Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ped Chil Leucodis 2021
Ped Chil Leucodis 2021
Leukodystrophies in Children:
Diagnosis, Care, and Treatment
Joshua L. Bonkowsky, MD, PhD, FAAP,a Stephanie Keller, MD, FAAP,b AAP Section on Neurology, Council on Genetics
including genetic testing. Although there are few cures, there are Clinical reports from the American Academy of Pediatrics benefit
from expertise and resources of liaisons and internal (AAP) and
significant opportunities for care and improvements in patient well- external reviewers. However, clinical reports from the American
Academy of Pediatrics may not reflect the views of the liaisons
being. Rapid advances in imaging and diagnosis, the emergence of or the organizations or government agencies that they
and requirement for timely treatments, and the addition of represent.
leukodystrophy screening to newborn screening, make an The guidance in this report does not indicate an exclusive course
of treatment or serve as a standard of medical care. Variations,
understanding of the leukodystrophies necessary for pediatricians taking into account individual circumstances, may be appropriate.
and other care providers for children. All clinical reports from the American Academy of Pediatrics
automatically expire 5 years after publication unless reaffirmed,
revised, or retired at or before that time.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2021-053126
INTRODUCTION Address correspondence to Joshua L. Bonkowsky, MD, PhD. E-mail:
joshua.bonkowsky@hsc.utah.edu
Inherited leukodystrophies are a group of genetically diverse diseases
PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275).
with more than 30% mortality by 8 years of age. Leukodystrophies,
Copyright © 2021 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
which are attributable to abnormalities of the brain myelin (white
FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: Other than the potential conflicts of
matter), are individually rare but collectively common, with a published interest listed below, the authors have indicated they have no
incidence of 1 in 4700 live births.1–4 Leukodystrophies can present at financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
any age from preterm infants and neonates to late adulthood5,6 and FUNDING: Supported by the Bray Chair in Child Neurology Research
have been reported across all ethnicities and regions of the world.7–13 and the Brain and Spine Center of Primary Children’s Hospital.
PEDIATRICS Volume 148, number 3, September 2021:e2021053126 FROM THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
Downloaded from http://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-pdf/148/3/e2021053126/1194309/peds_2021053126.pdf
by guest
Today, definitive cures exist only for and families as they navigate disease, X-ALD, and metachromatic
a few leukodystrophies. However, between different subspecialists for leukodystrophy (MLD). Better-
there is tremendous excitement for treatments, provide long-term known hypomyelinating
patients, providers, and families follow-up after therapies such as leukodystrophies include Pelizaeus-
because of a multitude of clinical hematopoietic stem cell transplant Merzbacher disease (PMD), RNA
trials and genetic therapies that are (HSCT), and counsel families who polymerase III–related
being pursued and rapidly becoming have an affected child or an affected leukodystrophies/4-H syndrome
available.18 In addition, a crucial relative. These roles for the (hypomyelination, hypogonadotropic
point is that all leukodystrophies are pediatrician are new and hypogonadism, and hypodontia),
treatable. Improved general care transforming rapidly and often have and hypomyelination with atrophy
and quality of life for patients and not been addressed in residency of the basal ganglia and cerebellum.
their families is recognized as a training. A single disease can fall into more
central goal of treatment. An than one category, even in the same
analogous dramatic example is that This clinical report from the AAP on individual. Also, this categorization
of cystic fibrosis, for which average leukodystrophies will help guide theme is based mostly on the
life expectancy has increased from policy management for NBS, appearance of the leukodystrophy
30 days to 30 years even in the approaches to diagnosis, timing and by using MRI, which can be
absence of a genetic cure.18,19 These choice of treatment, and supportive subjective.
gains in longevity were largely therapies. Leukodystrophies,
derived from incremental formerly considered a rare There is disagreement over the
improvements in the approach to neurologic disorder that would not exact definition of a leukodystrophy
routine care (eg, aggressive be seen by a general pediatrician, and whether certain conditions meet
physiotherapy, antibiotics), and are relatively common as a group of required criteria.2,3 Further
applying standard preventive health disorders. Therefore, familiarity complicating this lack of consensus
maintenance has the potential to with the general principles for are differences in the severity of the
improve overall health.20 diagnosis and supportive disease. For example, the exact same
management in leukodystrophies is genetic mutation of ABCD1 (the gene
Because of the potential for important for all pediatricians. The responsible for X-ALD) in twin
treatment when recognized early, primary take-home message is that brothers can lead to rapid cerebral
the US Health and Human Services recognizing and diagnosing a demyelination in childhood or to a
Advisory Committee on Heritable leukodystrophy is important, slow and chronic effect mostly of
Disorders in Newborns and Children because some leukodystrophies the peripheral nerves. Finally, next-
(ACHDNC) Recommended Uniform require urgent treatment. generation sequencing techniques
Screening Panel (RUSP) now are revealing complex genotype-
recommends universal newborn phenotype disease relationships of
CATEGORIES AND DISEASES
screening (NBS) for X-linked leukodystrophy genes, which were
adrenoleukodystrophy (X-ALD).21 What is a leukodystrophy? Broadly unsuspected and unknown 5 years
New York, Connecticut, speaking, it is any genetic disease ago.
Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and affecting the myelin of the central
California now include some nervous system (CNS). Table 1 One standard for definition of
leukodystrophies in their NBS presents a list of commonly used leukodystrophies was published in
panels, and more than 15 states terms, definitions, and abbreviations 2015 based on the consensus
added testing for X-ALD in their used in leukodystrophies. opinion of a panel of inherited white
panels in 2019 and 2020.22 Leukodystrophies fall into broad matter disease experts.23 The group
Additional states are in the categories: (1) hypomyelination, in classified 30 diseases as
evaluation process for consideration which there is absent or diminished leukodystrophies, defined as
to add X-ALD and/or Krabbe disease myelin production; (2) heritable disorders affecting the
to their NBS panels. dysmyelination, in which there is white matter of the CNS with or
abnormal myelin development; or without peripheral nervous system
The general pediatrician plays an (3) demyelination, in which there is involvement.23 This does not include
important role for children with loss and/or destruction of acquired CNS myelin disorders, such
leukodystrophies. The pediatrician previously established myelin. as multiple sclerosis, and related
may need to assist with prompt and Demyelinating leukodystrophies acquired CNS demyelinating
appropriate referral for NBS results, tend to be the more well-known processes. Inborn errors of
provide a medical home for patients leukodystrophies, including Krabbe metabolism, in which the clinical
include (1) substantial cost (up to Sequencing is as cost-effective as a patient having decision-making
$15 000 to $20 000), although these brain MRI and, with improved data capacity, could affect health
numbers are rapidly decreasing; (2) analysis, will become as rapid. insurance coverage, or could reveal
potential for identifying However, even after in-depth unexpected issues such as
unanticipated disease variants biochemical and genetic testing, a consanguinity or unexpected
unrelated to the test indication; (3) portion (around 25% to 40%) of parentage.40
potential false-negative results leukodystrophy cases can remain
because of imperfect exome undiagnosed. NBS
coverage; and (4) methodologic
There are important current NBS for selected leukodystrophies is
limitations in the interpretation
limitations to use of next-generation being developed in several
phase if a clear disease-associated
sequencing approaches. There are states.44,49 X-ALD NBS has been
variant is not identified. This fourth
unanswered questions about the added to the US Health and Human
problem is significant because of
disconnect between the underlying Services RUSP. X-ALD is the only
the large number of deleterious
gene or biochemical defect, as in X- leukodystrophy included (at the
gene variants in all humans that
ALD or Krabbe disease, and actually time of this publication) on the
could plausibly be related to a
developing the disease.44,45 RUSP. X-ALD is gradually being
phenotype (especially in the CNS),
which could yield false-positive Additionally, WES does have caveats added to state NBS panels, including
associations. for diagnosis, including copy (at the time of this publication) 18
number variation mutations, states, Puerto Rico, and the District
WES continues to become more mitochondrial genome mutations, of Columbia.22,50,51 There are a
accessible and may become the and insufficient coverage of some variety of resources for management
method of choice for the diagnosis exons to reliably call heterozygous of results, and a flow diagram of
of leukodystrophies, because it can variants. WGS is also becoming management for X-ALD (from the
avoid the diagnostic odyssey faced clinically available. It provides California Department of Public
by many patients.42,43 Researchers nearly complete information of DNA Health) is provided in Fig 2.
in a recent study used WES on a sequences but until recently has
cohort of 71 patients with only been available in research Krabbe disease has been included in
persistently unresolved white studies. Some recent work suggests NBS on the basis of legislative
matter abnormalities with a that WGS may be useful as a first- mandate in 7 states; Krabbe
suspected diagnosis of line diagnosis tool.46 However, screening was not recommended by
leukodystrophy or genetic unresolved ethical questions the ACHDNC.44,49 Addition of
leukoencephalopathy. Diagnostic surround the implementation of conditions outside the ACHDNC
pathogenic variants were WGS as a screening or general process, such as occurred for
identified in 35% (25 of 71) of diagnostic tool.47,48 These ethical Krabbe disease, has been
patients and potentially concerns include that WGS can controversial. Krabbe disease was
pathogenic variants were found in reveal information unrelated to the proposed for inclusion on the RUSP,
clinically relevant genes in an patients’ current symptoms but that but it was not confirmed because of
additional 7% (5 of 71) of cases, may affect the health of the patient a lack of evidence of an effective
giving a total yield of clinical and his or her family, could reveal treatment. In Krabbe disease,
diagnoses in 42% of individuals.17 future health issues before the mutational analysis and residual
POTENTIAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST: Dr Bonkowsky discloses the following: consultant relationships with bluebird bio, Inc, Calico, LLC, Denali Therapeutics,
and Enzyvant; Board of Directors relationship with wFluidx, Inc; general stock ownership in Orchard Corp, and royalties (spouse) with BioFire Diagnostics,
LLC; and Dr Keller has indicated she has no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.
REFERENCES demyelinating disorders. Semin Pediatr 6. Lynch DS, Rodrigues Brand~ao de Paiva
1. Heim P, Claussen M, Hoffmann B, et al. Neurol. 2012;19(4):219–223 A, Zhang WJ, et al. Clinical and genetic
Leukodystrophy incidence in Germany. 4. Soderholm HE, Chapin AB, Bayrak-Toyde- characterization of leukoencephalopa-
Am J Med Genet. 1997;71(4):475–478 mir P, Bonkowsky JL. Elevated leukodys- thies in adults. Brain.
trophy incidence predicted from 2017;140(5):1204–1211
2. Bonkowsky JL, Nelson C, Kingston JL, Fil-
loux FM, Mundorff MB, Srivastava R. The genomics databases. Pediatr Neurol. 7. Kaul R, Gao GP, Aloya M, et al. Canavan
burden of inherited leukodystrophies in 2020;111:66–69 disease: mutations among Jewish and
children. Neurology. 2010;75(8):718–725 non-Jewish patients. Am J Hum Genet.
5. Duffner PK, Barczykowski A, Jalal K, Yan
1994;55(1):34–41
3. Vanderver A, Hussey H, Schmidt JL, Pas- L, Kay DM, Carter RL. Early infantile
tor W, Hoffman HJ. Relative incidence of Krabbe disease: results of the World- 8. Coelho JC, Wajner M, Burin MG, Vargas
inherited white matter disorders in Wide Krabbe Registry. Pediatr Neurol. CR, Giugliani R. Selective screening of
childhood to acquired pediatric 2011;45(3):141–148 10,000 high-risk Brazilian patients for the