You are on page 1of 2

310

antiomeric separations and a historical re- scientists and laboratories active in this area,
view. Part 2 consists of one chapter only, as well as by the libraries of science-based
dealing with chiral derivatization. This can be institutions. Overall the quality of production
an important preamble to chiral resolution, is good. There is some variation with regards
but could well have been embodied in Part 1 to schemes, diagrams and chromatograms,
to avoid its lonely isolation in Part 2. All of arising presumably from the variation in qual-
the introductory chapters are relevant and ity received by the publisher from the authors.
allow the text to stand on its own as a refer- This does not however detract from the over-
ence work. The chapters are well written and all feel of the book. Finally, this reviewer
illustrated, and stick closely to their objec- much prefers the referencing system which
tives. Part 3 is undoubtedly the crux of the uses numbers in the text, rather than authors'
book and in eight chapters deals systemati- names, but again this is purely a personal
cally with direct chiral resolution. Chapter view.
titles are: chiral ligand exchange chromatog-
raphy; synthetic multiple-interaction chiral D.C. SHERRINGTON
bonded phases; immobilised proteins as
HPLC chiral stationary phases; cyclodextrin
inclusion complexation; binding to cellulose Bioseparations: Downstream Processingfor Bi-
derivatives; binding to synthetic polymers; otechnology, by Paul E. Belter, E.L.
ion-pairing; and other direct chiral resolution Cussler, and Wei-Shou Hu, John Wiley
methods. Throughout these the book lives up and Sons Inc., New York, NY, 1988, 368
to its objective by concentrating on applica- pages, ISBN 0-471-84737-2, £38.50.
tions, the influence of experimental parame-
ters, other practical considerations, ad- In the preface, the book claims to provide
vantages and disadvantages of procedures etc. a bridge between the two cultures of life
Columns and column stationary phases are sciences and engineering (presumably chem-
more often taken for granted in that "active" ical). It is aimed at final-year chemical
structures are presented, but few details are engineering u n d e r g r a d u a t e s and post-
given concerning preparation and manufac- graduates from other disciplines: life sciences,
ture (this information is often protected by chemistry and civil engineering.
suppliers of course!). Numerous examples of The book is organised around four main
specific chromatographic separations are sections which follow common stages in the
given along with the actual chromatograms. recovery and purification of biological prod-
Part 4 deals in three chapters with the strategy ucts; removal of insolubles (filtration, centri-
and optimisation of chiral chromatographic fugation and cell disruption), product isola-
separations, including a discussion of how to tion (extraction and adsorption), product
go about choosing a particular separation purification (chromatography, precipitation,
procedure. For those in the field already it is ultrafiltration and electrophoresis) and pol-
dubious how valuable these pages are likely ishing (crystallisation and drying). Distilla-
to be. Finally Part 5 covers future trends and tion, evaporation and absorption are among
requirements and deals with instrumental those topics given scanty treatment, if any,
hardware as well as new chiral column pack- since they are not considered to be biosep-
ings, the demand for preparative scale sys- arations.
tems and computer modelling studies. On the whole this is not a book for chem-
The book certainly seems to fill a gap in ical engineers. The treatment is generally
the market and should be acquired by all much too brief and will have been covered
311

more extensively elsewhere in their course. from the attempt to play down issues. For
There are one or two exceptions to this, for example, " . . . t h e 'equilibrium line' ... is
example the section on cell disruption. Some- nothing more than an energy balance" or the
times the significance of the material being statement that the main purpose of a psych-
biological is emphasised, e.g. protein de- rometric chart is to give " t h e equilibrium
naturation during drying. Other times it is concentration in the vapor versus tempera-
not, e.g. problems with emulsification and ture".
damage to proteins due to solvents are men- The feature I most like is that it is often
tioned only in a worked example. admitted that theory is being presented only
The book is, however, a good attempt to because it is conventional to attempt to use it
provide a guide to bioseparations for non- while time and again the need for experimen-
chemical engineers. It avoids the pit-fall of tal testing is stressed. There are many worked
being too descriptive which can give the mis- examples and problems for which answers are
leading impression that Chemical Engineering provided.
is a non-numerate discipline. Equations are The book would make an excellent text for
presented with just enough derivation to non-chemical engineering students though the
clarify the underlying principles and assump- price may limit the demand. For anyone in
tions. industry it would make a useful primer to
The style is pleasantly light and informal. bioseparations. I will use it as a source of
Occasionally this g r a t e s - - " . . , the results are problems and exam questions.
a bevy of Bessel functions". Any disagree-
ments I have with the technical content stem G. BELL

Books received

High-Performance Liquid Chromatography of Techniques, xiv + 379 pages, hardcover,


Biopolymers and Biooligomers, by O. Mike~, $150.00/Df1285.00; Part B: Separation of In-
Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988, ISBN 0 - 4 4 4 - dividual Compound Classes, xiii + 721 pages,
41616-1. Part A: Principles, Materials and hardcover, $189.50/Df1360.00.

You might also like