Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In essence, JTB must strictly monitor the purpose of the facilities granted to its customers48 as guided by the below
policy directives:
a) For Active accounts, it is mandatory that JTB personnel who are in direct contact with a given client (the
Branch Manager and/or Credit Officer) conduct an unannounced site visit to the client’s project premises (or
an announced visit to the client’s working premises where no project is being financed) twice a year. Further,
any designated JTB member who is not in direct contact with the client’s file must also conduct a site visit
once a year. The frequency of visits must increase for accounts that are classified as Special Mention or
below.
b) JTB is to reconsider the adequacy of approved facilities at least once a year and as needed, in order to
ascertain that the facilities granted to each customer are properly used, in conformity with available data on
the customer’s financial situation and volume of activities. This matter rests with the Credit Committee. The
CRR Manager must ensure that such reconsideration takes place upon every file renewal.
c) Whenever examining a real estate credit file, JTB is to verify on its own responsibility the purpose of the
credit and the repayment sources. This matter rests with the Corporate & SMEs Banking Department. The
CAD Manager must prompt the CBD Manager to ensure the strict compliance of the RM team with this
requirement.
d) Whenever financing a construction project, JTB is to verify the validity of the sale contract concluded
between the owner and the purchaser, monitor the project’s cash flows, and make sure that the purchaser is
paying the installments according to the agreed schedule. Once again, this matter rests with the Corporate &
SMEs Banking Department alongside the Credit Risk & Review Department. The CAD Manager is to prompt
both Department Managers to strictly comply with this BDL requirement.
e) JTB is to strictly adhere to the contents of the credit file as specified in BCC Circular 238, as this facilitates the
monitoring process and prevents any late detection of delinquency signals. The CAD Manager is the custodian
of such file, and must trigger all related parties (the branch, Relationship Managers or the Monitoring and
Control Unit) to provide the necessary information to ensure file completion at any moment in time.
At JTB, when a file defaults, the monitoring officers bear a portion of the responsibility. This is so because
adherence to an early warning signal philosophy should, in most cases, avoid the deterioration of a given situation
from delinquency to outright default. Such responsibility is also to be shared with the Credit Officers at the Branch
who are supposed to be the first point of contact with clients. All said, a diligent early problem recognition process
should be adhered to, as downgrading customer classifications jeopardizes the Bank's capital and depositors’
funds, and Credit Officers, whether at the Administration Department or at the Branch, should do their utmost
best to avoid any downgrade situation. For this reason, The CRR Manager should receive the following reports
issued by the Monitoring & Control Officer before their dispatch to Mr. Chairman & The Credit Committee, and
should present possible solutions to the Committee or Mr. Chairman within the stated delays below:
48
As stressed in various BDL Circulars and clearly stated in Article 161 of the Code of Money and Credit.
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 104
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | January 2016
1. Credit Administration Officers maintain a manual (Excel) table for each Term Loan granted at JTB.
2. On a monthly basis, Credit Administration Officers extract data on actual settlement from the core banking
system and drop the limit manually on their Excel files.
3. The Credit Monitoring & Control Officer double-checks all entries made by the various Credit Admin Officers,
client by client, and provides an approval to drop / change the actual limit manually on the core banking
system.
4. The Credit Monitoring & Control Officer extracts a list of clients in default and shares it with Mr. Chairman with
a copy to the CRR Manager.
5. Where a client is found to be in default with one or more outstanding bills, SOP 59 - Managing Over-due
Accounts enters into effect.
2. S/he extracts the customer position on a monthly basis from the core banking system for every client
benefitting from the Kafalat program.
3. S/he cross-checks the entries on the customer position with the required Kafalat loan balance in order to
monitor for any over-dues.
4. Where a client is found to be in default with one or more outstanding bills, SOP 59SOP 60 - Managing Over-Due
Kafalat Bills enters into effect.
5. The Officer updates the listings under preparation for all Kafalat-related reports (see the policy under the
Reporting chapter below); namely:
Kafalat & Subsidized Loans Report (weekly)
Kafalat Balances Report (weekly)
Unsettled Kafalat Bills Report (monthly) –copy to be shared with the CRR Manager
Subsidized Loans Report (quarterly).
Inputs Outputs Executors Collaborators
Core banking data on Updated Kafalat reports Credit Monitoring &
customer position Control Officer
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 120
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | January 2016
1. Based on data extracted from the core banking system, the Credit Monitoring & Control Officer produces the
report of all unsettled commercial bills.
2. Over the first 10 days of the month, the Monitoring & Control Unit contacts the relevant branches through
follow-up e-mails and letters to alert the listed clients and request prompt payment.
3. Based on the results obtained until the 10th of the month, the Credit Monitoring & Control Officer produces the
following The Unsettled Bills Report which includes:
Statistics on all overdue bills for Retail and Commercial combined
The listing of all commercial clients categorized as Active, Special and Special Mention, whose records show
unsettled bills, along with an update of branch contact results.
4. The Monitoring & Control Unit sends the Statistics portion of the above report to Mr. Chairman and the Client
Listing portion to the Credit Risk & Review Manager.
5. Over the span of 5 days, the Credit Risk & Review Manager shall attempt to contact and selected clients
together with the CBD Manager, and undertake preventive treatment procedures. All results are to be
forwarded as recommendations to Mr. Chairman and the Credit Committee.
6. The outcome of Mr. Chairman’s decision and/or of the Credit Committee’s deliberations is to be communicated
by the CAD Manager to all Junior Credit Committee members.
7. Following no progress at the end of a 30-day period, the procedures under Chapter 15.0 - M ANAGEMENT OF THE
P ROBLEM L OAN enter into effect.
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 121
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | January 2016
SOP 49 Monitoring & Reporting on the Ceilings of Credit Limits and the Single Economic Group
1. The Reporting Officer at the Credit Administration Department shall obtain the latest value of Tier 1 Capital
from the Finance Department. This value forms the basis for the ensuing monitoring and reporting procedure.
2. The Reporting Officer at the Credit Administration Department extracts the customer position of clients
representing 5% of Tier 1 capital or belonging to a Single Economic Group.
3. A pre-formulated template of the report requested by BDL is used for entering all relevant data as provided in
the Appendices and attachments to BCCL Circular 276 and BDL Circular 311.
4. When filling the template, the Reporting Officer shall observe the following guidelines:
By “facilities” is mean the higher between approved and utilized facilities. Any commercial bills issued by
the debtor or any of his/her economic group members and purchased by JTB are to be added to the total
of facilities.
Provisions, if available, are to be deducted from the above facilities
The weights provided in Appendix 3 of BCC Circular 276 are to be applied to all facilities (net of
provisions). These weights have already been pre-programmed in the Excel module that is available at the
Credit Administration Department for this purpose.
5. The Officer issues the following reports on the Single Economic Group:
Form C-8 as provided in the Appendix of BCC Circular 276
Form G-8 as provided in the Appendix of BCC Circular 276.
These forms have already been pre-programmed in the Excel module that is available at the Credit
Administration Department for this purpose.
6. The Reporting Officer shall submit the report to the CAD Manager for observation62.
7. Where the bank is in excess of any of the maximum lending limits set forth by the BDL and BCCL as calculated
through this procedure, the CAD Manager shall duly notify ALCO, and various options for balancing the excess
will have to be studied.
8. The CAD Manager shall approve of the contents prior to sending the report to the Finance Department for
submission to the BDL. A copy of the report will be shared with the CRR Manager.
62
Signatures for BDL reporting purposes are as described in the Reporting Chapter of this Manual
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 130
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | February 2016
Procedures
SOP 53 Early Problem Detection
1. As per the Policy section of the Credit Administration chapter, the CRR Manager should receive the following
reports issued by the Monitoring & Control Officer prior to their sharing with Mr. Chairman by the indicated
dates, and should formally request such reports if not received on time:
Monthly Over-Limits & Accidental Debtors Report (by the 10th of the month)
Monthly Client Listing of Overdue Discounted Bills & Acceptances Report (by the 15th of the month)
Annual Credit Performance Report (24 Branches – to be received entirely by Mid-December).
2. The CRR Manager reads through the above lists and selects those credit files that are exhibiting one or more of
the following symptoms. The CRR Manager requests the launching of a mid-cycle review process for these files
(as per Workflow Chart 1 and the methodologies described in Chapter 8.0 - T HE C REDIT A PPROVAL P ROCESS ):
One or more overdue bills
Delay in the settlement of limit excesses beyond one month
Down-grading request by the CAD
3. The CRR Manager reads through renewed files for a given month and selects those credit files that are
exhibiting one or more of the following symptoms:
Financials indicative of an unrealistic repayment structure
Delays in submitting financials
Formation of hardcore overdraft
Slow account movement
Kiting between banks
Willingness to pay very steep interest rates
Frequent returns of issued checks for insufficient funds
The existence of any previous problems surrounding the borrower
The existence of question marks surrounding the borrower's business practice
Management concerns (problems between partners, or managers and owners)
Lack of transparency in financial reporting
Excessive withdrawals or very generous dividend policy
Indications that the life style of owners or managers is beyond their means.
Loose management (i.e. lack of MIS and internal controls)
Excessive dependence on key raw materials
The existence of a few customers relative to sales (thus a high bargaining power)
Obscure management succession
Vulnerability to shifts in technology
Substantial changes in accounting practices (percentage of depreciation, income recognition, etc.)
4. For selected files, the CRR Manager requests the CBD Manager to undertake a Mid-Cycle Review as per the
criteria and methodologies described in Chapter 8.0 - T HE C REDIT A PPROVAL P ROCESS .
5. The CRR Manager will classify each of the selected files as “Under Close Supervision” and will continue
monitoring it for a further month to come.
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 135
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | February 2016
6. The CRR Manager awaits 5 – 7 days for the results of the mid-cycle review to identify the source of the delay in
payment settlement. Where the CRR Manager does not receive the results of mid-cycle review to identify the
source of the delay in payment settlement within a period of 5 – 7 days, the CRR Manager will raise the matter
to do Credit Committee.
7. Where mid-cycle review data is compiled and analyzed at the CBD, and a CAM is received by the CRR Manager,
the CRR Manager shall consider the following and act accordingly:
If the source of the problem is related to general economic conditions affecting the sector under
consideration, the CRR Manager will advise the CBD Manager to advise the client to consider alternatives
for settlement, of which rescheduling is one. Where rescheduling is the chosen option, the CRR Manager
will initiate the steps in Chapter 8.2 - Amendments – Workflow Charts 2 and 3 above, as applicable.
If the source of the problem is related to the client’s own financial mismanagement, the CRR Manager will
advise the CBD Manager to request a joint client meeting in the presence of the Branch Manager in order
to:
Warn of potential down-grading of the client’s classification, and request an immediate settlement.
Discuss alternatives for settlement and obtain the client’s written pledge to execute the chosen
alternative.
8. The final outcome of the review process is compiled by the CRR Manager and attached to the original reports
received from the Credit Administration Department, then forwarded to:
Mr. Chairman
The Credit Committee, with a request to hold a meeting for discussion for selected clients (if necessary).
9. The Chairman's and / or Committee's response would be, as usual, addressed to the Credit Admin Manager,
with the CRR Manager on copy. The CAD Manager will act according to the instructions stated by Mr. Chairman
and the Credit Committee.
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 136
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | January 2016
16.2 REPORTING SCHEDULES
Weekly Repots Initiated By Report Description Addressed to
Kafalat & Subsidized Reporting Officer Listing of all loans that benefit from obligatory reserve deductions Finance Department
Loans Report Reference Forms: ARO-10; ARO-02; ARO-10
Kafalat Balances Report Reporting Officer All Kafalat loan balances by type of loan (Basic, Basic-Delegation and Plus), alongside the original Deloitte & Touche
approved limits and utilized portions.
Over-Limits & Accidental Monitoring Officer Report by branch on all accounts exceeding limits either due to a temporary over-limit decision Credit Committee
Debtors Report (through password) or accidentally. Chairman & GM
Individual branches
Passwords Report Monitoring Officer Listing of all clients whose accounts are over the specified limits due to passwords, whether the Chairman & GM
excess is still within the allowable term or not. Audit Department
Credit Risk & Review
Manager
Past Due Transactions Monitoring Officer A report grouping all past due transactions for the week Credit Committee
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 147
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | January 2016
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 148
JTB Credit Policies & Procedures
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement
Version 2.0 | January 2016
Edited by Paragon Business Improvement | Version 2.0 | Feb 2016 | www.paragon-bi.com Page 149