlation (r =
0.737) between share price movement and general market movement. The coefficient of
determination which is 0.543 or 54.30 percent, which means that general market movement
has explained only 54.30 percent variation in the share price. Correlation coefficient (r) is
greater than P.E. implying it has been significant. So, we can conclude that the share price
behavior of Prabhu Bank Ltd. is because of general market movement.
The relationship between share price and Banking index is always positive. It means, Banking
indices increase due to increase in share price and vice-versa. In the above calculation of
three sample banks, all of them have been positively correlated. Sometimes, result may be
negatively correlated because the Banking index indicates the average increase or decrease
in share price of all listed banks. When individual share prices are independent from each
other, some may increase and some may decrease.
4. Conclusion
The results discussed above reveal that the right offering announcement has the signaling
effect on the share price of the selected banks. The fluctuation in price of share is not only
due to general market movement. There must be some signaling the effect of right share
offering. Theoretically, the price of share should increase after the rights announcement for
few days and then after the price should decrease by the value of right. The general market
movement along with right share offering has been responsible for the price decrease. The
relationship between share price and Banking index is always positive. It means, Banking
indices increase due to increase in share price and vice-versa.There has not been obvious
impact of rights offering on the share price movement in case of NCC Bank and Prabhu
Bank. But this has not hold true in case of Kumari Bank. Change in share prices of Kumari
Bank has not been due to the announcement of rights offering. It can be attributed to the
general market movement.
The rights offering have some significant impact on the share price. The general market
movement to a greater extent in Nepal also influences the market price of share. It is believed
that as the capital market gets matured and developed, rights issue practice would contribute
a lot to raising funds for every company
This study is a try to establish a link between right share issue announcements and market price
movement. This link is important because it is documented that the right share issue announcement
affects share price negatively and it conveys there is an irregularity in the market.
The results reveal the information irregularity behavior which brings a negative change in
market price after the announcement of rights and there is evidence of reducing market price
after the rights announcement. Investors can anticipate the nature of change in share price
after rights issue announcements and develop strategic plans to improve the trading activity
in the market.
5. Discussion
Initial public offering and right share offering are the two main means preferred by Nepalese
banks to collect the obligatory capital. The right offering announcement has the signalling
effect on the share price of the commercial banks. However, the right announcement gives a
negative signal to the stock market. The finding is not consistent with the result of Paudel’s
(2015) study, who found that the market price of share is influenced by right offerings. The
share price of Nepalese commercial banks decreases after the announcement of right in spite
of the increase in the market index in the corresponding period. This is consistent with the
theory of right offering in case of NCC Bank and Prabhu Bank but not in case of Kumari
Bank. However, the finding is consistent with the result of the earlier study by Pathak and
Giri (2008). The irregularity in the share price movement after the right announcement may
be either because of an inefficient market or leak of information before it becomes formally
public. Therefore, future study can be carried out to identify the cause of the irregularity in
share price in case of Kumari Bank by testing the efficiency of the Nepalese capital market.
References
Allen, D. E., & Soucik, V. (2008). Long run underperformance of seasoned equity offerings: Fact
or an Illusion? Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 78 (2), 146-154. doi: 10.1016/j.
matcom.2008.01.034.
Barns, E., & Walker, M. (2006). The seasoned-equity issues of UK Firms: Market reaction and issuance
method choice. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 33 (1), 45-78.
Bashir, A. (2013). Impact of right issues announcement on shareholders’ wealth: Case study of
Pakistani listed companies. International Journal of Contemporary Business Studies, 4 (3).
Bayless, M., & Jay, N. R. (2003). Is the performance of firms following seasoned equity issues
anomalous? Journal of Banking and Finance, 27 (7), 1273-1296.
Bist, J. P. (2017). Stock market development and economic growth in Nepal: An ARDL representation.
Journal of Finance and Economics, 5(4), 164-170. doi: 10.12691/jfe-5-4-2
Hansen, R. S. (1988). The demise of the rights issue. Review of Financial Studies, 1(3), 289-309. doi:
10.1093/rfs/1.3.289
Heron, R. A., & Lie, E. (2004). A Comparison of the motivations for and the information content of
different types of equity offerings. The Journal of Business, 77(3), 605-632.
Holderness, C. G., & Pontiff, J. (2013). Shareholder nonparticipation in valuable rights offerings. doi:
10.2139/ssrn.2173543
Holderness, C. G., & Pontiff, J. (2016). Shareholder nonparticipation in valuable right offerings: New
findings for an old puzzle. Journal of Financial Economics, 120(2), 252-268. Retrieved from
https://www2.bc.edu/ Clifford Holderness/Rights Offerings_ and_Shareholder_Nonparticipation.
pdf.
Holderness, C. G., & Pontiff, J. (2016). Shareholder nonparticipation in valuable right offerings: New
findings for an old puzzle. Journal of Financial Economics, 120(2), 252-268. Retrieved from
https://www2.bc.edu/ clifford-holderness/Rights_Offerings_ and_Shareholder_Nonparticipation.
pdf
Kang, J. K., & Stulz, R. M. (1996). How different is Japanese corporate finance? An investigation of
the information content of new equity issues. Review of Financial Studies, 9, 109–139.
Karanja, A. (2006). An Evaluation of post rights issue effect on firms’ share price and traded volumes.
Unpublished MBA Project. Egerton University.
Kendirli, S., & Elmali, M.E. (2016). The Effects of Right Offering Announcements on Returns of
Shares of Deposit Banks. Journal of Economic Development, Environment and People, 5.
Lukose, P. J. J., & Rao, S. N. (2003). Operating performance of the firms issuing equity through rights
offer. Vikalpa, 28(4), 25-40.
Marsh, P. (1980). Valuation of underwriting for UK rights issue. The Journal of Finance, XXXV (III),
639-715.
Miglani, P. (2011). An empirical analysis of impact of right Issues in the Indian listed companies.
Journal of Arts, Science and Commerce, 2, 169-176.
Modigliani, F., & Miller, M. H. (1958). The cost of capital, corporation finance and the theory of
investment. The American Economic Review, 48(3), 261-297.
Olesaaya, E. (2010). The effects of rights issue on stock returns. Case Study of Companies Listed at
the NSE. University of Nairobi.
Otieno, O. D., & Ochieng, D. E. (2015). The effects of Rights Issue Announcements on Stock Returns
for Firms Listed at the Nairobi Securities Exchange. international Journal of Education and
Research, 3 (9), 411-426.
Pathak, H., & Giri, D. (2008). Right share issue practices in Nepal. The Journal of Nepalese Business
Studies, 5(1), 93-100.
Pathak, H.P. & Gupta, S. (2018). Right Offering and its Effect on Share Price Movement. A Study of
Commercial Banks. The Journal of Nepalese Business Studies, XI (1), 1-13.
Paudel, R. K. (2015). Analysis of right share practice in Nepal and its effect in market price
(Unpublished master’s thesis). FOM, Prithvi Narayan Campus, Pokhara, Nepal.
Sakwa, C. (2013). The effect of rights issue announcement on stock returns of companies listed at the
Nairobi securities exchange. An Unpublished Master Degree Thesis, Submitted to Office of the
Dean, Faculty of Management, Tribhuvan University. Kathmandu.
Thenmozhi, M., Malhotra, M., & Gopalaswamy, A. K. (2007). Announcement effect of rights issue on
stock returns:A study of selected Indian manufacturing companies. Journal of Services Research,
7(1), 215-231.
Van Horne, J.C. (2002). Financial Management and Policy. New Delhi: Prentice Hall of India.
White, R. W., & Luszting, P. A. (1980). The Price Effect of Rights Offering. The Journal of Financial
and Quantitative Analysis, XV (I), 25-40.
Abstract
This study examines the intersectional relationship between work-family conflict and
career progress of married women employed in the financial sector within Kathmandu
Valley. Although both work and family are important dimensions of human life, in
Nepalese context the intersectional relationship between gender roles, work and family
responsibilities and career progress has been inadequately studied. Hence, this research
aims to conceptualize work-family conflict by examining the intersectional relationship
between socio-demographic factors, antecedents of work-family conflict and career progress
of married women employees in the context of Nepalese Financial Sector. In this study
intersectional research design has been used to analyze relationships between variables
together with ninety (N=90) married women employees as research participants. Results of
both descriptive and inferential statistics indicate that asymmetry still remains prevalent and
permeable among married women employees regarding their work-family interfaces and
involvements. Hence, antecedents of work family conflict intersect a predictive association
with subsequent existential experiences, ambition gaps and perceptions that negatively
influences career progress of married women. Based on the findings, this study recommends
a sustainable corporate culture and human resources management practices that remains
sensitive to gender issues and also assimilates complex and conflicting necessities of both
work and family involvements.
1 Gaurav Ojha is the Faculty at IEC College of Arts and Fashion. He is also the visiting Faculty of Sunway
International Business School & Kathmandu University School of Arts, Nepal.
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
This study examines the intersectional relationship between work-family conflict and career
progress of married women in the context of Nepalese financial sector. In Nepalese context,
different studies have examined antecedents of work- life balance and work-family conflict and
its potential consequences on career satisfaction, job satisfaction and well-being of employees
in financial sector (Adhikary, 2018; Pathak, 2018; Acharya, & Padmavathy, 2018). However,
possibilities of differentiated understanding using an intersectional approach when it comes to
conceptualizing work-family conflict by acknowledging distinct contextual experiences of being
married, woman and employed in Nepalese financial sector remains as a research gap.
Moreover, the importance of the intersectional approach used in this study for analyzing
work-family conflicts has been confirmed by the Gender Equality Index, 2019 published by
European Institute for Gender Equality. As the survey exemplifies, certain groups of people,
especially married women employees are expected to carry the double burden of work and
family and are always at disadvantage in their search for reliefs from constant pressures of
work-family conflict (Gender Equality Index, 2019).
Even with ever increasing inclusion of women as employees in Nepalese Financial sector
regarding positions of top level managers, executives and leadership positions in these
organizations, still women are discouragingly underrepresented. As evidence indicates
according to Nepal labor force survey 2017/18 (Central Bureau of Statistics, 2019) human
resource employed in financial services consists of 63,000 men and 55,000 women, hence
in terms of percentage gender disparity only entails to 6.78 %, however when it comes
to executive and leadership positions within financial sector gender disparity remains
enormous and still there is a sharp contrasts between supply of women with relevant degrees
in financial sector and executive position occupied by women employees.
More importantly, among different factors that influence married women’s career
advancement in an organizational context, as compared to men, women employees are
perceived as having work-family conflict and these perceptions result in glass ceiling
barriers regarding their career progress (Hoobler et al., 2009). More importantly, Hoobler
et al. (2009) have indicated that both male and female top-level managers still perceive
women employees as having greater family-work conflict and this perception has significant
implications for career advancement of women employees. Therefore, it is necessary to
conceptualize the prevalence of work-family conflicts within the experiences of married
women employees. After all, the impact of work family conflict remains as a glass ceiling,
potential stereotype and perceptual bias regarding their career progress.
Besides, in Nepalese context work family conflict is not perceived as a serious problem
for a married woman because in a collectivist society dominated by masculine orientations
regarding gender roles, women are expected to share the burden of family responsibilities
exclusively (Hofstede et al., 2005). And, gender roles prevalent within Nepalese culture still
categories women as responsible for family matters, hence exclusively incompatible with
higher organizational roles and responsibilities.
In a survey conducted by McKinsey & Company entitled closing the gap leadership
perspectives on promoting women in financial services, nearly half of senior-level women
say that they continue to accept most of household responsibilities, while just 13 % of their
male peers do the same. More importantly, as the survey indicates, women in entry-level
roles in financial services seldom envision themselves in a top executive position and most
of the entry-level women in financial services have concerns about balancing family and
work commitment (Chin et al., 2018).
However, there is no study in Nepalese context that acknowledges gender inequalities within
both work patterns and family structures where women before men are expected to carry the
double burden of work and family. More importantly, this study examines contextual effects
on work – family conflict incorporating a range of contextual demographic characteristics
and intersectional experiences that subsequently results into negative perceptions and
stereotypes regarding career progress of married women.
Besides, no other study has examined issues related with work-family conflict from the
perspective of Sustainable Development Goal-5 that aims to overcome this leadership
and empowerment gap by eliminating many root causes of gender discrimination and
career progress barriers within both private and public spheres by 2030, and this study
acknowledges work-family conflict as an important hindrance for career progress of married
women employed.
Similarly, regarding time pressures this study builds its theoretical orientations from the
rational model, this model proposes that people who spend more time on either work or family
domains may experience mutual propositions of conflict in each domain (Gutek et al., 1991).
In addition, for involvement misbalance this study develops its theoretical foundations from
role theory. Role theory also proposes that multiple roles lead to imbalance of involvement
as it becomes more difficult to perform each role successfully, due to conflicting demands on
time, lack of energy, or incompatible behaviors among roles (Greenhaus, & Beutell, 1985).
Regarding, involvement imbalances and its stress, conservation of resources theory also
explains stress outcomes for both inter-role stress, this model proposes that inter-role conflict
leads to stress because resources are lost in the process of juggling both work and family
roles (Wright, & Cropanzano, 1998) and increasing female representation in Nepalese
financial sector means that married women are juggling between their work and family roles
and eventually this inter-role conflict creates constant condition of involvement imbalances
for a married women.
Moreover, in a study, Lakmal and Gahan (2019) based on identity theory, concluded that
crossover effects of work and family role imbalances were found to be more pronounced
for women than men. Moreover, in a study Edwards and Rothbard (2000) have linked
mechanisms between work and family and identified time as a finite resource, hence
spending time in one life domain would automatically result in diminished time available
to perform in another domain that subsequently results in constant time pressure. Recent
studies in North American (Chin et al., 2018) and European context (Gender Equality Index,
2019) also indicate that asymmetry continues to exist between genders when it comes to
sharing the burden of family responsibilities and family interference on work.
Similarly, Chincholkar and Krishna (2012) in a study on the work-family conflict among
the married working executives in Greater Mumbai argued that women employees were
acknowledging responsibilities than they would to deliver themselves in both domains and
the article concluded that women need to redefine role expectations for themselves and their
families. Similarly, in a study Hyman and Summers (2004) on financial sectors find that in
the United Kingdom both direct and indirect work intrusions into domestic responsibilities
of married employees.
Moreover, Jogulu and Wood (2011) in a study regarding married women and their career
progress as comparative study between Malaysia and Australia‘s middle managers indicate
that women in two countries studied still have significant responsibilities for performing
family duties, and bringing up children. In particular, the Malaysian respondents viewed
family and personal responsibilities as their greatest impediment to attaining senior
management positions. Besides, in a study, Valdez, and Gutek (1987) mention the career
progression of working women will be affected due to work-family conflict.
Socio-demographic Antecedents
factors:
Of Work Family conflict
Married, gender-role, (Involvement Misbalances,
family expectation, age, Time pressures, Spill-over
dual career couple, family, strains)
employees age of children
Outcome:
Negative impact on career progress
(Ambition Gaps, Work-family interface
challenges and Perceptual Bias)
Outcome:
Negative impact on career progress
(Ambition Gaps, Work-family interface
challenges and Perceptual Bias)
Based on the above conceptual framework this study was guided by the following research
questions:
RQ2. Are socio-demographic factors such gender-role, family expectation, age, dual career
couple, family and age of children contributing factors to antecedents of work-family conflict
and its subsequent outcome?
3. Research Design
In this study intersectional quantitative design has been used for this study and intersectional
approach to research indicates that different combinations can lead to different lived
experiences of individuals in comparison to other individuals who might share one or
more, but not all of the same elements (Christoffersen,2018). Methodological implications
of intersectionality include the experiences of those at an intersection of multiple cultural,
institutional and social positions that may not be accurately described by cross-sectional
studies. This research design allows for framing social category such as gender using
purposive sampling, to examine how measures demonstrate conceptual equivalence,
measurement invariance and multiple level of intersectional even within a particular group
(Else-Quest, & Hyde, 2016)
4. Findings
4.1 Demographic information
Demographic data from the survey indicate that of 90 married women (N=90) sampled for
this study, 40% (n=36) of the respondent were under the age group of 30-40 age and 30%
(n=27) were under the age group of 20-30 age and rest (n=27) were in the age group of 40-50
and 50 above. Majority of research participants in this study have under-graduate or master's
degrees (80%, n=72) and 12% have master's in philosophy or doctoral degree (n=11) and
the rest 8% (n=7) have completed high-school. Again, among married women employees
approximately, 65% of respondents have management degrees and 25% have humanities
and social science degrees and 10% have computer related degrees. Approximately 50%
(n=45) have work experience in the financial sector for 5-10 years, 20% have less than 5 and
remaining 30% are into the category of 10-15 and above.
No. of Percentage
Respondents character
responses (Approximately)
Work Experience
Less than 5 years 18 20%
5-10 years 45 50%
10-15 years and above 27 30%
Total 90 100%
Organizational Hierarchy
Lower Level 9 10%
Middle Level 68 75%
Senior Management 13 15%
Total 90 100%
Dual Career Couples
Dual Career Couples 68 75%
Non-Dual Career Couples 22 25%
Total 90 100%
Family Structure
Nuclear Family 54 60%
Joint Family 36 40%
Total 90 100%
Number of Children
Without any Child 23 25%
1 Child 49 55%
2 or more that two children 18 20%
Total 90 100%
Of sample married employee (N=90) within organizational hierarchy 15% (n=13) are in
senior management position, approximately 75 % (n=68) on middle-level & lower level and
10% (n=9) in non-managerial position and this demographic data regarding organizational
position also exemplifies the findings of a discussion note published by IMF that has
identified large gaps between the representation of men and women in leadership positions
in banks and in banking-supervision agencies worldwide (Sahay, & Cihak, 2018). Similarly,
the study finds that approximately 75% (n=68) women employees are dual career couples
and in 65% (n=58) families both mom and dad work full time.
Regarding family structure, majority of respondents are part of nuclear family (60%, n=54)
and rest 40%, (n=36) belonged to joint family and concerning children, 55% (N=49) of
sample married women are with one child, 25 % of them are without any child and rest
20% have 2 or more than two children. Similarly, approximately 90 % (n=81) of married
women with children are using child-care centers and pre-school for their child under age
of 6 and the rest of them, 30% (n=24) are using in-home care. Besides, approximately 45%
(n=41) of respondents indicate that they have used child-care centers for their child within
6-15 months of age and majority of respondents, 70% (n=63) of them fall under the 30-40
age group.
Consequently, on the issue of gender differences, 78% (n=70) of participants have responded
in the range of very much and much that asymmetry still continues to exist between men
and women in work and family roles and being a woman contributes to their experience of
work-family conflict. In addition, regarding comparative rank question on influence of work
and family demands, 60% of participants (n=54) responded that expectation of family has
greater impact on their career progress than work and this finding relates with a study by
Choi (2008) that work and family demands cause life stress among Chinese employees and
the effect of family demands on life stress is mediated by work–family conflict.
Approximately 80% (n=72) of married women indicate very much or much regarding their
involvement in domestic responsibilities more than their husband. Similarly, regarding the
response on do you consider challenges of work-family interference have resulted into an
ambition gap regarding your career progress, approximately 70% (n=63), identify very much
and much. Here, comparable with findings of Chin et al., (2018), this study also explores
that the challenge of balancing work family conflict results in ambition gaps for a married
woman employee.
Similarly, Person's correlation also indicates a positive relation (r=0.78, P=0.025) between
negative impact of work-family conflict on career progress (Do you think work-family
conflict negatively influences your career progress) and gender difference (Do you think
your gender roles influence your experience of work-family conflict). Similarly there is a
positive and significant relationship between being a dual career couple (r=0.72, P=0.020),
regarding age of youngest child (r=0.12, P=0.44) there is statistically insignificant and weak
positive correlation. Likewise, regarding child and parent role, a study found that women
find their child as central to their identity and give more importance to parental role (Gaunt
& Scott, 2017). Hence, married women find it difficult to consider the age of their child as a
burden. Regarding family expectations, this factor has a positive and significant relationship
with work family conflict (r=0.67, P=0.032).
group. Regarding age, approximately 80% (n=29) of women in the age range of 30-40
age group and 60% (n=20-30) indicate their current age group as an important factor that
influences their work family conflict and also their concerns about career progress. Therefore,
this study has evaluated a statistically significant degree of difference among demographic
factors (age) and its association with work-family conflict. After all, a study indicates that
the relationship between gender and work-life conflict is significantly moderated by age
(Cloninger et al., 2015).
*.Significant at the 0.05 level, R2 = 0.68, F = 33.032, p < .05 β = Standardized Regression
Coefficient, * p <.05
Since standardized βs are positive, based on regression analysis this study indicates that 1
percent enhance in involvement imbalances, time pressures and spill-over strains, normally,
and has the positive relationship influence of a rising work-family conflict that results in
hindrance for the career progress of a married woman. Regression analysis of this study
confirms the model of Greenhaus and Beutell (1985), which recognizes time, strain and
involvement imbalances as sources of work-family conflict.
As comparable to findings, another study has also indicated that as the employed mother
is experiencing time pressures in work and family roles then the motivation to advance her
career diminish (Bartolome & Evans, 1979). Regarding involvement imbalances and its
stress, conservation of resources theory also explains stress outcomes of inter-role imbalances
results in a negative state of being (Grandey, & Cropanzano, 1999) that culminate into lack
of interest in career development.
5. Discussions
In this study, descriptive and inferential results indicate an intersectional relationship
between different socio-demographic factors such gender-role, family expectation, age, dual
career couple and age of children and work-family, and the result of descriptive, correlation
and chi-square analysis are comparable with studies that have been conducted in South
Asian Context (Jain & Nair, 2016; Rajadhyaksha, & Velgach 2009; Buddhapriya, 2009) and
consistent with other studies that have considered moderating role of socio-demographic
factors on work-family conflict (Pleck, 1977; Byron, 2005).
Descriptive analysis of the study indicates that among sample married women within
organizational hierarchy 15% are in senior management position and this find is
comparable to a study by Chin et al. (2018) research shows that women remain significantly
underrepresented in the upper levels of financial-services companies and even in Northern
American Context, women account for only 19 % of leadership positions. Hence, despite
this growth of employment opportunities for women in Nepalese financial sector, regarding
leadership, senior managerial and senior professional roles, gender disparity remains
extremely high (Ross-Smith, & McGraw, 2010).
Moreover, this study finds that career decisions of married women employee, predominantly
guided by the demands of family care and they experience negative spill-over effects of
work-family conflict on their career. And, this asymmetric remains consistent even in this
study and also comparable to findings by Abeysekera and Gahan (2019) that the impact of
crossover effects of work-family conflicts was found to be more pronounced for women.
Besides, as socio-demographic variables associated with family domain and presence of
antecedents of work-family conflict in both professional and family role of a married woman
indicate that ambition gap persists even among married women employee because of their
inability to balance family and due to this major reason they are not pursuing top executive
roles (Chin et al., 2018). After all, based on the findings of inferential statistics, this study
also concludes that an employee experiencing strains of work family conflict is less likely to
participate or take initiatives for career development (Higgins et al., 1992)
More importantly, Hoobler et al. (2009) consider work-family conflict as a main hurdle for
career progress of a married women employee since top-level management perceives women
having greater family-work conflict and therefore view them as mismatched for leadership
roles in an organization. And, due to asymmetrical involvement in both work and family
domains, there is a tendency among top-level managers to perceive women employees as
experiencing greater family-work conflict. Therefore, mismatched for career advancements
and leadership fits within the working style of the financial sector that recognizes long
hours as organizational commitment, besides it is difficult for married women to balance
the conflicts arising from work and family spheres (Lockwood, 2003). After all, this study
also indicates that balancing work and family conflict is both experientially and existentially
difficult for employed married women.
Moreover, this study recommends a need for sustainable corporate culture and human resource
practices which acknowledges diversity, family supportive cultures, and gender issues and
assimilates complex and conflicting necessities of both work and family. Besides, this study
recommends organizations to realize that work and family are interrelated domains, and
strains experienced in each domains have a mutual impact on another (Kalliath et al.,2012).
More importantly, gender inequalities in work–family balance decreases opportunities for
career progress among married woman (Sullivan, 2019)
This article also recommends that organizations need to introduce family-friendly policies,
flexible work arrangements, compressed workweek plans and cultivate a family-supportive
organizational culture to ensure that married women employees have the necessary family
supportive programs. Besides, organizations need supportive resources for those employees
who are most in need for balancing work-family interfaces (Mansour, & Tremblay,
2018). And, to reduce stress associated with work-family conflict, it is also necessary
for organizations to incorporate policies that facilitate work–family enrichment (Jain, &
Nair, 2020). Besides, it is necessary for organizations to develop systematic and robust
organization-based approach to provide solution for work-family conflict within financial
institutions especially for married female employees (Ajayi et al., 2020)
Moreover, recent study indicates that clarifying priorities between work and family roles
may result into lesser work family conflict (Erdogan et al., 2019) Therefore, concerning
married women, this study recommends them to become better with role segmentation,
seek colleague support, negotiate for flexible work arrangements, have enough courage to
overcome social criticisms and disapprovals, cultivate highly impermeable and inflexibly
role boundaries between work and family domain.
References
Abeysekera, L., & Gahan, P. (2019). Work–family conflict among Australian dual-earner couples:
Testing the effects of role salience crossover and gender. The International Journal of Human
Resource Management, 30(10), 1549-1582.
Acharya, A., &Padmavathy, G. (2018). Work life balance and job satisfaction: A study from private
banks of Nepal. International Journal for Advance Research and Development, 3(12), 33-37.
Adhikary, J. R. (2018). Work Family Conflict and Career Satisfaction: Role of Social Support,NRB
Economic Review.30(1), 69-96.
Adhikary, J. R. (2016). Barriers to career progression: a study of the perceptions of Nepali women
employees. Journal of Business and Management Research, 1(2), 17-32.
Ajayi, M. P., Olawande, T. I., Jegede, A. E., Amoo, E. O., & Olawole-Isaac, A. (2020). Work-
family conflict: Evaluating the mediating role of personal intervening strategies. Cogent Social
Sciences, 6(1), 1731224.
Bartolomé, F., & Evans, P. A. L. (1979). Professional lives versus private lives-shifting patterns of
managerial commitment. Organizational Dynamics, 7(4), 3-29.
Bellavia, G. M. (2005). Work-family conflict. I J. Barling, EK Kelloway & MR Frone (Red.) Handbook
of Work Stress (s. 113–147).
Buddhapriya, S. (2009). Work-family challenges and their impact on career decisions: A study of
Indian women professionals. Vikalpa, 34(1), 31-46.
Byron, K. (2005). A meta-analytic review of work–family conflict and its antecedents. Journal of
Vocational Behavior, 67(2), 169-198.
Central Bureau of Statistics. (2019) Report on Nepal Labor Force Survey, 2017/18.Kathmandu, Nepal:
CBS Chincholkar, S., & Krishna, N. (2012). Work-Family Conflict of Married Women Business
Executives in Mumbai. SIES Journal of management, 8(2).
Chin S., Nadeau M., &Krivkovich A. (2018). Closing the gaps in perspectives on promoting women in
financial services. Global Banking Practice. New York:McKinsey and Company
Choi, J. (2008). Work and family demands and life stress among Chinese employees: The mediating
effect of work–family conflict: Work and family demands and life stress among Chinese
employees: The mediating effect of work–family conflict. The International Journal of Human
Resource Management, 19(5), 878-895.
Christoffersen, A. (2018). Researching Intersectionality: Ethical Issues: Jo Campling Essay Prize,
Postgraduate Winner, 2018. Ethics and Social Welfare, 12(4), 414-421.
Cinamon, R. G., & Rich, Y. (2005). Work–family conflict among female teachers. Teaching and
Teacher Education, 21(4), 365-378.
Cloninger, P. A., Selvarajan, T. T., Singh, B., & Huang, S. (2015). The mediating influence of work–family
conflict and the moderating influence of gender on employee outcomes. The Journal of Human
Resource Management, 26(18), 2269-2287.
Edwards, J. R., & Rothbard, N. P. (2000). Mechanisms linking work and family: Clarifying the
relationship between work and family constructs. Academy of management review, 25(1), 178- 199.
Else-Quest, N. M., & Hyde, J. S. (2016). Intersectionality in quantitative psychological research: I.
Theoretical and epistemological issues. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 40(2), 155-170.
Erdogan, I., Ozcelik, H., & Bagger, J. (2019). Roles and work–family conflict: how role salience and
gender comes into play. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 8(23), 1-23
Grandey, A. A., &Cropanzano, R. (1999). The conservation of resources model applied to work–family
conflict and strain. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 54(2), 350-370.
Greenhaus, J. H., & Beutell, N. J. (1985). Sources of conflict between work and family roles. Academy
of management review, 10(1), 76-88.
Greenhaus, J. H., & Powell, G. N. (2012). The family-relatedness of work decisions: A framework and
agenda for theory and research. Journal of vocational behavior, 80(2), 246-255.
Gutek, B. A., Searle, S., & Klepa, L. (1991). Rational versus gender role explanations for work-family
conflict. Journal of applied psychology, 76(4), 560.
Higgins, C. A., Duxbury, L. E., & Irving, R. H. (1992). Work-family conflict in the dual-career
family. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 51(1), 51-75.
Hofstede, G., Hofstede, G. J., &Minkov, M. (2005). Cultures and organizations: Software of the mind
(Vol. 2). New York: Mcgraw-hill.
Hoobler, J. M., Wayne, S. J., & Lemmon, G. (2009). Bosses' perceptions of family-work conflict and
women's promotability: Glass ceiling effects. Academy of management journal, 52(5), 939-957.
Huffman, A., S. Culbertson, S., B. Henning, J., & Goh, A. (2013). Work-family conflict across the
lifespan. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 28 (7/8), 761-780.
Index, G. E. Work-life balance (2019) European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE -Gender Equality-
Index-2019).
Jain, S., & Nair, S. K. (2016). Work–Family Conflict in India: Construct Validation and Current
Status. Asia-Pacific Journal of Management Research and Innovation, 12(1), 31-45.
Jain, S., & Nair, S. K. (2020). Integrating work–family conflict and enrichment: understanding the
moderating role of demographic variables. International Journal of Organizational Analysis. 28
(2),23-31.
Jogulu, U., & Wood, G. (2011). Women managers' career progression: an Asia Pacific perspective.
Gender in Management: An International Journal, 26(8), 590-603.
Kalliath, P., Hughes, M., & Newcombe, P. (2012). When work and family are in conflict: Impact on
psychological strain experienced by social workers in Australia. Australian Social Work, 65(3),
355-371.
Lockwood, N. R. (2003). Work/life balance. Challenges and Solutions, SHRM Research, USA.
Mansour, S., & Tremblay, D. G. (2018). Work–family conflict/family–work conflict, job stress,
burnout and intention to leave in the hotel industry in Quebec (Canada): moderating role of need
for family friendly practices as “resource passageways”, The International Journal of Human
Resource Management, 29(16), 2399-2430.
Pathak, R. R. (2018). Work Life Balance in Nepalese Commercial Banks. Journal of Business and
Social Sciences, 2(1), 116-125.
Phipps, S., Burton, P., & Osberg, L. (2001). Time as a source of inequality within marriage: are
husbands more satisfied with time for themselves than wives? Feminist economics,7(2), 1-21
Pleck, J. H. (1977). The work-family role system. Social problems, 24(4), 417-427.
Rajadhyaksha, U., &Velgach, S. (2009, May). Gender, gender role ideology and work-family conflict in
India. In Academy of Management Annual Meeting (pp. 1-40).
Ross-Smith, A., & McGraw, P. (2010). EOWA 2010: Australian census of women in leadership:
research conducted by Macquarie University, supported by ANZ.
Sahay, M. R., & Cihak, M. M. (2018). Women in Finance: A Case for Closing Gaps.
International Monetary Fund. Sullivan, O. (2019). Gender inequality in work-family balance. Nature
Human Behaviour, 3(3), 201-203.
Valdez, R. L., & Gutek, B. A. (1987). Family roles: A help or hindrance for working women? In B. A.
Gutek & L. Larwood (Eds.), Women’s career development (pp. 157-169). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Vithanage, V., & Arachchige, B. J. (2017). A study on the work-family balance and job performance of
academics in Sri Lanka. IUP Journal of Management Research, 16(2), 7-18.
Voydanoff, P. (2005). Consequences of boundary-spanning demands and resources for work-to-family
conflict and perceived stress. Journal of occupational health psychology, 10(4), 491-505.
Wright, T. A., &Cropanzano, R. (1998). Emotional exhaustion as a predictor of job performance and
voluntary turnover. Journal of applied psychology, 83(3), 486.
Abstract
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
The concept of women empowerment and entrepreneurship development have assumed
greater relevance in developed as well as developing nations across the world. The
development of entrepreneurship, which is a human activity, has become imperative in
the economic development and prosperity of any country. The success of an economy
1. Siby Abraham, PhD is an assistant Professor, Department of Economics, Sacred Heart College
(Autonomous), Kochi, Kerala, India.
2. Prof. Himachalam Dasaraju is a Senior Fellow & Professor Emeritus (former), Commonwealth Visiting
Fellow, UK. He has served at Sri Venkateswara University, Tirupati, Andra Pradesh, India.
3. Jency Treesa, PhD is an Assistant Professor, Department of Commerce, St. Teresa’s College (Autonomous),
Kochi, Kerala, India.
According to the World Bank, empowerment means "the process of increasing the capacity
of individuals or groups to make choices and to transform those choices into desired actions
and outcomes”. The core of this process is actions which build both individual and collective
assets and improve the efficiency and fairness of the organizational and institutional context
which govern the use of these assets (UN, 2012). The empowerment is multidimensional
encompassing the extension of freedom of choice and action in social, economic, and political
spheres thereby upholding one's life with adequate control over resources and decisions.
Women's freedom is often restricted due to the inherent gender inequality prevailing in
homes and society. For the empowerment, women require a lot of assets and capabilities
at the individual level to transform the untapped assets into products or services. The right
approach towards achieving this end could be through entrepreneurship development among
women. The entrepreneurial spirit with good education is one of the most important means of
empowering women with the knowledge, skills, and self-confidence necessary to participate
fully in the development process of any economy (UNFPA Report, 1995).
2. Research Methodology
The study aims firstly, to examine the problem of gender gap existing in India and the policy
measures taken by the Government of India to promote women entrepreneurship. Content
analysis was used for analyzing the textual material required for this. In this approach building
a coding frame is central (Schreier, 2012). Extensive literature review was done to gather
published data and the based on the research objectives data was coded based on the theme
of women entrepreneurship and policy measures taken to promote women entrepreneurship.
To know the problem of women entrepreneurs, one to one expert interview was conducted
among 6 women entrepreneurs. Meuser and Nagel (2009) discuss the expert interviews as a
specific form of applying semi- structured interviews. The problems of women entrepreneurs
enlisted in the latter part of the paper is the experts’ subjective orientations, points of view
and interpretations.
3. Review of Literature
There is a growing body of literature that recognizes women empowerment as a solution for
bridging the gender equality. The literature review is based on themes as Women empowerment
and gender equity, Women's Empowerment: Global Scenario, Women Empowerment:
Indian Scenario, Women Entrepreneurship as a Means of Women Empowerment, Women’s
Entrepreneurship - present need, scope of women entrepreneur, and Institutional Support for
Women Entrepreneurship in India.
The Gender-related Development Index (GDI) and the Gender Empowerment Measure
(GEM) were introduced in 1995 in the Human Development Report of the UNDP with
the prime aim of the measures were to add a gender-sensitive dimension to the Human
Development Index (HDI). It is high time to presume that every woman should be self-
reliant, self-sufficient, healthy, resilient, respected, courageous, strong, equal treatment, and
heard. For strengthening this movement every year on the 8th of March observed globally
the International Women's Day to review the progress and propose the action plan to achieve
the target. International Women's Day was organized globally on March 8, 2021, and debated
on the main theme "Choose to Challenge". Further, the celebrations focused on the review
of the achievements of women and calls for action to empower women to create a gender-
equal world.
Empowerment of women and minimizing the gender gaps in the world of work will in
general help to achieve the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and particularly
achieve the Sustainable Development Goals: Goal 1 on ending poverty, Goal 2 on food
security, Goal 3 on ensuring health, Goal 5 to achieve gender equality, Goal 8 to promote
full and productive employment and decent work for all; and also Goal 10 on reducing
inequalities (UN-SDGs, 2020).
A recent study in the United States indicated that 1 out of every 11 adult women is an
entrepreneur. Women business owners generated overall employment of 18 million workers
and earned from $2 to $3 trillion in U.S. economy revenues. Women substantially contribute
towards economic development and their contribution in the development process has
been continually increasing all over the world. The steep rise in the number of female
entrepreneurs can be attributed to many reasons like passion to pursue their ideas, the desire
to become self-employed, and the urge to address philanthropic causes and this is at par with
the rationale of their male counterparts. It is a truth that the women in almost all the known
societies of the world have not enjoyed the same status, privileges, rights, and powers as men
(Mayoux, L, 2000).
relevant and important for sustainable human development (UNFPA, 2007). The concept of
human development has evolved out as a broader measure of the socio-economic progress
of the nation. Human development is measured in the form of a composite index called the
Human Development Index (HDI). In 1995, the Human Development Report put forward the
concept of Gender-related Development Index (GDI) and Gender Empowerment Measure
(GEM). GDI, while measuring the achievements in the same dimensions and variables as
the HDI, also incorporates inequality in achievement between women and men (Anand et.
al, 1995).
The world population increased from 3.6 billion to 7 billion between 1970 and 2011.
As that population becomes more educated, its growth rate will slow down. The Human
Development Report of 1995 focused on gender inequality in the development process of
various countries. It highlighted the fact that among 900 million illiterates in the developing
world, women outnumbered men. Among the 1.3 billion people in poverty, 70 per cent were
women. But the invisible non- monitored contribution of women to the world output was
a staggering $ 11 trillion per annum i.e., nearly 50 per cent of the official estimated world
output of $ 22 trillion. The report also said that women's position was unenviable in all
countries and in all respects. Even in administrative and managerial careers, women were far
behind. In India in 1992, women accounted for 2.3 per cent of employed in the carder and
the rest were occupied by men.
The Gender-related Development Index (GDI) and the Gender Empowerment Measure
(GEM) were introduced in 1995 in the Human Development Report of the UNDP to add
these measurements of gender-sensitive dimensions to the Human Development Index
(HDI).
It is observed from the above diagram of the Global Gender Gap Index 2021 of WEF, that
India ranked 140 globally out of 156 countries, and 62.5 per cent of the gender gap in the
gender parity in South Asia. India is ranked as 140 (slipped 28 places) among 156 countries,
as per the Global Gender Gap Report 2021, by World Economic Forum. In 2020, India was
at 112th position among 153 countries. Iceland remains the topper as the most gender-equal
country in the world for the twelfth time.
Source: World Economic Forum (WEF)- Global Gender Gap Index 2021.
Table:1 The Global Gender Gap Index rankings in South Asia, 2021
According to the report of the South Asia's Global/Regional-wise Gender Gap Index, 2021,
India got 6th regional rank and 140th global rank as mentioned earlier, as detailed in Table
no.1.
Source: World Economic Forum (WEF)- Global Gender Gap Index 2021.
Interestingly, India dropped a place in the overall Human Development Index (HDI) ranking
though improved in its absolute value of HDI to 0.645 in 2019 from 0.642 in 2018, a change
of -2 from 2018. We have miles to go to reach the considerable global HDI, followed by
Bangladesh and Nepal. India dropped a place in the overall Human Development Global
Gender Gap Report which is annually published by the World Economic Forum (WEF). It
benchmarks countries on their progress towards gender parity in four dimensions: Economic
participation and opportunity, educational attainment, health and survival, and political
empowerment (WEF, 2021).
Source: World Economic Forum (WEF)- Global Gender Gap Index 2021.
Table no.3 presents the score comparison of India’s profile in world gender gap in 2006 and
2021. It can be observed from the table that the global gender gap index score rose from
0.601 in 2006 to 0.625 in 2021 and the rank rose from 98 in 2006 to 140 in 2021. It indicates
that the global rank slipped 42 ranks from 2006 to 2021. Likewise, all other factors like
economic participation and opportunity, educational attainment, health and survival, and
political empowerment also declined from 2006 to 2021.
Gender equality apart from being a fundamental right is a necessity for a peaceful and
sustainable world. When compared to the past decades we see positive changes with regard
to gender equality. The enrolment of girls in the schools increased, fewer girls are forced
into early marriages and more women take up leadership roles. Covid-19 is said to have
reversed the limited progress that has been made on gender equality and women's rights.
Disproportionate role is assigned to women in responding to the virus, including as frontline
healthcare workers and caretakers at home. The unpaid job of women at home increased
many folds during lock down times, especially due to the school closures and the increased
need of care for elderly people.
The government of India has given importance to the development of women since the
Planning era. But only in the Sixth Five Year Plan the focus of the government changed
from women welfare to the development of women. The Eighth Plan set vigil to ensure
that benefits of development from different sectors do not negatively affect women. The
Rashtriya Mahila Kosh was set up in 1993 to meet the credit needs of poor women. The
Ninth Plan was remarkable as it envisaged "empowerment of women" and “Convergence of
existing services" available in both women-specific and women-related sectors. The Tenth
Plan (2002-07) planned at "empowering women as the agent of socio-economic change and
development". In tune with the recommendation of the National Policy for Empowerment of
Women, the Tenth Plan put forward a three-fold strategy for empowering women, through
social empowerment, economic empowerment, and gender justice.
The socio-cultural pattern of the Indian society is largely based on the Hindu Caste system
in which class, caste, ethnicity, and gender largely determine the socio-economic status of
various populations. Moreover, Indian society is a patriarchal society with masculinity as
one of the characteristics in most of the families of the society which influence all aspects of
the social, cultural, and economic life of the people (Oliver D'Souza, 2011).
Women's Economic Empowerment (WEE) has important linkages with gender equality.
For attaining gender equality, India has formulated several schemes and legislations that
aim to empower women and enhance their participation in the economy. Unfortunately,
these initiatives have had only limited success. According to the WEF 2021 report, India
has slipped on the political empowerment index as well by 13.5 percentage points, and a
decline in the number of women ministers, from 23.1 per cent in 2019 to 9.1 per cent in
2021.But it still scored relatively well compared to other countries, ranking at 51 in women's
participation in politics. In the index of education attainment, India has been ranked at 114.
The WEF's Global Gender Gap Report 2021, indicates the following in the Indian context
(WEF, 2021).
1. India ranked 140 among 150 countries in the overall global rankings. It is noticed that
India has fallen 28 places in the overall ranking globally.
2. In South Asia, India lagging behind the neighboring countries like Bangladesh, Nepal,
Bhutan, Sri Lanka, and Myanmar.
3. India’s position in the political empowerment index decreased by 13.5 percentage
points.
4. India has ranked 114th in the index of education attainment.
5. India has fared badly in Health and Survival, which includes sex ratio and economic
participation in national and regional economic activity.
6. In India, the estimated earned income of women is only one-fifth of men's, which puts
the country among the bottom 10 globally on this indicator.
In India the proportion of women in senior and managerial positions remains very low; only
14.6 percent of these positions are held by women and there are only 8.9 percent of firms
with female top-level managers. Further, the estimated earned income of women in India is
only one-fifth of that of men, which puts the country among the bottom ten globally on this
indicator, it said. Discrimination against women is also reflected in the health and survival
sub-index statistics. With 93.7 percent of this gap closed to date, India ranks among the
bottom five countries in this sub-index. Wide gaps in sex ratio at birth are due to the high
incidence of gender-based sex-selective practices. In addition, more than one in four women
has faced intimate violence in her lifetime, as explained in the report. "Conversely, 96.2%
of the educational attainment sub-index gender gap has been closed, with parity achieved in
primary, secondary and tertiary education. Yet, gender gaps persist in terms of literacy: one-
third of women are illiterate (34.2%) compared to 17.6% of men," the report added (Global
Gender Gap Index 2021).
The extent of gender inequality is evident from the high incidence of violence against
women, including violence at homes. Studies reveal that over one-third of adult women in
India have experienced sexual or physical violence. Domestic violence is one of the most
common forms of cruelty faced by women. These high levels of tolerance for domestic
violence reveals the need for increased efforts to raise awareness of women's rights and the
law among both women and men and community leaders (ADB, 2013).
The Government of India has defined women entrepreneurship as an enterprise owned and
operated by women with a minimum of 51 per cent financial interest and women employees.
Women entrepreneurs can perform the same tasks and responsibilities as their male
counterparts. They need to explore the prospects of starting a new enterprise; undertake risks,
introduce innovations, coordinate administration, control business, and provide effective
leadership in all aspects of the business (Frankel, FR, 1997). Women should be encouraged
to free themselves from the shackles of conservative traditional customs, which confine
them mostly to household activities. Because of their capacity for hard work, commitment,
and sense of responsibility they should be properly motivated and their talents and abilities
have to be nurtured. In the small-scale industrial sector, there is considerable scope for their
gainful employment and they can improve their standard of living, their own as well as that
of people in general. But as the situation now prevails, there is no perceptible improvement
in women entrepreneurship. It is most unfortunate because, in India’s population, women are
on par with men. But their participation in economic activity and share of income in the total
resources of the country are pitiably very low.
In India, the ownership and management of business and industry has long been considered
a male prerogative. It is important to note that as per the Planning Commission estimates,
the total requirement of employment during 1990-95 would be about 65 million and during
the decade 1995-2005, it would be 105 million, of which the major employment seekers
would be from rural areas. Therefore, it is necessary to develop small-scale industrial
units in areas where there is chronic unemployment, dearth of capital, lack of appropriate
technical know-how, and certain inherent structural imbalances in the economy. Because
this sector has a high potential for the generation of employment, the scope for dispersal
of industrial units, narrowing down regional imbalances, utilization of hitherto untapped
locally available resources, and for the promotion of entrepreneurship among women.
Towards this end, the Government of India has taken several measures in the area of
finance and managerial assistance for the promotion of women's enterprises. Despite these
measures, the small-scale units are still plagued by a series of problems. The crux of the
problem is that women entrepreneurs are found lacking in initiative, motivation, innovation,
and the spirit of encountering risks which are closely associated with all business operations
The emergence of women entrepreneurs in India has increased over the years and it has
significantly grown after the economic reforms in the 1990s. According to the Bain &
Company report on women entrepreneurship, India has 13.5-15.7 million women-owned
enterprises, representing 20 per cent of all the enterprises. Most of them are managed and
operated by a single person but provide direct employment for an estimated 22-27 million
people. Even though the numbers show a sudden spurt in women entrepreneurship, a sizeable
number of these enterprises are run by male counterparts and the ownership of women remain
only in papers. The virtue of women entrepreneurship has not been accepted in the traditional
Indian social setup and ignored its potential as a game-changer in women empowerment in
the country. However, the urban population has acknowledged the capability of women and
entrusted them with greater responsibilities in the corporate world.
The Government of India has undertaken several programs wherein entrepreneurs are trained
on all, technical, managerial and other related skills so that they may enter the industrial field
confidently with risk-bearing capacity and manage their units on scientific lines. In this
context, it is important to recognize that in entrepreneurship development equal importance
has to be given to potential and prospective women entrepreneurs. Given the important
role women can play in the industrial scene, the Government of India is encouraging them
and trying to bring them into the fold of industrial activity. But it seems that women have
not responded as favourably as expected. Probably the customs and tradition are generally
against their assuming new roles, which are mistakenly regarded as roles of men.
Unemployment in rural areas has been on the increase and migration from rural to urban
in search of livelihood has become a greater and vexing problem. An estimate by the
Planning Commission placed employment backlog at about 28 million by the beginning of
Eight Plans. And their number is sure to have increased perceptibly since then. Among the
countless employment seekers, a major portion is from rural areas. Therefore, it is necessary
to develop small-scale industrial units in areas where there is chronic unemployment, dearth
of capital, lack of appropriate technical know-how, and certain inherent structural imbalances
and bottlenecks in the economy. As the small sector has a high potential for employment
generation, there is plenty of scope for the dispersal of industrial units over a wide area
so that regional imbalances are narrowed down, untapped local resources are utilized and
also entrepreneurship among women could be promoted in the process. Towards this, the
government of India has tried to provide financial and managerial assistance.
In India, a very substantial portion of women are unemployed though they can undertake
varied activities including industrial activity. Therefore, it is essential to expose them to the
various employment profit generating avenues and promote and develop entrepreneurship
among them. And it is a fact that in some parts of our country, some women have established
beyond any doubt, their competence as successful entrepreneurs. But unfortunately, this
development has taken place in cities only. And the rural women are still caught in the
targeted levels of poverty, restricting social traditions, customs, and prejudices. Hence, it is
quite necessary to emancipate them and bring them into the fold of entrepreneurship.
MSME Sector: The micro and small-scale Sector is a major area in which enthusiastic,
talented women can start several small units. The field is vast and as many prospective
women, entrepreneurs, as can venture, would find openings in it. It provides avenues in
various areas where raw material and labour and other infrastructural facilities are abundantly
available. It is easy to start units in this sector as it depends totally on locally available
resources. All entrepreneurs who are prepared to invest up to Rs.75 lakhs in fixed assets
can start a tiny unit in rural and backward areas. There is fair evidence of women all by
NJMSR Volume IV Issue I
139
https://www.nepjol.info/index.php/njmsr/index ISSN (Print) : 2467-9356, ISSN (Electronic) : 2795-1545
Empowerment of Women through Entrepreneurship Development in Emerging Economies: A Case of India
Rural Sector: Rural industries are vital for the development of rural areas, though they
are generally associated with agriculture, forest produce and handloom. Rural industries
are characterized by the high potential for employment and income generation. These
industries are using locally available raw materials and operate with low investments in
plants and machinery. Women can successfully venture into various rural industries such
as bee-keeping, making of hand-made papers, bags, carpentry, bio-gas, making of palm
gur, candles, perfumes, matchbox, soaps and non-edible oils, leather goods, processing of
pulses and cereals, fruit-processing and the preservation etc. Increased women participation
in such ventures in rural areas leads to their self-sufficiency and greater economic freedom.
Microenterprises in rural areas have a commendable role in empowering women in rural
areas. They provide gainful employment to women and helps to develop personal and social
capabilities in them. Women entrepreneurship in microenterprises gives them much needed
financial independence, self-confidence and a better standard of living. Economic betterment
of women leads to equal socio-economic opportunities, gender justice, property rights,
political representations and ultimately results in the overall development of the nation.
c. Socio-cultural barriers:
Women have to perform multiple roles in the family and it is very difficult for them to
create a work-life balance unless they have been given flexible working hours and space.
The system of social setup is patriarchal in nature in which men hold predominant roles in
financial decision making, political representations and control of the property. In case of
financial stress in the family, the girl child has to leave education for her brother. Successful
women entrepreneurship requires overcoming all these socio-cultural barriers. As a result,
this impedes the progress of women and handicaps them in the world of work. So, while
putting a step ahead into the entrepreneurial world or any other profession, women need
to think several times because of lack of confidence, economic dependence, and social
bindings.
5. Conclusion
Women empowerment through entrepreneurship has assumed greater importance in
the economic progress of an emerging economy like India. The development of a
sound entrepreneurship culture is an indicator of the empowerment of people, industrial
development, and the overall development of a country. The development of an economy
mainly depends on entrepreneurial ability, competence, and perseverance of the people
in general and women in particular. India has to sort out, nourish and develop competent
entrepreneurship, which is very vital for its rapid industrialization and empowerment of
the people. Despite the government level efforts for providing a congenial atmosphere for
women entrepreneurship and thereby women empowerment in the country, the progress is
still far behind expectations. The ongoing Covid pandemic crisis and industrial sickness
discourage women to take up entrepreneurship risks. Women entrepreneurs should be given
adequate motivation, guidance, training and financial support for taking up challenging
entrepreneurial tasks. The fostering of women entrepreneurship leads to their empowerment
and contribute to the uninterrupted economic development in challenging times.
References
Anand, S., & Sen, A (1995). Gender Inequality in Human Development: Theories and Measurement.
Readings in human development, OUP, New Delhi.
Asian Development Bank (2013). India, gender equality diagnostic of selected sectors, Philippines.
Bain & Company (2019). Women entrepreneurship in India. Bain & Co. and Google, New Delhi.
Carter, S. L., & Shaw, E. (2006). Women’s business ownership: Recent research and policy development.
Retrieved July 2, 2021, from https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/8962/1/sbs_2006_report_ for_bis.
pdf.
D’Souza, O. (2012). Truth about Dalits, caste system, and untouchability. London Institute of South
Asia, UK.
Francine, F. (1978). India’s Political Economy (1947-1977). The gradual revolution, Princeton
university press 1978 MSU CN.
International Labour Organisation (2018). Women and men in the informal economy-A statistical
picture, 3rd eds., ILO office, Geneva.
Mayoux, L., (2000). Micro-finance and the empowerment of women: A Review of the key issues,
International Labour Organization, Geneva.
Malach-Pines, A., Lerner, M., & Schwartz, D. (2010). Gender differences in entrepreneurship:
Equality, diversity and inclusion in times of global crisis. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An
International Journal, 29(2), 186–198. https://doi.org/10.1108/02610151011024493
Meuser, M., & Nagel, U. (2009). The expert interview and changes in knowledge production.
In Interviewing experts (pp. 17-42). Palgrave Macmillan, London.
OECD (2020). Women’s economic empowerment, Paris, France.
Orhan, M., & Scott, D. (2001). Why women enter into entrepreneurship: An explanatory model.
Women in Management Review, 16(5), 232–244. https://doi.org/10.1108/ 09649420110395719
Sarri, K., & Trihopoulou, A. (2005). Female entrepreneurs’ personal characteristics and motivation:
A review of the Greek situation. Women in Management Review, 20(1), 24–37. https:// doi.
org/10.1108/09649420510579559
Schreier, M. (2012). Qualitative content analysis in practice. Sage publications.
Singh, J. S. (1998). Creating a new consensus on population: the International Conference on
Population and Development. Earthscan.
The Wire (2021). India slips 28 places in WEF's gender gap index, ranked 140th among 156 nations.
Available at https://thewire.in/gender/india-slips-28-places-wef-gender-gap-index-ranked-140th-
among-156-nations.
United Nations Development Programme (1995). Human Development Report. Available at http://hdr.
undp.org/en/content/human-development-report-1995
United nations Development Programme (2000). Human Development in South Asia Report.
United Nations Development Programme (2020), Human Development Report. Available at http://hdr.
undp.org/sites/default/files/hdr2020.pdf
United Nations Organization (2012). Employment: What does it mean to you? UN Social Development
Network.
Abstract
The study explores the adversities faced by wompreneurs (Women Entrepreneurs) of Odisha
and talks about their work-life balance issues. The paper presents the viewpoint (motivation)
of wompreneurs as to why they think of starting an enterprise of their own. Focus is also laid
onthe supportive factors of wompreneurs and factors that disrupt maintaining their work-life
balance.The present exploratory paper is the outcome of a pilot study that has been performed
using thematic investigation & analysis to find out solutions for the above-mentioned issues.
For this paper, Qualitative research is used, which is conducted by assimilating data from
personal interviews and thematically analyzing it. Suggestions for better work-life balance
are given at the end. The area of work-life balance is devoid of studies in India, where
wompreneurs are expected to have a better work-life balance as they are their own "boss",
the paper tries to explore the authenticity of such assumptions. The model has been devised
with the above research objectives to provide insight into motivating factors and work-life
balance issues of wompreneurs, which can help the Government, policy-makers, research
fraternity and other training counselling institutions to emphasize such emerging issues that
would lead to empowered women as well as an empowered Nation.
1. Introduction
1.1 Background
Entrepreneurship is the initiation of a new venture with a futuristic approach by assembling
and utilizing capital, raw material, and manpower for developmental activities. The
term Entrepreneurship first came into usage byRichard Cantillon (1680-1734) as cited
in Landstorm(1999).During the early twentieth century, the only reason women joined
entrepreneurship was because of economic needs, to supplement family needs or the personal
loss(divorce or death) of a spouse. Later in the 1990's the thinking started to transform, the
rise in feminism bought about various changes in the living and standard of women, the
1 Prof.Dr. Sanjay Satapathy is the Vice Chancellor of Kalahandi University, Bhawanipatna, Odisha, India.
2 Dr.Anita Pareek, Cuttack,Odisha.
world started to recognize and accept women as entrepreneurs. And women started to opt
for entrepreneurship as a preferable choice for greater flexibility and autonomy in managing
life. Women preferred entrepreneurship so that they can manage their work-life balance
better, i.e. the juggling of responsibility among work and family domains would be easier
with the flexibilities that entrepreneurship offers. The corporate world is not found very
appealing for women entrepreneurs nowadays owing to issues like gender biases, unequal
pay, and working hours, for which many women move towards the field of entrepreneurship
(Appelbaum Asham,&Argheyd, 2011).
Women entrepreneurs can be defined as a person with clarity in vision and entrepreneurial
skills like identification of market opportunities, risk-taking nature, and achievement as the
key motivation as given by Vinze(1987).Wompreneurship is the entrepreneurial venturing
by enterprising women in mostly sustainable business tracks with 7C's (Creativity, Care,
Consonance, Competence, Concatenation, Commitment, and Cooperation) (Satapathy,2018).
Though women's entrepreneurship has deep roots of origin the boost-up was only possible
after the rise in education, globalization, and availability of several schemes and programs
by the government for women, which has led to the ultimate Women Empowerment in India
as well Odisha.
Women entrepreneurs have proved to be building blocks of the economy, as India constitutes
a nearly equal population of both men and women, in such a scenario, women's contribution
as entrepreneurs are seemingly essential for building up a strong economy and leading to
global prosperity. Thus the participation of women in the economy is essential for themselves,
for creating employment for others as well as for boosting up the entire economy.
The government of Odisha provide them training for the above activities and also sanctioning
loans at a minimum rate of interest, which has helped them to make products and sell them
to local markets as well as other districts to earn their living, become independent, and lead
a better life.
These wompreneurs have left no segregation wall of so-called men's work and women's
work, as they are visibly present in almost all sectors. The reason for such proactiveness
is Government support, friendly policies of work, financial helping hand, and a conducive
ecosystem have all let the rise in entrepreneurship of women in Odisha. The Micro Small
and Medium Enterprise(MSME) Department and Women and Child-Care Development
Department of Odisha are equally alert about the needs of budding entrepreneurs and helping
them to contribute towards the growing economy of Odisha.
2. Review of Literature
Women and entrepreneurship have a connection from early decades. The involvement
of women in business ventures has grown significantly and this work has resulted in the
evolvement of work-life balance-related issues. Thus, to gain a proper work-life balance
needs to apply a flexible timetable between work and personal roles(Frame,&Hartog, 2003).
Such imbalances seem to generate greater stress among the women counterpart. Studies
reveal that women face a burden that is not in equal proportion when it comes to household
responsibilities (Bird, 2006). The stress which is caused due to poor work-lifebalance practices
deteriorates the mental &physical health of women and creates and negative behavioral
changes among women. Also, the imbalance in the distribution of home responsibilities which
include child care and other household responsibilities becomes a big challenging barrier to the
advancement in the career of women (Cross, &Linehan, 2006).
In countries like India where the role of women is believed to be closely tied with family
as homemakers and males as a bread earner of the family, such tags make the career of
mothers less negotiable than that of fathers(Gronlund, 2007).There are various reasons
why women entered this field. Studies by researchers define them as Push and Pull factors
(Sarri, &Trihopoulou, 2005). Push and Pull factors are based on choice and necessity
respectively, Brush(1992). One such emerging need is work-life balance, which was earlier
seen to be a western concept, but due to globalization, it has a presence steadily spreading in
eastern cultures and affecting the organizational setup of the entire world (Lewis, Gambles,
&Rapoport, 2007).
Many research studies have supported the thought that the field of entrepreneurship has
been chosen due to the flexibility it offers women to maintain the equilibrium between home
and family. Brush, Carter, Gatewood, Greene, and Hart(2006) stated that it is women, who
resort to entrepreneurship as a solution more, compared to men. Also due to the biases in the
corporate world, women followed the way towards self-creation of job, where they enjoy the
freedom and can satisfy the need for achievement, flexibility, and economic independence.
But the challenges that come up in the way of wompreneurs are significantly unavoidable.
Though they do get some sort of support from friends, family, relatives, or the Government
which in a way helps them to sustain themselves in this profession. Earlier studies have
focused that the phenomena of work-life balance have been mostly concentrating managerial
levels(Lewis, &Cooper,2005) and there exist scarce study on the work-life balance of
wompreneursspecifically (Shelton, 2006), thus the issues like entrepreneurial motivation,
support network, and work-life balance should be investigated to bring out better insights
with the changing time and scenario.
The following section gives a view about theMotivation factors, Supporting factors, and
work-life balance issues of wompreneurs, based on the extant literature:
Economic needs
Entrepreneurship has a direct connection with earning and profit-making, while some earn to
fulfill their needs and others earn to live a lavish life. In the case of wompreneurs, economic
needs have been a significant factor to become an entrepreneur. Issue of Economic needs
arises due to reasons like spouse demise, divorce, serious illness of the bread earner of the
family and even sometimes cases where spouse don't share the earnings with wife which is
to be utilized for household purpose and spend it elsewhere due to which, domestic violence,
improper child care and degradation in living standards occur. These issues mostly connect
to the Indian context where women hesitate to go out and work due to various traditional and
social norms of society. But today women have to an extent overcome societal barriers and
are looking for a better financial status.
With time, the roles and duties of both men and women have experienced transformations.
In the early days, men were the sole bread earners of the family, and women were household
caregivers. But during the Industrial Revolution, the family started behaving as a cohesive
unit and, all members of the family worked inconsiderate of their age to contribute to the
enhance the economic situation of the family. Thus women entered as a contributor. (Tilly
and Scott, 1978). The involvement of both spouses at work disrupts this balance and creates
imbalance (Boyum-Breen, 2006). Okafor and Amalu (2010) stated in their study about,
many women starting a venture to support the economic needs of the family.
Premise2: Economic needs of the family have a positive influence on the development of
women entrepreneurship
Competencies
The term competency was coined by Boyatzis (1982). He conducted a study that explored
100 competencies from a sample of 200 managers. Based on the finding, he defined
competency as a certain behavior that matches with the demands of the job and parameters
of an organization, which ultimately results in the desired behavior. The terms like talent,
abilities, and competency are interchangeably used in the literature of research(Mitchelmore,
& Rowley, 2013). Competency in terms of entrepreneurship relates to developmental and
growth steps taken towards new ventures (Bird, 1995). Women are said to be comparatively
weak than men in terms of financial skills and good at interpersonal relations(Collerette,
& Aubry, 1990), such an existing skillset give way to new opportunities in the field of
entrepreneurship. These skill-sets become the catalyst for wompreneurs which are non-
substitutable and rare in nature (Wernerfelt, 1984). Competency helps to c manage work
better and enhance performance. A person having a good skill set can manage situations
better at home and work. The skillset helps wompreneurs to grow and excel at par with
society. Competencies are mostly inborn but can be developed and enhanced with time to
meet the growing needs, as the struggles of a competent individual become in a way easy
than a less competent person.
Emotional instability
The psychological stressors that create stress and anxiety are majorly from work, known
as 'work stress infusers' compared to 'family stress infusers'. The women who cannot
balance both domains often get burnout anxiety and get derive no satisfaction from any
domain(Makowska,1998). The road to handling both work and family together often
create a crossroad situation for women and adversity affects the health and wellbeing of
women(Carlson, Kacmar & Williams 2000.
3. Research Methodology
The data is collected from the city of Bhubaneswar(capital city of Odisha), from October
2019 to November 2019 using convenience sampling and data is collected via personal
interview(qualitative research). An interview method provides deep insight into the response
given by the respondents and the reasons after it. It also helps to analyze the data on a
behavioral basis even though it is non-statistical, this method can draw critical reasoning
and understanding of respondent's behavior which is sometimes not possible using a written
questionnaire.
Threeentrepreneurs of the city were chosen for this study and the mode of interaction was
a face-to-face interview, where the name has been kept unidentified for privacy reasons
provided by them. The entrepreneurs are selected from three different sectors, to gain more
clarity sector-wise. The sole aim of these interviews is to prove the objectives of this study
by enquiring about the motivating factors of their entrepreneurship, the supporting factors of
their entrepreneurship, and their key work-life balance issues. To achieve the objectivity of
this study the elaborated interviews are put as case studies where a case study is relevant for
a study of this kind having a limited geographic area and limited respondents (Zainal, 2007).
Source: Authors
The Methodology adopted for this study is given in Figure 2 by using a diagrammatical
approach.
Figure2 :
Diagrammatic
representation of the
Methodology
Source: Authors
4. Case Description
4.1 Case:1
Mrs. A, a housewife from Bhubaneswar, havingthree children, wanted to start something on
her own, due to the financial requirements and ill health of her husband. She initially thought
of a stitching/tailoring shop but due to lack of capital, she decided to start a business with
whatever minimal resources she had and which required no extra training. She converted
her passion for cooking into a business. The famous sweet delicacy of Odisha, with a few
kilograms of raw material she started her business, in which she initially faced a lot of
troubles for the first six years. In the meantime, when her business started to grow, she
was at time betrayed by her staff who learned the recipe from her and started a business of
their own. With a lot of patience and hard work she, did not stop and continued to sell the
sweets. Having so many hardships and managing a family was no easy for her. Having the
role of a mother, wife, and entrepreneur who was budding gave her many challenges. And
the biggest struggle was marketing her goods, gradually she gave samples to the big hotels
of Bhubaneswar, and her efforts succeeded. She faced a lot of emotional challenges while
bearing so many hard situations altogether. Every component of her life sought attention
from her. Today, she has her own food company which sells sweet delicacy and other snacks,
all big restaurants are her customer and she takes party/ marriage orders. Recently she was
felicitated by Government. All of this was the outcome of her spouse and family support.
Her husband was the motivation and emotional backbone, where her children helped her in
all stages from making to marketing. The cooking skills she learned from her mother-in-law
helped her to gain recognition as an entrepreneur, where her passion today is taking her to
new heights of success with every passing day.
4.2 Case:2
Mrs. B is a school owner at Bhubaneswar. She started her dream school with a capital of
30000/-, 17 students and five teachers and now the school has 150 teachers and 2000 students,
the first day-care school in the city. Not only she is an entrepreneur but a teacher, who believes
in quality education and parity among students, by not considering their academic results,
she says such biasedness demoralizes students and they cannot improvise their performance.
She completed her studies and married with a precondition that she would open a school
one day. She worked as a primary school teacher and was blessed with a son. At times it
became difficult to manage the profession so she quit the job for some time, but later she
again joined a college as a lecturer for the love she has for teaching (her passion). She
opened the first school in a cottage building with less than 20 students and a low fee, so easy
affordability. To continue and grow the school, she has to leave her job, as it was creating
stress to managing multiple responsibilities at a time. Her husband and in-laws supported
her in running the school, which gradually developed with time through Government help
and their investment, which they earned by running their small school. In the year 2002-
2004 the school received CBSE affiliation, after which she took a loan and developed the
infrastructure. She opened the first branch at Puri in 2015, after Bhubaneswar and today
the school is among the best schools in Bhubaneswar. She is also a national awardee and
believes that passion is the strongest will and courage for a women entrepreneur, which
helps her to achieve and balance all equations of life.
4.3 Case:3
Mrs. C is the owner of a beauty chain salon in Bhubaneswar. Not only she became a successful
entrepreneur but bought about a revolution in Odisha salon industry by educating women
about make-up skills. Born and bought up in a highly educated family, she gained education
outside Odisha and finally worked across European countries with her husband. There she
was exposed to various fashion and trends and decided to make her passion into a business.
In search of flexibility and pursuing her passion, she thought of leaving the corporate world
and starting her salon chain in India, for which she took professional beauty and makeup
courses. To follow her dreams, she left the high-paid jobs and shifted to India and opened
her salon in Bhubaneswar, with her spouse's support both, mentally and at work. The high-
paid jobs could not satisfy her passion and she wanted a bigger name and recognition in this
industry. The risk of leaving a settled job abroad and coming back home town for a new
venture created an immense emotional pressure, which bought in many challenges. But the
support network, zeal for a better earning, and the faith in her dreams gave her reasons to
start this venture. Having a daughter, she has multiple roles of mother, wife, and boss a huge
number of salon staff but, she tries to create that balance and get energy from the smiling and
happy faces of her satisfied clients. She believes that, though imbalance and challenges will
prevail each day, every problem has a solution, thus having love for your work and a support
structure can make women win any battle of life. She has also been recognized and awarded
by various bodies for being a strong leader.
4.3.1 Observation
It is observed that three of the cases had an underlying passion within them, which became
their ultimate motivation to start a new venture. Two of the cases show that along with
passion, they were also looking for the financial growth of their family. In three of the
cases, the major support system was their spouse and family. Along with this, their skill set
or the competencies they possessed helped them to stand high in tuff situations. The work-
life balance issues were mostly regarding role conflict (i.e. at a single time, they had to
portray various roles) and this role demand, along with other factors like risk-taking created
immense emotional pressure on them, which in the midway to success gave them many
challenging situations, but due to the supportive factors, they could reach various levels of
success. though three of them believe that both work and family are unavoidable spheres and
challenges are constant, so every day is a new day with fresh adversities and opportunities
with wompreneurs should embrace with agreeableness to become independent as well as
create the identity of their own.
WORK LIFE
SUPPORT BALANCE
MOTIVATION
FACTORS +ve FACTORS +ve ISSUES
-ve
-ve
+ve - Positive impact
-ve - Negative impact
Source: Authors
The figure. 3 is the proposed model, The Wompreneurial Balance Framework, which
establishes the relationship among the motivation factors, support factors and work-
life balance factors and the impact they owe on each other. The model is based upon the
pieces of literature that authors have come across and cited in the Review Of Literature
and also insights are drawn from the case studies of this study. The support factors have a
positive impact on both motivation and work life balance factors, as support factors provide
a backbone to both these areas and possess a positive impact. The motivation factors if
are strong enough can spill a positive impact on work-life balance factors and decrease
the imbalance. Whereas the work-life balance issues hurt both motivation and well as
support factors, as these issues, disturb the existing equilibrium and leads to many health
and emotional troubles. The discussed cases in this study show that wompreneurs who had
strong motivation factors could be able to sustain their work-life balance, because of the
passion and needs they had, they tried to resolve and balance their issues, hence it has a
positive impact. The support factors in the discussed cases also prove to help get motivation
and manage work-life balance, which shows a positive impact. The work-life balance issues
harm the motivation and support factors, as these issues tend to create anxiety, health,
work, and family conflicts due to which many womprenurs quit their venture and become
victimized due to paucity of stability and balance.
An entrepreneurial journey is never easy. Especially, as a woman, one may feel forced to
handle everything with balancing the household and work sphere. But, the truth is, no person
can do it all. To lead a healthy life, one must learn to balance self with work efficiently. So,
blaming and treating oneself for everything would de-motivate the growth of women as
bread earners. Rather the family, society, as well as government, should look for ways in
which women can keep both their spheres at par and prove to be excellent entrepreneurs, and
thus be a part of the growth of the nation. Awareness and togetherness of women can bring
forth catalytic change in micro and macro levels.
1.10 Suggestion by wompreneurs via the personal interviews in the study, insights
for managing better work-life balance and balanced life at large:
• Identifying works that are truly important
• Allocating stipulated time to filter distractions: set boundaries
• Avoiding jumping between multiple lines and streamlining tasks.
• Creating a strong support network: take external help
• Follow health routine
• Having practical expectations: having a perfect/stress-free life is a dream
• Devote time for yourself
• Don't compare with others
References
Appelbaum, S.H., Asham, N., &Argheyd, K. (2011).Is the glass ceiling cracked in information
technology? A qualitative analysis: Part 1.Industrial and Commercial Training, 43 (6), 354-61.
Bird, B. (1995).Towards a theory of entrepreneurial competency.Advances in Entrepreneurship, Firm
Emergence and Growth, Vol. 2 (1), 51-72.
Bird, S.R. (2006). Theorizing masculinities: recent trends in the social sciences. Gender Studies
Journal of Eastern Europe,14(1), 1-21.
Boyatzis, R.E. (1982), The Competent Manager: A Model for Effective Performance.New York:John
Wiley& Sons.
Boyum-Breen, T.L. (2006).A phenomenological inquiry of the work and home life experiences
of mothers who are college presidents, doctoral dissertation, Major: educational policy and
administration, University of Minnesota.
Brush, C.G. (1992). Research on women business owners: past trends, a new perspective, and future
directions. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, Vol. 16 (4), 5-30.
Brush, C., Carter, N., Gatewood, E., Greene, P., & Hart, M. (2006). Women's entrepreneurship in the
United States. In Brush, C., Carter, N., Gatewood, E., Greene, P. and Hart, M. (Eds), Growth-
Oriented Women Entrepreneurs and Their Businesses, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Carlson, D.S., Kacmar, K.M., & Williams L.J. (2000).Construction and Initial Validation of a
Multidimensional Measure of Work-Family Conflict. Journal of Vocational Behavior, Vol. 56,
249—276.
Casper, L.M., &Bianchi, S.M. (2001), Continuity and Change in the American Family.California,
CA:Sage Publications.
Collerette, P., &Aubry, P. (1990).Socio-economic evolution of women business owners in Quebec
(1987). Journal of Business Ethics, 9 ( 4/5), 417-422.
Cross, C. and Linehan, M. (2006). Barriers to advancing female careers in the high-tech sector:
empirical evidence from Ireland. Women in Management Review, 21(1), 28-39.
Dehle, C., Larsen, D., & Landers, J., (2001). Social support in marriage. The AmericanJournal of
Family Therapy, 29 (4), 307-324.
Eagle, B.W., Icenogle, M.L., Maes, J.D., & Miles, E.W. (1998). The importance of employee
demographic profiles for understanding experiences of work-family inter-role conflicts. The
Journal of Social Psychology, 138(6), 690–709. http:// dx.doi.org/10.1080/00224549809603255
Eagly, A.H., &Wood, W. (2011).Social role theory.In Van Lange, P.A., Kruglanski, A.W. and Higgins,
E.T. (Eds), Handbook of Theories of Social Psychologypp. 458-78).London: Sage Publication.
Frame, P., &Hartog, M. (2003). From rhetoric to reality. Into the swamp of ethical practice:
implementing work‐life balance.Business Ethics: a European Review,12 (4), 358-68.
Greenhaus, J. H., &Beutell, N. J. (1985). Sources and conflict between work and family roles. The
Academy of Management Review, 10(1), 76–88.
Gronlund, A. (2007). More control, less conflict? Job demand-control, gender and work-family
conflict. Gender, Work & Organization, 14 (5) , 476-97.
Gurvinder Singh (2018),A teacher's job is to guide children and not to demoralize or ignore them' , The
Weekend Leader, 9 (7).
Ivancevich, J., Konopaske, M. and Matteson, E. (1997) Management: Quality and Competitiveness.
Boston:McGraw-Hill.
Kim, J., & Ling, C.,(2001). Work-family conflict of women entrepreneurs in Singapore.Women in
Management Review, 16(5), 204–221.
Kirkwood, J. (2009) .Motivational factors in a push-pull theory of entrepreneurship. Gender in
Management: An International Journal, 24(5), 346–364.
Lewis, S., &Cooper, C.L. (2005). Work – Life Integration: Case Studies of Organisational Change,
John Wiley & Sons, Chichester.
Lewis, S., Gambles, R., &Rapoport, R. (2007). The constraints of a ‘work-life balanceapproach: an
international perspective. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 18 (3),
360-73.
Maskowska Z.(1995) Psychosocial characteristics of work and family as a determinant of stress and
well-being of women: A preliminary study. International Journal of Occupational Medicine and
Environment Health 8, 215-22
Mauno, S., Kinnunen, U., &Ruokolainen, M. (2006). Exploring work and organisation based resources
as moderators between work-family conflict, well-being and job attitudes. Work and Stress,
20(3),210–233.
McKay, R. (2001). Women entrepreneurs: moving beyond family and flexibility. International Journal
of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research,7 (4), 148–165.
Mitchelmore, S., & Rowley, J. (2013). Entrepreneurial competencies of women entrepreneurs pursuing
business growth. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 20 ( 1), 125-142.
Okafor, C., &Amalu, R. (2010) .Entrepreneurial motivations as determinants of women entrepreneurship
challenges. Petroleum-Gas University of Ploiesti BULLETIN, . 2(2), 67–77.
Pereira, F.C. (2001) Representacao Social do Empresario, EdicoesSilabo, Lisboa.
Rosenbaum, M.& Cohen, E., (1999). Equalitarian marriages, spousal support, resourcefulness, and
psychological distress among Israeli working women. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 54(1),
102-113.
Sarri, K., &Trihopoulou, A. (2005).Female entrepreneurs' personal characteristics and
motivation: a review of the Greek situation. Women in Management Review, 20 (1), 24-36
Satapathy, S.K.(2018) Wompreneurs(unpublished manuscript).
Tilly, L.A., & Scott, J.W. (1978), Women, Work, and Family, New York, NY
Vinze, M.D. (1987), Women Entrepreneurs in India: A Socio-Economic Study of Delhi, 1975-85.New
Delhi: Mittal Publications,
Wernerfelt, B. (1984).A resource-based view of the firm.Strategic Management Journal, 5 (2) ,171-
180.
Women entrepreneurs in Odisha show the startup way (2018, December). The New Indian Express.
Retrieved from https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/odisha/2018/dec/02/women-entrepreneurs-
show-the-startup--way-1906145.html
Zainal, Z. (2007) Case Study as a Research Method. JurnalKemanusiaan, 9, 1-6
Abstract
Consumer awareness about their appearance and beauty results in the growing demand
on the market for cosmetic and beauty products. Cosmetic used by consumers depends on
various attributes such as size, consistency, brand name, brand loyalty and labeling. This
study therefore tries to analyze awareness level of female consumers on purchasing online
beauty products in Kathmandu valley. Descriptive method is employed in this study where
285 female customers who buy cosmetics online are taken as sample for the study. Likewise,
awareness level is also measured with the help of awareness index. Findings of the study
revealed that 95% females are aware about online purchase of cosmetic products. Likewise,
both literate and illiterate women use online platforms to buy cosmetic products however,
the ratio of literate women is higher. Also, the trend to buy cosmetics product is higher in
unmarried compared to married females. Thus, the study concludes effectiveness of online
beauty products can be enhanced if online sites focuses on delivering quality products in
reliable price to customers.
1. Introduction
The beauty products are witnessing tremendous growth on the market today and have
become one of the world's leading industries (Priyanto, 2019). It is estimated that 15-20
percent of the cosmetics market is rising annually in our country, Nepal. The demand for
skin whitening dominates the phenomenon relative to other beauty products (Kumar, 2005).
Consumer awareness about their appearance and beauty results in the growing demand on
the market for cosmetic and beauty products. Customers buy products based on their tastes,
desires and purchasing power (Cheung, Lee, & Rabjohn, 2008). Chaudhary (2018) entails
young people and adults in Nepal are more worried with their appearance and prefer to buy
cosmetic products for that. Cosmetic used by consumers depends on various attributes such
as size, consistency, brand name, brand loyalty and labeling (Chaudhary, 2018). Earlier price
1 Seeprata Parajuli is the faculty at Quest Int’l College Pokhara University, Nepal.
2 Bhawana Thapa is the faculty at Quest Int’l College Pokhara University, Nepal.
3 Niranjan Devkota is the faculty at Quest Int’l College Pokhara University, Nepal.
4 Udaya Raj Paudel is the faculty at Quest Int’l College Pokhara University, Nepal.
5 Saraswati Gautam is the faculty at Quest Int’l College Pokhara University, Nepal.
used to be the major dominating factor for customers (Hsu, Yen, Chiu, & Chang, 2006) but
now all of these variables are playing a major role in market dominance.
Marketing has a strong positive effect on customers' purchasing habits, and they have a
direct impact on consumers buying a product from a business they are well aware of (Ab
Rahman & Asrarhaghighi, 2015). Mirabi, Akbariyeh, & Tahmasebifard (2015) addresses the
six stages of information, understanding, desire, interest, persuasion and purchase suggested
by researchers before preparing or deciding to purchase the product. Online shopping in
Nepal is becoming increasingly popular by the day. Nearly all people with internet access
have been drawn to online niche products at least once and many decide to buy it as well
(Shrestha, 2019). Yet unfortunately, many are left disappointed due to many problems
with the online shopping experience. Online shopping websites in Nepal lack reviews and
ratings of clients. Such portals may provide some discount or coupon codes for each review
received to encourage further customer interaction (Chaudhary, 2018). Chaudhary (2018)
states that cosmetics that are used daily by females for beauty purpose have huge amount
of chemicals in them. There are lots of beauty products used and purchased by individuals
and beauty parlors for the customers however they don’t assure quality (Himalayan News
Service, 2019).
Nepal imported Rs. 3.65 billion of cosmetic products in FY2015/16, while Rs. 3.24 billion
of cosmetic products entered the country in FY2014/15 (NRB, 2016). However, Nepalese
women still hesitate to buy the cosmetics product online dues various reasons. In Nepalese
context, while e-commerce is booming like anything, online shopping for cosmetics products
is still to be improved a lot (Devkota et al., 2021). It can be a difficult and deliberate decision
to buy beauty products because these decisions affect an individual's overall appearance.
Thus, this study will help individual and beauty product sellers to learn about the consumer
purchase behavior and its coverage. Also, there are various factors that directly and indirectly
affect the purchase of beauty products. Many consumers today are particularly interested in
what they put on their bodies, with growing concerns about health and environment. This
study will also focus on impact of these products to the Nepalese female customers. Upon
completion of this paper online purchase pattern of cosmetics or beauty products can be
identified up to certain extent.
Further part of this study is structured as follows: second section incorporates review of
literature followed by methods used in section three. Fourth section presents results followed
by discussion in fifth section. Finally last part concludes the study.
2. Literature Review
Beauty gives blissful pleasure, which is why it is sought after (Feng, 2012). Every individual
seem to possess an inner need for beauty that is both primitive and rather intensive. We all
want to experience beauty, and to be beautiful - whole industries are built on these needs
(Kun, 2005). According to the French writer Anatole France, "beauty is the greatest power
in this world". So, obviously, it is a power to be reckoned with, and only a fool would
neglect trying to understand such might (Bechan, & Ehsanul Hoque, 2016). Food and Drugs
Administration (FDA) has defined the difference between personal care products and beauty
products. Under the law, some of the products commonly referred to as "personal care
products" are beauty products. These include, for example, skin moisturizers, perfumes,
lipsticks, fingernail polishes, eye and facial makeup preparations, shampoos, permanent
waves, hair colors, toothpastes, and deodorants. Some, however, are regulated as drugs.
Among these are skin protectants (such as lip balms and diaper ointments), mouthwashes
marketed with therapeutic claims, antiperspirants, and treatments for dandruff or acne
(Sameer, 2007).
Today, the worldwide beauty industry, which covers everything from hair and skin care to
makeup, is an estimated $425 billion industry. In countries like Nepal, where society and
communities have experienced lots of financial related issues, however with the changing
lifestyle of people lots of money has been spent in beauty products. Not just the female but
even men have been using beauty products in Nepal too (Shrestha, 2019). From casual day to
party day’s beauty products has become part of our everyday routine. Similar to the hundreds
or perhaps thousands of grocery stores around town, there are cosmetic shops set up at every
nook and corner of Kathmandu. From departmental stores to local beauty parlors, there is
no dearth of cosmetic products for potential customers (Anjana, 2017). Beauty products
are mainly imported from abroad. Nepal gets its cosmetics products of various brands from
a number of different countries. Needless to say, like other imports, a significant share of
cosmetics products available in Nepal is manufactured in India (Kumar, 2005).
The importance of cosmetics can be gauged by their best feature. The right cosmetic products
provide nutrition for skin, ensuring it stays hydrated and supple. Since your body needs
care and the right food, quality beauty products can give your body the nutrition it needs.
Cleansing and exfoliating removes impurities from the skin’s surface and also cleans out the
pores. If left to their devices, these pores can fill with oil and then cause other skin issues
(Cash, & Smith, 1982). Women who work in the corporate sector know the importance of
making the right impressions. They need the right beauty products to make sure they look
professional and are up to the mark. Employment laws suggest that candidates shouldn’t be
judged on their appearance, but with the look on point there’s always a chance that female
can get a leg up (Mirabi et al., 2015).
Today social media plays greater role as a marketing platform for any companies and have
greater role in influencing customers to purchase the products as well. As per the research
instagram, YouTube are generally popular for marketing content as well including market
for beauty products and are effective source where customers rely upon to buy their beauty
products (Denton, 2019). As mentioned by Kinski (2017) there were 14.9 billion videos
related to beauty products on You Tube and 700 million videos were being watched monthly.
However only 3% were actually uploaded or controlled by actual brands remaining 97%
were uploaded and reviewed by vloggers. Also, consumers want to see real results of the
products being advertise so that they can expect same result with themselves.
The research shows that online retail was projected to be $271.1 billion by 2011 (Forrester
Research, 2006). Online shopping is quite adopted by people of this generation however
they also opt for in-store shopping (Millenials, 2015). Sebastianelli et al. (2008) mentioned
that women were more likely to use internet to buy clothes, beauty products and toys. For
instance, websites attracts women in buying clothes and beauty products by offering various
coupons and discounts.
3. Research Methods
3.1 Research design and study area
There are numbers of customers who purchase online products on daily basis and among
them, for this study customers who buy cosmetic products online particularly from
Kathmandu Valley are considered. Kathmandu valley is situated between 27 ° 32'13" and 27
° 32'13" latitudes. The latitudes of 27° 49'10" to the north, and the ranges of 85° 11'31" and
85°31'38" to the south the east, at an altitude of 1,300 meters above sea level. It occupies
an area of 899 square kilometers and is divided into three areas: Kathmandu, Lalitpur, and
Bhaktapur, with a combined area of 665 square kilometers.
In case of online purchase of beauty products the most important factor the affects the most
is the marital status of women as women are married they are expected to spend the most.
If the women are married they are expected to spend more and more money in the cosmetic
products and they tend to use lots of beauty products. However our study revealed that
51.22% respondents who buy cosmetics online are unmarried. This means unmarried ladies
spend more on cosmetics while comparing to married woman.
Table 2 unleashed that among 285 respondents only 1% respondents does not use any kind
of beauty products remaining 99% uses beauty products in different forms. It was also
identified that most of the females (40%) who responded to this study has been using some
kind of beauty products from 5-10 years. However, only 8% female stated that they have
been using beauty products since 20 years that means the craze for beauty products among
females in Nepal has just emerged and that with the emergence of online platforms and
social media. In many different cultures, beauty items are commonly used and embraced.
The artistic self-expression and self-identity factor can be attributed to the popularity of
beauty products (Kun, 2005).
Basically, females were found to use Lip Cosmetics, Eye Cosmetics, Hair Care Cosmetics
and Skin Care Cosmetics, Facial Products and Eye Cosmetics. However, majority of females
(185) were found to use lip cosmetic products and eye products were used by least number
of females (81). As with most industries, marketing and advertising internal processes have
become more effective and efficient by moving online and, thus, can cut costs and save time.
In line with this the study also shows that around 63% of respondents are directly influenced
by the online advertisement. The study further indicated that 56% customers’ visits websites
and pages of beauty products before they purchase them on the other hand, 44% does not
visit any websites or pages while buying beauty products. The advertisements promote an
idealized lifestyle and manipulate readers to a certain extent into believing whatever that is
advertised is indeed true (Kaur et al., 2017).
In our result, we found out that 221 out of 285 respondents are influenced by the information
provided in the website or page about the success of the product given in advertisements
influenced them to purchase beauty product. This denotes that 77% of respondents do read and
check the information provided in the advertisement. Also, it was found that approximately
28% of respondents do not relate themselves to the advertisement of beauty product while
rest 72% of respondents can relate themselves. This shows that maximum respondents can
relate themselves to advertisement displayed by cosmetic companies. On the similar note
56% females agreed that guarantees made in an advertisement influenced them to purchase
particular beauty product. Similarly, Family and friends affect young people’s behavior in
various ways. Aidla (2011) set as example, traditions and values are very important in the
family while among friends the significant factor is social pressure. 72% female denoted that
they do get influenced by friends and family while buying beauty products.
Likewise, 72% respondents bought the beauty products because it was given during a
consultation at a cosmetic counter of various departmental store and malls. This shows that
it is an effective way to sell the beauty products by putting the store and stalls and giving
consultations to the customers that visits to the departmental stores and shopping malls for
various products. Sometimes, they even get what they were searching for in such stores and
malls. According to a research done by Bailey (2011) women shop for skincare items as
a way to indulge themselves. They want to buy expensive-looking items from the luxury
brands and they want to be pampered at the beauty counter. Similar to the findings 56%
females in Kathmandu valley tend to buy beauty products because the company was offering
free gifts however, 44% would look for various other factors rather than gifts while buying
cosmetic products as they affect their health as well.
Consumers also feel more pleased with their purchase when it is part of a promotion. 179 out
of 285 respondents do get influenced by the beauty products promotional events and sale.
Promotion, events and sale can be conducted frequently in order to get good customer attention
in the field of marketing plus in the case of female products female tend to get more attracted
by these sales and offers. Social responsibility has been gaining attention of customers of
different segments. Likewise, customers who purchase beauty products have also seen to be
being aware towards the social responsibility that the cosmetic companies are practicing. In line
with the same factor it was found that 179 out of 285 respondents do get influenced whether
or not the purchased beauty product’s company practices social responsibility. From this it can
also be said that in Nepal as well customers are being aware about the social responsibility
practices followed by the companies where they buy or are planning to buy any products which
also brings companies into pressure to follow social responsibility.
Though Nepal is experiencing changes in shopping pattern, adopting online platforms for
shopping price factor still plays crucial role while making purchase decision. But, while it is
the matter of cosmetic products 72% female stated that price factor does not influence them
to buy cosmetic products, they try to purchase genuine quality which suits them, their skin
the most. But, 28% respondents feel that expensive beauty products are of better quality.
Also, 62.8% cosmetic buyers stated that color, texts, shape of packaging influences them to
buy cosmetic products to greater extent. Salim Khraim (2011) states in the cosmetic market,
luxury cosmetics, such as Max factor, L'Oreal, Revlon have a brand name picture of high
product class and broad recognition and customers opt for those products with stronger
brand name which can be stated true in this study as well, as 77.6% customers would make
choice of superior brand products in comparison to non-branded products. Likewise, Out of
285 females 160 believe that they purchase of particular beauty product based on frequency
of shopping with the brand and regularity to the website is discussed. And rests 125 do not
believe that they purchase of particular beauty product based on frequency of shopping
with the brand and regularity to the website is discussed and 56% thinks brand is the most
important attribute to be considered while purchasing any beauty product.
Majority (45.9%) of customers prefer online purchase because they think they can compare
price, quality and other various related factors from one site to another and one page to
another which sells similar beauty products. Which could make their purchase decision easier.
However, 95.7% customers feel that pricings schemes of online shops are not reasonable.
Likewise, 39.6% prefer online purchasing due to convenience, 28.7% due to prompt service
and 27.1% due to B2C facility.
Besides the good factors, there are drawbacks of online stores as well. The study analyzed
some of the major reasons that make online business unreliable and backwards. The major
reasons are trust issues, delayed response, costly and no timely delivery. Among various
reasons one of the major reasons why customers don’t prefer online purchase of cosmetic
products is online cosmetic products are costly as stated by 45.96% respondents. However,
only 26.6% does not prefer online purchase of cosmetics because they think products are
not delivered on time. Similarly, 45.26% have trust issues with online shops/companies and
43.15% feels online platforms provides slow response.
C Product Attributes
The price influenced me to purchase my product. 168 117
The “expensive” price influenced me to purchase my beauty product 177 108
because I felt like the product must be made of quality
The colors, text, and/or shape of the packaging influenced me to 175 110
purchase my product.
Awareness was measured in multiple factors which are explained accordingly. Then two of
these three dimensions are evaluated at three ranges that are less aware, moderately aware
and highly aware. The ranking is shown by the index number. The 0-50 index is graded
as less aware and the 51-100 value index as highly aware. For the index, each respondent
with the answers to the given question is first calculated separately. In comparison with the
users, further satisfaction level is then measured in conjunction with the gender, showing
the percentage of male and female users' satisfaction level. Under awareness index we have
analyzed and considered various variables that further help to depict the awareness level of
the users on online shopping. Thus, the study found that 95% females are aware about the
online purchase of beauty products.
Major challenges in online purchase of beauty products as depicted from this study is arise
from supplier (31.2%). Likewise, other problems relating to online purchase are threats of
competitors, online companies, advertising agency, distribution channel and communicating
skill of seller. However, communicating skill of sellers is found to be causing less challenge
(0.004%) on online purchase.
5. Discussion
This study finds that 95% of total respondents have knowledge of online shopping which the
awareness level of online purchase in Nepal is gaining betterment. Hsu et al. (2006) further
stated that the faith of other individuals, such as friends, authorities and groups, would have a
positive impact on social factors to influence a person to use IT and make purchase decision
accordingly. The component associated with the behavioral intent to payment electronically
also resulted in perceived ease of use in the online purchase behavior of beauty products in
this study and the finding is highly significant.
This study found that the Nepalese online shopping consumers appear to pay more attention
to the timely service and quality of product. Supporting the result of previous research, the
online purchase behavior of beauty product's features dominate the behavioral intention or
their judgment on the online purchase behavior of beauty products, including the effect of
social influence. Nepal is becoming increasingly popular by the day. Nearly all people with
internet access have been drawn to online niche products at least once and many decide to
buy it as well (Shrestha, 2019). Yet unfortunately, many are left disappointed due to many
problems with the online shopping experience. Online shopping websites in Nepal lack
reviews and ratings of clients. Such portals may provide some discount or coupon codes
for each review received to encourage further customer interaction (Chaudhary, 2018). This
could help new customers on their website who are looking to buy. Often, as they provide
incentives, internal penalties may be levied on comments with false opinions and seller-
harmful opinions.
6. Conclusion
Since this paper aimed to analyze awareness of female consumer towards online purchase of
beauty products it was found that 95% females are aware related to online purchase of beauty
products. The study also indicated that though women are shifting their purchase behavior
to online platforms they still face challenges which arises due to the unreal products shown
in the picture of online sites or pages and the actual product differs which have also caused
reluctance among women to purchase beauty products online. Likewise, the price levied on
products are found to be comparatively higher than in stores. So, if online portals and sites
selling beauty products makes their selling efficient by providing real and quality products,
charging effective and reliable price then women are ready to make their purchase from
online sites and pages.
Therefore this study recommends that ensuring quality products, learning about competitor’s
next move, increasing online payment method and making users aware about it, giving
discounts and offers to customers can enhance online purchasing pattern of female
customers towards beauty products. However, this study only covered awareness of females
customers from Kathmandu valley so for more effective and reliable result further study can
be conducted targeting women of different areas of Nepal.
References
Abd Rahman, A., Asrarhaghighi, E., & Ab Rahman, S. (2015). Consumers and halal cosmetic products:
knowledge, religiosity, attitude and intention. Journal of Islamic Marketing, 6(1), 148-163.
Aidla, A. (2011). The impact of family members and friends habits on youths smoking behaviour:
Consequences for social marketing. Revista de Management Comparat Internațional, 12(1),
184–196.
Anjana, S. (2017). A study on factors influencing cosmetic buying behavior of consumers. International
Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics, 118(1314-3395 (on-line version)), 453–459.
Bailey, R. L. (2011). A study of the factors impacting women's purchases of anti-aging skincare
products (Doctoral dissertation, UGA).
Bechan, K., & Ehsanul Hoque, M. (2016). Influence of income growth on purchasing patterns of
luxury cosmetic products among Nigerian customers. Public and Municipal Finance, 5(4), 41–47.
Bosnjak, M., Galesic, M., & Tuten, T. (2007). Personality determinants of online shopping: Explaining
online purchase intentions using a hierarchical approach. Journal of Business Research, 60(6),
597-605.
Cash, T. F., & Smith, E. (1982). Physical attractiveness and personality among american college
students. Journal of Psychology: Interdisciplinary and Applied, 111(2), 183–191.
Chaudhary, R. (2018). Cosmestics ma Jaydai Chemical. Kantipur, p. 1.
Cheung, C. M. K., Lee, M. K. O., & Rabjohn, N. (2008). The impact of electronic word-of-mouth: The
adoption of online opinions in online customer communities. Internet Research, 18(3), 229–247.
Denton, K. (2019). How social media uses the psychology of persuasion to influence the purchase
of beauty products to the young generations (Doctoral dissertation, Southern New Hampshire
University).
Devkota, N., Budhathoki, A., Paudel, U. R., Adhikari, D. B., Bhandari, U., & Parajuli, S. (2021). Online
trading effectiveness in Nepal share market: Investors awareness, challenges and managerial
solution. Asian Journal of Economics, Business and Accounting, 21(5), 90-98.
Evans, D., & Volery, T. (2001). Online business development services for entrepreneurs: an exploratory
study. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 13(4), 333-350.
Feng, X. (2012). A study of the factors that affect the impulsive cosmetics buying of female consumers
in Kaohsiung. African Journal of Business Management, 6(2), 275–282.
Forrester Research. 2006. Projected online retail sales: 2006 to 2011. U.S. Census Bureau. Retrieved
October 15, 2007, from http://www.census.gov/compedia/ statab/tables/08s1021.pdf.
Hankins, M., French, D., & Horne, R. (2000). Statistical guidelines for studies of the theory of reasoned
action and the theory of planned behaviour. Psychology and Health, 15(2), 151–161.
Himalayan News Service. (2019, May 26). The Business Of Beauty. The Himlayan Times, p. 3.
Hsu, M. H., Yen, C. H., Chiu, C. M., & Chang, C. M. (2006). A longitudinal investigation of continued
online shopping behavior: An extension of the theory of planned behavior. International Journal
of Human Computer Studies, 64(9), 889–904.
Kaur, K., Arumugam, N., & Yunus, N. M. (2013). Beauty product advertisements: A critical discourse
analysis. Asian social science, 9(3), 61.
Kinski, N. (2017). A perfect match: Influencer marketing and the beauty industry. Upfluence.
Kumar, S. (2005). Exploratory analysis of global cosmetic industry: major players, technology and
market trends. Technovation, 25(11), 1263-1272.
Kun, C. (2005). Beauty of simplicity. Ceramics - Technical, 20, 25–28.
Lipnevich, A. A., MacCann, C., Krumm, S., Burrus, J., & Roberts, R. D. (2011). Mathematics attitudes
and mathematics outcomes of US and Belarusian middle school students. Journal of educational
psychology, 103(1), 105.
Millennials change consumer marketing. (2015). Millennials change consumer marketing. Home
Furnishings Business, 10(11), 17-18.
Mirabi, V., Akbariyeh, H., & Tahmasebifard, H. (2015). A study of factors affecting on customers
purchase intention. Journal of Multidisciplinary Engineering Science and Technology
(JMEST), 2(1).
NRB (2016). Monetary Policy for 2016/17. Nepal Rastra Bank, Baluwatar, Kathmandu, Nepal.
Paudel, U. R., & Devkota, N. (2018). Socio-economic influences on small business performance in
Nepal-India open border: Evidence from cross-sectional analysis. Economics & Sociology, 11(4),
11-30.
Paudel, U. R.; Parajuli, S.; Devkota, N., & Mahapatra, S. K. (2020). What determines customers’
perception on banking communication? Evidence from Nepalese commercial banks. Global
Economy Journal, 20(4), 1-21.
Priyanto, A. (2019, October 24). Beauty standards show racism runs deep in Indonesia. The Kathmandu
Post, p. 7.
Salim Khraim, H. (2011). The influence of brand loyalty on cosmetics buying behavior of UAE female
consumers. International Journal of Marketing Studies, 3(2), 5389–5398.
Sameer, C. M. and M. D. D. (2007). Industrial Management & Data Systems Article information.
Sebastianelli, R., Tamimi, N., & Rajan, M. (2008). Perceived quality of online shopping: Does gender
make a difference? Journal of Internet Commerce, 7(4), 445-469.
Shrestha, N. M. (2019, November 10). Mystery of Ageing. Republica, p. 6.
Navin Duwadi1
Abstract
This study focuses on bloackchain as an emerging technology regarding its use to restructure
the systems and advance education upon quality outcomes. What are the benefits of
integrating blockchain in education concerning system reformation and advancement in
developing better educational process for all encompassing learning outcomes? With the
recent developments of blockchain applications across multiple domains, the education
industry seems to be benefited from this technology in considerable degree. Transcripts and
certificates play a vital role in individual’s life so it needs to be stored in tamper-proof and
long term available ledger. In pursuant to addressing afore stated question, this study bring
information regarding what blockchain technology is, how it functions and what its uses
if it comes to integrate with education at different levels. This may include reviewing the
conceptual/knowledge bases, research and development studies and sources that introduce
blcokchain including its features but with special highlight on how it has been integrated in
the education sector especially in innovative situation.
To this end, this study was designed to provide a systematic review of all the literature focused
on decentralized ledger technology. Multiple sources were reviewed following a systematic
pattern that allows selection of relevant sources, sort out information being guided by the
research question and make final selection of required information that connects with what
and how of Blockchain in education.
1. Introduction
Blockchain technology was proposed by someone called Satoshi Nakamoto in 2008 and
was applied in a virtual currency application. Using blockchain technology, Nakamoto has
invented a digital currency called bitcoin. It is a peer-to-peer network that uses distributed
ledger technology to store and disseminate information (Nakamoto, 2009). After Satoshi
Nakamoto implemented blockchain technology to invent bitcoin there are many other
cryptocurrencies also started emerging on the market.
1 Navin Duwadi is a faculty for graduate studies at Global College International and a director of Department
of Information Technology.
Every block in the blockchain can store a little volume of data (generally around 1 MB), which
might be any information that has to be stored securely while still being widely disseminated.
These might be information of monetary transactions (virtual currency) or exam credentials
or learning records in the case of education (Sharples, & Domingue, 2016). That data is kept
on all participating devices and may be seen by anybody with the cryptographic ‘public key,'
but cannot changed or altered, even by the original author. The data records are timestamped,
ensuring a reliable and accurate record of the new information.
The blockchain is an enormous and worldwide encoded data set that goes to the requirement
for decentralization and security of cycles normal to general people and organizations,
finishing the syndication or monopoly of data by the elements that dealt with that data. In this
sort of phenomenal and general arrangement, a group of individual records called "blocks"
are joined in a “chain" that can't be altered, being approved by different PCs through the
Internet. An enormous, decentralized, encoded, and open book of records where different
specialists control the veracity of the information and guarantee its moral soundness were
discussed. Its utilization incorporates the exchange of cryptographic forms of money,
decentralized programming, and the enrollment of charges, and a long record of exchanges,
everything being equal. (Gomez, 2021)
In the beginning, blockchain technology was limited only to the digital currencies application
but these days there are lots of research undertaken to explore the importance of blockchain in
other domains such as healthcare, education, smart cities, banking, insurance, and many more.
The trend has shifted towards the security and verifiable system because blockchain provides
an unbreakable and unhackable system for computer-based applications (Magazine, 2015).
The new and quick advancement of dispersed figuring and blockchain innovation has
pushed us to reevaluate and reconsider a large number of the basic parts of the frameworks
of education, literacy and training. Ideas like trust, worth, protection, and personality are for
the most part, coming into question as another set-up of advancements has been introduced.
The recent and rapid advancement of distributed computing and blockchain technologies
has compelled to reconsider and redesign many of our established educational institutions.
A new set of technologies, concepts like trust, value, privacy, and identity are all being called
into question when the blockchain technology is brought into the academic institution.
The main concern of blockchain technology in the education sector is how this technology can
provide the secure as well as a trustable and traceable exchange of educational information.
Later that information is shared among the multiple institutions in the field of education
including teaching and learning process that too encompass accreditation and validation of
educational achievements that are in turn secured in the ledger (Blockchain in education,
2021). It has been found that Blockchain technology provides an environment where
individuals can be the custodian of their academic records and won’t necessarily require
any intermediaries to record or alter records. Issuance, validation, and sharing of certificates
can also be done by education providers using blockchain technology, a cryptographic data
exchange which will ultimately help to prevent the certificate frauds that are seen so often.
A revolutionary field for technologies is identified in the education sector, an emerging area
where the requirement for the certificate is fundamental. It can be found on the multiple
research done by researchers, certain percentage of the applicants falsified the degree
certificates. The need to check this sort of data is presently not accidental and might be
valuable to keep away from certain ensuing debates (Sharma, 2018).
Students’ records are a very crucial part of the education sector, and with blockchain
innovation, resources like learner participation, courses, and installments toward educational
cost on the off chance that they go to a public or private school, grades, coursework, and
surprisingly their certificate can turn out to be essential for their own blockchain record. Since
these records can't be erased, this assists with information security in that it is permanent.
Student records are the property of the students rather than to the school. With blockchain,
no member can alter a record after it has been saved. On the unusual chance that a record
has a blunder, another record should be added to address it, and both the erroneous and right
records will stay apparent (Hance et al., 2021).
1.2 Objective
The main goal of our research is to,
(i) analyze the evolution of blockchain-related research topics across time and venues,
(ii) classify blockchain-related existing research,
(iii) identify the opportunities and challenges of blockchain technology implementation
in education, and
(iv) map the connections between the discovered blockchain opportunities and
challenges with the identified research topics.
2. Review of Literature
In this section of the paper, some of the theories and ideas related to blockchain technology
and its application in the educational process and institutions has been explained.
The blockchain simply refers to the data records that have been hosted on decentralized
networks and are a part of the blockchain and cannot be modified. Blockchain is a peer-
to-peer network that uses cryptography technology to keep data safe. In the blockchain,
all existing records are managed by a group of nodes that cannot be owned by a single
entity so updating or even damaging records on all networks is nearly impossible. All of
the transactions that the block will bring are linked together so that they may be validated
and signed using cryptographic evidence that the blockchain and its volunteers have solved
(Guustaaf et al., 2021).
The application of blockchain-like virtual currency such as Bitcoin uses the public key
infrastructure (PKI) mechanism. In PKI, generally, pair of a public and private key is
distributed to the users. The public key is used to identify the address of the currency wallet
and a private key is used to identify the authenticity of the user. The ledger of the transaction
consists of the sender’s and receiver’s public key and the value of the transaction. In about
ten minutes, the transaction will be written in a block (Yli-Huumo et al., 2016). A previously
written block is then linked to this new block. All blocks, including information about each
transaction, are saved in the users' disk storage, which is referred to as nodes. Each node
stores information about all Bitcoin network transactions and uses prior blocks to verify the
integrity of each new transaction. Checking the accuracy of transactions rewards the nodes
(Haugsbakken & Langseth, 2019). Mining is the term for this process, and it is supported
by Proof-of-Work, which is one of the key concepts in Blockchain technology. A consensus
exists amongst all nodes when all transactions are successfully confirmed (Yli-Huumo et al.,
2016). The new blocks are linked to previous blocks and all the blocks are aligned in one
continuous chain. This chain of blocks is the public ledger technique of Blockchain.
executed, with no control of a third-party association. The benefit of Blockchain is that the
public record can't be adjusted or erased after the information has been supported by all
nodes. This is the reason Blockchain is well known of its information trustworthiness and
security attributes (Casino et al., 2019). Blockchain innovation can likewise be applied to
different sorts of users. It can, for instance establish an environment for virtual contracts
and peer to peer information sharing in a cloud computing service (Swan, 2015). The solid
place of Blockchain strategy, information trustworthiness, is the motivation behind why its
utilization stretches out additionally to different administrations and applications such as an
education sector.
As a result, no one can add any transaction blocks to the ledger without the approval of the
majority of nodes. Furthermore, once the transaction blocks add to the ledger no one can
go back and alter the transaction. Thus, not any user will be able to change or delete the
transaction added on the ledger.
attacks. Every piece of data on the blockchain is cryptographically hashed. In simple terms,
the network information conceals the underlying nature of the data (Iredale, 2021). Any
input data is passed through a mathematical method that generates a different form of value,
but the length remains constant. Each block in the ledger has its own hash and also contains
the hash of the previous block. Users will be provided with a private key to access the data
and a public key to make the transaction (Daley, 2021).
3. Research Methodology
This study follows systematic literature review. Systematic literature review is a method of
collecting, assessing, and interpreting all relevant research for a certain research question,
topic area, or phenomenon of interest. Primary studies are individual studies that contribute
to a systematic review; a systematic review is a type of secondary study. A systematic
literature review was conducted by searching for relevant papers according to Petersen et
al. (2008) principles. The systematic review process was chosen as research methodology
because the goal of the review was to explore the existing studies related to Blockchain
technology. The following subsections go over the steps of the guidelines.
1) Identify the need for a review, specify the research questions and develop a review
protocol.
2) Identify the research, select the studies, assess the quality, take notes and extract data,
synthesize the data.
3) Carried out the survey applications with blockchain in use for academic purposes.
1) When and how often were blockchain research articles for education published?
The main aim of the research question is to identify the trends that includes the
publication trends over the time in a multiple region and also helps to understand the
research topic, blockchain in education is accepted by scientific research community as
a relevant research topic.
2) What are the opportunities that blockchain technology could bring into the field of
education?
This research question intends to identify the opportunities of employing blockchain
technology for education that have been discovered in the peer-reviewed literature. It
will also aid future scholars in their efforts to enhance blockchain adoption in the realm
of education.
3) What are the various challenges while implementing blockchain technology in education?
This research question intends to identify the challenges of implementing blockchain
technology for education that have been found from the peer-reviewed literatures. It will
also help future scholar to improve blockchain adoption in educational institution.
Full paper available on the internet related to the blockchain technology in multiple domains.
4.1.2 APPII
APPII based on London, England used to authenticate credentials using blockchain
technology. To validate the academic credentials of prospective students and lecturers, the
company uses blockchain, smart contracts, and machine learning. Users of APPII build
a profile and complete their academic CV, which includes their educational history and
transcripts. APPII then uses blockchain to validate a user's identity and save their data in
its Blockchain (Daley, 2021). APPII has created a system that registers and evaluates the
credentials and experience of pupils and those already in the workforce utilizing modern
technologies such as blockchain and smart contracts. APPII also can be used as a career
verification tool that helps screening candidate resume for further selection with the help of
the blockchain technology.
4.1.4 ODEM
ODEM is a blockchain-based educational online platform that provides students with
economical academic courses that can be tailored to their specific needs (Pixelplex, 2021).
Students can communicate directly with academic experts and agree on the optimum learning
environment. The platform employs smart contracts and blockchain-enabled payment
systems to incentivize and reward students for their academic endeavors, as well as to
encourage teachers to produce better courses. The blockchain stores all of the certifications
that students have earned. As a result, they may be easily accessible and shared on social
media, as well as used as evidence in digital CVs.
BEN was created to assist emerging, growing, and not-yet-existing college organizations
in establishing a presence on their campuses, receiving administrative recognition and
financing, and connecting students with similar college and institutions. In order to change
the face of electronic finance and innovation, BEN provides educational and professional
materials, contacts, speakers, and guidance (BEN, n.d).
4.1.7 Disciplina
Disciplina based on Kesklinna, Tallinn, Estonia is a personalized learning management
system that keeps track of learners' academic achievement using blockchain technology
(Daley, 2021). Each student is given a score based on their academic performance,
extracurricular activities engagement, and other accomplishments. These results are used
by schools and institutions that have registered on the platform to personalize the learning
process and generate unique programs for each course. Disciplina also attempts to improve
communication between students and teachers by providing easy-to-use tools for grading,
rating, and reviewing. Recruitment firms and businesses can also use the platform to find
potential employees (Pixelplex, 2021).
4.1.8 Parchment
Parchment based on Scottsdale, Arizona, provides digital credential services to students,
academic institutions, and companies, and uses blockchain in education. K-12 educators can
upload any significant developmental progress to the company's blockchain. The platform
is used by higher education institutions to assess academic merit, process applications, and
issue unchangeable diplomas. Students also have 24/7 access to all educational information
and can simply share their academic achievements with potential employers and educational
institution (Daley, 2021).
4.1.9 Bitdegree
BitDegree based on Kaunas, Lithuania is more tech-focused online education platform
integrates blockchain ledgers and tokenization. To help more people learn about digital ledger
technology and eventually adopt a blockchain-related career, the organization offers online
courses such as “Cryptocurrency for Dummies: Ethereum vs Bitcoin and Much More.” The
site also encourages education by awarding tokenized scholarships for completion of the
course or fulfillment of specified goals (Daley, 2021).
According to Loukil et al., (2021) adopting the blockchain to secure and verify shared
evidence can improve the education area. Because student records are saved on a blockchain,
papers such as diplomas and certificates can be eternally secured and certified, even if the
institutions that issued them closed down or the entire educational system collapsed due to
conflicts or natural disasters. Because they can verify the validity of their certificates issued
to third parties directly on the blockchain, the nature of blockchain technology can help
educational institutions save time and resources associated with transactions to confirm the
validity of their certificates issued to third parties.
Some of the reviewed articles has explained that many blockchains also support smart
contracts. This means that lectures and courses can be written into the blockchain and
run automatically when certain criteria are satisfied. A teacher, for example, could
assign assignments to students. The smart contracts on the blockchain may verify the
accomplishment of each task automatically. Teachers might be paid in crypto tokens for
completing all responsibilities, and pupils could be given credits. This method might be used
to lay out entire courses. (Cedeño et al., 2020)
Tokens are earned when students on educational platforms view tutorials and invite new
members to the system. When people connect with their material, content providers earn
extra tokens.
• Scalability
The amount of transactions in blockchain technology is increasing every day and making
the distributed ledger bulky. In the blockchain, every node should store transaction records
and information (Zheng et al., 2017). With the increasing number of blockchain nodes in
the network, it reduces the efficiency of the algorithms and the response time of the nodes.
Although it has been said that blockchain technology is tamper-proof but still there are a lot
of cases where hackers have attacked the system so this challenge is not addressed properly
there will be a high risk of the leakage of teachers and student information. (Ma & Fang,
2020)
• Non-technological factors
Blockchain engineers and experts
Blockchain technology is a new and emerging field and it can be found that there is still a lack
of skilled professionals, engineers, and experts on the market. With the rapid development of
blockchain applications in multiple domains, the demand for human resources of blockchain
technology is increasing (Ma & Fang, 2020). Most of the companies, either start-up or well
established are looking for blockchain developers to implement blockchain-based systems.
Nevertheless, the education field is sensitive so high-level research and development group
is needed to develop and implement blockchain technology in the higher education sector.
Because of the increasing demand on the market place blockchain professionals are very
expensive to afford for the educational institution. Skilled professionals will be a huge
challenge for an educational institution to implement blockchain technology.
• Trust factors
The trust factor is one of the major obstacles among blockchain users to implement blockchain
technology. Especially in the education sector trust plays a vital role to keep student's and
teacher's information securely over the blockchain network. There are two different types of
challenges related to trust. Firstly, the organizations may not be able to trust the technology
and may not trust the other organization on a distributed ledger network. (Ma & Fang, 2020)
• Cost
Another important factor for blockchain’s poor adoption in the education sector is that few
decision-makers in the field have a good understanding of what it is and how it may improve
the entire system. The main reason will be costs: the cost of altering the environment, setting
up the infrastructure, the cost of blockchain development, and the cost of blockchain training
for employees. It may be difficult to predict the long-term financial benefits of blockchain
integration, which include lower administration and record-keeping costs, as well as additional
gains from implementing cryptocurrency payments and rewards (Pixelplex, 2021).
5. Conclusion
The use of blockchain technology in education is still in its initial phase. As a result, a
review of current blockchain research in the field of education is required to identify specific
research gaps that should be addressed in future research. The goal of this research was
to give a thorough examination of blockchain applications in the sector of education. We
conducted a systematic literature review for this purpose. We were able to identify the
opportunities and challenges of implementing blockchain technology into education because
of our review of literatures. As a result, this analysis can help future research efforts in the
field of blockchain adoption in education overcome present solution limitations. Although
this technology is still in its early stages of development and must undergo testing, it has the
potential to spur a lot more innovation in the future. In our future work, we will introduce
tokenization of educational activity in detail. Furthermore, monetizing all of the students
activities on blockchain network will inspire students to participate in multiple activities
such as sports, attendance, and homework and so on.
References
Arndt, T. (2019). An overview of blockchain for higher education. Proceedings of the 11th International Joint
Conference on Knowledge Discovery, Knowledge Engineering and Knowledge Management. https://doi.
org/10.5220/0008343902310235
Ark, T. V. (2018). 20 ways blockchain will Transform (Okay, May IMPROVE) EDUCATION. Forbes. https://
www.forbes.com/sites/tomvanderark/2018/08/20/26-ways-blockchain-will-transform-ok-may-improve-
education/?sh=cb87fff4ac91.
Blockcerts. (n.d.). Blockchain credentials. Blockcerts. Retrieved September 27, 2021, from https://www.blockcerts.
org/about.html.
Blockchainedu.org. (n.d.). The blockchain Education NETWORK (BEN). Retrieved September 28, 2021, from
https://www.blockchainedu.org/about.
Brown, M. (2021). 5 challenges with blockchain adoption and how to avoid them. SearchCIO. https://searchcio.
techtarget.com/tip/5-challenges-with-blockchain-adoption-and-how-to-avoid-them.
Casino, F., Dasaklis, T. K., & Patsakis, C. (2019). A systematic literature review of blockchain-based applications:
Current status, classification and open issues. Telematics and Informatics, 36, 55–81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
tele.2018.11.006
Cedeño, J. (2020). How blockchain could impact education in 2020 and beyond. Getting Smart. Retrieved September
30, 2021, from https://www.gettingsmart.com/2020/02/23/how-blockchain-could-impact-education-in-2020-
and-beyond/.
Chen, G., Xu, B., Lu, M., & Chen, N.-S. (2018). Exploring blockchain technology and its potential applications for
Education. Smart Learning Environments, 5(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40561-017-0050-x
Daley, S. (2021.). 9 blockchain education companies Earning Straight A's. Built In. Retrieved September 27, 2021,
from https://builtin.com/blockchain/blockchain-education.
Garcia-Font, V. (2020). Blockchain: Opportunities and Challenges in the Educational Context. Lecture Notes on
Data Engineering and Communications Technologies. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-29326-0
Gomez, D. (2021). Blockchain in education, a large and global encrypted database. eLearn Center Blog. https://
elearncenter.blogs.uoc.edu/blockchain-in-education/.
Guustaaf, E., Rahardja, U., Aini, Q., Maharani, H. W., & Santoso, N. A. (2021). Blockchain-Based Education
Project. Aptisi Transactions on Management (ATM), 5(1), 46–61. https://doi.org/10.33050/atm.v5i1.1433
Hance, M. (2021). What is blockchain and how can it be used in education? MDR. https://mdreducation.
com/2018/08/20/blockchain-education/.
Haugsbakken, H., & Langseth, I. (2019). The Blockchain Challenge for Higher Education Institutions. European
Journal of Education, 2(3), 41. https://doi.org/10.26417/ejed.v2i3.p41-46
Housley, R. (2004). Public Key Infrastructure (PKI). The Internet Encyclopedia. https://doi.org/10.1002/047148296x.
tie149
Iredale, G. (2021). 6 key blockchain features you need to know now. 101 Blockchains. Retrieved September 27,
2021, from https://101blockchains.com/introduction-to-blockchain-features/.
Liang, X., & Zhao, Q. (2020). On the design of a blockchain-based Student Quality Assessment System. 2020
International Conference on High Performance Big Data and Intelligent Systems (HPBD&IS). https://doi.
org/10.1109/hpbdis49115.2020.9130584
Loukil, F., Abed, M., & Boukadi, K. (2021). Blockchain adoption in education: A systematic literature review.
Education and Information Technologies, 26(5), 5779–5797. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-021-10481-8
Ma, Y., & Fang, Y. (2020). Current status, issues, and challenges of blockchain applications in education.
International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning (IJET), 15(12), 20. https://doi.org/10.3991/ijet.
v15i12.13797
Magazine, B. (2015). Beyond bitcoin: How the blockchain can power a new generation of enterprise software.
Bitcoin Magazine: Bitcoin News, Articles, Charts, and Guides. https://bitcoinmagazine.com/business/
beyond-bitcoin-how-the-blockchain-can-power-a-new-generation-of-enterprise-software-1443635470.
Malavolta, G., Moreno-Sanchez, P., Schneidewind, C., Kate, A., & Maffei, M. (2019). Anonymous multi-hop locks
for Blockchain scalability and interoperability. Proceedings 2019 Network and Distributed System Security
Symposium. https://doi.org/10.14722/ndss.2019.23330
Mingxiao, D., Xiaofeng, M., Zhe, Z., Xiangwei, W., & Qijun, C. (2017). A review on consensus algorithm of
blockchain. 2017 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics (SMC). https://doi.
org/10.1109/smc.2017.8123011
Nakamoto, S. (2009). Bitcoin: A peer-to-peer electronic cash system. Retrieved September 28, 2021.
NuWire. (2021). The role of Blockchain technology in the education sector. NuWireInvestor. Retrieved September
30, 2021, from https://www.nuwireinvestor.com/the-role-of-blockchain-technology-in-the-education-sector/.
Office of Educational Technology (2021). Blockchain in education https://tech.ed.gov/blockchain/.
Petersen, K., Feldt, R., Mujtaba, S., Mattsson, M. (2008). Systematic mapping studies in software engineering. In
12th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering (EASE) 12 (pp. 1–10).
PixelPlex. (2021). Blockchain education applications & use cases. PixelPlex. Retrieved September 28, 2021, from
https://pixelplex.io/blog/blockchain-education-use-cases-and-applications/.
Raman, R. K., & Varshney, L. R. (2018). Distributed storage meets secret sharing on the blockchain. 2018
Information Theory and Applications Workshop (ITA). https://doi.org/10.1109/ita.2018.8503089
Sharma, A. (2018). Blockchain could revolutionize Education next. Here's how. Hacker Noon. https://hackernoon.
com/blockchain-could-revolutionize-education-next-heres-how-1b720bdf5945.
Sharples, M., & Domingue, J. (2016). The Blockchain and kudos: A distributed system for educational record,
reputation and reward. Adaptive and Adaptable Learning, 490–496. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-
45153-4_48
SGE. (n.d.). Sony global Education develops technology using blockchain for open sharing of ACADEMIC
proficiency and Progress Records. Global Brands Magazine. Retrieved September 28, 2021, from https://
www.globalbrandsmagazine.com/sony-global-education-develops-technology-using-blockchain-for-open-
sharing-of-academic-proficiency-and-progress-records/.
Swan, M. (2015). Blockchain: Blueprint for a new economy. O'Reilly.
Tuson, M. (2018). Gilgamesh platform knowledge - sharing social network platform. Medium. Retrieved
September 28, 2021, from https://medium.com/@kotpodkolpakom/gilgamesh-platform-knowledge-sharing-
social-network-platform-178c68bfae6d.
Ullah, N., Mugahed Al-Rahmi, W., Alzahrani, A. I., Alfarraj, O., & Alblehai, F. M. (2021). Blockchain technology
adoption in Smart Learning Environments. Sustainability, 13(4), 1801. https://doi.org/10.3390/su13041801
Yli-Huumo, J., Ko, D., Choi, S., Park, S., & Smolander, K. (2016). Where is current research on blockchain
technology?—a systematic review. PLOS ONE, 11(10). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0163477
Zheng, Z., Xie, S., Dai, H., Chen, X., & Wang, H. (2017). An overview of blockchain technology: Architecture,
consensus, and future trends. 2017 IEEE International Congress on Big Data (BigData Congress). https://doi.
org/10.1109/bigdatacongress.2017.85