You are on page 1of 6

Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2011) 131:173–178

DOI 10.1007/s00402-010-1115-2

ORTHOPAEDIC SURGERY

Percutaneous discectomy and drainage for postoperative


intervertebral discitis
Jian Li • Denglu Yan • Lijun Duan •
Zhi Zhang • Haodong Zhu • Zaihen Zhang

Received: 28 January 2010 / Published online: 20 May 2010


Ó Springer-Verlag 2010

Abstract tissue showed 17 cases of sterile and 14 had positive cul-


Background Postoperative intervertebral discitis occurs ture. Spine X-rays films showed narrowed disc space in 29
following spinal surgery. This study was done to evaluate cases, and bridging osteophytes were noted in 19 patients.
the effect of percutaneous discectomy and drainage (PDD) Destructive and sclerotic changes of vertebral bodies with
for postoperative intervertebral discitis. narrowing of disc spaces were observed in 14 patients.
Methods A retrospective study of postoperative inter- Conclusions The results show that PDD is a minimally
vertebral discitis treated by PDD procedures was conducted invasive procedure for obtaining sufficient biopsy material
from January 1997 to June 2006. There were 34 patients for histological analysis and culture in cases of discitis, and
(24 males, 10 females); 10 cases of after lumbar discec- has a good clinical outcome recommended for patients with
tomy (L3–4 in 3 patients, L4–5 in 7 patients), 21 cases of early stage postoperative intervertebral discitis without
after percutaneous lumbar discectomy (L3–4 in 7 patients, neurologic deficit.
L4–5 in 14 patient), 2 cases of after percutaneous cervical
discectomy (C5–6 in 1 patient, C6–7 in 1 patient), and 1 Keywords Intervertebral  Diskitis  Treatment 
case of C5–6 after percutaneous cervical nucleoplasty. Percutaneous  Discectomy
Results All patients tolerated the procedure well and
there were 31 cases had followed up. VAS scores dem-
onstrated statistically significant improvement after PDD Introduction
when compared with preoperational values (P \ 0.01).
Elevated CRP and ESR values returned to normal range Intervertebral discitis most frequently occurs following
within 3–8 weeks. CRP and ESR values demonstrated spinal surgery, and its incidence after conventional or
statistically significant improvement after PDD when minimally invasive surgery varies between 0.1 and 4.0%
compared with preoperative values (P \ 0.01). Biopsies of [3, 6, 9, 15, 19, 24, 28]. The histological findings of discitis
the disc were performed in all patients and pus was seen in included disc vascularisation, the formation of mature
17 patients at the pathology levels. Inflammatory cells were granulation tissue in both discs and vertebral bodies, and
observed nine cases (4 cases showed infiltration of lym- the occasional presence of acute inflammatory cells in
phocytes and plasmacytes, 5 cases showed infiltrate of addition to chronic inflammation. Positive cultures may be
polymorphonuclear leucocytes). Cultures of disc and bone obtained only in 42 and 73% of patients [19, 22]. Periop-
erative bacterial contamination is considered a more likely
cause of postoperative septic discitis than blood borne
J. Li  D. Yan (&)  Z. Zhang  H. Zhu  Z. Zhang
Orthopedic Department, Third Hospital of Guangzhou Medical bacterial infection. When blood cultures are non-confir-
College, Guangzhou, People’s Republic of China matory, biopsies by open or minimally invasive surgery are
e-mail: spineyan@hotmail.com alternative methods for bacteriologic verification [11].
Early diagnosis is crucial in the management of discitis
L. Duan
West China Second University Hospital, Sichuan University, because delayed treatment can lead to increased morbidity
Chengdu, People’s Republic of China and mortality [16, 26]. Disc biopsy is critical for diagnosis

123
174 Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2011) 131:173–178

and to administration of the correct antibiotics for treat- L4–5 in 14 patients) of after percutaneous lumbar discec-
ment from identifying the offending pathogen. Enoch et al. tomy (PLD), 2 cases (C5–6 in 1 patient, C6–7 in 1 patient)
[6] had a retrospective of 98 computer tomography (CT)- of after percutaneous cervical discectomy (PCD), and 1
guided biopsies in 103 patients. Malignancy was diagnosed case of C5–6 after percutaneous cervical nucleoplasty
in 49 episodes. Discitis and paravertebral abscess accoun- (PCN).
ted for 27 cases. Culture was positive in 9 of 25 (36%) The patient presented symptoms of local intractable pain
samples received by the microbiology laboratory. The from 1 to 21 days after spine surgery (average 14 days).
traditional approach to the management of vertebral On examination, all patients show no warmth in the region.
infection is to obtain the material by needle biopsy fol- The spine movements were terminally restricted, but there
lowing the technique described by Valls et al. [25]. Per- was no motor weakness. Babinski’s sign was negative and
cutaneous discectomy, which has the advantage of biopsy, there were no objective sensory deficits. Haematological
decompress and solution irrigation the disc space, when investigations revealed a raised CRP (9.6–36 mg/L, aver-
combined with antibiotic therapy, may serve as an alter- age 24.1 ± 2.2 mg/L) or ESR (range 32–95 mm/h, average
native to open surgery [8, 9, 19]. 61.8 ± 8.3 mm/h). The leucocyte count was raised in 15
Percutaneous discectomy and drainage (PDD) is a patients, and the neutrophilic granulocyte was raised in 19
minimally invasive procedure for conservative treatment of patients. The blood culture and tuberculin skin tests were
discitis [9, 19]. With improved instruments, the pathogens negative.
and infected tissue can continue to be sucked out by this
minimally invasive procedure, which not only relief in-
tradisc pressure and irrigation of inflammatory factors, but Surgical procedures
also preserving the adequate stability contributing to
immediate back pain relief. A series of 34 postoperative All procedures were under local anaesthesia. For the cer-
intervertebral discitis patients been treated by PDD in our vical spine procedures, the patient was placed in a supine
clinical, and 31 cases had followed up from 2 to 10 years. position with the neck extended by placing a rolled towel
under the shoulders. A soft strap was placed over the
forehead for stabilization. The shoulders were gently dis-
Patients and methods tracted downward with tape. C-arm fluoroscopy was used
in anteroposterior and lateral planes to localise the level of
A retrospective study of postoperative intervertebral dis- discitis and directed the placement of a spinal needle onto
citis treated by PDD procedures was conducted from Jan- the disc surface. Initially, at the point of entry adjacent to
uary 1996 to June 2006. The inclusion criteria were early the medial border of the right sternocleidomastoid muscle,
stage postoperative intervertebral discitis without neuro- firm pressure was applied digitally in the space between the
logic deficit. Exclusion criteria included spontaneous muscle and the trachea and pointed towards the vertebral
infectious intervertebral discitis, intervertebral discitis with surface. The larynx and trachea were displaced medially
neurologic deficit, and infection associated with epidural and the carotid artery laterally. The anterior cervical spine
abscess. Four spontaneous infectious intervertebral discitis was palpated with the fingertips, and a spinal needle was
cases been excluded. The patients’ all medical records used to puncture the right side of the neck and passed into
were reviewed, which include the visual analogue pain the disc space. Lumbar patient was positioned prone, and
(VAS) scale for cervical and back pain. the procedures as previously reported [9, 19].
All patients were treated for the disc herniation com- C-arm fluoroscopy was used in anteroposterior and lat-
plaints of radicular pain, and the local pain of neck or back eral planes to localise the level of discitis and directed the
were from 1.2 to 4.3 on VAS (average 2.69 ± 1.78) before placement of a spinal needle onto the disc surface. After
first surgery. There were no patients with postoperative guiding pin punctures and passed into the disc space, a
pneumonia or urogenital infections. However, intractable small stab incision was made and a dilator cannula was
neck or back pain was presented and narcotic pain control inserted over the guiding pin until it reached the annulus.
and bed rest was required. Intervertebral discitis was Then, biopsy instrument was used to get the tissue as
diagnosed on the basis of clinical examination, includ- sample, and additional tissue from the disc was obtained by
ing elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and means of discectomy forceps. Following biopsy and
C-reactive protein (CRP; normal range 0–5 mg/L) values, debridement procedures, normal saline solution was used
and roentgenographic and magnetic resonance imaging for irrigation. After completion of the discectomy, a guide
(MRI) findings. Then, there were 34 patients (24 males, 10 wire was introduced into the disc space, and a silica gel
females); 10 cases of after lumbar discectomy (L3–4 in 3 drainage tube was inserted into the debrided disc space
patients, L4–5 in 7 patients), 21 cases (L3–4 in 7 patients, over the guide wire and connected to a negative-pressure

123
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2011) 131:173–178 175

vacuum draining bag, and then the drainage tube was Elevated CRP (mg/L) and ESR (mm/h) values returned
removed the next day after PDD. to normal range within 3–8 weeks. The average CRP and
These tissue samples of all patients were sent for Gram ESR were 24.1 ± 2.2 and 61.8 ± 8.3 preoperatively,
stain and aerobic, anaerobic, fungal, and tuberculosis cul- 13.3 ± 2.8 and 32.4 ± 9.6 1 week postoperatively,
tures. Histopathological examination of the samples was 3.1 ± 1.6 and 18.4 ± 3.5 4 weeks postoperatively, and
also performed. Prophylactic intravenous antibiotics 0.91 ± 0.32 and 8.5 ± 2.6 on 8 weeks follow-up. CRP
(cefazolin, the choice of antibiotic should be taken in to and ESR values demonstrated statistically significant
account for the drug’s ability to penetrate bone and inter- improvement in PDD when compared with preoperational
vertebral disc) were administered from been diagnosed values (P \ 0.01).
before surgery and continued till the culture specimen Biopsies of the disc were performed in all patients and
sensitive out. Intravenous antibiotics were used until after pus was seen in 17 patients at the pathology levels.
3 weeks of the symptoms disappeared and ESR return Inflammatory cells were observed in nine cases (4 cases
normal, and then the patient was discharged on oral anti- showed infiltration of lymphocytes and plasmacytes, 5
biotics for another 3 weeks. The cervical patients had cases showed infiltrate of polymorphonuclear leucocytes).
immobilization in a cervical cast at least for 2 weeks, and Cultures of disc and bone tissue showed 17 cases of sterile
the lumbar patients were told to be in bed rest at least for and 14 had positive culture [9 cases of Gram-positive
4 weeks. bacteria (7 patients had Staphylococcus aureus, 2 patients
had Staphylococcus epidermides), 2 cases of Escherichia
coli, 2 cases of Klebsiella, and 1 cases of Pseudomonas
Statistical analyses cepacia]. Systemic antibiotics were administered according
to the sensitivity studies for identified pathogens.
Statistical analyses were performed independently by a Spine X-rays films showed narrowed disc space in 29
non-clinical research assistant and an outside party to cases, and bridging osteophytes were noted in 19 patients.
ensure objectivity using SPSS Version 16.0 software. The Destructive and sclerotic changes in vertebral bodies with
treatment effect was evaluated by the Macnab standard narrowing of disc spaces were observed in 14 patients. The
[17] and using VAS for cervical and back pain. The Stu- cervical discitis cases showed narrowed disc space and
dent’s t test with a two-tailed paired comparison was used erosive and sclerotic remodel in the vertebral endplate 1
to compare the means between visits and to compare suc- and 3 years later, and one case had spontaneous fusion at
cess based on demographic variables. The results were the C4–5 level.
considered statistically significant if the P value was equal
to or less than 0.05 for continuous variables.
Discussion

Results Patients with infectious discitis who have had surgery of


the spine can be considered to have postoperative discitis
All patients tolerated the procedure well and there were 31 [1, 4, 6, 11, 27]. There is a considerable variation in the
cases had followed up (3 cases lost) from 2 to 10 years time of manifestation of the symptoms of postoperative
(average 6.4 years). Macnab standard results were excel- septic discitis. Iversen et al. [12] reported a large series of
lent in 17 cases, good in 9 cases and fair in 5 cases (5 patients with postoperative septic discitis, the average time
lumbar patients had back pain). The rate of excellent and ranged from 2 to 5 weeks after surgery. In the current
good was 83.9%. series of patients, the patient presented symptoms of local
Twenty-five patients (89.3%) reported immediate relief intractable pain from 1 to 21 days after spine surgery, and
of back pain following PDD. All cervical patients had pain the symptoms developed 3 weeks postoperatively in only
improvement within 24 h and condition improved within one patient. Cervical discitis is a known complication of
the first week after the procedures. None had recurrence of cervical discography [3, 28]. Heyde et al. [11] reported 20
neck pain at the last follow-up. At 1-week follow-up, 23 consecutive patients, and thought spondylodiscitis in cer-
lumbar patients did not have back pain, and 5 lumbar vical spine should be treated early and aggressive to avoid
patients had back pain. The pain index was 9.67 ± 0.44 local and systemic complications. There were three cervi-
preoperatively, 3.51 ± 0.74 1 week postoperatively, cal postoperatively intervertebral discitis in this study, one
2.23 ± 0.52 4 weeks postoperatively, and 2.44 ± 0.61 on case of C5–6 and one case of C4–5 after PCD (Fig. 3), and
8 weeks follow-up. VAS scores demonstrated statistically 1 case of C5–6 after PCN.
significant improvement after PDD when compared with Surgical intervention is indicated for patients with sig-
preoperational values (P \ 0.01). nificant neurological deficit, large epidural abscesses,

123
176 Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2011) 131:173–178

extensive vertebral body destruction, severe kyphotic et al. [7] obtained bacteriological diagnosis in 9 (36%) of
deformity or spinal instability, or failed antibiotic therapy 25 patients biopsied, using a Mazabraud trocar. Staatz et al.
[5, 14, 20, 21]. Percutaneous discectomy was employed for [23] reported 16 (76%) positive cultures for 21 patients,
infectious spondylitis in selected cases, which can obtain a using CT-guided, percutaneous, and catheter drainage.
sufficient amount of material for microbiological exami- Rankine et al. [21] isolated an organism in 6 of 12 patients
nation directly from the infected region [8, 9]. In addition, not taking antibiotics and only 2 of 8 patients taking anti-
eradication and irrigation of infected and necrotic tissue biotics. Haaker et al. [9] identified the specific infection in
from a disc and even an epidural space facilitate a fenes- 45% of 16 lumbar disc infection patients. Bavinzski et al.
tration similar to open debridement [1, 10]. Iversen et al [1] succeeded in making a bacteriologic diagnosis in 88%
[12] reported postoperative septic discitis had a signifi- in 17 cases with postoperative septic discitis using a closed
cantly higher incidence of chronic low back pain. In this suction irrigation system. Culture was positive in 9 of 25
study, Macnab standard results were excellent in 17 cases, (36%) samples received by the microbiology laboratory
good in 9 cases and fair in 5 cases (5 lumbar patients had [6]. Staphylococcus aureus and Mycobacterium tubercu-
back pain). The rate of excellent and good was 83.9%. losis (3 cases) were the most frequent organisms isolated,
Twenty-five patients (89.3%) reported immediate relief of followed by group G streptococci and coagulase-negative
back pain following PDD. VAS scores demonstrated sta- staphylococci [26].
tistically significant improvement in PDD when compared In this study of 31 discitis cases, the blood culture and
with preoperational values (P \ 0.01). Elevated CRP and tuberculin skin tests were negative. All patients had got the
ESR values returned to normal range within 3–8 weeks, tissue samples (Fig. 1) and sent for Gram stain and aerobic,
which demonstrated statistically significant improvement in anaerobic, fungal, tuberculous cultures, and histopatholo-
PDD when compared with preoperative values (P \ 0.01). gical examination. The inflammatory cells were observed
The results of percutaneous biopsy may be negative for in nine cases (4 cases showed infiltration of lymphocytes
various reasons, including inadequate amount of specimen, and plasmacytes, 5 cases showed infiltrate composed of
sampling error, or previous antibiotic therapy. Fouquet lymphocytes and polymorphonuclear leucocytes, Fig. 2).

Fig. 1 a Resect the infected tissues and gets the disc tissue as histopathology sample at L4–5 discitis case, b an enlargement in the picture
showed it, c pressurised irrigation with more than 2 L of saline or antibiotics solution irrigation the disc space, d disc tissue from PDD

Fig. 2 a Histopathology sample at L4–5 discitis case, b histopathology shows the sample was disc tissue, c an enlargement in the picture showed
nucleus pulpous, d an enlargement in the picture showed the acute inflammatory reaction of neutrophile granulocyte infiltration

123
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2011) 131:173–178 177

Fig. 3 a Lateral plain radiograph of cervical spine shows loss of disc space narrowed. d Lateral plain radiograph of 10 years after PDD
height at C4–5. b Lateral fluoroscopic images during PDD of infected shows spontaneous fusion at the C4–5 level
disc. c Lateral plain radiograph of 6 months after PDD shows the disc

Fig. 4 a Lateral plain radiograph of cervical spine shows loss of disc fluoroscopic images during PDD of infected disc and vertebral
height at L3–4 (arrows). MRI demonstrates decreased signal intensity bodies. Lateral plain radiograph of 3 months (e) and 6 months (f)
on T1-weighted sequence (b) in L5 and L6 vertebral bodies, and showed narrowed disc space and erosive in the vertebral endplate and
increased T2 signal (c) intensity within the disc space as well as aggravation narrowed disc space
altered signal within the adjacent vertebral bodies. d Lateral

False-positive and false-negative cultures were seen in the invasive technique, remove some of the infected material
17 patients, and bacteria were isolated in 14 were positive may shorten the time of healing with spontaneous
(11 cases of E. coli, 2 cases of Klebsiella, and 1 case of interbody fusion. In our case, spine films showed nar-
P. cepacia). The biopsy of microbiological yield in this rowed disc space in 24 cases, and bridging osteophytes
study was 45.2% (14/31), and the no-infection discitis was were noted in 15 patients. Destructive and sclerotic
54.8% (17/31) which may be caused by a chemical or changes in vertebral bodies with narrowing of disc
aseptic process, or the pre-biopsy administration of anti- spaces were observed in four patients. The C4–5 discitis
biotics may yield negative cultures [7]. cases plain films showed narrowed disc space, and
The radiological findings of discitis are a narrowed 10 years after PDD shows spontaneous fusion at the C4–
disc space, erosions, and sclerotic changes on the 5 level (Fig. 3). The L4–5 discitis cases, MRI demon-
opposite region of the vertebral bodies [2, 13, 18]. strates decreased signal intensity on T1-weighted
Nielsen et al. [18] reported a series of 53 patients with sequence in the L–4 and L–5 vertebral bodies; 2 months
postoperative discitis, intercorporeal fusion had occurred after operation shows almost signal intensity on T1-
in 17%, whilst Wirtz et al. [27] reported osseous fusion weighted sequence in vertebral bodies, and the narrowed
had occurred in 65.5% in 59 patients. PDD, a minimally disc space (Fig. 4).

123
178 Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2011) 131:173–178

Conclusion 13. Kasperczyk A, Freyschmidt J (1994) Pustulotic arthroosteitis:


spectrum of bone lesions with palmoplantar pustulosis. Radiology
191(1):207–211
Percutaneous discectomy and drainage is a minimally 14. Krodel A, Sturz H, Siebert CH (1991) Indications for and results
invasive procedure for obtaining sufficient biopsy material of operative treatment of spondylitis and spondylodiscitis. Arch
for histological analysis and culture in cases of discitis, and Orthop Trauma Surg 110(2):78–82
has good clinical outcome recommended for patients with 15. Li J, Yan DL, Zhang ZH (2008) Percutaneous cervical nuc-
leoplasty in the treatment of cervical disc herniation. Eur Spine J
early stage postoperative intervertebral discitis without 17(12):1664–1669
neurological deficit. 16. Luzzati R, Giacomazzi D, Danzi MC, Tacconi L, Concia E,
Vento S (2009) Diagnosis, management and outcome of clini-
cally-suspected spinal infection. J Infect 58(4):259–265
17. Macnab I (1971) Negative disc exploration. An analysis of the
causes of nerve-root involvement in sixty-eight patients. J Bone
References Joint Surg Am 53(5):891–903
18. Nielsen VA, Iversen E, Ahlgren P (1990) Postoperative discitis.
1. Bavinzski G, Schoeggl A, Trattnig S et al (2003) Microsurgical Radiology of progress and healing. Acta Radiol 31(6):559–563
management of postoperative disc space infection. Neurosurg 19. Onik G (1996) Automated percutaneous biopsy in the diagnosis
Rev 26(2):102–107 and treatment of infectious discitis. Neurosurg Clin N Am
2. Bozgeyik Z, Ozdemir H, Demirdag K, Ozden M, Sonmezgoz F, 7(1):145–150
Ozgocmen S (2008) Clinical and MRI findings of Brucellar 20. Ozuna RM, Delamarter RB (1996) Pyogenic vertebral osteomy-
spondylodiscitis. Eur J Radiol 67(1):153–158 elitis and postsurgical disc space infections. Orthop Clin North
3. Connor PM, Darden BV (1993) Cervical discography complica- Am 27(1):87–94
tions and clinical efficacy. Spine 18(14):2035–2038 21. Rankine JJ, Barron DA, Robinson P, Millner PA, Dickson RA
4. Dimar JR, Carreon LY, Glassman SD, Campbell MJ, Hartman (2004) Therapeutic impact of percutaneous spinal biopsy in
MJ, Johnson JR (2004) Treatment of pyogenic vertebral osteo- spinal infection. Postgrad Med J 80(948):607–609
myelitis with anterior debridement and fusion followed by 22. Sharma SK, Jones JO, Zeballos PP, Irwin SA, Martin TW (2009)
delayed posterior spinal fusion. Spine 29(3):326–332 discussion The prevention of discitis during discography. Spine 9(11):936–
332 943
5. Emery SE, Chan DP, Woodward HR (1989) Treatment of 23. Staatz G, Adam GB, Keulers P, Vorwerk D, Gunther RW (1998)
hematogenous pyogenic vertebral osteomyelitis with anterior Spondylodiskitic abscesses: CT-guided percutaneous catheter
debridement and primary bone grafting. Spine 14(3):284–291 drainage. Radiology 208(2):363–367
6. Enoch DA, Cargill JS, Laing R, Herbert S, Corrah TW, Brown 24. Tronnier V, Schneider R, Kunz U, Albert F, Oldenkott P (1992)
NM (2008) Value of CT-guided biopsy in the diagnosis of septic Postoperative spondylodiscitis: results of a prospective study
discitis. J Clin Pathol 61(6):750–753 about the aetiology of spondylodiscitis after operation for lumbar
7. Fouquet B, Goupille P, Jattiot F et al (1992) Discitis after lumbar disc herniation. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 117(3–4):149–152
disc surgery. Features of ‘‘aseptic’’ and ‘‘septic’’ forms. Spine 25. Valls J, Ottolenghi CE, Schajowicz F (1948) Aspiration biopsy in
17(3):356–358 diagnosis of lesions of vertebral bodies. J Am Med Assoc
8. Gebhard JS, Brugman JL (1994) Percutaneous discectomy for the 136(6):376–382
treatment of bacterial discitis. Spine 19(7):855–857 26. Viale P, Furlanut M, Scudeller L et al (2009) Treatment of
9. Haaker RG, Senkal M, Kielich T, Kramer J (1997) Percutaneous pyogenic (non-tuberculous) spondylodiscitis with tailored high-
lumbar discectomy in the treatment of lumbar discitis. Eur Spine dose levofloxacin plus rifampicin. Int J Antimicrob Agents
J 6(2):98–101 33(4):379–382
10. Hadjipavlou AG, Mader JT, Necessary JT, Muffoletto AJ (2000) 27. Wirtz DC, Genius I, Wildberger JE, Adam G, Zilkens KW,
Hematogenous pyogenic spinal infections and their surgical Niethard FU (2000) Diagnostic and therapeutic management of
management. Spine 25(13):1668–1679 lumbar and thoracic spondylodiscitis—an evaluation of 59 cases.
11. Heyde CE, Boehm H, El Saghir H, Tschoke SK, Kayser R (2006) Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 120(5–6):245–251
Surgical treatment of spondylodiscitis in the cervical spine: a 28. Zeidman SM, Thompson K, Ducker TB (1995) Complications of
minimum 2-year follow-up. Eur Spine J 15(9):1380–1387 cervical discography: analysis of 4400 diagnostic disc injections.
12. Iversen E, Nielsen VA, Hansen LG (1992) Prognosis in postop- Neurosurgery 37(3):414–417
erative discitis. A retrospective study of 111 cases. Acta Orthop
Scand 63(3):305–309

123

You might also like