Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Under this term are included a group of conditions that share in common
one sonographic findings: the impression that the fourth ventricle
communicates with the cisterna magna. These conditions include: Dandy-
Walker malformation, Blake’s pouch cyst, vermian hypoplasia/agenesis.
They have a similar sonographic appearance, particularly in early
gestation, and differentiation requires a multiplanar approach.
Abstract: Under this term are included a group of conditions that share in
common one sonographic findings: the impression that the fourth ventricle
communicates with the cisterna magna. These conditions include: Dandy-
Walker malformation, Blake’s pouch cyst, vermian hypoplasia/agenesis. They
have a similar sonographic appearance, particularly in early gestation, and
differentiation requires a multiplanar apparoach. Magnetic resonance mey also
be useful. The prognosis is variable, and depends mostly upon the frequent
occurrence of associated anomalies. Blake’s pouch cyst, the most common
entity, when isolated is probably a normal variant.
Includes:
Dandy Walker malformation, vermian hypoplasia, vermian agenesis, Blake’s
pouch cyst, Joubert syndrome and related entities (vermian agenesis/hypoplasia
with ‘molar tooth’ sign)
Excludes:
Definition
Dandy-Walker malformation defines the combination of an enlarged cisterna
with superior displacement (rotation) of the cerebellar vermis.1-5 The
term Dandy-Walker complex (or continuum) indicates a spectrum of anomalies
with anatomic similarities to Dandy-Walker malformation. There is no general
consensus in the categorization of posterior fossa anomalies and the interested
reader is referred to specific works on this subjects.1-5 In this section we include
a group of anomalies that share in common one sonographic finding: the
impression that in a axial plane of the head the fourth ventricle is open
posteriorly and communicates with the cisterna magna. This finding will be
referred to in the following as the ‘open fourth ventricle’. The most frequent
anomalies that demonstrate this sign include: Blake’s pouch cyst, vermian
agenesis/hypoplasia, Dandy-Walker malformation; Joubert syndrome and
related entities (vermian agenesis/hypoplasia with ‘molar tooth’ sign) The
rational for grouping them together is that they are often difficult to differentiate
and they tend to overlap clinically.
Incidence
Dandy-Walker malformation is found in 4-12% of all cases of infantile
hydrocephalus and has an estimated prevalence of about 1:30,000 births.6-8
The incidence of the other varieties of the Dandy-Walker complex is unknown.
Pathology
Enlargement of the Blake’s pouch (or of the entire fourth ventricle in the most
severe forms) is responsible for the superior displacement of the vermis that is
encountered in the Dandy-Walker complex. The enlarged Blake’s pouch/fourth
ventricle balloons into the cisterna magna and in the most severe cases
obliterates it and distend the posterior fossa. With most techniques of
diagnostic imaging, whether prenatal or postnatal, the thin walls of the Blake’s
pouch/fourth ventricle are difficult to visualize and the impression is that of a
communication between the fourth ventricle and the cisterna magna.9, 15
The term Blake’s pouch cyst was originally introduced in infantile neuroradiology
to indicate a type of obstructive hydrocephalussecondary to failure of formation
of the foramen of Magendie and Luschka, resulting in a compressive cyst of the
posterior fossa displacing superiorly the cerebellar vermis.14, 16 More recently, the
term has become popular in fetal imaging studies to indicate cases with a
posterior fossa cyst displacing superiorly an intact cerebellar vermis, typically in
association with a normal ventricular system and a normal size of the posterior
fossa.3, 4, 10, 17 This finding has been interpreted as failed or delayed regression of
the Blake’s pouch. The entity described in the original neonatal studies and the
one later described in fetal studies are likely to be different, as the latter has
typically a normal outcome and appears to be rarely associated with
ventriculomegaly.
Joubert syndrome and related disorders are a group of conditions that share in
common hypoplasia of the cerebellar vermis in association with the
characteristic neuroradiologic 'molar tooth sign. These features are associated
with extraneural anomalies to constitute different syndromes: classical Joubert
syndrome, Coloboma, Oligophrenia/developmental delay, Ataxia, Cerebellar
vermis hypoplasia, Hepatic fibrosis (COACH), cerebello-oculo-renal syndrome
(CORS), oral-facial-digital syndrome type VI (OFD-VI), Senior–Løken syndrome.
The gene products that are affected in these group of conditions are however
known to take part into the development of the primary cilium and/or basal
body and centrosome apparatus. Essentially, Joubert and related disorders are
now considered to belong to the general group of ciliopathies.22-24
Etiology
Genetic factors have a major role in the etiology of the Dandy-Walker complex.
Dandy-Walker malformation and vermian hypoplasia/agenesis may occur as a
part of Mendelian disorders and chromosomal aberrations.25 In rare cases, the
disease is inherited as an autosomal recessive or dominant trait. Environmental
factors, including viral infections, alcohol and diabetes, have also been
suggested to play a role in the genesis of Dandy-Walker malformation, but the
evidence is uncertain.25 Joubert syndrome and related entities have a genetic
etiology with autosomal recessive or X-linled transmission. The genetics is
however complex with at least 8 genes involved.
Recurrence risk
In the absence of a recognizable syndrome, a recurrence risk of 1-5% is
suggested for Dandy-Walker malformation and vermian
hypoplasia/agenesis.25 Autosomal transmission, both dominant and recessive
has been documented. There are no available information on Blake’s pouch cyst,
and vermian agenesis/hypoplasia include probably a number of heterogeneous
entities. Joubert and related cerebellar disorders are transmitted as an
autosomal or X-linked recessive trait and have therefore a high recurrence
risk. 22-24
Associated anomalies
The Dandy-Walker complex is frequently associated with chromosomal
aberrations, syndromes and other cerebral malformations (mostly
ventriculomegaly, agenesis of the corpus callosum, holoprosencephaly,
cephaloceles), polycystic kidneys, cardiovascular defects and facial clefting. 10, 11,
21 A detailed list of condition found in association with Dandy-Walker
malformation is reported in Table 1.
Diagnosis
The landmark of the Dandy-Walker complex is the open fourth ventricle. This is
demonstrated by sweeping the transducer in the posterior fossa along the axial
plane and visualizing a fluid-filled tract seemingly connecting the cavity of the
fourth ventricle to the cisterna magna. In early gestation this is a normal finding,
as the developing cerebellar vermis has not yet completely enfolded the fourth
ventricle.26-28 It is therefore imprudent to make a diagnosis of the Dandy-
Walker complex at this gestational age, with the possible exception of those
(rare) cases in which there is an obvious cystic enlargement of the cisterna
magna or other abnormal findings. After 20 weeks the vermis has normally
‘closed’ the fourth ventricle and therefore the demonstation an opening is
indicative of the Dandy Walker complex.
The varieties of the Dandy-Walker complex have much different prognostic
implications. Differentiation may be difficult at times, and requires a systematic
approach using multiplanar examinations possibly aided by magnetic
resonance. Assessement includes evaluation of the vermis (absent, hypoplastic,
intact), and of the cisterna magna (normal, enlarged).3, 4, 10 The degree of
vermian rotation is also relevant.29 The evaluation of these findings is difficult
and involves an elements of subjectivity, but an expert examiner using either
sonography or magnetic resonance (or both) is able to make a precise diagnosis
in the majority of cases,4, 10, 13, 19 probably with the remarkable exception of
subtle vermian hypoplasia/partial agenesis.10, 13, 19
To assess the presence of the vermis the best approach is to sweep the
transducer in the posterior fossa along the axial plane. The vermis appears as
an ovalar echogenic structure interposed between the fourth ventricle and the
cisterna magna. When this is not seen and the area of the fourth ventricle is
seen to communicate with the cisterna magna at any level, vermian agenesis
can be inferred.30, 31
To assess the integrity of the vermis and the position of the torcular a median
view is required. This can be obtained directly by multiplanar imaging, scanning
preferably through the posterior fontanel as this allows better visualization of
posterior fossa and brain stem. Three dimensional ultrasound can also been
utilized.32, 33 Indeed, one of the major shortcomings in the median view is the
difficulty to obtain with absolute precision the exact plane of section and to
confuse the cerebellar hemispheres with the vermis. The advantage of three
dimensional ultrasound is to control the sections using as reference the
orthogonal planes. The use of volume contrast imaging may also facilitate
visualization of subtle anatomic details.32, 33 Once the vermis has been
identified in the median plane, both a qualitative and a quantitative evaluation
should be performed. It has been suggested that if the posterior apex (fastigium)
of the fourth ventricle and the two main fissures of the vermis can be identified,
the vermis is presumably intact.10, 19, 32-35 The secondary fissure is at times
difficult to define in early gestation and a semiquantitative approach can be
used alternatively (normally, twice as much vermis is found below than above
the primary fissure.34Measurements of the fetal cerebellar vermis have been
reported.36, 37 Most cases of defective vermis involve agenesis of the caudal
portion and therefore the vertical diameter is probably the most relevant one.
A small vermis with an abnormal configuration (absence of fastigium and/or
fissure) indicates partial agenesis. Conversely, a small vermis with a normal
configuration indicates hypoplasia.5, 10, 19, 35 In practice, the distinction
between these two entities in the fetus is difficult.
The degree of rotation of the cerebellar vermis is also relevant. It has been
recently demonstrated that the Blake’s pouch cyst has usually a rotation of less
than 30°, while a value in excess of 45° favors the diagnosis of a Dandy-Walker
malformation.29
The Blake’s pouch cyst, which is by far the most frequent variety encountered
prenatally is featured by a slight (< 30°) rotation of an intact cerebellar vermis
with a normal cisterna magna.17, 29 Vermian hypoplasia/partial agenesis is
featured by an upward displacement of a small vermis, while the cisterna magna
and torcula are normal (Figure 7).5, 13 The landmark of the Dandy-Walker
malformation is the large cisterna magna and the consequent superior
displacement of the torcular. The vermis is always significantly rotated
superiorly (>45°)29 and may be either normal or defective.35, 39 It has been
suggested that the shape of the opening of the fourth ventricle in the axial plane
is relevant for the differential diagnosis of the different varieties of the Dandy-
Walker complex.40 Also in our experience, an hourglass opening (buttock sign)
is typical of the Blake’s pouch. A triangular or square shaped opening is
indicative of either vermian hypoplasia or Dandy-Walker malformation).
Differential diagnosis
The Dandy-Walker complex should be differentiated by other cystic anomalies
of the posterior fossa. In case of megacisterna magna, the cisterna magna is
large but the cerebellum is intact and the fourth ventricle is triangular and
closed.10, 31, 34 Cerebellar hypoplasia results in ex-vacuo large cisterna magna41 but
the main feature of the condition is a global reduction in the size of an otherwise
normally shaped cerebellum.4, 10, 31 Arachnoid cysts growing in the posterior fossa
have a mass effect and cause asymmetrical distortion of the cerebellum.10, 31 The
greatest difficulty is probably encountered by posterior fossa hemorrhage that
results at times in destruction of the cerebellar vermis and enlargement of the
cisterna magna mimicking very closely a Dandy-Walker malformation or
vermian hypoplasia.10, 42 Thrombosis of the torcular Herophilii may result in
massive dilatation of the superior sagittal sinus mimicking a posterior fossa fluid
collection. A specific diagnosis is however relatively easy, considering that the
blood contained in the enlarged dural sinuses has on sonography a
corpuscolated appearance, usually with a large echogenci blood clot at the level
of the torcular, and that the fluid accumulation is found cranial to the posterior
fossa.43, 44
Prognosis
Neurosurgical series that report the combination of Dandy-Walker
malformation with hydrocephalus describe abnormal neurologic development
in 40-70% of survivors.6-8 Dandy-Walker malformation is also a part of many
genetic syndromes, with a wide spectrum of outcomes. The clinical significance
of Dandy-Wallker malformation without ventriculomegaly is debated.48 It has
been suggested that the neurologic outcome is mainly related to the
appearance of the cerebellar vermis. When this is of normal size and
morphology a normal development has been reported in 85% of cases.
Conversely, when the vermis is abnormally lobulated and/or there are
associated cerebral anomalies, the prognosis is poor.35, 39 In reality this
evaluation is difficult prior to birth.4, 10 Most of the antenatal series thus far
reported demonstrated a poor outcome in a large proportion of cases. In a
recent antenatal stuidiy about 50% of isolated cases had a normal
outcome.10 The association with other complex anomalies and/or syndrome was
the main risk factor for an abnormal outcome.10
About one third of Blake’s pouch cysts detected antenatally are associated with
other anomalies, including chromosomal aberrations (in most cases trisomy
21).10, 11When the Blake’s pouch cyst is an isolated finding and the karyotype
is normal, however, the outcome is usually good. Intrauterine remission occurs
in about 50% of cases, and a normal developmental outcome is registered in
96% of cases.10, 11 Despite small case series in the pediatric literature in which
Blake’s pouch cyst is associated with obstructive hydrocephalus this occurred
only in 1/51 cases diagnosed antenatally.10, 11 Blake’s pouch cyst does appear
to represent a risk factor for other anomalies, but when isolated is probably a
normal variant.10, 11
Most infants with Joubert syndrome and related disorders have severe
intellectual impairment and early death is common. Neurologic dysfunction
typically includes ataxia, abnormal breathing patterns (hyperpnea intermixed
with central apnea in the neonatal period) and abnormal behaviour
(temperament, hyperactivity, aggressiveness, and dependency)22-24
Obstetric management
The diagnostic workup must include a detailed search for associated anomalies
including karyotyping. Genetic consultation is reccomended. When Joubert
syndrome is suspected, a search for the specific mutations may be considered.
In counselling couples, it is stressed that with the exception of Joubert sydrome,
the Dandy-Walker complex may have a good outcome when there are no
associated anomalies. Blake’s pouch cyst, the most common abnormal finding
of the posterior fossa, is most frequently a normal variant. Serial scans are
suggested because of the potential for cerebral maldevelopment including
ventriculomegaly. With the exception of those cases associated with
hydrocephalus and macrocrania, that may require cesarean delivery, no
modification of the standard obstetric management is indicated.
References
1. Barkovich AJ, Millen KJ, Dobyns WB. A developmental and genetic classification
for midbrain-hindbrain malformations. Brain. 2009;132(Pt 12):3199-230. Epub
2009/11/26.
14. Calabro F, Arcuri T, Jinkins JR. Blake's pouch cyst: an entity within the Dandy-
Walker continuum. Neuroradiology. 2000;42(4):290-5.
19. Tilea B, Delezoide AL, Khung-Savatovski S, Guimiot F, Vuillard E, Oury JF, Garel
C. Comparison between magnetic resonance imaging and fetopathology in the
evaluation of fetal posterior fossa non-cystic abnormalities. Ultrasound Obstet
Gynecol. 2007;29(6):651-9. Epub 2007/05/04.
20. Ecker JL, Shipp TD, Bromley B, Benacerraf B. The sonographic diagnosis of
Dandy-Walker and Dandy-Walker variant: associated findings and outcomes.
Prenat Diagn. 2000;20(4):328-32.
24. Parisi MA. Clinical and molecular features of Joubert syndrome and related
disorders. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet. 2009;151C(4):326-40. Epub
2009/10/31.
25. Murray JC, Johnson JA, Bird TD. Dandy-Walker malformation: etiologic
heterogeneity and empiric recurrence risks. Clin Genet. 1985;28(4):272-83. Epub
1985/10/01.
26. Babcook CJ, Chong BW, Salamat MS, Ellis WG, Goldstein RB. Sonographic
anatomy of the developing cerebellum: normal embryology can resemble
pathology. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1996;166(2):427-33. Epub 1996/02/01.
27. Bromley B, Nadel AS, Pauker S, Estroff JA, Benacerraf BR. Closure of the
cerebellar vermis: evaluation with second trimester US. Radiology.
1994;193(3):761-3.
28. Laing FC, Frates MC, Brown DL, Benson CB, Di Salvo DN, Doubilet PM.
Sonography of the fetal posterior fossa: false appearance of mega-cisterna
magna and Dandy-Walker variant. Radiology. 1994;192(1):247-51. Epub
1994/07/01.
34. Adamsbaum C, Moutard ML, Andre C, Merzoug V, Ferey S, Quere MP, Lewin
F, Fallet-Bianco C. MRI of the fetal posterior fossa. Pediatr Radiol. 2005;35(2):124-
40.
40. Phillips JJ, Mahony BS, Siebert JR, Lalani T, Fligner CL, Kapur RP. Dandy-Walker
Malformation Complex: Correlation Between Ultrasonographic Diagnosis and
Postmortem Neuropathology. Obstet Gynecol. 2006;107(3):685-93.
41. Ghidini A, Fromberg RA, Tiernan J, Wieneke JA, Manz HJ, Sherer DM. Dilated
subarachnoid cisterna ambiens: a potential sonographic sign predicting
cerebellar hypoplasia. J Ultrasound Med. 1996;15(5):413-5. Epub 1996/05/01.
46. Mahony BS, Callen PW, Filly RA, Hoddick WK. The fetal cisterna magna.
Radiology. 1984;153(3):773-6.
49. Limperopoulos C, Robertson RL, Jr., Khwaja OS, Robson CD, Estroff JA,
Barnewolt C, Levine D, Morash D, Nemes L, Zaccagnini L, du Plessis AJ. How
accurately does current fetal imaging identify posterior fossa anomalies? AJR Am
J Roentgenol. 2008;190(6):1637-43. Epub 2008/05/22.