We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
PS.2171
RTFC — Preparing Project Contract
or Baseline Schedules
Edward E. Douglas III, CCP PSP FAACE
Abstract—The contract documents provide the participants with the guide to the scope and
technical requirements for the project. The project scheduler must achieve a thorough
understanding of the contract documents in order to develop a complete and accurate project
contract or baseline schedule. Preparing the project baseline or contract schedule is a labor
intensive planning effort which requires an understanding of the scope of work, knowledge of
the key technical tasks, procurements and deliverables as well as the sequence and timing for
project execution. The project management team must be involved in the development of
schedule tasks, activity sequences and durations and proactively participate in schedule reviews
during the contract schedule development process. This paper will discuss how to locate the
important schedule details in the contract documents for use in the baseline schedule
development process. Techniques will also be discussed that can be used to speed the schedule
development process such as the use of schedule templates, modular CPM schedule series and
successful use of schedules extracted from similar historic projects.
ps.2171.1
CConyightB ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Table of Contents
Abstract
Introduction ..
The Contract ..
Understanding the Contract
Contract Information Sources ..
What is a Contract Schedule
Project Scope and Performance
Project Planning for Execution...
Schedule Change Order Process .....
Schedule Activity Durations
Scheduling Techniques and Software ..
Schedule Risk and Contingencies .....
Schedule Integration Process
Schedule Progress Reporting ..
Schedule Resources
Project Procurement Planning ...
Key Procurements and Submittals,
Safety & Quality Hold Points and Inspections .
Punchlist/Turnover/System Start-up
The Role of the Scheduler .... .
Schedule Development Shortcuts ....
Contract CPM Schedule Review
Contract CPM Schedule Submittal
Conclusion
References
weomarNanuessuur
PS.2171.2
Copyright® ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Introduction
Preparation of the project contract or baseline schedule can be a challanging and daunting task
for the project scheduler. Often there are limited opportunities for the scheduler to interface
with the project team in order to obtain an understanding of the details of the project that are
needed to prepare the contract schedule. The preparation of the contract (baseline) schedule
requires understanding of the sequence and timing for key phases of project execution, as well
as a knowledge of the technical tasks, procurements and deliverables. The contract documents
provide the scheduler with the detailed source of the information regarding the scope and
technical requirements of the project. The project scheduler is responsible for preparing a CPM
schedule that meets the requirements of the contract and represents the project team
execution plan requirements. The project scheduler must understand the scope of work (SOW)
of the project, and then identify key project tasks & deliverables, often with minimal project
team interface or guidance and within a limited turnaround time to complete. The project
management team must actively participate in schedule planning and development of the
tasks, time frames and planned execution needed to provide the proper sequence and level of
details for input to the contract schedule. The project management team will also actively
participates in schedule reviews throughout the contract (baseline) schedule development
process. The project scheduler must achieve an understanding of the various elements of the
contract documents in order to develop a complete and accurate project baseline schedule.
This paper will identify the essential elements of information that can be extracted from the
project contract documents with emphasis on how to focus on the important contract details
needed for developing the project baseline schedule. Techniques will also be discussed that
could speed the schedule development process such as the use of schedule fragnets and
templates, modular CPM series and extracting schedule details from similar historic projects.
The Contract
Construction contracts take on a variety of forms and types. The more common (or standard)
forms of construction contracts are the Engineering- Procurement- Construction (E-P-C);
Design-Build Agreements; Construction Management (CM) agreements; and Guaranteed
Maximum Price (GMP). Additionally there are a variety of contract types: Fixed Price or Lump
Sum; Cost-Plus Fee; Unit Price contracts, and so on. Each of these contract types has an effect
on the method of administration of the project but not the actual execution of the work for the
project. [1] These contract forms and types have been developed by the various contracting
entities and are preferred for their specific use. Detailed descriptions of these contracts can be
found in a variety of sources. Professional associations such as the American Institute of
Architects (AIA); Associated General Contractors (AGC) and Construction Management
Association of America (CMA) all provide a large volume of information describing the
advantages and shortcomings of these contract agreements. This paper will not attempt to
describe the contract forms or types in detail nor try to discuss the advantages and
shortcomings of any of the contract agreements.
PS.2171.3
Copyright ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Understanding the Contract
“Understanding the Contract includes not only identifying the particular type of contract-
delivery mechanism, (such as CM-at Risk, fixed fee, and the others described above); the
contract payment process, terms and conditions, retainage, requisition backup requirements;
time limits for submission of documents; unit prices/alternates/ allowances; liquidated
damages or other penalties; estimating and bidding assumptions affecting the work; purchasing
requirements, including owner-furnished material & equipment; minority participation goals;
project labor agreements or special union issues; project closeout requirements; schedule and
project milestone requirements; delay notification and changed conditions requirements;
insurance, Workers’ Compensation, labor payroll certification, lien waivers; bonding
requirements; exculpatory language that is unreasonable toward your company; and multiple
other topics that could impact the contractor's risk of successful performance.” (2, p.158-159]
Project management sources caution all of the contracting parties to “Examine and carefully
read the contract documents, subcontracts and purchase order to make sure that you
understand the implications of these items. If you are not sure, ask someone knowledgeable for
assistance.” [2, p. 159] Professor Matt Stevens further emphasizes that “the project manager
and field manager(s) must be familiar with every aspect of the contract documents to avoid
errors, save time and money. All contract issues must be communicated between the
contracting parties in writing to clarify details.” [2, p. 159]
Contract Information Sources
The contract documents generally include four key sections/ components: the General
Conditions; Special Conditions; the Design Drawings and the Technical Specifications. “The
General Conditions of the construction contract make up the major element of the prime
contract documents and by reference also become a major part of each subcontract.” [3, p29]
These General Conditions should “flow down” or be passed along to the subcontractors which
will simplify the contract development process and provide both the prime contractor and
subcontractor with contract protection in the event of claims or disputes that might arise
during the project performance phase. The General Conditions section of the Contract will
include: the Scope of Work (with all inclusions/exclusions); the contractor's responsibilities;
subcontractor’s responsibilities; changes to the work; type of contract (fixed price/ time
&material/ other); design completion status; site access and work restrictions; safety, quality &
environmental compliance; regulatory & agency permits as well as contractor requirements for
insurance, indemnity, and waivers.
The General Conditions will also include project scheduling information: the contracted period
of performance from start date or notice to proceed (NTP) date as well as major contract or
performance milestones; materials and key equipment requirements. The scheduling
specification should include information regarding the required frequency for schedule
progress updates and submittal of the progress schedules which are often coordinated with
periodic contract payments. The scheduler should also become familiar with any contract
ps.2171.4
Conyight B ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
clauses related to liquidated damages (LDs); No Damage for Delay clauses and contract clauses
relates to claims and dispute resolution.
What is a Contract Schedule?
A contract or baseline schedule is a realistic time phased project plan that represents how the
project will be built. In order for that contract schedule to be complete it must include: the
entire scope of the project; key milestones and project phases; specific activities with
reasonable durations; a logic or sequence of work activities; and how these various activities
interrelate. Successful development of the contract (or baseline) schedule is facilitated by the
ability of the project scheduler to identify the information that is included in the contract
documents.
The schedule must represent the complete logical representation of the contractor's
construction plan. Too often a schedule is submitted, issued or distributed without full
understanding of what work is included in the schedule or whether the schedule represents the
contract requirements. The submittal may be a time scaled graphic layout with generic
descriptions of the activities, possibly with an attached listing of activities showing the
predecessor and successor relationships, and a stack of graphics resource curves or spending
histograms. All of these are provided with the perceived intent to confuse the project owner,
construction manager, and the project team leaders. The result would be a schedule that is not
utilized the project time management tool as intended. Too often contractors, during the rush
to complete their schedule submittal, the planning background: assumptions and constraints,
inclusions and exclusions are left behind in the stacks of working draft documents and
ultimately lost. At best, the planning documentation input from the various project team
members is clipped together and filed ...or piled in the corner of the construction trailer.
The scheduler needs to develop a systematic process for extracting the various elements of
information from the contract documents to prepare the project baseline schedule. A contract
review checklist similar to that described in AACE® international Recommended Practice RP
38R-06 “Documenting the Schedule Basis” [4] will help guide the scheduler’s contract review
and will provide the project management team with a better understanding of what is or is not
included — or what is specifically excluded in the project schedule. A lack of schedule
documentation makes it difficult for the project participants to fully understand the overall
project planning that was incorporated in the contractor schedule, which can have serious
effects on the ultimate success or failure of the project to achieve completion in the time
forecast in that contract baseline schedule. A structured approach to that schedule
documentation process will eliminate much of that uncertainty and provide a clearer
understanding of the schedule Including such items as the Scope of Work; Work Breakdown
Structure; project performance time period; key assumptions and constraints; issues and
impacts; schedule inclusions and specific exclusions that will improve the likely achievability
and predictable of project success.
PS.2171.5
Copyright ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Project Scope and Performance
The basic information regarding the project is obtained directly from the contract documents:
Project Title, contract number, and date the contract was signed. The Scope of Work is
described along with the project execution strategy and any key project assumptions and
constraints. The contract includes all of the important project conditions, and potential issues
or impacts to the project. The Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) may be defined in the
contract. The contract work to be performed “by others” such as systems start-up,
performance testing or commissioning not in the contract scope must be identified by
appropriate activity linkage in the contract schedule.
The contract performance period will be included in the General Conditions of the contract.
From the “Notice to Proceed” date to the contract completion date; the total number of
calendar days is specified for the project. All key project or contract milestones and key project
events would be listed with their contract dates. Those contract milestone dates are sometimes
referenced as a specific number of calendar days from the notice to proceed or notice of award
date. The project procurement and subcontracting requirements should be included in the
contract documents. Important contract terms such as engineering completion, mechanical
completion, substantial completion, beneficial occupancy or Certificate of Occupancy (CO), etc
should be defined for a clear understanding by all participants.
Project Planning for Execution
There are numerous challenges for the project scheduler when planning a contract baseline
schedule. The scheduler is tasked to prepare a CPM schedule that meets all the requirements of
the contract and represents the project team execution requirements: Understanding the
Scope of Work (SOW) of the project; identify key project phases, tasks & deliverables; often this,
must be accomplished with minimal project team interface or guidance and limited turnaround
time to complete development of the schedule. Both the project scheduler and the project
management team need to conduct a thorough review the contract documents to clarify their
understanding of all elements of the project including the scope of work for the project; status
of the design drawings, review the technical specifications and specified construction materials
and equipment; and compare their results to the project cost estimate.
The contract should describe any special procurement of materials and equipment and the
parties responsible for providing the material or equipment. Frequently when there is a
technically sophisticated procurement, or in many cases where a public entity wants to make
multiple procurements of identical equipment items (multiple projects with similar special
equipment requirements) there will be owner furnished equipment (OFE) specified in the
contract,
The contract will describe if there are special labor requirements/restrictions i.e. prevailing
wage agreements/or contractual requirements for hiring of union or open shop labor or
PS.2171.6
Copyright ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
minority subcontractors requirements. Site access and work restrictions could be included in
the contract: these site access and egress conditions will have an impact on the performance of
work in the schedule. For example; a project that had restricted access to the construction area
required adequate off-site parking for the craft and staff away from the restricted site and all
workers were transported into the jobsite by busses. Work hours were specified and additional
transportation arrangements were required for off shift or overtime work. The contract should
include provisions related to the influence of weather on the project: Either heat or cold may
influence the scheduled performance of the work. The project scheduler should be aware of
the type of work being performed and the seasonal impact of early or late performance.
Example: a seasonal wetland that was virtually dry and hard packed in the summer months
seriously affected vehicle travel in the wet season. Delayed or early completion of scheduled
work can have significant impacts on seasonally sensitive work
The contract may require the preparation and submittal of an initial project schedule that
details the project activities planned for the first 90 calendar days of the project. Usually those
activities in the early stage of the project include the preparation of project plans; material and
equipment submittals; vendor procurement activities; permits and mobilization activities
While contract baseline schedule development is underway the initial “90 day schedule” needs
to be tracked and statused. Ultimately, those 90 day schedule activities will be folded into the
contract baseline schedule.
Schedule Change Order Process
The contract will include an explanation of the change order process as it relates to schedule
change proposals. What is the required format for a schedule change proposal submittal for
client approval? The contract should specify if a contemporaneous Time Impact Analysis (TIA) is
required or a simple fragnet of the proposed schedule change. The inclusion of a flow chart of
the contract change process for schedule change proposals: from contractor notification,
submittal, to client approval and incorporation of that change into the schedule can be an
extremely helpful contract guide.
‘Schedule Activities Durations
The contract schedule specification section will contain information related to activity durations
and frequently include a statement that the maximum activity duration cannot exceed 2 30
calendar day duration except for: concrete curing; submittal reviews; or equipment fabrication
& deliveries. Activities other than procurements with planned work durations longer than 15,
working days, or 30 calendar days often need to be exglained. Holidays or other planned
project non-workdays would be identified in the contract.
PS.2171.7
Copyright® ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Scheduling Techniques and Software
The schedule specification would not be complete unless information related to the
scheduling software and techniques utilized to develop the schedule are included. More and
more frequently the project owners continue to expand the contract scheduling specifications
regarding scheduling software compatibility, as well as guidance regarding the use of logical
relationships, lags and the use of constraints. The use of “alternative relationships” (start to
start, finish to start, and finish to finish) and lags/leads can provide misleading results if used
incorrectly in the schedule and the use may be limited or prohibited by the contract.
The contract should discuss the software scheduling rules such as the use of “retained logic
vs. progress override” and the use of constraints. The contract should describe if the project
can use “Preferential Logic” defined by AACE® International Recommended Practice 105-90 as
“the contractor's approach to sequencing the work over and above those sequences indicated
in or required by the contract documents. Examples include equipment restraints, crew
‘movements, concrete form reuse, special logic (lead/lag) restraints, etc. that are factored into
the schedule which would mask the associated activity float times.” [5] The contract may
describe the use of multiple calendars established for various types of work plus to identify
project holidays and project non-work periods. The contract is usually silent about the project
use of the activity coding dictionary frequently used to provide for activity sorting,
organization, and filtering capabilities for the various schedule report layouts. The scheduling
specification may describe the accepted contract methods for identifying impact/delay
activities in the progress schedule. If any activity log records or notes are to be used for
recording schedule issues in the progress schedules, that process should be described in the
contract. Float ownership and use is often a significant concern that should be clarified by the
contract,
Schedule Risks and Contingencies
Risk Analysis is the assessment of what can go wrong (risks) and what contingency actions can
be taken to reduce the impact of those problems when they occur. [6] The contract should
include an explanation about how any potential schedule impacts should “addressed” in the
project schedule: weather; labor strikes or shortages, procurement delivery delays, etc.
contracts more frequently address those potential risk issues and explain how or if there is any
related “schedule contingency” that can be factored into the schedule. The contract should
describe how schedule contingencies are handled within the scheduling mechanics. The
contract schedule specification section should also describe how the schedule has been
evaluated in relation with cost estimate such as a “Time versus Cost” analysis in addressing the
potential for schedule risks and impacts. Any software scheduling technique used for handling
project planning assumptions and constraints (such as funding limitations) should also be
described in the contract. Most importantly, the scheduler must insure that all of the
requirements included in the contract schedule specifications are incorporated in the baseline
PS.2171.8
Copyright ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
contract schedule. If there are any deviations from that scheduling specification, describe that
variation and submit a request for approval to the project owner.
Schedule Integration Process
Integration of schedules from subcontractors, design engineers, vendors and the project
owner is required for the schedule to realistically reflect the overall project plan. The project
contract schedule should be a complete integration of the engineering, procurements, owner
furnished fixtures and equipment (FFE), work by other contractors, as well as the startup and
commissioning “by others”. The contract should describe those schedule “linkage points” if
that other scheduled work is managed separately and not included in the scope of the
contract schedule,
Schedule Progress Reporting
The process for schedule progress reporting and maintaining updates must also be described
in the contract documents. If the frequency of reporting schedule progress is not specified by
the contract, then as a minimum a statused schedule and progress update should be provided
representing the same time period as the contractor's progress payment submittal. The
contract will often describe the schedule update process of obtaining and verifying schedule
status and updates, and the level of detail to be reported upward to the various project
participants. Typically the Work Breakdown Structure would identify the various management
levels that receive the schedule progress reports.
Schedule Resources
Contract specifications vary about the requirement for resource and cost loading schedule
activities. There are pros and cons related to whether or not to resource and/or cost load
schedules. These resource-loading issues are considered to be a “double edged” sword for both
contractors and owners. (7] If the activities are resource loaded or cost (value) loaded, then the
following information should be included or explained in the schedule basis narrative. [8] What
are the units of measures? Are the resources crews or man-hours? If a crew, then what are the
normal, maximum and minimum crew sizes? if there is @ multiple “trades — crew” mix, the
maximum work area capacity might result in a stacking of trades limit. If other contractors are
working on the project what are those planned staffing requirements? Critical equipment or
key equipment requirements need to be identified. Not all equipment needs to be included in
the schedule. Non-critical project equipment such as administrative vehicles, generators,
compressors, backhoes and man lifts that are not essential to critical path work do not need to
be included as resource loaded equipment.
PS.2171.9
CConyight B ABCE® iterations
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Project Procurement Planning,
One of the important elements of the project schedule is the inclusion of planned
procurements. It is important that the scheduler become knowledgeable of the procurement
process in order to provide a realistic procurement sequence of actions with reasonable
durations. The project procurement planning will normally take place at around the 90% design
completion phase, and involves the project owner (developer) along with the construction
manager (CM) and key members of the project management team. The project scheduler needs
to be involved in these procurement planning sessions as much as time permits. The project
team prepares the project for procurement by assembling all the procurement related
information from the contract technical specifications. The contract drawings and technical
specifications review notes are then consolidated and organized into procurement packages.
Failure to review all of the contract technical requirements by this point can have a serious time
impact on the successful completion of the project. Each of those procurement packages
should include a scope of procurement as well as a preliminary time line or phase of the project
that the procurement will be required for assembly, installation or construction. The project
team will also be required to recommend whether to use modular, pre-assembly, “stick build”
or a combination of construction methods for various stages of the project. Time will be
required to prepare the subcontracts and bid packages as well as to prequalify vendors,
suppliers and trade contractors. A key point to remember as these technical procurement
packages are identified is that the procurement must support the construction date NOT the
construction trying to accommodate the procurement date.
Key Procurements and Submittals
The key procurement activities should be included in the contract schedule. The procurement
(vendor) source time frames must be included for the bid, award, fabrication, and delivery
activities. Consider and record for future reference any other procurement options that can
shorten the time frame for “long lead time” procurements. These planning activities should also
identify if material or large equipment storage is required and where that storage will be
located. If the storage area is off site, additional time must be added to the delivery schedule to
take into account that additional time. If the equipment or system requires assembly, identify
where that will take place; on-site or if the components be pre-assembled and directly
offloaded and set in place.
Most contracts require a “submittal schedule” that includes every specified technical submittal
included in the contract documents. Critical submittals need to be included in the project
schedule and particularly those that can impact the time of performance on the project. Those
scheduled submittal activities should include adequate time to develop and submit the shop
drawings, significant material samples, full size mock-ups, as well as the contract specified
review/approval time frames for the architect/engineering/owner, leading to the schedule
linkage to the applicable construction activities.
PS.2171.10
CConyight B AACE® iterations,
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Safety and Quality Hold Points and Inspections
Safety and Quality are both important to the project and if there are specific contract required
project “hold points” and/or contract inspections, these key schedule events need to be
included in the contract schedule.
Punchlist/Turnover/System Start-up
How often have we seen a project schedule that includes a single “stream of consciousness”
activity titled: “punchlist/turnover/system start-up” with a nominal ten or fifteen day duration?
system functional testing such as HVAC balancing, life safety systems and fire alarm system
tests, plumbing hydrostatic or pressure tests, mechanical or electrical equipment preliminary
operations, and any other scheduled or required “pre-commissioning” work needs to be
included in the schedule. These important activities require a realistic plan for inclusion in the
schedule. If this work will be performed “by others” then coordination will be required to
identify the details for proper incorporation of the activities into the project schedule. The
contract needs to clearly address these important requirements.
The Role of the Scheduler
The role of the project scheduler is described in AACE® International Recommended Practice
148-90. [9] The scheduler’s primary responsibility is to prepare a CPM schedule that meets the
contract requirements and that represents the project team execution plan. Some contracts
designate the scheduler as one of the key project personnel and require submittal of the
scheduler’s qualifications and experience for approval. The scheduler should attend the
preconstruction project “kickoff” meeting, and all meetings that affect the CPM schedule and
be prepared to discuss, in detail, the scheduled sequence of work and methods of execution.
There will often be a requirement for the scheduler to work on site rather than remotely or in
the home office of the contractor. This better positions the scheduler to perform the role of
maintaining the schedule updates and progress reporting. To be successful, the scheduler must
be knowledgeable of the status of all aspects of the work throughout the duration of the
contract including but not limited to the original contract work, additional work, new work, and
changed conditions of work. The scheduler should be able to lead the discussion of the
schedule related topics and the scheduler should be invited to as many project management
meetings as possible. By attending those meetings the scheduler will be able to obtain
additional information regarding impacts or issues and gather information that affect the
schedule. By listening proactively at the meeting it is much easier for the scheduler to obtain
updated schedule information that to try and chase down a busy field superintendent or
subcontractor outside the meeting.
PS.2171.11
CConyight B ABCE®itorastiona
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
Schedule Development Shortcuts
Schedulers are often asked to create CPM schedules faster. There are several CPM schedule
preparation shortcuts that can beemployed rather than to “Stick Build” (activity by activity &
link by link) every new baseline contract schedule. One technique is to create and use generic
schedule “templates” for repetitive tasks. Templates initially take more preparatory time but
can be time savers through repetitive use, The template technique has been used successfully
on several Department of Energy (DOE) program baseline schedules. Another technique is to
use the “as constructed” sequence of activities from similar historic projects. These similar
historic projects do not have to be the identical configuration of the current planned project. By
referring to the historical data the various construction phases can be compared for similarities.
Several years ago, Tennessee Valley Authority planners used the similar features from TVA
steam plants to develop a conceptual schedule for the Atmospheric Fluidized Bed (AFB) project
constructed in western Kentucky. [10] By reviewing construction schedules the TVA planners
were able to develop schedule sequences for a variety of similar features: site facilities & coal
handling facilities; powerhouse; water treatment plant; and the transformer & switch yards.
Some years later, TVA construction project controls compared construction schedules for two
Nuclear Power Plant construction projects, both containing similar Westinghouse reactor
equipment, at Sequoyah and Watts Bar Tennessee. The Department of Defense (DOD) Chemical
Weapons Demilitarization Program spent a significant effort to establish open communication
channels between the various prime contractors who were construction these projects at
various US locations.
Modular CPM scheduling has been around for a long time. Stephen Goodman presented a
Paper on “Modular CPM” techniques in 1992. [11] A modular CPM series is a predefined
“strings” of activities and the technique has been employed successfully at power plants for
many years. The Modular CPM series is most useful for a specific business Line. These CPM
modules are created then logically detailed at the proposal stage: Examples of modular CPM
series include site preparation & common facilities; critical plant generator equipment: Gas
Turbine Generators; Heat Recovery Steam Generators; & Steam Turbine Generators; balance of
plant equipment; i.e. switch yard facility and pre-engineered (vendor designed) buildings. Other
modular series have included “supporting strings: such as engineering/ procurement; general
design: by discipline/by system; procurement fabrication & delivery sequence. Sharing historic
and repetitive scheduling information can be beneficial for future project success.
Contract CPM Schedule Review
Although generally not a contract requirement, a good project practice is the conduct of
schedule reviews. The primary objective of a schedule review is to determine if the project CPM
schedule is “accurate, logical and achievable” and meets all the requirements of the contract.
The contract CPM schedule review determines if the schedule meets the contract
requirements; including the complete scope of the project; key milestones and constraints;
Inter-discipline coordination; key equipment & materials. The CPM schedule review will
PS.2171.12
Conyight B AACE®itornstiona
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
compare the contract requirements and the baseline CPM schedule for the complete scope of
work (inclusions/exclusions); reasonable work sequence & activity durations; adequate
procurement lead time for materials & equipment; interface of craft trades & engineering
disciplines; site access and work restrictions; impacts of weather on the project for a “seasonal
shift” in the weather. The contractor project management and project owners including the
design team management should participate in a joint schedule review to coordinate the
project schedule interfaces and improve opportunities for project success.
Contract CPM Schedule Submittal
The project scheduler is responsible for preparing and assembling the contract CPM schedule
submittal.
The CPM contract baseline schedule submittal must be complete in accordance with the
contract scheduling specifications: in the proper schedule format: CPM/Bar Chart/Time Scaled
logic graphics, etc. at the appropriate level of detail and specified activity durations; required
graphics/time scaled or graphic schedule layouts/activity listings with logical relationships;
proper use of logical links/ leads/lags and mechanical constraints; resource curves; specified
electronic (CD) format/and include a schedule narrative /basis of the schedule.
Conclusion
The contract documents provide the project participants a guide to the scope and technical
requirements for the project. Preparing the project baseline or contract schedule is a labor
intensive planning effort which requires an understanding of the scope of work, the sequence
and timing for project execution, as well as a knowledge of the technical tasks and
procurements/ deliverables. The project scheduler must have a thorough understand of the
content of these contract documents in order to successfully develop a complete and useful
project baseline schedule. The project management team must be involved in development of
the schedule and actively participate in schedule reviews throughout the contract baseline
schedule development process. Techniques such as the use of schedule fragnets and templates,
modular CPM series and extracting schedule details from similar historic projects could speed
the schedule development process. Understanding the contract documents is an important
step in reaching the objective for successful development and use of the project contract
schedule. A structured approach to reviewing that contract documentation will reduce or
eliminate the uncertainty and provide the scheduler with a better understanding for the likely
achievability and predictable of project success.
PS.2171.13
CConyight B AACE®itorastiona
This paper may not be reproduces or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International2016 AACE® INTERNATIONAL TECHNICAL PAPER
References
1. O'Leary, Arthur F., 1996, A Guide to Successful Construction, Effective Contract
Administration, Third Edition, Building News Publications, inc. (BNI), Las Angeles CA
2. Stevens, Matt, 2007, Managing a Construction Firm on Just 24 hours a day, McGraw Hill,
New York
3. Groff, Mark J. & Wickwire, Jon M. 2001, Contract Documents, Fourth Edition, Associated
Specialty Contractors, Inc., Bethesda MD
4. AACE® International Recommended Practice 38R-06, 2009, Documenting the Schedule Basis,
‘AACE® International, Morgantown WV
5. AACE® International Recommended Practice 10S-90, 2004, Cost Engineering Terminology,
AACE® International, Morgantown WV
6. Rubin, Robert A.; Fairweather, Virginia; Guy, Sammie D., 1999, Construction Claims, Third
Edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York
7. Pinnell, Steven S., 1998, How to Get Paid for Construction Changes, McGraw-Hill, New York,
New York,
8 Douglas, Edward £. Ill, 2005, Documenting the Schedule Basis, AACE® International,
Morgantown WV
9 AACE® International Recommended Practice 14R-90, 2006, Responsibility and Required
Skills for a Project Planning and Scheduling Professional, AACE® International, Morgantown
w
10. DuBois, Ron, 1982, Developing a Conceptual Schedule for a 200MW AFB Combustion Plant,
‘AACE® International, Morgantown WV
11, Stephen Goodman, 1992, “Modular CPM,” AACE® International, Morgantown WV
12. Lewis, James P., 2001, Fundamentals of Project Management, Second Edition, AMACOM,
‘American Management Association, New York
Edward E. Douglas Ill, CCP PSP FAACE
ACTPMA LLC Consulting
actpma@optonline.net
PS.2171.14
Copyright B AACE® interactional
This paper may not be reproduced or republshed without expressed written consent from AACE® International