Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Municipal Governance
Municipal Governance
NQF Level 5
SAQA ID: 67467
Apply the principles of budgeting within a municipality
US ID: 116345
No part of this Publication may reproduced, stored in retrieval system, or transmitted, in any
form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without
the prior permission of the copyright owner.
Although every attempt has been made to ensure that the management guidelines are safe
and correct, the developer, publishers, and sponsors of the manual cannot accept any
responsibility for errors arising from the use of this manual for any purpose.
BBT-6-US: 116345
Table of Content
ACKNOWLEDGMENT.................................................................................................7
Preface:.............................................................................................................................. 8
1.Introduction..............................................................................................................9
2.2 Learner Support.....................................................................................................10
3. Assessment............................................................................................................... 11
3.1 Formative Assessment.......................................................................................11
3.2 Summative Assessment.....................................................................................11
4. Navigating the Learner Guide....................................................................................12
4.1 Use of Icons........................................................................................................12
Group Activity / Pair Activity:...............................................................................12
Individual Activity:...............................................................................................12
5. Learner Administration...............................................................................................13
5.1 Attendance Register...........................................................................................13
5.2 Learner Registration Form..................................................................................14
5.3 Programme Evaluation Form..............................................................................14
(US ID: 116345) Apply the principles of budgeting within a municipality..........15
Introduction....................................................................................................................... 15
SO1. Municipal Budgeting.......................................................................................16
1.1 Definition of municipal budgeting...........................................................................16
Individual Activity 1:............................................................................................19
1.2 Aims of budgeting..................................................................................................19
Municipal Budgeting......................................................................................................... 22
Group Activity / Pair Activity 1:............................................................................22
1.3 Importance of the budgeting...................................................................................23
Importance of effective municipal financial planning and management.........................23
What is financial management?....................................................................................23
Individual Activity 2:............................................................................................24
1.4 Components of a budgeting...................................................................................24
The "Financial Year" and budget consultation...............................................................24
Types of budgets........................................................................................................... 24
The difference between the operating and capital budgets...........................................25
Sources of municipal income.........................................................................................25
This learning material has been entirely developed and organized by Bull’s Business and
Skills training institute (BBT Institute) under supervision of NSA Consulting.
Many people have contributed in various ways to help develop and produce the original
version and the later edition of this manual. We wish to thank all those who have contributed
in one way or another.
We are heartily thankful to BBT and NSA agency employees, family and friends, whose
encouragement, guidance and support from the initial to the final level enabled us to compile
and have an understanding of this manual.
Lastly, we offer my regards and blessings to all of those who supported us in any respect
during the compilation of this Manual, especially LG SETA, for the practical support and
resources required to put up this manual.
Other sources
LG SETA
SALGA
The DTI
DBSA
Wikipedia
This guide should be used to prepare the learner to be able to participate in the Municipal
governance environment.
The qualification is aimed at senior managers and future senior managers in local
government. The typical learner will be an employee in local government, wishing to gain the
competence to fulfill the requirements of his/her current job obligations or a municipal
employee wishing to gain a qualification so as to advance his/her career opportunities. In
addition persons seeking future employment in the local government sector may choose to
complete the qualification. Persons employed in non-profit organizations and non-
governmental organizations as well as private sector agencies which interface with local
government would benefit from the qualification.
Qualifying learners may operate at the level of executive mayor, executive councilors,
councilors, municipal manager; chief financial officer; department managers; strategic
managers and managers of municipal entities.
Office bearers and employees at local government level are responsible for managing the
provision of services to the community. The Constitution of the RSA (Act 108 of 1996)
section 27 (1) states that all South Africans have the right to access health care services;
sufficient food and water and social security. Section 27(2) requires the state to take
reasonable measures within its available resources to provide these basic human rights. The
state is also responsible for providing education for the community and managing all of the
country's resources. The constitution therefore allows the community to demand that
services are met and that government office bearers and managers have the skills to take
reasonable measures in providing services.
In this manual, the knowledge and skills achieved will enable the learner to maximally
combat the processes involved in assessment and disseminate accurate and relevant
information regarding assessment procedures to achieve the specific outcomes.
Welcome come.
TRAINING MANAGER
1. Introduction
This Unit Standard is intended for practitioners at local government who are involved in
municipal policy decision-making and strategic planning. Learners who are required to
advise on the legislative mandate of municipalities from a provincial or national government
perspective will also benefit from this Unit Standard.
The Unit Standard will contribute to social and economic transformation by equipping
municipal practitioners with skills in budgeting which could translate into better use pof
resources and improved delivery services.
Please remember that as the programme is outcomes based – this implies the following:
You are responsible for your own learning – make sure you manage your study,
practical, workplace and portfolio time responsibly.
Learning activities are learner driven – make sure you use the Learner Guide and
Portfolio Guide in the manner intended, and are familiar with the Portfolio requirements.
The Facilitator is there to reasonably assist you during contact, practical and workplace
time of this programme – make sure that you have his/her contact details.
Learning Outcomes:
Please refer to the beginning of each module for the learning outcomes that
will be covered per module.
In this Learner Guide, several activities are spaced within the content to assist you in
understanding the material through application. Please make sure that you complete ALL
activities in the Learner Guide, whether it was done during the contact session, or not!
The Portfolio Guide will assist you in identifying the portfolio and evidence requirements for
final assessment purposes. You will be required to complete Portfolio activities on your own
time, using real life projects in your workplace environment in preparing evidence towards
your portfolio.
Portfolio Activity:
DO NOT WAIT until the end – the programme is designed to assist you in
evidence preparation as you go along – make use of the opportunity!
Remember:
In some evidence, the process you followed is more important than actual
outcome / end-product.
Therefore …
Please make sure all steps for the Portfolio ActivitiesError: Reference
source not found are shown where required.
Throughout the learning programme icons are used to focus your attention on important
aspects of the learning programme. The following icons are used in this learning programme
to direct your attention in using at as a reference guide.
You will be required to complete an activity on your own that relates to the
outcomes covered in the module.
Portfolio Activity:
Self Reflection:
Learner Tip:
Resources:
Possible sources for further research and study is listed under this icon.
Resources may include additional reading, handouts, web-sites, multimedia
Facilitators Note:
Mentored Discussion:
Learning Outcomes:
Please refer to the beginning of each module for the learning outcomes that
will be covered per module.
You have come to the end of this module – please take the time to review
what you have learnt to date, and conduct a self assessment against the
learning outcomes of this module
Learner Tip:
You are required to sign the Attendance Register every day of attendance. Please make
sure you sign daily!
Pease refer to the portfolio Guide for the Learner Registration Form. Make sure you
complete it using the Key Document, and submit to your Facilitator before the end of the
contact session with a copy of your ID document.
Learner Tip/Truths:
At the end of the Learning Guide is a Learning programme Evaluation Form. Please
complete the form before the end of the contact sessions, as this will assist us in improving
our service and programme material. Your assistance is highly appreciated!
Learning Outcomes:
Introduction
A budget is defined as the formal expression of plans, goals, and objectives of management
that covers all aspects of operations for a designated time period. The budget is a tool
providing targets and direction. Budgets provide control over the immediate environment,
help to master the financial aspects of the job and department, and solve problems before
they occur. Budgets focus on the importance of evaluating alternative actions before
decisions actually are implemented.
Budgeting allocates funds to achieve desired outcomes. A budget may span any period of
time. It may be short term (one year or less, which is usually the case), intermediate term
(two to three years), or long term (three years or more). Short-term budgets provide greater
detail and specifics. Intermediate budgets examine the projects the company currently is
undertaking and start the programs necessary to achieve long-term objectives. long-term
plans are very broad and may be translated into short-term plans. The budget period varies
according to its objectives, use, and the dependability of the data used to prepare it. The
budget period is contingent on business risk, sales and operating stability, production
methods, and length of the processing cycle.
There is a definite relationship between long-range planning and short-term business plans.
The ability to meet near-term budget goals will move the business in the direction of
accomplishing long-term objectives. Budgeting is done for the company as a whole, as well
as for its component segments including divisions, departments, products, projects, services,
manpower, and geographic areas.
Budgets aid decision making, measurement, and coordination of the efforts of the various
groups within the entity. Budgets highlight the interaction of each business segment to the
whole organization. For example, budgets are prepared for units within a department, such
as product lines; for the department itself; for the division, which consists of a number of
departments; and for the company.
salaries
pension contributions
purchase of short-life equipment
repair and maintenance
servicing of long-term debt (principal and interest)
Capital Budget
Operational and Capital Budgets should be separated until the full impact of TCA
reporting is understood. This process is in transition with the PSAB requirements for
corporate style financial statements.
Capital Expenditures are defined in the new TCA policies. These types of expenses
could be funded out of a current year’s revenue but should usually be derived from
long term planning and the creation of previous year’s reserves to self finance large
replacement projects such as water and sewer construction or a swimming pool.
Operating Budgets
Timing of budget preparation: preliminary would be in the fall with finalization early in
the new year once grants, requisitions, and prior year actuals are available.
A summary worksheet detailing gross revenues and expenses by
function/department provides the basis for budgeting. Spreadsheet columns could
include: Actuals, Budgeted Amounts, Approved, Variances. Detail at each program
level should be attached.
Consistent application of a standardized Chart of Accounts provides the basis for
accurate, comparable financial information.
The MACs system in Alberta has been in place for over 40 years. Example provided.
Expenses should be broken down by key areas: Salaries/wages, Contracted
Services, Goods and Supplies, Grants to other organizations, Allowances, etc.
Labour costs consist of projections for permanent, previously approved salaried
positions and wage costs (seasonal short term labour.) Permanent positions and the
applicable pay grades would be approved by Council prior to implementing and
recruiting to a position.
Labour should be separated by department, which complies with your FIR
breakdowns. Council can request projections by position. Usually there will be a
previously negotiated COLA clause that can be identified and factored in; if not
Administration should be making a recommendation on no change or a change
based on Cost of Living.
Capital Budgets
Recommend having five to ten year capital budgets updated annually which also
include the use or establishment of internal reserve funds.
Adequacy of reserves is directly related to capital requirements and council’s attitude
to debenture borrowings or other debt.
The first items that need to be identified are incomplete Capital Projects carried
forward from the prior fiscal year. Unexpended budgeted revenues should be
transferred to reserves or set up as deferred revenues if the criteria are met. The
impact of these projects must then be worked into the current budget.
New projects should be defined and methods of funding should be identified –
reserve allocations, grants, current year taxation, offsite levies, or other revenue.
Capital borrowing required must be identified with the appropriate bylaws enacted.
Individual Activity 1:
Organising
Planning
The organisation's goals are selected and actions established to meet these goals.
Budgeting forces key people in the organisation to plan. Participation by stakeholders in the
budgeting process leads to ownership of the budget and a greater awareness of
organisational requirements.
Leading
The organisation's goals are achieved by assisting organisational members to perform their
planned tasks through:
communicating the budget's objectives and how they will be achieved; and
motivating members to focus on their individual budgeted targets.
Organising
The organisation's goals are efficiently achieved by acquiring resources and allocating those
resources in a co-ordinated manner so that all parts of the organisation are efficiently
working towards the same objectives.
Controlling
The attainment of the organisation's goals is measured against set standards. Current
performance is measured and compared against those standards and where necessary
remedial action is taken.
At this stage the budget may be revised and the process begun again.
Financial management
One of the most important duties of a municipal council is to manage its funds effectively.
This means -
Drawing up a budget - working out what income the municipality will receive and
balancing this with what they think they will have to spend it on
Protecting the income, capital and assets such as money in the bank, motor vehicles,
computer equipment, by putting in proper controls
Monitoring the actual income and expenditure and comparing this to the budget
through regular financial reporting and taking action to correct things when necessary
Auditing on a regular basis and reporting the financial statements to all stakeholders
Budgets have a key function in that they also serve a number of useful purposes which are
key to an organisation’s success, i.e.
Planning;
Co-ordination;
Communication;
Motivation;
Control;
Evaluation.
Planning
Managers are required to produce detailed plans to enable the implementation of the long
term or strategic plan. The annual budgeting process encourages managers to plan for
future operations, refine existing strategic plans and consider how they can respond to
changing circumstances. This encourages managers to anticipate problems before they
arise and ensures reasoned decision making. Without this incentive the pressures of day to
day operations may tempt managers not to plan for future operations and hasty decisions
based on expediency rather than reasoned judgement will be minimised.
Co-ordination
Budgeting facilitates consolidation and co-ordination and allows the actions of the different
parts of the organisation to be brought into a common plan. It also compels managers to
examine the relationship between the different parts of an organisation when making
decisions and in assists in identifying and resolving conflicts. Examples of the type of
conflicts which could arise in a manufacturing setting for example would be between a
purchasing manager who buys in bulk to obtain large discounts, a production manager who
wishes to avoid large stock levels and an accountant who is concerned about the impact on
the business’s cash resources. Budgeting aims to reconcile these differences.
Communication
All managers within the organisation must have a clear understanding of the role which they
are required to play in ensuring budgetary compliance. This ensures that the most
appropriate individuals are made accountable for budget implementation. Senior
management can also use budgets to communicate corporate objectives downwards and
ensure that other employees understand them and co-ordinate their activities to attain them.
The act of preparation as well as the budget itself will also improve communication.
Participation in budget setting relates to the extent that subordinates are able to influence
the figures incorporated in their targets. Participation is often referred to as bottom-up budget
setting whereas a non participatory approach whereby subordinates have little influence on
the target setting process is sometimes called top-down budget setting.
Motivation
Budgets can also provide a motivation for managers to perform in line with organisational
objectives. It therefore sets a standard which under circumstances managers may be
motivated to achieve. It is important, however, that managers are involved in the budget
setting process and that budgets are used as a tool to assist them in managing their
departments. With ‘top-down’ approaches there is a risk that dysfunctional motivational will
occur.
Control
Managers can also use budgets to control the activities for which they are responsible.
Analyses of variances allow managers to identify those costs which do not conform to the
long term plan and therefore may require alteration. By investigating the reasons for budget
deviations managers may also be able to identify inefficiencies.
The budget forms the basis of a controlling mechanism for the various resources of an
organisation which is achieved by comparing the resource measured to the end of a given
period with that which was expected. This approach can be used for all measurable
resources and activities within the organisation – not just those which are directly financial.
Budgetary control highlights variations from the expected in order that management can take
remedial action to ensure that the policy objectives set in the budget can be met. It is a
constant monitoring process and requires continual updating and amendment of the budget
through operational feedback. This also allows for performance against objectives or targets
to be measured.
Evaluation
Municipal Budgeting
1. to set out a complete programme with regard to all expenditures of the municipality
during the coming year, and the purpose for which they are to be made, and to
forecast the revenues from which such expenditures are to be financed;
2. to provide a method of controlling expenditure so that a municipality may live within
its means.”
Effective financial management can help municipalities to transform their local areas into a
better place to live and work. Most councillors and members of the community know what
municipal services they would like to have in their area. This dream of the ideal community is
known as a "vision" for the municipality.
Without funds to implement the policies, councillors will not be able to "make a difference" or
serve their communities well. Effective financial management ensures that there are funds
available to implement council policies. This is a great responsibility as municipalities are
responsible for managing large amounts of money and delivering services that affect
people's lives every day. Councillors, committee members and officials all have a duty to
ensure that these monies are managed carefully, transparently and honestly.
Good financial management is the key to local delivery – local activists and ward committee
members should understand municipal finance and budgets so that they can engage
councillors on the bigger debates about spending and development priorities.
The table below sets out the financial management processes that are used in
municipalities.
Budgeting Working out what income the municipality will get and
balancing this with the planned expenditure, by preparing
detailed plans and forecasts.
Ward committees have the right (and duty!) to discuss, ask questions and make recommendations to
the council on the best ways to generate income, to keep costs down, prevent corruption and
safeguard the assets of the municipality. That is good financial management!
Individual Activity 2:
The financial year of South African municipalities runs from 1 July of each year to 30 June
the following year. Municipalities must prepare budgets for each financial year. Council must
approve these budgets before the new financial year begins, after proper planning and
consultation with ward committees and other stakeholder groups in the area. For example,
the budget for the financial year beginning in July 2002 must be approved before the end of
June 2002. The draft budget should be ready a few months before so that it can be used for
consultation. (Around March)
The approval of the budget is one of the most important tasks undertaken by councillors,
after consultation with ward committees and other stakeholders.
Ward committees should carefully look at the parts of the budget that affect the people in
their area. Ward councillors can also call ward meetings to discuss the budget. If your
organisation is affected by the municipal budget and plans, invite a councillor to come and
discuss the budget and plans with you. All members of the community also have the right to
observe the special council meeting at which the budget is debated and voted on.
Types of budgets
There are two types of budgets: operating budget and capital budget.
Capital budget deals with big costs that you pay once to develop something, and how you
will pay for this – for example putting in water pipes to a new township.
Operating budget deals with the day-to-day costs and income to deliver municipal services –
for example the meter readers’ wages and maintenance work to keep the water flowing.
The operating budget – the municipality’s operating budget lists the planned operating
expenditure (costs) and income, for the delivery of all services to the community.
Operating expenditure is the cost of goods and services from which there will be short-term
benefit - that is, the services will be used up in less than one year.
For example, the payment of staff salaries results in a short-term benefit as salaried
employees are paid monthly for one month's work. They could resign, next month, and the
municipality would not have the benefit of their skills anymore. Examples of operating costs
are salaries, wages, repairs and maintenance, telephones, petrol, stationery.
Operating income is the amount received for services delivered for a short-term period. For
example, ratepayers pay rates monthly or annually as payment to their municipality for
receiving municipal services. Examples of operating income are property rates, service
charges, investment interest, and traffic fines.
The capital budget - The capital budget puts money aside, for planned expenditure on long-
term purchases and big investments such as land, buildings, motor vehicles, equipment and
office furniture that will be a municipal asset for more than a year - probably for many years
to come.
A municipality's capital budget will list the estimated costs of all items of a capital nature
such as the construction of roads, buildings and purchase of vehicles that are planned in that
budget year.
A useful way for to look at the difference between operating and capital expenditure is to
think about the purchase of a car. The purchase of a car is capital as the expected life of the
motor vehicle is much more than one year. The cost of fuel and repairs only provide short-
term benefit (less than a year) and therefore is operating expenditure.
The capital budget and operating budget have to be prepared and discussed together. This
is important because planned expenditure that is included in the municipality’s capital budget
will impact on the operating costs and income needed to "operate" the municipality’s assets,
efficiently.
This link between capital and operating budgets can be explained by using the car example
again. If you decide to buy a car, in addition to including funds for this in your capital budget,
you are going to have to include money in the operating budget for tyres, driver’s wages,
petrol, service and other operating expenses.
Municipalities must ensure that there will be adequate money to pay for their planned
expenditure if they are to "balance the budget". There are various sources of income that
can be used by municipalities to finance their expenditure. This section outlines the various
sources of municipal income, and looks at ways of deciding which will be best for your
municipality’s needs.
External loans - External loans (from a bank or other financial institution) are an expensive
form of financing the capital budget because of the high interest rates in South Africa.
External loans should only be used to finance the purchase of major capital items such as
roads, buildings, sewerage works and water systems.
Internal loans - Many municipalities have internal "savings funds" such as Capital
Development Funds or Consolidated Loan Fund. These funds can make internal loans to the
municipality for the purchase or development of capital items, usually at a lower interest rate
than for an external loan and the municipality is paying the interest back to its own "savings
fund", which can later be used for another capital project.
Contributions from revenue - When purchasing a small capital item, the small total cost
can be paid for from the operating income in the year of purchase. This financing source is
known as "contributions from revenue". In most municipalities, this source of financing is
used to pay for smaller capital items, such as one or two items of furniture and equipment.
As no interest is payable, this source of financing is considerably cheaper than external or
internal loans.
Government grants - Municipalities may apply to national government for grants for
infrastructure development. The two main funds available are:
Donations and public contributions - Local and foreign donors may sometimes donate a
capital item or money to be used specifically for the purchase of a capital item, in a
disadvantaged area. They may want publicity for their donation, which the municipality can
arrange to acknowledge their sponsorship.
Property Rates - All people and businesses who own fixed property (land, houses,
factories, and office blocks) in the municipal area are charged "Property Rates" - a yearly tax
based on the value of each property. Rates income is used by the municipality to pay for the
general services to all people, which cannot easily be charged to a specific service user as a
"service charge" for example roads, pavements, parks, streetlights, storm water
management, etc.
Service Charges / Tariffs - For specific services that can be directly charged to a house or
factory, the principle of "user pays" should be adopted. That is, to charge a price or "tariff" for
services such as water, electricity or approval of building plans; where the exact usage of the
service can be measured, to the person or business who actually used that service.
Fines -Traffic fines, late library book fines, penalties for overdue payment of service
charges: these fines are another source of income or "revenue" , while at the same time
motivating users of services to have a culture of obeying democratic laws, rules and
deadlines.
Equitable share - The equitable share is an amount of money that a municipality gets from
national government each year. The constitution says that all revenue collected nationally
must be divided equitably [fairly] between national, provincial and local spheres of
government. The local government equitable share is meant to ensure that municipalities
can provide basic service and develop their areas. The amount a municipality gets depends
mainly on the number of low-income people in the area – rural municipalities usually get
more. Most municipalities only get a small part of their operating budget from the equitable
share.
Degree of Urgency
Benefits Derived
Cost and Financial Impact
Acceptability
Individual Activity 3:
A Budget is basically a financial document that encompasses planning for future savings and
expenses. It provides a future picture of the expenditures and revenues and also helps in t
he future spending pattern whether it be an organization or an individual.
There are not eight but six key steps in the Budgeting Process which are as follows:
existing rates of taxation and an assessment of the likely growth and inflation rate
over the ensuing fiscal year.
On the capital receipts side, targeted amounts to be realised through divestment of
public sector equity and amounts to be realised by way of repayments of loans is
made. All the estimates flow to the revenue secretary.
Once this exercise is completed expenditure estimates are matched with revenue
estimate to arrive at a first estimate of the shortfall in revenue to meet projected
expenditure.
Following this the government, in tandem with its chief economic advisor, determines
the optimum level of borrowings that the government can resort to.
The level of external borrowings is an easily estimated figure because much of the
external borrowing on government account consists of bilateral and multilateral
assistance which is known by the time budget exercises are undertaken.
The level of domestic borrowing depends partly on the desired level of fiscal deficit
that the government targets for itself. A part of the revenue gap is left unfilled to be
met through the issue of ad hoc treasury bills. Over the past few years, this gap,
called the overall budget deficit, is government by an understanding between the
Reserve Bank of India and the finance ministry on the maximum level of ad hoc
treasury bills that can be issued during a fiscal year.
This has been done to ensure that the issue of ad hoc treasury bills to fill revenue
gaps does not lead to problems of monetary management.
After the targets for the fiscal deficits and the overall budget deficit have been
decided by the government, any remaining shortfall is filled through a revision in tax
rates where considered feasible and in keeping with fiscal incentive structure the
government wishes to put in place to stimulate the growth in different sectors.
Subsequently adjustments are made in expenditures, should it be required, to ensure
that the fiscal and overall deficit remain at targeted levels.
Such adjustments in expenditure are usually made on the plan side - the only item of
expenditure that offers any scope for adjustments. With nearly 90 per cent of non-
plan expenditure being accounted for by interest payments, subsidies and
administrative expenditure and the political sensitivities involved in reducing
subsidies, non-plan expenditure of the Indian government is characterised by an
extraordinary degree of rigidity.
Inevitably, therefore, plan expenditures are determined as a residual after pre-
emptions have already been made for non-plan expenditure.
The presentation of the Budget for the ensuing fiscal year (beginning April 1) is
usually done on the last working day of February. Parliamentary scrutiny of proposals
and the passage of the budget does not normally get completed until the second
week of May, well after the commencement of the new fiscal year.
Since expenditures cannot be incurred in a new fiscal year without Parliamentary
approval, the government usually seeks an interim approval to meet emergent
expenditures that have to be incurred pending the approval of the budget.
Individual Activity 4:
Ensure that municipal budget and financial reporting formats support the other financial
management reforms introduced by the MFMA;
Improve the local government spheres’ ability to deliver basic services to all by –
If Councils are provided succinct and understandable financial and non-financial information
they will be better able to take informed decisions that promote effective financial
management, and that are aligned to service delivery performance.
Formalise the norms and standards governing municipal budget and financial reporting
formats, so as to improve the credibility, sustainability, transparency, accuracy, and reliability
of budgets and in-year reports of municipalities and municipal entities, provide budget format
certainty and align budget format policy to financial\ reporting policy.
The budget formats were designed to achieve the following specific aims:
In financial management reforms elsewhere “a principle result of budget reform has been the
creation of a more transparent and user-friendly budget document”
(b) Ensuring standardisation across the local government sphere by very clearly specifying
the information requirements. This will enable municipalities and their information system
suppliers to develop software and report writing formats that are unlikely to need to be
changed in future. It will also facilitate reporting on the ‘whole-of-local government’, and thus
contribute to improved ‘whole-of government’ reporting, monitoring and evaluation.
(c) Developing a standardised budget structure that municipal councils will use to approve
municipal budgets. The structure will promote long-term consistency in monitoring
performance, and will preserve comparative financial performance history even when the
organisational structure of a municipality changes. The standardised structure provides that
–
• ensure that municipalities with entities will also approve a budget on a similar basis to the
‘parent’ entity and so achieve effective financial management control and consolidation; and
• promote vote approval flexibility that can facilitate improved budget control given the
specific organisational structure of each municipality. This recognises that structures vary
significantly across municipalities within South Africa.
The advantage of using GFS standardisation is that it transcends local requirements and
local changes in organisational structure.
(d) Minimising the cost of compliance and information gathering. The format templates are
designed to assist municipalities with the development of budgets, and so minimise the cost
of complying with the Municipal Budget and Reporting Regulations.
(e) Ensuring consistency and comparability with other spheres of government. This is
achieved by –
•aligning the formats to the maximum extent possible with those prescribed for national and
provincial government, taking into consideration differences in accounting approaches.
It is anticipated that this will also facilitate credit rating agency and financial institution
understanding and assessment of municipal budgets.
Individual Activity 5:
Maintaining a budget can keep you organized, help to reduce stress and assist you with
planning for the future. However, responsible financial planning can require more than one
budget or spreadsheet. It's important to determine what formats you will need before
beginning to outline your budget and goals.
Tax Budgeting
Every year you will need to file taxes, but waiting until the last minute can cause
unnecessary stress. Consider keeping a separate tax budget. This spreadsheet format
works well for all people who work, but especially for freelancers or independent contractors
who need to track earnings. Set up a spreadsheet and take a few minutes every day to
record your earnings. At the end of the year, you will have a clear record of your taxable
income.
Zero Budgeting
Zero budgeting is a type of budget format that tracks your income and expenses. This type
of budget works well for people who have a consistent income, enabling them to track every
dollar that is going in and out of their bank account. To do this, add up all of your income and
all of your expenses, and then divide your money into categories such as rent, groceries,
electric, gas and other expenses. Sticking with the plan is key to this type of budgeting. One
tool to keep on track is to separate categories into envelopes with cash so that you have a
visual indicator of how much money you have left to spend in each category.
Long-Term Budgeting
For future financial goals, consider a long-term planning budget. This type of spreadsheet
will help you to create long-term goals and balance your expenses to achieve those goals
within a certain time period. The spreadsheet will calculate how much you have already
saved in your account and how much you have left to save to meet your goal by a certain
date.
This type of budget format works well for young people who may not have the same types of
long-term goals as people who are saving for a house or retirement. Necessity and luxury
budgeting can teach teenagers to save for certain items such as clothes and electronics
without using a credit card. This budget format is very similar to zero-budgeting on a more
simple level.
South African municipalities are required by law to use the Integrated Development Plans
(IDP) as a basis for formulating their budgets. To form the basis of municipal resource
allocation, IDP entail the integration of municipal strategic planning and budgeting processes
and a shift from input to outcomes based budgeting. Budgeting can be seen as the process
of resourcing strategic plans within available finances, in order to give effect to policies and
ensure service delivery. Without an understanding of the strategic priorities, public resources
end up not being directed in a way that achieves maximum impact.
Due to heavy resource requirements of the IDP process, municipalities were only required to
table an interim IDP in 2000 – a process that was met with mixed success. In 2002/2003 all
municipalities were required to table their first five-year IDPs. In the sample reviewed, the
IDP and budget processes are typically not integrated, nor have IDPs had a meaningful
impact on these municipalities’ budgeting processes. This section looks at a number of
contributing factors. Some of these may well be “teething problems”, but others are probably
more structural in nature.
Therefore there is a lack of clarity around the status of the IDP and what it should include.
Many municipalities and communities do not view the IDP as a prioritisation process and use
the IDP to produce “wish lists”. Councillors have been reportedly changed IDP plans after
IDP adoption without any adjustment to municipal budgets. Up until 2002, transfers to
municipalities from other spheres of government tended to be gazetted too late to inform
municipal planning processes. Whether the indicative allocations for transfers given for outer
years of the MTEF provided in the 2002 Division of Revenue Act are accurate enough to
allow for more informed budget planning remains to be seen.
Municipal staff lacks necessary financial, project management and business planning skills
for the development of suitable project proposals and business plans that would result in
quicker disbursements from National and Provincial departments.
Up until November 2002 the assignment of powers and functions of core municipal services
to districts and locals has been unclear. This affected the willingness of municipalities to
allocate resources to these services, meaning that sectoral plans with accompanying
financial plans have not been developed.
There are alarming information voids in municipalities which range from a lack of information
on communities to costs of service provision. Municipalities are unable to model the
implications of varying tariff and rates levels on total revenue or realistically forecast the
financial implications (both capital and operational) of service expansion projects identified in
IDPs.
Municipalities are typically not collecting all revenue due from communities. The causes of
this are economic, structural and, in some instances, political. Predictions of future revenue
streams are thus not credible, undermining any existing linkage between IDPs and budgets.
Furthermore, municipalities are hard pressed to accumulate surpluses that could be used to
finance capital projects that often more a key component of IDPs.
As many of the problems mentioned above are interlinked, a holistic approach to developing
a set of solutions is required. The problems mentioned above could, however, be seen in the
context of four themes - information, capacity, process and structure.
The following sources of information are necessary to provide a means by which planning
and budgeting could be better integrated:
collection rates. This would allow for easy tariff and rates modelling and an
understanding of affordability levels
Detailed cost information on services and service expansions to provide
credible financial plans.
Corporate level systems producing information in formats understandable to
all departments.
Project design and specification skills leading better proposals and business
plans would allow IDP role-players a better understanding the financial
commitments, potential revenue sources and time spans involved in the
project.
Municipal officials and councillors need to understand the process of
specifying objectives, outputs and outcomes in specific terms to aid current
budget reform processes.
All role-players need view IDPs as a political process involving prioritising
activities so that remain within the resource constraints faced by
municipalities and not merely as a formality.
Capacity in conflict resolution and negotiation would aid municipal officials,
politicians and communities to compromise where there are differences in
priorities.
The separation of the IDP and budget processes could be identified as the principle cause of
IDPs not impacting budgets. The following recommendations can be made in this regard:
The IDP must be seen as the basis on which the budget is formed and
adjustments to the budget must be consistent with the IDP.
The budget and IDP timetables within the municipality must be aligned to
ensure that the processes occur simultaneously and are integrated
To conflict, the measurable performance objectives required by both the
Municipal Finance Management Bill and the Municipal Systems Act should
coincide in the IDP and the budget.
Since upper-level management often circumvents the budgeting process, the first thing to do
in budgeting is to find out what does management expect from the budgeting process ?
Next, make sure management decision making is linked to the budgets. You can accomplish
this by creating budgets within the strategic planning process. Don't forget to include
external factors when preparing budgets. Outside events and issues can impact your budget
estimates.
Budgets should be easy to revise. When new planning data pops up, your budgeting
process should adopt and accept this new data. Hold you're cost centers responsible for
meeting their budgets. This can force feedback from end-users for improvements in the
budgeting process. If you find yourself always revising a budget, consider preparing several
budgets or setup a contingency budget if you expect changes. Prepare the basic outline or
summary of a budget and get approval before you spend lots of time preparing detail
budgets. Or better yet, try to reduce the detail in your budgets to streamline the entire
process.
Budgeting should be a dynamic process within strategic planning. The more your budgets
can react to change, the closer budgeting will be to a value-added activity. If your budgets
don't add value to decision making, than it's time to improve the process.
Individual Activity 6:
In any of the described approaches to budgeting, the key point is that the budget is a
management tool to assess whether the business is on track, or adjustments are required.
Budgets should take account of market conditions such as margin pressure, macroeconomic
factors such as changing tax legislation, as well as internal factors such as resource
allocation.
Incremental Budgeting
In Incremental Budgeting last year’s budget is used as a starting point for the new budget,
and a number of increases are ‘pre-programmed’. These include inflationary increases,
salary increases, and overall market growth increases.
Usefulness
An inherent assumption that the current methodology and cost structure is the best
way, and should be built upon
It encourages people to have expectations of inflationary increases in salary and
business, for doing the same role in a changing market
It assumes that existing customers will grow in line with market growth, without
accurately reflecting the incremental costs of winning new customers
It encourages departments to spend all of their allocated budget to ensure that there
is an increase next year
In ZBB the budget for any activity at the start of each year is set at zero. All expenditure
must be justified on a cost/benefit basis, including justification of continuing existence.
Usefulness
ZBB introduces an environment where only the projects that deliver the best cost/benefit to
the organisation will succeed. This tends to focus all company resources on agreed goals
and objectives, since by inference, successful delivery of a justified project will deliver
cost/benefit. ZBB also gives managers a better understanding of the other parts of the
organisation, and the priorities of the company, as they can see relative project priorities. In
principle, ZBB leads to the most efficient allocation of resources, as they have to be justified
and deployed to the most important projects on a cost/benefit basis.
There is a tendency to assume that since the budget approves all spending, that all
business decisions will somehow lie within the ‘Oracle of the budget’
In BB, Phase 1 of the budget is designed with ‘just enough’ resources to run the organisation
as a going concern. Any incremental spending above this level must be justified on a
cost/benefit basis.
Usefulness
BB is less resource intensive than ZBB, but once again has some limitations, including:
BB does nothing to promote better productivity in the ‘Just Enough’ resource space.
For example, if the warehouse is always included, and alternatives such as
outsourcing are not considered, what incentive is there to drive costs down in the
warehouse?
In ABB, the budget recognises that it is activities which generate cost in a business, and the
desire is to control these cost drivers. For each identifiable activity, the cost of a unit is
measured, the demand is measured, a budgeted cost is set for each unit of activity, and the
budget is designed around activity terms (e.g. Laptop Z3200 Product Build) rather than the
traditional functional areas (e.g. Manufacturing).
Usefulness
ABB means that costs can be assigned to activity and product level, rather than averaged
out across a number of products or services. This means that real cost behaviour and cost
drivers can be analysed, leading to better cost focus and more targeted customer pricing.
ABB requires a large effort to measure and analyse activities, and assumes a causal, linear
relationship between activity and overheads. This may be erroneous, as multiple factors may
drive the costs, including the sharing of costs over activities, and the method of allocating
fixed and variable costs.
Kaizen Budgeting
Usefulness
Individual Activity 7:
Any budget that is prepared for a 12-month period. An annual budget outlines both the
income and expenditures that are expected to be received and paid over the coming year.
Annual budgets are used by individuals, corporations, governments and various other types
of organizations.
It seems to be the least sexy part of running a business, but maintaining a realistic budget -
and paying attention to it - can make or break your company.
An operating budget is a prediction of all expected revenues and expenses over a 12-month
period. It projects your gross and net sales, along with your net profits or losses.
On the expense side, it includes both one-time expenditures such as equipment purchases
and ongoing costs such as rent.
Rent
Insurance
Personnel, including payroll taxes
Costs of purchasing or producing your product
Sales and marketing
Phone, Internet, and utilities
Repairs and maintenance
Outside services (accounting, legal etc.)
An operating budget allows you to try out different assumptions in advance for variables like
pricing and staffing, so you can take your best shot at making a healthy profit.
Novice business owners sometimes neglect the second kind of budget: a cash-flow budget.
But in fact, it is problems with cash flow rather than profitability that cause many new
businesses to fail.
Positive cash flow means you have enough money on hand to pay your bills at any given
point in the year. A business can be profitable but still have cash-flow problems if, for
instance, it has to shell out money in advance for inventory but doesn't receive payment from
buyers until months later.
"You can operate at a loss for a while – a lot of small businesses do when they start out –
but you can't operate with a negative cash flow," Long says.
To create a cash-flow budget, start with the assumptions about income and expenses that
you developed for your operating budget. Then figure out, month by month, when you can
expect to receive payments and when you'll have to pay bills.
"You may bill clients this month but not collect from them for 60 or 90 days," says Suiter. "If
you can see beforehand that you'll be short of cash, you can arrange to get a line of credit,
or borrow money, or pay (bills) out of your personal reserve."
Ongoing businesses can use the prior year's financial data as a starting point in setting next
year's budget. But start-ups don't have this advantage. They've got to come up with all their
budget numbers from scratch. Some questions you should ask yourself include: How much
should we charge for your product or service? How many units of it will we be able to sell in
our first year? How much will we need to spend on inventory or production? How many
employees will we need, and what will they cost when we add in payroll taxes, workers'
comp insurance, and benefits?
Talk to owners of similar ventures that are not your direct competitors. Look at aggregate
industry data: You can find free financial benchmarks for a number of industries at Biz Stats,
or at some other sites mentioned by Long in her blog.
Individual Activity 8:
a) Budget:
A formal statement of the financial resources set aside for carrying out specific activities in
a given period of time.
b) Budgetary control:
Any differences (variances) are made the responsibility of key individuals who can either
exercise control action or revise the original budgets.
A responsibility centre can be defined as any functional unit headed by a manager who is
responsible for the activities of that unit.
a) Revenue centres
Organisational units in which outputs are measured in monetary terms but are not directly
compared to input costs.
b) Expense centres
Units where inputs are measured in monetary terms but outputs are not.
c) Profit centres
d) Investment centres
Where outputs are compared with the assets employed in producing them, i.e. ROI.
Compels management to think about the future, which is probably the most important
feature of a budgetary planning and control system. Forces management to look
ahead, to set out detailed plans for achieving the targets for each department,
operation and (ideally) each manager, to anticipate and give the organisation
purpose and direction.
Promotes coordination and communication.
Problems in budgeting
Whilst budgets may be an essential part of any marketing activity they do have a
number of disadvantages, particularly in perception terms.
Budgets can be seen as pressure devices imposed by management, thus resulting
in:
b) Inaccurate record-keeping.
Waste may arise as managers adopt the view, "we had better spend it or we will lose
it". This is often coupled with "empire building" in order to enhance the prestige of a
department.
Responsibility versus controlling, i.e. some costs are under the influence of more than one
person, e.g. power costs.
Managers may overestimate costs so that they will not be blamed in the future should
they overspend.
Characteristics of a budget
Analysis of costs and revenues: this can be done on the basis of product lines,
departments or cost centres.
In organising and administering a budget system the following characteristics may apply:
a) Budget centres: Units responsible for the preparation of budgets. A budget centre may
encompass several cost centres.
b) Budget committee: This may consist of senior members of the organisation, e.g.
departmental heads and executives (with the managing director as chairman). Every part of
the organisation should be represented on the committee, so there should be a
representative from sales, production, marketing and so on. Functions of the budget
committee include:
liaising between the budget committee and managers responsible for budget
preparation
dealing with budgetary control problems
Individual Activity 9:
a) The municipal council’s vision for the long term development of the municipality with
special emphasis on the municipality’s most critical development and internal
transformation needs;
b) An assessment of the existing level of development in the municipality, which must
include an identification of communities which do not have access to basic municipal
services;
c) The council’s development priorities and objectives for its elected term, including its
local economic development aims and its internal transformation needs;
d) The council’s development strategies which must be aligned with any national and
provincial sectoral plans and planning requirements binding on the municipality in
terms of legislation;
h) A financial plan, which must include a budget projection for at least the next three
years; and
1) Each district municipality, within a prescribed period after the start of its elected terms and
after following a consultative process with the local municipalities within its area, must adopt
a framework for integrated development planning in the area as a whole;
2) A framework referred to in subsection (1) binds both the district municipality and the local
municipalities in the area of the district municipalities;
3) The framework must ensure proper consultation, co-ordination and alignment of the IDP
Process of the district municipality and the various local municipalities.
In terms of the Municipal Systems Act, municipalities are required to prepare organisational
performance management system that must be linked to the IDP. Tremendous progress has
been made with the process of aligning the IDP, Budget and Performance Management
System (PMS). Every endeavor is made in the 2010-11 financial year to link and integrated
these three processes to an even greater extent through the Process Plan. It should
however, be noted that the PMS on its own requires an in-depth process comparable to that
of the IDP. Such PMS is tightly linked and guided by the IDP and Budget processes.
The IDP, performance management systems (PMS) and budget are all components of one
overall development planning and management system. The IDP sets out what the
municipality aims to accomplish, how it will do this. The PMS enables the municipality to
check to what extent it is achieving its aims. The budget provides the resources that th e
municipality will use to achieve its aims. As indicated earlier, every attempt has been made
in this process plan to align the IDP and PMS formulation and/or review, and the budget
preparation process.
Have great differences in level of services between rich and poor areas
Have sprawling informal settlements and spread out residential areas that make cheap
service delivery difficult.
Rural areas were left underdeveloped and largely unserviced. The new approach to local
government has to be developmental and aims to overcome the poor planning of the past.
An Integrated Development Plan is a super plan for an area that gives an overall framework
for development. It aims to co-ordinate the work of local and other spheres of government in
a coherent plan to improve the quality of life for all the people living in an area. It should take
into account the existing conditions and problems and resources available for development.
The plan should look at economic and social development for the area as a whole. It must set
a framework for how land should be used, what infrastructure and services are needed and
how the environment should be protected
All municipalities have to produce an Integrated Development Plan (IDP). The municipality
is responsible for the co-ordination of the IDP and must draw in other stakeholders in the area
who can impact on and/or benefit from development in the area.
Once the IDP is drawn up all municipal planning and projects should happen in terms of the
IDP. The annual council budget should be based on the IDP. Other government departments
working in the area should take the IDP into account when making their own plans.
It should take 6 to 9 months to develop an IDP. During this period service delivery and
development continues.
The IDP is reviewed every year and necessary changes can be made.
The IDP has a lifespan of 5 years that is linked directly to the term of office for local
councillors. After every local government elections, the new council has to decide on the
future of the IDP. The council can adopt the existing IDP or develop a new IDP that takes
into consideration existing plans.
The executive committee or executive mayors of the municipality have to manage the IDP.
They may assign this responsibility to the municipal manager.
In most municipalities, an IDP co-ordinator is appointed to oversee the process. The IDP co-
ordinator reports directly to the municipal manager and the executive committee or the
executive mayor.
The IDP has to be drawn up in consultation with forums and stakeholders. The final IDP
document has to be approved by the council.
There are six main reasons why a municipality should have an IDP:
The IDP will help the local municipality focus on the most important needs of local
communities taking into account the resources available at local level.
The local municipality must find the most cost-effective ways of providing services and
money will be spent on the causes of problems in local areas.
For example, a municipality may decide to allocate resources to building a canal that will
prevent homes being damaged during the flood season. This will reduce the financial burden
placed on the municipality’s emergency services.
The IDP identifies the least serviced and most impoverished areas and points to where
municipal funds should be spent. Implementation is made easier because the relevant
stakeholders have been part of the process.
The IDP provides deadlock-breaking mechanisms to ensure that projects and programmes are
efficiently implemented. The IDP helps to develop realistic project proposals based on the
availability of resources.
Government departments and private investors are willing to invest where municipalities
have clear development plans.
Strengthens democracy
Through the active participation of all the important stakeholders, decisions are made in a
democratic and transparent manner.
Municipal resources are used to integrate rural and urban areas and to extend services to the
poor.
For example: The Department of Health plans to build a clinic in an area. It has to check that
the municipality can provide services like water and sanitation for the effective functioning of
the clinic.
Municipality
Councillors
The IDP gives councillors an opportunity to make decisions based on the needs and
aspirations of their constituencies.
The IDP is based on community needs and priorities. Communities have the chance to
participate in identifying their most important needs.
The IDP process encourages all stakeholders who reside and conduct business within a
municipal area to participate in the preparation and implementation of the development plan.
Many government services are delivered by provincial and national government departments
at local level -for example: police stations, clinics and schools. Municipalities must take into
account the programmes and policies of these departments. The departments should
participate in the IDP process so that they can be guided how to use their resources to address
local needs.
Before starting the planning process, an IDP Process Plan must be drawn up. This plan is
meant to ensure the proper management of the planning process.
At District Council level, a framework will be developed in consultation with all local
municipalities within the district. This framework will ensure co-ordination, consultation and
alignment between the district council and local municipalities. The framework will guide the
development of the IDP Process Plan for each local municipality.
PHASE 1 ANALYSIS
During this phase information is collected on the existing conditions within the municipality.
It focuses on the types of problems faced by people in the area and the causes of these
problems.
The identified problems are assessed and prioritised in terms of what is urgent and what
needs to be done first.
PHASE 2: STRATEGIES
During this phase, the municipality works on finding solutions to the problems assessed in
phase one.
This entails:
Developing a vision -
The vision is a statement of the ideal situation the municipality would like to achieve in the
long term once it has addressed the problems outlined in phase one. The following is an
example of a vision statement:
An economically vibrant city with citizens living in a secure, healthy and comfortable
environment
Development objectives are clear statements of what the municipality would like to achieve
in the medium term to deal with the problems outlined in phase one.
For example: Provide access to clean water for all residents living in the informal settlement
Development strategies
Once the municipality has worked out where it wants to go and what it needs to do to get
there, it needs to work out how to get there. A development strategy is about finding the best
way for the municipality to meet a development objective.
For example: Co-operate with the Department of Water Affairs to provide one water stand
pipe for every 20 households.
Project Identification
Once the municipality has identified the best methods to achieving its development objectives
it leads to the identification of specific projects.
PHASE 3: PROJECTS
During this phase the municipality works on the design and content of projects identified
during Phase 2.
Clear details for each project has to be worked out in terms of:
Clear targets must be set and indicators worked out to measure performance as well as the
impact of individual projects.
PHASE 4: INTEGRATION
Once all projects have been identified, the municipality has to check again that they
contribute to meeting the objectives outlined in Phase 2. These projects will provide an
overall picture of the development plans.
All the development plans must now be integrated. The municipality should also have overall
strategies for issues like dealing with AIDS, poverty alleviation and disaster management.
PHASE 5: APPROVAL
The IDP is presented to the council for consideration and adoption. The Council may adopt a
draft for public comment before approving a finalised IDP.
The DPLG proposes that an IDP Representative Forum be established to encourage the
participation of communities and other stakeholders.
Traditional leaders
Heads of departments and senior officials from municipal and government department
People who fight for the rights of unorganised groups – e.g. A gender activist
A code of conduct should be drawn up for these forums that provides details on:
The Council should also approve a strategy for public participation. The strategy must decide,
amongst other things, on:
The framework of Chapter 6 of the Local Municipal Systems Act requires municipalities to
develop performance monitoring systems that are intended as strategic management tools
to enable municipalities to :
Integrated Development Plans are regarded by government as the primary tool to re-
orientate local authorities to be more “ developmental”, customer-focused and effective in
meeting basic needs. The IDP process has :
Set appropriate performance indicators, including outcomes and impact, with regard
to the municipality’s development priorities and objectives set out in the IDP
Set measurable targets
Monitor performance
Measure and review performance at least once a year
Aim to improve performance
Establish a process of regular reporting.
(a) comply with al the requirements set out in the Municipal systems Act ;
(b) demonstrate how it is to operate and be managed from the planning stage up to the
stages of performance review and reporting ;
(c) clarify the roles and responsibilities of each role player, including the local community, in
the functioning of the system ;
(d) clarify the processes of implementing the system within the framework of the integrated
development planning process ;
e) determine the frequency of reporting and the lines of accountability for performance ;
The Integrated development Plan (IDP) is a strategic document that clearly outlines the city’s
development objectives and provides a policy framework that guides management in
decision making related to budgeting and planning of the city.
In terms of the eThekwini Municipality we have an eight-point plan within the IDP that is
outcomes based :-
In compliance with the Municipal Structures Act and MFMA the city’s budget must be
informed by and aligned to the IDP objectives
The budgetary allocations for both capital and operating expenditure needs to be undertaken
in a manner that will not only ensure that the IDP outcomes are achieved but also leads to
the city’s vision being realised
It is a process not an event and requires continuous improvement to the budget and IDP
processes to ensure a seamless process eventually
However, we can commence with alignment on operating side and ensure that the key
priorities of the IDP are given a bigger slice in terms of new spending
• Commitments
• Approve budget Principles (capital and operating), which provide guidance on how
allocations are made and budgets are spent. Principles are drawn from intent of IDP.
• Key projects prioritised as identified in the IDP and allocated budgets (if not
previously budgeted as part of MTEF)
• inalisation of budget process
• Review and prioritise all requests
• Finalise impact of tariff inceases
• Approval by Council
• Feedback/presentation to business, community based organisations and wards
• Prepare SDBIP
• Quarterly monitoring
The MFMA requires municipalities to prepare a service delivery and budget implementation
plan as a strategic financial management tool to ensure that budgetary decisions that are
adopted by municipalities are aligned with the IDP strategy
The SDBIP serves to provide an implementation plan that covers all functional areas of the
municipality and focuses on actual implementation and delivery with mechanisms for regular
review
The primary objective of the SDBIP is to strengthen local accountability and governance
and improve capital, as well as operational, planning, spending and service delivery
To avoid issues related to budgets being underspent and not achieving the programme’s
desired outcomes an outline of quarterly projections of service delivery targets and
performance indicators are also included.
There are many ways to approach budgeting for governments such as cities, towns,
counties, states, and the federal government. Several of the most common approaches to
budgeting for municipalities will be discussed and analyzed in the following paragraphs. The
primary emphasis in this paper is on cities, rather than county, state or federal units.
Performance-Based
Another budgeting approach, which is based on allocating resources (via budgets) to desired
levels of support for government programs or services, is called performance budgeting, or
performance-based budgeting. Rivenbark & Kelly (2006, p. 36) state that "Performance
budgeting occurs when performance results are used to inform decisions during budget
preparation and adoption." Or, performance budgeting may attempt to identify desired levels
of specific outcomes and then allocate funds to the program or service based on a per unit
cost allocation (Franklin & Carberry-George, 1999). Performance measures may be used to
inform budget decisions and allocation of funds when the budget request is new or
significantly expanded from prior periods (Rivenbark & Kelly, 2006).
Hybrid Approach
And some municipalities may collect performance measures without adopting a formal
performance measurement system; for example, public safety departments usually monitor
call volumes and/or response times, but may not directly tie those measures to the budget
process (Rivenbark & Kelly, 2006).
The budgeting process is the essential first phase of a municipality’s financial management
cycle. This includes a variety of related activities and programs that, if carried out with care
and diligence, will produce a valuable planning tool for the municipality to use as a guide in
the management and operation of the municipality. “Municipal budgets are developed to
cover a three-year budget period, which forms the medium term planning framework. Budget
tables will show figures for the actual fiscal year, plus for the following two years.
The value of the medium-term planning framework for budgeting is that it:
The following are some of the advantages of developing and using a realistic budget:
b) Allows regular comparisons of estimated costs to actual costs during a given fiscal or
financial period. Knowing where the Council is in terms of its financial picture is important.
c) Budgeting must also be done in order to establish the tax rates for a municipality
e) Budgeting provides a vehicle for communicating the plans and activities of Council to the
general public, the provincial government or to other agencies.
Control
Control sets limits for employees; permit top management to identify deviation from plans
and individual commitments.
Motivation
Evaluation
Another benefit of budgeting is that it provides an objective basis for rating performance.
From the perspective of the municipal government, the idea of participatory budgeting does
have the potential to allow the local government to draw upon the collective experience of
businesspeople as well as others within the community. That experience can sometimes
provide additional insight into the benefits of key services or projects that help to increase
the standard of living and the appeal of the municipality to others who may be looking for a
home. While this approach can be somewhat more cumbersome than the creation and
management of a budget by a few appointed or elected officials, participatory budgeting can
also make the process of financial management of the city’s assets much easier over the
long run.
While processes for participatory budgeting may vary slightly, depending on the size of the
municipality or community involved, most approaches will involve a few basic steps. This
begins with citizens and officials identifying priorities for inclusion within the budget, creating
delegate committees to assist in the planning, working with officials to develop proposals
that are presented to the city at large, based on the style of government involved, and finally
a public vote on the allocations within the budget. Since this approach allows citizens from
all economic classes and backgrounds to participate, the outcome usually has a greater
share of support in the wider community than would be possible using other methods.
In budgeting, cities may use “Base Budget Additions,” where money is added every year to
each category rather than using the Zero Based Budgeting approach in which every program
and expenditure has to be justified each year. This could lead to unnecessary expenditures.
Another potential pitfall is that individual city departments may not be well-trained in the
budgeting process. They might not approach the process analytically, which often leads to
irrational requests for expense line items. They may look at the total dollar and not the
underlying components of expenses. Usually they look at previous numbers and build on
them without justifying future expenses. They are either not fully cognizant or intentionally
ignore the relevant.
Incremental budget
• Assumes activities and methods of working will continue in the same way.
• No incentive for developing new ideas.
• No incentives to reduce costs.
• Encourages spending up to the budget so that the budget is maintained next year.
• The budget may become out of date and no longer relate to the level of activity or
type of work being carried out.
• The priority for resources may have changed since the budgets were set originally.
• There may be budgetary slack built into the budget, which is never reviewed-
managers might have overestimated their requirements in the past in order to obtain
a budget which is easier to work to, and which will allow them to achieve favourable
results.
Capital budgeting involves the financial planning needed for companies to expand and grow.
This type of planning enables companies to leverage existing and future cash flows while
reaping the best possible profits. As one of many methods of capital budgeting, the payback
approach helps companies identify rates of return on an investment or project. The strengths
and weaknesses of the payback approach can vary depending on the types of projects
under consideration.
Capital Budgeting
Companies considering expansion projects, research and development plans or new product
line offerings use capital budgeting as a way to compare the costs and benefits of different
project options. Companies invest large amounts of cash for long periods of time, so project
selection becomes a priority. Different capital budgeting methods use different criteria for
determining the strengths and weaknesses of each project. One company may wish to know
each project's profit earnings capacity while another focuses on each project's overall costs
versus revenues. Companies concerned with recouping the monies invested in a project
may opt to use the payback period approach in their capital budgeting process.
With any project investment, companies attempt to maximize their return on investment in
one way or another. For some companies, recouping their initial cost in as short a time as
possible provides the maximizing effect needed. The payback period approach enables a
company to calculate the length of time it will take before a project generates as much
money as it costs. When comparing two or more project options, the length of time it takes
each project to pay for itself becomes the determining factor in project selection when
companies use the payback period approach. In other words, the faster a project can recoup
its initial investment cost the more likely a company will consider investing in it.
Strengths
The payback approach may offer advantages in cases where a company has certain time
requirements in terms of how long a project will take to pay for itself. Because of its focus on
cost returns, companies can use the payback approach as an initial screening tool when
comparing two or more project options. Knowing how long an investment will take to pay for
itself also comes in handy in cases where project investments tie up large amounts of money
for long time periods. For companies just starting, a need for cash flow may require a project
to generate a fast return on investment. The payback approach helps identify which projects
offer the quickest payback period.
Weaknesses
The one bill deals with the approval of unauthorised expenditure while the other facilitates
the transfer of money to the South African National Roads Agency Limited (SANRAL) to
assist with the e-tolls debt.
The Finance Act focuses on the approval of unauthorised expenditure for the defence and
military veterans departments as well as correctional services.
In the first two schedules, amounts of approximately R40 million and R21 million are
authorised for the defence and military veterans departments.
In the third schedule, a total of approximately R484 million was authorised for the
correctional services department.
According to the act, the expenditure must be charged against the budget allocations of the
correctional services department over the next three years.
The Additional Adjustments Appropriation Act allows for national treasury to provide R5.75
billion to SANRAL to help pay for the Gauteng Freeway Improvement Project (GFIP).
On budget day this year, the finance minister, Pravin Gordhan, announced that the capital
injection had been approved. The money was to be made available in the current financial
year.
SANRAL had incurred a debt of R20 billion for GFIP during the construction phase.
The budget cycle can be divided into three distinct phases that are generally sequential and
yet intertwined. The first phase, which culminates in the transmittal of the President's budget
proposals to the Congress, is called the budget formulation phase. In the next phase, the
Congress acts upon laws that together constitute the enacted budget. Once the laws have
been enacted, executive agencies carry out the laws in the budget execution phase. The
budget cycle is governed mainly by the following laws, which we describe below:
Before enactment of this law in 1921, there was no annual centralized budgeting in the
Executive Branch. Government agencies usually sent budget requests independently to
congressional committees with no coordination of the various requests in formulating the
Government's budget. The Budget and Accounting Act required the President to coordinate
the budget requests for all Government agencies and to send a comprehensive budget to
the Congress. It created the Bureau of the Budget, now the Office of Management and
Budget (OMB), to help the President implement these requirements. It also required the
President to include certain information in the budget. These are some of the requirements:
• "On or after the first Monday in January but not later than the first Monday in
February of each year, the President shall submit a budget of the Government for the
following fiscal year."
• "Each budget shall include a budget message and summary and supporting
information. The President shall include in each budget the following...." The
provision goes on to list about thirty items, such as expenditures and receipts for the
past year through the fourth year following the budget year, information on debt,
financial information, and information on employment levels.
Resources:
Read more:http://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/annual-
budget.asp#ixzz1wHe0l4M9
Self Assessment
Self Assessment:
You have come to the end of this module – please take the time to review
what you have learnt to date, and conduct a self assessment against the
learning outcomes of this module by following the instructions below:
Keys: - no understanding
- Some idea
- Completely comfortable
SELF
RATING
NO OUTCOME
1.
Demonstrate an awareness of the role of a budget in the municipal
context.
2.
Differentiate between formats of budgets used in a municipality.
3.
Evaluate a municipal budgeting system.
4.
Contribute to preparing a municipal budget that reflects an
integrated development plan.
5.
Differentiate between approaches to preparing a municipal budget.
Learner Tip:
Please complete the Evaluation Form as thoroughly as you are able to, in
order for us to continuously improve our training quality!
Your honest and detailed input is therefore of great value to us, and we
appreciate your assistance in completing this evaluation form!
Sufficient
Excellent
Standard
Above
Poor
No Criteria / Question
Above Standard
Below Standard
Sufficient
Excellent
Poor
B Facilitator Evaluation
1 The Facilitator was prepared and knowledgeable on the
subject of the programme
2 The Facilitator encouraged learner participation and input
3 The Facilitator made use of a variety of methods,
exercises, activities and discussions
4 The Facilitator used the material in a structured and
effective manner
5 The Facilitator was understandable, approachable and
respectful of the learners
6 The Facilitator was punctual and kept to the schedule
Additional Comments on Facilitation
Excellent
Standard
Standard
Above
Below
Poor
1 2 3 4 5
C Learning Programme Evaluation
1 The learning outcomes of the programme are
relevant and suitable.
2 The content of the programme was relevant
and suitable for the target group.
3 The length of the facilitation was suitable for
the programme.
4 The learning material assisted in learning new
knowledge and skills to apply in a practical
manner.
5 The Learning Material was free from spelling
and grammar errors
6 Handouts and Exercises are clear, concise
and relevant to the outcomes and content.
7 Learning material is generally of a high
standard, and user friendly
Additional Comments on Learning Programme
D Assessment Evaluation
No Criteria / Question
Above Standard
Below Standard
Sufficient
Excellent
Poor
1 2 3 4 5
1 A clear overview provided of the assessment
requirements of the programme was provided
2 The assessment process and time lines were clearly
explained
3 All assessment activities and activities were discussed
Additional Comments on Assessment