You are on page 1of 16

Journal of Sedimentary Environments

https://doi.org/10.1007/s43217-022-00090-x

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum


prospectivity of the Mandawa Basin: remote sensing manifestation
confirmed by seismic results
Elisante E. Mshiu1 · Emily Barnabas Kiswaka1 · Bahati Mohamed1

Received: 13 July 2021 / Revised: 18 November 2021 / Accepted: 25 January 2022


© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2022

Abstract
This work reports remote sensing aided identification of salt deposition and remobilization within a sub-rounded structure
with approximately equant dimensions in the Mandawa Basin. A calculated surface flow direction has revealed the sub-
rounded structure from Shuttle Radar Topography Mission—Digital Elevation Model (SRTM DEM) data. Internally, the
body contains several structural highs and lows reflected by multiple peaks and troughs displayed by profiles drawn across
the body. Seismic interpretation results confirmed these structural highs and lows, and they conform to salt build-ups (salt
pillows and domes) and sedimentary minibasins, respectively. Seismic work, a follow-up investigation of the remote sensing
findings, involved qualitative interpretation of 24 seismic profiles, 7 of which were chosen to represent the findings. East Lika
1 well stratigraphy was used to assign the age of the studied interval, and confirm that features of interest are associated with
salt deposition and remobilization. Moreover, the East Lika 1 well tie corroborated that the interpreted salt deposition and
the associated build-ups are within the Nondwa Formation of the Pindiro Group. Remote sensing observation, coupled with
seismic interpretation, has revealed that the Mandawa salt basin is more extensive than reported before. Oil seeps, which are
potential indicators of a working petroleum system, have been reported in the Mandawa Basin. One of these seeps is adja-
cent to a mapped salt dome. This observation probably indicates the influence of salt tectonics in the Mandawa petroleum
system. Further work on a better quality seismic dataset may help resolve the problem of hydrocarbon whereabouts as far as
the influence of salt tectonics is considered.

Keywords  Remote sensing · Sub-rounded · Equant · Mandawa Basin · Salt domes · Seismic interpretation · Oil seep

1 Introduction despite the potential indication of a working petroleum sys-


tem. The Mandawa Basin is part of the coastal sedimentary
Remote sensing has been widely used to map different basins of Tanzania. The working petroleum system in this
geological features for both social-economical and aca- basin was first proved by Mandawa-7 well (Fig. 2) which
demic reasons (e.g. Becker, 2006; Bhaskar & Kumar, 2011; penetrated good source rocks and some gas and oil shows
Hewson et al., 2020; Ielp et al., 2016; Jaiswal et al., 2003; (Hudson & Nicholas, 2014); is evident from the discovered
Kazimoto & Mshiu, 2020; Santos et al., 2019; Shahid et al., oil seeps (an example of which is shown in Fig. 2). In the
2000; van der Meer et al., 2014; Zumsprekel & Prinz, 2000). current work, the remote sensing technique has allowed the
The work’s social-economical and academic aspects may be demarcation of a more or less circular body in the Mandawa
understood well if one thinks about the absence of commer- Basin (Figs. 2 and 3). The body, having approximately equal
cial hydrocarbon discoveries in the Mandawa Basin (Fig. 1) dimensions, about 40 km wide in a planar view (Fig. 3), led
to two assumptions regarding its reflected feature. It was
Communicated by E. Pereira. thought to indicate either a batholith or salt build-up(s).
The first assumption was dismissed due to the absence of
* Emily Barnabas Kiswaka scientific works reporting such features in the study area.
ekiswaka70@gmail.com More weight was given to the second assumption due to the
1
School of Mines and Geosciences, University of Dar es presence of petroleum exploration wells that have penetrated
Salaam, PO BOX 35052, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania salt deposits (e.g. East Lika 1, Mandawa-7, and Mihambia-1

13
Vol.:(0123456789)
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Fig. 1  Geological map showing structural elements within the study explained in this work; but are shown to complete the map (after
area (blue dashed rectangle). Songo Songo, Kilwa and Mavuji groups Hudson, 2011; Kent et al., 1971)
were not thought to have influenced salt remobilization thus are not

whose locations are shown in Figs. 1 and 2) and several manifestation of a potential geobody. Thus, the focus of this
research works reporting salt deposition and remobiliza- work was in the evaporitic interval, the Nondwa Forma-
tion in the Mandawa Basin (e.g. Didas, 2016; Hudson & tion of the Pindiro Group, which is of the Triassic to Eary
Nicholas, 2014). These studies report that salt tectonics, a Jurassic age, but a slightly longer stratigraphic interval was
complex process encompassing subsurface movement of salt investigated to get a broad understanding of postdepositional
and resulting features (Belenitskaya, 2016), has influenced processes that may have culminated in the emplacement of
the structural development of the Mandawa Basin (Didas, the features observed from remote sensing images.
2016; Hudson & Nicholas, 2014) of which the salt deposit
is thought to be manifested by the shown remote sensing 1.1 Tectonics and geology
images (Figs. 2 and 3). The Mandawa salt deposits form
part of the Pindiro Group deposited during the Late Trias- 1.1.1 Tectono‑sedimentary development
sic-Early Jurassic period; the oldest reported stratigraphic
interval in the basin (Hudson & Nicholas, 2014). The sec- The evolution of the coastal basins of Tanzania has been
ond assumption has forced us to use available 2D seismic largely controlled by tectonics (Kent et al., 1971). Major
lines to confirm the concept while looking for the seismic tectonic events include the Permo-Triassic Karoo rifting,

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

Fig. 2  Remote sensing DEM image with topographic highs (white) pillows (green arrows) and domes, and the position of oil seepage
and lows (dark grey) in the study area (see Fig. 1 for location). This in the study area. The interpreted seismic lines (with respective salt
image shows locations of interpreted seismic lines, interpreted salt structures) are shown in Figs. 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12

Triassic rifting that initiated fragmentation of Gondwana and partly sea-level fluctuations and climate variations,
Supercontinent, Middle Jurassic rifting that culminated at have influenced the sedimentary development of the coastal
the opening of the Somali Basin and the East African Rifting basins of Tanzania (Fossum et al., 2020; Hudson, 2011; Kent
during Cenozoic (Kent et al., 1971). These tectonic events, et al., 1971; Wopfner, 2002). For example, the Karoo rifting

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Fig. 3  Further details from a close-up view of the study area using profiles AA′ and BB′ in (c). These profiles have peaks and troughs
clustered flow direction method. a Close-up view of Fig.  2 with a conforming to structural highs and lows in (b)
sub-rounded feature demarcated by white dashes, b positions of two

caused dominance of continental deposition, but occasional 2014). Stratigraphically, the group consists of Mbuo,
marine incursion is also evident in the Mandawa Basin due Nondwa and Mihambia formations, which form part of
to localized rapid subsidence (Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). the syn-rift package emplaced during the initial stage of
During the Late Triassic, the marine incursion led to the Madagascar rifting from East Africa (Hudson & Nichol-
deposition of Nondwa evaporites in the Mandawa Basin ous, 2014). The Mbuo Formation was deposited under
(Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). fluvial, alluvial and lacustrine environments; it contains a
matured organic-carbon-rich interval with poor petroleum
1.1.2 Geology and stratigraphy of the study area generation potential at a well location (Emanuel et al.,
2020). Source rock generation potential is not expected
The Triassic to Eary Jurassic successions of the Mandawa to be uniform over the entire basin. Thus Mbuo Forma-
Basin is grouped under the so-called Pindiro Group which tion may have economic potential in other deeper basinal
is overlain by the Mandawa Group (Hudson, 2011; Fig. 4). areas as well. Either poor or economic generation potential
The Pindiro Group comprises the lowermost stratigraphic characterizes the Mbuo organic-rich intervals, the Mbuo
interval that overlies the metamorphic basement of the Formation may have still sourced seeping hydrocarbons
Precambrian age unconformably (Hudson & Nicholous, in the Mandawa Basin (Fig. 2). The Nondwa Formation,

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

Fig. 4  A chronostratigraphic scheme of the studied interval in the Mandawa Basin based on the works of Fossum et al. (2020), Godson (2017),
Hudson (2011) and Hudson and Nicholas (2014)

an evaporitic interval, was deposited under a restricted Late Triassic, experienced a high subsidence rate relative to
marine environment (Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). The the surrounding areas (Hudson & Nicholous, 2014).
youngest interval of the Pindiro Group, the Mihambia For- The Mandawa Group follows upward and is subdivided,
mation, was deposited in a shallow to the marginal marine from oldest to youngest, into Mtumbei, Tendaguru, Kipa-
environment (Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). timu, Mbaro, Mitole and Nalwehe formations deposited
The thickness of the Nondwa Formation ranges from during the Middle Jurassic-Lower Cretaceous (Fossum
58 to 2802 m, and is reported to be the oldest outcropping et al., 2020; Fig. 4). The Mtumbei Formation is character-
unit, mainly due to salt diapirism (Godson, 2017; Hudson ized by oolitic limestone deposits; it was laid down when
& Nicholous, 2014). The Nondwa Formation contains the entire coastal area of Tanzania was under the marine
limestone and dolostones, gypsum, anhydrites and shales influence, leading to the development of a stable carbonate
characterized by complex internal folding resulted from platform during the Middle Jurassic (Kent et al., 1971). The
salt diapirism (Godson, 2017; Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). Late Jurassic-Cretaceous documented multiple regression-
Hudson and Nicholous (2014) suggested restricted marine transgression cycles that caused an alternation between flu-
conditions during deposition of the Nondwa Formation vial derived sediments and marine carbonates during which
whereby Pande High and Ruvuma saddle may have formed Tendaguru-Nalwehe formations were deposited (Fossum
eastern and southern limits of the restricted basin, respec- et al., 2020). The Tendaguru Formation contains alternat-
tively. This basin experienced an intermittent connection to ing marginal marine and continental successions (Bussert
the open ocean in the North around the Kilwa area (Hudson et al., 2009). The Kipatimu Formation contains massive and
& Nicholous, 2014) and a semi-arid climate essential for cross-stratified sandstone bodies alternating with purple to
evaporates deposition (Hudson, 2011). The Nondwa evapo- greenish claystones and minor conglomerates which are
rites are thickest to the south of the Mandawa Basin because interpreted to have been deposited under fluvial and fluvio-
the southernmost and central parts of the basin, during the deltaic environment (Hudson, 2011; Kent et al., 1971). The

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Mbaro Formation was deposited from lagoonal-tidal flat all the processes. The obtained sub-rounded structure in
sedimentation (Fossum et al., 2020). The Mitole Formation the study area is characterized by structural highs and lows
is subdivided into basal oolitic limestone and fluvial-alluvial whereby many profiles were selected to construct different
upper sandstone members (Hudson, 2011). Fluvially derived cross-sections across it. All cross-sections display peaks and
sediments dominate part of the Nalwehe Formation, inter- troughs that conform to structural highs and lows, respec-
preted to represent either deltaic deposition or deposition tively, within the sub-rounded structure (examples are shown
within a river-dominated estuary (Fossum et al., 2020). in Fig. 3B and C).

2.2 Seismic interpretation
2 Methods and datasets
Twenty-four (24) 2D seismic lines, through the Mandawa
Two techniques have been used to accomplish this work. Basin, have been analyzed using Petrel. Out of these lines,
They include remote sensing and qualitative seismic seven seismic profiles are presented here to show major fea-
interpretation. tures that have been recognized in the seismic interval of
interest. The analysis involved the traditional tracing of seis-
2.1 Remote sensing mic reflectors and discontinuities. This technique has been
widely used to map the subsurface geology (e.g. Kiswaka &
Remote sensing has been widely used to map surface geom- Felix, 2020). In the current study, stratal relationships and
etries/elements reflecting subsurface geology in several areas geometries of sedimentary deposits were key to deciphering
(e.g. Ganapuram et al., 2009). Similar technique is applied the studied interval sedimentary development. The seismic
to accomplish this work. In the study area, a remote sensing interpretation was focused on two major reflectors; base and
approach was used to demarcate a sub-rounded structure/ top salt reflectors. Age assignment for the Nondwa Forma-
geometry, approximately equant in planar view (Figs. 2 and tion relied entirely on East Lika 1 well; a synthetic seismic
3). The geometry of the sub-rounded structure was enhanced section was generated to establish a relationship between
by the preprocessed Digital Elevation Model (DEM) data seismic reflections and stratigraphy of the East Lika 1 well
and clustering of the calculated surface flow directions from (Fig. 5). The ages of other reflectors and packages were
Shuttle Radar Topography Mission—(SRTM DEM) data. determined tentatively based on their stratigraphic posi-
The latter is effective in enhancing surface geological fea- tions relative to the salt reflectors. The synthetic generation
tures. 30 m spatial resolution DEM data is a freely available process encountered mismatching errors due to technical
in the USGS earth explorer database. Preprocessing of the errors in sonic log acquisitions and seismic processing and
DEM data was done to reduce geometrical errors and replace interpretation uncertainties. The technical errors are taken
the void pixels with average values from the surrounding into consideration because of depth mismatches between the
pixels, and ArcGIS software was the tool mainly used for used well logs and seismic images on the actual occurrence

Fig. 5  Seismic well tie of the East Lika 1 well shown by the generated synthetic seismic profiles. The synthetic sections were generated to locate
the base evaporite marker that stratigraphically bears the salt deposit within the Nondwa Formation

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

of geological elements of interest (e.g. salt deposits) that can the domes, with rounded crests, are characterized by minor
be easily identified on both well logs and seismic images. folds and normal faults (Figs. 7, 12 and 13). Most of the
domes with pointed crests underlie normal faults that sole
out along the top salt (Fig. 6). Wedge-shaped sedimentary
3 Results and interpretations packages, thickening towards the dome-shaped structures,
have been observed in some places (an example of which
3.1 Seismic observation is shown in Fig. 7). Generally, the domes have a chaotic
internal configuration whereby no defined pattern can be
Several dome-shaped structural highs with rounded and established (Figs. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13). Locally, the
pointed crests have been observed. These domes are found dome structures are linked to pillow-shaped deposits sepa-
in areas marked by zones of deteriorated seismic quality rated by up to 15 km wide depressions accommodating sedi-
(domes A-O in Figs. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13) which mentary successions (Fig. 12). The pillow-shaped deposits
appear as tall vertical and slanted bodies cutting across the are mostly chaotic with occasional internal reflectors. The
overlying sedimentary layers. Other reflectors are onlapping basal parts of the sedimentary depressions flanked by the
onto these tall domes (Fig. 7). The observed domes have pillow-shaped deposits contain numerous faults; are slightly
varied widths ranging from less than a kilometer (e.g. dome tilted from the center of the depression southward (Fig. 12).
D in Fig. 6) to more than 10 km (e.g. immediate interval Despite the limited quality of the used dataset, the sedimen-
below the marked part of dome K in Fig. 9). In some places, tary depressions bounding the domes have been found to
the domes are surrounded by depressions up to 10 km wide overlie tilted reflectors (Fig. 11), indicating the existence
(e.g. Figs. 7, 8 and 11). Immediate sedimentary strata above of deep-buried sedimentary successions older than those

Fig. 6  Uninterpreted (top) and interpreted (bottom) seismic line L-1 domes reported in this work. No clear fault control is seen on domes
showing multiple salt domes across the Mandawa Basin. Domes B and D despite having pointed crests. The red reflector is marking
B-E have pointed crests while domes B and E underlie major normal top salt in all seismic lines presented herein. See Fig. 2 for locations
faults which sole out on top salt. Salt dome D is the thinnest of all salt of all seismic lines

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Fig. 7  Uninterpreted (top) and interpreted (bottom) seismic line L-2 thinning and possibly completely salt removal due to loading may be
showing three dome-shaped structural highs, faulting of the imme- present across potential welds. Red arrows show salt intrusion paths
diate layers above the highs and a sedimentary wedge thickening and the existence of further salt at depth
toward dome H. Other reflectors onlap onto the domes. Significant

forming domes and pillows. These deep-buried packages Fig. 2, whereby all domes are located in areas with struc-
overlie thick chaotic intervals without any defined reflector tural highs revealed by the remote sensing image. The dark
configuration (Fig. 11). areas between the domes represent seismic depressions
(Figs. 8, 9 and 12). From remote sensing data, few seismic
3.2 Combined seismic and remote sensing data domes (e.g. dome B in Fig. 2) could not be linked to peaks/
structural highs. The structural highs on Fig. 2 seem to
The observed seismic domes and pillows and their asso- extend further North-West and South-East, but there was
ciated depressions conform to structural highs and lows no seismic data to confirm the conformity between the two
from SRTM DEM data. An example of this is shown in in these areas.

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

Fig. 8  Uninterpreted (top) and


interpreted (bottom) seismic
line L-3 showing further salt
domes. Minibasins surround salt
dome E. This survey line was
interpreted to ensure maximum
coverage of the circular body
reflected by remote sensing
images

3.3 Interpretations the Mandawa Basin. The occurrence of salt domes with


rounded and pointed crests suggests that both active and
The vertical bodies of deteriorated seismic quality (domes reactive diapirism modes of Jackson et al. (1994) were the
A-O in Figs.  6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13), which cut mechanisms of salt intrusion. Reactive diapirism mode
through the superjacent sedimentary successions, are is supported by (i) presence of normal faults terminating
interpreted to represent salt domes (see Belenitskaya, along top salt adjacent to the pointed crests of the domes
2016 and references therein for similar features). Sev- (Fig. 6), (ii) tilting nature of the basal salt (Fig. 12), (iii)
eral of these domes have not been reported before in existence of slanted domes (Fig.  10), and (iv) sub-salt

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Fig. 9  Uninterpreted (top) and


interpreted (bottom) seismic
line L-4 showing further
domes in the basin. Here upper
part of the widest salt dome,
dome K, in the study area is
shown. Some parts of dome K
(unmarked interval) are more
than 10 km wide

deformation (Fig. 12). Variation in width of the salt domes the base salt’s slight tilting and localized faulting (Fig. 12).
may be due to different modes of diapirism; reactive dia- The East African Rifting during Cenozoic (Kent et al.,
pirism produced thin domes, whereas active diapirism 1971) may have been responsible for this.
produced wide domes. The depressions surrounding salt Sedimentary wedges thickening toward the salt domes
domes with pointed crests (Figs. 6 and 8) indicate that tec- (Fig.  7) imply gravitational gliding during deposition,
tonic forces and sedimentary loading influenced diapirism. suggesting an interplay between sedimentation and salt
Previous works from other salt basins have shown that tectonics, and are interpreted to mark syn-kinematic pro-
similar depressions, on passive continental margins, may gradation of clastic sediments. Prograding sedimentary
document basal salt deformations and tilted basal salts due wedges can induce lateral expulsion of salt due to dif-
to external factors, including tectonism (Peel, 2014). Tec- ferential loading. Salt domes bounded by depressions on
tonic influence in the Mandawa diapirism is manifested by both sides convey salt centered view (Peel, 2014). These

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

Fig. 10  Uninterpreted (left) and interpreted (right) seismic line L-5 showing a tilted dome in the Mandawa Basin. The dome has a pointed crest
and is surrounded by minibasins. Red arrows indicate salt flow directions and the presence of further salt at depth

depressions are interpreted to represent salt withdrawal Onlapping of the reflectors onto the tall salt diapirs (e.g.
minibasins (see Peel, 2014 and references therein for defi- Fig. 7) reflects the domes’ rotation and steepening due to
nitions) within the Mandawa Basin. A similar interpreta- shearing of the overlying deposits during salt emplacement
tion is given herein to account for the depressions between (see Stewart (2006) for similar examples).
pillow-shaped deposits (Fig.  12). The pillow-shaped The chaotic nature of the salt pillows is due to velocity
deposits represent salt pillows, marking the primary stage disturbance and complex arrangement/folding of the layers
of salt movement in the study area. Stages of salt remo- due to diapirism. Occasional reflectors within the salt bod-
bilization, starting with pillow formation followed by ies (Fig. 13) are due to the layered nature of the deposits
diapir and post diapiric stages, are well summarized by within the Nondwa Formation.
the Trusheim model (see Trusheim, 1987) of halokine- The sedimentary package below the salt pillows and
sis (Mohr et al., 2005). Significant thinning, and possibly domes represent the Mbuo Formation, which exists in the
complete salt removal due to salt withdrawal upon sedi- area (see Hudson & Nicholas, 2014) and possibly other
mentary loading is interpreted to have occurred in some older intervals that have not been penetrated by wells. This
areas of the Mandawa Basin. These areas form potential is because the Carboniferous deposits have been reported
welds (Fig. 7), which might be migration pathways for in other sedimentary basins of Tanzania (Kreuser et al.,
hydrocarbons or act as an impediment for further move- 1990). The chaotic to transparent seismic interval below
ment of hydrocarbons depending on different conditions the oldest sedimentary successions observed in this work
(see Wagner, 2010; Wagner & Jackson, 2011; Peel, 2014). marks the metamorphic basement flooring of the Mandawa
Faulting of the immediate superjacent strata, roofing Basin. Similar interpretation was given by Didas (2016).
the salt domes with rounded crests, is interpreted to have The Mandawa Basin topography conform to remote
resulted due to pressure build-up from the accumulating sensing, and seismic interpretation results confirm salt
salt material. Salt accumulation produced convex bulges deposition and remobilization at depth. The used remote
reflected by minor folding of the layers roofing the diapirs sensing data could not resolve some seismic domes (see
and pillows (Figs. 7, 12 and 13) showing that deposition dome B in Fig. 2) because they are too small and are deep
of supersalt strata followed basin geometry/topography. buried.

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Fig. 11  Uninterpreted (top) and interpreted (bottom) seismic line L-6 showing a chaotic structural high (dome N) separating two sedimentary
depressions (minibasins). The fills of both depressions overlie sedimentary successions that rest directly on the basement

4 Discussion they are equant and elongated in planar view, respectively


(Jackson et al., 1994). The halokinesis, which may culminate
Based on the seismic investigation, at least fifteen diapirs in the formation of salt pillows, salt diapirs, salt withdrawal
have been found in the Mandawa Basin (domes A-O in minibasins, and other related deformations, is due to buried
Figs. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13). The diapirs N and O occur salts’ re-establishment of equilibrium based on the Archi-
in areas that have been previously reported to have outcrops medes principle (Peel, 2014; Trusheim, 1987). Salt(s) buried
of salt deposits, and several gypsum quarries are located under great depth(s) reach a stage where they behave plasti-
around these structures (Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). Due cally and begin to flow when essential conditions are met.
to limited seismic quality, it is unclear whether diapir H has These conditions include tectonically related halotectonic
reached the surface or ends at the seismic depth/level marked movements, and non-tectonic factors leading to halokinetic
in Fig. 7. Further work involving analysis of high-quality movements (Jackson et al., 1994; Mohr et al., 2005; Trush-
seismic lines and field visits may clear the doubt, although eim, 1987). Halokinetic movements are believed to have
it is not uncommon for the Mandawa diapirs to have reached taken place in most if not all larger salt basins of the word
the surface (Hudson & Nicholous, 2014). (Trusheim, 1987). Halokinetic movements are triggered by
Salt build-ups resulting from subsurface salt remobiliza- salt squeezing due to overburden weight; the movement
tion and related structures are widespread and easily recog- began from areas experiencing denser sedimentary load
nized in all salt-tectonics basins. These structures, including whereby salts are displaced laterally depending on potential
salt pillows and diapirs, result from halokinesis, encompass- gradient (Trusheim, 1987; Wagner & Jackson, 2011; War-
ing all processes involving gravity that influenced salts’ sitzka et al., 2013). Transformation of gypsum to anhydrite,
movement (Trusheim, 1987). Salt pillows are plano-convex which involves water loss and volume shrinkage for about
bulges with a concordant contact with the superjacent strata; 38%, leads to increased salt mobility (Trusheim, 1987). The

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

Fig. 12  Uninterpreted (top) and interpreted (bottom) seismic line is shown in Fig. 13. The pillow-shaped deposits overlie sedimentary
L-7 showing pillow-shaped deposits bounding a depression filled by successions underlain by an interval characterized by chaotic configu-
sedimentary deposits. The pillows are linked with a dome-shaped ration (basement). Thicknesses of supersalt packages vary laterally,
structure high further north of the seismic image. Here the base salt and the layers follow geometry produced by the underlying salt bod-
is slightly tilted and fragmented. Red-dashed rectangle (A) is a close- ies (pillows and diapirs)
up view of the dome structure and part of the pillow deposit, as it

Nondwa Formation is characterized by different lithologies, loading is interpreted to have resulted from a high influx
including gypsum and anhydrite (Godson, 2017). Part of the of fluvially-derived clastic sediments following multiple
anhydrite package, within the Nondwa Formation, may have regressive-transgressive cycles during the Late Jurassic-
resulted from gypsum-anhydrite transformation, which is Early Cretaceous (Fossum et al., 2020).
one of the reasons that facilitate subsurface salt remobiliza-
tion (Trusheim, 1987). The potential gradient may result
from many factors, including tectonics re-arrangement and 4.1 Salt withdrawal minibasins
tilting of the blocks, depositional basin geometry/topogra-
phy, and differential loading and compaction (Jackson et al., Salt withdrawal minibasins are about 1–10 km wide sedi-
1994; Peel, 2014; Trusheim, 1987). The outcomes of haloki- ment-filled depressions into a larger salt mass (Jacskon and
netic movements are that the salt intervals that experience Talbot, 1991). The salt withdrawal minibasins within the
denser overburden will be thinned, supplying salt to the study area have similar dimensions and salt build-ups bal-
swelling area(s) roofed by thin or weak overburden (Peel, ance salt withdrawal in the adjacent areas (Peel, 2014). The
2014; Trusheim, 1987; Wagner & Jackson, 2011). All these build-ups may differ depending on resulting shapes (e.g. salt
aspects are present in the Mandawa Basin. pillows, salt diapirs, and salt cored anticlines). The build-
In this work, differential loading is considered the major ups in the current work contain salt pillows and salt diapirs
cause of salt withdrawal, development of salt pillows, and (Figs. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13). Salt withdrawal miniba-
formation of minibasins (Figs. 7, 8, 11 and 12). Differential sins have distinctive geometry that allows their identification

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

also been noted that intrusion of some of the diapirs (e.g.


Fig. 10) was triggered by extensional tectonics because of
the presence of major normal faults which sole out at the
top salt. Kent et al. (1971) have reported the dominance of
extensional regimes during the Jurassic and Cenozoic. The
observed major normal faults terminating at the top salt
(Fig. 6) may have originated from these tectonic phases,
which are thought to have created structural grains that
controlled the migration of hydrocarbons. We believe that
further work on a better seismic dataset may help reveal the
whereabouts of the long-searched hydrocarbon accumula-
tions in the Mandawa Basin.
Salt withdrawal minibasins are of economic interest since
they control petroleum system element’s development, dis-
tribution and timing (Peel, 2014). These elements include
source rocks, reservoir intervals, the position of traps and
migration pathways, timing (Peel, 2014). The salt layer may
become welded out when it is too thin for further withdrawal
(Jackson et al., 1994). A fully welded salt basin, which may
be due to salt withdrawal and dissolution (Wagner, 2010;
Wagner & Jackson, 2011), can contain minibasins that are
Fig. 13  A close-up view of the dome-shaped structural high and part surrounded by salt diapirs displaying “a hub-and-spoke
of the pillow-shaped deposit shown in Fig. 12. Seismic reflectors are geometry” (Peel, 2014). Petroleum reservoir and seal inter-
seen within part of the pillow-shaped deposit of Fig. 12. Minor nor- vals may be found in these minibasins (Jackson & Hudec,
mal faults are seen above the dome structure 2017). Areas with potential welds and several minibasins
have been identified in this work (Figs. 7, 8, 11 and 12).
even when the basin configuration has been deformed tec- The presence of these welds (Fig. 7) is an important factor
tonically (Peel, 2014). in the evaluation of the petroleum system in areas where the
source rock is enclosed or overlain by salt layers; it affects
4.1.1 Petroleum potential the migration pathways whereby hydrocarbons may migrate
to the trap through areas characterized with complete welds
The potential of the identified salt withdrawal minibasins (Wagner & Jackson, 2011) depending on how long the welds
and the associated diapirs is not discussed in detail since have been existing relative to the hydrocarbon migration
the current work focused on identifying potential geologi- (Peel, 2014). The organic-carbon-rich intervals within the
cal feature(s) demarcated by remote sensing (Figs. 2 and 3). Mbuo Formation (Emanuel et al., 2020), which may have
However, due to social-economic reasons, it is worth high- economical petroleum generative potential in other basinal
lighting how important the observed features are concern- areas, are overlain by the Nondwa salt; thus, the identified
ing the petroleum prospectivity of the study area. Further welds may have been migration pathways to potential reser-
research, on a seismic dataset with better quality, will focus voirs within the salt withdrawal minibasins shown in Figs. 7,
on Nondwa salt tectonics’ influence in the Mandawa Basin’s 8, 11 and 12.
petroleum system.
About half of the world’s hydrocarbon reserves are asso- 4.2 Conformity of remote sensing and seismic
ciated with salt basins due to the role played by salts and the results
associated remobilization in the localization of petroleum
system elements (Belenitskaya, 2016; Harding & Huuse, An equant body identified by remote sensing image (Fig. 3)
2015) which may also explain the unsuccessful petroleum conforms to an area characterized by several salt pillows and
exploration in the Mandawa Basin. A key observation here diapirs as it is confirmed by seismic images (Figs. 6, 7, 8, 9,
is that diapir O is very close to one of the oil seeps in the 10, 11, 12 and 13). The area conforms to and extends beyond
study area (Fig. 2) proposing the likelihood of salt tectonics the reconstructed Late Triassic palaeogeographic distribu-
as the main factor influencing oil accumulation and seep- tion of the Nondwa salt reported by Hudson and Nicholas
age. Salt tectonics has influenced petroleum prospectivity (2014). Hudson and Nicholas (2014) showed that the salt
and seepage locations in several similar sedimentary basins lake was situated around and slightly beyond the areas
worldwide (dos Reis et al., 2017; Macgregor, 1993). It has where Nondwa Evaporites are shown in Fig. 1. However, the

13
Extensive salt deposition and remobilization influencing petroleum prospectivity of the…

potential salt deposit seems to extend further North, South been reported previously. One of the shown diapirs is linked
and East of the Mandawa Basin which suggests that the salt to oil seepage, suggesting the influence of salt tectonics over
basin, and respective deposition, extend beyond the current the petroleum system of the basin. Salt welds are thought to
perceived boundaries. Further studies on improved seismic be possible migration pathways of the petroleum generated
datasets may allow better mapping of the boundaries. by the Mbuo shales. Potential reservoir and seal intervals
Several salt diapirs, identified on seismic lines, conform are believed to be housed by the salt withdrawal minibasins.
to the cross-sections’ peaks across the equant body, retrieved
from remote sensing. This observation confirms that the
remote sensing images (Figs. 2 and 3) show a topographic 6 Recommendations
reflection of Nondwa salt deposition, remobilization, and
extent of the salt deposition within the Mandawa Basin. Few Further work, using an improved seismic dataset, is recom-
identified salt diapirs (for example diapir B in Fig. 6) could mended for more understanding of salt structures and the
not be linked to the peaks of the cross-sections, and this is associated petroleum system elements in the study area.
because these diapirs are too small and deeply buried com-
pared to other diapirs that the peaks could reflect. Acknowledgements  Comments and suggestions from Gabriela Avella
and two other anonymous reviewers improved the submitted manu-
script to be considered for publication. We thank Thomas Mugwe for
4.3 Associated uncertainties his contribution, which led to the improvement of the geological map
of the study area.
One should be mindful that the used seismic dataset is
subjected to potential uncertainties reflected by a slight Author contributions  Not applicable.
mismatch between the generated synthetic seismic and the
actual seismic line crossing the East Lika 1 well. Here the Funding  Not applicable.
uncertainties are mainly from the sonic data and seismic
Availability of data and materials  Not applicable.
processing. The sonic tool’s anticipated miscalibration that
tends to accumulate when the log is integrated with depth
Declarations 
and difficulties in running sonic readings in the shallow
part of the hole are the major sources of error in the sonic Conflict of interest  The authors declare that they have no known com-
data. Seismic processing and interpretation uncertainties peting financial interests or personal relationships that could have ap-
are mainly due to considerable uncertainty on the correct peared to influence the work reported in the submitted manuscript.
wavelet to be used during synthetic generation and incorrect
zero phasing of wavelets during seismic processing. Despite
these uncertainties, the seismic results presented herein are References
reliable because all major seismic characteristic expressions
of salt deposition and remobilization have been observed Becker, M. W. (2006). Potential for satellite remote sensing of ground
water. Groundwater, 44, 306–318.
on seismic; salt deposition and remobilization, in the Man-
Belenitskaya, G. A. (2016). Salt tectonics at the margins of young
dawa Basin, have been highlighted by previous workers (e.g. oceans. Geotectonics, 50, 244–256.
Hudson, 2011; Hudson & Nicholous, 2014; Didas, 2016; Bhaskar, A. S., & Kumar, R. B. (2011). Remote sensing of coastal geo-
Godson, 2017). morphology to understand river migration in the Thengapatnam
area, southern India. International Journal of Remote Sensing,
32, 5287–5301.
Bussert, R., Heinrich, W. D., & Aberhan, M. (2009). The Tendaguru
5 Conclusion Formation (Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous, southern Tanzania):
Definition, palaeoenvironments, and sequence stratigraphy. Fossil
Record, 12, 141–174.
This work reports the demarcation of an area character-
Didas, M. M. (2016). Geophysical investigation of the subsurface struc-
ized by salt pillows and diapirs in the Mandawa Basin, all tures of the Mandawa Basin, southeast coastal Tanzania. M.Sc.
uncovered with the help of remote sensing techniques. Digi- thesis, University of Dar es Salaam. 155 pp.
tal Elevation Model (DEM) data has shown a topographic dos Reis, R. P., Pimentel, N., Fainstein, R., Reis, M., & Rasmussen, B.
(2017). Influence of salt diapirism on the basin architecture and
manifestation of the Nondwa salt basin, salt deposition and
hydrocarbon prospects of the Western Iberian Margin. In Permo-
remobilization within the basin. The salt deposition was con- Triassic Salt Provinces of Europe, North Africa and the Atlantic
firmed by a seismic well tie, whereas salt remobilization was Margins (pp. 313–329). Elsevier.
confirmed by characteristic seismic expressions of salt pil- Emanuel, A., Kasanzu, C. H., & Kagya, M. (2020). Geochemical char-
acterization of hydrocarbon source rocks of the Triassic-Jurassic
lows and diapirs. Results show that the salt basin and deposi-
time interval in the Mandawa basin, southern Tanzania: Implica-
tion were relatively extensive than what has been reported tions for petroleum generation potential. South African Journal
before. Several diapirs, shown in the current work, have not of Geology, 2020(123), 587–596.

13
E. E. Mshiu et al.

Fossum, K., Dypvik, H., Haid, M. H., Hudson, W. E., & van den Brink, Trøndelag Platform. Norwegian Journal of Geology, 100, 2020.
M. (2020). Late Jurassic and Early Cretaceous sedimentation in https://​doi.​org/​10.​17850/​njg100-​2-3
the Mandawa Basin, coastal Tanzania. Journal of African Earth Kreuser, T., Wopfner, H., Kaaya, C. Z., Markwork, S., Semkiwa, P. M.,
Sciences, 174, 104013. & Aslanidis, P. (1990). Depositional evolution of Permo-Triassic
Ganapuram, S., Kumar, G. V., Krishna, I. M., Kahya, E., & Demirel, Karoo basins in Tanzania with reference to their economic poten-
M. C. (2009). Mapping of groundwater potential zones in the tial. Journal of African Earth Sciences, 10, 151–167.
Musi basin using remote sensing data and GIS. Advances in Engi- Macgregor, D. S. (1993). Relationships between seepage, tectonics and
neering Software, 40, 506–518. subsurface petroleum reserves. Marine and Petroleum Geology,
Godson, G. (2017). Characterization of Triassic hydrocarbon source 10, 606–619.
rocks of the Mandawa basin, Tanzania (Doctoral dissertation, The Mohr, M., Kukla, P. A., Urai, J. L., & Bresser, G. (2005). Multiphase
University of Dodoma). salt tectonic evolution in NW Germany: Seismic interpretation
Harding, R., & Huuse, M. (2015). Salt on the move: Multi stage evo- and retro-deformation. International Journal of Earth Sciences,
lution of salt diapirs in the Netherlands North Sea. Marine and 94, 917–940.
Petroleum Geology, 61, 39–55. Peel, F. J. (2014). How do salt withdrawal minibasins form? Insights
Hewson, R., Mshiu, E., Hecker, C., van der Werff, H., van Ruitenbeek, from forward modelling, and implications for hydrocarbon migra-
F., Alkema, D., & van der Meer, F. (2020). The application of tion. Tectonophysics, 630, 222–235.
day and night time ASTER satellite imagery for geothermal and Santos, M. G., Hartley, A. J., Mountney, N. P., Peakall, J., Owen, A.,
mineral mapping in East Africa. International Journal of Applied Merino, E. R., & Assine, M. L. (2019). Meandering rivers in mod-
Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 85, 101991. ern desert basins: Implications for channel planform controls and
Hudson, W. (2011). The geological evolution of the petroleum pro- prevegetation rivers. Sedimentary Geology, 385, 1–14.
spective Mandawa Basin southern coastal Tanzania (Doctoral Shahid, S., Nath, S., & Roy, J. (2000). Groundwater potential modelling
dissertation, Trinity College Dublin). in a soft rock area using a GIS. International Journal of Remote
Hudson, W. E., & Nicholas, C. J. (2014). The Pindiro Group (Trias- Sensing, 21, 1919–1924.
sic to Early Jurassic Mandawa Basin, southern coastal Tanzania): Stewart, S. A. (2006). Implications of passive salt diaper kinematics
Definition, palaeoenvironment, and stratigraphy. Journal of Afri- for reservoir segmentation by radial and concentric faults. Marine
can Earth Sciences, 92, 55–67. and Petroleum Geology, 23, 843–853.
Ielp, A., Ventra, D., & Ghinassi, M. (2016). Deeply Channeled Pre- Trusheim F. (1987). Halokinesis. In Structural Geology and Tecton-
cambrian rivers: Remote sensing and outcrop evidence from the ics Encyclopedia of Earth Science. Springer https://​doi.​org/​10.​
1.2 GA Stoer Group of NW Scotland. Precambrian Research, 1007/3-​540-​31080-0_​49
281, 291–311. van der Meer, F., Hecker, C., van Ruitenbeek, F., van der Werff, H., de
Jackson, M. P., & Hudec, M. R. (2017). Salt tectonics: Principles and Wijkerslooth, C., & Wechsler, C. (2014). Geologic remote sens-
practice. Cambridge University Press. ing for geothermal exploration: A review. International Journal
Jackson, M. P. A., & Talbot, C. J. (1991). A Glossary of Salt Tectonics. of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 33, 255–269.
Univ. Tex. Austin Bur. Econ. Geol. Circ. 91–4 (44 pp). Wagner, B. H. (2010). An analysis of salt welding (Doctoral disserta-
Jackson, M. P., Vendeville, B. C., & Schultz-Ela, D. D. (1994). Struc- tion). University of Texas at Austin, 236 pp.
tural dynamics of salt systems. Annual Review of Earth and Plan- Wagner, B. H., & Jackson, M. P. A. (2011). Viscous flow during salt
etary Sciences, 22, 93–117. welding. Tectonophysics, 510, 309–326.
Jaiswal, R. K., Mukherjee, S., Krishnamurthy, J., & Saxena, R. (2003). Warsitzka, M., Kley, J., & Kukowski, N. (2013). Salt diapirism driven
Role of remote sensing and GIS techniques for generation of by differential loading—Some insights from analogue modelling.
groundwater prospect zones towards rural development—an Tectonophysics, 591, 83–97.
approach. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 24, 993–1008. Wopfner, H. (2002). Tectonic and climatic events controlling deposi-
Kazimoto, E. O., & Mshiu, E. E. (2020). Reconnaissance assessment tion in Tanzanian Karoo basins. Journal of African Earth Sci-
of the Stenian-Tonian granitoids of southern Tanzania for metal ences, 34, 167–177.
resources by using geological remote sensing and geochemical Zumsprekel, H., & Prinz, T. (2000). Computer-enhanced multispectral
techniques. Geochemistry, 80, 125533. remote sensing data: A useful tool for the geological mapping
Kent, P. E., Hunt, J. A., & Johnstone, D. W. (1971). The geology and geo- of Archean terrains in (semi) arid environments. Computers &
physics of coastal Tanzania. Natural Environment Research Coun- Geosciences, 26, 87–100.
cil, Institute of Geological Sciences, Geophysical Paper, 6, 1–101.
Kiswaka, E. B., & Felix, M. (2020). Permo-Triassic sedimentary fills Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
and tectonic phases off Mid Norway: Seismic investigation of the jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

13

You might also like