Effects of Thermal Barrier Coatings On Turbine Blade Cooling

Proceedings of GT2006

!"$##%%&
('*),+-/.012%&231(450
ASME Turbo Expo 2006: Power for Land, Sea and Air
May 8-11, 2006, Barcelona, Spain
687:9;<;=?>@AB9<;9
GT2006-91202
CEDGF$HJILK:M<N7:OF$PRQTSVUXWS
PLPZY[F?P]\M<SBI^Y`_a<KbM_dc8efefPgM<S
HOF$KbILM
7ihPLjkY`_FlWmU[SonfFp\MqMrU`Y`_a
s
tutvgw`xy{z
|J}$~}By{z(szz[,Rzz
Ryzzy`2((w
sJwz[t utvgw`xy{z`t ,t w`
q r&
qqB ñ1ò ³ ¨ó (RÕw`²`(y{z
sJzy`zLw*o J(z¡`y*vR`zLRw¢,(*£/ vRJ¤2wz¥z ô ³ õÿ{¡öz÷§z*z(z
(zZ,¡w¥(w,¦§`&¥z[B¦/w*¨¥(((zR*`(z^©w¢wy{&z(zª2`y ø ³ Ðx`¡q¼R©w*±x
w*
¦/w*¡«zJ,¬w*Lw`¦2z¥z[q|¬(w®®¥w&¢, Ú ³ Ðz({±x
,^$¡z`(Lw,¦&¡¬(w`¢(©x®©y{zz¯z©xw*¥*r¡¬(w`*z[ ù ³
,±³±w`³±²J`yyz¡¬z`¥z
`w
w¡¬w*(z¢gz¯zxt1°±R{Rw`²J`Rz[¥(<*,(z?©w¢wy´³ ~¥(¬(
(q¦/w*¡¶µ[·¸bwº¹*¸bw,¦¡,{z[`¡8`<,!yz[*ºw| úûæ ³ á^`(z$(yz
z[¥w*(Lw,¦§z[`y{xr»*¹¸²J(yzR¡`,((^(z`¡qzLww* ú ³ á^`(z$z(
(yzRz¡q¬z`¥(zt^}f`,y{x{JJ{z²J¼w`²J`[ üý ³ }?``²Z,y{y
²J(z½! vR:zy{z[¾¥(¬wE¿(zº*`(zÀ(z¡,yz þ ³ Rw¢wy`
¬(w(z*Áª2`yx
yzZ©w¢wy`LLzÂ*¥{z[r¥(
z`y þÿ ³ Rw¢wy`^(yz
wwy{(r`yw(z<w¡¬,z[qwªy{¡bww*y(t^ J{Jz¬z[`yyx þ ³ Rw*RÕw`²
¥(z¦/w*L¡,y{y¥(((zJ²J(zz$z`y2ww*y($²J(w¥(1ªy¡ ³ ó¨÷§z*z
wwy{($¬z¡qL(z¥(±¦Ãzw*¥(`xryx*zLw
z¡`y`¡r³ ³ Rw¢wy`^z©®z[
,^w`z
*(´ª§,R¦/w*qw`¦Lz?*,(z$¥(Ä¦Ã*©z*t ³ Rw*¡r(¥(w*
ÿ
³ õ&y¡ww*y(
³ Ôf`(z`¡:¢`
Åq.Æ!+0Ç),-/È[É1'`+ ÿ ³ Rw¢wy`^z
³ °±¡¬((z¡z(Òz
³ Ôz,y
Ê ³ }z Jÿ ³ Rw¢wy`^z$¡z`yz¡q¬z`¥(z
ËRÌ ³ ~¬z´ª§$(z[, ³ ó¨(z{wJz
Í ³ Î2z[(<z*z<®¼,¡zz ³ ~¥(±¦±*z
Ï ³ Ð,¡zz^w,¦Ñ¡¬{*z¡qz®Ò©z þ ³ J(z¡`y2v^,{z?Rw¢,(
Ó ³ Ôf`RÕ¥`z þÿ ³ vî¢zw
Ö ³ ×Jz[,J,(±¦5z?wz¯©{z¢ þ ³ vîz(zw*
Ø ³ J(z¡`y2w*¥{±x
Ù ³ vLyw`²J(`wÚ(Û [Å
q À
`VÅ
ÜfÝ ³ |J¥(zy¥(¡rz J (zr±²Rw¬({¡`xz[`w*(B¦/w*z[¥(fz
¦/*w*ºw`¦
Þ
ß ³ à1,y¨¥(¡rz w¡¬(zw*J,*z
,{g¥(z[¦/w^¥({z?*,(z?©w¢wy{<`z
Þ ³ á^`(z$¬( (zfyë*zy(ww(Gw,¦<z¥(E|E¬(w®®¥w&?,E,½¡r³
â ³ ×Jw*yz$¬( ¬(w`*z¡qz^w*¡q¬w(z^z©¯zxt^Rx(yz$z¯z©xJ¡r³
ã ³ ×Jz[,RÕ¥ ¬(w`*z[`²J(w¥(1`{zJw*w*1(yz1z¡q¬z`¥(z*x
¡r³
ä$å ³ sJzx(wy¼®^¥(¡rz ¬(w`*z¡qzGz©w*¡¬w*z<z¯©{zz[tsJz[®¥(!z
ä$å`æ ³ çJ(sJzx¢w*yR¢¥¡rz z¡¬z,¥(zw*¬½w(zº*`z¥(zfwG¡qÁ((fw,¦<z
èé ³ ~,¢w*¥(¡rz wwy¼,`¡`(z`¡öÕw`²J[z¥(y$y{w`²Rz$w*¡r(¥±³
è ³ ~¥(±¦±*z
`©z w*L,*zRz¡¬z,¥(z*t1}¿y{w`²Rz1*`z^(yz1z¡¬z,¥(z
ê ³ Ñz¡¬z,¥(z (w*¥(yoz¥(y^z[®¥z[|r¬(w(¥w*¨t& J(z$z{`(y±x
êÝ ³ Ñ¥(¥(yzz
z(±x w,¦Ñ|z[®¥w¦5w*J`¦/R`z¬z[`yyxr*w*¥(r¬w`²^z
é ³ J(ë(z ,¬(¬(y`{w({q²Jzyx¿z[w*( z2t|½¬(w(¥w*i{
Û ³ áLzyw(±x zxfw*³±y{z[`¦/¥(w*ºw`¦Jz¡¬z,¥(z µ tró1*zGq¡`yy
ì ³ ¡`LÕw`²E,z z[¥w*

w*¡r¥({wz¡¬z,¥(z^,
*zRR*(´ª§`
í&îï(îð ³ ×Jw*yz$¬*( ¡¬*Lwf|¬(w(¥{w&t
µ Copyright © 2006 by ASME
Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

ó1*z(w*¥* *,(zX©w¢wy{½`f!z©z`º(w*®³ wwy{((z¥(w*r¦5w®©¥(zJww*y((zzzJ*,(zJ²J
,*z`(yzJ`1z[`¥(z?1L*`y`(yz1¦/w1²^wë
z(*©w*r w(yxz`y$ww*y(fwªy¡ ww*y(t Ðz¬z(!w*¿z
(z$w*w*(zz

¬zÄ¦/w*¡`z$¬z`y±xrwr(z$*`(z*tLvgz³ z÷2z[*z(zºy{z*zy±Rªy¡pwwy{(!w,¦/z½z[Â¥(zf*w*,y
,¥(zR1{¨(w*®³Ä,*z`(yzJ`[{Lwwy{(,Ñw,¦/z
zzz[® z`y2ww*y(
rwzRw¡,¢`<z¬(`(yz$*`zJz¡³
µ·*¸«w,¦Ñz
¡,{rz[`¡ ,{t1 J(J(*q¦/*{ww,¦g©w¢wy` ¬z,¥(z[t
,{$z[¥zr*`(zrz¯©{zxtfsJzz[!,º 1¥(z » ``yx z[ °±w*¡q¬`(z`yw*(yx<,oªy¡wwy{(zz,y&`Ä³
±²Rwr`*z×à¿¥(((z§,q¬(zzzº(zz¥(y
`$` ¥(¡¬(w*(R*z$wrz
¡*zt1 ÑwJÒ¥(´¦/xq(zz<`¥(¡q¬(w(
zw*¬xºz`zfwz[*Gy¼zrw`²
t Jzrzw¬x!{®³ z*z`y,¬z[qw`¦$*`(zq(z[`r,(±¦/z`zz,¡(z[2t ó¨³
z[`z
²J`J¢zrwr`f`zw(x`¡q¼RywJò¡´({ ¬z¡qz`y2`©w*¡¬¥(,w*,y(*`zz(z,y&(z[,`±¦/z
yw*[t2 Jz^*,(z^`zw(x`¡q2yw*&²J`Ñ®¥(z^ww*¥((`x?yxz z¥(yV,z®{¥(z[2t J(z(w¼©zw`¦`¬¬(w¬(`z(yw`²J(
w`²J¨t^ Jz
zw*¬x{z[,zr¥(z
wr¡´((
²J`w*(y{x `w^òªy{¡«z÷2z[*z(z*,y¥(z^,z?®{¥(z[2tg J(zz³
Õ¥zz[¢xww*y`RÕw`²JtJõ(wJ(z$ª`*zo*`(z*²J {¢±xqw`¦Lz[Â¥(z[!ww*y(rwq(zo¦/*{wfw`¦^wwy{(q¥(z
$ww*y,¢ÇÕw`²G`zw`¦ *¸`(zz¢w¬¢xz[`z?¥(zw
¡q´¢³ ¦/w2ªy¡ wwy{(JL``yx z[2t2}<¡q¬((*z¡qzz,y®©w¢wy´³
(f²J`µ*µ *¸ w`¦(zf`zw(x`¡q¼z¢w¬¢x!©z[,z*t¿õ(w ((z¡qzJ{L(wz¦/wLw*¡q¬`{zJz[Â¥(zoÕw`²G`z[
(zfzw*i`zf*`(z^²J½!ww*y`Õw`²b`zfw`¦
w*y{x z[,¥(zw`¦Jrw*¡q¬`(y{±xq²J{!±²^wº¡z(w*,yÇ,`yx³
»¸2(zrz¢w¬¢xºz[`z¥(zrwf¡´((r²J`$w*(yxGµ¹*¸ w`¦ {t<õ¨`yyxw¡¬,w(`zr(w`²JÀ¦/w*¢z`yLw(yx,
(z<`zw(x`¡qJzw*¬xz`zt°±f*w*&(z(w* ªy¡ wwy{(q²J,f²J(w*¥($ vR w`{*
`$±²Rw*,(z
wwy{z²J`ëz`w(`z[²J((yxww*yz[q*`(zJ{z[,z szx(w*yR¥(¡rz[t
(z¥(z*(zrzzXxº(zqww* t Eyw(ëzV,yÃt 2`
²RzyyÑ,BÔÀ*}¥( L¬w¢w*¥(,$z[¥w*?f(zz³
Â¥(zwwy{(q¦/*w*(<,zr(zz[z[ z¦5w*zr{(z
¥({z `1B À1`VÅ .
$& 2
(yzRz¡q¬z`¥(zxzyr*z[`z?©x®©y{zoz¯zxt
J(z¡`y2vR`z?Rw`(£5 v^R¤Lz$(z$¬(w*¡zJw`¦ |sJz¥{w
z[,yx
z¥(<©w¢wy`¨Õw`²Gz[Â¥(z¡qz[tL×w`²^z*z*(zx |f¬(w(¥w*R*zxz(z
wrz¡¬z,¥(z*,
,z1¥(*Ò©z[1wJ¬`yy`{w&t}Xw(z*`*z^z*
`¬¬(w*

zxºz`(yzrwz[¥z|!¬(w(¥©w*&tqsJz[¥(
wz?²J(w*¥(2zyx{Jw*$(zg{¥(y`(^¬w*¬zz1w`¦(z (zfw*¡r(¥w
w*¥yzrz¡¬z,¥(z*Rê úû g¥((,¢`yyx!z³
vRR[`(z,¬(¬(yx
z¡ ¦/w*L(zLz(zª2`y¬(w¬zzt ¥z|¬(w(¥{w&tLõw*J
w*,Jw*w*R(yz^z¡¬zÄ³
°±z$¦/¥(¥(z*²J(zf¬,yy¼,w*qJy{zyë*zy{x v^R¡xrz ,¥(z**ê æ[z[¥(<(z`¡qw*¥(¨w`¦&*`zww*y`1yw`²^zLz
zy{zwfwqz[®¥zrww*y(Õw`²`z[ t E(zf(?®w*(z*
(zrz±xw,¦wwy{(qÕw`²«`z
w®z*!¬`,¡zz *,(z^(yzú gz¡q¬z`¥(z*ê úû tLvgx<¡``((Jê ú æ^w*,[
,(*zt (z$¥(((z$w*¥(¬(¥(J¬w`²^z^¥(÷2z[z2t
á^`zww*y(,{ ì 2w,¦/z!z©©zz[µ[·¸:w`¦J(zr¡`
}JzJ`y±t ¹ (w`²^zr`J`L¡qw®®z,z?szx(w*yg¢¥¡r³
z¡r¥w`¦L(zo¥w*f¥(±¦Ãzw`¦^wy{q*`z?z¡,(z[ Õw`² ,[t
sJww?ww*y,¢$þ `[²J(º{$`*z[,(yzV,{2©z
y`¡q`2`1`{y{zÑ¥(¥(yzzJw,¦¢z({±xow`¦
¸t&×Jw`²Rz*z[ rwzr(w!²Rw*ë! (zªr,*z*Rr*zz,y{yx!yzr,
}
&w`²^z[q`2Ò¥(J(z$¬(zzz<w,¦&ªy¡m©w¢wy{
(w*yz ¹¸bw`¦ ì úû tqá^`(z©w¢wy`
`<w¡z¦/w*¡8(z©w*¡¬zw*
,¥(zr`(¥(¬(L`w*,1(z(w*yz*t¨}½ww*y((z¡qzJ¥(±³ `z<`$z¡q¬z`¥(z2ê i`¬(¬(w({¡`zyxr`y´¦Ñw,¦^z
(w*(yxrz`y&©w¢wy{²J(zz
zÕw`²½z¡,{Ly`¡,[ *,(zJw*¥(yzLz¡¬z,¥(z*ê ú æ t1}w*(,¢ ËRÌ z[`L`y`©z
¡xzJ¬(z¦5z,(yzJw$w*(zJ¥(ªy¡ ww*y(²J(zz(zRÕw`² {z
`w*^wr¥((¥(yz(z`Jz?yz[(z[*zt ê ú æ µ ê ú©û
çJ{fw*(yxz`y^©w¢wy{
¡¬(*`y¨²J(z!y`*z ì þ ì úû £µ!ê þ ê ú æ¤
,¡w*¥¢1w`¦Ñww*y(
`L*zw
z?z5Òz[z[¦/w¡(z,{y( ~¥(¡` §(w`²^z|Jº¬(w(¥©w*!`
¦5¥({wfw`¦Rz¡³
z[®*z*t¨ 1w*w*$ò¥(*z¬(`(yx$(ë$`y{Jz[*z*¥(z ¬z,¥(zr¦/w
´÷§zzV©w*¡r(¥(w[t J(
z¦/zzz(w`²^z
z*(ÿ{¡q((zJww*y,¢Õw`²
(&z*w*$w$R¦/z²!¬zz `r(zyw*¬zw,¦B(zfy(z¦/w*´÷2zz¢fw¡r(¥(w*`z
w,¦?z¡`(z`¡8Õw`²
t J(zf¡Òw±xfw`¦
(zfww*y`r {¡qy¼,[t2Ôzyywz?,yÃt **zo,z
w,¦Ç|J¬(w(¥w*f,
¥(y{ z`Rªy{¡:ww*y(t
õ¨{1(
¬,¬z<yy¥(`z
(z¡¬w*,zw`¦Jz[¥³ Ü í Ë å í*â £ "! ê¤

{w(Rw`¦L¥(((z$*`(z
wwy¼,Z,J{Jzy`zw|¬(w(¥³ ²J(z# z ! $» %
*¹$· &('!
,zGw*(,¢ Ë {w*¬w`z
{w&tf~z[©w*2g(zq¬`¬zz`¡q{z$(zqz÷§zqw`¦¥({y ( w(z©w*¡r(¥(w^¬,,¡zzt
vRR
w*!`¬¬(w*(z
w¥(((zr*`(z©w¢wy{t
°±!y*w`¦ L*z?,yÃt Ñ©w*zy`z[|¬w(¥w*!`?o¦5¥(³
(zz[¥z[i(z[`qyw¢* `w(`z[¿²J¿ vRR[J(zf¬,¬z {ww`¦1¦/¥(zy´³±w,³Ä,{J`{w,w*(z$¬,`¡qzz[t J(z?w±³
(w`²J(zGw*w*(q¥(z²J¼¢z`y$*`(z!ww*y( zy`w(1**zR|¬(w(¥w*,^¦/¥wrw`¦&w*¡r(¥w
,y{w(zJ¡xz?¬z¦/zz[w`zgªy¡mww*y(t E(yz¡w^©w¢wy´³ (yzRz¡q¬z`¥(z*ê ) ê þ (¬(z¥(z§Þ )¬z¥(zVw*¬
((z¡z¥(zfw¡r(`{wfw`¦w*!¢z`yJ`Àªy¡
» Copyright © 2006 by ASME

Þ Þ )`R`k¦/¥(zy´³±w`³`
`{wt! J(zfw¡r(¥(w*!z¡¬z ³
100
¥(z* Rê L²J`¦/w¥( ¢x¿`¥(¡q{¦5¥(zy´³Ãw`³``w^,
T3 / Tf
uz±³±}E¦5¥(zy¬(w¬zztZõ¨*¥z
µ(w`²JR(z$|¬(w®®¥w
,ÑR¦5¥({w
w`¦ê ``
ê ) ê ¥({?(zJw*zy`w*
w,¦z¦5z±³
0.4
zz ,1zL` *zz1²J

(zL(`J
(z^z*w(ww(
0.5
0.6
10
0.5
w,¦§»*··*$· & '!t&°±{Lwzy`w<(zJz(¬w(z1¦/w1(zg¦/¥(zy´³±w,³
,{Ä³Ñ`w
²J` (t %(t¨ J(zz÷2z[w`¦1*`,w*(1ê ) ê Lzy´³
NOx, g/kg fuel
,*zyxq¡(w*t°±z[,(ê ) `
w*,¦5¥(zy´³Ãw`³``{w
`¬(yx
z[`z|¬(w(¥{w&t1×Jw`²Rz*zz`(ê )
,w*(,¢$ê ®z[z`z<(z$¦/¥(zyÁ³±w,³Ä,J`w(²J¼z
w<w,÷§z(z<| ¬(w(¥©w*f¥(z$wr{z[,z[ê ) t
1
______ Exponential relationship ref. 8

õ¨{¥(z!µ`ywºw`²Jz|X¬(w®®¥wX¥(!z
zy`w((¬qw`¦Lz¦5zzz (²J(²Z,?zz¡(z[¦/wJ`Ä³
¥(`y2`Jw*¡r(¥wt1 J(^¬,¬zJ¦/w(¥(JRw*zB,(*z$
1500 2000 2500
|Jº¬(w(¥©w*º²Jºz¡q¬z`¥(z*1`f(w$w*º(z,(w,³
õ¨tRµ?|¬w(¥w*q¦/w*JÞ
Tf, K
) %» $
· Ø Þ ! Þ Þ ) ¸t
y¥(z|Gyz*zy±t J(zw*,[ Ë &!z,w`zrz[Â¥`w*
¦/w*¡8z©¦/zzz ²J`r(w*z¿wf*zrz`¡qz|Gyz*zy
,?òw`¦Jz¦/zz©z f,?ê »*·*·$· &(' Ñ,fê ) ê · ¹t
ó1zrw*¥(z?¥(*zJ`z?z*z[V¦/w¡´÷§zz^w*¥(z
4.0
(z$yw*¬zq(z$(*z¡¬z,¥(z$z{wf`z${¡qy¼,[t
õ&¥(z$»
(w`²J^(z$,w<w,¦Ç|J¬w(¥w*²J*,(z
wC/w40 TC/T41
0.05 0.4
wwy¼,Jw|f¬(w®®¥wf²J(w¥(J*`(zww*y`[tJR¥(*z
,z(w`²JÀ¦/w*$±²Rw*`(zrww*y`wf*,(z<z©®$z¡¬z,¥(z
0.10
0.15
0.05 0.6 `w[,q¦/w(zz©w¢wy`Jwq¡`qz[`¡ Õw`²,z ³
NOx(T40) / NOx(T41)
{w[t« J(zzG¥(*zÀ²^zzz(z`z[`¥(¡q{Gê ú©û ê t
3.0
0.10
0.15
°±º¬(zqê úû
yz
,!ê ¥zrww¡r(¥(w*
wwy{(t
L*©{$z`y±t 2`z$`w¡r(¥(w*Rww*y(<(w*¥y¼zow*
(z
w*z$w`¦$µ[·*¸öw`¦L(z<¡`(z`¡öÕw`²
tJ`y¥y¼,w*Jw`¦
2.0 |Jf¬(w(¥{w&2²J(w*¥¢z[¦/w*$w*¡r(¥w?wwy{(
*z?,y¡w*Lz?`¡qz,w*,`z?(w`²Jª*¥(zB»t
õ¨*¥z!»* (w`²JÀ`w*zz¡(z[¥((¿(zGw±³
zy`wXw,¦
z¦/zz©z (R²J(zz(zf,w!w`¦<|JE¬(w(¥³
{w«{Gå íâ £ "! ê úû ¤ å íâ £ "! ê ú æ¤t E(yz¿(zi`ww`¦
|J¿¬(w(¥w*¿w¢zw`²JG²J¿z[`(!ê æ[R(zf*³
¥`yL|f¬(w®®¥wz[`z
`¬(yx²Jfz¡ú ¬z,¥(z*t
1.0
1500 2000 2500
*¤Jsz¦/zzTz ,<K©w*zy`{w
}J$ê ú æ »*··*$· &' z[¥©w*!w,¦·t ·¹rf(zww*y`Õw`²
41
3.0
`zR*zÑz¥{w<r|<w,¦w`*zL»¹*¸`¨ê þ ê ú æ ·
,
w,¦§z[`y{x»*·*¸ `1zJ(*(zLwwy¼,Ñz¡¬z`¥z`{wt
wC/w40 TC/T41
0.05 0.4
õ¨*¥(zZ»,<(w`²J1,w*Lzz¡q(z[o¥(($zw*zy`w*
2.5
0.10
w,¦^ L*qz<,y±t Ät
óÑ©z¬(
`
(zr,w?yz
z(z
wrê ú æ[(z
z¥y{?,J(*z¡¬z`¥z
`z$¡y`Lz
0.15
0.05 0.6
±²Rwºª*¥zt J(zº¡r¥¿zz¬zy{w¬zº`yw`²mê ú æ *,y{¥z
NOx(T40) / NOx(T41)
0.10
0.15
(w`²J{qª¥(zµ¦/wJ(zzy,w*((¬w`¦Lz¦5zzz z
2.0
z[`w*E²Jx¿(z!|½¬w(¥w*E`w {q*z[`zf`yw`²
z¡¬z,¥(zª*¥(z<»*`qª*¥z
»`&tRsJz[®¥(rz
wwy¼,
Õw`²:,zyw`²^z|X¬(w®®¥w&tE}bz[`w*,(yz
w¢`yg{wºz¥z ì þ ¦/w¡ µ·fwk¹¸ w`¦ ì úû tGvgw*G¬,
w,¦Ñª*¥(z<»(w`²`(w¥(yz¥(yr»¹*¸öz[®¥w
1.5
|J&to°±¡¬(w`*z[w¡r(¥(w*$z(
²Jyy&z¥(y
fyw`²Rz
|Jr¬(w®®¥w&tLvL¥[¥(zw
Lz({¢±xw<©w*¡r(¥(w*
1.0
z¡¬z,¥(z*|¬(w®®¥w²Jyyz¡`z({z$wrz
*,(z?wwy¼,LÕw`²,z$,wt
1500 2000 2500
¤sz¦/zzTz ,rK w*zy`w*
41
õ¨t&»os`w?w,¦|¬(w(¥©w*r²Jr*,(zww*y,¢1w<| Rw¡¬,wrw`¦¨ªy¡m`qz`y&©w¢wy{
¬(w(¥{w²J{(w©w¢wy`
Copyright © 2006 by ASME

Õw`²(w¥(*!(zww*y(q(w*yzt< Jzz(`(w`²q`¬(
1000 Case Tu,% M z[`zº¥w*!¥±¦Ãz(z`
`±¦/z(z[,
zww*y(
C004 1 0. (wyz[t¨ J(zJz÷2z[Rw`¦2{¬¬(($(zJw*¥((`x<yx*zÑLw*(y{x
C011 1 0.92 SS
z¬zz$w*szx(w*yJ¥(¡rz`¥((¥(yz©z<yzzy±t
800 C065 1 1.049 PS
(z<¬z¥(z¥±¦Ãz*¨²J(zzr(zryw(`yLsJzx¢w*y¥(¡rz$
yw`²Rz[zzR&(wÇ*Áª2`2(z[,1,(±¦5z1{z[,z,&z
C036 6 0.0
C040 6 0.917 SS
C060 6 1.224 PS wwy{(R(wy{z[t1õ(w2(z^`zg(w`²J&(z^*z`zL(z[,&`±¦/z
z[`z¦/w*L(z$¥©w*q¥(Ä¦Ã*z
w`²Jz[`¡:w`¦&(zw*yzJ
hEFF, W/m K
600 235 6 solid vane

2
(z`yx *·*¸gz*zE(w¥(*¿(zw*y *`(z(z`r`(Ä¦/z

((zJ¦/z`w*¨t
400
}y{w!(w`²J ª*¥(z !`zz(¬z¡qz`y$(`º¦/w
(yw`²J(r`w?yw*zrwqw*(z*t 1w¬zz?w*$¢,?(zw*
Gz(*(zf`¬¬(y¼`w(<(zfww*y(º¬(yz¥(¡ w,yJ¬(z¥(z
zzz[$(z$`Jz$w*,y&¬(z¥(zt^ Jzz¦5w*zyw(,y2(yw`²R³
200 Hole locations
(º,w*`zÀ±x¢¬¼`yyx!w*(zfwr*z[`z[t 1z²Rzz©w*³

Pressure
¥z[²J{z(z¥©w*2£±~(~(¤w*J¬(z¥(z`£±àL~(¤$z$(yw`²R³
surface Suction surface
0
−0.08 −0.04 0.00 0.04 0.08
((¥(2w*&w*$¡r¥(y,(zw*¥yx¢t×Jzz Ö 2(zLz©÷§z[©*z
Surface distance, m
¤L 1¥zB(wz©®szx(w*yJ|Jwt µºµ[· (z`$`(Ä¦/z
wz¯z[¨²J(kw¥(¦/w*$(z<z©÷§z[©w`¦
ªy¡m©w¢wy{`qJ¬(w¬w{w`y2wr(z$(z`J`(Ä¦/z`z*t
Ö ã £/ê <ê ¤LRw*¡q¬`(^(z
µ[¸ `
*¸¥(¥(yzz
z±x z¥ y{ (w`²`(*!(yz¥((¥(yzzz[¥z
1200
Pressure surface Suction surface
(z
z(zª<w,¦1ªy¡ ww*y(tJ JzVJ· ¢·rz¥y{$(w`²«r(w,³
¼©z[`(yz$z[`z
¬z¥(z<¼®z
(z[,J,(±¦5z[2`z¥y{
w,¦Ç¥{wf¥±¦Ãz<y{w`²J(tR J(¡¬(yzR,$¥w*f¥(±³
¦Ãzr(yw`²J(¥¬(z[,¡ w`¦(zr(w¢,
z`z¦/zzz[`¡
1000
zyw®©{z^z[`(z$¬(z¥(z¥(Ä¦Ã*©z*t
800
õ¨*¥(z `(w`²JJ(z$z(¬z¡qz`y2(,B¦/w*sJzx(wy
¥(¡rz
w,¦B» ¿µ[· `tG Jzwy¼ *`(zq`({w*(r`,w¥(
hEFF, W/m K
2
600
(z`¡qzyw(`w*X,r(zqªy¡ ©w¢wyz[ *`(z*t¿¿(zf¥³
{w!¥(Ä¦Ã*©zf(z`w* yz(*Gryw*(z[gz*zX(w*¥*
400 Case Tu,% M
(z
¥(¥(yzzr¢z({±x$*z[`z[t$ J(zz{(wqªy¡ ©w¢wy´³
C073 1 0.0
(rf(z<yz[(rz[z<z*w&t°±À(z*w&2`wfz
Hole C076 1 0.799 PS
¬(z¥(z¥(±¦Ãz(zz[`
,(±¦/z<
yw`²Rz[t E(w*¥(
,¢x
wwy¼,^(z
yw`²^zJ¥((¥(yzzr,¥(zyw`²^zJz[`,(±¦5z
200 C072 1 1.049 SS
locations
239 6 solid vane
w*z?yz[(z[*z$z*w*¨(`qw*q(z$¬(z¥(z¥±¦Ãz*t
Ezwwy{(o{R¬(zzJ(z$(z[`R`(Ä¦/zJRy{w`²RzRw*rw*
0
−0.08 −0.04 0.00 0.04 0.08
Surface distance, m (z
¥w*º`¬z¥(zr¥(Ä¦Ã*z[t
×Jw`²Rzz[,z[wfz
¤R 1¥(z
w*qz(sJzx¢w*yJ|Jwt »!µ[· z¥(y
fª¥(zr»*2zr(z[`$`±¦/zz¥{w²Rw*¥y¼Àz
yzJÁ¦1(zo{y{z^¥((¥y{zz²^zz$(*(zt
õ¨t <|zz[`J`±¦/z$wz¯zJ³^(,w,¦Ñ}
J(z`¬(¬(w*¬(`zrsJzx¢w*yJ¥(¡rzJ¦/w?w¡¬,w(J
y`*zyxzz¡(z[qx(z
z
w`¦L(z
*`z*t^Ôf,x¡w(z
ó¨(z,y&(z`J`(Ä¦/z$(`(t ó¨(¬z¡z,y§`B(w`²E` ¥(((zB,zz*(z¦/w
`º{y{z¬(z¥(z(z[, *¹,¡qw`³
Ò¥Jz?¬zzzw`¦¨ªy¡mww*y((w*yz,¥(z?¬(¬((w`¦ ¬((zz[R`!z¡¬z`¥zz[`r»*··*$· & '!t~©zrÚ(Ûb<
qy`¡q{`Rw¥((,xºy¼xz$w¥(¥(yztr}J$y{w`²«sJzx(wy ¡(¡<¥(¡b`w(ww([R*`(zqw`²z©®rsJzx(wy
¥(¡rz(
,z¥(y
fy,*zozy`*z(z[`$`±¦/zo{®³ ¥(¡rzLJzy¼,*zy{xr(z({*z$w(z$*,(z$¬(z¥(z<`{wt
z[`z[tõ¨*¥(z yy¥(,z
([tr Jz(`r¦5w*¡ }
z õw*(zzw*w*((zr¥æ(?sJzx¢w*y$¥(¡rz[´£/ÚÛ ø ¤J
,yÃt ¹ ©¦/w*J$wy¼o*`z*(ò¦5w*¡«}
`¦5w*L(z`¡zJ*,(z ,¬(¬(w(¡,zyx$¹*·*··*··
t1}E¡`yy¢,¦/LwL¡w¥(±³
²Jww*y(J(w*yzL,zR(w`²J&t¨°±
(z^z©®¬z{¡qz1w`¦}
((z2²JG`!(`yL(wºw`¦
µr¡¨`ºq¥z(w*ºw`¦»
(zz²^zz$±²^wow`²JRw`¦Ñyw*zyx<¬*©z[ªy¡ww*y(
w*yzRw* ¡º`,
*,(z¥(z
(w*rz(sJzx¢w*yL¥(¡rzRw`¦Ñz[`y{x
w*Gz¬(z¥(z,!¥{wG¥(±¦Ãz*t! Jz¥{wG¥(±³ ¡yy{´w*&tR J(zrsJzx¢w*y$¥(¡rzw*¥(yÀzz*z`yL¡q{yyw`
¦Ãzrww*y`w`²J$²^zzV,$¥(Ä¦Ã*z®{,z$w`¦·(t·µ
$
r, ¦/wy`*zr`©¦5?w$*w¥(º¬w`²^z?¥({z[tr}J
¥(z`
·t ·µ %
¡qzz[tLz?¬z¥(z<¥(±¦Ãz$(z
`z²Rzz ,{ ¦/Lz*(z*,(zsJzx¢w*yL¥(¡rzLLz[¥zx,w¥(
³·(t·(µ$·
,³Ä·t·(µ <¡qzz[tR J(zox¡rwyL¦/w`z<$» ¹r`z ¦ÃwÑw,¦§(zz*tL}¿¡w(z`z^ z`©¦5Lz({z`L¥{z*
¦/w$(zqw*yÀ*`(zr`<,!(yz$¥((¥(yzzz±xfw`¦
¸t wBq¡`yy¨*w¥(À¬w`²Rz
z(*(zr,$¥zw*º*,(zz({
J%· $
(`<,z¦/w*J(z$,¡z¥(¥(yzz¢z({±x(`r(w szx(w*yR¥(¡rzJ(z$w*(z³±w,³Ã±²Rwr¡yyÁw<`(z*t

sJz¦/zz©zk¹ `
(,¿z©¦/zzzEµ·ºwµ[»º(w`² wz¯©{z¢L`$z©÷§z[©*zzR*`y¥(z¨w*<yz[*(Jz*zJxy{®³
z(¬z¡qz`y¨*`(z(z[,$,(±¦5z
`$¡w(z`z
wq(*f¥(±³ `yL¡qw(zy1¦/w<´÷2zz¥((¥(yz©zz(zr`!z³
(¥y{zz$yz*zyt1}*z`z$¥w*¥(Ä¦Ã*©z
z(~,¢w*q¢¥¡r³ {±x ,w*t½õw*`¿y¥®z[¿`(y{zw,¦ ·$&`J(zf*z`z
z²Rzz!E(z!,(*z!· ··( µ èé · ··*»t|z[`yxEz (z`$`(Ä¦/z{z[,z[ y{z[`y{x²Jºzww*y`$¡w¡z³
,yÃt µ[· ¡z`¥z[¡q¬,*z`z
¥©w*¥±¦ÃzV~®`w* ¥(¡Õ¥<`{wt2}J1(z{1((z1¥((¥y{zzJz(±x
w`¦ ¸
¥(¡rz$w`¦?·t ··(µ ,!·(t··(µ
¦/w
±²Rwf*`(zrzw*¡qzzV, (zJz`z²Z,L¹*·*¸ `L¡w¡z¥¡EÕ¥®V`w$w`¦Lµ*t¹t&õ(w
z(J¥(zrw*ÀsJzx(wy¼®¥(¡rzJw,¦g» ¹ kµ· `t°±(yz¥(±³ ¡qw*¡rz¥¡Õ¥,w*Jz±²RzzGµ
,fµt ¹oz
z÷2z[z(z
(¥y{zzfzzq²^zz
ºw º¬zz[t s*w¡ë¢xG, ²J`Rz±²^zzk·t{µ»
`·t(µ t
J(wyz µ*µ 2¡z`¥z[*z`z
¥w*À¥(Ä¦Ã*zo¡¬`*,(z
~`w
¥(¡rz¨w`¦&·(t·*·»*·J`
·(t·*·»*»g¦/wL`
z(LsJzx(wy ó¨(z,y&(z`J`(Ä¦/z¬(z[®¼©w*(t Jõ1Ðp`y¥(y`w*(º¦/w
¥(¡rzJw`¦µ {µ µ[· ,§,¥((¥y{zz{z({z?w,¦µ[·, (z`$`(Ä¦/z<(¥w*($wkªy¡ ©w¢wyz[f*,(zw*$ww*
»·*¸t¨ J(zx,yw(w`²Rz[ èé ä$å
û ò t1}$Ò¥(((z<~®`®³ (yz?,z¡qw*z?w¡¬(yzr,(w*z¦5w*J
w*yr(y*®z*t1 J(
w*G¥(¡rzrw`¦?z¦/zzzEµµw!(zfszx(w*yr¥(¡rzw`¦ 1z¬z[,y{yx¥(z²J(zz`y¥(y,w*(g{y¥zJz?ww*y(
z¦/zzzfµ·r*z?~`wf¥(¡rzw`¦Z·t ··(µ r`f·t·*·(µ (t (wyzZ,¬(yz¥(¡ zw*¡qzz[t1
` µ[¹ (¢*zRz¥(yg¦/wLz³
×`,`¡$, !z[y`ëz µ[» ¡z[,¥(z[¦5¥(yy¬`q*`(z(z[` z`y1w*¡q¬`{w*(R¦5w*Rªy¡bww*yz[(yz
(z[,`±¦/zt~z³
`±¦/zw`*zV`(zw,¦?sJzx(wy¼®
¥(¡rz[L,!` (yz z`yLw,¦Z(zz©w*¡¬`w*(²^zz¡*z¥(((z$yz×J
¥((¥y{zzfz±x!w`¦
(t¹*¸tº}Jrzr(*(zsJzx(wy ÐG|zÄ³Ä~w*ëzLw(zZ®zz[x
~z¢(w*w<zL,yÃt µ
t
¥(¡rzw,¦Z¹ » Gµ[·
(z*z`z<¡q¼®¬,¥{w¥(±¦±*z J(Jw(z
o*z(z`y z[¡r¥(y(yw(ëBª(z$*wy¥(¡zw(zt
~`w<¥(¡rz1²J`^·t ··(µ»(t2 J(L¡q¬,
¥w*r¥(±¦±*z õ¨*¥(z !` ¾©w*¡¬`zJõ1Ðb¬(z[w(¥((
~`w<¥(¡rz1²J`Lz[,zR,<(z¬`²Jzz,*zR¦/w (z
$yz(× w(zo²J{(z
(,w`¦L}
2¦/wJ¥z<(w*
(zf¥w*i¥(Ä¦Ã*zt Rw*z[(G(z·(t··(µ[»À*`y¥(zwGz z(?szx(w*yJ¥(¡rzw`¦$µ
`f»¡yy{w&t1 J(zrw*¡q¬(¥(³
szx(w*yR¥(¡rz^w,¦Ñz©¦/zzzfµ[·oz[`z${Rw·t·*·(µ t {w`y&®w*¡,r²Z,J(z
¡q¬,rz[©w*fw,¦L(z
*,(z*tR~x¡r³
JzzLz¦/zzz^z(z`yyxw`²G*z`*zg¬(z¥(z^¥(±¦±*z ¡qz¼Bw¥((,xww($²^zz`¬(¬y{z[Àfzr¬,¢²Jz
~`w<¥(¡rzÇ,w¥( *·¸w`¦2z*z`*zJ¥{w<¥(±¦±*z z[w&tr°±!*({ww(zr¡`fz[,¡ Õw`² ¬,&¨z
*,y{¥z*t1}fz©©z¬(wfz<(`w`¦L×```¢,¡` !z[¢³ ¬(yz¥(¡q[1` (zwwy{(º¬,,*zr²J(!(z*`z²Rzz
y`ëz µ[» Ätq J(z(*Gszx(w*y
¥(¡rz<`(w`²Rz[!` w¬w*`z{w
(z$Jõ1ÐE¡qw®®zy±t&J`y¥(y,w*(1²Rzz$w*z
(z^*z`zL¬(z¥(z$`$¥{w
¥±¦Ãz^z[`¨,(±¦5zL,z ²JoÕw`² (w*¥(V,y{y¦/w¥(1w`²JLw,¦§w*yz¨¦/w¡ w*r¬(yz¥(¡
²Rzzo(z[`yxzÂ*¥`y±2¥(z
w¬(z¥(zq¥(Ä¦Ã*z`(w**zx {¡r¥y{`(zw*¥(y{xtÐ$,
,zR¦/wL(yw`²J($`w*L`^,zz(z
ywz$wr(z$y{z*(z[z*t zw!w*©y{wzw!w(z*t¿°± ª¥( z (Ç¦/w*r`¿z(sJzx(wy
}~,¢w*¥(¡rz^w,¦Ñ·(t·*·µ*zJ
z[`w*,(yz
`¬(¬(w³ ¥(¡rzw,¦µ µ[· `(zGJ· ·G(,¿`zº¦/w*¥w½¼®z
¡,w*B¦/w*L(zz¢z$*`(z¥(Ä¦Ã*©z*tLõ(wZB¢`Rz¡¬z,¥(æ z (yw`²J(L(¥((w ¬(z¥z!zÀ(yw`²J{t J(zºJ$·
*· (`
w,¦Z»*··*$· & '!Ñ,º¥((
sJzx(wy$¢¥¡rz$w,¦Z¹*··*·*··
,zq¦/w*r¬z¥(z¼®zf(yw`²J(1(¥(w!¥wXz(yw`²R³
r~`w¢¥¡rzJw,¦Z·(t··(µ$w*z¬w$w(z[`$`±¦/z (t< Jzr,¬!¬{ëz
º(z[ò,(±¦5z<`z`$zww*y(
wz¯©{z¢Jw,¦ ¢· ò '!t (wyzyw(,w*(t½¿(zÀ¥w*E¼®z*Jw`²J(z[,¡¶w`¦
z
Î2z[(rz[z
z*w*(`(w`²¡r¥y`*zJ*,`w*( (wyz[(z¬(z[{w²J{ê þ ê · *$» o`*zzJ²Rzyy2²J
º(z[`$`±¦/zrwz¯z[t×Jz[,
`(Ä¦/z
º(zryz[( (z(`(t}b`y¥y¼,w*º<`ywf(w`²J!²Jzzz¬(yz¥(¡
z[®*zz*w`rz?zz¡(z[V¦/w¡ ÜÀ Ý Ë
ä$å Jt Ë (yzrww*y`
z¡¬z`¥zf`wf²J`rz[¥©z[¿w!·(t¹tGõ(w
,w¥(Jµ*t $w<w*¥¢Ç¦/w*1(*r¥(¥(yzzy{z*zy[t1ä$å ºLz (?yw`²Rz[(¥($z({zr±x¢¬¼`y±2ww*y`$z¡q¬z`¥(zr`{w
(yz
sJzx¢w*y$¥(¡rz,z[ºw!(zryz[(z[®*z`¡qz³ (z
(z[,JÕ¥®À,¬(¬(w¢*(z zw(z[,?·t %· *¹,¡w*f(z
¥w
z[ÍtÑä$å k`*`xo¢xo¡w*zL`rJ¦±*w*Lw,¦zrz±²Rzz ¥(±¦Ãz*tL×w`²^zz[(z$(z`R,(±¦5zJz,¬(yx¢t¨ó1*zq¦/w
¡`yy&,fy,*zz((z[to J(zrz(z,yL(z[,?,(±¦/z<wz¦³ (zZ©w¢wyzLww*y`&(zzJ{1J{(´ª§,¢1¥w
¥(Ä¦Ã*©zJ(z[`
ª§©{z¢ Ö J¬(w¬ww`y¨w
ä$å ÍtJ J(zo{y{z±³±w`³±z( yw¢2`²J(²Rw*¥y¼*zJwzz¡w`*z¢xrz,y§wwy{(t
szx(w*y$¥(¡rz
,wf`(z²J{!(zqz($Õw`²,(*yz* J(z,`yx$¥(®z<¬z[<(zz[`
,(±¦/z<!z
,(z$`¡qzzÄ³Ãw`³(w*`w
*`{z^`¡qw*(
´÷2zzJz³ yz[(rz[zrz{wf¥(¬(z[`¡ w`¦^(zr¥©w*!`¬(z¥(z
{E`¬(¬(w¢z[t«$zyz`y±t µ (w`²Rz[¿`¦/w* (* ¼®zVwwy{(q(w*yzt J(z(`q²^zzrw*(`(z[À²J!`º(yz
ä$å » {µ Eµ[· ,Z,Gº¥(¥(yzzºyz*zyJz[` *¸¶Rz ¥((¥y{zzfz±x¿w`¦
¸tE J(zº`y¥(y,w*(r²Rzzw*z
¬z[`ëÀy{z*(qz[*zrz[`$`(Ä¦/z
*º©w*z¬w*(z({ ²Jf±²Rwrz[Â¥`w*& Ø ¾¥(¥(yzz¡w(zy±(,`J{
~`w¥(¡rz$w`¦·(t··*»*¹t
J(zz,*zrw`z$(zryz[( szx(w*y¢¥¡rz(zÕw`²(w$,({wk©y{wzwz
z[®*z$zw*²Z,^yz`f·(t··*»(t yz[(<z*z*t$Rw*¡q¬`(
z
(*f`yw`²½¥((¥y{zz{®³
Îz[*(z[®*zªy¡ ww*y((z[,$,(±¦5z
,z`ºz¦ ³ z(±x¿(`f!ª*¥(z f(w`²Jr`rG(zy{z*(ºz[z
¦/z*z(zw(*yxz¬z!w*ºzr¥((¥(yzzqyz*zy±tr Jz z*w*!(zf`y¥y¼,z[ (z`,(±¦5zr<Gww® `zz¡qz
(yw`²J(f`{w!r±x¬(,y{yx!{zX,(z`w!w`¦
(zyw(`y ²JÀ(zyw`²½¥((¥y{zzrz(±x`t$ J(zr`¬(¬(y,(y{±x
¡`gÕ¥fwz
(yz¡`gÕ¥&tJ°±À¬(,yÑ`¬¬(y¼`w( w,¦,¥(*¡qz`w*$¡w(zy¨¦/wÑ(zJz÷2z[Jw`¦2¥((¥(yzz$z®³
(^*,y{¥zJ{Ryë*zyx
w<z
yw*zww*(z{rwzJwr*w*(w {±xÀw*!y`¡q{`z[`
,(±¦/z
¦/w
(y*®zr(z[ò,(±¦5zr²Z,
`R{*zw*&tló1ëë**rz`y±t {µ 2¡z[,¥(z[rz[`,(±¦5z ¥(z[xvgw`xyzz$`y±t {µ t
¹ Copyright © 2006 by ASME

z[¥w*®¥(zwVwwy{(o{gz[,w*`(yxr²Rzyy¬(z[z[2tL Jz
1000
,y¥(y`{w!¦/wV!©w¢wy`<z¡¬z`¥zf`w!w,¦B·(t¹À(w`²J
C040 Tu=6%
`rz`y$ww*y(º{ryyJz[Â¥(z[ ¦/wr(zfz[`qw`¦
z
C060 Tu=6%
¥w¥(±¦±*z*t
J(zyz[*(z[z<z*w`r,z$¦5w*?µ¸¥(¥(yzz
800 TC/TG=0.728
TC/TG=0.5
z±x¢t1J`y¥y¼,w*L²J(zz
`({w*²J`R¥¬(¬(zzf
(zfyz[*®{z[®*zfz*w*¿²Rzzº¿*ww(X,*zz¡z¢¦5w*rz
¬(z¥(z zºw`¦r(z*w*&tö J(¬(z[®¼©w*y{yx
600
hEFF, W/m K
2
((z`ºz(`¦/w?(z¥w*ºz*t°5¦^`w*º
(w^¥(¬(¬(zz[2z?¥(¡w(´ªz[ Ø X¡qw®®zy(w`²JJ`(´³
{wrz*(((<,y¡w*L`R(zy{z*(
z*z¦/w^
¥(¥(yzz
400
z±xrw`¦
*¸t E`q{y{zJ¥((¥(yzzo{z(±xrw,¦µ¸
200 ¥w¥±¦Ãz
`(w*q{Jyy&yw*z?w<(z
yz[(
z[z*t
Pressure Suction
vgw*(z
`,yx¢^`q(`
(w`²E¬(z¥(z¥±¦Ãz$(z[`
surface surface
`±¦/zw*(z¢²J!¥((¥y{z¢BÕw`²
t Eº(w©w¢wy`
0 (z`,yx¢
w`*zo¬(z[®¼©rzJ$· »(`(t J(zq¬(z[®¼©z[
−0.08 −0.04 0.00 0.04 0.08
(z``(Ä¦/zfz[z[`zX¥zw¾©w¢wy`rÕw`²J( *z[`z
¤L 1¥zB(wz©®szx(w*yJ|Jwt µºµ[· `!!z(,(tÀ J(z`y¥(y`w*º¦/w<¬(yz¥(¡ z¡¬zÄ³
Surface distance, m
,¥(zr`ww,¦·t¹®w¢z
(w*o(w`²«y`zV®z[z`zº(z[`
C076 PS Tu=1%
C072 SS Tu=1%
`±¦/z(`q$(´ª§`R¬(z¥z
¼®z(z[,^yw*z¡`(t
á^,(zyw,y¼©¥(y`w&t J(zº*z`*zÀy{wq{iw*`y¬(z¥(z
Tu=1%
Tu=6%
²J`J`y¥y¼,z[¦/w^(zz
w`¦1(z$¬(z[w(J(w`²Jrª*¥(z
2000
No L.E. Tran.
Tu=6% TC/TG=0.5
&t E(z<(zzJ²J`¨Õw`²!w¥(1w`¦(zJww*y`1(w*yz1`1z^z³
1600
No coolant
¬z¡qz`y1z¡¬z,¥(z*¨(zrw*,yL¬(z¥(zyw*?©z[,z[
x ¸tJ J{z`zr²J`$`¥z[ºxfrw*,yÑwwy¼,JÕw`²
`zrw,¦Zw(yxGµ*t ¸:w`¦J(zr¡`(z[,¡:Õw`²
tr J(zz²J``
1200 (w*`y*yw1z`zJw,¦w*z^¬z©z^²J(z<ê þ ê ²Z,1z³
hEFF, W/m K
¥z[w·(t¹(tRÎ2w`²Rz(r(z<ww*y,¢Jz¡¬z`¥z
z[`z
2
(z
ww*y`J¡,gÕw`²`z*t^óÑ®,¬wy¼,((zz
z¥(y?w
800
(©w¢wy`RÕw`²,z,w*(w`²J(z[`yxV¦/w*±x¬zz
z[`zJ<w*,y(¬(z¥(z$yw*Ç®¥(zJw<zr¬zzJww*y`Ä³
400
w`³±¡`(z[`¡ Õw`²E`z
,wt
Pressure Suction
surface surface
õÿ¡ ©w¢wy{<(yw`²J(
`{wt JzG,wEw,¦<ªy¡ ww*y(Ew
0
−0.08 −0.04 0.00 0.04 0.08
¡`(z[,¡ Õw`²EJ**zx
¤R 1¥(z
w*qz(sJzx¢w*yJ|Jwt »!µ[· ì þ
*ÿ
Ï òþ
£ÃÙ ¤
Surface distance, m
õ¨tVRw¡¬,wrw`¦L(z[,J`(Ä¦/z¬z[w*(J²Jf(, ì ú©û ¢Þ â

æ
²J(zzÞ:
(z*,(zr¬(& â (zwwy{(À(w*yzr¬(!
Jz<¬(z¥(zq¥(Ä¦Ã*©zr(z[`$`±¦/zo{ª*¥(z ¢{$(w (z
¬`²Jz<z[w&2`|Jw`²J(z¢¥¡rzJw,¦Lw`²J[t
²Rzyy¬z[z[2tR J(z
(,o*z
o(z[`J,(±¦/z?(¥(w* J((w`²J,?(zrww*y(r(w*yz<®¼,¡zz[ Ï þ (w¥(yz
w(z
²Jºy`¡q{`J(z[,$,(±¦5zV,¥(*¡qzz[¢xÀ(* ,^¡`yy2`J¬(*`y±zzf²J(z â Ï þ z¡,(Z©w*(`t
¦/zzz`¡ ¥(¥(yzzJz÷2z[[tR×Jw`²Rz*z`z^¬(z[{w(L`z Ù ^(z
z©¦/zzz(yw`²J{
,w(,q{J*zq¢x
w(z$²Jf¥((¥y{z¢Õw`² ,yw*(r(z<¬z¥(z¥±¦Ãz*t
ó1zG´¦J(zww*y`$Õw`²J<¬(¬z[!(zw*¥((`x!y¼xz[L,
(Bszx(w*y¥(¡rz?(z¦Ãw*,(yz
¬(z¥(zq*z$z³ Ù £/£5ÚÚ(ÛBÛ
¤ ¤ ÿ
Ù
2þü

2þü
y`¡q` z[º(zÕw`²
t J(z®z[z`z!¿(z[,`±¦/zq¦/w
qww*y`z¡¬z`¥zr,ww,¦Z·(t¹{yz¦/w?(z¬(z¥(z }*z`*zªy¡m©w¢wy{<z÷2z[*z(z[t ~z(zfwwy¼,r(w*yz
¥(±¦Ãz$,q¦/w*J(z$¥w*¥(Ä¦Ã*©z*t w*,y(¬(z¥(z
(w*¥y¼zzz[q(z¦/zzz[`¡:w,y¬(z¥(z
õ&¥(z *q(w`²JJ`(`R(z$((zsJzx¢w*yR¢¥¡rz ,$zZwwy{(Jz¡¬z`¥zJÑ,w¥(1`y´¦(w`¦(zg¦/zzz[`¡
(z<¥{w¥(±¦±*zr(z`
`±¦/zo{(w*
,?²RzyyL¬(z[z[2t z¡¬z,¥(z*¼®z[`yÙ
2þ(ü
*`y¥(z^`¬(¬w¢r±²^wtÑvgz[,¥(z
J(z(wG©w¢wy`
Õw`²¬(zw*i{¡r¥G{(zr`¿z w,¦Ñz`©z
yw*z[¬(,y&(yw`²J(
`{w`z?z[`w*(z*t
(w ¥©w*¥(±¦ÃzGww*y,¢Õw`² `®£ÃJ%· $
*¤t J(zºzz 1w¡q{{¡r zoªy¡ wwy{(º¥(`*z(zf¥(¡rz<w,¦ªy¡
wwy¼,JÕw`²¬(z[{w(<,zrz(¬z¡z,y1ê ê ,w wwy{(w`²J^,o(z zJw`¦2z(wy{zÑ(w*¥y¼z`g¡,yy¢`
(w`²G¥w<¥(±¦Ãzz^w(z^²J<(zþ J $· »(,(t ¬w*(yz*t
J{$yz[
w²Jzyx¬*z[ºw`²J
w`¦R(w*yzt< Jz
}y{(w*¥*(z$¬(zw*?`z$(*(zJ`(z
(`(((z ªy¡m©w¢wy{<w*®ª*¥(`{ww`¦Ñ}
1*¬(z¥(z`


¥w¥±¦Ãz$y{z(*(Z®w`²J(z[,¡mw,¦&(z
ww*y(
w*yzRw`¦

!
#"
µ·*·ºì(µ ¢·ºw*yz,¡zztE(zq,Xz[`r(zfyz[*¢³ $!%'&( *)+
(ºz[z*Jzf¡º¬w*rw`¦
(zº,z©w`*zz[¿x!ªy¡ +&(!,%.-/#-$"01325476(8:9 ;<(>= <? =
wwy{(
w,¦/z!w!(zqw*zw`¦¹*·f,¡zzt J(zz`z @ .AB 5C !%. D(D D(;
¡`xªy¡ww*y(
¥®{z[z©¦/zzzµ wr»*·¦/wLz`¡q¬(yz* EF%HGIJ 0JK2.8:8 <(>L =J ;
²J(f(w`²,$(zr*z`z
z÷2z[z(z<w`z
`©z 16MK2476(8N9 D(=(O?=(= ;?;(;(;
w,¦^µ[·*·B(w*yz`¡qzzR{R`¬(¬(w({¡`zyx<·(tµ*t¨vLw(JzJ`y±t {µ
(w`²^z$,&(zL(*oz÷§z*z(zRyw*zRw(zRww*y(J(w*yz P
--CQ
$AB 5C%.& .RS%. -0>TU2476(8 N 9 VIL?=(= VL(=(=
¦/wÑy{w`²º(yw`²J(J,ww,¦§·(t ¹R{¨*z[`y{x
¡q{{(z[x$(* T,6W$16XKQY[Z\I]?^3_ =J DJ<O =>D<XO
¦/zzz`¡¥((¥y{zz*t EV$¥(¥(yzz{z(±x
w,¦Çµ *¸
(zz÷2z[*z(zf¹*·º`¡qzz$¦/w*¡ (zfww*y(f(wy{zq²Z,
z[¥zw·t ·¹(t¨ J(Jz¦5zzz<(w`²Rz[¡,yy{z^z[z[`z h-film / h-no film
Àªy¡ z÷2z[{z(z¥(zrwf¥((¥(yz©z`
y{w`²J(q,w 1 2
w,¦Zµ*t¹t1}J?¹*·o(wy{z
,¡zzJ(z
z÷2z[{z(z
z[`z[fw
10
η =0
·t %· (t1õ(w¥((¥(yz©z
¢z({±xqw`¦µ[¸ (z
z©÷§z[©*zz<,
¹·w*yz`¡qzz1²Z,^yw*zw·(t(µ $`Lz(zR(yw`²J{?`{wt η =0.1 1.5
L`ëz(2z?`y±t µ §(w`²^z¥({z
*`(z$¥wf¥(Ä¦Ã*©z<z¦ ³
w -fillm / w - no film
¦/z*z(zJ*,y¥(zL(z`J·(t(µ
`R¹*·$(wyz`¡zz[t1à1z¥(z
¥(±¦Ãzrz÷2z[{z(z²J`
z*z!yw`²Rz[¨z{·(t· `<¹·´³ 1.0
,¡zzt$ J(zzz¥(y`z*zxf{¡qy¼,^w(wzz¬w*z[
xÐw
`vgw*y »· t<×*(z*z`*zz÷2z[{z(zr*`y´³ 10
0
¥(z`zow*¡qz¡qzLz¬wz2t×Jw`²Rzz[(zz<`z$¦/wJz(z
yw`²¿(yw`²J(<`{ww*R(z$¬(zz©zrw`¦Ñyw`²E¥(¥(yzz*t
~z(±xrwrz`y2z[`J`±¦/zt õw*qªy¡ ©w¢wy{Gz η =0.2
`w!w,¦Bz[``(Ä¦/z²J ªy¡¶ww*y(!w (z[``±¦/z
²Jw*¥(gªy¡mww*y( ã üÿ J{zx
Ö
ã üÿ ã ã *ÿ
* ÿ
Ö ÿ
ÿ
µ ùô
-1
10
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

°5¦ ô ù L`&yz[,Lw(z*`w?z,yww*y(J1(zz[z2(òz w-film / w-total

*¤J|wr v^w¢,(
w(yx
z[Â¥(z¡zR^w
¬(w`z¥¯zJww*y(
w<*(zz
(z<zz[À*`y¥(z¦/w ô tJ J(z
±²Rw¬`,¡zz ù , ô `z
{zx h-film / h-no film
ù £/ê !ê ¤ £/ê ºê þ ¤ 2.4 2
1.5
ô £/ê ºê üý ¤ £/ê ê þ ¤ 2
ê z`zL¦/wÑz*(¨zyx(w
vRRÑzy`{z^w?z*( η =0
w -fillm / w - no film
1.0
²J(w(w*Rzy{xrw(z(¥(y`(o¬(w¬zzJw,¦& v^RtL°5¦
µ ô ù qy{zf` zw$(zz(w (zz[i¦/wz`y
wwy{( tX×w`²^z*zZ,r(* ¥((¥(yzzºyz*zy{r(zf*z`z
1.6
*,y{¥z¦5w* ô ry{w`²
RwG`rz`y
ww*y(º¡x!yyz η =0.1
z[Â¥(z[q²J(zÀ v^R,z
¥(z[2t
}ww*y``q{r²J²J¾¦/w¡ (zf(y*®z*Jzz
1.2
yz<ww*y,¢$*`y`(yz¦/w?z,yÇ©w¢wy{t
×,&&Ð¥((
,fó1ëë** »µ Lw`² `¦/w*
q*`z±xw`¦J{z,y^ww*y(
,,(*z¡zz|¥(zy¥(¡rz{r¬w*¬w*w*`yRw!z 0.8
szx(w*y¢¥¡rzw¬w`²Rz[ 1t$ J{$z(¬w*(z¢$$*zz±³ η =0.2

,y{yxrz±²Rzz!·(t
*¹`À·(t *¹tL J(z
yw(,yÑww*y,¢RÕw`²½`z
¬(w*¬w*w*,yw
zBszx(w*yR¥(¡rz[t¨°5¦Ñ`yyw`¦&zB©w¢wy` 0.4
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
²Rzzr¥z[k¦/w*ªy¡ ww*y(2(zz,*zszx(w*y$¥(¡rz w-film / w-total
¤ i{ vR½©w¢`(
J,yÁ¦L(z<(yz*`y¥(z*tJRw(z[Â¥(z¢yx¢zVz,*z
z`y
(z`J`(Ä¦/z{Rz¥z[Àx(z`yx ·*¸t õ¨t1¹
°±z[,z©w¢wy{$Õw`²¥(z$wrz(*©w*&t

Õw`²:,z,(zfÕw`²m¬(w*zztó1(zq²ZxR(zÀ{z±³
1.5
,yz[`J`±¦/zJ©z[,zwr*w¡¡qw®`zRz?z$z
No Film Cooling wwy¼,Jz¡q¬z`¥(z*t$ J{$`ºz<(w`²Jfxz[Â¥`{z
1.4 Film cooling
(z`Lyw¢$,z[w*(zJ(yz^©w¢wy`1z¡q¬z`¥(z*ê þ(ÿ ¢,
z[Â¥(z!z`yLz[`$`(Ä¦/z<©w¢z©¯z[ Ö ²J
(zw(zf,z[iw*i(z!*z`zkwwy¼,z¡¬zÿ
,¥(z* ê þ
hI−REQ / hI
1.3
,zV¥,y1(z[`$`±¦/zwz¯z[ Ö ÿ t
óLÂ¥`{z
1.2 z`y2z[`Jyw¢r{z
Ö ÿ
£/ê Jÿ ºê þÿ ¤ µ £ ê þ ºê þÿ ¤
Öÿ
1.1
£5ê Jÿ ê þ ¤ £/ê Jÿ ê þ ¤
1.0
0.0 0.1 0.2
hAS/wCCp
0.3 0.4 0.5 õw*R(wªy¡mwwy{(
õ¨t
°±z[,z©w¢wy{
z[Â¥(z[f¥(zowoÕ¥(q(z[`(t ê þ ê þÿ Ö ÿ Ê £/ê Jÿ ê þ ¤ £±» ì þ ËRÌ ¤
õ¨{¥(z¹{yy¥(,zzz÷2z[rw,¦²J{²J{©w¢wy` ²J(zz Ê (z
¥(±¦±*z,z[w`¦^(z
*`z*t°±Àz¡w,¦^z
w(z¿`¡w¥(w`¦ww*y,¢Àz[Â¥(z wE¡,¢`½E©w*³ (z`J`(Ä¦/z`w<(Jz[©w*¡z
`¡(¡¥(¡«¡z`y&z¡¬z`¥z*t J(zzrz¥(y
`z
¦/w Ö ÿ
Ö ÿ µ Ö ÿ Ê £Ã» ì þ Ë Ì ¤
¿ww*y,¢Ä³Ãw`³±¢,z¡¬z`¥zG`{wiw`¦·(t¹(
,¿¡ (Á³
¡r¥(¡b¡qz,yLz¡¬z,¥(z³Ãw`³±¢,<z¡¬z,¥(z`wfw`¦?·t t EV,y{y(wwy{($w*(w$ªy¡©w¢wy{z?*z`zRÕw`²G`z
}y{w($ª¥(zr²J`
zz¡(z[º¥((f(w¡`y2*,y¥(z$¦/w Rz[¥z[x`y´¦wr`R(z$z
ww*y,¢Rz¡¬z,¥(z
°±©w*(zyJ`º v^ z¡`y^w¥©{z »*»À`!%» Ñ, w¥((yzt1 J(z
(ë(zz » Ät1 Jzxf`z${z L`(yz°t J(J`y{z
,y{w
y¥®z<¡q¼¢³Ã`(z
*`y¥(zo¦/w*o(zqz(z`yR(z[,<`±¦/z Ö ÿ
Ö ÿ µ Ö ÿ Ê % £ ì þ Ë Ì ¤
wz¯©{z¢tá^`¼,w*(zr¬(w*¬z{z
(w`²Jº L,(yz<° Jzz¡ Ö Ê ì Ë Ì `¿zz¡`z!xX,¥¡r³
z¥(yz[!ºª¥(z¡q{y,Jwª¥(z¹(t}¬(¬z´k}:*z
(z
z,y{Jw,¦Ñ(z
`y¥(y,w*(J¥z[qwrz(z`z$ª*¥z<¹t (¬,²J{z<wÿ z$ z!þ xy{®z
(z[,z[ºw`z
,y´¦^
¥(±³
J(zJ¬wzJyw*¬zRw`¦&z?¥(*zJoª*¥z?¹Bz¥(yL¦/w*¡ ¦ÃzJ`z(t1Rw¢wy{`((zy{1z^z,y®~®`w*¢¥¡rz
yw`²RzLz`y(z[,^`±¦/zJ`RzJ¦/*{wrw`¦&w*,y§©w¢wy` ,w¥(Ñ·t ·µ[·t}¿`(zy(,ÑJyz*®³Ãw`³`¡zz2`w(z[`
µ·(t1çJ(r(zz
*`y¥(zJ*z Ö Ê ì ËRÌ · »t&}z[`³
¥(z[¦/w*ªy¡ ww*y(©z[,z[2tró1zº(w¥(*º²Jªy¡
wwy{($(zz÷2z[*z$(z[,^`±¦/z©w¢z©¯z[ Ö Lz³ ¥(y`?©w¢wy{,((zyR²J!²Jÿ ºþwÀ*`(z¬,!,ww`¦
z`yyxy{w`²Rz$`º(z¥,yL(z[,
`(Ä¦/z<©w¢z©¯ z[ Ö ·t ·¹$*zJ(z$`¡z*`y¥(z¦/w Ö ÿ Ê ì þ ËRÌ t
õÿ¡ ww*y(G©z[,z Ö w*¡q¬`z[¿wG(w ªy¡ wwy{(t õ¨*¥(z
(w`²J(zoz[Â¥(z(z[,`(Ä¦/z$,w¦/w`yy
J(
©z[,z`Gz¥(( `¼,y±&´¦Rªy¡ ©w¢wy{`¥(z ªy¡8ww*y(`º(wªy¡ ww*y(t i(y{zoªy¡ ww*y(`
y`¡q`1w*¥(`xqyx*zRwrz[w¡z$¥((¥(yz[t {(z
yw*¬z*1(zz÷2z[rw,¦?*©w*¥((¦/w*
(z©z[,z[
Rw¡¬,(1ª*¥(zL¹*J`
¹`$w`²JÑ`2(zJww*y`Õw`² wwy{(oz¡q¬z`¥(z
Jz(¬z[z[fw<z
¡`yy±t
(zJ{z,y§©w¢wy{B,¬(¬(w¢*(z`q*z Ö Ö
`w{1yzLz*zJw Ö *,`{w(&²Jzr(zJ vRG©w¢`(
R¬(zz[tg J(z$zy`w*((¬rz±²Rzz ô ` Ö ^yy¥(`z[ ¡qw*zJ®z¬zzJw`¦ Ö ÿ Ê ì þ Ë Ì t&°5¦1¡¬((z¡zÿ
Lww*y ( ÿ
¿(ª*¥(z*t EE v^bw`{X` ô · »!È ¥z[ºw[Ò¥(w*º²J,yy2ªy¡ ww*y((z{y{zB,
Ö *ÿ
Ö *ÿ
»¢zLzJ`¡qzLz¥(yR`1²J(z ô · µ yw(`y2*,y¥(zRw`¦Ñê þ `z
z?`¡qz*t
,r(z$(z[`J,(±¦/zJ`w<²J`
µt ·tÑvgw*¬`Jw`¦¨ª*¥z
¹ °±z,y2(z[``(Ä¦/z[t J(zz$`z^z*z`y2`¬(¬w¢(z1¦/w1{®³
(w`²G`Lz*zr´¦2(zJ(z`R,(±¦5zL,w$µ*`¥(L(z[,yxr`yy z,y&ww*y(t1~z
¬(¥¬w*zow`¦Ñ(J²^wërJwrw¡¬,z
(zV©w¢wy`$¥(zÀ¦/w*ªy¡ ww*y(zzr$(wz[®¥w (z
`(zwwy{(oÕw`²JJ¥(z$wr vRR`ªy¡mwwy{(
z[Â¥(zww*y,¢¨¦/w ô *`y¥(zLyz^`·t»(t&ó1z(w*¥* w¡¬,w(&`zJ¡z1¥((
ò{¡q¬((*z¡z(z¡qz*t1 J(
(zz[z[`z${ ô ²J`zJ¦/w*¡ (z$ww*y($(w*yzLLw ,¬(¬(w*,ë*zÀz[`¥(z<((z¡z<(zz
(zozyz³
w*¡zgz(zJw*¡q¬z`z[x Ö *ÿ
Ö *ÿ
`¬(¬w¢(( *,¢z`yww*y(J¥z[*,2¥(,(yz1¦/w&R±²^w¡qz³
w(z*((zzr{*Áª2`Jz[`z<fz[Â¥(z[f©w¢wy`´¦^ {w`yR`,y{x{t J(
(z¡z,yw`¡q{y,zwªy¡
¥((`,y¦/w*qw`¦1(z<©w¢wy`^R¥(zq¦/w*gªy¡mwwy{(t wwy{(Jz[`1`(Ä¦/zt1 J(zZ©w*zy`{w<*z
x
õÿw*¢¥z
õ¨{¥(z$¹<®w¢zJ(w*J*©w*¥(g¦/w*J`x{z[,z$(z
*zÄ³ z
,yÃt »*¹ &¦/w
,**zz[ `xfw`¦J(wy{z?$¥(z[2t Eº(w
,*z?©w¢wy`Jz¡q¬z`¥(zB¦/w*Rz(zJªy¡wJ(w*³5ªy¡mwwy{z w*±³5Õw`²½(z
|J¥(zy¢¥¡rzR,z[qw*$Òz,¡zz[ Ï
*,(z[t1õw*¨Õw`²G
(zJ¬`²Jzzw*¨*`wªy{¡ ©w¢wy´³
(r(zVz,*z<©w¢wy`Jz¡q¬z`¥(zz[`z<`(zoÕw`²
¬(w*zzt i{rªy¡m©w¢wy{<(zzo{z[©z[,z{(z ÜfÝ &þ · %
$£ í Ï ¤
û ú £ ï Ï ¤
û ú òò £ ð Ï ¤ û û ä$å û ò Þoß æ )

²J(zz ð Ï {(zrw*¡`yz[`©zrw(zr¥±¦Ãz*t í Ï
, ï Ï `z(z$¬((zJw,¦&(z$(wy{z[tLõw*R¡¬(y±x í Ï 1200
,¥¡z[z[Â¥`y¨w ï Ï t No cross flow

Ew±³5Õw`²(z|J¥(zy¥(¡rzRJz[¥z[x
x/d=10
1000 d,mm
0.5 z/d=5
ÜfÝ Ü Ý &þ µ Ë ß£ í Ï ¤£ ï Ï ¤£ ð Ï ¤*£ Ó þ Ó ¤

f
hAS/wC, W−sec/kg−K

800
1.0
Ó ` Ó `zf(zº¡,oÕ¥(zq¦/wr(z©w*±³5Õw`² ,

Òz<þ z¬z[{ zyx¢ti°±³±y{(zq¡¬((z¡rz$(w*yzrzºyw`²Rz
600 2.5
x/d=5
w*±³5Õw`²¬z`y±x!`¿wf`*zz[ {¡q¬((*z¡zw*yz[t 0.5

õw*J³±y{z?w*yz Ë ß · $¹ %
((Ü í · µ$· (Ü ï · $ 400 1.0
Ü ð · *%· (`qÜ Ó · %¹
(µt 2.5
E(w*¥(w±³5Õw`²:(zf|¥(zyr¢¥¡rzo{zy¼,*zy{x x/d=2
(z({zw(z²J`yy´³Ãw`³ÁÒz
¬*©{ ð Ï tk×w`²^z*zLz
200 0.5
w*±³5Õw`²bz[®¥w½w*(y{x¿Õ¥zz[ixG(`{wt 2.5
óÿ¥(*zw`¦
¥(¬(z[`¡pw*rÕw`²
ð è ¡z Ó Ó
¬(w*¬w*w*,y&wz<w*,yÑw*$Õw`²R³± w`³ÁÒzRÕw`²`þw ²J
0
0 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000
−1
è z(r(z
yz(qw`¦L(z$¡¬{*z[¥(±¦Ãz*t
Coolant unit Reynolds number, Re1 cm
çJ(<(zzy`{w({¬¦5w*L(z${z,y§~®`w*r¥(¡rz õ¨t < ~®z({±xw,¦Çwwy¼,^wr*zw¡zxr¬,`¡qzz[t

` èé ÿ ÜfÝ ä$å *Þoß Ö ÿ Ê ì þ ËRÌ Lª¥(zqw`¦?¡qz
,!zfz©ª(z[2tº J($ª*¥(zw`¦¡qz

(z(z[,<`±¦/z
wz¯©{z¢R¢z
x
(zww*y`Õw`²G`zJ¬zL¥(Ñ¥(±¦±*z 1.0
yz(`q¬`&t1°±JJ*zx z/d
Ö ÿ Ê ÜfÝ ËRÌ í ò
GCROSS / GJET = 1
0.8 1
ì þ ä$å Þoß Ï
Nusselt number ratio
õ¨*¥(z Àw`²J Ö Ê ì ¦/wr(z(w!w*Ä³/Õw`² ,z

,k¦/¥(©w*w`¦<(z!¥(ÿ (f sJzþ x¢w*y¥(¡rz¦/w*zÒz[ 0.6
ä$å æ ä$å Ï t«}(zw,zºz`z[$z!z[Â¥(z 3
wwy¼,$Õw`²mzz[,z¦/w*rÀ**z!*,y¥(zrw`¦ Ö ÿ tº J(z¥((
szx(w*yR¥(¡rzJw`¦Ñ(z^ÒzJ{Jzy`z[wr(z
z(z,y1¥(( 0.4
szx(w*y$¥(¡rz[¨zqw!zr(z[,yxfz,¡zw`y
¬(z¥(zt^°5¦1(zLÒzZÔf¥(¡rzLJ·(t»*¹¢,r(z
ww*y`Ä³
w`³±¢`z¡q¬z`¥(zr`{w2ê þ ê 2<·t¹((z©w¢wy`$¥(( 0.2
5
szx(w*y¨¢¥¡rz1L`w*¥(1,y´¦w`¦2(zJ¡`(z`¡¥((1z({
szx(w*yL¥(¡rztÑõw*R(zz<,¥¡¬({w(Læ (z
ww*y`R¥((
szx(w*yr¥(¡rzr`w*¥(»*¹· î ·*·*·
t J(zª¥(zÀw`¦
¡qz2&(wLJw(¦/¥(w*
w,¦ ð Ï `,
ð Ï ¹&¥(z[2t 0.0
2 4 6 8 10
R¥(*z,z
(w`²Jq¦/w*Jw*yz
`¡zz[(·(t¹,¡¡f(µt ·,¡¡f*, Hole spacing, x/d
»t ¹,¡¡ft}<(z(w*yz®¼,¡zz<zz[,z Ö ì þ ©z[,zt ¨õ t <óÑ÷§z[©?w,¦Çw*JÕw`²w*qz[Â¥(zfww*y`gÕw`²
t
|w*$¥(¬({*yx¢¨¡`yyÑ®¼,¡zz
(wyz
*z<zzª¥(z
w,¦Ñ¡z[t¨ J(z$¡¬(y`w*
(gª*¥z
Rwr¥(z?(z
¡`yy Õw`²
t E(z (wfªy{¡ ww*y(f<¥z[2R(z¡`
Õ¥G,w
*,y{¥zR¦/w* Ï `fä$å æ 2`qy`*z$*`y¥(zJ¦/w í Ï tR×Jw`²Rz*z[ ,¬(¬(w*(zow*(z*¨`!,*(´ª§,yxfz¥zq(zrz`y
(zx!`(w*
z`(,yx(w*z&t Ö ÿ ¨²J(!z¬z®rw* Öt
(zz$¬,,¡zz¡r¥(1z?y,*zz(w¥(*qw<{z*z$(z$z³ õ¨*¥"z $(w`²J^ÜfÝ *w*($w zwr`^®Á÷2zzZw¡r(³
{z[q¡ ®¡¥(¡ ¡`z`yz¡¬z,¥(z*t {w(Jw`¦ í Ï ` ð Ï *,y¥(z[t J(?$¥(z
wz(`¬w*y`w*
õ¨*¥z B(w`²JR(z$wÄ³/Õw`²z÷2z[Jw|J¥(zyJ¥(¡rz w,¦B(z!w*zy`w*Ezx*w¿(`!,z*t«õÿw*¢¥z !z
¦/w Ó þ Ó µ*`ryy{¥`zLzy¡,w*(¨w`¦&z`y ,yÃt »*¹ Ñ(w`²^z!z¥(yr²Jzzzw*`zrºª*¥(z À²Z,
w(yxVwwy{(t&~¡`yy ð Ï *,y¥(z^,zzz[z[w
¡q{{¡q zRz z[,zJ`f·(t t&°±J(,y{yx
zz¡qz[f`¬¬(w¬(`z$w`z<
(z`,(±¦/z?z[¥©w*!¥(z
ww*Õw`²
t×Jw`²Rz*z[2¡`yy ¡q{{¡¥(¡ |¥(zy?¥(¡rzRw*f`(zy¨Õw`²E¥((r(zw
ð Ï *,y{¥zLz¥(yLry`*zJww*y`L¬(z¥(z
w*¬(g¥((yzRz Õw`²¿¡`ÇÕ¥& Ó þ tL×Jw`²Rz*z(J`¬(¬w¢,^(z$(z[`
(wyz?¬*©{ í Ï y¼,z*t^Ôf ({¡q ( í Ï ¡(¡q zRz `±¦/zo{z[,(f²J!{z[,( Ó þ ¨Gw**w*
z[¥w*z[`J`±¦/z$¥(z$w©w*±³5Õw`²
t i(zf`yy2z w<(z
z(¬z¡z¢`y&(,t
z`y&©w¢wy{<J¥(z[¦/w*Rªy¡m©w¢wy{(zz
J(ww*Ä³

µ¤<R(wwzwwy¼,rz¡q¬z`¥(zf`{wLê ê R¡(¡<¥(¡
η ¡qz,y2z¡q¬z`¥(z
`{w(ê ê 2` Ø þ é *` y¥(z¦/w*Jw*
(z$¡z`y2`q vR$t
TM/TG TC/TG
0.60
»¤rR(ww*zz(z,y$(z[`q`(Ä¦/z©w¢z©¯z,´÷§zz
0.0 0.6 0.4
0.1
0.2 szx(w*yR¥(¡rzR¦/w^w*w*y,ªy¡mww*yz[q*`z[t
0.0 0.7 0.5
¤^R(wwz
z÷2z[*z(z$*`y¥(zR¦5w*R(z$ªy{¡:ww*yz[q*`(zt
¤&J`y¥y¼,zLz©®z`y2`$z,y¢¥(±¦±*zJz¡¬z,¥(z1¦/w
0.1
hI−TBC / hI− NO TBC
w*y`ªy¡mwwy{z*,(zJ²Jf,q²J{(w*¥Z vR$t
0.40 0.2
0.0 0.8 0.6
0.1 ¹¤^J,y¼©¥(y`z$(z
z`y2(z`,(±¦/zwz¯z¦/wLªy¡
0.2
wwy{z*,(z*2`z[®¥z[À(z[,`(Ä¦/z
wz¯zB®¥(z<w
w*±³5Õw`²E¦5w*`q¢z`y&w(yxww*yz[q*`z*t

¤ Ðzz¡(zö(z:z[Â¥(z[ í Ï ¦/w*«` z`yi¥((
szx(w*y¥(¡rzrw`¦<»*¹· î ·*·*·
æ Z, ¦/w*r( í Ï z³
0.20
z¡q{z?(zz[Â¥(zwwy¼,JÕw`²`zo¦/wz<z{z<*,(z
¥(±¦Ãz*t
¤LÐzz¡(z(z$ww*y`±³±w,³Ã¡`(z`¡Õw`²X`zR¦/w*Rz
0.00
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6
´÷2zz¢©w*{w([t
Rw¡¬,w<w,¦Ç vR`q¡z`y*`z?z[`J`±¦/zt
hO / (k/t)METAL
õ¨t <óÑ÷§z[©?w,¦Ñ vREwz[Â¥(z Ö ÿ t J(z$(w*z$w`¦2ªy{¡:ww*yz[rw^w(yx<z,y&ww*y($¦/w^ vR

w`z[f*,(z{
z¬zz
w*º¬z[´ª§r,¬(¬(y`w*(t 1wy´³
×Jz``(Ä¦/zfw*¡q¬`w*`z¡*zf,¥¡(!z y¥(,z¦5`¡qz²Rw*ë¦/w1¡`ë($ww*y(
w*z*LL(zy{¬®³
z{zf*`zfww*yz[¾¥((Òz¡q¬((*z¡qz<ww*y(t½°± ¦/¥y^wk(ww*zÀ¬z[´ª§q*`z*zw*¡zxtf 1wº¡,{`fz
z[w*( z[À`¡q¬((*z¡qzL(w¬(*`y1fzV ¦/ ¦/w(¥
w*!(z¥(zrw,¦^ªy¡ ww*y(f`!w¢,(*¡¬y{z
¬w*w*fw,¦^z<*,(z*²J(zzr¬(Àª`,(*z¡qz¡xz ±²Rw`³¡zw*,yÕw`²½,z$J¥(z[tLvLz[`¥(zV(,`zB*,yÁ³
(zz[z[2tR×Jw`²Rz*z[(RR¦/zyJ,[²J,zzz,yÑww*y( ,(yzJ,^yy¥(`zz*z`y2w,¦ÑzJ¦Ãw÷2z[(<z©®z`y
,¬(¬(w*º{$¥(z[2¨,
zrzy`*zz÷§zw`¦Jzyx(w*! (z`,(±¦5zr¦/w
ªy{¡ ww*y(fGz¦/zzzº¹,
L{
vR w*!zw*zw,¦Z¥(fz`yRw*y{xÀw*$ªy¡ ww*y( *,(zf*zw*¡zx (w*z&t Ezz!*`y`(yz*R(`G,z
²Rw*¥(yz$¡q{y,[t ((zo¥((¥(yzzq¢z({±x´£
¸r¤&,zr¥(z[2t J(z(,f,
yw`²Rz¥((¥y{zzz(zo(w`² {z,yLw*y{xºww*y(
vgz(zªw,¦L v^Rt vLz`¥(zw,¦Z(zryw`² w*®¥±xfw`¦Jz º¡qw*zq¦Ãw*`(yzy{[R(¥(`zÀ(w*`z¬(zz`z!w`¦
vRR[Rzf(z[,Õ¥Xrz[,yxGz[¥z2tõ(w!w*(,¢ z*(z
*,(z<(yz$w*w*(t E(yz
zzrz¦/zzzr*z
¡(¡<¥(¡ ¡z`yz¡¬z,¥(zX(zGz¡¬z`¥zEz[z[`z (,f,V®Á÷2zzrz({rÔf ¥(¡rz[1w(yx!(z·(t fÔf
w(zº¡z`yyz²J{E vRR[tmRw(zÂ*¥zyx¢z ¥(¡rzJ(`<,z
¥(z[q(zz*t
²J`yy´³Ãw`³ww*y`$z¡¬z,¥(z®Á÷2zzzºry¼,z[R` yz L`(yz°°R¥(¡q¡` zL(z
w*¡q¬`{w*rz±²Rzzªy¡m,
z`y&©w¢wy`^Jz[Â¥(z[2tg J(^Jyy¥(`z[qrª¥(z ( (w³5ªy¡ wwy{(¦5w*¡qz,y&w(yx®z*B,fz*($¥((
²J(zz(z,wrw`¦^z,yÇ©w¢wy{r²J{f vRR?wz`y vREw¢,z[*,(z*t1 J(zJ*,(zJ¥±¦Ãz^z[w$zz
wwy{(²J(w¥(1 v^RLL*zr`L¦/¥(©w*rw,¦§(zJ(w*¡,yÁ³ w*¡z²J`r`(,x z{w([t¿ Jzfyz[*(ºz[zfz*w*¿
z[z©®z`y2(z[,^,(±¦/zwz¯z[tLõ¨*¥(z $(w`²JR²J¢x z±²Rzz(zªw`²Ew,¦Çww*y,¢g(w*yzJwz?¬z¥(z<¥(±³
ªy¡ ©w¢wy{r¬(zzy{x¿¥(z[2t E(zX(zfw,z,w ¦Ãz`(zª^w`²Xw,¦&(w*yzRw*r(z¥{wr¥(Ä¦Ã*©z*t^õÿ¡
w¢zLw zw(z{(zR²Z,y{yz¡¬z,¥(zL(z`¡z,Lz wwy{(!{z*w*!²J``z[!w!(zqz¥(yrw,¦?ó1ëë**
wwy¼,Ñ`Lz¡¬z`¥zJ¦5w*^¡z`yw*(yx
(yz*`r,r{®³ z`y±t {µ tr J(zq(z[,
`(Ä¦/zwz¯z²Z,
z[`z[ ¢x
ª{z?,¡w*¥¢1w,¦Çww*y(
Lz[Â¥(z[t Eªy¡ww*y(
z (z`yxf»*·¸w`z$(z(w³/ªy{¡bww*yz[À(`(t$ J(z$ªy{¡ ©w¢wy´³
¥*z?(´¦/wr(z¢, ô ©z[,zt E(z ô z[`z (oÕw`²`z
²J``yz[¦/w¡m(z
z(¬z¡z¢`y&(,t^ Jz
¥¯zyx`w*(yx<Bz[,w*`(yz?,¡w¥(Ñw,¦©w¢wy{?Lzz[z[t yz[($z[*zJz*wr²Z,µ ¸w`¦&(zJw,y(¥(Ä¦Ã*©z?`z[(t1 Jz
} Ö z[z[`z[g(zr`ww`¦ Ö ÿ ²J{k,º²J(w¥($ v^R ¥w<¥(±¦ÃzJz*w*&¦5w*¡(zww*y((w*yzLw$(zR`y´³
,¬(¬(w*(z$w(z*t$°5¦^(z<z©®z`yL(z`Õ¥f$*zxyw`²
z (z[z*tL J(`z

(µ ·(w*yz
`¡qzz[(,
*¸ w`¦
z[Â¥(z[qz`y&wwy{(o{Jyw`²
`Jy{z÷2z[z[xrz (z<w*`y1¥(Ä¦Ã*©z,z*t~¡y`y{x(z¬(z¥z¥(±¦±*z
¬(zzzw,¦q vR$t2°±z[`( ô &z[¥©z Ö
&²J( `z^¨¦/w*¡zZwwy{((w*yz1w?(zR,y{(z[z*t1 J(
,J(z$`¡zw`*z`yy2z÷2z[$`Jz¥(q(z
`(t `z<µµ[·(w*yzr`¡zz[&, %
*¸:w,¦Z(z<w*`yL¥(±³
J(zf`¬(¬w¢X¥z[¿wGzz¡q{z´¦$(zz`zzz³ ¦Ãz<`z*t$ J(zrww*y`J`wq{(zr`¡qw*¥(Rw`¦Z©w¢wy`
ª
wÀ{z,y^w(yxww*y(²J(z v^Rr`zr¥(zG,Gz z[Â¥(z[À¬z
¥(($¬,k®{z[¢xÀ(z¡,{qÕw`²`zr¬z
¥(¡¡` z<,R¦/w*yyw`²J ¥({R¬`&£/Ú(Û
¤ ÿ Þrt
µ[· Copyright © 2006 by ASME

ghjiIkmlonqpsrtukmrvxwy&rpcl(z|{{lokmr}

!#" ~ wv|pcl/{!rlm 3
1 'a ' ! E ! E
%$ & '()*+%, %yGp!z|w
-. /%* 1032 w9p!t%kmr}w t%}w
/
8 @
4
57698/:<;>=7? =%A? BA? =A? BA? j.! E !¡ !¡
CED &FG ¢ m Eo m Eo
IH 7%J,7JE £ ¤ E ¤ ! ¥ E ¦c
KL#M N<OP 6 Q R%SS ? TTB S RS%S ? TTB S §%¨!¨ .! ¤!E !!¦ ! ¡! !c
U MP+P BV BV B%V BV © |ª
W/X O W/Y 6 ?)AV ?AV ?AZ S[ ?)AZV)= «'¬ «' E ¥ E ¥ !¡
K)\M N<OP Q =RZSZ SVS? [ Z%?? [[ =7? ®|.! ¤! ¦ ¦! ¡!¡! !¦!!¡
W \ O W]Y ?)A^= [ ?)A^ [ ^ ?A^%^ S ?)A^V%B « ®f « E ¤E ¡ ¤!¡¥ ¤ E ¤
23!3!,_` T' S%[ =AZ%B ?)AB^ ?)ABB {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯%kor%v&wyxrpclf¯° ¤¡! ¥ E m
CED ,%a" D &FG {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯±lon²¯!° ¡!¤ E ¡¤ E ¡¤ ¡!¤
KL#M N<OP 6 Q R =[ = Tb^ S T R =[ = Tb^ S T %z|vxko{r´³xyfp!z w ¡!¦ !¡¦
U MP+P V? V? V%? V? j.! !¦! !¦!
W/X O W/Y ?)AV ?AV ?AZ%ZB ?)AZV R ¢ m Eo m Eo
K \ M N<OP 6cQ =7B%B^ [ =7?%^V%Z [R%R ? [ T?B £ ¤ E ¤ !¤E E ¥!
W \ O W]Y ?)A^B%^ ?)A^ [ B ?A^%V= ?)A^V%B §%¨!¨ .! !¥¤!¤ ¦!! ¤ ¡c ¡!¥!
23!3!,_` V R ? R A^T ?) RS ?) R T © |ª
de "" D " D &Ff% «'¬ «' E ¥!¤¦ E ¥¤!
®|.! !¡c ! ! ¡! ¤ ¡!! !¤
KL#M N<OP 6 Q T=7?%? TbBTbV T'=c?? TbBTbV « ®f « E ¤E ¤!¦ ¤ ¡ E ¤
RR RR R%R RR
U MP+P {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯%kor%v&wyxrpclf¯° ! ¡ ¤E E ¡
W/X O W/Y ?)AV ?AV ?AZ%^ R ?)AZ^%Z {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯±lon²¯!° ! !
K)\M N<OP 6 Q Z%V R T S B)=7? [ =cV S [B[Z
µ yxw³&³&yxw³&yGp!z|w
W \ O W]Y ?)A^!T= ?)A^ [ Z ?A^%V [ ?)A^V [ j.! !¥ ¡!¦!¦ !¥ ¡!¦!¦
23!3!,_` B S ^ [ AB%V ?) [ V ?) [ Z ¢ m Eo m Eo
e £ ¤ E ¤ ¡!E E !¡!¥
23!3!,_` = R [%S =c?AV [ =%ABB =%= T §%¨!¨ .! ¡! ¡!¡!!¤ !¥!¦¦
© |ª ! ! !
J`y¥(y,w*(J²RzzVw(z
²Jº{¡q¬((*z¡z^,¡zz «'¬ «' E ¥!¡¦ E ¥¡!¤
w,¦·t ¹,¡¡ºt(}yy2ww*y`1Õw`²X`zJ²^zz?`y¥(y`z[,¥(¡( ®|.! c ¤! ! !¤9¦ ! c¦
(wfw*±³5Õw`²
tr}J
(zzqz¡q¬z`¥(z
(zr¡qz,y1w*(yx,y´³ « ® « E ¤s¦ ¤! ¤ ¥ E ¤ ¥
¥y¼,w*²J(©y{¥z[ºwoÕw`² w*z[©w* z¥(yz[º {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯%kor%v&wyxrpclf¯° !¥!¥ ¤¡ E !¡
z(z¡qzyx?{$Õw`²!`z[*,
¡qw*zÑ¡q¬w,yx¢¡q¬(´³ {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯±lon²¯!° ¡ E ¡E E ¡E ¡
,y(¡¬((z¡rz&`x
¬`,¡zzt& 1w
*w*¡q¡w((`zLw ({!vpsl
Õw`²i(zLÒz$`¡qzz^²Rzz
z(z¡zyxry`*z*t {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯%kor%v&wyxrpclf¯° 9¦¦!¤ ¦E ¦¡ E ¦ ¥
J(zoz(z`yLz[`,(±¦5z
wz¯z
L`(yz
°°`z {{lpsrvypcvxko{)¯±lon²¯!° c E s E s c
,z[wr(zz(¬z¡z`y2|J¥(zyR¢¥¡rz^`r$(z¡,y ¶#·!wypslml]z|{%{!l¸pcr%vypcvxko{)¯b° ! Eo ¡E E ¡!
w¥©{±xº`
»*··*$· & '!t Jz Ö *,y{¥z<`z`y¥y¼,z[ºw
¡``rr¡(¡<¥(¡ ¡z`y2z¡ÿ ¬z,¥(z<w,¦(µ ¢·· & ' t^ Jz J(z¡qz,y^w(yx!w*`yJww*y(Õw`²Jr! L`y{zq°°º`z
z`y¨(z[,?,(±¦/zB©w¢z©¯z
`zV,y¥(y`z[¥({z z±²RzzEµ[·q` µ[¹¸:w`¦J(z¡,(z[,¡:Õw`²
t
J(zzÕw`²
w¥©{±xrw,¦Ç,{,
µ[··*$· & '!t `wV,zwwº(*Gwzz/Òz[©z[ ¦5w*¡](z`y(fz[z*t
L`y{z°°(w`²J(z`yxzq¦/wy¼qz[¥w*©w¢wy` J¥(y<zZ,yÃt » ({r(zJz¦/w*^B(*r¬(z¥(z
¥({z
Õw`² ,zR²J(z$ v^ L¥(z[2tg J(zJz(zª§,y2z÷§zR¦/w*¡ fyz<`»*¸bw,¦(zr¡`(z`¡ ,?z5Òz[z[ ¦/w¡ z
¥(( v^ `z¬({¡`{yx¥zrw,©z[,z{ºz<¥(±³ `y(z[*zt J(zoz[Â¥(zwwy¼,²J(zÀ v^1 ¹ ?,z¥(z
¦Ãzz¡q¬z`¥(z*tq J(
z¥(y
!y{w`²Rz$*`z<(z`$Õ¥®®z[t Ry{z`f»¸«w`¦1(z
¡`(z`¡ Õw`²
t
Rw(z[Â¥(z¢yx¢(z$¡z`y(((zJ²Z,y{yz¡¬z,¥(zz[`z* Rw*¡q¬`($ Ç,(yz°°r` Ç,(yz°°±¦5w*R(z$¡z`yw*y{x
²J(z¥(yJ<yw`²Rzzz[Â¥(zrz`y(z[,L`(Ä¦/zJw`³ *,(z$(w`²Jy`*z
`¡qw*¥(Lw,¦L{z,yÑwwy{(Jz[Â¥(z[2
z¯©{z¢[t zz²J{
ªy{¡ ©w¢wy{t2°±¬(z¢(w*`y¢©w¢wy{w`²J
²Rw*¥(yz
*z[qwrz[¥zz?z[Â¥(z[{z,y&ww*y(t
µ*µ Copyright © 2006 by ASME

!!"!#$ %&# '( *) (+S$5-#$<--B/^ @ ( #-=-J+$5C 0=0#*!CT0
# (+,(-. / 0 12345&6'7 /*8 =0 .` W 53#0JCJF!y01 o E"+/,#4 b0yl
9:;250 14< ='0 !#+24"+/ 3#2='*(3 =0 *!b(-o"8c W ")CO 1=H#-2k04!
#0 =0-/&"8?>(3@ 5 (31A+(4!B0B= / 35CEDF5 ! ='3#*!0 "!^)-#0 " . 3@' #=-J+H5C$6&5
G.<-. !4#H 'E53(EAI+4!B0B='#3 ( #-(): 1 /M5 W 3(! W B5C$&# '-+o
@' 5-J+5 45 *!K K*5 +='0 ! +LM"+(1 #-# 04!<!*#*#8
04!N= O "8 P$'+ @ # *!NU#%Q( zCT0 "!6B
>(3@ 5 (CQP%5=SR#R 35 !1P%=R#RJ=1CT($ UP$V> Z^*#BC +H(21P$VQ>|CT# B i5 !@'CSk&([l
W 5*(!U#XY![Z\#3'0 :8H .
'-](-') < q "0-#3/&#*8HV*50 1C 34#B "!0 #-(2
#$ # ^#-_-# /&#+3Q/% 5BCT(% (-f *(0#3#sB +$(gfP$V>O) # -+
(`
a(-"!b #0 "8dc W ") H
e. 1"+B= 35 # W 8_# # +1f

fQ< f 53J4f O # ^(+g(M5*8h W i5j) (1(B= #1C= ( oO0 "!o!@' !B(F#B @'*[
\
# (i^45&: b f 6
?k&(-S%*#-+6 5@@4#-(8
#-<3<#*13#H(lm
a(-"!` ni5 oB='# 3"^ 6¡m¢y£:¤'¥o¢¦§
AI+4!0B='"8FP-_-'!4#B 5g5bA+(4!
0B=' # :+31"+U# ^= _@ Cm #*!^8 P@' 3/&!5if@ W 4!*!_=+U¨f*8:P+ #Q'!U¨f*8
p < <&# '$< qi5 B#3B0 #o ©O#1PO#*#-+35@@#*4#*!^8
H6P$V>rk&# ) k *5 1&# 'sk&(-gtCT
(0&#<CT# _ uv5O4#8<h$2 i5):
#*#Bo-# 5Q< OUG(wxn(O-W / *81RmC 3 fª$<$Y}
#*#O-3k&(-U!0f B ( %'!B='1 0 !y*!B
P%=-_R R ): 3 (i5zk&(-E#-104!Y #-%='B _ 5 «*¬B®#¯4®°±J²"®*³:´$¬¶µ¬[³^«k·"·*¸5³$¹%º"»B¼½(¾ ¿ÀÁÂBÃ^ÄÅ$¿½5»iÆ4ÀÄÁ(³ Ç®ÈÉ"ÊË
D(8 {(x|CT$_P$VQ>K '8 ®ËÌÍmÌÉ"Ê³ÎÏkÐ"ÑÉ*±ÒbÓ± Ï/ÊÈ#ÌÔ³ÕmÊÈ"¬³Ö®i×oØ:É*±JÙ¬
Ú5¬UÛ®®Ë³Ü¬ ´f¬³Î^Ý(±JÊ®±³Þ<¬ ßf¬³^Ú*à"à"á³Qâã´QÊHä^ÊÍJ±JÉ"åÐEÉ"ÔJÔ$´åæ
}U~BY}13"H]3f3<H (
å J
± t
É Ï/È çN¯MÉ"±ÏÞ6®ÏÊ5Ñ¶ÌÊ®Bè^Ñ-Ï/Ë®±JÉ×KÞ6ÉË®#Ñs×ÌÍJç1éÉ"ÝåÑ¶ÌÊ(ê3ÍJÉÎ^®ÔJÍ
ë ÏÍ ÏOÏ/ÊË3ì ë é%Ó ë Û®ÔJÝÑÍJÔ³ í_´vÇ(ÞBäHåÏå®±vßÎÚ*à"à*ákæjî"¸*î"à"¸
U5 + :C / W J+$5C\$hI@ !0' _ Sk&([l ä\ðyì®¬^ÈïYÍÉÌ¶Ñ¯^ÈiÎ^ÉÈ#ÝÙ±J³y°5ÌÛvÊ¬®Oéè^¬[³*Ñ-ØÏ/ËÉ"®OÝÊ(éêÉ³É/ÜÑ¶Ì¬¶Êè%ê¬[³tÉ"Ï/ÊUÊËÍJç(µ®vÉ*éz±mÑÐÉÈ È#ÑÙ®$³ä\Üñ¬ µIÈ ¬Ì³®Ú*Ê(à"Èià*Ð6á5É/³ ¯òâJÎßçÏ/®Ô
_ i5 f *!1# W o6 1 #*!0 k . W 5 Î^Ý(±J°ÌÊ®ó'É×®±%éÐÈ#Ñ®iÔ³ í$´ÇÞBä`ôÄ½¾#Á&º"õÄJö%÷ÁøÀÁ&Â#Â¾ ÀÁø'öÄ¾$¹%º"»
(-B5E#[
\5 +B *!y0 B$hIH@ !0 k 8c$5
# W 1H'7 <CT#]#b .
W 1@ 3W1"+ ¼(½¾#ÿ(¿¬ÀÁ&ÂkÞB»QÏºÈÁ´ù$±JÍJúçÄÝû^±³vÂ¾Jévüý:¬ ë É¬Ñ4³¬'«k«·"Ú*·*þ5·5³&³å(åâã´¬'«kËà"²*·kÏ/æ Ê«kÈÚ"®à5Ëo¬ ´Q®±JÉ/æjä^Ê(êÌÊ(®1Î^Ý±mæ
#*!0 6$hIE=+3JJ+B
W O@ /i"8
r5 + B5C#.Z\" H5CP$VQ>n#-3( °5°5ÌÌÊÊ®%®ÔÎ^³ í ®È ç(ÊÉ/ÑÉ*ê/ ÷ Ì®ÔQ
Ï/ÊÆ ËÁÎ%&ç(Æ ®#Ì±´*åÅ åÑ¶ÌÈÏ/ÄÍmÌÁ É*Ê6IÍJÀ-É¾ Õm%Ê¾mËÂ Ý(ºÔJÆ ÍJ±mÀÌ-ÁÏøNÑ^ß÷sÏÁÔ:øÀÎ^ÁÝÂ±m» æ ü
#*(0 *! W 5$'% *!6# % / 5+Uk&([l ÓÑÉ"±J®ÊÈ®"³&ÕmÍ ÏÑÐ"³ ó^Ï/å®i±·*·kæjþ5«ká5«*¬
.E"+.= .@@#@#4 <CT(3!#-(3#+-F(,#HP$V>
#U1iB1"U03' <@ #0 89(Q W 5 ´f¬ ï`á¬¬³:«k´·"±J·*ÍJà5Ô³Q³QâJÎ´¬[®³Q±J ÉæmÏ Î%$ç°®®± ±JÍBÏËÑ®1ÕTÊÛ²"®É*ÔJÝ(Ím²Ìêt±JÏ/ÉÌÍmÍÌÉ"³OÊFÞ<É/¬¯v³vÏ6Ï/ÊµËbÌê"ÛçÑÝÐHÍJç(®Ét±m¯MÏ/É"Ë±J®ËË ³
AI+4!%0B='#*)5 45 *!< B#E ")-#Jl Î^± Ï/ÊÔJÉ"ÊÌÈQyÌÊ®Ï/±^Î^Ý±J°5ÌÊ®QßÝ5ÌË®ýsÏ/Ê®séÏÔJÈÏ/Ë®"³ í!ý ÕÎ^®È ç(ÊÌÈÏÑ
5(+k&(-3S5 # W 6= */0#B 6W *#+H #-# ÖÉ*ÍJ®f«þÿ(¬
#o 0#=0 o!0Y 2#F(-o31"+F='o W 4!"!^8 î5¬´Q±JÍJÔ³Î¬[³«·*·"á5³\âJÎç®± ÏÑÕmÊ²*®ÔJÍmÌêÏÍmÌÉ"ÊUÉ/¯\ÏµzÌê*ç5ÑÐUÉtÏ/Ë®Ë
#X<P$V>q B##-# W J+.C$< #FA+(4! Î^± Ï/ÊÔJÉ"ÊÌÈ1Î^Ý±J°5ÌÊ®FÓÌ¶Ñ éÉÉÑ®ËßÝÌË(®HýsÏ/Ê®í(³O#« "$äòÝ±JÉ"å®kÏ/Ê
0B='v5Q#$ '<CT 3'+35 03@#-(8 éÉ"Ê¯J¬2É"ÊoÎ^Ý±J°%É ÏÈ#çÌÊ®±JÐ.æÓÑÝÌË ë ÐÊ&Ï fÌÈHÏ/ÊËoÎ%ç(®i± OÉË(Ð"æ
h W J)#S/404#%0 6 OO cIPky!yS# &Ï fÌÈ´QÔJå®ÈÍJÔ³&ä^±mÑ-Ï/Êê"®±³ ß®i± Ï/ÊÐ"³&ÏÑÔJÉO!ý Õ^å±J®å±mÌÊÍI«k·"·*ákæ «"«*¬

Ê
#*# 5=+!f@ *!yMk C*5s#i5JCT/z# 5/z!y0Q# þ5¬]ÇçÝ Ï/Ê³Î¬¶Û¬³Ú"à*à"à³3â#(Ö ')Ï/ÊËr*é ' Ó(É*± Ï/ÍmÌÉ*ÊL¯4É*±

d'8RmC^
7k&(-Q(Q0 *!^)##v_*!NCT( Ï/È®ÍJÏÉ*Ê5+± æjó^'±Jå ® ®f± ÏÌ )ÍJ®®ËUËFÏ/Þ6Í®ä'ÍJÑç&®Ï/²*ÊÏ/®#ÍJ®æT´ËÌÎ^±S ® éO%É å&$®°(± Ï/ÝÍJÔJÝÍm±JÌÉ"®Ê1Ô³ í$ÌÊFóòç ÏNë Ü®iÎ%ÍmæJçÇ®ÍmÔmÌÌ±JÔ±J³®Þ6ËH®ÛÈ ç®#æ ¬
(0 6 # H<! ).@ *!yMk 1=4!_*
#iJCT"8 ')Q##FE.*!`CT(B3!. 2(0& äòÊ¸ê"¬Q±¬ Þ6ë ®#®Ñ¶Ñå(É(Í³¬³ Ü¬¶,%ó'Ê5¬³&Ì²Þ6¬®#ÉÑ¶¯ÑÉ"ï1±³ Ï´fÔJç5¬ Þ<ÌÊê"¬[³&ÍJÉ*ÇÊÍJ®¬ ®#Ñ®"³\Û¬¶é¬³&Ï/ÊË3-Ç fÌÍJç.³ f¬/'f¬³
CT( EkZ\*k 35CCT / # *5;#0 =0-/ H(2*5U#i5JCT/*) «·*·"þ5³yâã´XÇ5ÍJÝËÐfÉ¯ÍJç(®zÓÏ/ÈÍJÉ*±JÔ:´%ð®ÈÍmÌÊê$Ö ')$0ä fÌÔJÔmÌÉ*Ê(Ô:ÌÊ®ÏÊ
#@ "4+31#f r4< "8
W 1 (01 # :+3(-_ Ki5 fQ# óò±J·51® ¬^fÎÌ )Ï®È#Ë$ÌÊÎ^Ï³&Ý(Ûv±J°¬Ì³Ê(ï3®zéz®Ð"#É ³&fé°¬[Ý³t'ÔJÍJÏÉ"Ì±JÊ(Ôê³ í³ó'´¬ÕT³´Ï/´1ÊËUå&ÞBÏ/å&Ï/®Ê±'ÔJ´QÉ"ÝÕm´±³(´%´$æ ¬[«³5·"Ú"·*à"þkà*æjÚ5Ú"³\þ*à"âã¸´ ¬
# ` <
].i#6CT(U<i5 W 5*) 1 # É×(Ö ')H®kÏ/Êæ ë Ì±J®ÈÍÕm&Ê 2J®ÈiÍmÌÉ"Ê³QÞ6Ý5ÑÍmÌåÉÌÊÍBÕmÊÍJ®ê*± Ï/ÍJ®ËXÞ6ÉË5æ
( +k&(-$'2i5 Q#$# &-()5 !#%3@-/3l Ý5Ñ®Sé%É $°(ÝÔJÍJÉ"±véÉ"ÊÈ®åÍ¯4É*±´Ë²*Ï/ÊÈ®ËB´%Ì±JÈ± Ïk¯4ÍvßÏ/ÔQÎ^Ý(±J°ÌÊ(®iÔ³ í
(Bv5-<@i( 45J8^ 1P$V> / 5^+3 Ö´vÇ5óÎQÞ_æjÚ"à*à"ÚkæjÚ«"«ìÿþ³ó^±J®ÔJ®ÊÍJ®ËgÏ/ÍÍJç®éÉ"Ê¯4®±J®iÊ(È®QÉ"ÊUÎ^®È#çæ
'= *(3O@#M/Q!0B 1 BB0' Y-f ui#*8NRJBl Ê(ÉÑÉ"êÌ®Ô1ÏÊ(Ë,é%É $°(ÝÔJÍmÌÉ"Êo¯4É*±BÏHé:Ñ®Ï/Ê,äòÊ²"Ì±JÉ*3Ê S®ÊÍ4³ 'åÉ"±JÍJÉ³
@ # W -
?k&(-$Z^*# W #Q(04!#*!0 k$ 4# W ó'É"±JÍJÝêÏÑ4³^ÜÝ5ÑÐUÚ"à*à5«*¬
(! W i5fCs / 5^+360 3_P$V>O8RJ # D*G

*D w8QI*+)Ü8 8-)--")o8 p 8)cI+&#)8 ¨68)'!EM(!(l G '8UP0)A_8¶Ü8)^c)¨68¶>O8)'! p (*):R8¶¨6)-)*D G)
!/)c8 '8-)D
) *#0 < %5C\c"%Pi5JCm%¨$# =0yl #+E}~E +Fzc(Mz # 0#3¨$/i*!H¨f#
#-(Xh W U# p 0JCj(6CScI-(+^!"!oP0 =-3/ AI@ ( ") B Op >AlD<({<=w)#8M l {{
lDLD
O0M!y Q*) Op H
!#"%$&' '($&#")*,+-%.0/21 G({89: #&0 j) %8 8)P 01)>O8¶A8)Q5 ! 1 /")
3 $&'4.56879:!'(2;%J8^D*=w <)(@@8:D >tlkD"{ 8 ¨68¶8)D D) p "B 9:-25 !Bc"PiJCT¨$# =0yl
DD(8A$(!< +&)A88)Q5 !`P)©U8 8-)G(wwG?) ¨$kl #-(CT(!( #i"+BRJ<@< 1> ( J') |

*!BV%(0 !5 +@"+/91" 0 < 1 p i# Q5 C[c?'2*a?/2.&'(2;%(J8^D*w W)@@
8 W=WL"Ql W G8
W 5 *!Y9# # *5Ps0 =0'A ^ W *) B
>(!CD/21 X%¢%Y£ b.
3 EFG4H>$I'(J*;KJ8 D"G ')@@8^D*=w L"lD*D 8 F
D"G8Bc$5i5 &5E) p 8 M8)^'!Ho*!yM5):8 P8-)D D) icI* F*¦ mF S^'b¡ ¦ z g§_5 m*¦ yz£`g T*¦ ¦¢ ^*¦ *¦ m
Pi5JCmH ! #!+ <MkE5CNbcI-( AI p @ /*!P0ãl 0
'-d(-O#$(S!< ( *5Q='4 k
=2I/-bO04!N Q5oP #*!#2A nRJ /&# (@4 W 1=+Z\
ò-(0 Mz-# (2>i/!P OTQR RMT> S) U>
TV/> 3
E8=G2H$&1
'(J*;J8 D(D W)@@8 W
Ql WD8 OfKPN SO* SCYOb NbS
*D W8oOJX ) M8 u8-Y) Q529( /)QB8 '8-)%V+)%A8 8):P0Jl
1)"Ü8¶A_8-)5 !B> W #")©68 >O8)D =Z) iV4!$cI*%Pãl O]% S Of SO* SCgOb V S
CT/[1*#0 /3 O @! M#*!4#-($H6Pi5 (4$P0#=
>5i(!) Op Hb@'@'[tlãOPlD*G({8 O]* S OfZN ]SX qOb ZNKYS
D '8sz&(!^) p 8 68-)c$5=) 8¶>O8)&5 !B¨f0)&c_8) *D Z ) i¨f*! -#U!/ H#3@'i5 0#)^ !<J+@4+B#*#
9:r>9 *#0 < 6>+& !#4 ^*(!$%!( # 4btCT bk0 KCm2L@ # #qCjk ")E5 !q
1!/] \q:Z^*`C9 /l p " Ps0 =0' !q>4 #* W / +nCJ#*8 Q50 q# 0<*! CT( O* SCg)
¨f#J+&) Sp Y^
>(F_/ 3
E8=G2H$&'(J*;F%J86D*Gw) O* S #O]% SB
) )^ P! )ò g
@@:8 LtCl (w L8 5-#B _E"60<i5^ <@ #0 8IP*(0 5 O#
D*{8H# X) 68 ©68)Gww(G,) icI*6 ãCT6 #* b(2&5 # W *!gCT#O 1#3@' 0 O ! #O]% SU8
#0 =BãCT$O Spy _A>O) A`(aQ'*a$b
>
cf)¨$0 i)Q5 !2(! G2D *!` '*)zCT6 tl
c?' %a96Fde>$f6gdh
:X;%(J8s=G W)(@@8$D"w tlk*D W<8 #-/J+2CO&# 'Sk&(-F 3") FI0 #30B='BW
*D <8 p #)%I8-) < J) 8 8)sAI=+&)^¨6i8 %8)%*D L) @#@'# 5^ < BA+(4!0B= / E6@'*)Z)'
#P$A X 9 W(Üi8 HVzl 10#lJ=#9: p ( fCTOP0#= (E"l w <(@{ ¡¢¤£ w L({8 p B#EAI+4!0B='OU! " +
##+E9:*) R $ @'@'[Ltlã=w <8 W

@#@'# 5 #B _-# 5_ i5 )
*D L8V+)A8 8)*-/j) M8 8)" ! <*)98¶8) 2M *!yMk
CT( O:Z\" 5Cs9# # *5dP0 =0 fBP0 =-$V%4!y ¥ @¦ ¨
§Q©Qª
cI*Pi5JCm*) Sp H@ @'$OP$G(ww 5lã
{ >W=WG8 /3
'- U0 "!^) - /@4*!=&+B#U(!4"l
D 8dV%(*j ) 'i8 M8-,) H #&0*)>O8¶¨68-)f !AI ")SA_8 Vf8) = 5 4^#3@'i5 0#?«¬F)M#1CT0 !NCT (d f

D*<) P:Z^*%5C\cB9 l p # *5P0 =0 W (g9: Z^*# W / *8
>QsZ\*k W ") Sp Hk>
j/> 3
E8=G2H$&'(J*; Pf=
\4:Z^* O5C
dB O5Z\# 6 (3
%(J8 D(D)(@@8D( lQG{8 !/ /S=+13 k *5 O 8RmCs0#
'- U50 O
*D 8Pz5#J)©U8) H5 #00iZ ) o8) (j) p 8-)5 ! p 5 ')P8-) 4< ='0 ! +<4"+#U='*(3O 0#=0*)'#O-' *5
*D wR ) 1:@ #3i5 p 0 !+<C%c*5PsãCT !19: /1= _ 0=#i5&#4J8
>.l ^ #@ "HA$#oPs0 =H(") Sp Y
'-q$0#*!6 / %B!!#-( @' 5-J+
Rm/ 3
E8=G2H$&'(J*;%(J8^DD*G)@@8 "l >=<8 #$ v(-I 2#*8(z5&#S5-:z W 5M5=
Gw8¨f ( *) n_8)&5 !BV%(4*) 8-)D =Y) RJ / (U5Cs¨$kl CT(O-# 5vk&(- 8BRmC$%5C$ 3(M5Sky#i( *! CT(
*!F9:>E:Z^*# W / 3'!ocW *5PiJCT6¨$ãl
)^#3 W /i(B&# '4f q *!y0 *!
=+B 5C8PO 6C%4 *(0 "!1 B
'- U#
# =0#-(Bo5BP0 = JCT(j) Op Ho
>(j #4 *(0 "!1 1+B # k&(-U\
/ 3 EFG4H>$&'J*;%J8'D*GD)@@8=G WWtlã
G &G8
GD(8$c$5) 8^>O8) ¨f0 ) p )^'!H!^) p 8 U8) G(ww(w?) pq+[*.
/ 3 $&'-c0'2*a[/
.&'([6mr!*e$&"D/Z'2G2Hs2"J*; tP%"+u ¥ ¨®=¯ ° ± µ´ f®=¯ ° ± D
9i5 QRJ'8) /l vQ( ^8 ¥ ¨²Z³2®¯ ° ± f²Z³2®¯ ° ±g¶
§Q©qª ´
D 2w { ¥ Z·¸Z ¥ Z®¯ ° ±g¶
GGx 8 w'0)$¨689) -")vA_8 8)Gww(wg) P 1$>'!0 #l ¨·¸Z ¨®¯ ° ± -#_CTi( 15Cs
'-nB#ik *!
# W J+H !Y4 #4F 1!00 W (0 15CvP/ E5%VQ5 #¥ (0< ¥ O
'- 6"8
> (0 !yEcI-(,cI*B9:-0y>'! ") y
[ PB / 0 _-
0#3{<Q#U(#*!25 03AN
/YH'EFz={
J|/Z' G4H>h4"J*;KJ} 8 )'8%G)@@8*D L{tlk*D w8
G W8 p @ *kM5R 1Q/=H flQ8 #@ *kM53*8¶( w L({8fP$( W 0_CTjo( W S< W W W 0OCT(

¥ ¨®=¯ ° ±9 ¥ Z²Z³2®¯ ° ±O8
DW

Effects of Thermal Barrier Coatings On Turbine Blade Cooling

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Effects of Thermal Barrier Coatings On Turbine Blade Cooling

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Proceedings of GT2006

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

zz  ,1zL ` *zz1²J 

______ Exponential relationship ref. 8

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

600 235 6 solid vane

(z `yx *·*¸ gz*zE(w¥(*¿(z w*y * `(z (z `r `(Ä¦/z 

(º ,w* `zÀ±x¢¬¼ `yyx!w*(zfwr*z[ `z[t 1z ²Rzz©w*³

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

õ¨tVRw¡¬ ,wrw`¦L(z[ ,J `(Ä¦/z¬z[w*(J²Jf( , ì ú©û ¢Þ â

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

°5¦ ô  ù L `&yz[ ,Lw(z*`w?z ,yww*y(J1(zz[z2( `oz w-film / w-total

szx(w*y¢¥¡rzw ¬w`²Rz[ 1t$ J{$z­(¬w*(z¢$$*zz±³ η =0.2

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

 Copyright © 2006 by ASME

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

,¥¡z[z[Â¥ `y¨w ï  Ï t No cross flow

ÜfÝ Ü Ý &þ µ  Ë ß£ í  Ï ¤£ ï  Ï ¤£ ð  Ï ¤*£ Ó þ  Ó  ¤ 

Ó ` Ó `zf(zº¡ ,oÕ¥­(zq¦/wr(z©w*±³5Õw`² ,

w*±³5Õw`²¬z `y±x! `¿wf `*zz[ {¡q¬((*z¡zw*yz[t 0.5

çJ(<(zzy `{w({¬¦5w*L(z${z ,y§~® `w*r¥(¡rz õ¨t < ~®z({±xw,¦Çwwy¼ ,^wr*zw¡zxr¬ , `¡qzz[t

yz( `q¬ `&t1°±JJ*zx  z/d

õ¨*¥(z Àw`²J Ö Ê ì ¦/wr(z (w!w*Ä³/Õw`²  ,z

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

õ¨t <óÑ÷§z[©?w,¦Ñ vREw z[Â¥(z Ö ÿ t J(z$(w*z$w`¦2ªy{¡:ww*yz[rw^w(yx<z ,y&ww*y($¦/w^ vR

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

Downloaded From: http://proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/ on 01/30/2016 Terms of Use: http://www.asme.org/about-asme/terms-of-use

You might also like

zz ,1zL` *zz1²J

(z`yx ·¸gzzE(w¥(¿(zwy `(z(z`r`(Ä¦/z

(º,w`zÀ±x¢¬¼`yyx!w(zfwrz[`z[t 1z²Rzz©w³

õ¨tVRw¡¬,wrw`¦L(z[,J`(Ä¦/z¬z[w*(J²Jf(, ì ú©û ¢Þ â

°5¦ ô ù L`&yz[,Lw(z`w?z,ywwy(J1(zz[z2(`oz w-film / w-total

szx(wy¢¥¡rzw¬w`²Rz[ 1t$ J{$z(¬w(z¢$$*zz±³ η =0.2

Copyright © 2006 by ASME

,¥¡z[z[Â¥`y¨w ï Ï t No cross flow

ÜfÝ Ü Ý &þ µ Ë ß£ í Ï ¤£ ï Ï ¤£ ð Ï ¤*£ Ó þ Ó ¤

Ó ` Ó `zf(zº¡,oÕ¥(zq¦/wr(z©w*±³5Õw`² ,

w±³5Õw`²¬z`y±x!`¿wf`zz[ {¡q¬((z¡zwyz[t 0.5

çJ(<(zzy`{w({¬¦5wL(z${z,y§~®`wr¥(¡rz õ¨t < ~®z({±xw,¦Çwwy¼,^wr*zw¡zxr¬,`¡qzz[t

yz(`q¬`&t1°±JJ*zx z/d

õ¨¥(z Àw`²J Ö Ê ì ¦/wr(z(w!wÄ³/Õw`² ,z

õ¨t <óÑ÷§z[©?w,¦Ñ vREwz[Â¥(z Ö ÿ t J(z$(wz$w`¦2ªy{¡:wwyz[rw^w(yx<z,y&ww*y($¦/w^ vR