Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Summary 3
2. Background 4
5. Challenges 14
6. Conclusions 15
1. Summary
Over the last four years something remarkable decision to privatise their water by deciding to
has been happening in South East Asia. Away manage their supply themselves.
from the headlines of military coups, economic
crises and corruption scandals a new form of These and many more small, yet significant
politics has been emerging – one that puts poor achievements have been the result of a
people at the centre. unique regional initiative supported by
One World Action, funded by the UK’s
A village in North Begkulu, Indonesia, allocated Department for International Development.
more of their local budget to health care and The project – Citizen’s Participation in Local
education; a local official in Thailand took the Governance (CPLG) implemented across
brave decision to speak to the media about the Philippines, Indonesia, Cambodia and
the corruption in his local area; for the first Thailand has provided exciting opportunities,
time civil society in Cambodia developed challenges and risks for all involved. As the
recommendations on a new national policy project comes to an end this paper looks at what
that were recognised and encouraged by the changes have been achieved, what lessons can
government; and in the Philippines an urban be learnt and asks have the risks been worth it?
poor community in Manila challenged the
3
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
2. Background
4
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
and who support policies and practices that of transformative governance across the
will contribute to meeting the Millennium region.
Development Goals. Supporting them both
before, and during their time in office, and
to identify what strategies and support can CPLG – What made it different?
be provided from civil society to keep these
people in office, and to keep them active and Having a southern co-ordinator –
accountable. Decentralisation in the Philippines is more
established and legally formalised than in the
To bridge social movements and people’s other project countries. Having IPD as the
organisations with formal politics. For many project co-ordinator enabled Filipino lessons
reasons involvement in formal politics has not and strategies to be shared and to take a
been a strategy used by civil society to gain more political and empowering approach to
power. A lack of resources, training, potential local governance. It also enabled decisions
accusations of co-option, corruption or selling and management to be closer to the people
out, apathy with established or traditional and organisations the project was aiming to
politicians and policies, different backgrounds support.
and agendas, and the desire to maintain
independence from political parties can all be An analysis of power and exclusion that
valid reasons, particularly in countries where includes gender – the realisation that
democracies are fragile and emerging from strengthening woman’s political engagement
authoritarian rule. However CPLG aimed to and participation must lie at the heart of local
challenge these assumptions by exploring governance.
and illustrating the impact that NGOs and
A truly regional programme – From its
ACOs could have if they looked beyond
inception the importance of exchanges,
their more established role, of monitoring,
sharing strategies and cross-country learning
analysing and critiquing politicians and
was at the heart of the CPLG. All involved
institutions. By highlighting the transformative
understood that if these aspects were to be
role that local politicians could play, with an
genuinely realised then realistic time and
emphasis on integrity and accountability,
resources would need to be allocated.
once in power, CPLG illustrated that gaining
power through formal political processes can A bottom up approach – CPLG partners
be a vital tool to bring about change – one believe that the democratic participation
that we as civil society cannot afford to of local people and people’s organisations
ignore. in local politics and governance processes
is essential if sustainable and equitable
Although incredibly diverse in history, culture,
development is to be achieved.
political traditions and current policies, the
majority of the women and men living in Working with local officials – Partners all
Cambodia, Thailand, Indonesia and the took an approach of constructive (if at times
Philippines face widespread corruption, critical) engagement with local government
human rights violations and denial of their officials – believing that stronger relationships
economic, civil and political rights. In the between government and civil society can be
midst of these challenges CPLG aimed beneficial for both sides.
to provide a positive and empowering
framework for ACOs, people’s movements Flexibility – Development failures of the
and local officials to work together. Despite last decades have shown us the dangers of
the challenges, CPLG aimed to be a catalyst applying a one-size-fits-all model to complex
for change, to support the emerging patches processes of governance and democracy.
5
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
6
A notice board in Sainawang Tambon, Cambodia, which displays the local budget, amounts being spent on infrastructure
projects, participatory community plans for the next year and dates of the next community consultation meetings.
3. Contributing to Change –
Country Overview and Highlights
Decentralisation in each country gravitates to the Tambon in Thailand, the Municipality in the
Philippines, the Commune/Sangkat in Cambodia and the Kabupaten in Indonesia.
7
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
2. Establishing informal networks of Tambon Following the coup there were many concerns about
Administrative Officials (approximately 150 the violent competition over natural resources in the
out of 2000 officials are members of networks localities, the lack of genuine decentralisation, poor
in different regions of Thailand). The network urban communities being forcibly displaced and a
in the North and North East of Thailand, the lack of access to information. These forums have
Local Government Organisation Officials of
been a vital step to ensure public input is included
the People’s Sector, is particularly strong.
in the people’s agenda for political reform.
Some officials were previously, and continue
to be representatives of social movements.
Suriyasai Katasila, Campaign for Popular Democracy
8
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
9
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
Indonesia
Highlights of CPLG in Cambodia
The Asian economic crisis severely devastated
1. Holding civil society consultations and
Indonesia’s economy and led to the end of
establishing a working group to submit
the Soeharto regime in 1998. Decentralisation
proposals on Cambodia’s new organic law.
was set in motion in 1999 as the government’s
This process was recognised and endorsed
response to local demands for greater autonomy
by the Ministry of Interior which was a first for
and control over natural resources, as well as
Cambodia. Usually international NGOs are the
threats of secession in some regions. However
only agencies to input on policy consultations.
legal frameworks were hastily assembled and
2. Creating mechanisms for engagement imprecise. The magnitude and ambition of the
between civil society and Commune task of decentralisation in Indonesia is vast
10
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
given the sheer size of the country and the 4. Documenting success stories of how
tradition of top-down planning after decades of marginalised groups can have a stronger
authoritarian rule. political influence (standing for election,
capacity building, campaigns etc). This has
Local governments lack the capacity to resulted in more marginalised aspects of civil
develop communities and policy making is still society becoming more engaged as experts
dominated by local elites, fuelled by powerful and consultants in formulating national and
political and business interests. Furthermore local policy.
many NGOs still take a more traditional state
centred approach and are resistant to local
governance work. Previously, local government representatives were
appointed by the party in power; now individual
candidates can stand for direct election if they use
The major focus has been to politicise civil society’s
eligible political parties as ‘vehicles’ to run. This
engagement in local governance (as opposed
means that citizens organisations potentially now
to donor initiated local governance projects),
have access to power at the local level, and the ability
strengthen organisations and institutions at the
to shape policies and spending priorities locally.
local level and learn how decentralisation can
Ibrahim Zudhi Fahmy Badoh,
be effectively implemented. There are lots of
Indonesian Corruption Watch
organisations working in Indonesia at the local level
but CPLG engages with local work as a political
project – it encourages civil society to become a
political player and to monitor and engage with new ICW documented success stories of activists
who ran as independent candidates in the 2004
opportunities that are emerging at the national level.
Senate elections in West Kalimantan province.
Luky Djani, Indonesian Corruption Watch
Muspani’s campaign in Bengkulu, depended
on grassroots organising. His nomination and
policies were based on extensive consultation
Highlights of CPLG in Indonesia with people organisations establishing
1. Implementing local legal frameworks and campaign teams down to village level. His
successfully advocating for decentralised campaign focused on land, protection for
budgets. informal vendors and access to credit. Due to
a lack of resources Muspani could not engage
2. Setting up participatory budget planning
the media but through intensive face-to-face
and allocation mechanisms in 10 villages
interactions with people in the villages he was
in North Begkulu that led to an increased
able to mobilise sufficient voters to end up in
allocation for health and education, the
third position and gain his seat in the Senate.
priority sectors identified by the villagers.
This involved local people in decision making, Maria Goretti’s campaign was supported by
policy development and budgeting. Training a Credit Union and a number of respected
and guidance on drafting local legislation and elderly leaders in the community who saw
monitoring budgets has been carried out in the elections as an opportunity to raise local
these 10 villages. issues related to the welfare of indigenous
Dayak people. She also raised women’s
3. Ensuring that activists from social
issues. Maria’s background as a journalist
movements have the skills and capacity to
gave her strong media coverage – she was
become involved in local elections and local
the only women candidate from her province
governance.
and gained a seat in the Senate.
11
Thai and Filipino CPLG staff meet to discuss the political events in Thailand, April 2006
12
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
13
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
5. Challenges
Overall there was more focus on country Why are social movements and civil society
specific activities than on advocating the organisations so resistant to gaining
political nature of CPLG and its successes at political office?
an international or regional level. However How can you communicate issues around
networking with Logolink did increase the local governance and democratisation in
outreach and profile of the work on the ground. an accessible and inspiring way?
Communication and translation issues were an How can you fund the development of
inevitable challenge throughout – the working progressive political parties and their
candidates?
14
Citizens’ participation and local governance in South East Asia
6. Conclusions
15
One World Action
Bradley’s Close
White Lion Street
London N1 9PF
T: 00 44 (0)20 7833 4075
F: 00 44 (0)20 7833 4102
Email: owa@oneworldaction.org
www.oneworldaction.org
Campaign for Popular Committee for Free and Institute for Popular
Democracy, Thailand Fair Elections in Cambodia Indonesia Corruption Watch Democracy, Philippines
Email: cpd_ngo@hotmail.com www.comfrel.org www.antikorupsi.org/eng www.ipd.ph