You are on page 1of 38

Simulation of Composite Manufacturing Processes

Introduction

Yann Duplessis Kergomard / Santiago Montagud Perez de Lis – ESI Group,


CoE Composite Manufacturing – ydk@esi-group.com / smo@esi-group.com
Octobre 2020
www.esi-group.com 1
Copyright © ESI
Copyright
Group, ©
2015.
ESI Group,
All rights
2015.
reserved.
All rights reserved.
ESI short presentation

www.esi-group.com 2
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
The Story of ESI

Image courtesy of Volkswagen AG Image courtesy of AP&T

1973 1985 1999 2000

THE STORY FIRST CRASH TEST VIRTUAL NYSE EURONEXT


BEGINS ON FULL CAR MANUFACTURING ESI enters the NYSE
ESI founded; expert First Volkswagen Polo Added to the ESI portfolio: Euronext Paris
in physics of materials • Casting stock market
• Sheet Metal Forming
• Welding
ISO 9001-2000 CERTIFICATION

www.esi-group.com 3
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
The Story of ESI

2001 2011 2012 2016

EXPANSION INTO ENTRY INTO VIRTUAL EMBRACING OPEN MAKE IT SMART


MULTI-DOMAIN REALITYv SOURCE
SIMULATION ESI acquires IC.IDO ESI acquires OpenCFD, the ESI makes prototypes smart by
• NVH makers of OpenFOAM integrating acquisitions in Systems
• Durability Engineering, Cloud Computing,
• Vibro-Acoustics Data Analytics and Machine
• Comfort Learning

Image courtesy of Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems Europe

www.esi-group.com 4
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
ESI Around The World

More than 40 countries 34 subsidiaries 1100 people

MILPITAS, CA DETROIT, MI SÃO PAULO PARIS FRANKFURT EKATERINBURG BANGALORE BEIJING TOKYO
USA USA BRAZIL FRANCE GERMANY RUSSIA INDIA CHINA JAPAN

www.esi-group.com 5
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
( YDK note: here slides from for industrial trade
presentation)

Virtual Prototyping to Drive Innovation

Image courtesy of Vesta Engheneria Image courtesy of Audi AG

www.esi-group.com 6
Copyright © ESI
Copyright
Group, ©
2015.
ESI Group,
All rights
2015.
reserved.
All rights reserved.
( YDK note: here slides from for industrial trade
A Complete & Integrated Offer presentation)

Virtual Manufacturing End-to-End Solutions

Casting Composites Sheet Metal Forming Welding & Assembly Virtual Performance Virtual Seat Solution
Solution

Virtual Performance

Crash & Safety NVH & Dynamics Interior Acoustics Statics & Strength Vibro-Acoustics

Virtual Environment Virtual Integration Platform Virtual Reality Engineering services

CFD & Multiphysics Electromagnetics Multi-Domain Decision Support Collaborative Consulting Services
Simulation decision-making

www.esi-group.com 7
Images courtesy of Fonderia Casati, AP&T, Škoda Auto, Volkswagen AG, EADS Casa Espacio and Ford.

Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.


Composite Materials

www.esi-group.com 8
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
What is it?

• Assembly of, at least, two


immiscible materials

• Exhibits new properties absent


from individual constituent

www.esi-group.com 9
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
What is it?

• Assembly of, at least, two


immiscible materials

• Exhibits new properties absent


from individual constituent Composite structures

www.esi-group.com 10
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
What is it?

• Assembly of, at least, two


immiscible materials

• Exhibits new properties absent


from individual constituent Composite structures

Well known composite materials

www.esi-group.com 11
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Composite part manufacturing processes

www.esi-group.com 12
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP)

Fibres

+
Organic Matrix

www.esi-group.com 13
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP)

Fibres Fibre : ϕ ~ 0,01mm

+
Organic Matrix

www.esi-group.com 14
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP)

Fibres Fibre : ϕ ~ 0,01mm

+ Yarn
Organic Matrix

www.esi-group.com 15
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP)

Fibres Fibre : ϕ ~ 0,01mm

+ Yarn
Organic Matrix

Ply
www.esi-group.com 16
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Arnaud Dereims (ESI Group) – Oct. 9th 2015 – ENSEIRB MATMECA

Composite Materials
Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP)

Fibres

+
Organic Matrix

www.esi-group.com 17
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Composite Manufacturing Processes
Overview of CFRP Manufacturing Processes

Liquid Composite Moulding


(LCM)

• 3 steps
‣ Preforming
‣ Impregnation
‣ Curing/Cooling
www.esi-group.com 18
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Composite Manufacturing Processes
Overview of CFRP Manufacturing Processes

Liquid Composite Moulding Pre-Impregnated semi-product


(LCM) (Prepregs)

• 3 steps • 2 steps
‣ Preforming ‣ Thermoforming
‣ Impregnation ‣ Curing/Cooling
‣ Curing/Cooling
www.esi-group.com 19
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Composite Manufacturing Processes
Overview of CFRP Manufacturing Processes

Liquid Composite Moulding Pre-Impregnated semi-product


(LCM) (Prepregs)

Supplier

• 3 steps • 2 steps
‣ Preforming ‣ Thermoforming
‣ Impregnation ‣ Curing/Cooling
‣ Curing/Cooling
www.esi-group.com 20
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Composite Manufacturing Processes
Overview of CFRP Manufacturing Processes

Liquid Composite Moulding Pre-Impregnated semi-product


(LCM) (Prepregs)

Supplier

• 3 steps • 2 steps
‣ Preforming ‣ Thermoforming
‣ Impregnation ‣ Curing/Cooling
‣ Curing/Cooling
www.esi-group.com 21
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Composite manufacturing issues by industries

www.esi-group.com 22
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
Industrial issues : Aeronautic industry
Simulation time divided by 5 thanks to simulation
Better quality parts with less scraps (better reproducibility)

• Medium to large parts


• Main constraints:
‣ Part design cannot be modified easily
• Processability of the designed part
• Process design cost
‣ Manufactured part quality (very few porosity,
no distortion…)
• New constraints:
‣ Manufacturing time and cost

G_MKT_RL_10_345, Courtesy of EADS Innovation Works,


Infusion simulation of a fuselage panel with PAM-RTM

G_MKT_R_L_13_255, Courtesy of VZLÚ

www.esi-group.com 23
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
Industrial issues : Wind industry
160 m φ
Source : « Wind energy use in Germany –
Status 31.12.2006 » , DEWI Magazine Nr.
30, Feb 2007

• Large to very large parts


• Some region very thick (> 10 cm) Airbus
A380
• Main constraints:
Wing span
‣ Size of the parts: 80 m
• Processability of the designed part
• Process design cost
‣ Manufactured part quality for the critical
structural part (spar)
‣ Manufacturing and material cost

An 81.6 meter long offshore wind turbine rotor blade & Analysis of several injection strategies with PAM-RTM on the root of the rotor blade
G.MKT.R.L14.625

www.esi-group.com 24
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
Industrial issues : Automotive industry

• Small to medium parts


• Main constraints:
‣ Material cost
‣ Manufacturing time window (<
2-3’) and cost
• Processability of the designed
part
Floor pan
• Process design cost injection

RTM application: Automotive floor panel

www.esi-group.com 25
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Simulation of composite manufacturing processes at
ESI

www.esi-group.com 26
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
ESI PAM-COMPOSITES
Summary
Compensated
Mold
Geometry

Distortion analysis
PAM-DISTORTION

LCM – Curing analysis Temperature


PAM-RTM & Degree of Cure
history

Pre-forming analysis Shearing of


PAM-FORM fibers

www.esi-group.com 27
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
What for ?

www.esi-group.com 28
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
What for ?

Impregnation of dry preform with resin and curing

• HP-RTM
• Curing
• …

• RTM • Infusion • C-RTM

www.esi-group.com 29
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
How to simulate and Why

www.esi-group.com 30
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Why simulate LCM process ?

To Determine and Optimize process parameters such as:


• Process parameters: • Material / Design
‣ locate injection gates and vents • Material behavior f(T, t)
‣ Flow rates or pressure • Ply book
‣ Vacuum • Design of new molds or improvement of existing molds
‣ Temperature cycle

Through prediction of:


• Air traps • Temperature evolution
• Micro porosity • Degree of cure evolution
• Injection time • Pressure in the mold

www.esi-group.com 31
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
Physics involved

www.esi-group.com 32
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding

Physics involved: Modelling


• Four physical phenomena are modeled

‣ Flow of resin inside the preform

‣ Heat exchanges inside reinforcement and mould

‣ Chemical reaction of resin

‣ Reinforcement deformation in case of infusion

www.esi-group.com 33
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
Physics involved: reinforcement modelling

Fibres

+
Organic Matrix

www.esi-group.com 34
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Liquid Composite Moulding
Physics involved: Preform modelling

tows fibers

Micro voids

Macro voids

Macroscopic Meso-scopic Microscopic

tow

www.esi-group.com 35
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Preform modelling
Physics involved: Preform modelling

Solid Mechanics Fluid Mechanics

Macro-scale

deformable preform made of undeformable filaments Porous medium approximation


𝐽 𝑥,
Ԧ 𝑡 + ∆𝑡 𝑣𝑓 𝑥,
Ԧ 𝑡 + ∆𝑡 = 𝐽 𝑥,
Ԧ 𝑡 𝑣𝑓 (𝑥,
Ԧ 𝑡)
Darcy law / permeability

www.esi-group.com 36
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
Flow Modeling
Darcy’s Experiment

www.esi-group.com 37
Copyright © ESI Group, 2015. All rights reserved.
F i n d e l ’ I nt ro d u c t i o n

www.esi-group.com 38
Copyright © ESI Group, 2014.
2015. All rights reserved.

You might also like