Professional Documents
Culture Documents
As of 2020, there were >100 approved peptides with therapeutic or formulation at Liverpool John Moores University,
mentored by Gillian A. Hutcheon and Christopher R.
diagnostic applications. However, a complete database providing Coxon. Her PhD research is focused on the
development and the formulation of novel small
information on marketed peptides is not freely available, making the peptide antagonists of the calcitonin gene-related
peptide receptor (CGRP-R), as a novel treatment for
peptide chemists’ job of designing future peptide drug candidates migraine.
challenging. Unlike the rules for small-molecule drugs, there is no general Paolo Dognini graduated cum
set of guidelines for designing a successful peptide-based drug. In this laude in medicinal chemistry
and pharmaceutical
review, together with our freely available database (PepTherDia, http:// technologies from the
University of Pavia in 2018. In
peptherdia.herokuapp.com), we provide insights into what a successful 2019, he entered the DTA3/
peptide therapeutic or diagnostic agent looks like and lay the foundation MSCA COFUND PhD
Fellowship Programme in
for establishing a set of rules to help future medicinal chemists to design Applied Biosciences for Health
and is currently undertaking doctoral studies in
peptide candidates with increased approval rates. medicinal chemistry at Liverpool John Moores
University, mentored by Francesca Giuntini and
Christopher R. Coxon. His research focusses on the
synthesis and development of new peptide conjugates
Introduction with applications as multifunctional drugs, diagnostic
agents, and materials. A particular focus is on
Following the approval of the first peptide therapeutic agent, the 51-amino acid (AA) hormone nucleophilic aromatic substitution to couple peptide
insulin, in 1923 [1,2], drug discovery has been progressively expanding into the chemical space cysteine residues with perfluoroaromatic compounds.
between small molecules and large proteins. Subsequently, a significant number of peptides (and Christopher R. Coxon is an
peptidomimetics) have received regulatory approval. Recently, peptides emerged as novel associate professor in
synthetic chemistry and a
modalities for various applications in the therapeutic and diagnostic markets, providing new Bicentennial Research Leader
opportunities for the modulation of difficult targets. Since the second half of the last century, the in the School of Engineering
and Physical Sciences at
number of peptides on the therapeutics and diagnostics market has steadily increased, reaching
Heriot-Watt University, UK.
the milestone of >100 approved peptide drugs in 2020 (Fig. 1). These drugs represent a unique His research programme
class of chemical compounds that bridges the gap between small molecules (typically molar mass focusses on peptide drug
discovery and using peptides as tools for biology. In
<500 g/mol) and large biologics (typically molar mass >5000 g/mol). Occupying an intermediate 2010 he completed his PhD in the development of
region of complexity and molar mass, they combine many of the benefits of these two categories. novel inhibitors of protein kinases at The Northern
Institute for Cancer Research, Newcastle University,
The main disease areas presently treated with peptide drugs are metabolic disorders, cancers, and before postdoctoral appointments in chemical biology
cardiovascular diseases, with emerging therapeutic applications in the areas of infectious diseases, and peptide chemistry at Durham University from
pain, and urinary tract, gastrointestinal, and respiratory disorders [1,3]. Given that the incidence 2010 to 2013. He previously held academic positions
at Durham University and Liverpool John Moores
University (between 2013 and 2019) and is now a
director and cofounder of Pepmotec Ltd.
Corresponding author: Coxon, C.R. (c.coxon@hw.ac.uk)
peptides approved In 2010, Vlieghe et al. reviewed and listed the synthetic therapeu-
tic peptides that have reached the main pharmaceutical markets
Total number of
100
(USA, Europe, and Japan) [10]. Six years later, Raghava and colla-
borators filed a repository (PEPlife) to provide the scientific com-
munity with data on peptide half-lives [11], followed, 1 year later,
50 by a database containing 852 US Food and Drug Administration
(FDA)-approved biologics, among which 28 were peptides [12].
Reviews KEYNOTE REVIEW
1410 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com
Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021 REVIEWS
TABLE 1
Main advantages of peptides over small molecules and proteinsa
Advantages of peptides over small molecules Advantages of peptides over proteins
Higher selectivity and specificity Lower molecular weight
Higher affinity and potency Easier synthetic procedures
Lower risk of systemic toxicityb Lower production costs
Lower risk of accumulation in tissues Deeper penetration into target tissue
Lower immunogenicity
the carbonyl carbon of one to the nitrogen atom of another with BOX 1
formal loss of water’ [17]. By contrast, the recommendations of the
IUPAC-IUB Joint Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature Glossary of terms and resources.
(JCBN) defines a peptide as a chemical entity presenting from 2 Glossary
to 50 AA residues [18], while the currently used regulatory FDA Amino acid (AA): every residue that presents both a carboxylic
definition delineates a peptide as ‘any polymer composed of 40 or acid and an amine functional group, capable of forming an amide
bond. Natural AAs, of which there are 20, are encoded by
fewer amino acids’, regardless of their production method [19,20].
proteinogenic AAs, presenting the amino group and the
Finally, the European Medicines Agency (EMA), instead of describ- distinctive side chain appended to the a-carbon with an overall L-
ing peptides based on their size, considers them as small molecules configuration. Non-natural AAs are amino acidic residues with a D-
if chemically synthesised, while treats them as biological entities if configuration, with non-native side chains, or bearing the amino
they are extracted from natural sources or produced with recom- group in non-a-positions (e.g., b-amino acids), as well as peptoid
binant methodologies [21], which highlights the fact that the monomers (e.g., sarcosine).
definition of peptide remains ambiguous. Constitutional members: group comprising three different types
of building block (natural AA, non-natural AA, and modification)
At this stage, the reader might state that this definition can be
identified for the purpose of analysing peptide structures.
considered as a philosophical debate that could elicit controversial Diagnostic peptide: peptide used to reveal, locate, and define a
answers. Indeed, the scientific community differs greatly on where pathological process.
to stop using the term ‘peptide’ and start using the term ‘protein’. Heterologous peptide: peptide the structure of which derives
In Box 1, the definition of peptide that led our research, together from a rational design and is not clearly related to any natural
with other terminologies are explained. compound.
Data collection and calculations Modifications: non-amino acidic building blocks existing in
peptide structures; these include lipids, sugars, or other chemical
A repository of 105 compounds was obtained by searching in
entities that do not fall under any of the other definitions.
DrugBank [22], FDA and EMA web pages [19,23], Pharmaceutical Natural peptide: peptide presenting an identical structure to the
and Medical Devices Agency website [24], and Drug Central web- biomolecule of origin.
site [25]. The key inclusion and exclusion criteria used in the Peptide analogue: peptide originated from modifications of
curation of PepTherDia are listed in Table 2. Examples of peptides natural molecules.
not included and the reason for their exclusion are shown in Table Peptide: chemical entity comprising at least two AAs, linked by an
3. With the aim of providing each peptide with a complete profile amide bond, with a maximum of 50 AAs and a molar mass
<5000 g/mol.
comprising relevant information regarding terminal half-life, pro-
Therapeutic peptide: peptide capable of healing or treating a
tein binding, therapeutic indications, and routes of administra- disease or a disorder.
tion, specific searches were carried out in DrugBank [22], National Key resources
Centre for Advancing Translational Sciences web page [26], Drugs. Chemicalize: https://chemicalize.com
com [27], and pharmaceutical companies’ websites, using the DrugBank: https://go.drugbank.com/
generic name of the individual peptide. References specific to each EMA: www.ema.europa.eu/en
approved peptide as well as SMILES codes used to calculate the FDA: www.fda.gov/home
PDMA: www.pmda.go.jp/english/
peptide molar mass values can be found on our website PepTher-
PepTherDia: http://peptherdia.herokuapp.com
Dia. PubChem: https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
Structural composition analysis of approved peptide
agents
As discussed and defined earlier, peptide medicines generally
comprise natural AAs, unnatural AAs, and non-amino acidic mod- defined single macrocycle and, therefore, the members of each
ifications. Fig. 2 provides an example of how the peptide dapto- macrocycle were not counted here.
mycin can be divided into the above components. However, in Each constitutional member can be further classified as polar,
some cases, such as the glycopeptide antibiotics (dalbavancin, acidic, basic, nonpolar aliphatic, or aromatic based on its structur-
telavancin, oritavancin, and teicoplanin), this is a complex (if al and physicochemical characteristics. For the natural amino
not impossible) task. Similarly, the complexity of some multicyclic acidic residues, the designations polar, acidic, basic, nonpolar
peptides does not allow the unambiguous identification of a aliphatic, or aromatic, derived from literature precedent [28],
www.drugdiscoverytoday.com 1411
REVIEWS Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021
TABLE 2
Key inclusion and exclusion criteria for the PepTherDia database
Structural criteria Other criteria
Lower length limit: two AAs linked by an amide bond Only non-insulin peptide drugs are included
Upper length limit: <50 AAs and molar mass <5000 g/mola Only peptides for human use are included
Peptides conjugated to other molecules are included, as long as they Theragnostic and diagnostic peptides are included
meet the other inclusion criteria (especially molar mass; i.e., antibody–
Reviews KEYNOTE REVIEW
TABLE 3
Examples of excluded compounds and reasons for exclusiona
Compound not included Reason for exclusion
Peginesatide 42 AAs + PEG results in a molar mass >5000 g/mol
Ritonavir and lopinavir No amide bond between two amino acids
Saralasin Peptide withdrawn
Bulevirtide Molar mass >5000 g/mol
Glatiramer acetate Mixture of random-sized peptides that comprise four AAs; no defined structure
a
Peptides withdrawn have not been included, with the exception of sinapultide, for which production has been deliberately ceased by the company in favour of the study of an improved
formulation.
are generally ascribed by the nature of the side chain. Given that 2639.14 g/mol, respectively). To evaluate the possibility of bias
non-natural AA members form an amide backbone in the same in the peptide design, which might have led to the deliberate
way as natural AAs, they can be classified following the same development of peptides of certain sizes to mimic specific biomo-
principles used for natural AAs. By contrast, peptide modifications lecules, it is necessary to analyse the origin of the peptide design
are a broad and varied structural class, and their classification case by case (Fig. 3e). In this context, it emerges that natural
requires consideration of their complete structure and the way peptides account for 30% of our sample. However, peptide analo-
in which they are conjugated to the peptide. For example, in gues account for 54%. Finally, heterologous peptides account for
daptomycin (Fig. 2), decanoic acid can be classified as a nonpolar 16% of the sample. This underlines that heterologous peptides are
aliphatic modification because the carboxylic acid moiety difficult to design a priori and are mostly discovered by library
becomes part of an amide and its contribution to the final polarity screening. In light of these findings, we can state that, unsurpris-
predominantly increases lipophilicity. ingly, there is a clear trend (in 84% of the cases) toward following
The complete list of non-natural amino acids and modifica- the route of inspiration from nature as a greater promise of success
tions, together with their polarity classification, can be found on and that the bimodal distribution could be attributed to the
the PepTherDia website. characteristics of the natural molecules that have inspired the
Molar mass distribution and origin of peptide design design. Examples that demonstrate this are the natural nonapep-
Thanks to improvements in synthetic and manufacturing tech- tide oxytocin and the 32-membered peptide calcitonin. Here, in
nologies, it is now possible to synthesise ever-larger peptides in a both cases, their length results from the size of the natural mole-
short time, yielding high purities and quantities. Nonetheless, cule of origin.
from our study, it emerged that most approved peptides (68%) Natural side-chain amino acid occurrence
are relatively ‘small’ peptides, comprising 2–16 constitutional Among all the constitutional members, most (around 81%) are
members, with a second minor cluster (27%) of larger size peptides represented by natural L-AAs. The residual 19% comprises non-
with 28–37 members (Fig. 3a). This is mirrored in a bimodal natural AAs and modifications. A careful analysis of the AA resi-
molar mass distribution in the ranges 300–1750 g/mol (major: dues contained in each approved peptide (Fig. 3c) showed that the
71%) and 2750–4250 g/mol (minor: 22%), with a remarkable lack most common AAs in the sequences are the nonpolar aliphatic
of mid-length approved peptides (Fig. 3b). Hence, the data suggest leucine (L) and glycine (G), followed by the polar serine (S). By
that there are two main groups of peptides: low molar mass and contrast, the least common residues are methionine (M), histidine
high molar mass with only a few examples in between (e.g., (H) and isoleucine (I). This is largely in agreement with the
sinapultide and ziconotide, with molar mass of 2469.45 and occurrence of natural AAs in proteins: in nature, leucine (L)
1412 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com
Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021 REVIEWS
Decanoic acid Trp (W) Asp (D) Thr (T) Gly (G)
FIGURE 2
Daptomycin and its constitutional members. Abbreviations: 3-Me-Glu, 3-methyl-glutamic acid; Ala, alanine; Asn, asparagine; Gly, glycine; Kyn, kynurenine; Orn,
ornithine; Ser, serine; Trp, tryptophan.
accounts for 9.1%, serine (S) for 6.8%, glycine (G) for 7.2%, and D-AAs with natural side chains account only for a small per-
alanine (A) for 7.8%, being the most common amino acids. By centage (4% of the total AAs with natural side chains) and are
contrast, methionine (M) and histidine (H) account each only for mainly represented by phenylalanine, alanine, tryptophan, and
2.3%, cysteine (C) for 1.9%, and tryptophan (W) for 1.4%, being arginine. The selective replacement of L-AAs by their enantiomers
the least common AA residues found in proteins [28]. The occur- (D-AAs) can protect the molecule from protease degradation [30].
rence of cysteine (C) in pharmaceutical peptides is higher than in This is a common technique to obtain proteolytic stabilisation by
proteins, because of the frequent use of disulfide bonds as a tool for backbone modification, even if this causes conformational
macrocyclisation (see ‘Conformational and shape properties’). In changes that might affect biological activity. An example is the
general, the AA composition of proteins and peptides is highly somatostatin-like peptide octreotide, in which natural phenylala-
variable; some AAs might occur only once or not at all in a given nine and tryptophan are replaced with their mirror-image forms,
peptide and might be repeated several times in another peptide leading to a 100-fold increase in the terminal half-life [31,32].
sequence. An example of where this is seen is the repetition of the Non-natural amino acid occurrence
moiety KL4 in the peptide sinapultide, designed to mimic the C- In peptide drug discovery, the use of non-natural AAs as well as
terminal domain of the surfactant protein B [29]. conjugation with non-amino acidic members are common tech-
www.drugdiscoverytoday.com 1413
REVIEWS Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021
(a) (b)
Reviews KEYNOTE REVIEW
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
(i) (j)
FIGURE 3
Structural trends in the pool of approved peptide therapeutics and diagnostics. (a) Number of constitutional members distribution; (b) molar mass (g/mol)
distribution; (c) occurrence of L-amino acids (AAs) (light blue) and D-AAs (green); (d) most frequently encountered non-natural AAs, in pink, and modifications, in
purple; (e) peptide origin; (f) peptide structure, divided into linear, monocyclic, and multicyclic; (g) macrocycle size, shown as the number of constitutional
members per cycle; (h) type of bond that forms the cycle within the peptide structure; (i) C-terminal modifications; and (j) N-terminal modifications.
1414 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com
Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021 REVIEWS
niques to overcome peptide limitations and have been widely adequately replicate the effects of tryptophan aromatic interac-
explored in both protein and peptide design [33,34]. In Fig. 3d, tions. In fact, as with any modification, the consequence of these
the most common non-natural amino acids and structural mod- replacements upon the peptide potency needs careful assessment,
ifications in approved peptides are reported. because it has been demonstrated that substitution of tryptophan
Position-specific incorporation of non-natural AAs bearing a with 1-Nal or 2-Nal decreases the potency of cholecystokinin
variety of bespoke side chains can provide improvements in analogues [43]. Nonetheless, this strategy has been successfully
peptide properties, activities, and functions [35]. In this study, used in the development of GnRH receptor (GnRH-R) antagonists
www.drugdiscoverytoday.com 1415
REVIEWS Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021
chemical and PK properties of peptide drugs through enhanced cyclosporine is the only case in which a marketed peptide com-
solubility and an increase in bioavailability and oral absorption prising more than five members (11 in this case) completely lacks
[21,45]. the polar component. This is reflected in its very long half-life
Other modifications can include metal cation-chelating agents (19 h) [56] and the fact that, after administration, 90% is found to
(DOTA in dotatate and DTPA in pentetreotide), typically found in be bound to serum proteins, mainly lipoproteins [57]. In this
diagnostic agents or linkers (2-amino-4,6-dimethyl-3-oxo-3H-phe- respect, the classification of natural and non-natural AAs is based
noxazine-1,9-dicarbonyl in dactinomycin). Finally, pyroglutamic solely on the nature of their side chain. Assuming that the impact
Reviews KEYNOTE REVIEW
acid (cyclic lactam of glutamic acid) is naturally found at the N- of the backbone on the final properties is largely consistent with
terminus of many neuronal peptides and hormones, but its func- the size of the peptide, its polar contribution has not been consid-
tion in living cells is still unclear [49]. In drug design, N-pyroglu- ered. This is the clearest way to distinguish between hydrophilic
tamyl formation is a common modification used to cap the N- and hydrophobic AAs, without overshadowing the contribution of
terminus to modulate peptide activity and increase resistance to the side chain with that of the backbone. To provide the reader
degradation [50]. Indeed, in some cases, pyroglutamyl is essential with a visual overview of the relative physical property balance,
to achieve full biological activity [51]. This modification is found the colour map in Fig. 4b shows the percentage composition of
in eight approved peptides, such as leuprolide and all GnRH each approved peptide when the constitutional members are
agonists. colour-coded according to their side chain properties: polar, acid-
Notably, voxilaprevir was the first example of fluorinated pep- ic, basic, nonpolar aliphatic, and aromatic.
tide on the market, bearing four fluorine atoms: a difluoromethy- Conformational properties
lene adjacent to a benzopyrazine modification involved in Another important aspect of structural composition is the propor-
forming a macrocyclic structure, and a difluoromethyl group on tion of peptide drugs and diagnostics that are either linear or
an aliphatic non-natural AA: 1-amino-2-(difluoromethyl)cyclo- contain a macrocycle. In nature, cyclic peptides of various sizes
propane-1-carboxylic acid. We predict that the exploitation of (from 8 to 50 AAs) occur in all kingdoms of life. Their enhanced
fluorine in peptides will follow what has already happened in stability and advantageous biopharmaceutical properties make
small molecules, by becoming a key medicinal chemistry tool in their application in drug design common [58]. Indeed, 53% of
which the judicious addition of a small and highly electron- the marketed peptides are linear, whereas 47% present one or more
withdrawing atom, such as fluorine, has been shown to have a macrocycles in their structure (Fig. 3f). Among the approved cyclic
key role in improving PK and physicochemical properties [52]. peptides, 39% are of natural origin, 55% are analogues and only
Hence, in the current peptide drug discovery pipeline, fluorination 6% are heterologous; perhaps nature has once again demonstrated
has been found to increase thermal stability and proteolytic sta- how to develop stable, biocompatible peptides and, consequently,
bility, without affecting biological activity [53]. This has been is a rich source of inspiration for candidates with optimal drug-like
applied to glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1), in which the substitu- properties. Interestingly, our analysis highlighted that, over-
tion with hexafluoroleucine in different positions has been shown whelmingly, peptide macrocycles comprise five-to-seven residues,
to improve both binding affinity and protease (DPP IV) stability with only a few exceptions (e.g., nesiritide and carperitide com-
[54]. prise a 17-membered ring) (Fig. 3g). Examples of peptides with five-
Polarity trends to-seven-membered macrocycles include oxytocin, desmopressin,
Further examination of the peptide structures reveals that there is, lanreotide, and eptifibatide. In general, smaller macrocycles tend
on average, a balance between polar and hydrophobic residues, to have greater conformational stability because of physical
when the polar contribution is derived by the summation of the restraints and fewer rotatable bonds. As such, macrocyclisation
polar, basic, and acidic constitutional members and the hydro- is a common medicinal chemistry technique used to enhance
phobic contribution is the summation of the aromatic and ali- peptide conformational stability and restrict the usual peptide
phatic constitutional members. Most approved peptides contain chain flexibility [59,60]. This can stabilise the peptide conforma-
from 35% to 75% of polar residues, indicating that these molecules tion for optimal receptor complexation and confer a protein-like
do not present a high excess of either hydrophilic or lipophilic secondary and tertiary structure [60–62].
components (Fig. 4a). This perhaps should not be a surprise, given Depending on the desired site of cyclisation, there are various
that both polar and hydrophobic components are generally re- strategies to generate cyclic peptides [63]. These can involve the
quired for drugs with good PK profiles. A small number of outliers peptide head (peptide C-terminal moiety), the peptide tail (pep-
that comprise 100% polar or 100% hydrophobic building blocks tide N-terminal moiety), or AA side chains. According to our
are present. However, these exceptions are generally represented findings (Fig. 3h), the most common technique is side chain-to-
by a few building blocks (two, three, or five) and their small size side chain cyclisation (58% of all the marketed cyclic peptides),
makes these peptides more similar to small molecules. Indeed, the with 25 out of 26 side chain-to-side chain macrocycles formed by a
hydrophilic dipeptide spaglumic acid as well as the hydrophobic disulfide bond between cysteine thiol pairs. The exception is
tripeptides ACE inhibitors (enalapril, perindopril, ramipril, quina- bremelanotide, in which a lactam is formed between the amine
pril, and trandolapril) respect the Lipinski’s Ro5 tailored for small side chain of a lysine residue and the carboxylic acid side chain of
molecules (computed by ChemAxon and Chemicalize [55]). Other an aspartic acid residue. However, disulfide bridges are not always
outliers are represented by the growth hormone secretagogue metabolically stable in vivo, limiting their application [64]. Macro-
receptor agonist macimorelin, comprising only three building cycles within a peptide can be formed also by head-to-side chain
blocks, and the hydrophobic antiviral peptides telaprevir, boce- cyclisation (24%), mainly via lactamisation between the C-termi-
previr, and ombitasvir, comprising four or five members. Finally, nal carboxylic acid and a side chain amine (e.g., lysine). The head-
1416 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com
Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021 REVIEWS
(a)
FIGURE 4
Peptide polarity evaluation. (a) Polarity distribution within the pool of approved peptides; (b) Colour-coded plot to show the aliphatic, aromatic, polar, basic, and
acidic contributions in each peptide under evaluation. Peptide ID refers to the database number assigned in PepTherDia.
to-tail cyclisation between the N-and C-termini (7%) generates an backbone is reduced because cyclisation removes the free N-and C-
all-amide end-to-end cyclic lactam, thus abrogating exopeptidase termini that are targeted by amino- and carboxy-peptidases, re-
hydrolysis. Finally, another cyclisation strategy encountered in spectively [65]. This explanation bears out in the approved pep-
two out of 47 cyclic peptides (i.e., grazoprevir and elcatonin) is side tides, with the mean experimental terminal half-life of cyclic
chain-to-tail macrocyclisation. When the head and/or the tail of peptides compared with linear peptides being 27 h and 12 h,
the peptide is involved in the macrocycle, protease access to the respectively.
www.drugdiscoverytoday.com 1417
REVIEWS Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021
Among marketed peptide therapeutics and diagnostics, 38% favourable pharmacological properties. The highlighted common
present an amidated C-terminus, whereas 10% present an acetyl threads that bring together the approved peptides do not have the
group at the N-terminus (Fig. 3i, j). Modifications of the peptide N- presumption of being strict rules to follow, but rather they should
terminus also include the addition of pyroglutamic acid (7%) or be seen as a means of lending a hand to peptide designers to avoid
deamination of the last AA (4%). Similar to head-to-tail cyclisa- certain pitfalls during early drug discovery stages. Indeed, some of
tion, this abrogates exopeptidase hydrolysis by masking N-and C- the above trends might be particularly subjective toward certain
termini [66]. Moreover, N-terminal acetylation or C-amidation disease areas or routes of administration.
Reviews KEYNOTE REVIEW
precludes ionisation and hydrogen bonding of NH2 and COOH Forecasting a starring role for peptides in the coming decades, we
groups, respectively [67,68], thus better mimicking natural pro- anticipate that new clear trends and, perhaps, rules in structural
teins. composition will emerge beyond our observations, leading to im-
proved rational peptide drug design. Although the mainstay of
Concluding remarks and prospects bioactive peptide discovery remains an analogue-based approach
Together with the database PepTherDia, this review offers the (modifying naturally derived peptides or protein epitopes), new
possibility of exploring common trends in approved peptide drugs medicinal chemistry strategies, such as peptide stapling, multicy-
and diagnostics. We have highlighted strategies most commonly clisation, novel AA synthesis, selective fluorination, peptoids, and
used in peptide drug design, which have successfully brought improved in silico design, should accelerate the future approval rate
these peptides to the market. The trends underlined cannot be of new designed or heterologous peptide pharmaceutical agents. In
ascribed to luck or coincidence. Most approved peptides (84%) the medium term, a combination of both naturally derived and
follow the rules ‘established’ by nature over several millennia of rationally designed strategies is likely to be the most successful route
evolution because they are naturally derived or analogues of to fulfilling the increasing need for chemical entities to treat new or
natural compounds. It is open to debate among drug discovery previously untreatable diseases, from cancer to infections, cardio-
scientists whether it is important to follow the route of nature to vascular, and neurodegenerative diseases.
obtain a successful peptide lead or whether the exploration of
completely new chemical space and compounds through rational Conflict of interest
design and library screening is a fruitful solution. We believe that C.R.C is a director of Pepmotec Ltd, a peptide synthesis spin-out
strategies provided by nature have to be properly understood and company from Durham University, UK.
taken into account when designing new drug candidates. *The PepTherDia website contains the full list and classification
On account of this meta-analysis, we can conclude that, at of non-natural AAs and modifications together with the detailed
present, a peptide most likely to become a drug will have a molar methodologies used for data collection, computational analysis,
mass <2000 g/mol and will present a balance between hydropho- and structural analysis.
bic and polar contributions. Furthermore, careful evaluation of the
C- and N-terminal modifications will be key for the PK properties Acknowledgements
as well as for the desired activity. Moreover, if a cyclisation strategy The authors gratefully acknowledge Daniele Tomasi for the
is under evaluation, it is important for a peptide chemist to development of the website PepTherDia. This work was supported
consider a more stable small-size macrocycle (five–seven mem- by a Liverpool John Moores University Vice Chancellor’s PhD
bers). In addition to the most frequently encountered natural AAs, Scholarship (V.D’A.) and a University Alliance Doctoral Training
we have provided a list of commonly used non-natural AAs that Alliance COFUND/Marie Skodowska-Curie (European Union’s
can effectively replace the former to introduce enhanced proper- Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme, grant
ties or opportunities for further diversification. Indeed, strategies agreement No 801604) PhD Fellowship Programme in Applied
to modify a peptide through conjugation with fatty acids or sugars Biosciences for Health (P.D.). The funding sources had no
are well represented in various approvals, suggesting that they are involvement in the study design.
promising tools to modify peptidic structures while retaining
References
1 Henninot, A. et al. (2018) The current state of peptide drug discovery: back to the 9 Craik, D.J. et al. (2013) The future of peptide-based drugs. Chem. Biol. Drug Des. 81,
future? J. Med. Chem. 61, 1382–1414 136–147
2 Lau, J.L. and Dunn, M.K. (2018) Therapeutic peptides: historical perspectives, current 10 Vlieghe, P. et al. (2010) Synthetic therapeutic peptides: science and market. Drug
development trends, and future directions. Bioorg. Med. Chem. 26, 2700–2707 Discov. Today 15, 40–56
3 Tsomaia, N. (2015) Peptide therapeutics: targeting the undruggable space. Eur. J. 11 Mathur, D. et al. (2016) PEPlife: A Repository of the Half-life of Peptides. Sci Rep 6
Med. Chem. 94, 459–470 (36617), . http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/srep36617
4 Ferlay, J. et al. (2015) Cancer incidence and mortality worldwide: sources, methods 12 Usmani, S.S. et al. (2017) THPdb: database of FDA-approved peptide and protein
and major patterns in GLOBOCAN 2012. Int. J. Cancer 136, E359–E386 therapeutics. PLoS One 12, 1–12
5 Daviglus, M.L. et al. (2006) Preventing cardiovascular disease in the 21st century: 13 Davenport, A.P. et al. (2020) Advances in therapeutic peptides targeting g protein-
therapeutic and preventive implications of current evidence. Am. J. Cardiovasc. coupled receptors. Nat. Rev. Drug Discov. 19, 389–413
Drugs 2 (2), 87–101 14 Tyagi, M. et al. (2020) Drug syntheses beyond the Rule of 5. Chemistry 26, 49–
6 Zimmet, P.Z. et al. (2014) Diabetes: a 21st century challenge. Lancet Diabetes 88
Endocrinol. 2 (1), 56–64 15 Lipinski, C.A. et al. (1997) Experimental and computational approaches to estimate
7 Transparency Market Research Peptide (2019) Therapeutics Market to Expand at a solubility and permeability in drug discovery and development settings. Adv. Drug
CAGR of 7.9% from 2019 to 2027. 2019 [Accessed February 22, 2020]www. Deliv. Rev. 46, 3–25
transparencymarketresearch.com/peptide-therapeutics-market.html 16 Wager, T.T. et al. (2016) Central nervous system multiparameter optimization
8 ClinicalTrials.Gov https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/ [Accessed February 22, 2021]. desirability: application in drug discovery. ACS Chem. Neurosci. 7, 767–775
1418 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com
Drug Discovery Today Volume 26, Number 6 June 2021 REVIEWS
17 McNaught, A.D. and Wilkinson, A. (1997) IUPAC. Compendium of Chemical 43 Rodriguez, M. et al. (1991) Synthesis and biological activities of cholecystokinin
Terminology (2nd ed.), Blackwell Scientific analogues substituted in position 30 by 3-(1-naphthyl)-l-alanine [Nal(1)] or 3-(2-
18 IUPAC-IUB Joint Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature (1984) Nomenclature naphthyl)-l-alanine [Nal(2)]. Eur. J. Med. Chem. 26, 245–253
and symbolism for amino acids and peptides: recommendations 1983. Eur. J. 44 Zhang, L. and Bulaj, G. (2012) Converting peptides into drug leads by lipidation.
Biochem. 138, 9–37 Curr. Med. Chem. 19, 1602–1618
19 FDA (2019) Impact Story: Developing the Tools to Evaluate Complex Drug Products: 45 Moradi, S.V. et al. (2016) Glycosylation, an effective synthetic strategy to improve
Peptides. FDA the bioavailability of therapeutic peptides. Chem. Sci. 7 (4), 2492–2500
20 Wu, L.C. (2013) Regulatory considerations for peptide drug products. In Peptide 46 Kang, R. et al. (2008) Neural palmitoyl-proteomics reveals dynamic synaptic
Therapeutics: Strategy and Tactics for Chemistry, Manufacturing, and Controls palmitoylation HHS public access. Nature 456, 904–909
www.drugdiscoverytoday.com 1419