Diskusi Webometrics

Universitas Halu Oleo Kendari

5 Oktober 2022

Ikhwan Arief
ikhwan@eng.unand.ac.id
 Webometrics Periode 2, tahun 2022
Indonesia World University Impact Openness Excellence
50 3970 Universitas Surabaya 5148 2386 5071
51 3984 Petra Christian University 2443 7521 4234
52 3993 Universitas Negeri Jakarta 3971 7521 3631
53 4003 Universitas Malikussaleh 5545 2805 4940
54 4062 Universitas Katolik Parahyangan 5402 2497 5112
55 4109 Universitas Teknokrat Indonesia 270 1539 7216
56 4130 Universitas Halu Oleo Kendari 2694 7521 4397
57 4139 Universitas Sultan Ageng Tirtayasa 2452 7521 4527
58 4168 Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta 2448 7521 4558
59 4202 Universitas Negeri Medan 2258 7521 4700
60 4217 Universitas Islam Negeri UIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya 1017 7521 5412
Indicators
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers (excluding the first 20)
Profiles

Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited in

EXCELLENCE Top cited
each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full database Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021
Bits and bops …
• Bahasa Inggris
• Open access
• Open citation
• Berhubungan dengan alat ukur lainnya (Scopus, Scimago)
• Traffic ke server
• Metadata
• Marketing
Visibility
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

Laman-laman web
di universitas
 INDICATORS MEANING
Web contents
VISIBILITY
Impact
Referring page title
Black panther - Wikipedia
SMM PTN-BARAT 2022 - Seleksi
Mandiri Masuk PTN-BARAT 2022
Kota Padang - Wikipedia bahasa
Indonesia, ensiklopedia bebas
Kota Padang - Wikipedia bahasa
Indonesia, ensiklopedia bebas
METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the
Ahrefs
institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Majestic
maximum value is chosen)
Referring page URL Target URL Anchor
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_ http://jinh.fmipa.unand.ac.id/index.p "Population dynamics and
panther hp/jinh/article/view/106/75 ecology of Javan leopard,
Panthera pardus melas, in
Gunung Gede Pangrango
National Park, West Java"
https://smmptnbarat.id/ https://www.unand.ac.id/id/ Kunjungi Situs
https://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kota_P http://wacanaetnik.fib.unand.ac.id/in "Urgensi Penguatan Identitas
adang dex.php/wacanaetnik/article/viewFile Kewarganegaraan Subnasional
/42/49 di Kota Padang Pasca Gempa
2009: Studi Tentang Reposisi
Etnis Cina Terhadap Kebijakan
Publik dan Politik Lokal"
https://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kota_P https://www.unand.ac.id/id/berita/un versi asli
adang iversitas/2686-universitas-andalas-
mendapat-akreditasi-institusi-a
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

Black panther - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_panther

http://jinh.fmipa.unand.ac.id/index.php/jinh/article/view/106/75

D. M.; Hindrayani, W.; Mulyanto, A. & Iskandar, D. (2018).

"Population dynamics and ecology of Javan leopard, Panthera pardus melas, in Gunung Gede
Pangrango National Park, West Java" .

Journal of Indonesian Natural History.6(1): 6–13.

INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

6 bulan terakhir

30 hari terakhir
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

# Traffic Traffic (Percent %) # of Keywords # of Pages Subdomain

1 504,332 36 363,484 55,759 scholar.unand.ac.id
2 164,128 12 394 4 portal.unand.ac.id
3 94,679 7 108,210 9,457 repo.unand.ac.id
4 63,917 5 30,529 1,780 jurnal.fk.unand.ac.id
5 41,297 3 16,727 2,370 www.unand.ac.id
6 32,915 2 4,598 214 pmb.unand.ac.id
7 29,740 2 305 4 ilearn.unand.ac.id
8 17,769 1 12,122 172 rsp.unand.ac.id
9 16,841 1 7,499 344 pustaka.unand.ac.id
10 16,689 1 370 110 fekon.ilearn.unand.ac.id
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

• Profil institusi – Website kampus, social media

• Wiki – Wikipedia mengenai profil insitusi dengan links
• Wiki – Konten wikipedia yang merujuk dokumen terbitan kampus
• Berbagi informasi – Social Media
• Tulisan-tulisan – Website, social media, koran daring, blog
• Website “bersahabat dengan metadata” TANPA MODIFIKASI
• LMS – Open access Learning Management Systems
• LiMS – Open access library collections
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)

• Jurnal dan prosiding terbitan kampus – DOI, indeks, akreditasi

• Repository – kampus, publik
• Kearsipan – aplikasi kearsipan dengan standard data internasional
• Video propaganda kampus – link ke website kampus
• Penerbit kampus – buku dalam format elektronik
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT

Number of external networks (subnets) linking to the

Web contents Ahrefs
VISIBILITY institution's webpages (normalized and then the 50%
Impact Majestic
maximum value is chosen)
Openness
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

22.398 15.197

Indonesia World University Impact Openness Excellence

50 3970 Universitas Surabaya 5148 2386 5071
51 3984 Petra Christian University 2443 7521 4234
52 3993 Universitas Negeri Jakarta 3971 7521 3631
53 4003 Universitas Malikussaleh 5545 2805 4940
54 4062 Universitas Katolik Parahyangan 5402 2497 5112
55 4109 Universitas Teknokrat Indonesia 270 1539 7216
56 4130 Universitas Halu Oleo Kendari 2694 7521 4397
57 4139 Universitas Sultan Ageng Tirtayasa 2452 7521 4527
58 4168 Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta 2448 7521 4558
59 4202 Universitas Negeri Medan 2258 7521 4700
60 4217 Universitas Islam Negeri UIN Sunan Ampel Surabaya 1017 7521 5412
43.515
| 7521 adalah penalti => Score = 0 |
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

• 1.183 profil di Google Scholar

• Sitasi 20 outliers: 29.112
• Sitasi profil 21 – 210: 43.515
• Ditemukan profil jurnal dan unit kerja
• Profil personal yang menyimpan publikasi bukan milik sendiri
• Ditemukan profil ganda
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

Profil personal yang menyimpan

publikasi bukan milik sendiri
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

Profil jurnal DAN menyimpan

publikasi bukan milik sendiri
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

Profil jurnal DAN menyimpan

publikasi bukan milik sendiri
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

Profil jurnal DAN menyimpan

publikasi bukan milik sendiri
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

• Dokumen atas nama sendiri • Dokumen ditemukan oleh Google

• Profil berstatus publik (bisa dibaca → DOI, Url website
publik) • Dokumen ditambahkan secara
• Jenis data; manual dan kemudian ditemukan
• Artikel dari jurnal oleh Google Scholar
• Artikel dari konferensi/seminar • Pastikan semua data sesuai,
• Bab dalam buku terutama penulisan nama author.
• Buku • Gunakan email institusi pada profil
• Skripsi/thesis/disertasi
• Paten
• Tuliskan Universitas Halu Oleo
• Laporan/keputusan pengadilan
pada nama institusi
• Dokumen lainnya
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

Advices and warnings about nasty practices (Aguillo, 2020):

• If you have several email addresses for accesing your Google account, probably
you have two or more Google Scholar Citations profiles. Please, delete
duplicate old profiles
• Entries marked # means there are other profiles for the same author
• If your name is common, the best advice is to disable the automatic updating.
The system could add to your profile (a lot of) papers that are signed by other
scientists with a similar name
• It is important to delete all the entries not being authored by you, as the
profile can be excluded until it is cleaned
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

• Contact with your colleagues or co-authors if you discover they are not maintaning
properly their profiles
• Identify yourself with your standard signature name (not inverse)
• Add the ORCID identifier, with the following syntax without blank spaces (ORCID:1234-
56789-8765-4321)
• Provide information about your affiliation, including institution name and country
• Use an institutional email account
• Use keywords in English (about 5) for allowing comparisons with international
colleagues
• Preferably, neither general terms (physics, chemistry, medicine) nor very specific ones
 INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Google
TRANSPARENCY Top cited Number of citations from Top 210 authors (excl. top
Scholar 10%
(or OPENNESS) researchers 20 outliers)
Profiles

• Orcid ID
• Publons ID
• Researchers ID
• Email institusi
• Non individual profiles (journals, departments, groups) included in
the top 210 results are penalized with the EXCLUSION of the whole
institution (citation count equals to zero).
Excellence
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021

#Books #Proceedings

#Academic #Theses/
Journals Dissertations
#Cited
Document

IMPACT/INFLUENCE
in ACADEMIC FIELD
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021

Overall 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

Publications in top 1% most cited 4 0 0 1 2 0 1
Publications in top 1% most cited (%) 0.3 0 0 0.4 0.6 0 0.6
Publications in top 5% most cited 16 0 0 3 3 3 7
Publications in top 5% most cited (%) 1.1 0 0 1.2 0.9 0.7 4
Publications in top 10% most cited 44 5 4 7 4 12 12
Publications in top 10% most cited (%) 3.1 4.8 2.2 2.8 1.2 3 6.9
Publications in top 25% most cited 185 22 31 26 30 46 30
Publications in top 25% most cited (%) 12.9 21.2 17.3 10.2 9.3 11.4 17.2

Citation thresholds for Outputs in Top Citation Percentiles (all publication types)

Percent 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

Top 1% 123 104 80 62 29 8
Top 5% 49 42 33 24 11 3
Top 10% 31 26 21 15 7 2
Top 25% 14 12 9 7 3 1
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021

Scopus

Mendeley
INDICATORS MEANING METHODOLOGY SOURCE WEIGHT
Number of papers amongst the top 10% most cited
EXCELLENCE Top cited in each one of the all 27 disciplines of the full
Scimago 40%
(or SCHOLAR) papers database
Data for the five year period: 2017-2021
 Sustainable Webometrics Ranking Performance

Strategi (Makro) Web

Publications Open Access
Marketing and
Champions Awareness

• Website yang user friendly dan Website Upload Visible Involve

metada mudah diterjemahkan naming publications publications stakeholders

oleh mesin
Accessible file Training of
• Implementasi konsep Digital Content Archive
format users
Marketing
• Menambah jumlah record di Interlinking
Online
publishing
Free electronic
resources
Provision of
funds
repositori
• Publishing → dokumen ilmiah Language Repositories
Enchance IT
Infrastructure
Collaboration
yang dipublikasikan
• Arsip lokal dan arsip internet Interactive
Benchmark
search engine
• Multi bahasa
Citations
Referensi
• Webometrics; webometrics.info
• AhRefs; ahrefs.com
• Google Scholar; scholar.google.com
• Scopus; scopus.com
• Sinta; sinta.kemdikbud.go.id