You are on page 1of 140

Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network

Manuel Luci

Università di Pisa
1 Introduction

2 How to model brain network

3 Measures of Brain Network

4 Modularity

5 Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory

6 Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric


Disorders

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 2 / 63
Introduction

Random Network

One of the most important properties of a graph is its degree distribution.


It gives important information about its topology.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 3 / 63
Introduction

Random Network

One of the most important properties of a graph is its degree distribution.


It gives important information about its topology.
A random graph G(N, p) is a graph of N nodes where each pair of nodes
is connected by probability p. One of the most important random graph is
ER graph (Erdős–Rényi).

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 3 / 63
Introduction

ER Model properties
ER graph has a Poission degree distribution: let be < k > the avarage
degree:
< k >k e −<k>
P(k) =
k!

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 4 / 63
Introduction

ER Model properties
ER graph has a Poission degree distribution: let be < k > the avarage
degree:
< k >k e −<k>
P(k) =
k!

< k >= p(N − 1)


Let be < L >: avarage number of links in a random graph:
N(N − 1)
< L >= p
2

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 4 / 63
Introduction

ER Model properties
ER graph has a Poission degree distribution: let be < k > the avarage
degree:
< k >k e −<k>
P(k) =
k!

< k >= p(N − 1)


Let be < L >: avarage number of links in a random graph:
N(N − 1)
< L >= p
2
Let be Ci the clustering coefficient:
Ci = p

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 4 / 63
Introduction

ER Model properties
ER graph has a Poission degree distribution: let be < k > the avarage
degree:
< k >k e −<k>
P(k) =
k!

< k >= p(N − 1)


Let be < L >: avarage number of links in a random graph:
N(N − 1)
< L >= p
2
Let be Ci the clustering coefficient:
Ci = p
Let d the avarge diameter (the longest path):
log n
d=
log < k >
Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 4 / 63
Introduction ER Model

ER Model properties

Degree Distribution

17.5
15.0
12.5

#Nodes
10.0
7.5
5.0
2.5
0.0
0.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 15.0 17.5
Degree

Figure: Degree distribution of the left


Figure: An example of ER graph with
graph, we can notice a Possion
p = 0.1,N = 100
distribution shape

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 5 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Scale-Free Network

ER graphs are not a good representation of real (in our case neural)
network.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 6 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Scale-Free Network

ER graphs are not a good representation of real (in our case neural)
network.
A good model is Scale-Free one:

P(k) = Ck −γ

This model is also called Barabási–Albert (BA)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 6 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Barabási–Albert Model Properties

This model has as parameters the number of nodes N and number of links
m, with the following properties:

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 7 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Barabási–Albert Model Properties

This model has as parameters the number of nodes N and number of links
m, with the following properties:

< k >= 2m
m(ln N)2
C=
4N
ln N
d=
ln ln N

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 7 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Barabási–Albert Model Properties

Degree Distribution

101

#Nodes
100
100 101
Degree

Figure: Degree distribution of the left


Figure: An example of BA graph with
graph, we can notice a power law
m = 7,N = 100
distribution shape

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 8 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Small World

Locally brain networks show small-world property.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 9 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Small World

Locally brain networks show small-world property.


Small world phenomena is characterized by:
High clustering coefficient.
Short distances.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 9 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Small World

Locally brain networks show small-world property.


Small world phenomena is characterized by:
High clustering coefficient.
Short distances.
It is possible simulate Small-World graph using Watts-Stogatz algorithm:
1 Start with a ring lattice with N nodes in which every node is
connected to its first K neighbours

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 9 / 63
Introduction BA Model

Small World

Locally brain networks show small-world property.


Small world phenomena is characterized by:
High clustering coefficient.
Short distances.
It is possible simulate Small-World graph using Watts-Stogatz algorithm:
1 Start with a ring lattice with N nodes in which every node is
connected to its first K neighbours
2 For every edge in the network add an additional edge with
independent probability p, connecting 2 nodes selected uniformly at
random.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 9 / 63
Introduction SW Model

Small World
SW Model at different p
p=0 p=0.2

p=0.4 p=0.5

p=0.8 p=1

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 10 / 63
Introduction SW Model

Small World

Average clustering coefficient at different p


0.5

0.4

0.3
C

0.2

0.1

0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
p

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 11 / 63
How to model brain network

Application to Brain Netwrok

In the brain we have ∼ 86 bilions neurons and ∼ 150 trillion synapses.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 12 / 63
How to model brain network

Application to Brain Netwrok

In the brain we have ∼ 86 bilions neurons and ∼ 150 trillion synapses.


We can model our brain in a network at every scale: from small (neurons)
to large one (brain region).

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 12 / 63
How to model brain network

Nodes

Nodes are neurons/brain regions:


Determined by combinations of brain mappings methods, anatomical
parcellation, measures of connectivity.
Choice of combinations determine network topology
Orders not important for computation, useful for visualization

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 13 / 63
How to model brain network

Edges

Divide into 3 types:


anatomical: white matter tracts
functional: magnitude of temporal correlations(linear, non-linear)
and patterns of cross-correlations.
effective connections: pattern causal interactions (computed with
transfer entropy)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 14 / 63
How to model brain network

Edges

Type of connectivity, measure-specific, weight and directionality:


binary obtained through a threshold (chosen arbitrarily);
weight: information about straights;
anatomical: size, density, coherence;
functional: magnitude of correlational or causal interactions.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 15 / 63
How to model brain network

Measurement technique

An important measurement technique is neuroimaging technique (fMRI)


functional connectivity: positron emission tomography (PET), low
temporal resolution, significant spatial resolution, useful for neural
signal generation

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 16 / 63
How to model brain network

Measurement technique

An important measurement technique is neuroimaging technique (fMRI)


functional connectivity: positron emission tomography (PET), low
temporal resolution, significant spatial resolution, useful for neural
signal generation
changes blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 16 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Functional Connectivity

Functional Connectivity: temporal correlation between BOLD signals in


spatially remote brain region, we divided them into:

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 17 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Functional Connectivity

Functional Connectivity: temporal correlation between BOLD signals in


spatially remote brain region, we divided them into:
Model - based: Identify brain connection network selecting one or
more "seed" regions detecting linear link between them.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 17 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Functional Connectivity

Functional Connectivity: temporal correlation between BOLD signals in


spatially remote brain region, we divided them into:
Model - based: Identify brain connection network selecting one or
more "seed" regions detecting linear link between them.
Model-free: No temporal-spatial patterns, quantify random neural
interaction.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 17 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Model Based

Cross-correlation and coherence: Correlation between BOLD


signals of any 2 brain regions.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 18 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Model Based

Cross-correlation and coherence: Correlation between BOLD


signals of any 2 brain regions.
Statistical parametric mapping (SPM): Detect region-specific in
neuroimaging data as fMRI-PET, using combination of general linear
model (GLM) and Gaussian random field (GRF);

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 18 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Model-Free

Decomposition based analysis: PCA (principal component analysis)


express fMRI data with linear combination of hortogonal
conntributors have greatest impact on data variance.Eigen maps
reflect connectivity architecture of the brain.
Computational high and fail for large data, it is used for dimension
reduction.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 19 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Model-Free

Decomposition based analysis: PCA (principal component analysis)


express fMRI data with linear combination of hortogonal
conntributors have greatest impact on data variance.Eigen maps
reflect connectivity architecture of the brain.
Computational high and fail for large data, it is used for dimension
reduction.
Clustering: group regions into different clusters based on similarity
between BOLD time series.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 19 / 63
How to model brain network Functional Connectivity

Model-Free

Decomposition based analysis: PCA (principal component analysis)


express fMRI data with linear combination of hortogonal
conntributors have greatest impact on data variance.Eigen maps
reflect connectivity architecture of the brain.
Computational high and fail for large data, it is used for dimension
reduction.
Clustering: group regions into different clusters based on similarity
between BOLD time series.
Mutual informations: quantifies shared information.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 19 / 63
How to model brain network Effective Connectivity

Effective Connectivity

Assess causal interactions between neuronal units.


Also in this case we can divided in Model-Based and Model-Free.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 20 / 63
How to model brain network Effective Connectivity

Model-Based

Granger Causality (GC): X "Ganger-causes" Y if Y can be better


predicted using stories both X and Y than only Y .

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 21 / 63
How to model brain network Effective Connectivity

Model-Based

Granger Causality (GC): X "Ganger-causes" Y if Y can be better


predicted using stories both X and Y than only Y .
Dynamic causal modelling (DCM): bilinear state equation, how
variations in neural activity are affected by activation in another node.
Estimates experimental modulation of both intensive and extensive
connections

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 21 / 63
How to model brain network Effective Connectivity

Model-Free

Bayesian network (BN): Represent conditional dependencies over set


of random variables through a directed acyclic graph
Edges: dependency between 2 variable;
Nodes have probability distribution, root has prior probability, child has
conditional one

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 22 / 63
How to model brain network Effective Connectivity

Model-Free

Bayesian network (BN): Represent conditional dependencies over set


of random variables through a directed acyclic graph
Edges: dependency between 2 variable;
Nodes have probability distribution, root has prior probability, child has
conditional one
Transfer entropy (TE): measuring transfer of information between
joint processing

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 22 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

1 Slice timing correction, realignment, image co-registration,


normalization based on segmentation, and spatial smoothing, are
performed on the acquired fMRI data.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 23 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

1 Slice timing correction, realignment, image co-registration,


normalization based on segmentation, and spatial smoothing, are
performed on the acquired fMRI data.
2 Parcellation scheme to divide brain into serial cortical and subcortical
anatomical units.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 23 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

1 Slice timing correction, realignment, image co-registration,


normalization based on segmentation, and spatial smoothing, are
performed on the acquired fMRI data.
2 Parcellation scheme to divide brain into serial cortical and subcortical
anatomical units.
3 Determine pairwise associations between the times series of brain
parcels, representing the functional connectivity network (Correlation
matrix).

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 23 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

1 Slice timing correction, realignment, image co-registration,


normalization based on segmentation, and spatial smoothing, are
performed on the acquired fMRI data.
2 Parcellation scheme to divide brain into serial cortical and subcortical
anatomical units.
3 Determine pairwise associations between the times series of brain
parcels, representing the functional connectivity network (Correlation
matrix).
4 Obtain binary connectivity by threshold values of correlation matrix.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 23 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

1 Slice timing correction, realignment, image co-registration,


normalization based on segmentation, and spatial smoothing, are
performed on the acquired fMRI data.
2 Parcellation scheme to divide brain into serial cortical and subcortical
anatomical units.
3 Determine pairwise associations between the times series of brain
parcels, representing the functional connectivity network (Correlation
matrix).
4 Obtain binary connectivity by threshold values of correlation matrix.
5 Obatin topological properties.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 23 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 24 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 25 / 63
How to model brain network Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Construction of Fuctional Brain Network using fMRI

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 26 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Segregation

Functional Segregation

Ability for specialized processing to occur within densely interconnected


groups of brain regions.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 27 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Segregation

Functional Segregation

Ability for specialized processing to occur within densely interconnected


groups of brain regions.
Measure segregation: Presence of cluster or modules, straight froward
interpreations in anatomical and functional network.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 27 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Segregation

Functional Segregation

Ability for specialized processing to occur within densely interconnected


groups of brain regions.
Measure segregation: Presence of cluster or modules, straight froward
interpreations in anatomical and functional network.
Cluster in anatomical networks: suggests potential for functional
segregations in these networks.
Cluster in functional networks: suggests an organization of statistical
dependencies indicative of segregated neural processing.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 27 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Segregation

Functional Segregation

Some measures of them are:


Clustering coefficient:
1X 2ti
Ci =
n i∈N ki (ki − 1)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 28 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Segregation

Functional Segregation

Some measures of them are:


Clustering coefficient:
1X 2ti
Ci =
n i∈N ki (ki − 1)

Modular structure: subdividing networks into groups of nodes,


maximally number within group link, minimally number between
group:  
 2
X X
Q= euv −  euv  

u∈M v ∈M

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 28 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Integration

Functional Integration

Ability to rapidly combine specialized information from distributed brain


regions.
Estimate how ease brain ragions communicate.
It is commonly based on the concept of a path.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 29 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Integration

Functional Integration

Ability to rapidly combine specialized information from distributed brain


regions.
Estimate how ease brain ragions communicate.
It is commonly based on the concept of a path.
Path anatomical: potential routes of information flow, shorter path →
stronger potential for integration.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 29 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Integration

Functional Integration

Ability to rapidly combine specialized information from distributed brain


regions.
Estimate how ease brain ragions communicate.
It is commonly based on the concept of a path.
Path anatomical: potential routes of information flow, shorter path →
stronger potential for integration.
Path functional: sequences of statistical associations and may not be
correspond to information flow on anatomical connections. Less
straightforward to interpret.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 29 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Functional Integration

Functional Integration

Some measures of them are:


The average shortest path (Characteristic path lengh):
P
1X j∈N,j6=i dij
L=
n i∈N n−1

Global efficiency:
dij−1
P
1X j∈N,j6=i
E=
n i∈N n−1

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 30 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Small World

Why Small World

Some studies proved as small world property is the most efficient way to
combine segregation and integration with low energy and wiring cost.
Brain networks in fact show the combination of functionally specialized
modules and robust number intermodular links.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 31 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Small World

Why Small World

Some studies proved as small world property is the most efficient way to
combine segregation and integration with low energy and wiring cost.
Brain networks in fact show the combination of functionally specialized
modules and robust number intermodular links.

Small-World networks should be simultaneously highly segregated and


integrated.
Anatomical and effective networks are simultaneously highly segregated
and integrated, so they have a small-world topologies

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 31 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Small World

Why Small World

Some studies proved as small world property is the most efficient way to
combine segregation and integration with low energy and wiring cost.
Brain networks in fact show the combination of functionally specialized
modules and robust number intermodular links.

Small-World networks should be simultaneously highly segregated and


integrated.
Anatomical and effective networks are simultaneously highly segregated
and integrated, so they have a small-world topologies

The functional networks are also highly segregated but have a lower global
efficiency, so that a weaker small-world attributes.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 31 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Small World

Small World

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 32 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Small World

Small World

As seen small world properties have a higher cluster coefficient than


random graph, but path length are almost the same.
A measure of small-worldness is:
C /Crand
S=
L/Lrand

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 33 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Global measures of integration and segregation belie a rich repertoire of


underlying local patterns of connectivity.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 34 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Global measures of integration and segregation belie a rich repertoire of


underlying local patterns of connectivity.
Anatomical triangles may consist in
feedforward loops;
feedback loops;
bidirectional loops.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 34 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Global measures of integration and segregation belie a rich repertoire of


underlying local patterns of connectivity.
Anatomical triangles may consist in
feedforward loops;
feedback loops;
bidirectional loops.
These patterns of local connectivity are known as motifs.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 34 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Global measures of integration and segregation belie a rich repertoire of


underlying local patterns of connectivity.
Anatomical triangles may consist in
feedforward loops;
feedback loops;
bidirectional loops.
These patterns of local connectivity are known as motifs.
The frequency of occurence of different motifs around an individual node
is known as the motif fingerprint.
It reflects the functional role of the corrisponding brain region.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 34 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Fuctional motifs are defined as possible subsets of connection patterns,


embedded within anatomical motifs.
Some measures of them are:

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 35 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Fuctional motifs are defined as possible subsets of connection patterns,


embedded within anatomical motifs.
Some measures of them are:
Motif z-score:
Jh − < Jrand,h >
zh =
σJrand,h

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 35 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Network Motifs

Network Motifs

Fuctional motifs are defined as possible subsets of connection patterns,


embedded within anatomical motifs.
Some measures of them are:
Motif z-score:
Jh − < Jrand,h >
zh =
σJrand,h

Motif fingerprint:
Fnh (h0 ) =
X
Jh0 ,i
i∈N

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 35 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality

Centrality is one of the most important measure and concept of Network


Analysis.
We mean not only spatial one, but also functional centrality.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 36 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality

Centrality is one of the most important measure and concept of Network


Analysis.
We mean not only spatial one, but also functional centrality.

Regions most central (called hubs) interact with many regions and they
play a key role in network resilience.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 36 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality

Centrality is one of the most important measure and concept of Network


Analysis.
We mean not only spatial one, but also functional centrality.

Regions most central (called hubs) interact with many regions and they
play a key role in network resilience.
Motifs and resilience are used to detect central brain region.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 36 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality
Some measures of centrality are:
Degree centrality: X
ki = aij
j∈N

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 37 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality
Some measures of centrality are:
Degree centrality: X
ki = aij
j∈N

Participation coefficient:
X  ki (m) 2
yi = 1 −
m∈M
ki

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 37 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality
Some measures of centrality are:
Degree centrality: X
ki = aij
j∈N

Participation coefficient:
X  ki (m) 2
yi = 1 −
m∈M
ki

Within-module degree z-score:


ki (mi ) − k̄(mi )
zi =
σk(mi )

nodes with this values higher but with lower participation coefficient
are called provincial, important for segregation.
high participation coefficient are likely to facilitate global integration.
Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 37 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measures of Centrality

Measures of Centrality

Closeness Centrality:
n−1
CC (i) = P
j∈N,j6=i dij

Betweenness Centrality:

1 X ρhj (i)
BC (i) =
(n − 1)(n − 2) h,j∈N
ρhj
h6=j,h6=i,j6=i

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 38 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measure of Network Resilience

Measure of Netwrok Resilience

Understand the resilience of neural network is useful to protect and heal it


from lesions and diseases.
A first indirect measures of resilience is the degree distribution: local
power-law distribution are resilient to random deterioration, but
highly vulnerable to target attack.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 39 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measure of Network Resilience

Measure of Netwrok Resilience

Understand the resilience of neural network is useful to protect and heal it


from lesions and diseases.
A first indirect measures of resilience is the degree distribution: local
power-law distribution are resilient to random deterioration, but
highly vulnerable to target attack.
Assortativity coefficient: is correlation coefficient between the degress
of all nodes on two opposite end of a link:
positive: likely to have a comparatively resilient core of mutually
interconnected hig-degree hubs.
negative: widely distributed and consequently vulnerable high-degree
hubs

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 39 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measure of Network Resilience

Measure of Network Resilience

Average neighbour degree:


P
j∈N aij kj
knn (i) =
ki

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 40 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measure of Network Resilience

Measure of Network Resilience

Average neighbour degree:


P
j∈N aij kj
knn (i) =
ki

Assortative Coefficient:

P P
i eii ai b i
r= P i
1− i ai bi

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 40 / 63
Measures of Brain Network Measure of Network Resilience

Measure of Network Resilience

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 41 / 63
Modularity

Modules

Modules in brain are called also communities.


Modular system tends to be small-world network.
We can portion module into sub-modules and so on

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 42 / 63
Modularity Why Modular?

Why Modular?

Modular can evolve by changing in one module at time, without


risking to lose function.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 43 / 63
Modularity Why Modular?

Why Modular?

Modular can evolve by changing in one module at time, without


risking to lose function.
Advantage for system to evolve under changing on competitive
selection.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 43 / 63
Modularity Why Modular?

Why Modular?

Modular can evolve by changing in one module at time, without


risking to lose function.
Advantage for system to evolve under changing on competitive
selection.
System with hierarchically modular will be more rapidly and robustly
assembled.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 43 / 63
Modularity Why Modular?

Why Modular?

Modular can evolve by changing in one module at time, without


risking to lose function.
Advantage for system to evolve under changing on competitive
selection.
System with hierarchically modular will be more rapidly and robustly
assembled.
Modular networks have small-worldness property.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 43 / 63
Modularity Why Modular?

Why Modular?

Modular can evolve by changing in one module at time, without


risking to lose function.
Advantage for system to evolve under changing on competitive
selection.
System with hierarchically modular will be more rapidly and robustly
assembled.
Modular networks have small-worldness property.
Modular network topology associated with rich non-linear dynamical
behaviour due to coexistance of segregated and integrated activity

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 43 / 63
Modularity Why Modular?

Why Modular?

Modular can evolve by changing in one module at time, without


risking to lose function.
Advantage for system to evolve under changing on competitive
selection.
System with hierarchically modular will be more rapidly and robustly
assembled.
Modular networks have small-worldness property.
Modular network topology associated with rich non-linear dynamical
behaviour due to coexistance of segregated and integrated activity
Modular process are viewed in color vision (anatomically localized)
and in working memory, demand acess more globally integrated
processing system.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 43 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Anatomical Brain

Modularity Anatomical Brain

We can identify 4 sub-netwotks used a modularity metric to quantify the


optimality of this partitions:
visual
auditory
somatosensorimotor
frontolimbic

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 44 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Anatomical Brain

Modularity Anatomical Brain

We can identify 4 sub-netwotks used a modularity metric to quantify the


optimality of this partitions:
visual
auditory
somatosensorimotor
frontolimbic
Using correlations between thickness of gray matter in different cortical
regions, we find:
visual
auditory/language
central (somatosensorimotor)
superior parietal modules

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 44 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Modularity in Functional Brain

We can report:
Posterior (occipital) and central (sensorimotor) modules
Defualt-mode module:
precuneus
cingulate
medial prefontal cortex

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 45 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Modularity in Functional Brain

We can report:
Posterior (occipital) and central (sensorimotor) modules
Defualt-mode module:
precuneus
cingulate
medial prefontal cortex
This modular organization is similar at a finer grain, including visual,
central-auditory, default-mode and subcortical modules.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 45 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Modularity in Functional Brain

We can report:
Posterior (occipital) and central (sensorimotor) modules
Defualt-mode module:
precuneus
cingulate
medial prefontal cortex
This modular organization is similar at a finer grain, including visual,
central-auditory, default-mode and subcortical modules.
Applying different thresholds to define binary graphs from a
continuous association matrix, it’s possible to show that as long as
the resulting networks are spare, the similarity between modular
decompositions were almost the same.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 45 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Modularity in Functional Brain

Most connector nodes are located at junctions between anatomically


segregated cortices(occipito-parietal, occipito-temporal,
parieto-central, and fronto-central junctions) and are often in regions
of multimodal association cortex, whereas the provincial hubs are
located within functionally specialized areas of cortex (primary or
unimodal association areas).

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 46 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Modularity in Functional Brain

100 100

200 200

300 300

400 400

500 500

600 600

100 200 300 400 500 600 100 200 300 400 500 600

Figure: Large scale cortical Figure: Large scale cortical


connectivity,nodes represent cortical connectivity,nodes represent cortical
areas and links represent large areas and links represent large
corticocortical tracts or functional corticocortical tracts or functional
associations, no threshold applied associations, threshold applied

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 47 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Modularity in Functional Brain

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 48 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Hierarchical Modularity in Brain Network

Highest level fewer and larger modules:


occipital
central
default-mode

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 49 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Hierarchical Modularity in Brain Network

Highest level fewer and larger modules:


occipital
central
default-mode
Lower: decomposed into sub-modules, for example central module
can be decomposed into lateral and medial.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 49 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Hierarchical Modularity in Brain Network

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 50 / 63
Modularity Modularity in Functional Brain

Hierarchical Modularity in Brain Network

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 51 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Human Intelligence

Human Intelligence
Importance of interaction between frontal and parietal areas.
Better intellectual performance are associated with a shorter path lenght
and the nodal centrality of hub regions in the salience network.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 52 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Human Intelligence

Human Intelligence
Importance of interaction between frontal and parietal areas.
Better intellectual performance are associated with a shorter path lenght
and the nodal centrality of hub regions in the salience network.
Intelligence quotient is positive correlated with nodal properties in the
attention-related network and is negatively correlated with nodal properties
in the default mode, emotion and language system.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 52 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Human Intelligence

Human Intelligence
Importance of interaction between frontal and parietal areas.
Better intellectual performance are associated with a shorter path lenght
and the nodal centrality of hub regions in the salience network.
Intelligence quotient is positive correlated with nodal properties in the
attention-related network and is negatively correlated with nodal properties
in the default mode, emotion and language system.
General intelligence is profoundly affected by the functional integration of
spatially distributed regions, they could not provide sufficient information
as to whether and how human intellectual performance is associated with
the brain’s modular architecture.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 52 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Human Intelligence

Human Intelligence
Importance of interaction between frontal and parietal areas.
Better intellectual performance are associated with a shorter path lenght
and the nodal centrality of hub regions in the salience network.
Intelligence quotient is positive correlated with nodal properties in the
attention-related network and is negatively correlated with nodal properties
in the default mode, emotion and language system.
General intelligence is profoundly affected by the functional integration of
spatially distributed regions, they could not provide sufficient information
as to whether and how human intellectual performance is associated with
the brain’s modular architecture.
Intelligence involves the nodal characteristics of functional connectivity
within and between different brain modules (especially in the parietal and
frontal areas), not global modularity properties or whole-brain ratios of
distinct node types.
Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 52 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Topological Changes Across the Lifespan

Topological Changes Across the Lifespan

Local efficiency and rich club coefficient were incremental until earlier
adulthood to drop with ageing, while global efficiency remain almost
unchanged (only in early years after birth).

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 53 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Topological Changes Across the Lifespan

Topological Changes Across the Lifespan

Local efficiency and rich club coefficient were incremental until earlier
adulthood to drop with ageing, while global efficiency remain almost
unchanged (only in early years after birth).
We can indentify changes in the number and strength of connections that
were created to achieve an optimal balance between the wiring costs and
communication efficiency over the lifespan.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 53 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Working Memory Performance

Working Memory Performance

Temporary storage and manipulation of the informations required to


perform intricate cognitive tasks such as reasoning and decision-making.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 54 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Working Memory Performance

Working Memory Performance

Temporary storage and manipulation of the informations required to


perform intricate cognitive tasks such as reasoning and decision-making.
Increasing global efficiency has been correlated with high functionality in
young adults but with a slight deficiency in older adults.
Right intraparietal sulcus is the area responsive to manipulations of
working memory load, in fact the centrality measures in this region
correlate inversely with working memory capacity.
From studying in action video-games, active learning affects the
integration of working memory (central executive) and attention-related
(salience) neural network.
Advanced player enhance the functional integration within and between
working memory and attention system.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 54 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Role of Default Mode Network in Behavioral Performance

Role of Default Mode Network in Behavioral Performance

Comparing brain topological alteration during cognitive task using fMRI


data, we can identify areas affected by human behavioural performance.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 55 / 63
Cognitive and Behavioural applications of Graph Theory Role of Default Mode Network in Behavioral Performance

Role of Default Mode Network in Behavioral Performance

Comparing brain topological alteration during cognitive task using fMRI


data, we can identify areas affected by human behavioural performance.
We can observe differences associated with language-related and
DMN (Default Mode Networks).
Greater intra-modular communication during decision making.
Reduction in modularity (increasing integration efficiency) before misses
compared with hits and task-free rest.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 55 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Epilepsy

Epilepsy

Chronic neurological disorder, accompained by aberrations in brain activity.


Most often: Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 56 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Epilepsy

Epilepsy

Chronic neurological disorder, accompained by aberrations in brain activity.


Most often: Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)
Network analysis showed contribution of basal ganglia thalamocortical
circuity to whole brain functional connectivity in TLE.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 56 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Epilepsy

Epilepsy

Chronic neurological disorder, accompained by aberrations in brain activity.


Most often: Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)
Network analysis showed contribution of basal ganglia thalamocortical
circuity to whole brain functional connectivity in TLE.
In patients with TLE we can find a disruption of Small-world
properties both in segregation and global integration.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 56 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Epilepsy

Epilepsy

Chronic neurological disorder, accompained by aberrations in brain activity.


Most often: Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)
Network analysis showed contribution of basal ganglia thalamocortical
circuity to whole brain functional connectivity in TLE.
In patients with TLE we can find a disruption of Small-world
properties both in segregation and global integration.
Localization related epilepsy leads to cognitive impairments by
inducing global changes in the brain network instead of a localized
disruption only.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 56 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Epilepsy

Epilepsy

Chronic neurological disorder, accompained by aberrations in brain activity.


Most often: Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)
Network analysis showed contribution of basal ganglia thalamocortical
circuity to whole brain functional connectivity in TLE.
In patients with TLE we can find a disruption of Small-world
properties both in segregation and global integration.
Localization related epilepsy leads to cognitive impairments by
inducing global changes in the brain network instead of a localized
disruption only.
Childhood Absence Epilepsy (CAE) hub nodes inside DMN and
thalamus are damaged, topological alterations in basal ganglia and
limbic system.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 56 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Alzheimer’s Diseas

AD

Chronic and progressive neurodegenerative disorder, leads to deficit in


memory and cognitive brain functions.
Cognitive decline due to aging: Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI).
Exhibited degeneration specific brain hubs, reducing clustering
coefficient and path lengths close to vales of random netwrok.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 57 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Alzheimer’s Diseas

AD

Chronic and progressive neurodegenerative disorder, leads to deficit in


memory and cognitive brain functions.
Cognitive decline due to aging: Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI).
Exhibited degeneration specific brain hubs, reducing clustering
coefficient and path lengths close to vales of random netwrok.
Global decrease in long-distance functional connections(frontal and
caudal brain regions)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 57 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Alzheimer’s Diseas

AD

Chronic and progressive neurodegenerative disorder, leads to deficit in


memory and cognitive brain functions.
Cognitive decline due to aging: Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI).
Exhibited degeneration specific brain hubs, reducing clustering
coefficient and path lengths close to vales of random netwrok.
Global decrease in long-distance functional connections(frontal and
caudal brain regions)
Degeneration and randomization, loss global information integration.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 57 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Multiple Sclerosis

MS

Chronic, degenerative, heterogeneous autoimmune disease of central


nervous system.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 58 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Multiple Sclerosis

MS

Chronic, degenerative, heterogeneous autoimmune disease of central


nervous system.
Sorted brain region based on connectivity patterns using eigenvector
centrality mapping (ECM)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 58 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Multiple Sclerosis

MS

Chronic, degenerative, heterogeneous autoimmune disease of central


nervous system.
Sorted brain region based on connectivity patterns using eigenvector
centrality mapping (ECM)
MS-related differences for centrality in specific regions. decreased
ECM values in sensorimotor and ventral stream areas were associated
with clinical disability.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 58 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Multiple Sclerosis

MS

Chronic, degenerative, heterogeneous autoimmune disease of central


nervous system.
Sorted brain region based on connectivity patterns using eigenvector
centrality mapping (ECM)
MS-related differences for centrality in specific regions. decreased
ECM values in sensorimotor and ventral stream areas were associated
with clinical disability.
Increasing in thalamus and posterior cingulate, highet connectivity to
regions with low centrality.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 58 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Multiple Sclerosis

MS

Chronic, degenerative, heterogeneous autoimmune disease of central


nervous system.
Sorted brain region based on connectivity patterns using eigenvector
centrality mapping (ECM)
MS-related differences for centrality in specific regions. decreased
ECM values in sensorimotor and ventral stream areas were associated
with clinical disability.
Increasing in thalamus and posterior cingulate, highet connectivity to
regions with low centrality.
Occipital, sensorimotor, hippocampal centrality less than healthy one.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 58 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Autism Spectrum Disorder

ASD

Complex neurodevelopmental disability characterized by difficulties in


communication and behavior:

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 59 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Autism Spectrum Disorder

ASD

Complex neurodevelopmental disability characterized by difficulties in


communication and behavior:
Modularity, clustering coefficient local efficency redyced in ASD;

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 59 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Autism Spectrum Disorder

ASD

Complex neurodevelopmental disability characterized by difficulties in


communication and behavior:
Modularity, clustering coefficient local efficency redyced in ASD;
Global communication efficiency increased (shorter average path
lengths);

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 59 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Autism Spectrum Disorder

ASD

Complex neurodevelopmental disability characterized by difficulties in


communication and behavior:
Modularity, clustering coefficient local efficency redyced in ASD;
Global communication efficiency increased (shorter average path
lengths);
Increasing betweenness centrality and local connections by analyzing
the prefrontal brain areas;

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 59 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Autism Spectrum Disorder

ASD

Complex neurodevelopmental disability characterized by difficulties in


communication and behavior:
Modularity, clustering coefficient local efficency redyced in ASD;
Global communication efficiency increased (shorter average path
lengths);
Increasing betweenness centrality and local connections by analyzing
the prefrontal brain areas;
Changin in structure of hub nodes.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 59 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Attention-Deficit/Hyperactiity Disorder

ADHD

No changing in small-world behaviour.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 60 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Attention-Deficit/Hyperactiity Disorder

ADHD

No changing in small-world behaviour.


Brain network more regular configurations with higher local efficiency
and trend toward decreased global efficiency.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 60 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Attention-Deficit/Hyperactiity Disorder

ADHD

No changing in small-world behaviour.


Brain network more regular configurations with higher local efficiency
and trend toward decreased global efficiency.
Nodal properties in medial prefrontal, temporal, and occipital cortices
experienced regional loss of efficiency. while an increased nodal
efficiency was found in the inferior frontal gyrus.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 60 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Attention-Deficit/Hyperactiity Disorder

ADHD

No changing in small-world behaviour.


Brain network more regular configurations with higher local efficiency
and trend toward decreased global efficiency.
Nodal properties in medial prefrontal, temporal, and occipital cortices
experienced regional loss of efficiency. while an increased nodal
efficiency was found in the inferior frontal gyrus.
Decreased anterior-posterior connectivity.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 60 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Attention-Deficit/Hyperactiity Disorder

ADHD

No changing in small-world behaviour.


Brain network more regular configurations with higher local efficiency
and trend toward decreased global efficiency.
Nodal properties in medial prefrontal, temporal, and occipital cortices
experienced regional loss of efficiency. while an increased nodal
efficiency was found in the inferior frontal gyrus.
Decreased anterior-posterior connectivity.
Weaker interconnectivity in DMN, dorsal attention network and
cerebellum.

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 60 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Attention-Deficit/Hyperactiity Disorder

ADHD

No changing in small-world behaviour.


Brain network more regular configurations with higher local efficiency
and trend toward decreased global efficiency.
Nodal properties in medial prefrontal, temporal, and occipital cortices
experienced regional loss of efficiency. while an increased nodal
efficiency was found in the inferior frontal gyrus.
Decreased anterior-posterior connectivity.
Weaker interconnectivity in DMN, dorsal attention network and
cerebellum.
Stronger short-range connectivity within reward network (ventral
striatum and orbitofrontal cortex).

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 60 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Schizophrenia

Schizophrenia

Economical small-world properties of low-frequency are impaired;

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 61 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Schizophrenia

Schizophrenia

Economical small-world properties of low-frequency are impaired;


Clustering and path-lenght closer to random graph;

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 61 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Schizophrenia

Schizophrenia

Economical small-world properties of low-frequency are impaired;


Clustering and path-lenght closer to random graph;
Reduced hierarchy of multimodal cortex;

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 61 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Schizophrenia

Schizophrenia

Economical small-world properties of low-frequency are impaired;


Clustering and path-lenght closer to random graph;
Reduced hierarchy of multimodal cortex;
Long physical distance between connected regions, compatible with
inefficient axonal wiring

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 61 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Schizophrenia

Schizophrenia

Displaying network 1 of 1 Displaying network 1 of 1


p-value: 0.046 p-value: 0.050
Number of edges: 60 Number of edges: 26
Number of nodes: 32 Number of nodes: 20
Click on a node or edge... Click on a node or edge...
Parietal_Inf_R

Figure: Neural Network of a Figure: Neural Network of a


Schizophrenia patient. For this Schizophrenia patient. For this
simulation I choose a threshold of 2.9. simulation I choose a threshold of 3.2.
This simulation has been obtained using This simulation has been obtained using
NBS NBS
Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 62 / 63
Disorganization of Brain Networks in Neurological and Psychiatric
Disorders Schizophrenia

Bibliography

Application of Graph Theory for Identifying Connectivity Patterns in


Human Brain (F. Farahani, W. Karwowki, N. Lightall)
Comparing Brain Networks of Different Size and Connectivity Density
Using graph Theory (B, van Wijk, C. Stam, A. Daffertshofer)
Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and
functional system (E. Bullmore, O. Sporns)
Complex netwrok measures of brain connectivity: Uses and
interpretations (M. Rubinov, O. Sporns)
Modular and hierarchically modular organization of brain networks (D.
Meunier. R. Lambiotte, E. Bullmore)
Network Science (A.Barabasi)

Manuel Luci (Università di Pisa) Graph and Network Analysis Applied to Neural Network 63 / 63

You might also like