Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/241633776
CITATIONS READS
9 2,186
3 authors:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Nur Hidayah Che Ahmat on 04 March 2016.
and deliver the right concept is the challenging part [17] and toilets should not be placed in the direction of Mecca, c)
because people are too complacent with conventional hotels no alcohol and pork in any outlets, d) products served must
concept besides merely understand the concept of Syariah be halal and slaughtered in the name of Allah, and e) the
Compliant through what is visible in their eyes. total development and operations should be financed through
Islamic financial in line with the principles of Syariah
Because the concept can be considered as ‘a new thing’ in finance.
the market, hence it has not yet received much attention
among the Malaysian researchers to conduct the study about B. Customer Awareness on Syariah Compliant Hotel
the topic despite there are growing research databases from Concept
the western parts. In fact and not to exaggerate, the study on The burgeoning of Syariah Compliant hotel concept
Syariah Compliant relating to the hotel realm is rather internationally triggers hotel operators in Malaysia to open
rudimentary. up such hotels in this country to cater the demand. However,
the awareness is still uncertain due to misconception, despite
II. LITERATURE REVIEW there is an increase in demand for this concept. Reference
[25] posited that information and knowledge could influence
The concept of Syariah Compliant was introduced to the
customers’ attitude towards (Syariah Compliant) concept.
industry to cater the Muslim market specifically. It was Customers should have the basic knowledge of Syariah
proven that the increasing number of Arab and Muslim Compliant, either through reading or other mediums suitable.
travellers and their growing purchasing power are some of
Hotel operators’ could work hand in hand to educate the
the key factor driving the growth of Syariah Compliant
customers regarding the concept to avoid misinterpretation.
hotels [21],[22]. Parallel with the above notion, it could be
said that Syariah Compliant has a very strong competitive Reference [26] argued that potential customers may not even
advantage which significantly helps to the increasing in aware of (Syariah Compliant) or may have their own
demand for Syariah Compliant hotels [5]-[8],[10]- perception about it. Hence, it is important to ensure
[13],[17],[18],[22],[23]. customers are aware of Syariah Compliant concept as it will
spark off the demand for Syariah hotel and help in customer
A. The Emergence of Syariah Compliant
decision making [27]. Awareness usually based on
The rise of Muslim travellers in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait consciousness feeling, but it will not necessarily lead to
[21] and the increasing wealth of the communities in the consumption (decision to stay in such hotel) [26]. The
region help the potential growth of the concept [23]. growing pattern for this concept shows a positive prospect to
Scholars also noted that the increasing availability of Syariah expand and success like other conventional hotels supporting
Compliant funds together with the changing pattern of by the rise in intra-region travellers market whose prefer to
lifestyle has boost up the concept [12]. Further, [17] stay in hotels that respect their values, cultures, and health
simplified that the emergence of Syariah Compliant is well- concern [8].
correlated with the growth of Islamic finance back in 1970s
C. Customer Acceptance level towards Syariah Compliant
where the concept is not strong enough at that time but Hotel Concept
slowly gained its strength over the years.
Acceptance always related to positive feedback of the
The word “Syariah Compliant” is not clarified enough
customers which could be measured through their
within the hotel industry. In fact and not to exaggerate, there
willingness to stay in Syariah Compliant hotel. Reference
are no such hotels in this category [5] and no written rules or
[22] stated that leisure travellers are very likely and some of
classifications currently exist for Syariah Compliant hotels them are fairly likely to use Syariah Compliant hotel for
[12],[13]. Reference [17] argued that the biggest challenge is family trip, in contrast with business travellers. Surprisingly,
to develop and deliver the right Syariah Compliant. It is
[10] identified that more than 50 percent of the customers
because people in the industry only understand the concept
are non-Muslims, came from Germany and Korea. The
and the practices through what is visible to their eyes. The
aforesaid statement dismissing the perception that Syariah
very popular misconception is when there is no alcohol
Compliant hotel is not only meant for Muslims since non-
served [5],[6] and by providing amenities for Muslims is Muslims also choose to stay in this hotel. In supporting the
already considered as Syariah Compliant. Nevertheless, literatures, Tamani Hotels and Resorts comprises a mix of
hotel industries implicitly follow one aspect of Syariah
business and leisure travellers shows occupancy rose more
Compliant by having halal certificates in their establishment.
than 95 percent for a week [5] and most of their customers
Reference [7] noted that most of the international brand
came from Germany, Europe, and Australia. Furthermore,
hotels especially four and five-star ratings are still refused to
report from De Palma hotels stated that their business doing
adopt Syariah Compliant hotel practices because they well proven through the increasing number of customers and
believe it gives less commercial value and hotels make a they claimed that the concept is successfully implemented
huge profit from selling alcoholic beverages, discotheque,
[16],[28]. These positive feedbacks from international
and nightclubs.
customers had inspired researchers to conduct the study in
In addition, [12] divided Syariah Compliant into three Malaysian contextual setting.
sections namely operations, interior design, and financial,
supported by other scholars who further listed the minimum
requirements for Syariah Compliant hotel [12],[21]. They III.METHODOLOGY
identified some of the key criteria that a Syariah Compliant
This study was conducted by using a quantitative method
hotel must have which are: a) separate facilities such as
and empirical investigation was carried out to determine the
floors, gym, function rooms for males and females, b) beds
relationship between the customer awareness and their
125
2012 International Conference on Innovation, Management and Technology Research (ICIMTR2012), Malacca, Malaysia :
21-22 May, 2012
126
2012 International Conference on Innovation, Management and Technology Research (ICIMTR2012), Malacca, Malaysia :
21-22 May, 2012
shows the new factors were relabelled as “Syariah To further answer the objectives of this study, a standard
Compliant Concept”, and “Syariah Compliant Practices” to multiple regressions was conducted to investigate the most
avoid misinterpretation of the original factors name. The influential factor influencing the awareness of customers.
KMO value for the items was 0.835, which depicts that Table IV shows the regression analysis and it was found that
items were interrelated and shared common factors. the practices of Syariah Compliant were significantly
Furthermore, the Bartlett’s test of Sphericity was significant influenced the level of awareness among customers.
(Approx. Chi-Square= 3446.322, p<0.000). Results of factor Adjusted R² shows the strength of association or the
analysis using Varimax rotated revealed the four factors with explanatory power of the model in Model 1 is 0.281 and
eigenvalue exceeding 1, explaining 66.887 percent of the significant at 0.01 levels. In this study, the value is 0.288
total variance. However, researchers decided to retain only which means, the model (which includes SCC and SCP)
two factors resulted a total variance of 38.01 percent. The only explains 28.8 percent of the variance in customer
first factor is Syariah Compliant Concept (SCC) consisted of acceptance which appears a low result. From the results of
12-items with eigenvalue of 7.526 and factor loadings multiple regression analysis, it is clear that Syariah
ranging from 0.603 to 0.781. The second factor, Syariah Compliant practices is the most influential factor in
Compliant Practices (SCP) is made up of 15-items with the explaining the level of acceptance among local customers.
eigenvalue of 5.396 and the factor loadings ranging from This is because the variable makes the strongest unique
0.466 to 0.710. The third factor is Component 3 with 1-item contribution to explain the dependent variable when the
and factor loading of 0.568 while Component 4 also with 1- variance explained by other variables in the model is
item and factor loading of 0.464. The reliability of composite controlled for.
variables is presented in Table II.
TABLE IV
TABLE II REGRESSION ANALYSIS BETWEEN CUSTOMER AWARENESS OF
CRONBACH’S ALPHA, MEAN, AND STANDARD DEVIATION OF THE CONCEPT AND PRACTICES
ALL VARIABLES Model R R Adjusted Std. F Sig.
Variables Number Cronbach’s Mean Standard Square R Error of
of Items Alpha Deviation Square the
Customer Estimate
Awareness 1 .537ª .288 .281 .53151 42.715 .000ª
(IV)
Model Unstandardized Standardized t Sig. Collinearity
Syariah 12 0.922 3.23 0.815 Coefficients Coefficients Statistics
Compliant B Std. Beta Tolerance VIF
Concept (SCC) Error
1 (Constant) 2.049 .316 6.486 .000
Syariah 16 0.858 5.12 0.650 Syariah .115 .045 .150 2.574 .011 0.997 1.003
Compliant Compliant
Practice (SCP) Concept
Syariah .489 .056 .507 8.711 .000 0.997 1.003
Total 28 Compliant
Customer 14 0.842 4.92 0.627 Practices
Acceptance Dependent Variable: Customer Acceptance
(DV)
N=214 V. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
TABLE III
CORRELATIONS OF ALL VARIABLES
Measures SCC SCP CA
The main objective of this study is to explore the
Pearson .180** .516** .449** relationship between customer awareness and their
Correlation acceptance level toward the implementation of Syariah
Sig. (2-tailed) .004 .000 .000 Compliant. Literatures on Syariah Compliant predicted that,
N=214 customer awareness in both concept and practices are
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
significantly and positively related to their acceptance level
which further bolsters the results of this study. In essence,
Correlations analysis was conducted to test the relationship
the dimensions of Syariah Compliant awareness expounded
between customer awareness with their acceptance level.
28.8 percent of the variation in the customer acceptance (as
Table III shows these relationships and it was found that
simplified in Table IV). Syariah Compliant concept has a
there is a weak or small perfect positive correlation between
positive relationship with customer acceptance. Same goes
customer awareness regarding the concept towards customer
to Syariah Compliant practices which also positively
acceptance (r=.180). In other word of saying, the more
correlated with the customer acceptance but the strength of
customers aware of the concept, the more they will accept
the relationship for practices is much stronger than the
Syariah Compliant. Furthermore, the results also depicted
concept. Nevertheless, both dimensions were found to be
that there is a strong or large perfect positive correlation
considerably related with customer acceptance. This finding
between customer awareness with regards to the practices of
again provides some evidence to the importance of customer
Syariah Compliant towards customer acceptance level
awareness which may affect their level of acceptance on
(r=.516). The more customers aware of the practices, the
Syariah Compliant in hotel industry.
more they will accept the application of Syariah Compliant.
In addition, there was an average, positive correlation Literatures in Syariah Compliant postulated this relationship
between customer awareness of the concept and practices of but little empirical evidence has been provided to prove this
Syariah Compliant towards the acceptance level of relationship. Hence, this study found that customer
customers (r=0.449, n=214, p<0.000), with high levels of awareness in terms of the practices is significantly and
awareness associated with high acceptance level. positively related to customers’ acceptance level. In
conclusion, this study has explored the literatures detailing
the relationship between customer awareness of Syariah
127
2012 International Conference on Innovation, Management and Technology Research (ICIMTR2012), Malacca, Malaysia :
21-22 May, 2012
Compliant and how it affects customer acceptance level [19] DeLorenzo, Y. (2000). Shariah Supervision of Islamic
towards the application of it. A review of theoretical and Mutual Funds. Paper presented at the Fourth Harvard
empirical research appears to indicate that the more University Forum on Islamic Finance, Harvard
customers aware about the concept and the practices of University, Cambridge, MA.
Syariah Compliant, the more they will accept it. Further [20] DeLorenzo, Y. (2007). Shari'ah Compliance Risk.
study should be undertaken in qualitative manner to close the Chicago Journal of International Law, 7(2), 397-408.
loops occurred between both approaches other than in depth [21] Stephenson, M. L., Russell, K. A., & Edgar, D. (2010).
study evaluates on the misconceptions about Syariah Islamic hospitality in the UAE: indigenization of
Compliant among hotel operators and customers to ensure products and human capital. Journal of Islamic
that a standardize requirement being established by the Marketing, 1(1), 9-24.
authorities to achieve their goals. [22] Tarrant, C. (n.d.). Middle East hotel guests express high
interest in Sharia compliant hotels Retrieved 21st May,
VI. REFERENCES 2010, from http://www.bdrc.co.uk
[23] Visele, N. (2007). Almulla launches world's first
[1] Henderson, J. C. (2010). Sharia-compliant hotels. international Sharia compliant hotel chain Retrieved 13th
Tourism and Hospitality Research, 10(3), 246-254. May, 2010, from www.zawya.com
[2] Bahrain Tribune (2008). Shariah-compliant hotel sector [24] Muhammad, Z. (2009). Al Jawhara: Promoting Islamic
grows Retrieved 13th May, 2010, from hospitality and Halal tourism. The Halal
http://www.menafn.com Journal(May/June), 60.
[3] Yusuf, S. (2009). The Real Sense of Shariah Hospitality [25] Huang, J., Qiu, H., Bai, J., & Pray, C. (2006).
Concept. S. S. Lootah Group. Awareness, acceptance of and willingness to buy
[4] Ahmed, Z. (n.d.). The issues and challenges of shariah genetically modified foods in Urban China. Appetite, 46,
compliance applicable to Islamic financial institutions 144-151.
Retrieved 31st May, 2010, from http://www.scribd.com [26] Briz, T., & Ward, R. W. (2009). Consumer awareness
[5] Staff Writer (2009). Demand for Shariah-compliant of organic products in Spain: An application of
hotels rising Retrieved 13th May, 2010, from multinominal logit models. Food Policy, 34, 295-304.
http//www.halalfocus.com/.../Demand_for_Shariah-... [27] Macdonald, E. K., & Sharp, B. M. (2000). Brand
[6] Seth, R. (2006). Alcohol-free hotels: What next? Awareness Effects on Consumer Decision Making for a
Retrieved 20th August, 2009, from Common, Repeat Purchase Product: A Replication.
http://www.halaljournal.com/.../alcohol-free-hotels... Journal of Business Research, 48, 5-15.
[7] Florian, J. (2007). Shariah-compliant hotels rise in the [28] Wan, P. (2010). De Palma goes syariah-compliant
Gulf Retrieved 13th May, 2010, from Retrieved 18th June, 2010, from
http://www.ameinfor.com/140356.html http://www.mmail.com.my
[8] Husain, S. (2007). Bringing hospitality in line with [29] Tourism Malaysia (2010). Malaysia Tourist Profile
Sharia Retrieved 20th May, 2010, from 2009 by Selected Markets Retrieved 3th August, 2010,
http://gulfnews.com fromhttp://www.tourism.gov.my/corporate/research.asp?
[9] Bernama (2007). Hotel brand that's syariah-compliant page=publications
Retrieved 18th June, 2010 [30] Roscoe, J. T. (1975). Fundamental Research Statistics
[10] Kola, A. H. (2008). Islamic hotels in demand in Mid for the Behavioral Sciences. New York: Holt, Rinehart
East Retrieved 21st May, 2010, from and Winston, Inc.
http://www.eturbonews.com [31] Hair, J. F., Black, W. C., Babin, B. J., Anderson, R. E.,
[11] Economist, T. (2009). Rise of the sharia-compliant & Tatham, R. L. (2006). Multivariate data analysis (6th
hotel? Retrieved 21st May, 2010, from ed.): Pearson Prentice Hall.
http://www.theelectroniceconomist.com
[12] Rosenberg, P., & Choufany, H. M. (2009). Spiritual VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Lodging - The Sharia-Compliant Hotel Concept. HVS This research would not have been started, nor
Global Hospitality Services – Dubai. completed without the financial support from the Universiti
[13] Birchall, L. (2009). Laying down Sharia Law Retrieved Teknologi MARA (UiTM) through an Excellence Fund
13th May, 2010, from http://www.arabianbusiness.com grant. Therefore, authors are thankful to the Research
[14] Javed, N. (2007). Islamic Hotel Branding and Muslim Management Institute for giving us the opportunity to do this
Hospitality http://www.salesvantage.com , research.
accessed 13 October 2009 .
[15] Sulong, Z., & Abdullah, N. (2010). Syariah compliant: VIII. BIBLIOGRAPHIES
Kalau bank boleh, kenapa hotel tidak Retrieved 5th Nur’hidayah Che Ahmat is born in Perak, Malaysia,
November, 2010 on August 2, 1985. She graduated with distinction from
[16]Halal Media (2011). Opinion: Shariah Compliant hotels. Faculty of Hotel and Tourism Management, and studied
at Universiti Teknologi MARA, UiTM Shah Alam.
Retrieved 20th September, 201, from
http://halalmedia.my/ Currently, she is a Lecturer at UiTM branches in
Penang teaching hospitality courses in the same faculty.
[17] Steinmetz, T. (2008). Sharia Compliant hotels: the next Her employment experiences were mainly in hospitality
big thing in Arabia. Retrieved 21st May, 2010, from industry namely fast food, and hotels. Her special fields
http://www.eturbonews.com of interest included revenue management, strategic
[18] Anonymous (2009). Consumers comply with shariah management and customer behaviours.
hotels. Hotelier Middle East, May 2009.