Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Introduction: A skiers thumb, or a partial or complete rupture of the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) is
Received 2 February 2016 a clinical diagnosis. Swelling, pain, natural left-right difference and inexperience of a young physician
Received in revised form 5 July 2016 can cause difficulty to correctly diagnose this injury. However, our theory is that any physician, given
Accepted 14 July 2016
the correct instructions, should be able to diagnose this injury solely on clinical findings, without the
necessity of additional imaging.
Keywords:
Material and methods: In a large Dutch teaching hospital, physicians (residents with working experience
Skier’s thumb
of 6 months–3 years) working at the ER received instructions for physical examination. Patients >18 years,
Ulnar collateral ligament
MR
with an injury <1 week old, suspected of a true skier’s thumb had an MRI reported by two independent
Sports injury radiologists to confirm the diagnosis.
Results: Thirty patients were included. Seven patients had no fixed endpoint (23%), all had a complete
ligamentous rupture of the UCL on MRI, of which three patients had a Stener lesion. Fifteen patients
(50%) met with the criteria >35◦ laxity in extension of MCP/ >20◦ laxity in 30◦ flexion of the MCP. Of
these, thirteen patients (81%) had a complete rupture (nine Stener lesions (56%)). One patient had a
partial injury and one patient had no UCL-injury. Eight patients (27%) had inconclusive results during
physical examination. Of these, two had a complete rupture (40%, 1 Stener). Three patients had a partial
rupture and three patients had an intact UCL.
Conclusion: A skier’s thumb can be diagnosed by any resident when correctly instructed. Additional imag-
ing when diagnosing a skier’s thumb should be reserved in cases when physical examination remains
inconclusive.
© 2016 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrad.2016.07.007
0720-048X/© 2016 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
M. Mahajan et al. / European Journal of Radiology 85 (2016) 1750–1756 1751
Fig. 1. Complete rupture of the ulnar collateral ligament, with the ruptured distal
end stuck underneath the adductor aponeurosis, the so-called ‘Stener lesion’.
1.1. Anatomy
Because the UCL comprises of two parts, the thumb must also be
tested in two positions. First, the patient’s thumb is held with the
Fig. 2. a–d: Complete UCL rupture without dislocation; the fibres of the UCL are
MCP joint in extension, while applying valgus stress to the thumb. discontinuous, but the aponeurosis of the adductor pollicis longus appears normal.
Then, the test is repeated with the MCP joint in 30◦ of flexion. Laxity a: T1W cor, b: PD TSE cor, c: T2 TSE cor, d: T2 FS cor.
of the joint is noted in these two positions. Care must be taken by
the investigator to place his/her thumb on the radial side of the
MCP joint to prevent rotational effects. Literature varies about what the emergency department (ER). In non-skiing countries such as
degree of laxity warrants the diagnosis of a complete rupture, but the Netherlands, this injury is relatively uncommon, which could
a standard of more than 35◦ during valgus stress with the MCP explain why it often is not recognized in acute setting. In our hospi-
in extension, more than 20◦ in extension and/or more than a 15◦ tal, we observed an incidence of approximately 20 patients a year
difference compared to the contralateral side [2–4] is commonly with a complete rupture of the UCL.
agreed upon. An alternative measurement could be the presence Lastly, there are limitations to the clinical investigation in acute
or absence of a firm endpoint during testing [2]. setting. A ‘firm endpoint’ seems logical however can still be unclear
to someone who has less experience with testing injuries of the
1.3. Limitations in physical examination thumb. Also, measuring the degree of laxity of the thumb is diffi-
cult and prone to inter-observer variation, even with a goniometer.
There are some problems in determining the correct diagnosis. A recent article has shown that when the examination is performed
First, the knowledge of how to correctly perform and interpret the incorrectly − with the MCP joint in slight pro- or supination − the
physical examination often lacks in (young) physicians working at diagnosis can be misinterpreted [5]. Also, in approximately one
1752 M. Mahajan et al. / European Journal of Radiology 85 (2016) 1750–1756
Fig. 4. a,b: Partial injury of the UCL, showing a subtle enhanced T2 signal in the T2
FS, indicating edema in the ligament. a: PD TSE cor, b: T2 FS cor.
adductor aponeurosis [Fig. 3a–d] [12]. The aponeurosis, which nor- In this study, we chose to compare the clinical diagnosis of a
mally appears as a thin hypointense structure, usually also shows skier’s thumb to the diagnosis on MRI, the last being our ‘gold
surrounding hyperintense effusion on T2-weighted MR images standard’.
[12].
Sometimes, a small injury without a complete rupture of the UCL
can be seen. However, this is very subtle on MRI and can only be
seen as a focally enhanced T2 signal on the T2 FS, indicating oedema
2. Objectives
in the ligament [Fig. 4ab]. Combined with the clinical finding of an
acute injury with a painful UCL, this could be classified as a partial
To determine the positive predictive value of the clinical diag-
injury.
nosis of a skier’s thumb compared to the accuracy of MRI of the
UCL.
1754 M. Mahajan et al. / European Journal of Radiology 85 (2016) 1750–1756
Table 1
Diagnosis of physical examination compared to diagnosis on MRI.
Findings at physical examination No. of patients Complete rupture/Stener lesion Partial injury No UCL injury
Table 2
Inter-rater agreement of the radiologists.
Radiologist B
[14] D. Melville, J.A. Jacobson, S. Haase, C. Brandon, M.K. Brigido, D. Fessell, [16] D.M. Melville, J.A. Jacobson, D.P. Fessell, Ultrasound of the thumb ulnar
Ultrasound of displaced ulnar collateral ligament tears of the thumb: the collateral ligament: technique and pathology, AJR Am. J. Roentgenol. 202
Stener lesion revisited, Skeletal Radiol. 42 (2013) 667–673. (2014) W168.
[15] F.S. Ebrahim, US diagnosis of UCL tears of the thumb and stener lesions: [17] C.F. Arend, T.R. da Silva, The role of US in the evaluation of clinically suspected
technique: pattern-based approach and differential diagnosis, Radiographics ulnar collateral ligament injuries of the thumb: spectrum of findings and
26 (2006) 1007–1020. differential diagnosis, Acta Radiol. 55 (2014) 814–823.