Professional Documents
Culture Documents
March 2022
Young renters join Mecanoo’s Kampus
£15/€30/US$35
Profile: Adam Khan Architects
ribaj.com
Activate your RIBA membership 03
or RIBAJ subscription for full
access to ribaj.com
RICHARD CHIVERS
MIKHAIL RICHES
LEWIS KHAN
Picture postcard Studios Q&A Sustainability Photograph Review
07 16 39 51 61 72
A glimpse of history Community input Stuart Coleman of Suppliers are key to How Jack Young saw Owen Hatherley’s
in the making at informed The Hithe, Coleman Anderson responsible design – Holmefield House swashbuckling tour of
Fredrikstad in IF_DO’s demountable on why the how do you manage upstage Trellick Tower modern buildings
Norway office scheme for practice is backing that?
meanwhile use apprenticeships President Review
House Architects’ 63 74
08 Housing Housebuilding account We’re busy – come An insight into the
RX Architects’ 22 40 56 and join in, says Simon pivotal part windows
house on the beach at Apparata’s A House Mikhail Riches and One architect’s Allford play in Japanese design
Camber Sands keeps for Artists lays out its BDP are helping York account of the
the elements at bay philosophy for living council build target thinking and making Opinion Future writers
600 homes of an infill house in 65 77
Museum Kampus, Hackney, east London Will Wiles probes the Write a piece on your
12 Manchester Sustainability myth of the tyrannical burning issue and
HAT Projects 28 46 architect we’ll publish it
breaks the fetters Mecanoo and shedkm Client discussion
of Ely Museum’s have transformed a tackles the difficulties Eye Line Obituary
site with a sensitive former university site of achieving 67 79
refurbishment into a verdant housing sustainable buildings Our annual drawing Creative engineer
scheme competition, Eye Line, Max Fordham, whose
is open for entries inquiring mind knew
no boundaries
Profile
Dropping in something like this could make 68
Building users rather
Letters
81
life decent and take away some of the pain than critics are what Home, beauty, bricks
motivateAdam Khan
On the cover from the situation of shared bathrooms Architects’ designs Parting shot
RX Architects’ house
at Camber Sands,
and bunks and other awful conditions 82
Stephen Cousins on Curl la Tourelle Head’s Ralph Deakin’s 1930s
photographed by pop-up refugee shelters: ribaj.com/refugee- photograph of the
Richard Chivers shelters Cathedral of Syracuse
Average issue
circulation Live/work, responsible design, refurbishments, meanwhile use and
25,160
FREE COLOUR CARDS & WALLPAPER SAMPLES | PAINT & WALLPAPER TO ORDER ABC audited June 2021 design in the making: what’s your view? letters.ribaj@riba.org
Nationwide Stockists | paintandpaperlibrary.com | +44 (0) 161 230 0882 | info@paintandpaperlibrary.com RIBA Journal is published 12 times a year by the RIBA. The contents of this journal are copyright. Reproduction in part or in full is forbidden without permission of the editor. The opinions expressed by writers of signed articles
(even with pseudonyms) and letters appearing in the magazine are those of their respective authors; the RIBA and the RIBAJ are not responsible for these opinions or statements. The editor will give careful consideration to material
submitted – articles, photographs, drawings and so on – but does not undertake responsibility for damage or their safe return. ISSN 1463-9505 © RIBA 2021
NYGAARDSPLASSEN,
FREDRIKSTAD, NORWAY
MAD ARKITEKTER
Read the full story:
ribaj.com/fredrikstad
KYRRE SUNDAL
the passage feels like being drawn into a huge warm em-
brace, free and encouraged to linger and mingle. •
Marianne Lie Berg
Elementary
1 Entrance porch 9 Plant room
IN NUMBERS Organise a visit to RX Architects’ latest pro- Ground floor plan
2 Hallway 10 Beach terrace
ject, Seabreeze, in Camber, East Sussex, and
178 m² you won’t be sent a conventional address
3 Boot room 11 Existing sand dune
design
4 Kitchen 12 Void
gia
with a number and a street name. Rather, the 5 Living/dining area 13 Master bedroom
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
10 Buildings
House
For thrii-thinkers
bedroom there are deep recessed bunks for
Master bedroom with
Lusso Stone free-
additional guests, while the master bedroom
standing bath, which has a free-standing bath with its own small
required steelwork in operable window and a fixed skylight to gaze
in washroom
the structure around up at the stars. The bed is surprisingly orien-
that corner.
tated at 45º to the view – and why not?
Remarkably, construction that had been
carefully scheduled to follow the bird migrat-
ing season ended up starting two days before
design
the national coronavirus lockdown in March
2020. There was a brief hiatus but ultimately
building work was eased because beach was
closed to the public, making access consid-
erably less busy than usual. For the clients
though, stuck in France, the whole project
was constructed remotely, with sample sign-
offs on Zoom. They saw it for the first time
only after it completed (‘a nervous moment’).
It was fortuitous then that RX Architects
is local. Indeed, the practice is now working
on other beach houses with a similar situa-
tion and already has six projects in each of the
four bays around Rye where its office is based
– one for a client in Costa Rica. This work
Credits house and its right-hand neighbour above has, of course, been bolstered by the pandem-
Architect RX Architects the entrance and lines the recessed porch. It ic and people wanting holiday homes on the
Contractor Coast View
Properties matches the timber of the decking and helps coast or to move out of cities, but it is becom-
Micro-fibre cement soften the seriousness too. ing almost coyly characteristic of a changing
Ideal Works Inside, the ground floor is characterised seaside – although Seabreeze possibly sets
Below The smoked Joinery Chartwood
Design by a pleasant sensible riot of texture and an more interesting new direction. Soon it
eucalyptus front kitchen;
M&E Baltic Heating materials. The floor and upstands are a ter- might be questioned in jest which came first;
the textured ceilings and
Kitchen Portrait Kitchens razzo tile that again helps to disguise sand the practice or the marine co-ordinates of the
walls are created using Tiles Mandarin Stone
Bauwerk lime paint. Sanitaryware Vado brought in from the beach. The kitchen is bay it is named after. •
made from fumed eucalyptus with a con-
crete-like quartz worktop also used for the View through the
hall to boot room,
dramatic heath in the sitting area. A bespoke
the void connecting
lightly smoked oak dining table, matching the galleried
pocket doors and other fitted joinery are landing above.
designed to mimic the engineered wood
flooring used on the stair treads, balustrade
and feature wall behind it – it is deliberate-
ly chunky and robust in keeping with the
solidity elsewhere. In the spa to the back of
the footprint the mood changes again; darker Introducing the new 3-in-1 washroom tap. Delivering soap,
with grey porcelain floor tiles, a sunken hot water and air touch-free from one source, the deck-mounted
tub, micro-cement walls and only a high-up
horizontal slot window for daylight. There is ThriiTap+ is the smarter way to design hygienic washrooms.
also a cloakroom, utility and boot room, but
the main focus is on the views from the living
room onto the beach, where at high tide the
sea is almost lapping at one’s toes.
Upstairs materials are pared back. The
panelled engineered oak stairwell feature
wall continues in the bedrooms and on the
floor, as does the bespoke smoked joinery.
Volumes extend to the rafters and in the rear thriitap.com
+44 (0) 1722 744 594
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com
12 Buildings Buildings 13
Xxxxxxx Museum
Penal reform
This image A sizeable Section A-A 1 Felons’ Yard IN NUMBERS
extension to the city’s 2 Pre-drainage Fenland
former gaol blends into
3
history
Post-drainage Fenland
532m²
the streetscape. gia
HAT Projes’ refurbished and extended museum in Ely’s 17th
history
Bottom The approach to
617m²
4 Gaol cell
the museum from Market
century gaol tells tales of the pa while doing community service Street. The old ‘Felons’ 3
5
6
New oak stair
New extension stair
gross area
Yard’ is beyond the
Words: Jan-Carlos Kucharek Photographs: Philip Vile 7
£1.01m
Kitchen area to
threshold. community room
.
Section B-B
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
14 Buildings 15
Museum
5
9 10
A A
8
6 7
3
4
2
1
cladding a timber structure in solid brick but Above A former rat run 1 Felons’ Yard
archy. Its new gable end is of reclaimed gault 5 New oak stair 14
Below The new entrance
brick; a sizeable window on the right winking creates space for school 6 Hall to staff and accessible
WC 11
at city-bound traffic. HAT’s Hana Loftus says groups to gather. To the
7 Staff kitchen
13
right, found planks from
they considered copper for the large bay win- 8 Lift
the gaol line the wall.
dow but felt the material detailing distracted 9 Staff area 16
from the simplicity of intent. Instead, they Credits 10 Exhibit storage
Client Ely Museum 11 Post-drainage Fenland
chose a matt-finish, russet-toned aluminium, history
Architect/ CDM co-
the vertical bays intimating Romanesque ordinator HAT Projects 12 Gaol cell
clusters of columns found on the cathedral. Structural engineer 13 Knowledge hub windows were replaced with double-glazed Hughes, but it’s a serious point: it all helps em- Top left The new oak Above Looking south in
Momentum Engineering staircase installed at the the new pitched, rooflit
Approaching from Market Street, the 14 Hall to WCs equivalents. The firm worked with Max bed the building in the community.
M&E consultant Max 15 Aedwen community room north end of the old gaol. extension. The gaol’s
corner entrance takes you into Felons’ Yard, Fordham Fordham who, says Loftus, went above and So, a simple building charged with the old wall carries marks of
16 Temporary exhibitions
where the gaol’s wall bears the marks of QS Gleeds beyond to specify the MVHR and keep ser- important task of creating a sense of place for Above left The stair’s previous interventions.
centuries of modification, odd brick infills Exhibition design Simon vices interventions discreet. The brick skin this small city, steeped in history of its own, double height allows
Leach Design exhibits such as 12’ long Below A reconstructed
cheek-by-jowl with pretty but super-soft Main contractor RG was made fully breathable too, re-pointed in resisting the appellation of being a dormitory
fen spades to be better gaol cell for 20 prisoners
local clunch stone. HAT’s new entrance area, Carters First floor plan lime mortar externally, with porous finishes town for Cambridge. And the case of a moti-
displayed. shows original graffi ti cut
replacing a uselessly small lean-to, finally al- and clay paint used internally. vated architect which embedded itself in the into the found planks.
lows space in the museum for groups to gather Hughes’ favourite part of the museum project from its genesis, guiding a green client
before starting a tour. Clad in copper and oak is the oak stair swooshing visitors graceful- through the process. It’s clear this was a la-
boards, it initially appeared on the physical ly from the pre-drainage fen history up to bour of love. Loftus sums up the big picture,
model, got supplanted by the lean-to due to post-drainage and modern day, but the show saying: ‘The story at Ely – to me – plays to the
perceived expense; but when tenders came stopper is the rear extension, making the mu- levelling up agenda in terms of how pride in
in under budget, was swapped back on again. seum accessible in a dramatic way. A birch and place and access to culture and opportunities
It’s an important breathing space for the mu- tulipwood stair in its hall allows the history of is made real in marginalised and regional
seum, thinks Hughes, with shadows cast by the old gable wall to be on show – including an communities.’ But it’s Hughes who makes
the trusses below the light slot running along original window connecting both staircases. the politics personal: ‘The museum is the first
the back wall ‘reminding kids of prison bars’. All lead to the new lofty, double-height space touch point for so many local kids in terms
HAT’s interventions internally were sim- for use not only by school kids but all manner of a cultural experience, so if we can make
ply to pare the structure back to its original of local groups too, and it is a much-need- it something that feels amazing and special
iteration and give exhibition designer Simon ed revenue generator. Triple-aspect, with a and beautiful and exciting, they might come
Leach room to move. 17th century windows large bay and rooflights, it’s proving popular. back again, or go and see a museum some-
were restored and slimline secondary glaz- ‘We’ve had the WI, belly dancers, Quakers, where else. That first perception here could
ing installed behind while old, rotten sash astronomers and spiritualists in here!’ quips stay with them for life.’ •
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
16 Buildings 17
Studios
Our space
If the phrase ‘meanwhile use’ conjures up
images of pop-up shops in shipping contain-
ers and street food stalls made of scaffolding
poles, architect IF_DO’s temporary addition
With a fresh approach to meanwhile use, to a gritty bit of south London might come as
a surprise. It’s a proper building for a start –
IF_DO bolsters a community feeling the albeit one designed to be relocated at the end
brunt of development of an 11-year lease on its present site.
Words: Chris Foges Photographs: Mike Massaro Providing affordable workspace for
small businesses, The Hithe sits comfort-
ably among eclectic neighbours on Albion
Street in Southwark: homes, shops, pubs, a
school and a church. Its softwood cladding in
shades of green picks up on oxidised copper
roofs found thereabouts, and double-height
dormers rise on two sides in friendly sa-
lutes to people exiting Rotherhithe station
or approaching from nearby Canada Water,
where a £3.3 billion regeneration scheme is
remaking the former docks.
The encroachment of development has
left a strong community feeling ‘squeezed
and under-appreciated’, says IF_DO director
Al Scott. That led Southwark Council to give
it a meaningful say when considering the
interim use of a small scrap of vacant land
perched above an awesome piece of Edward-
ian civil engineering. The plot is on the cor-
ner of Albion Street and a pedestrian route
to the Thames, and bounded on two sides
by deep cuttings for the Rotherhithe Tunnel
approach and a railway line.
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
18 Buildings 19
Studios
cost £240,000, though the final sum turned While the logic is clear, The Hithe’s unu- 2 Shared space
3 Community garden
out to be £415,000), with some special fea- sual status threw up various hurdles. Secur-
4 Large studio
tures like the jaunty dormers that reflect ing finance was challenging: what value does Ground floor plan 3
The Hithe’s urban prominence and social the structure have without ownership of the
significance. land beneath it? Bridgeman suggests that
The footprint was determined by ex- Below To the north Above Ten ground floor it from relatively few prefabricated elements. for similar projects, asset finance compa-
isting strip foundations, left by a long-gone The Hithe overlooks studios and a shared The ground floor comprises five steel-framed nies who would treat the building as a piece
the Rotherhithe Tunnel space are formed
terrace of three houses. To ensure that the modules and provides 10 tiny studios – just of equipment might be more receptive than
entrance. from fi ve steel-framed
structure can be relocated economically, modules.
6m² apiece – all accessed externally. Those conventional property lenders.
IF_DO worked with engineer Elliott Wood at the rear enjoy privacy, while those at the Building regulations are also tricky:
and fabricator Weber Industries to assemble front get a public ‘shop window’. waivers for temporary structures only apply 2
On my visit I met one new tenant selling
skincare products and another giving sew-
ing lessons; both were thrilled with their bi- 1
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
20 Buildings
Xxxxxxx
Thrii-up your
IN NUMBERS
283m²
site area
washroom
200m²
gifa
£415,000
construction value
space
25 weeks
time on site
Ideal homes
A House for Artists is the first building of its
kind, and the first major project by architect
Apparata. It’s a remarkable debut. Having
won a 2016 competition to create a novel live/
work set-up for artists in east London, the
newly-formed practice set about challeng-
ing the habits and assumptions that make so
much contemporary housing feel cramped,
flimsy and dull. Its muscular addition to
Apparata lays out its philosophy for living with A House for Barking town centre is something like a man-
Artists, a bold, raw concrete statement intended to bring ifesto, combining ideas about collective living
with a determination to make light-filled,
creativity to Barking spacious and adaptable homes.
Words: Chris Foges The initial impetus for the project came
from the London Borough of Barking &
Below Concrete formwork
Dagenham’s ambition to attract artists priced
was composed to suggest out of inner London. Council leader Darren
masonry construction. Rodwell says it aims to enrich cultural life and
STÅLE ERIKSEN
STÅLE ERIKSEN
JOHAN DEHLIN
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
24 Buildings 25
Housing
inject economic stimulus while avoiding the open decks on both sides giving two means
STÅLE ERIKSEN
IN NUMBERS 1 Linton Road
gentrification often said to follow an influx of 2 William Street Quarter of escape. To the east, outside bedrooms, this 1
the creative classes – the very process pushing 1553m² 3 Anne Mews 3 is a narrow strip with gates between private
gross internal area 4 William Street
artists out of the city. LBBD’s wholly-owned 5 Residential towers
areas belonging to each home. To the west,
housing firms can provide a counterweight to
market forces, he suggests. A House for Art-
470 6 Barking Station 6
glass-walled living rooms look onto access
decks shared by three flats on each floor.
kgCO2eq/m² 2
ists shows what that might mean. Co-com- embodied carbon ‘Deck access has negative associations’,
(A-5, B-5, C-4)
missioned with Create London, a non-profit says Brennan, ‘but that doesn’t mean we
curator of public art projects, it offers long should reject the idea; we just have to design
leases on 12 flats, and sets rents at a third be-
9.52 4
5
variety, with flats set behind a grid of deep of omitting lobbies: more living area, and free- circulation.
4 5
loggias. A Bauhausian vocabulary of circles, dom in its use. Flats conform to national space
squares and triangles adds a playful touch, standards but feel much larger – a sensation
recurring in windows, cut-outs and eccen-
tric manipulations of the roofline. (The orig- 5
inal design was even fruitier, but triangular
columns and sloping concrete canopies were
dropped to aid buildability).
With glass walls set behind deep col-
umns, the rugged community hall is like First floor plan
an extension of the street, putting activity
within on public display. ‘It can open up for
events and become quite fluid,’ says Brennan.
Blockwork service risers screen some studi-
os at the back, and artists can also work in a
fenced yard to the side.
From the yard, the route to residents’ 6
7
homes is entirely outdoors, via external
stairs and open decks. ‘In many apartment
buildings flats are approached through dark 4
5
corridors’, says Apparata co-founder Astrid
Smitham. ‘We wanted all shared spaces to be
pleasant places to be, helping to form a com-
munity’. The architect was equally keen to 5
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
26 Buildings
Xxxxxxx
or study can be carved out of living rooms, so Set aside the specific provision for art- standard flats Architect Apparata
incorporate features Architects
residents can remain in place as needs change. ists, and Apparata’s cogent piece of ‘built
including rooflights and a Client London Borough
Another kind of flexibility is found on research’ not only shows that imaginative of Barking & Dagenham;
double-height space.
the second floor, where double doors in party architects can still find wriggle room within co-commissioned by
Create London; delivered
walls allow three flats to be combined in an the straightjackets of finance and regulation Below Three inter- by Be First
airy enfilade, to suit co-housing or extended to do something different in housing design, connected flats support Fire Menzies Consultants
families. Communal life is optional, not im- but also provides a template for others. The co-living arrangements. Contractor J Murphy &
Sons
posed, says Brennan: ‘You can still close the building’s austere character, or its trade-offs
Below left Glazing is Engineering
doors and be done with co-living for the day’. between privacy and community, wouldn’t
Our net carbon negative products
arranged to allow sub- Expedition Engineering
At the front, one of the four non-stand- suit everyone, of course. But plenty would val- division of living rooms. M&E consultant
Max Fordham
ard flats has an extraordinary double-height ue the space and light, and jump at the chance
can offset building emissions
QS Artelia
space in one of the triangular roof volumes, to shape their own environment. A House for
and a private patio. ‘Affordable housing in Artists should be the first of many. •
Britain offers very few flat types,’ says Bren-
nan, ‘but by keeping costs down we could add
variety’. (LBBD won’t disclose the contract
sum, but says it was within normal range). Our UK-made sheet products lock in more carbon
Construction is lean, legible and surpris- than we emit manufacturing them. Using more of
ingly sustainable – exceeding the RIBA 2030 them in a build or refurb will help reduce a building’s
climate challenge target for embodied carbon carbon count, helping to comply with net zero targets.
by more than 20%. The primary structure is
all exposed concrete, using 50% GGBS. Load-
Carbon negative.
Positive future.
uk.westfraser.com/carbon-negative
STÅLE ERIKSEN
Student revision
At Manchester’s city-centre
This image The
development looks
Kampus development, Mecanoo
across Canal Street to and shedkm have transformed a
the north-west.
former university site into a verdant
Below right South- housing scheme
west entrance to the
complex through Little Words: Eleanor Young
David Street, which runs Photographs: Greg Holmes Photography, Daniel Hopkinson
between the warehouse
buildings and had been
closed off for decades.
PHOTOS:GREG HOLMES
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
30 Critique 31
Housing
8
5 6
1
Mecanoo wanted to
emphasise the small-scale
10 10
rather than fight through vines with machetes. You find venture partner Henry Boot Developments decided
your way into the central courtyard or ‘hidden garden’ build-to-rent was the best route, partly based on ease of
through narrow alleys. ‘We made it almost too close,’ financing for the £250 million scheme.
Rick Splinter of Mecanoo explains. It is more plants The Amsterdam rhythm of Canal Street, across the
than paving, silver birches, tree ferns, euphorbia and Rochdale Canal from the site, suggested there might
fatsia threatening to claim paths as they expand over be a Dutch influence to tease out, says Higgins. Delft-
the edges of the sandstone flags. A colonnade of newly based Mecanoo, which then had a Manchester office,
exposed 1960s concrete columns sits in pools of plants, was engaged to masterplan and design the site. The
with climbers promising to colonise the structure density and massing is so different from traditional
further. Keeping the raised caretaker’s flat – dubbed Amsterdam streets it seems a rather vain hope, but
the Bungalow – allows glimpses through its stilts to the ‘Dutch’ houses perched atop two of the new-build brick-
adjacent canal rather than a more formal framing. clad towers are a nod to it. Liverpool-based architect
After four hours criss-crossing Manchester city shedkm, a long-standing collaborator, was called in to
centre, I had seen three scrappy patches of green, some deal with the old warehouses. And Chapman Taylor
drearily deserted paved ‘public’ spaces and barely took the new build through to completion.
a tree. So it is clear why, in rational moments, green As well as bringing a topping of Dutchness, Mecanoo
was one of a series of attractors that Capital & Centric wanted to emphasise the small-scale experience of the
identified to give character, value and a certain uplift pedestrian; Kampus is experienced on foot rather than Credits
in rents to this tall, super dense build-to-rent project of when driving past. These are big buildings, the most Client Capital &
533 homes. dense in Mecanoo’s office. They could have been denser. Centric and Henry Boot
Developments
Residential use was not a given. The floor plate of The strategic development framework had agreement Design and landscape
the business school suggested commercial uses, and for a 30-storey tower but, when it came to detailed architect
Higgins doesn’t remembers there being many large- planning permission, Capital & Centric settled for 16 Mecanoo
PHOTOS:GREG HOLMES
Architect for listed canal
scale residential projects in the city centre at that time storeys and three extra on the 12-storey business school. warehouse buildings
in 2013. Likewise the build-to-rent sector was nascent Mecanoo took cues from the city’s surrounding Shed KM
with only a few built examples Higgins could find, even Victorian buildings, borrowing the classical tripartite Landscape architect
and delivery architect
in London. But Higgins, his business partner in Capital division. At the base, the podium has ins and outs, a for new build
& Centric, Tim Heatley (see profile July, 2021), and joint colonnade and raking columns and a jettied warehouse Chapman Taylor
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
32 Critique NOW PLAYING
Housing
DANIEL HOPKINSON
A two-storey metal-
blocks of yellow opening up spaces and choose pleasure
clad podium provides a
over super efficiency (though I am assured they still consistent base for the
manage 70 per cent net to gross, not far behind the new-build and tower
80 per cent of the new builds). Both buildings have element.
WRAPTITE®
THE SELF-ADHERING AIRTIGHT AND VAPOUR
PERMEABLE MEMBRANE
GREG HOLMES
0:03 3:29
1 One-bed flat
2 Two-vbed flat
3 Roof terrace
4 Warehouse
2
Station, and from Pollen Bakery and General Stores lundhsrealstone.com | @lundhsrealstone
(both successful enterprises born in the regeneration of
4 4
Ancoats), and green surroundings. There will be events
and happenings in the canalside Bungalow. With the
3 inevitable churn of renters (average age 31) moving on,
Capital & Centric will have to keep attracting people to
0 50m Kampus to keep the flats let. But so far that is looking
easy to do. •
MICHAEL FRANKE
for UK buildings, focusing on a ‘fabric first’ ‘All junctions within the construction
principle of constructing a building with a were simulated to eliminate thermal
highly insulated and airtight envelope in bridging. The Schüco systems minimise heat
order to reduce space heating demand to a loss in winter and solar gains in summer.
Quarry House, a newbuild within the pit Above Schüco technical experts Below Large areas of glazing very low level. Infiltration is minimised using a Pro Clima
of a disused stone quarry, nestled between provided test data and details make the most of the setting, Although Passivhaus standards exceed Intello Plus Vapour Check Membrane, and
Below All window
of heat loss through profiles without compromising on
mature forest and open fields, required those of the Building Regulations, it is systems must be fresh air is provided mechanically, with all
to support the Passivhaus thermal performance.
exceptional sensitivity to the surrounding consultant.
down to the designer to decide how best to super-insulated. heat recovered from out-going air.’
environment and demanding Passivhaus meet the criteria, which means Passivhaus A-Zero Architects is a RIBA chartered
standards of energy efficiency. buildings can be built using almost any practice based in London. Founded in
The house is partially below ground, so construction method. 2010, its work focusses on designing and
it was imperative to make as much use of procuring buildings in a way which does not
natural light as possible without losing heat. Key criteria that a Passivhaus scheme must have an adverse impact on the environment.
Inside, a central double height atrium space meet are the following: Aumaxum Architectural Glazing
is flanked by private and semi-private spaces • The building must be airtight with less has over 20 years of experience in the
at two levels, each with their own view to than 0.6 air changes per hour at a pressure architectural glazing industry and is a
the outside. of 50Pa Schüco partner. •
The project was granted permission • Space heating demand must not exceed
under Paragraph 80 of the National Planning 15kWh/m2/yr
Policy Framework, which requires a • Exterior walls must have a U-value less
proposal’s design to be ‘truly outstanding or than 0.15 W/m2K
innovative, reflecting the highest standards • And the windows must be super-insulated
in architecture, and would help to raise with a U-value less than 0.8 W/m²K which
standards of design more generally in rural generally means they must be triple
areas.’ glazed, with a g-value of 50% to capture www.schueco.com/uk/specifiers
The design, by A-Zero Architects, uses heat from the sun. For further information on Schüco products and services,
materials local to the site – stone from please contact mkinfobox@schueco.com
the quarry and timber from the forest, The range of Schüco systems specified work
with aluminium products from Schüco, to together to create a home that is designed
achieve the right blend of aesthetics and with the objective of setting a low-energy
performance. standard.
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
Going for green Practical lessons 39
– clients – house
46 56
You employ one of Sam was doing his year out with our eight-strong Kent ONLY ON RIBAJ.COM
the first cohort of
Level 7 architecture
practice, and enjoying it. He applied for a part-time
diploma, but in 2018 London South Bank University
How can we make
Business, clients
apprentices, who has
just qualified. How
launched the new apprenticeship. He could qualify buildings more
& services did that come about? by studying one day a week while earning, and we got succinct? We need
stability as he’d be with us for at least three years. Our
materials that
Stuart
willingness also stems from our objection to conventional
education: it’s too long, expensive and divorced from provide structure,
practice. This is a better way to train well-rounded insulation,
Coleman
architects. We’ve since taken on two more apprentices.
waterproofing,
What’s involved for The government pays 90% of the course fees and we durability and have
the practice? make up the rest. We also opted to cover travel and other
costs, and pay a full-time salary. The apprenticeship
a suitable aesthetic
is arduous and stressful, so it’s only fair to give quality. What are
proper support. We commit time to meet tutors, and these materials?
to mentoring – making sure apprentices meet the The construction of
workplace requirements. As year-out staff sign up for an egg gives Steve
apprenticeships six months before starting, we have to Webb pause for
decide that they can handle it quite early. That could be a practical thought:
ribaj.com/cladding-
gamble, but our apprentices have completed first degrees,
egg
which shows maturity and commitment to architecture.
Director of How has it worked For apprentices it is incredibly tough. They study
Coleman Anderson out? three hours a night plus weekends, needing good
time management. It’s also hard to switch between,
Architects explains for example, the sort of drawings made for a tutor or a
why his practice client. Some have suggested that apprentices miss out
is employing on creative development, but they get stimulation at
university while learning how to talk to contractors and
and supporting win jobs. I underestimated the breadth of experience
architectural they need to get in practice, but luckily in a firm of our
apprentices size everyone sees everything, and we’ve organised CPDs
to fill gaps. As a practice we’ve benefited, as creative
juices flow and they bring in new skills. It does stretch
resources – they are too busy to take on paid overtime –
but that just needs good practice management.
We know commercial washrooms. Do you recommend it Absolutely – perhaps every practice should offer
to other practices? them. As early adopters we learned on the job, and the
Unity toilet cubicles, finished in ‘Dark Walnut’ laminate, were specified in all six
university did too, but requirements are now clearer
of the new male and female washroom areas at Capital One’s Head Office in
to employers, with support in place; it helps that our Intelligence is officially
Nottingham. Setback pedestals fixed to the cubicle partitions, gives Unity its
apprentices are at the same university. We’ve seen approved RIBA CPD. Look
sleek floating appearance. Unity’s flush fronted design has made a huge visual
the benefit to the practice and the apprentices, and it’s out for icons throughout
impact and has complemented the décor of these stylish new washroom areas.
Call 01474 353333 incredibly fulfilling to experience their whole journey the section indicating core
Read the full case study at www.venesta.co.uk/case-studies www.venesta.co.uk marketing@venesta.co.uk to becoming an architect. curriculum areas.
L Specify your washrooms with the help of our new website | www.venesta.co.uk D A V F E
40 Intelligence 41
Client
LOWFIELD GREEN
Lowfield Green in the south-west of the
city replaces a former school with 165
Sustainable Places, planning homes, 146 of which are being developed
Architecture & community by the council alongside six self-built
houses and a 19-home co-housing scheme.
York’s housebuilding
It circles around a new 0.4ha green and
includes apartments for the over-55s and
bungalows, which have been attractive
it. The only drawback was that much of the dustry to the zero-carbon challenge has been
Isabelle Priest
early work was in assembling a team. It now pretty slow out of the blocks,’ adds Carter, ‘so
The City of York Council’s housebuilding re- totals 12 with Jones, one of the recruits, join- we wanted to prove that it could be technical-
cord wasn’t totally non-existent by the time ing from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. ly possible and commercially viable.’
the business case was agreed for it to embark Travelling around the south-west of York As the project has gained momentum,
on a 600-new-home programme in 2017. It near Lowfield Green, the most advanced the deliverables have also become more am-
ISABELLE PRIEST
had completed around 60 homes during the scheme, it doesn’t appear the city is short of bitious. The Lowfield Green development
preceding five years, mostly small estate homes. Tang Hall in the east was the second was as much about the council proving to
infills. What the go-ahead did was launch council estate built in England under Homes itself that it could build successful schemes
an ambition to mass build homes on a scale for Heroes following the First World War. that are attractive places to live. All the de-
unseen in the city since the post-war period. Elsewhere you will encounter successive velopments are mixed tenure and Lowfield
The first 40 homes on the initial site, housing estates that radiate from the centre Green cross-funds 28 social rent and 28
Lowfield Green, are already occupied. The forming evidence of changing architectur- shared ownership homes by developing 90
next wave of residents will move in shortly al styles and urban design thinking from market sale properties, but didn’t go as far
and the third phase of construction will start the 1930s to 1970s like the dating rings of a as zero-carbon. The next sites to construct
soon. The local authority has two schemes tree; yet noticeably lacking housing from the will be at least 40 per cent affordable homes
ready to start on site, one in planning as well 1980s to present day. and will be fully zero-carbon in use, meaning
as two projects in the initial design stages. The backdrop is that, by 2017, the council annual heating and electricity will be gener-
According to head of housing delivery and had accumulated several vacant sites that it ated by the homes, including for TV, laptops,
asset management Michael Jones, the coun- was considering disposing of. But more wide- phone-charging, not just cooker, fridge,
cil should be halfway to reaching the target ly, the city is facing a housing affordability freezer. They will also be Passivhaus-cer-
lifting of the borrowing cap on housing rev- mix of newcomers, students, houses in mul- go further still by attempting to bring down
enue account receipts in 2012 – which also tiple occupation, and older people staying embodied carbon using timber construction
generated Goldsmith Street for Norwich in family homes. Key and low-wage work- and recycled newspaper insulation as a more
City Council. However, whereas many au- ers, essential to York’s retail and hospitality sustainable alternative to block and brick.
thorities have opted to deliver via separate industries, are priced out. Right to Buy has In terms of design, York Council has been
Top The apartment block for over 55s
development companies in partnership with been an additional negative drag, chipping at Lowfield Green overlooks a new
resistance from developers to meet afforda- and city in the country we see classic cook- keen to work with architects that meet its
private developers and housing associations, away the once 15,000 social rent homes to public park. ble homes targets on private developments ie-cutter mass housebuilding developments, ambitions. The first two schemes, Lowfield
York is doing it alone. Its delivery model is 7,500. At the same time, the average earn- Above A row of semi-detached (20 per cent on brownfield, 30 per cent of but we wanted to demonstrate that you can Green and Castle Mills in the city centre are
entirely based on borrowing off housing rev- ings to house price ratio in the city is 1:10, a bungalows forms one boundary of greenfield), which was also affecting quality. do it differently. You can still do it in a com- designed by BDP’s Sheffield office, appointed
Lowfield Green.
enue account receipts – a method director of figure more comparable with the south and ‘There was an element that we can do it mercially minded way in terms of making it via the OJEU process (although it had worked
Right Mikhail Riches' Duncombe
housing economy and regeneration Tracey south-east than elsewhere in the north of Barracks is on a site with planning for
better and raise standards in the city,’ ex- stack up, but you can offer a different product with the council on other projects previous-
Carter says is simpler to the point where it is England. It has led to high land prices so that 34 homes (20 per cent social rent, 20 plains Jones on why the council wanted to get that’s better quality.’ ly). However, as the local authority’s ambi-
perplexing that more councils don’t opt for by 2017, the council was receiving ever more per cent shared ownership). involved in housebuilding. ‘In every town ‘And the response of the construction in- tions grew it went down the procurement
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
42 Intelligence
Client
ORDNANCE LANE
Mikhail Riches’ first project for City of
York Council, which is in planning, will
MAPEI
create 85 new homes on a former MOD
site, south-east of the city centre. It GROUTS.
will involve demolishing several rather
charming existing military housing
buildings (because the architect couldn’t
86 COLOURS
make the site work with them) but retain
what is called the ‘married quarters’ WITH UNIQUE
which will have community and commercial
units at ground level. Between the rows
PERFORMANCES.
MIKHAIL RICHES
Design
2-CD: Concept Design
Construction
PROJECT MANAGEMENT PROJECT ACCOUNTING PROJECT COLLABORATION
5-MC: Manufacturing and Construction
Get organized — Stay on track — know Work better together
deliver every project on the true value of all — bring clarity to 6-H: Handover
time and budget your projects complexity
Ongoing Use
7-U: Use
DERWENT LONDON
outcomes? Why would they hesitate, given (65%), a lack of client engagement (62%), and Bennie felt that in-use performance veri-
the rising end-user demand for environmen- product substitution and value engineer- fication was the way forward. This implies a
tally friendly buildings, the importance of ing (57%). On top of that, 32% thought they greater focus on RIBA Plan of Work’s Stage 7
pro-social, green values in real estate invest- would fail as a business if they only produced and more post-occupancy evaluation (POE).
ment (especially after COP 26) – and of course sustainable designs. Although it is probably an urban myth, ar-
the risk of reputational damage? Importantly, the survey did not distin- chitects sometimes fear their PI insurers are adding that deviating from where we are now increased likelihood of losing control is likely Above 80 Charlotte Street, a London office
To find out, the RIBA Client Liaison guish between kinds of client, who of course against POE on the basis that it risks dredg- to much-needed improvements in design to be an inhibiting factor. building designed by Make for Derwent
London, uses air-source heat pumps and solar
Group convened a roundtable discussion all have different resources and motivations. ing up problems. Runacres recommended performance places an additional burden on
thermal panels and has 8% lower embodied
with client representatives and architects Certainly, Benjamin Lesser of Derwent consulting them to avoid any difficulties. the client project team in terms of disciplines, Accounting for externalities carbon intensity than the RICS benchmark.
who are leaders in the field of sustainability. London did not recognise the impression There is a need for not only useful evalu- time and cost, with the added lag in the omis- Development appraisals favour short-term
The roundtable interrogated eight clients that clients deliberately obstruct. In his ex- ation criteria but also a reporting system to sion of their pricing in appraisals. As we are decision horizons at the expense of long-term side. This ties in with the current dearth of
who retain a long-term interest in the assets perience, environmental and social govern- capture and share findings. Caspar Rodgers all having to upskill industry-wide, could ones that might account for non-financial verified data from assets in use. As Langdon
they develop – five from the private sector, ance matters are top of investors’ list of con- of architect alma-nac proposed there should architects take on delivering say Passivhaus costs. As Jenkins said, ‘In the bidding process said, ‘One of the biggest barriers is education
three from the public sector. cerns. In turn, Derwent pushes its teams to be a ‘common pool of knowledge so that compliant schemes – and even certify them? for assets and opportunities, not everyone is with the client, advisers and consultants.
Led by Nigel Ostime, chair of the Client hit stringent sustainability targets. everyone can sing from the same hymn sheet’. Runacres described the difficulty of jus- pricing in future carbon risk.’ They need to be making better decisions
Liaison Group and partner at Hawkins\ Peter Runacres of Argent agreed, although This should make it easier to reach agreement tifying extra upfront capital expenditure in Chris Langdon of Equans (part of Engie) based on better information and knowledge.’
Brown, the online event was split into two. he suspected that funders’ understanding on targets and for clients to compare options return for theoretical but unproven eventu- amplified the point in relation to decisions James Halsall of the London Legacy De-
During the first part, client representatives does not go very deep. As he said, ‘Many in the from a position of greater certainty. al in-use savings in operational expenditure. about whether to refurbish or demolish. The velopment Corporation bemoaned the lack of
outlined what they thought were the main business still just want a box ticked.’ Success depends on convincing funders that failure to account properly for the carbon systemic knowledge capturing and sharing
barriers to sustainable outcomes. In the sec- Finance: cost, viability, predictability money is spent where it is most effective. costs of demolition, and to exaggerate the fi- from exemplar projects as standing in the
ond, they set out possible solutions, including
how architects could help. The architect pan- Although it is probably an While the industry has, as Lesser put it, long
been picking the low-hanging technical de-
Taking the leap is just as hard for publicly
funded projects, where initial capital cost is
nancial uplift from building anew, mean that
refurbishment is rarely selected despite often
way of upskilling. Louisa Bowles, sustain-
ability lead at Hawkins\Brown, confirmed
ellists were given a chance to comment based
on their experiences of working with clients. urban myth, architects sign solution fruit, it is only just moving to
the high-hanging, and it is far from straight-
constrained and politically sensitive, added
Bennie.
being the more sustainable option. that concern: ‘Architects are often well
aware of the broader sustainability agenda
The RIBA’s November 2021 Decade of
Action poll of architects gave some useful sometimes fear that their PI forward. ‘It’s a risk because we are having to
invest significant funds years in advance on
Unfamiliar design solutions entail com-
paratively unpredictable costs. Since cost
Education and competence
The panel implicated a general lack of knowl-
around issues including social value, biodi-
versity and land use, but don’t know how to
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
48 Intelligence
Sustainability
Design freedom
without compromise Procurement Sustainable
& contracts Architecture
Realise your project aspirations with leading
Responsible
product solutions in curtain wall.
design needs
With bespoke and standardised product solutions from
Reynaers Aluminium, you can rely on:
a whole team
Expertly engineered systems that perform to your
thermal and acoustic requirements
Uncompromising quality and craftsmanship
Support that matches your project programme, How tp bennett manages its
timescale, and budget strategy to source materials
World leading curtain wall solutions sustainably and responsibly
DRONECAM SOLUTIONS
Achieves many test standards including CWCT – and the ripple effect
(dependant on variants)
Structural glazing, unitised glazing, roof glazing
and fire rated solutions available
the civil society organisation Verité listing 18 Above tp bennett’s ‘Carbon Cube’ installation in Leeds
Chris Webb during COP26.
countries – and one-in-six cotton products –
Buildings are responsible for 39% of global reported to have forced labour within their
energy related carbon emissions, almost a supply chains. some product assessment certifications do
third of which are released from materials While these are extreme examples, they exist, such as Environmental Product Dec-
and construction, the World Green Building represent a key issue: the more geographical- larations and Declare Labels, none give full
Council has reported. The materials we spec- ly complex and removed a product’s supply insight across all areas of concern.
ify therefore are not only one of our greatest chain is, the greater the risk is that some- Even if there was a one stop shop to meas-
sustainability impacts, but also offer a signif- where, some people involved in its produc- ure attainment across all our target aspects of
icant opportunity for change. tion might be working in unhealthy or uneq- environmental and social sustainability, it is
At tp bennett, materials are an important uitable conditions. unlikely that many products would perform
focus area as part of our commitment to meet perfectly across all indicators. And here is
the RIBA 2030 Climate Challenge Targets Positive impact the greatest issue: How do we measure and
and the detailed programme that we have So there is a lot to consider. And our goal then prioritise areas of good and bad perfor-
implemented to align with UN Sustainable should be to not just prevent environmental mance? Where are the red lines? Do we rank
Development Goals. We have developed a harm and inequality, but to actively regen- embodied carbon values above, for example,
chart and a questionnaire for our suppliers erate environments and to achieve positive payment of the local living wage?
that helps us (and them) analyse and work social value across all geographies. Consider two versions of the same prod-
on sustainability issues in their widest sense. To make change, first we need to under- uct – one is made locally in the UK, in a fac-
The embodied carbon of a product is an stand a product’s constituent parts and prov- tory using heavy industrial processes, and is
important environmental performance indi- enance, which is by no means easy. Although then driven to site in an electric vehicle. The
cator but it is crucial that we also look beyond comparative product is made by a responsi-
that to manufacturing waste, water con- ble co-operative half-way around the world,
sumption and polluting processes – and the but is then air-freighted to the UK. What is
wider social risks and responsibilities too.
For example, a study from Sheffield Hal- Although some product best? Opinions may differ – sustainability is
often an emotive subject!
lam University strongly linked photovoltaic
panels, widely used in the UK, with some assessment certifications do While some suppliers have exception-
al insight, all too often, others do not have
Together for better componentry manufactured by the forced
labour of indigenous Uyghur and Kazakh cit- exist, none give full insight all the information we need about prod-
uct origin. Although most want to increase
Reynaers reynaers.co.uk
across all areas of concern
izens in China. The cotton and wider textiles their own socio-environmental performance
Aluminium supply chains can have similar issues, with across their business, they often do not know
0121 421 1999 reynaersltd@reynaers.com
ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
RENEWABLE ENERGY PERFORMANCE CARBON REDUCTION
52 Intelligence
Sustainability
Strategy tools
To tackle these myriad problems, we have
developed a Responsible Sourcing Charter
and Supply Chain Questionnaire, through
consultation with suppliers and clients. The
10-point charter sets out the collaborative
approach and ethos needed to make positive
change, throughout our supply chains. The
questionnaire helps us understand how sup-
pliers and products are performing.
We ask potential suppliers to sign up to
the charter and to fill out the questionnaire
and, although it does require them to put in
HUFTON + CROW
time and effort, the information we receive
back not only allows us to make more in-
formed specification decisions, but also helps
show the supplier where to focus their effort.
Having launched the initiative only a
year ago, we have already collected data SUPPLY QUESTIONNAIRE FOCUS AREAS Above tp bennett's Herbal House office in Farringdon,
from around 130 different suppliers. And it 1 Product materials and chemical content – including London, for George Soros' Open Society Foundations.
is having a real impact. After using our ques- human health considerations such as indoor air quality, as
tionnaire, a joinery manufacturer that we well as raw materials footprint. To that end we have been using QR codes
Redeveloped residential building certified
work with is looking at incorporating on-site to make some of the data that we hand over to
renewables at its manufacturing site and has 2 Manufacturing, resource, consumption and waste – for facilities management teams accessible to all BREEAM ‘Outstanding’ for its environmental,
replaced the plastic corners of its packaging example factory energy use, both on- and off-site. users of the building. They can simply scan economic, and sustainability attributes.
with protectors made from off-cuts. the materials to find out more about them. Project: Clapham Park, London
Similarly, a supplier of surface finishes 3 Product circularity – for example recycled content, As a signatory to Architects Declare, we
Architect: PJMA Architects
now actively monitors and reduces its waste, modularity and take-back schemes. are committed to sharing our knowledge
Sustainable
water and electricity footprints and is ex- and research. The long-term intention for Approved Contractor: E J Roberts
ploring the use of ingredients with lower 4 Transport – covering locality and full transportation the Responsible Sourcing Charter and Sup- PV installer: M&M Electrical Ltd
rooftops to
embodied carbon footprints. miles, prioritising rail over road and shipping over flights, ply Chain Questionnaire is to move the plat-
We have also been very impressed by the use of electric vehicles and consolidated journeys. form to an online tool which we hope will be
extent to which contractors have embraced accessible to everyone.
support the
the idea when we are working with them 5 Packaging – looking at reduction, reuse, FSC- Our series of public exhibitions, ‘Mate- Specify a rooftop solution that encompasses Bitumen waterproofing with green roof
and solar PV
on design and build contracts. It helps to set certification, avoiding single-use plastics and more. rials Matter’, linking each of our seven key robust waterproofing, a biodiverse green roof,
ambitions at the start. Success then comes focus areas to actions that anyone can take
environment
and a solar PV array on one roof area.
down to sharing our data and monitoring 6 Social sustainability and ethical sourcing – covering now, is an effort to engage the wider public
their tender specifications. We can ensure supply chain audit, factory visits, social sustainability in our sustainable design process too.
that they keep within the same embodied certifications and payment of local living wage. After all, knowledge is power. The de- Bauder BioSOLAR is a unified solution with
carbons bracket, for example, even if they cision-making process remains complex design support, bespoke calculations and
find a cheaper alternative product. 7 Embodied carbon – including holding environment and somewhat subjective but collecting and specification, installed by fully trained
product declarations or commitment to accurately using data to make informed choices is an
approved contractors, with a guarantee for the
Delivering the goods calculate and reduce embodied carbon. important step to supplying, sourcing and
Clients are starting to really see how we can specifying more sustainably. Both pollution entire roof package.
deliver their ESG strategy through every de- prevention and purpose must be as key a part
tail of the buildings we design for them. Peo- of specification decisions as price, perfor- n Robust waterproofing with BBA certified life
ple love to understand and share the story of mance and programme. • expectancy of over 35 years
n Diverse range of 35 RHS recognised ‘Perfect
the materials and products in their building Chris Webb is head of sustainability at tp for Pollinators’ vegetation species
with their staff and visitors. bennett n Cooling effect from the vegetation increases
panel output by up to 5%
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com
01473 257671 • START YOUR PROJECT • bauder.co.uk
54 Guest content 55
Aluproof
Aluproof’s
• Using trees (shading, wind protection)
Sustainable design is no longer a trend construction industry. Buildings account designing windows on south walls, using
Below Environmental
or a design option. For a profession as for 67% of total energy consumption, with sun shades, maximising passive energy
anti-carbon
Building York University,
responsible as that of an architect, it is the UK residential sector accounting for gains York, UK. Applied
a necessity. So what are the tasks facing 77% of CO2 emissions across the whole • Using recyclable building materials (eg systems: MB-70, MB-
the industry in the context of the climate construction industry. It is clear that it is aluminium). SR50N.
culture crisis?
The construction industry is responsible
for 40% of the UK’s carbon footprint.
the construction sector and, in particular,
housing, that needs to be focussed on most
strongly.
With pressure on the Architecture, engineering and By 2050, the UK has to achieve
construction industry construction (AEC) is not the only reason the objectives of the Climate Change
that the climate crisis exists, but it is Act 2019 and reach climate neutrality
to cut its carbon impact responsible for a very large part of the (zero carbon). To help achieve this, the
growing every day, global warming process. According to Minimum Energy Efficiency Standard
architects have a major ourworldindata.org, as much as 17.5% of (BEIS 2020) aims to improve the energy
global greenhouse gas emissions are the performance of buildings while reducing
responsibility to design result of using huge amounts of energy to the energy poverty of the population.
sustainably. Aluproof heat and light buildings. However, government arrangements alone
can help realise these If we look at the problem on the scale are not enough to make a difference. The
of this country alone, the situation looks whole AEC industry must work together
ambitions even more serious. The UK Green Building and, above all, architects must be active
Council estimates that 40% of the carbon in improving the energy efficiency of
footprint in the UK is created by the buildings in their designs.
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
56 Intelligence 57
Architects’ account
A
Design, construction 3 1
& technology B
6
5 2 7
Sustainable,
cheerful –
4
sequent residential projects. I pay the elec- sculptural with a structural curved bookcase We tendered the project and worked with Architect Macdonald Wright Architects
Client James Macdonald Wright This is the first in a new series of architects'
tricity bills and the tenants reimburse me, so that supports the Douglas fir staircase. The a small local contractor we knew before, but accounts about designing and making their
Structural engineer Osbourne Edwards
I know exactly how the house is performing shape on plan references the arches of the li- hadn’t previously built anything on that scale. Sustainability consultant Conker Conservation buildings. Read more Design in the making on
compared to the original design calculations. brary next door. There is a small courtyard It turned into quite a collaborative effort. Main contractor DanEco Build ribaj.com
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
58 Guest content 59
Futurebuild
A showcase
the game-changing products already construction industry faces. Companies
leading brands that are thought leaders will
The countdown to sustainable built clearly established what the industry must transforming the built environment. developing the most take to the stage at
on the trail include consultants of Cradle
environment event Futurebuild 2022 do, we must now focus on how to do it at Sessions on day three will explore innovative technologies, Futurebuild’s conference to Cradle Certified® materials 540 World,
to inspire
has begun. From March 1 to 3 at ExCeL scale. Futurebuild will be perfectly timed creating a healthier, happier place for all products and solutions. programme. timber specialist James Latham, standards
London, the net zero pioneering exhibition to tackle the key issues facing the built organisation MCS and construction
will bring together the disruptive thinkers environment and collaboratively solve management software provider Procore.
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
Hatherley’s travels Endlessly inquiring 61
– review – obituary
72 79
As well as being a high opacity emulsion, and perfect for use on new plaster, Trellick Tower, was stopped in his tracks
by Julian Keable’s curious, glimmering
the new Dulux Trade Supermatt formulation offers an improved flow out blue tiling and circular, louvred vents.
In the time it took to grab his camera and
and finish† for professional results. focus, a VW camper van had trundled
into view and was caught in the frame, in
its uncannily analogous blue. A moment
in the sun for a block living, literally and
figuratively, in the shadow of Goldfinger’s
masterpiece. • Jan-Carlos Kucharek
We promise our paint will give you the perfect colour with a uniform finish and the
Jack Young
coverage stated, or we’ll replace it. Visit dulux.co.uk/promise Untitled, 2020.
Terms and conditions apply. Claims must be made within 6 months of purchase. Proof of purchase required. Colour claims limited to 10L per customer.
Sony A7iii with 28mm prime lens
Manufacturer’s tips and instructions must have been followed. UK purchases only. Jack Young’s ‘The Council House’
is available from ribabooks.com
*Based on in-can VOC content, measured in accordance with ISO 11890-2:2013. †Compared to previous formulation ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
Culture 63
President
• Seminars by high profile architects USING CODE Awards will be announced during April and May. The sharing of expertise between our members RIBA International
Prize 2021, the
Full programme available online 1810 Celebrating the best of what we do is important.
But capturing and sharing information about the
and with the wider industry and government is the
foundation of our House of Architecture concept,
Friendship Hospital
in Bangladesh, by
• Materials curation OXYGEN by MaterialDriven exemplary projects that are awarded is equally @RIBA – the creation of a 21st century virtual and Kashef Chowdhury/
• Photo wall selected by world-architects valuable. RIBA membership is about sharing best physical institute of ideas, where all are welcome. • URBAN.
practice and learning how it can inform architecture
• RIBA pop-up Bookshop
and help us and our clients to make better projects.
• Art To this end the RIBA has launched a new series
of free online talks – ‘Building Stories’ – to celebrate
OPEN BAR award-winning projects. We are keen that this
new weekly series will give an opportunity for
project teams to share their particular story of the
collaboration between architect, design team, client,
Neutral
Opinion
HAGEN STIER
mid-rise apartment blocks. Inside, large-scale
models are arranged on shelves enveloping a chunky
structural column. Specification samples are half
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
70 Culture 71
Profile
displayed, half stored in the open. Densely packed of uncertainty. The walls of the space before the
LEWIS KHAN
long letter on the merits and disadvantages of a career prescriptive, telling people how to live. As a place to celebratory bunting around its roof. It’s flexible,
in architecture and said if she was convinced about live I find that uptight, but it’s not sustainable either.’ curious and already well-loved, as its director says:
doing it, she should study in London, the Netherlands Scalbert joined the team two years into Brockholes; ‘The jewel in the crown of Somers Town.’ •
then came a homeless centre in King’s Cross and
another wildlife visitor centre, at Pensthorpe in
Norfolk. Here the practice untangled the masterplan,
restored five cottages and built a play barn with a
sawtooth roof, carefully designed steel frame, lots of
daylight and a lining of textured acoustic panels. From
Left and right The
photographs, it looks fun externally and an exercise in distinctive recently
subtle light and shadow inside not usually afforded to opened Central Somers
Left Model of a house children. The same goes for New Horizons, completed Town community
ADAM KHAN ARCHITECTS
for a female artist in a in 2010, where its teenage users recognise the calming facilities on ‘Plot 10’
converted glass factory DAVID GRANDORGE includes 10 apartments,
and other-worldly effect of the all-timber interior. At
in Brussels, currently an outdoor adventure
under construction, with
Seizure Gallery, Roger Hiorns’ artwork was relocated playground, indoor
its feminist motif on the from a council estate in south east London to the playrooms and a football
facade. boundary of the service yard to maintain its feeling pitch on the roof.
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
72 Culture 73
Review
Hatherley’s
find that these are far from being dry listings. Each solecisms in the Buildings of England series too.
section of text on a building or group of buildings is a It’s sobering for me, with all these years’ head-
self-contained piece of description and architectural start on young Owen in this trade, to find – again!
ALL IMAGES © CHRIS MATTHEWS, TAKEN FROM MODERN BUILDINGS IN BRITAIN BY OWEN HATHERLEY
addictive process that is made easy to navigate. After imperial pomp (Lutyens, Baker etc) the drag factor. It
an excellent scene-setting introduction starting with was hard for anyone to attempt something radically
the roots of modernism in the industrial buildings of different from the prevailing orthodoxy.
the 19th century, there are 14 sections, each one a part I think of Hatherley here not so much as a
of the country, each divided into its key areas. There modern-day Pevsner or Nairn, Betjeman or Meades,
are three indexes – of buildings, of architects, and a those diverse architectural and social cataloguers,
general one in which you can search for, say, places, polemicists and presenters. His mission, given
styles, types. When you get to the page you want, you the rate at which buildings of the past century are
vanishing, is more akin to a Cecil Sharp or Vaughan
Williams, travelling the country at the start of the
20th century to collect the oral traditions of folk
song and dance in the nick of time, just before the
Left Plastic classroom singers died out and the songs and dances all but
at Kennington Road
ceased. I imagine Hatherley departing his beloved
Primary School,
Preston, 1974. By
Sheffield, say, writing notes on a particularly fine
Roger Booth for bit of municipal brutalism, his train vanishing from
Lancashire County sight just as the first thump of wrecking-ball against
Council architects’ reinforced concrete echoes out across the city. So long,
department.
the wonderful Castle Market. Or the Dorman Long
Right Halifax Building
coking works tower in Middlesbrough, demolished in
Society HQ, 1968-74 September 2021 after being listed. How many of the
by BDP – listed. buildings in this book will survive much longer? •
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
74 Culture 75
Review
Through a
Left Yōsuitei, Kyoto,
built during the
Kan’ei era (1624-
window: views
1644) of early Edo
period (1603-1868),
Teahouse for Gotō
from Japan
Kanbei
JEREMIE SOUTEYRAT
Architects.
TAKUMI OTA
There’s a quick look at the windows as a literary
Buxton looks in device in storytelling, perhaps to indicate separation
or the entrance to another world, and as an element
Is the window ‘the single most fascinating Window Research Institute. The aim was to raise ‘Japanese architecture before the modernism in manga comic strips. Other displays look at the role
component of architecture’? That’s the contention awareness of the particular features and possibilities movement did not have many windows of the hole- of windows in sustainable design and the practical
of Windowology: New Architectural Views from of windows in Japanese culture to a general, as well in-the-wall type, but rather fitted shoji, fusuma and role that workshop windows have played in the
Japan, a tantalising exhibition on the history and as an architectural, audience. They’ve certainly held shutters (amado) as movable partitions in a post-and- production of Japanese crafts. An installation by
cultural significance of windows, covering their Windowology: New a long fascination for Taro, who has been working on beam framework structure,’ says Taro. Tsuda Michiko explores the relationship between
Architectural Views
JEREMIE SOUTEYRAT
manifestation in everything from traditional the Windowology research project for 15 years. For The exhibition narrative is embellished by a Japan House and adjacent streets.
from Japan, until 10
teahouses to manga. him, windows present a multiple attraction for their series of wall quotes from architects and thinkers The exhibition takes in contemporary as
April 2022, Japan
Located at the Japan House cultural centre in House, 101-111
role between inside and outside, as the place ‘where emphasising, variously, the poetic and kinetic Below O House, Tokyo,
well as traditional Japanese architecture. An
London, the exhibition is curated by architectural Kensington High St, light, wind, heat (and sometimes people!)’ come nature of window in Japanese culture: ‘Shoji can be designed by Hideyuki array of photographs by Jeremie Souteyrat shows
critic Igarashi Taro, alongside the Tokyo-based London W8 5SA in and out, and as a focal point for various human thought of as walls that let light pass through them, Nakayama Architecture. extraordinary examples of homes in dense city
behaviours and communications. Not only are they and by being moveable, they enable openings to be centre locations, their window composition carefully
Yōsuitei tea house installation at important elements of the design of the facade, but transformed in different ways,’ (Koyama Hisao). considered in relation to neighbours and contexts. A
Windowology: New Architectural Views they also they serve, he says, to show the character Two of the most eloquent exhibits focus on few, such as Sou Fujimoto’s House NA in Tokyo, take
from Japan, at Japan House, London. of a building’s interior to the outside world. In doing traditional teahouses, which developed a particularly a theatrically transparent approach – and it would
so, the exhibition suggests, windows can be thought diverse array of window designs. have been great to know what it’s like for those who
of ‘as windows to the souls of buildings’. They are The tranquil film Transition of Kikugetsutei is live in such experimental homes. Windowology
also, we learn, cultural products that ‘are tied to the a detailed look at a day in the life of Kikugetsutei, is an enjoyable and stimulating show of what
peculiarities of their local contexts’. a teahouse in the 18th century Ritsurin Garden in is undoubtedly an intriguing subject. I’d have
Anyone who’s ever dipped into Junichiro Takamatsu. We watch as the teahouse is opened welcomed, however, more narrative and context
Tanizaki’s famous aesthetics essay In Praise of up in the morning, and later closed at night in a than is perhaps possible in a one-gallery exhibition
Shadows will have got a sense of a deeper cultural finely honed ritual of considerable time and effort. in order to form a deeper understanding of the
appreciation of the nuances of light and shadow This captures both the changing quality of light special character of Japanese windows, and why they
in Japan than seems customary in the West. This throughout the day and night and the dynamism developed the way they did. Fortunately, help is at
exhibition sets out the very different approach to of the screens in motion, including a nifty corner- hand. For those wanting to delve further, there is a
windows in traditional Japanese architecture. Rather turning detail which allows partitions to be moved very nice set of accompanying booklets to the show
than static elements, they form hashirama sōchi around different sides of the building. outlining the Window Research Institute’s further
JEREMIE SOUTEYRAT
– devices between structural columns consisting of This is a large structure in contrast to the tiny research into topics such as window ethnology,
sliding screens, partitions and shutters of varying 17th century Yosuitei teahouse in Kyoto. Despite its dialectology, linguistics and behaviorology.
PHOTO CREDIT
design, translucency, framing and layering. These diminutive size, this contains 13 different window There are also plans for more publications and
include the shoji sliding screens of translucent panels, openings in one room, all designed to enhance research, including, Taro hopes, an encyclopedia of
and fusama opaque partitions. the tea-drinking experience, whether through windowology. •
The RIBA Journal March 2022 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
Culture 77
Competition
ISTOCK-HAPABAPA
film Parasite and asked deep questions about
the possibility of anti-racism in architecture as a
profession and beyond.
The award-winning RIBA Journal is now giving
you the chance to have your say with a writing
competition run in collaboration with RIBA Future
Architects Network. Above Entries to Network are designed to support, inspire and give a
RIBA Jobs is the official job board How can RIBA Jobs help you? We want to hear from and feature the voices of the Future Writers voice to architecture students, pre-qualification, and
• Online job board makes it easy to filter and competition tackle the
of the Royal Institute of British search for your specialty – set up your search
architecture students and early career professionals
(part 1, part 2 or studying for part 3) to showcase the
pressing issues facing
those who shape our
early career architecture professionals, as they move
from study to practice.
Architects, exclusively positioned to requirements and get relevant jobs straight to
voice of the next generation.
We are looking for bright, original submissions
environments. Future Architects is a way for emerging architects
to engage with the profession at the start of their
support the architecture profession. your inbox of 800-1,000 words that give an insight into design career and offers continuing support throughout the
• Exclusive jobs you won’t find advertised in the making, the ideas, strategies and techniques educational journey.
that go into making up architecture. Entries should Our writing competition deadline is Monday 4
anywhere else be aligned with the three main sections of the RIBA April 2022 and the winning article(s) will be featured
• Friendly team who are here to help Journal: Buildings, Intelligence and Culture. Articles on ribaj.com. •
• Access to informative blog posts and should be in one of the following categories: Enter now at ribaj.com/future-writers-2022
• Building/place: A study of a building – new or
guidance on CV writing, portfolio creation, refurbished – or place Evaluation panel:
architect Salary Guide and more • Tech/practice: An informative piece on an industry Sarah Maafi Guest lecturer, Technical University
innovation or hot topic for architects of Munich, winner Future
• People: A profile of a person or practice connected Architects writing competition 2021
with architecture, in the UK or internationally Lucy Watson Commissioning editor, Financial
The judging panel, chaired by RIBA Journal Times
contributing editor Chris Foges, will include Nana Biamah- Architect, teacher, writer and
Follow us professional architectural journalists and emerging Ofosu director of Studio NYALI
@RIBAJobs architects. Chris Foges Contributing editor, RIBA Journal,
This competition and RIBA Future Architects chair of the panel
jobs.architecture.com
ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
68 Buildings Obituary 79
Xxxxxxx
IN MEMORIAM
Max Fordham
Balkrishna
ELECTED 1951, BRISTOL
Alexander Henry
Bannerman
Doshi
John Reginald Spratley
ELECTED 1954, HENLEY-ON-
Max Fordham had a transformative influence on has guided the growth of Max Fordham LLP to its THAMES
building design. He started out as a heating engineer, current size of over 250 people with 120 partners.
became a services designer, introduced us to building Early projects included the Alexandra Road John Michael Moore
physics and was at the forefront of sustainability estate with Neave Brown, where heating emitters ELECTED 1955, ORPINGTON
before the word was in common currency. He was were built into concrete party walls, and the RMC
Podcast featuring conversations a polymath with an enquiring mind that knew few headquarters with Ted Cullinan, a prototypical low-
Granville Trevor Dodgson
ELECTED 1958, ILKLEY
with leading architects, talking boundaries. Born in north London to a journalist energy building with skylights in an earth-covered
and a child psychiatrist, he received a progressive roof. Both are now listed. Our own work with Max
about their work, their clients, education at Dartington Hall School that fired his started with the New Environmental Office for the
John Finlay Walls
ELECTED 1958, LIPHOOK
themselves. interest in creative design and craftsmanship, and a Building Research Establishment and the theatre for
natural sciences degree from Cambridge, giving him Bedales school, and was followed by headquarters for James Gordon Anderson
the ability to engage in any conversation and take it in the National Trust and the Woodland Trust, and The ELECTED 1959, HAMILTON
Their obsessions, how they operate a challenging new direction. Hive library in Worcester. All were precedent-setting
Colin Percival Smart
and where it goes right (and wrong) It was always slightly risky taking Max to meet
a client for the first time; you were never quite sure
low-energy buildings using natural daylighting and
ventilation, each carefully monitored. Max had an
ELECTED 1961, ST ALBANS
whether his idiosyncracies would be appreciated. I insatiable curiosity about how buildings worked, and Marke Ellie Markovitz
Listen now at ribaj.com remember introducing him to a client at the National
Trust and listening while he explained that the
always learned from previous experience.
Max was recognised by his own profession,
ELECTED 1961, HERZLIYA
PITUACH
most economic way to use solar energy in a deep- which gave him the CIBSE gold medal in 1997 and
John McFarlane
Acclaimed Indian architect plan office building was to offset lighting loads with acknowledged him as Britain’s most influential
ELECTED 1962, OMAGH
glare-free northlights. With eyes looking upwards services engineer. RIBA made him an honorary
Balkrishna Doshi will receive the he did the mental arithmetic to prove it, adding with fellow, and the RSA celebrated him as a Royal
David Richard Walker
RIBA Royal Gold Medal 2022 in a chuckle ‘Of course I may be out by a factor of ten!’. Designer for Industry. Some would say his OBE was ELECTED 1962, NSW
With a different client that might not have inspired not quite sufficient recognition for the pioneer of a AUSTRALIA
April, one of the world’s highest confidence, but he got the job and his philosophy new scientific and professional discipline.
honours for architecture. inspired the design of the building. An important
Liverpool part of his legacy comes from his
Metropolitan Donald Malcolm
It was Sir Leslie Martin, then head of the Cathedral. He
teaching. Tarnloved being at the centre of intellectual Gallagher
worked with the Art and ELECTED 1966, BARNET
architecture school at Cambridge, who suggested debate, where he could bring scientific understanding
Listen to the latest RIBAJ Meets as that Max could use his science education to
Architecture Department
toofthe humanistic
the Roman Catholic
study of architecture. He taught me
Alan Porter Richards
atArchdiocese.
Cambridge in the late 1960s, and taught with me in
he gives Eleanor Young a rare insight become a creative services engineer. After a short
ELECTED 1969, MILTON
DIRK LINDNER FOR ERIC PARRY ARCHITECTS
apprenticeship he joined the fledgling Building Bath for nearly 20 years. He was above all a holistic KEYNES
into how Ahmedabad and his studio Group at Arup in 1961; led by Derek Sugden and thinker, whose conceptual approach combined with
there taught him the importance of Philip Dowson, it later became Arup Associates.
In 1966 Max set up his own practice with his
a pragmatism unconstrained by convention, and a
belief that a good idea could always be practically
Peter Maxwell Atkinson
ELECTED 1974, FOULDEN
sound and silence to design, about wife Taddy, who died in 2017, and with whom he realised. ‘Start with the edge of the universe as a
flexibility and rejoicing, and putting had three sons, Jason, Cato and Finn. It was always boundary’, he would say, ‘and quickly narrow down To inform the RIBA of
Find RIBAJ meets on to be a kind of family business, with collaboration to a specific problem’. It is the breadth of his vision – the death of a member,
people first.
NO CREDIT
and partnership at the heart of the organisation: ‘a and the infectious chuckle – for which he will always please email membership.
your podcast app and responsibility-sharing scheme, not a profit-sharing be remembered. • services@riba.org with
at ribaj.com/meets scheme’, as Max often said. It is a set of principles that Peter Clegg is senior partner at Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios details of next of kin
The RIBA Journal March 2019 ribaj.com ribaj.com The RIBA Journal March 2022
Culture 81
Feedback
Exchange
February 2022
Can anyone please tell me when it was that 66 Portland In the UK, the vast majority of clay bricks are fired
Architecture’ (President, RIBAJ, January 2022)? To my pollutants from the air. Bricks made at traditional/
mind, it has always been not only the House, but also the heritage plants fired using coke (purified coal), oil or
interior design terms. Home, of British Architecture. wood make up only a small proportion of the market.
The latest releases for Anthony Philpott, Berkshire Compared to other cladding materials, clay brick
ribaj.com
ribaj.com
Editor
Eleanor Young
Deputy editor
Jan-Carlos Kucharek
Managing editor
Isabelle Priest
Contributing editor
Chris Foges
Sub editing
Alysoun Coles
Simon Aldous
Design
Linda Byrne
Production
Richard Blackburn
Jane Rogers
Account manager,
Midlands and North
Sunil Shah
+44 (0) 7501 466 660
Account manager,
London and South
John Ward
+44 (0) 7741 265 696
Advertising and
digital support
Barbara Tognini
+44 (0) 20 7496 8326
RIBA Publishing
marketing
Charmian Beedie
ar
chi
tec
tur
alac
ous
ticfini
shes
Publishing director
Helen Castle
RALPH DEAKIN / RIBA COLLECTIONS
Telephone
+44 (0) 20 7496 8300
Fax
+44 (0) 207 374 8500
Email Her
balHous
eof
fices
,London.
firstname.surname
@riba.org
SonaSpr
ayK-13i
ngreyappl
ieddi
rec
tlyont
ool
dconc
ret
esl
abt
oref
urbi
shandac
ous
ti
cal
l
ytr
eatt
hiss
tunni
ngt
wo-
stor
ey,
Manhatt
anlof
tst
yleof
fice.
Subscribe to RIBAJ:
Print + Digital
Cathedral of Syracuse UK £180 ex VAT
Whet
heritbef
orafit-
out,r
efurbi
shmentornewbui
l
d,t
aki
ngof
ficeac
ous
ti
css
eri
ous
lyc
ans
igni
ficant
lyi
mpr
ovet
he
RoW £225 ex VAT
Ortygia, Sicily, 480 BC onwards Digital £90 ex VAT oc
cupant
sheal
thandproducti
vit
y.
subscriptions.ribaj@
riba.org
The small island of Ortygia, part of the historical finally returned to its previous use and transformed
Wit
hourrangeof5sprayappl
ied,ac
oust
icdecor
ati
vefini
shesf
rom t
extur
edi
ndus
tri
alc
hic
,tot
hes
moot
hes
tac
ous
ti
c
centre of Syracuse in Sicily, is populated by again by the Normans. Further additions were the
numerous architectural landmarks from different 15th century marble floor and the Baroque facade,
pl
ast
eronthemarket
,therei
safinishtos
uitev
eryproj
ectandbudget
.
RIBA Journal
eras, reflecting the rich history of the city and its completed in 1753. The structure of the Greek ribaj.com Cr
edi
ttoTPBennet
t,BW Wor
kpl
aceEx
per
ts&T
om Gr
eenPhot
ogr
aphy
.
region. This variety is encapsulated by the splendid temple, as can be seen in this 1930s’ photograph, was Published by RIBA
1834 Ltd
cathedral, which stands at the heart of Ortygia. The never demolished but instead incorporated in the Registered office:
first important building on this site was the renowned church’s walls, and its columns are still clearly visible 66 Portland Place,
London W1B 1AD
Temple of Athena (480 BC), which was converted into from both inside and outside the building. This
a church in the early Middle Ages and later became unique feature has earned the cathedral the status of a Reprographics by
PH Media
the city’s cathedral. It was probably used as a mosque Unesco World Heritage Site. • Printed by Warners
in the 9th century during Arab domination, and was Valeria Carullo Midlands plc
January2022
The RIBA Journal March 2021 ribaj.com
ribaj.com
THE FINEST IN
WASHROOM EXPERIENCE
Complete washroom solutions tailored to your users’ needs