You are on page 1of 14

ultimately bore his name.

2 Until the beginning of the twenti-


eth century, most children with congenital megacolon died,
presumably from malnutrition and enterocolitis. Because
the underlying pathologic abnormality was not recognized,
surgeons who operated on these children usually resected
the dilated proximal bowel with or without primary anasto-
mosis, with mixed results.3
The absence of ganglion cells in the distal colon of a child
with Hirschsprung disease was first noted by Tittel in 1901.
Over the following decades numerous papers were published
to document abnormalities of innervation within the colon
and recognize the absence of ganglion cells that is now patho-
gnomonic of Hirschsprung disease. The first surgical recogni-
tion of aganglionosis as the cause of congenital megacolon was
by Ehrenpreis in 1946. In a landmark paper, Whitehouse and
Kernohan summarized the literature and presented a series of
cases of their own, which documented that the aganglionosis
within the distal colon or rectum was the cause of the
functional obstruction.4
In 1949 Swenson published a paper in the New England
Journal of Medicine recommending rectosigmoidectomy with
preservation of the sphincters as the optimal treatment of this
disease.5 This operation was originally performed without a
CHAPTER 101 decompressing colostomy.6 However, technical difficulties in
small infants and the debilitated and malnourished state in
which most children presented caused most surgeons to adopt
a multistaged approach with colostomy as the initial step,6 an
Hirschsprung approach that became the standard of care for decades. In
recent years, improvements in surgical technique and earlier
suspicion and diagnosis of the disease have resulted in an
Disease evolution toward one-stage and minimal access procedures.
These advances have resulted in significantly improved
morbidity and mortality in infants with Hirschsprung disease.
Jacob C. Langer

Etiology and Genetics


Hirschsprung disease is a developmental disorder of the in- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

trinsic component of the enteric nervous system that is char- Ganglion cells are derived from the neural crest. By 13 weeks
acterized by the absence of ganglion cells in the myenteric and postconception, the neural crest cells have undergone a pro-
submucosal plexuses of the distal intestine. Because these cells cess of migration through the gastrointestinal tract from prox-
are responsible for normal peristalsis, patients with Hirsch- imal to distal, after which they differentiate into mature
sprung disease present with functional intestinal obstruction ganglion cells.7 In infants with Hirschsprung disease this pro-
at the level of aganglionosis. In most cases the aganglionosis cess is disturbed, so the ganglion cells are absent in the distal
involves the rectum or rectosigmoid, but it can extend for bowel. There are two theories as to why this occurs. The most
varying lengths, and in 5% to 10% of cases can involve the en- prevalent is that the neural crest cells never reach the distal
tire colon or even a significant amount of the small intestine. intestine because they either mature or differentiate into gan-
The incidence of Hirschsprung disease is approximately 1 in glion cells earlier than they should. Data supporting this the-
5000 live-born infants. ory come from spontaneously occurring animal models of
aganglionosis8 and from studies of normal neural crest cell mi-
gration done in chick embryos and human fetuses.9,10 The
second theory is that the ganglion cells do reach their destina-
History tion but fail to survive or proliferate. Data in support of this
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
theory include animal studies suggesting that there are at least
The condition of “congenital megacolon” has been recognized two sources of neural crest cells (vagal and sacral), with migra-
for centuries. The first description of this condition was in the tion both proximally and distally. In addition, a number of
seventeenth century by Frederick Ruysch, who described a studies have suggested that the smooth muscle and extracel-
5-year-old child dying from an intestinal obstruction, followed lular matrix in the aganglionic bowel provides an inhospitable
by another account of a child with congenital megacolon by microenvironment for neuronal growth.11,12 It is likely that
Battini in 1800.1 It was not until 1887 that Harald Hirsch- Hirschsprung disease is actually a heterogeneous condition
sprung, a pathologist at Queen Louise Children’s Hospital with multiple genetic causes and etiologic mechanisms, so
in Copenhagen, described two cases of the condition that each of these theories may be true in individual cases.
1265
1266 PART VII ABDOMEN

The heterogeneous nature of Hirschsprung disease is sup- Hirschsprung disease from more common causes of constipa-
ported by increasing evidence that mutations in a variety of tion. Clinical features that point to this diagnosis include
genes may be responsible.13–15 The most commonly identified failure to pass meconium in the first 48 hours of life, failure
gene is the RET proto-oncogene, which was first identified in to thrive, gross abdominal distention, and dependence on
studies of Mennonite populations. RET encodes a tyrosine enemas without significant encopresis.21
kinase receptor, and many mutations of this gene and related
genes such as neurturin and glial cell line–derived neuro-
trophic factor (GDNF) have been identified in association with Enterocolitis
Hirschsprung disease. It remains unclear how these mutations Approximately 10% of children with Hirschsprung disease
result in aganglionosis, but there is some evidence that early present with fever, abdominal distention, and diarrhea due
neuronal cell death may be a prominent mechanism.16,17 to Hirschsprung-associated enterocolitis (HAEC), which
RET abnormalities are more commonly found in familial may be chronic, or may be severe and life-threatening. Be-
and long-segment disease. Mutations in the endothelin family cause Hirschsprung disease is generally thought of as causing
of genes, particularly endothelin-3 and the endothelin-B constipation, presentation with diarrhea may be confusing
receptor, are also commonly associated with Hirschsprung and the diagnosis may not be considered. A careful history
disease, although many of these children also have other including the failure to pass meconium and the presence of
abnormalities of neural crest–derived tissues, the most common intermittent obstructive episodes should lead to investigation
of which is Shah-Wardenberg syndrome. There is evidence for Hirschsprung disease.
from animal models that mutations in the endothelin and The etiology of HAEC is controversial. The most common
SOX-10 genes may produce early maturation or differentia- theory is that stasis caused by functional obstruction due to
tion of neural crest cells, which decreases the number of the aganglionic bowel permits bacterial overgrowth with sec-
available progenitor cells and prevents the neural crest cells ondary infection. Infectious agents such as Clostridium difficile
from migrating any further.18,19 Other genes that have been or Rotavirus have been postulated as being causative, but
associated with Hirschsprung disease include S1P1 (now there are few data to support a specific pathogen.22 There is
known as ZFHX1B), and Phox2B. some evidence implicating alterations in intestinal mucin
Hirschsprung disease is also associated with a number of production and alterations in the mucosal production of
syndromes for which the precise genetic basis of the aganglio- immunoglobulins in children with Hirschsprung-associated
nosis has not yet been elucidated. These include Trisomy-21, enterocolitis, which presumably results in loss of intestinal bar-
congenital central hypoventilation syndrome, Goldberg- rier function and allows bacterial invasion.23,24
Shprintzen syndrome, Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome, neurofi-
bromatosis, neuroblastoma, and a variety of other congenital Associated Conditions
anomalies.
Hirschsprung disease is associated with a variety of other con-
genital abnormalities, the presence of which should increase
the clinician’s level of suspicion (Table 101-1). These include
Diagnosis
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
malrotation, genitourinary abnormalities, congenital heart dis-
ease, limb abnormalities, cleft lip and palate, hearing loss, mental
CLINICAL PRESENTATION retardation, and dysmorphic features. In addition, Hirschsprung
disease may be part of a large number of recognized syn-
Neonatal Obstruction
dromes such as trisomy 21, a variety of neurocristopathies,
Approximately 50% to 90% of children with Hirschsprung and congenital central hypoventilation syndrome.
disease present during the neonatal period with abdominal
distension, bilious vomiting, and feeding intolerance sugges-
TABLE 101-1
tive of distal intestinal obstruction. Delayed passage of meco-
Congenital Anomalies and Conditions Commonly Associated
nium beyond the first 24 hours is characteristic but is only with Hirschsprung Disease
present in approximately 90% of children with Hirschsprung
disease. In some patients cecal or appendiceal perforation may Down syndrome (trisomy 21)
be the initial event.20 Plain radiographs usually show dilated Neurocristopathy syndromes
bowel loops throughout the abdomen. The differential diag- 1. Waardenberg-Shah syndrome
nosis includes intestinal atresia, meconium ileus, meconium 2. Yemenite deaf-blind-hypopigmentation
plug syndrome, or a number of other less common conditions. 3. Piebaldism
4. Other hypopigmentation syndromes
Chronic Constipation Goldberg-Shprintzen syndrome
Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome
Some patients present later in childhood, or even during Multiple endocrine neoplasia 2
adulthood, with chronic constipation. This is most common Congenital central hypoventilation syndrome (Ondine curse)
among breast-fed infants, who typically develop constipation Isolated congenital anomalies
around the time of weaning. Although most children who pre- 1. Congenital heart disease
sent after the neonatal period have short-segment disease, this 2. Malrotation
history may also be found in those with longer segment or 3. Urinary tract anomalies
even total colonic involvement, particularly if the child has 4. Central nervous system anomalies
been exclusively breast-fed. Because constipation is frequently 5. Other
seen in childhood, it may be difficult to differentiate
CHAPTER 101 HIRSCHSPRUNG DISEASE 1267

RADIOLOGIC EVALUATION RECTAL BIOPSY


For the neonate with a clinical picture and plain radiographs Definitive diagnosis of Hirschsprung disease is based on his-
suggesting distal neonatal bowel obstruction, the first step in tologic evaluation of a rectal biopsy, which remains the gold
the diagnostic pathway is a water-soluble contrast enema. The standard diagnostic technique. The definitive finding that de-
pathognomonic finding of Hirschsprung disease on contrast fines Hirschsprung disease is absence of ganglion cells in the
enema is a transition zone between the normal and aganglio- submucosal and myenteric plexuses (Fig. 101-2, A). Most pa-
nic bowel (Fig. 101-1, A), although approximately 10% of tients will also have evidence of hypertrophied nerve trunks
neonates with Hirschsprung disease may not have a demon- (Fig. 101-2, B), although this finding is not always present,
strable radiologic transition zone.25 It is important to use particularly in children with total colonic disease or a short
a water-soluble material because the enema may potentially aganglionic segment. Because there is normally a paucity of
be a definitive treatment for other conditions in the differential ganglion cells in the area 0.5 to 1 cm above the dentate line,
diagnosis such as meconium ileus and meconium plug syn- the biopsy should be taken at least 1 to 1.5 cm above it. How-
drome. In older children an unprepped barium enema should ever, a biopsy too proximal may miss a short aganglionic seg-
be done rather than a water-soluble contrast study. The ab- ment. Most surgeons use a suction biopsy technique, which is
sence of a transition zone is less common in this age group associated with a low risk of perforation or bleeding. For chil-
but may still be present due to a short aganglionic segment. dren in whom the suction biopsy yields an inadequate spec-
In both neonates and older children, the most important view imen and in older children in whom the mucosa is too thick
is the lateral projection, in which a rectal transition zone will for a suction biopsy, punch biopsies or full-thickness biopsies
be most evident (Fig. 101-1, B). Other findings on the contrast provide more tissue and deeper levels.
enema that are suggestive of Hirschsprung disease include a In many centers the routine hematoxylin and eosin staining
reversed recto-sigmoid index (Fig. 101-1, B) and retention is supplemented by staining for acetylcholinesterase, which
of contrast in the colon on a 24-hour postevacuation film. has a characteristic pattern in the submucosa and mucosa
in children with Hirschsprung disease (Fig. 101-2, C). Other
pathologists choose not to use acetylcholinesterase staining,
believing that it is too subjective and does not add any infor-
ANORECTAL MANOMETRY
mation to the hematoxylin and eosin. A number of newer
The recto-anal inhibitory reflex (RAIR) is defined as reflex re- stains have recently been shown to have additional value for
laxation of the internal anal sphincter in response to rectal dis- the diagnosis of Hirschsprung disease. The most accurate
tension and is present in normal children but absent in appears to be immunochemical identification of calcitonin,
children with Hirschsprung disease. The RAIR can be docu- which is almost always absent in patients with Hirschsprung
mented using anorectal manometry by inflating a balloon in disease (Fig. 101-2, D).26
the rectum while simultaneously measuring the internal Occasionally a premature infant will develop distal intesti-
sphincter pressure. Anorectal manometry is not widely avail- nal obstruction, and the possibility of Hirschsprung disease
able for neonates and is often operator dependent. In older will be raised on the basis of clinical and radiologic parame-
children the test is technically easier, but false-positive results ters. Early rectal biopsy in these children is not recommended
may occur due to masking of the relaxation response by con- for two reasons: (1) The pathologist may have difficulty recog-
traction of the external sphincter, as well as artifacts created by nizing ganglion cells due to their immaturity, and (2) it may be
movement or crying. Anorectal manometry is most useful in difficult to obtain enough tissue without increasing the risk of
the evaluation of an older child with chronic constipation, complications in a small premature infant. It is best in this
where documentation of a normal RAIR effectively rules out situation to decompress the rectum using stimulations and/or
Hirschsprung disease and avoids the need for a rectal biopsy. irrigations and wait until the child is closer to term before

A B
FIGURE 101-1 A, Water-soluble contrast enema demonstrating a transition zone at the splenic flexure. B, The lateral view is the most important one to
identify a low transition zone. In this case the recto-sigmoid index, consisting of the ratio of rectal diameter (R) to sigmoid diameter (S), is less than 1.0. D.
Retention of contrast on a 24-hour postevacuation film.
1268 PART VII ABDOMEN

A B C1

C2 D1 D2
FIGURE 101-2 Pathologic findings in children with Hirschsprung disease. A, Absence of ganglion cells in the myenteric plexus. B, Hypertrophied nerve
trunks. C, Cholinesterase staining in normal colon and colon affected by Hirschsprung disease. D, Calretinin staining in normal colon and colon affected by
Hirschsprung disease. (D, Courtesy Dr. Raj Kapur.)

doing the rectal biopsy. Although some surgeons believe that be administered, and a nasogastric tube should be inserted.
Hirschsprung disease is not seen in premature infants, this Children with associated abnormalities such as cardiac disease
condition has been well-documented in a number of series. or congenital central hypoventilation syndrome must be
investigated and managed before definitive surgical repair.
Children with enterocolitis or those in whom immediate
Preoperative Management surgery cannot be done for other reasons should undergo
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
decompression of the colon using digital rectal stimulation,
In most cases the treatment of Hirschsprung disease is surgi- irrigations, or occasionally an emergency stoma.
cal. However, there are a number of important preoperative Once a child has been resuscitated and stabilized, opera-
interventions that must be considered before definitive surgi- tion can be done semielectively. While waiting, most children
cal intervention. The first priority is resuscitation, particularly can be discharged home on breast milk or an elemental for-
in neonates with intestinal obstruction or children presenting mula, in combination with rectal stimulations or irrigations.
with enterocolitis. In both groups, intravenous fluids and In the older child with an extremely dilated colon, operation
broad-spectrum antibiotics against enteric organisms should should be delayed until the diameter of the colon has
CHAPTER 101 HIRSCHSPRUNG DISEASE 1269

decreased sufficiently to do a pull-through safely. This can some- the anus while preserving normal sphincter function. The
times be accomplished with weeks or months of irrigations, but most commonly performed operations are the Swenson,
some of these children may require a colostomy in order to Duhamel, and Soave procedures (Fig. 101-4), although a
adequately decompress the dilated colon (Fig. 101-3). number of other operations such as the Rebhein and State pro-
Some authors have advocated nonoperative long-term cedures have been described and are still done in some cen-
management of short-segment Hirschsprung disease using ters. Although many publications in the literature report
enemas and laxatives. Others have suggested that simple results after each of these operations, few randomized or prop-
myectomy may be adequate.27 However, these techniques erly controlled prospective studies exist. Because of this lack of
do not provide a good quality of life for most children with evidence, it is fair to say that all are acceptable alternatives and
Hirschsprung disease, and most pediatric surgeons recom- that the best operation for an individual patient is the one that
mend a pull-through procedure. the surgeon has been trained to do and does frequently.

SWENSON PROCEDURE
Pull-through Procedure for Swenson provided the first description of a surgical approach
Hirschsprung Disease to Hirschsprung disease in the late 1940s. Swenson’s goal was
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
removal of the entire aganglionic colon, with an end-to-end
The goals of surgical management for Hirschsprung disease anastomosis above the anal sphincter. The operation was orig-
are to remove the aganglionic bowel and reconstruct the intes- inally done through a laparotomy, with the anastomosis being
tinal tract by bringing the normally innervated bowel down to performed from a perineal approach after eversion of the

A B
FIGURE 101-3 Value of a decompressing colostomy to decrease the size of the dilated sigmoid colon before pull-through surgery. A, Before colostomy.
B, Six months after colostomy.

A B C
FIGURE 101-4 The three most commonly performed operations for Hirschsprung disease. A, Soave. B, Swenson. C, Duhamel. þ ¼ ganglionic
bowel,  ¼ aganglionic bowel.
1270 PART VII ABDOMEN

aganglionic rectum. Safe performance of the operation re-


quires careful attention to dissection tightly on the rectal wall, Role of Colostomy
in order to avoid injury to deep pelvic nerves, vessels, and ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

other structures such as vagina, prostate, vas deferens, and Swenson’s initial operation was described as a one-stage
seminal vesicles. Despite the theoretical risks inherent in procedure, but relatively high incidence of stricture, leak, and
the deep pelvic dissection, long-term outcome studies of the other adverse outcomes led him and others to recommend a
Swenson procedure report excellent functional results with routine preliminary colostomy, followed by a period of growth
respect to continence, urinary, and sexual function.28 and a subsequent reconstructive operation.32 This approach
became surgical dogma, which was reinforced by the fact that
many children with Hirschsprung disease presented late with
SOAVE PROCEDURE
malnutrition and dilated colon, so a colostomy was a life-
The Soave procedure was designed to avoid the risks of injury saving procedure. In the 1980s, however, a number of surgeons
to pelvic structures inherent in the Swenson procedure by reported series of single-stage pull-through procedures even in
doing a submucosal endorectal dissection and placing the small infants.33,34 Over the next 10 to 15 years, one-stage
pull-through bowel within a “cuff” consisting of aganglionic operations became increasingly popular and many reports
muscle. In the initial description of the operation, the documented the safety of this approach, suggesting that a
pulled-through colon was left hanging out through the anus. single-stage procedure avoids the known morbidity of stomas
This exteriorized bowel was excised, and the anastomosis in infants and is also more cost-effective.35–37 It is important
done, at a second operation several weeks later. This was sub- to remember, however, that a stoma may still be indicated
sequently modified by Boley, who performed the procedure in for children with severe enterocolitis, perforation, malnutri-
a single stage.29 Over the years there has been controversy tion, or massively dilated proximal bowel, as well as in situa-
regarding how long the cuff should be, as well as whether it tions where there is inadequate pathology support to reliably
should be split or a segment excised. Despite claims by some identify the transition zone on frozen section.
authors that the Soave procedure is more likely to result in
long-term issues with constipation due to incomplete excision Minimal Access Approaches
of the aganglionic rectum,30 most late follow-up studies have ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

reported similar outcomes to that seen with the Swenson LAPAROSCOPIC PULL-THROUGH
procedure.31
With the advent of laparoscopic surgery in the late 1980s,
minimal access techniques became increasingly applied to
DUHAMEL PROCEDURE
pediatric surgical diseases. The first minimal approach to
The Duhamel procedure involves bringing the normal colon pull-through surgery for Hirschsprung disease was described
down through the bloodless plane between the rectum and by Georgeson in 1995,38 who described a laparoscopic pull-
the sacrum and joining the two walls to create a new lumen, through for Hirschsprung disease, involving laparoscopic bi-
which was aganglionic anteriorly and normally innervated opsy to identify the transition zone, laparoscopic mobilization
posteriorly. In the initial description, two Kocher clamps were of the rectum below the peritoneal reflection, and a short
used to join the walls and were left in for a week. More mucosal dissection through a perineal approach (Fig. 101-5).
recently, surgical staplers were used instead. The Duhamel The rectum is then prolapsed through the anus, and the anas-
procedure has several potential advantages over the Swenson tomosis is done from below. This procedure has been
or Soave procedures. It is believed to be easier and safer, with associated with a shorter hospital time, and both early and mid-
less pelvic dissection than the other two operations; it has a term results appear to be equivalent to those reported for the
large anastomosis, which decreases the risk of anastomotic open procedures.39 Laparoscopic approaches have been also
stricture; and the presence of a “reservoir” makes it appealing described for the Duhamel and Swenson operations, with
for children with longer aganglionic segments. excellent short-term results reported.40,41

A B
FIGURE 101-5 Laparoscopic pull-through. A, Confirmation of the pathologic transition zone. B, Laparoscopic view of the completed pull-through
from above. (Courtesy Dr. Steve Rothenberg.)
CHAPTER 101 HIRSCHSPRUNG DISEASE 1271

TRANSANAL (PERINEAL) PULL-THROUGH


rationale for this practice is the known inaccuracy of the
The transanal pull-through procedure uses the same mucosal contrast enema in predicting the level of aganglionosis, with
dissection from below as the Georgeson operation, but with- approximately 8% of children who have a rectosigmoid tran-
out laparoscopic mobilization of the rectum. The mucosal in- sition zone on contrast study having a more proximal transi-
cision is made 0.5 to 1 cm above the dentate line, depending tion zone on histology.46 This step is particularly important for
on the size of the child, and the mucosa is stripped from the surgeons who do a different operation for long-segment dis-
underlying muscle as in the Soave operation. The rectal mus- ease than they do for rectosigmoid disease. The preliminary
cle is then incised circumferentially, and the dissection is con- biopsy can be done using a laparoscopic approach, or through
tinued on the rectal wall, dividing the vessels as they enter the a small umbilical incision, both of which can also be used to
rectum. The entire rectum and part of the sigmoid colon can mobilize the splenic flexure in children with higher transition
be delivered through the anus. When the transition zone is zones.47 The advantage of the umbilical approach is that it can
reached, the anastomosis is done from below (Fig. 101-6). be done by any surgeon, anywhere in the world, and does not
In patients with a more proximal transition zone (usually require laparoscopic skills or equipment. Evidence would
above the proximal sigmoid colon), laparoscopy or a small suggest that a preliminary biopsy to determine the pathologic
umbilical incision can be used to mobilize the left colon transition zone does not have a deleterious effect on post-
and/or splenic flexure to achieve adequate length. A transanal operative outcomes such as time to feeding, pain, or length
approach can also be used if the patient has already had a co- of hospital stay.45,48
lostomy, by using the stoma as the end of the pull-through There is also controversy about whether the transanal pull-
bowel and performing the rectal excision using the transanal through is best done in the prone or supine position.49 The
technique. prone position provides excellent visualization and is familiar
The transanal approach has a low complication rate, re- to most pediatric surgeons because of their experience with it
quires minimal analgesia, and is associated with early feeding in the repair of anorectal malformations. The supine position
and discharge.42–45 Although there have not been any studies has the advantage of access to the peritoneal cavity for initial
comparing the transanal and laparoscopic approaches, the colonic biopsy or for mobilization of the colon or a stoma if
transanal pull-through can be done by any pediatric surgeon, necessary. Finally, there is controversy about the length of
including those without laparoscopic skills, and by pediatric the rectal cuff. The initial description of the transanal pull-
surgeons in parts of the world where access to appropriately through involved a long cuff, with a submucosal dissection
miniaturized laparoscopic equipment is limited. extending into the peritoneal cavity. Many surgeons continue
A number of ongoing controversies surround the transanal to do the operation this way, and most advocate division of the
pull-through. The first is whether the pathologic transition cuff to prevent narrowing. Other surgeons have modified the
zone should be defined before beginning the anal dissection. procedure by doing a short submucosal dissection for a few
This was not done in the early descriptions of the operation centimeters, and others have abandoned the submucosal
and continues to be omitted by many surgeons. The main dissection entirely and do what is essentially a transanal

A B C

D E
FIGURE 101-6 The transanal Soave pull-through. A, An umbilical incision is used for a preliminary biopsy. A Heger dilator is used to push the sigmoid
into the umbilical incision. B, Eversion sutures are placed, and a nasal speculum is used to provide exposure to the anal canal. A circumferential incision is made
5 mm from the dentate line. C, The submucosal dissection is carried 2 to 3 cm. D, Once the muscle cuff has been divided circumferentially, the dissection
is carried proximally, staying right on the colonic wall. E, The bowel is divided at least 2 cm above the biopsy showing ganglion cells, and the anastomosis
is performed. Care must be taken to do the anastomosis to the rectal mucosa, not to the transitional epithelium, or normal sensation will be lost and the risk
of incontinence will be increased.
1272 PART VII ABDOMEN

Swenson procedure.50 The advantage of a shorter cuff is a Once the level of aganglionosis has been identified, most
lower rate of narrowing and potentially a lower risk of surgeons create a stoma, wait for permanent sections, and
postoperative obstructive symptoms and enterocolitis.48 do a definitive reconstructive procedure at a later time. Al-
though primary pull-through without ileostomy for total co-
lonic disease has been reported, this approach requires a
Surgical Approach to Long- high degree of confidence in the pathologist because it re-
quires doing a total colectomy on the basis of frozen sections
Segment Hirschsprung Disease alone. In addition, many surgeons believe that the results of
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
pull-through surgery are better once the stool has thickened,
Long-segment Hirschsprung disease is usually defined as a which usually occurs in the first few months of life.
transition zone that is proximal to the midtransverse colon. Three types of operations are available for reconstruction in
The most common is total colonic aganglionosis, which usu- children with long-segment Hirschsprung disease: straight
ally also includes some of the distal ileum. In rare cases most of pull-through, colon patch, and J-pouch construction. Straight
or the entire small bowel is aganglionic. Long-segment disease pull-through procedures involve bringing the normally inner-
is more likely to be associated with a positive family history51 vated ileum to just above the anal sphincter, using any one of
and is more likely to be diagnosed prenatally.52 Contrast the standard techniques (Swenson, Duhamel, or Soave). Co-
enema typically shows a shortened, relatively narrow colon lon patch procedures involve a side-to-side anastomosis be-
(“question mark colon”) (Fig. 101-7),53 and there may also tween normally innervated small bowel and aganglionic
be a transition zone in the small bowel. The rectal biopsy colon, using the small bowel for motility and the colon as a
shows absence of ganglion cells, but in many cases there are reservoir for storage of stool and absorption of water. The
no hypertrophic nerves or abnormalities of acetylcholinester- Martin procedure consists of a Duhamel reconstruction that ex-
ase staining. tends proximally to involve the entire left colon (Fig. 101-8, A).
Early resuscitation and management is similar to that de- Kimura, using the rationale that the right colon is better at water
scribed for standard Hirschsprung disease. Sequential colonic absorption than the left colon, advocated a staged procedure, in
biopsies are done looking for ganglion cells on frozen section. which the right colon is anastomosed side-to-side to the ileum.
These can be done through a standard laparotomy, laparosco- The “ileo-colon” is then disconnected from the right colonic
pically, or through an umbilical incision, which in a newborn blood supply after several months and anastomosed above the
can be used to access all parts of the colon. Traditionally, many anal sphincter (Fig. 101-8, B). The J-pouch procedure is done
surgeons started with an appendectomy, assuming that lack of commonly for children and adults with ulcerative colitis and
ganglion cells in the appendix would be diagnostic of total familial polyposis syndrome, and some pediatric surgeons
colonic disease. However, this may result in a false-positive have reported the use of this operation for children with
diagnosis of total colonic Hirschsprung disease because there long-segment Hirschsprung disease.55
may be a paucity of ganglion cells in the appendix in children There are no prospective or well-controlled series reporting
with shorter segment disease.54 long-term results of surgery for long-segment Hirschsprung
disease. Although the colon patch procedures theoretically
result in decreased stool output due to better water absorp-
tion, the aganglionic colon gradually tends to dilate and many
of these patients develop severe enterocolitis, which requires
removal of the patch or a permanent stoma. Children under-
going straight pull-through tend to experience gradually
decreasing stool frequency over time, with an acceptable
quality of life.56–58
Near-Total Intestinal Aganglionosis
Rarely, almost the entire intestinal tract of a patient is agangli-
onic, usually leaving 10 to 40 cm of normally innervated jeju-
num. In most of these cases, there is not enough functional
small bowel to support enteral nutrition and intestinal failure
results. These children require total parenteral nutrition from
birth, a situation that has been associated with a high risk of
mortality from liver failure. The surgical approach at the time
of the first laparotomy is to determine the extent of aganglio-
nosis on the basis of frozen sections and to bring out a stoma at
the most distal point that has normally innervated bowel.
Some surgeons prefer to bring out a more distal stoma, but this
approach may increase the risk of chronic intestinal obstruc-
tion and bacterial overgrowth. A central venous catheter
should be inserted for parenteral nutrition, and a gastrostomy
should be considered for continuous “trophic” feeding of
FIGURE 101-7 Contrast enema in a child with total colonic Hirschsprung
breast milk or elemental formula.
disease. There is no transition zone in the colon, and the colon is foreshor- The management of these children is similar to the manage-
tened with a “question-mark” configuration. ment of any child with intestinal failure.59 Strict attention to
CHAPTER 101 HIRSCHSPRUNG DISEASE 1273

C
FIGURE 101-8 Operations for long-segment Hirschsprung disease. A, Martin procedure. B and C, Kimura procedure.

prevention of sepsis, treatment of bacterial overgrowth, use of A number of surgical options are available for children with
trophic feeds, and prevention of TPN-related cholestasis are near-total aganglionosis.61 For children who develop signifi-
all extremely important. Recent experience with omega-3 cant proximal dilatation of the normally innervated bowel,
lipids has resulted in encouraging trends toward prevention tapering, imbrication, or bowel-lengthening procedures
and treatment of this problem.60 such as the Bianchi or serial transverse enteroplasty (STEP)
1274 PART VII ABDOMEN

procedure may be used.62,63 Zeigler has popularized a tech- OBSTRUCTIVE SYMPTOMS


nique known as “myectomy-myotomy,” in which a length of
aganglionic small bowel distal to the transition zone un- There are a range of obstructive symptoms that can be seen
dergoes myectomy.64 Although a few successful cases using after a pull-through. Abdominal distension, bloating, vomit-
this technique have been reported, most surgeons have not ing, or ongoing severe constipation may be present immedi-
found it to be successful and have noted high rates of postop- ately after surgery or may develop later after an initial
erative complications. For children with ongoing liver failure, period of normal bowel function. There are five major reasons
small bowel or combined small bowel-liver transplantation for persistent obstructive symptoms following a pull-through:
may offer the only chance for survival. A recent report from mechanical obstruction, recurrent or acquired aganglionosis,
Paris documented extremely good results in 12 patients, many disordered motility in the proximal colon or small bowel,
of whom underwent successful pull-through surgery follow- internal sphincter achalasia, or functional megacolon caused
ing their intestinal transplant.65 by stool-holding behavior (Table 101-2). The clinician will
have much greater success in managing these difficult patients
if an organized approach to this problem is taken. One
Postoperative Care
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
proposed algorithm is shown in Figure 101-9.71
Mechanical Obstruction
Most children undergoing a laparoscopic or transanal pull-
through for standard Hirschsprung disease can be fed imme- The most common cause of mechanical obstruction after a
diately, and most can be discharged within 24 to 48 hours. pull-through is a stricture, which usually occurs after a Swen-
The anastomosis should be calibrated with an appropriately son or Soave procedure (Fig. 101-10, A). Patients undergoing
sized dilator or finger 1 to 2 weeks after the procedure. Al- a Duhamel procedure may have a retained “spur” consisting of
though many surgeons instruct the parents to dilate the anas- the anterior aganglionic bowel, which may fill with stool and
tomosis on a daily basis, others have found it to be obstruct the pulled-through bowel (Fig. 101-10, B). In other
unnecessary in most cases and instead perform weekly cali- cases, there may be obstruction secondary to a twist in the
bration for a period of 4 to 6 weeks. It is important for the pulled-through bowel (Fig. 101-10, C) or narrowing due to
parents to protect the buttocks with a barrier cream because a long muscular cuff in children who have had a Soave
at least 50% of children will have frequent stools and peri- procedure.
neal skin breakdown postoperatively. Fortunately, this prob- Obstruction can be identified using a combination of dig-
lem tends to resolve over time. ital rectal examination and a barium enema. Initial manage-
As with any operation, children undergoing a pull-through ment of anastomotic stricture consists of repeated dilatation
may develop a wound infection or intra-abdominal bleeding. using a finger, dilator, or radially dilating balloon. Some au-
In addition, anastomotic complications such as leak or stric- thors have advocated innovative techniques for recalcitrant
ture may occur. Intestinal perforation can occur at a proximal strictures including antegrade dilatation over a string using
biopsy site due to back pressure from anal sphincter spasm or Tucker dilators72 and the use of intralesional steroid.73 In
due to unrecognized cautery injury. Bowel obstruction can re- some cases the stricture cannot be successfully dilated, and
sult from intra-abdominal adhesions, a twist in the pull- revision of the pull-through is necessary. This is best done
through bowel, or a muscular cuff that has rolled down and using the Duhamel technique, although other operations have
constricted the pull-through bowel. In rare cases, rectovesical also been advocated.74–76 Duhamel spurs can be resected from
or rectovaginal fistulas have developed after pull-through above or managed by extending the staple line from below,
surgery. Close monitoring for and early treatment of these with or without laparoscopic visualization. Twisted pull-
complications is imperative. In addition, children with throughs and narrow muscular cuffs usually require surgical
Hirschsprung disease can develop enterocolitis, even in the intervention, typically a repeat pull-through. In some cases,
early postoperative period. The family and the primary care a muscular cuff can be divided laparoscopically without
physician should be educated about the signs and symptoms having to re-do the entire pull-through.
of enterocolitis, and the family must be told to bring the child
to the hospital if there are any signs suggestive of this problem Persistent or Acquired Aganglionosis
because children can become very sick and even die from This rare problem may be due to pathologist error,77 a tran-
enterocolitis.66 sition zone pull-through,78 or ganglion cell loss after a
pull-through.79 Repeat rectal biopsy, above the previous anas-
tomosis (it must be posterior in the case of an initial Duhamel
Long-Term Outcomes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
procedure), should be done to determine whether there are
Long-term problems in children with Hirschsprung disease
include ongoing obstructive symptoms, soiling, and enteroco- TABLE 101-2
litis.67 Quite often an individual child may have a combination Causes of Obstructive Symptoms Following Surgery
of problems. Although early reports suggested that long-term for Hirschsprung Disease
issues were rare after surgical treatment of Hirschsprung dis- Mechanical obstruction
ease,68 it is now clear that these complications are more com- Recurrent or residual aganglionosis
mon than previously recognized.31,69,70 It is important for the Motility disorder involving the ganglionated bowel
surgeon to follow these children closely, at least until they are Internal anal sphincter achalasia
through the toilet training process, in order to identify and Functional megacolon (stool-holding behavior)
provide early treatment for these problems.
CHAPTER 101 HIRSCHSPRUNG DISEASE 1275

Physical exam and barium enema

No stricture Stricture

Rectal biopsy
Dilate or redo
pull-through
Ganglion cells present
No ganglion cells

Motility workup
Redo pull-through

Normal Abnormal focal Abnormal generalized

Try botox Resect


Bowel regimen
or stoma

Clinical response No clinical response

Repeat botox or
myectomy

FIGURE 101-9 Algorithm for the investigation and management of the child with obstructive symptoms following a pull-through.

A B C
FIGURE 101-10 Causes of mechanical obstruction after a pull-through. A, Stricture following a Soave procedure. B, Anterior aganglionic “spur” following
a Duhamel procedure. C, Twisted transanal pull-through.

normal ganglion cells present in all patients with persistent Motility Disorder Children with Hirschsprung disease
obstructive symptoms after surgery. The pathology from the often have associated motility disorders including an in-
original operation should be reviewed to ensure that there creased incidence of gastroesophageal reflux and delayed
was normal innervation at the proximal margin, and in some gastric emptying,81 small bowel dysmotility, and disordered
cases further sections should be done circumferentially from colonic motility. Some cases are more focal, usually involving
the resection margin because the transition zone is often asym- the left colon. In some cases the disordered motility may be
metrical in children with Hirschsprung disease.80 The best associated with histological abnormalities such as intestinal
treatment for persistent or acquired aganglionosis in most neuronal dysplasia (discussed in greater detail later).
cases is a repeat pull-through, which can be done using either In children who have been shown not to have a mechanical
a Soave or Duhamel approach.75 obstruction and who have normal ganglion cells on rectal
1276 PART VII ABDOMEN

biopsy, investigations for motility disorders should be under- TABLE 101-3


taken. This can include a radiologic shape study, radionuclide Causes of Soiling Following Surgery for Hirschsprung Disease
colon transit study,82 colonic manometry,83 and laparoscopic Abnormal sensation
biopsies looking for evidence of intestinal neuronal dyspla- 1. Inability to feel rectal distension
sia.84 If a focal abnormality is found, consideration should 2. Loss of transitional epithelium
be given to resection and repeat pull-through using normal Abnormal sphincter function
bowel. If the abnormality is diffuse, the appropriate treatment “Pseudo-incontinence”
is bowel management and the use of prokinetic agents. Some 1. Associated with severe constipation
children with particularly dysmotile colon will benefit from 2. Associated with hyperperistalsis of the pulled-through bowel
placement of a cecostomy for antegrade colonic enemas.85

Internal Sphincter Achalasia This term refers to the lack of


a normal RAIR that is present in all children with Hirsch-
sprung disease (as described earlier in “Diagnosis”). It is abnormal sensation exist. The first is lack of sensation of a
unclear why only some children develop obstructive symp- full rectum, which is also identifiable using anorectal manom-
toms from this nonrelaxation, while others function normally etry by expanding a balloon in the rectum and asking the
in the postoperative period. It is also unclear why most chil- child to state when he can feel it. The other type of sensation
dren eventually “grow out” of this problem over time, usually that may be abnormal is the ability to detect the difference
by the age of 5 years. Internal sphincter achalasia is a diagnosis between gas and stool, which is dependent on intact transi-
of exclusion, which is made after ruling out mechanical ob- tional epithelium in the anal canal. This sensation may be im-
struction, aganglionosis, and dysmotility. The diagnosis can paired if the anastomosis is done too low and the transitional
be confirmed by demonstrating a clinical response to intra- epithelium is damaged. This problem is usually evident on
sphincteric botulinum toxin.86 However, the response to bot- simple physical examination. Neither sphincter weakness
ulinum toxin is not related to the absolute value of the internal nor abnormal sensation is amenable to a surgical solution,
anal sphincter pressure (i.e., patients with a higher resting and most of these children are best managed using a bowel
pressure are not necessarily more likely to benefit from botu- routine that may include a constipating diet, rectal enemas,
linum toxin). or antegrade enemas through a cecostomy. Biofeedback train-
The standard treatment of internal sphincter achalasia has ing has been advocated, especially for those children with
been internal sphincterotomy or myectomy,87,88 but because sphincter weakness. In some cases the child is best served
this problem tends to resolve on its own in most children by a colostomy.
and there is concern about sphincter-cutting operations If both the sphincter and sensation are intact, the
exacerbating future soiling issues, we prefer to use “che- most common cause of soiling after a pull-through is “pseudo-
mical sphincterotomy” with intrasphincteric botulinum incontinence.”93 Some patients have severe obstipation with a
toxin.86,89,90 In many cases repeated injection of botulinum massively distended rectum and develop overflow of liquid
toxin or applications of nitroglycerine paste or topical nifedi- stool around the fecal mass. Others simply leak small amounts
pine are necessary while waiting for resolution of the problem. of stool through the day, creating “skid marks” in the under-
wear on a constant basis. Other children suffer from hyper-
Functional Megacolon Functional megacolon is the result peristalsis of the pulled-through bowel, which results in
of stool-holding behavior, a common cause of constipation inability of the anal sphincter to achieve control despite
that some authors claim affects up to half of normal children normal sphincter function.83
at some time during their first few years of life.91 This Successful management depends on a clear understanding
condition is probably even more common in children with of the underlying basis for the soiling, which requires a clear
Hirschsprung disease because of their predisposition to con- history and physical examination, as well as investigations
stipation, which leads to hard painful stools, withholding be- such as abdominal radiograph, barium enema, anorectal ma-
havior, and a resulting vicious cycle.92 The treatment for this nometry, and in some cases colonic manometry. Children with
problem is a bowel management regimen consisting of severe constipation will benefit from laxative therapy. How-
laxatives, enemas, and behavior modification including ever, if the sphincter or sensation, or both, are inadequate,
support for the child and family. In some severe cases of passive laxatives such as lactulose or PEG 3300 will make
obstructive symptoms, the child may be best served by use the problem worse and the child should instead be treated
of a cecostomy and administration of antegrade enemas, or with stimulant laxatives such as senna or enemas. On the other
even by the creation of a proximal stoma. In many cases the hand, children with stool-holding behavior who have a nor-
cecostomy or stoma can ultimately be reversed when the child mal sphincter and sensation will often experience exacer-
reaches adolescence. bation of the behavioral problem by rectal enemas or any
other kind of anal manipulation. Children without constipa-
Fecal Soiling tion who have hyperperistalsis of the pulled-through bowel or
There are three broad causes of soiling after a pull-through: abnormal sphincter function or sensation will benefit from a
abnormal sphincter function, abnormal sensation, or constipating diet and medications such as loperamide. Chil-
“pseudo-incontinence” related to abnormal rectal function dren with slow transit constipation or stool-holding behavior,
or obstipation (Table 101-3). Abnormal sphincter function on the other hand, will benefit from a high-fiber diet and
may be due to sphincter injury during the pull-through or passive laxative therapy. The treatment of soiling must be
to a previous myectomy or sphincterotomy and can usually based on a clear understanding of the child’s underlying
be identified using anorectal manometry. Two forms of problem.
CHAPTER 101 HIRSCHSPRUNG DISEASE 1277

Enterocolitis
enterocolitis, in the absence of an ongoing source of obstruc-
Enterocolitis may be present both before and after surgical tion, usually resolve after the first 5 years of life. Studies of
correction of the disease, and it can be severe or life threaten- teenagers and adults with Hirschsprung disease suggest that
ing. HAEC is more common in children diagnosed at a youn- sexual function, social satisfaction, and quality of life all
ger age,94 those with longer segment disease, and those with appear to be normal in the vast majority of patients once they
trisomy 21. The clinical features of HAEC are generally agreed reach their late teens.69,97
on and include fever, abdominal distention, diarrhea, elevated Several populations of children have less optimistic out-
white blood cell count, and evidence of intestinal edema on comes. Children with long-segment disease appear to have
abdominal radiograph. Because there is overlap between a higher risk of enterocolitis, incontinence, and dehydration
HAEC and other conditions such as obstructive symptoms than children with shorter-segment disease. Children with
and gastroenteritis, there has been confusion in the literature Hirschsprung disease associated with Down syndrome have
as to the exact definition and the true incidence of the condi- a greater risk of enterocolitis and incontinence.98,99 Finally,
tion. A recently developed HAEC score may be useful in the prognosis may be poor in children with other types of comor-
future in both the clinical setting and in research into this area bidity such as those with congenital central hypoventilation
(Table 101-4).95 syndrome, congenital heart disease, and syndromes that are
The treatment of postoperative HAEC involves nasogastric associated with mental retardation or other forms of disability.
drainage, intravenous fluids, broad-spectrum antibiotics, and
decompression of the rectum and colon using rectal stimulation
or irrigations. The risk of HAEC can be minimized by using pre- “Variant” Hirschsprung Disease
ventive measures such as routine irrigations96 or chronic ad- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ministration of metronidazole or probiotic agents, particularly Some children present with signs and symptoms suggestive of
in those who are thought to be at higher risk for this complica- Hirschsprung disease but have ganglion cells present on rectal
tion on the basis of clinical or histologic grounds. Because en- biopsy.100 There is a significant amount of controversy sur-
terocolitis is the most common cause of death in children with rounding the definitions and features of many of these condi-
Hirschsprung disease and can occur postoperatively even in tions,101 and in some cases their existence has even been
children who did not have it preoperatively, it is extremely im- called into question.
portant that the surgeon educate the family about the risk of this
complication and urge early return to the hospital if the child
should develop any concerning symptoms.66 INTESTINAL NEURONAL DYSPLASIA
This condition was first described by Meier-Ruge in 1971. Two
Long-Term Outcomes
types are usually described.102 Type A is less common and is
Despite the relatively common occurrence of postoperative characterized by diminished or absent sympathetic innerva-
problems, most children with Hirschsprung disease overcome tion of the myenteric and submucosal plexuses, as well as hy-
these issues and do well. Obstructive symptoms, soiling, and perplasia of the myenteric plexus. Type B consists of dysplasia
of the submucous plexus with thickened nerve fibers and
TABLE 101-4 giant ganglia, increased acetylcholinesterase staining, and
Hirschsprung-Associated Enterocolitis (HAEC) Score* identification of ectopic ganglion cells in the lamina propria.
Type B can occur on its own or can be present in the nonagan-
History glionic bowel in children who also have Hirschsprung disease.
Diarrhea with explosive stool 2 In addition, intestinal neuronal dysplasia may be either diffuse
Diarrhea with foul-smelling stool 2 or focal. The reported incidence of IND varies significantly
Diarrhea with bloody stool 1 from one center to another, largely due to differences in
Previous history of enterocolitis 1 definition of the condition.
Physical examination Despite multiple publications on the topic of IND, this
Explosive discharge of gas and stool on rectal examination 2 topic still stimulates controversy among pediatric surgeons
Distended abdomen 2 and pediatric pathologists.103 The diagnostic criteria have
Decreased peripheral perfusion 1 changed over time, and there is disagreement among pathol-
Lethargy 1 ogists about the diagnosis both in general terms and with re-
Fever 1 spect to individual patients.104 Sophisticated histologic
Radiology techniques including special stains and the use of thick sec-
Multiple air-fluid levels 1 tions are often believed to be necessary for an accurate diag-
Dilated loops of bowel 1 nosis.105 In addition, there is some evidence that the
Sawtooth appearance with irregular mucosal lining 1 histologic finding of IND may in some cases be secondary
Cutoff sign in recto-sigmoid with absence of distal air 1 to chronic obstruction rather than the cause of it, and in many
Pneumatosis 1 cases there may not be good correlation between the histologic
finding of IND and the motility function of the bowel.106
Laboratory
Leukocytosis 1 Hypoganglionosis
Shift to left 1
This is a rare form of dysganglionosis, which is characterized by
*A score of 10 or higher was associated with a positive diagnosis of HAEC by an sparse and small ganglia, usually in the distal bowel, often as-
international panel of experts. sociated with abnormalities in acetylcholinesterase distribution.
1278 PART VII ABDOMEN

Ultrashort-Segment Hirschsprung Disease


The appropriate treatment is to resect the abnormal colon and
perform a pull-through procedure, much as one would do for There is much confusion in the literature regarding this
a child with Hirschsprung disease.107 It is important to differ- condition and how it is defined. Some authors use this term to
entiate this condition from immature ganglia, which is seen in describe children with normal ganglion cells on rectal biopsy,
preterm children who present with a picture of distal intesti- but with absence of the RAIR (which is synonymous
nal obstruction resulting from underdeveloped colonic motil- with the definition of internal sphincter achalasia). We prefer
ity. The colonic motility is self-limited and should not be to reserve it for children who have a documented aganglionic
treated surgically.108 segment of less than 1 to 2 cm. In children with thiscondition, the
findings of hypertrophic nerves and abnormal cholinesterase
staining may be absent.114 The treatment of ultrashort-segment
Internal Sphincter Achalasia
Hirschsprung disease is controversial. Some authors advocate
Some children have normal ganglion cells on rectal biopsy but simple anal sphincter myectomy,115,116 and some prefer excision
lack the RAIR on anorectal manometry. These children will of the aganglionic segment and pull-through reconstruction.
sometimes develop obstructive symptoms or severe constipa-
tion that mimics Hirschsprung disease. Similarly to the situa-
tion mentioned previously in which obstructive symptoms Desmosis coli
continue after surgery for Hirschsprung disease, this condi- This is a condition described by Meier-Ruge characterized by
tion has been termed internal sphincter achalasia.109 The diag- total or focal lack of the connective tissue net of the circular
nosis is made using anorectal manometry and rectal biopsy. and longitudinal muscles and the connective tissue layer of
The initial treatment is a bowel management regimen, consisting the myenteric plexus, without any abnormality of the enteric
of diet, laxatives, and enemas or irrigations. If this is unsuccess- nervous system.117 Patients with this condition present with
ful, many surgeons have advocated the use of anal sphincter chronic constipation. In one family Hirschsprung disease
myectomy.110,111 Because the constipation associated with this and desmosis coli coexisted,118 although in most cases they
condition usually improves over the first 5 years of life, the are completely separate entities.
same rationale has been used to advocate temporary or revers-
ible sphincter-relaxing measures such as botulinum toxin,112 The complete reference list is available online at www.
nitroglycerine paste,113 or topical nifedipine. expertconsult.com.

You might also like