Refer to attached list of comments [3xA4].

W. Ghasoup
26/5/2014

Mohamad Aboushwareb 26-05-2014

 Reply to GI Boxes

Material Submittal # [1150R1-008-RR-EP-MT-265100-40-Rev01]

With Action Code “B/C’’

MANUFACTURER: - “SLC/KSA”
SUPPLIER: - “SLC/KSA”


Kindlyfindhereunderourpointbypointreplies:Ͳ

A) Remarks:Ͳ    
1. OurapprovalexcludesA1,L1&EX1fixtures..
2. Noted,howeverspecificationtitle//name/numbertobeamendedtoMFFRproject.
3. Noted.
4. Noted.
5. Noted.
6. Noted.

B) ElectricalGeneralComments:Ͳ
1. Thelightingcalculationsareaccepted.
2. Noted,howeverspecificationtitle//name/numbertobeamendedtoMFFRproject.
3. Allitemsrespondedbyoutofscope,byothersornotsubmittediscontractorresponsibility.
4. Noted,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttorelevantsubmittalapproval.
5. Noted,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttorelevantsubmittalapproval.
6. Noted.
7. Noted.
8. Noted.
9. Noted,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttosite/architecturalapproval.
10. Noted,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttorelevantsubmittalapproval.
11. Noted.
12. Noted.
13. Noted.
14. Noted.
15. Noted.
16. 
a. WehavenoticedthatyoursubmittedtestreportnotindicatingtheIECref.,inadditionthemeasured
datacurrentishigherthan/exceedsthementionedIEClimits,clarify.
b. Noted.
17. Noted.
18. Noted.
19. Noted.
20. Noted.
21. Noted.
22. Noted.
23. Noted.

 Page1

 

24. Notedd.
25. Notedd,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttorrelevantsubm mittalapprovval.
26. Notedd.
27. Notedd.
28. Notedd.
29. Notedd.
30. Notedd.
31. Notedd.
32. Notedd.
33. 
a. Noted.
b. Noted.

34. Notedd.
35. Notedd.
36. Notedd.
37. Notedd.
38. Notedd.
39. Wehavenoticedtthatyoursub bmittedtestreportnotin ndicatingtheeIECref.,inaadditionthemeasureddaata
currentishighertthan/exceedssthementio onedIEClimitts,clarify.
40. Notedd.
41. Notedd.
42. Notedd.
43. Notedd.
44. Notedd.

C
C) Structura
alComments:Ͳ
1. Noted d,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttorrelevantsubm mittalapprovval.
2. Noted d,howeverfinalapprovalsubjecttorrelevantsubm mittalapprovval.

D
D) AdditionaalGeneralCo omments:Ͳ
1. Noted d.
2. Noted d.
3. ForAllLEDlightingfixtures:Ͳ
Ͳ Dimmableedriverpowersupplyteechnicaldataasheetshoulldbesubmitttedforapprrovalwhichsshould
includebu utnotlimiteddtoEMIfilteers,THDIcurrent,wiringddiagram,etc.
i. O
Ourconcernisstomaintain nconstantligghtingoutputattheendofLEDlifetim meassuchth
his
feeaturewillbeeabletolockktheoutputatacertainlevelproporttionaltothelifetimewith hout
dimmingthed driverbydim
mcommand,asthedriverritselfcantaakethisactio on.SBGshallfinalize
financialissueesduringBIDDprocess.
ii. W
Wehavenoticcedthatyourofferedfitttingisstep6MacͲAdamsellipseafter25%ofthellifetime,
w
whichviolatin ngourrequireementsofsttep2/3pleasseadvise/am mend.
iii. Sppecifiedcolo
oris4250Kandnot3000Kassubmittted,pleaseaamend.

 Page2



Ͳ Noted
Ͳ ProvidesupportingdocumentensuresthatLORforLEDlightis99.9%.
Ͳ Finalapprovalsubjectto/pendinguponsubmittingLMͲ79&LMͲ80reports.
Ͳ Noted.
Ͳ Noted.
Ͳ Contractortocomply.
Ͳ Noted.
Ͳ Noted.
Ͳ Noted.
Ͳ Noted.
Ͳ Noted.

E) SpecificComments:Ͳ
1. TypeT1“codeC”
a) Noted.
b) RefertospecifiedcommentsonLED[D.3].
c) Submitwiringdiagramforsuchconnectioni.e.twodriversusedineachluminaire.

2. TypeF1,F2,E1,E2,T2,T3,T4,W1“codeB”
a) Noted.
b) Noted.

3. TypeM1“codeC”
a) Noted.
b) Thefixtureshouldbebidirectional.
c) Noted.
d) RefertospecifiedcommentsonLED[D.3].

4. TypeHM“codeB”
a) Noted.
b) Finalapprovalsubjectto/pendinguponwitnesstestinyourlabtoensureIP.

5. TypeP1,P11,P2,P22,P3,P33“codeB”
a) Noted.
b) Finalapprovalsubjectto/pendinguponwitnesstestinyourlabtoensureIP.

6. TypeUB“codeB”
a) Noted.
b) Noted.

F) LowCurrentComments:Ͳ
1. Contractortocomply.
2. Contractortocomply.

 Page3