River Restoration Landscape Between The Ecology and Aesthetics Landscape Architecture Platform Landezine

River Restoration Landscape Between the Ecology and Aesthetics « Lan... https://landezine.com/river-restoration-landscape-between-the-ecology-a...
Search
• Projects
• Offices
• Products
• Advertisers
• Awards
• Submit Work
• Explore
• Advertise
River Restoration Landscape Between the Ecology and Aesthetics

Katarina Bajc /
The project for ecological restoration of Swiss river Aire has been winning trophies on most visible landscape architecture biennials and conferences. After receiving Public
Choice Award and standing ovations at the International Biennial of Landscape Architecture in Barcelona in 2016 it was most recently again rewarded at the LILA Awards
Ceremony 2018 in Hamburg. The circumstances and the task of the River Aire project are familiar and comparable to many other water bodies in industrialized and in urbanized
context around the globe. The design solution which addressed these circumstances however is groundbreaking on many levels as a materialization of contemporary paradigms in
several fields from natural sciences to design. It comes as a no surprise that the project was developed by an interdisciplinary team consisting of biologists, hydrological engineers
and architects. The project can be summarized as a clear statement that designed landscape is not a static everlasting entity as it develops from its morphological context and
depends on it to thrive in the future.
The context of this project’s designed landscape is the River Aire, which flows from glacial moraines in France to a fertile plain near Geneva. Plaine de l’Aire where the project is
situated was historically devoted to agriculture, in the 20th century industry, a major highway and housing joined. To protect these from floodwaters and to drain the farming land
consequently dykes were build, a stretch of river was straightened and canalized, later underground culverts were added. Thus, the river was gradually confined and modified from
1 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
a shifting and dynamic waterbody and habitat into a pure infrastructure for efficient disposal of excess flood water. Such technological solutions allow for fast conveyance of the
floodwater through the area, but fatally increase the velocity and amount of the floodwater problem for the areas downstream.
River restoration projects became widespread in Europe since the establishment of EU Water Framework Directive for integrated river basin management in 2000. Switzerland is
part of these efforts with its laws to improve water quality, enhance ecological value and most importantly improve access and appeal of river spaces for people. Accordingly, in
2001 the Canton of Geneva announced a competition for ecological restoration of the canalized reach of the river Aire and established a fund to finance it. Under the pressure of
growing intensity and size of precipitation events however, also the existing floodwater protection infrastructure needed to be enlarged. The designers faced these tasks from a
fresh perspective in terms of ecological science, flood protection engineering, landscape design as well as cultural heritage. They challenged paradigms in all those fields and
synthetized them in an interdisciplinary holistic work. An experiment. A dynamic and eventful landscape for playful nature experience.
© ADR / Superpositions
The floodwater solution and the restoration of the river Aire works systematically on several scales. Totality of the intervention which is ongoing since 2002 and the cumulative
effect of all its parts improves its flood, and ecological resilience. The project started with the creation of two retention basins on the floodplains, restoring a meander bend that
has been cut off and finally by introducing an ecologically revitalized portion of the river parallel to the existing channel. So, a space for the floodwater was provided locally,
which allows it to run off slowly in a controlled manner, to feed and rejuvenate the floodplain ecology as well as refill the groundwater. This approach also reduces the stress and
danger for the areas downstream. The ecologically restored part of the river complements the valuable existing portions of the river up and downstream of the canal. The strength
of the project derives from improved function and connectivity rather than cosmetic gardening.
The ecological thought was at the heart of the project but never as a “re-naturalization”. Its goal was the establishment of a braided river pattern, as a home to riparian habitats
within the river and floodplain ecosystems. Its approach was not to recreate a natural state, as an opposite to culture, but rather to acknowledge and celebrate the interdependency
of both. The strategy of the project was to initiate display and stage the emergence and genesis of the natural process of fluvial morphology over time, and not to create a final,
‘natural’ state. In such a way the concept corresponds to contemporary ecological discourse.
Ecology as a science faced a paradigm shift in the past decades. The notions of stability are being replaced by ecological dynamics as a vital aspect of ecological health and
resilience. The ecological theory was previously explaining ecosystem development as a path which progresses steadily towards a desired climax state. River restoration projects
accordingly strived to reconstruct this climax state and preferred channel stability with the banks of the river artificially reinforced and then secured with vegetation or organic
material such as wood. This was the case even for previously unconfined alluvial and meandering rivers.
2 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
© ADR / Superpositions
New paradigm in ecology currently explains rivers as ecological systems with inputs and outputs of material, which inform the logic of fluvial morphology. Bank erosion,
deposition of sediment material and wood as well as diverse flow patterns and velocities are vital to forming and regeneration of the river bed and banks. They assure diversity of
its habitats, deeper waters for fish migration and sandbars for hatching, enclosed spaces for protection. Disturbances such as bank erosion and deposition which cause these
dynamics thus came to the focus of river restoration. They influence not only river ecology but also the aesthetic aspects of the spaces they create a new, through ancient
morphological processes. This was the premise from which the project at Aire was established.
The design group Superpositions suggested a powerful but simple intervention to make genesis of fluvial morphology palpable and perceptible to human eye. Orthogonal diamond
shaped depressions were cut in the vast otherwise featureless riverbed to establish a possible channel migration zone. The water was then rerouted to it and allowed to fight its
own way through diamond shaped islands, dimensioned to match its erosive strength. By migrating, eroding and depositing freely the stream recreated its own complex braided
pattern, not unlike the one that coined the rivers character centuries ago. The designers managed to reestablish its intrinsic identity, as well ecological as also formal, without
imposing its finished state from the start. Instead of widening and removing the concrete canal, a new 80m wide riverbed was established parallel to it. The width offers space to
enormous amounts of floodwater during the peaks. During the normal water flow, there is a number of smaller and a deeper stream to provide water for fish migration.
© Superpositions / ADR
The sharp juxtaposition of orthogonal, man induced versus wild, spontaneous slowly merges yet always keeps signifiers of the previous states, as a testimony of its natural or
cultural dynamics – as a palimpsest of its history. This stance was exhibited also in the decision to keep the existing channel as a cultural artefact and reinvest it with new meaning
as a linear garden. The fortified concrete bed was removed and its banks now reinforced by vegetation are accessible by stairs or cantilevered concrete slabs to provide calm and
enclosed spaces within the canal. Bridges, paths, pergolas, outdoor furniture and gardens are situated here to accommodate the majority of visitors, taking pressure of the wild
riparian corridor. Both the channel and the riverbed offer a multitude of possibilities to experience the water with all the senses. Avenue of characteristic poplar trees reminiscent
of in the European countryside landscape and tradition; the footprint of the existing reinforced channel once at the height of technology; added contemporary architectural
elements all frame and guide the succession of experiences along the river space. The ecology, cultural relicts, flood protection features, the gardens so become an ever-changing
event. The traces of past and ongoing processes bound to the region impose a new understanding and perception of time and other forces upon the landscape, society, individual
3 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
and their ecologies.
Kondolf, G. Mathias, 2012. The Espace De Liberté and Restoration of Fluvial Process: When Can the River Restore Itself and When Must We Intervene? In: Philip J. Boon and
Paul J. Raven (eds.), River Conservation and Management, Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 223–241.
The River Chronicle II, June 4, 2016. www.superpositions.ch/, accessed February 3, 2017.
Télécharger PRIX SCHULTHESS DES JARDINS 2012 superpositions.ch/, accessed February 3, 2017.
Johnson B.R, Pulliam H.R. 2001. Ecology’s new paradigm: what does it offer designers and planners? In: Ecology and Design: Frameworks for Learning. (Ed.). Johnson B.R. and
K. Hill Washington, Island Press, 51-84.
Bio
Katarina Bajc was born in Ljubljana, Slovenia where she studied Fine Arts Education at the University of Ljubljana, from 2002 to 2007 and later also Landscape Architecture at
University of Ljubljana from 2005 to 2010. She was exchange student at Faculty of Architecture and Landscape Sciences at Leibniz University Hannover, Germany in 2008/9.
She later moved to Munich, where she finished Master in Landscape architecture at Technical University Munich, Germany in 2013. She worked in landscape architecture and
urban planning offices in Germany and Portugal, as well as in art galleries in Slovenia from 2005-2015. In 2015 she was Teaching and Research Assistant at Technical University
in Munich, Chair for Landscape Architecture and industrial Landscapes. She received a Fulbright scholarship for the Year 2015/16 which allowed her to pursue research in the
field of ecological aesthetics in landscape architecture at Berkeley College for Environmental Design at University of California. From 2016-2017 she held a teaching and
research position at the Institute of Landscape Planning and Ecology at the University of Stuttgart. Currently, Katarina is a researcher at HafenCity University in Hamburg.
1 Comment
• André Nascimento 02.24.19
Thnaks for the very interesting example of landscape architecture and river restoration. I was working with the same scope in project and research. It can be a huge
challenge connect landscape aesthetics, river restoration and ecology but it´s amazing when it happens. Congratulations
Leave a comment!
Name (required):
Email (required):
Website: http://
Speak!
Katarina Bajc is a landscape architect, currently working as a researcher at HafenCity University in Hamburg.
Published on February 12, 2019

Like 0 Share
Tweet
Share
Save
Newer post
Older post
Products
List Your Products

Visit Product Library
Plane Single Seat With Backrest A by Grijsen
4 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
Monolight by Metalco
Kore by Metalco
Libre by Metalco
Ponte W / A Benches by Metalco
5 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
Parallel 42 by Landscape Forms
Plane II Double Seat With Backrest by Grijsen
Três by Metalco
BOX W by SIT
6 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
Wenters Single Seat With Backrest (Wood) by Grijsen
Volo Evolution by Metalco
Ametista by Metalco
Manufacturers
See all
7 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
See all products
8 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
See all products
9 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
See all products
Advertisers
List Your Company

See all advertisers
10 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
11 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
12 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
13 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
14 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
Landezine Newsletter
Best of Landscape Architecture in Your Mailbox
Twice per month!
Subscribe Keep in touch!
About Us / Contact
Send us your project!
Advertise
Landezine LIVE
LILA - Landezine International Landscape Award
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
© 2009 – 2022 Landezine

+386 40 81 40 04
info (at) landezine.com
All rights reserved. All photos, plans and renders of projects on Landezine are property of a photographer or landscape architects mentioned within a specific project presentation.
15 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM
Watch Landezine LIVE Lectures
See LILA - Landezine International Landscape Award Winners
16 of 16 26-Oct-22, 3:49 PM

River Restoration Landscape Between The Ecology and Aesthetics Landscape Architecture Platform Landezine

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

River Restoration Landscape Between The Ecology and Aesthetics Landscape Architecture Platform Landezine

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

River Restoration Landscape Between the Ecology and Aesthetics « Lan... https://landezine.com/river-restoration-landscape-between-the-ecology-a...

River Restoration Landscape Between the Ecology and Aesthetics

and their ecologies.

• André Nascimento 02.24.19

Published on February 12, 2019

List Your Products

Plane Single Seat With Backrest A by Grijsen

Ponte W / A Benches by Metalco

Parallel 42 by Landscape Forms

Plane II Double Seat With Backrest by Grijsen

Wenters Single Seat With Backrest (Wood) by Grijsen

Volo Evolution by Metalco

See all products

See all products

See all products

List Your Company

Subscribe Keep in touch!

© 2009 – 2022 Landezine

Watch Landezine LIVE Lectures

See LILA - Landezine International Landscape Award Winners

You might also like