Professional Documents
Culture Documents
April 2021
3
Information Classification: GENERAL
MSCI ESG Rating model key issues
Example: Soft Drinks Sub-Industry
MSCI ESG Score
GOVERNANCE
ENVIRONMENT PILLAR SOCIAL PILLAR
PILLAR
Env. Social
Climate Natural Pollution & Human Product Stakeholder Corporate Corporate
Opportuniti Opportuniti
Change Capital Waste Capital Liability Opposition Governance Behavior
es es
Toxic Labor Product Access to
Carbon Controversia Business
Water Stress Emissions & Clean Tech Managemen Safety & Communicat Board
Emissions l Sourcing Ethics
Waste t Quality ion
Responsible
Key issues selected for the Soft Drinks Sub- Investment
Industry (e.g. Coca-Cola)
Insuring
Health &
Universal key issues applicable to all industries Demograp
hic Risk
4
Information Classification: GENERAL
Which issues are more relevant?
CARBON WATER PRIVACY & HEALTH &
EMISSIONS STRESS DATA SECURITY SAFETY
t CO2e / mil USD m3 / mil USD Data breaches / fatalities per
sales sales USD sales million
workers
Energy
Materials
Industrials
Cons. Disc.
Cons. Staples
Health Care
Financials
IT
Telecom
Utilities
Real Estate
Sources: Carbon emissions and freshwater withdrawal intensities based on sample of 3,823 and 1,633 companies, respectively as of March 2,
2020. Percentage of companies with active bribery and ethics controversies is based on the number of companies with ongoing bribery & fraud
controversies in the MSCI ACWI Investable Market Index (IMI) as of March 2, 2020. Fatalities per million workers calculated based on three-year
average fatality rates from the Census of Occupational Injuries (US Bureau of Labor Statistics). Data breach intensity calculated based on three-
year average of the number data breaches by sector (Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report) and business segments for companies in the 5
MSCI ACWI Index as of March 2, 2020.
Information Classification: GENERAL
Alternative data helps minimize reliance on voluntary
disclosure to deliver key insights
Alternative data is a Problems to solve:
significant input to ESG • The company does not self disclose sufficient information to gauge its risk
Ratings model management capabilities on the topic
100%
Mandatory
Company • Risks may emerge at the macro level, requiring information external to the
20 company
% Disclosures
80% Alternative data sets are information about a company published by sources outside
of the company. We use them to:
60% Alternative
45 Data • Deliver insight not captured with voluntary company disclosures
%
• Identify unexplored risks and opportunities
40%
• Create innovative signals
Voluntary
20% 35 Company REGULAT
% ESG ORY
Disclosur DATASET
e Example data:
0% Product recalls S
Consumer complaints ALTERNA
2,434 constituents of the MSCI ACWI
Index as of November 30, 2017
TIVE
Source: MSCI ESG Research DATA
Example data: ASSET- SOURCES NEWS Example data:
Facility locations LEVEL AND Controversial incidents
Mine production DATA MEDI Director malpractice
A
6
Information Classification: GENERAL
Example: Measuring exposure to product liability
issues requires more than company disclosure
% of source used to identify product recalls by companies, grouped GICS sub-industry
100%
80%
72 Text mining using alternative data (US FDA,
60% % China Food and Drug Administration (CFDA)
and UK Medicines and Healthcare Products
40%
Regulatory Agency (MHRA))
20% 28 Company disclosures
Company disclosures only
0%
% alone would not
Pharmaceuticals identify product recall
outliers
Example: pharmaceutical industry (Jan’16-Jul’18) – identifying outliers
Description: Recall Class indicates severity of health implications, with Class I being the most severe cases and Class III the least severe recall
types. 120
Class III
Total Product Recalls (Class I, II, III);
100 Class II
January 2016 - September 2018
Class I
80
60
40
20
Perrigo
GSK
Zoetis
Bausch Health
Roche
Lupin
Astellas
UCB
Cadila
Kyowa HK
Dr Reddy's
J&J
BMS
AstraZeneca
Chugai
Merck & Co
Teva
Shionogi
Aurobindo
Novo Nordisk
Bayer
Merck KGaA
Otsuka
Eisai
Glenmark
Sanofi
Mylan
Pfizer
Santen
Daiichi Sankyo
Takeda
Allergan
Sun Pharma
Novartis
Sumitomo
Mitsubishi
“n” references the companies flagged for product recalls. Source: MSCI ESG Research, MSCI ACWI as of 20 Dec 2018 7
Source: MSCI ESG Research, US FDA, UKInformation
MHRA, Australia Classification: GENERAL
TGA, Health Canada, and Japan Pharmaceutical and Medical Devices Agency
Tech-enabled human insights
We use technology and artificial intelligence
(AI) to increase the timeliness and precision
of data collection and analysis, and to check
and validate data
20% of all data extracted Dynamic rating model New analytical techniques 60% of files validated via
via natural language calibrated to company-, allow researchers to derive pre-release AI based
processing & advanced industry- and market- timely insights from checks
parsing techniques specific factors unstructured data
Data Quality
Assessment Insights
extraction review
Subject-matter specialists Every rating validated by Research analysts share Analysts conduct profile
validate and refine data lead company analyst and, unique insights providing reviews and threshold-
extracted by machines if needed, defended to context and analysis on key based quality checks
industry lead and rating trends, events
committees
5. 3. controversies
Upgrade, Incorporate
new
downgra
de or re-
information in 425 companies are
scores and updated to reflect new
affirm 4. report on governance information
rating Significant weekly basis
All ratings pro-
actively reviewed score
in full if no rating changes
action has been
triggered in last trigger
12 months rating Over 2,300,000 data values updated per
action month
Information Classification: GENERAL
Systematic data verification process
incorporating issuer feedback
INDEPENDENT
8 people dedicated to issuer ▪ No solicited ESG Rating
communications, representing ▪ Dedicated team focusing solely
210+ ESG analysts. on issuers’ communications
CONSISTENT
One portal enabling issuers ▪ Systematic outreach to all
to download their rating, verify companies
their data and learn about ESG
▪ Standard data review process
1 2 3 4
Reporting Risk Returns Mobilization
• Implement a common Management • Establish best • Increase private financial
disclosure framework practice/standards for flows by connecting
built on the TCFD • Ensure that the financial financial institutions to available capital with
recommendations sector can measure and assess the credibility of investable projects and
manage climate-related companies’ transition encouraging new market
• Improve the quality and financial risks.
quantity of climate- plans to net zero. structures.
related financial • Embed use of scenario • Create a framework for
disclosures. analysis in the financial measuring the alignment
sector using the NGFS of investment portfolios
reference scenarios with climate targets.
237
The Task Force on Climate-related 101
Financial Disclosure (TCFD) is a voluntary Release of TCFD 2017 2018 2019 2020
disclosure platform designed to: Report June
2017
provide a framework for companies and
other organizations to develop more GOVERNANCE STRATEGY RISK MANAGEMENT METRICS & TARGETS
As the transition
@Enterprise level (Asset Manager / General Partner) accelerates, companies
with a well-articulated
Establish & report on: @Fund / portfolio level
Governance long-term strategy, and a
Strategy: overall climate risk
@Holding / company level clear plan to address the
Measure & report on:
assessment, scenarios analysis
S1 & 2 footprint; Scope 3 transition to net zero, will
Expected actions: footprint; Brown/Green ratio; Identify exposure to climate
Integration into overall risk Scenario analysis, T° alignment risks & opportunities: distinguish themselves
management Expected actions: Measure: S123 emissions, with their stakeholders -
brown & green exposure,
Strategic asset allocation Re-allocate from brown to
physical risk exposure, TCFD with customers,
Set Net Zero Targets green; divestment policy;
Tilt towards leaders & away
disclosure policymakers, employees
Report on TCFD Assess credibility of
Policy advocacy
from laggards;
companies’ transition plans to and shareholders”
Use a climate-related / ESG Net Zero: patents, green CapEx,
performance benchmark targets scorecard, T° alignment Larry Fink's 2021 letter to CEOs extract.
Expected actions:
Select securities
Engage
https://www.blackrock.com/corporate/investor-relations/larry-fink-ceo-letter
Information Classification: GENERAL 15
The four dimensions of MSCI Climate Analytical Framework
Coverage:
More than 10,400 companies including large, mid and small cap developed and emerging market equities, as well as Investment Grade, high yield
and emerging market fixed income issuers; 198 countries for select / relevant metrics.
Measure the carbon footprint of your holdings along different scopes and conduct
attribution analysis
Understand how your holdings rely upon "Brown Revenues" for growth
Assess how management teams are able to adapt to new/upcoming regulatory constraints
Source: MSCI ESG Research, extract from the Climate Risk TCFD portfolio level template
Information Classification: GENERAL 17
Capture Green opportunities
Security Selection - Identify & invest in climate solution providers, including companies investing in
low carbon technologies.
Report on your exposure to EU-taxonomy aligned companies.
Consider tilting portfolios towards companies that are developing low Assess the current revenue streams of companies to assess which are already
carbon technologies generating revenue from low carbon products and services
On a company level,
ask yourself:
Are the companies you
have invested in aware of
physical climate risk
exposure?
A - AA -25% A -75%
Transition MSCI USD IG MSCI USD IG MSCI USD IG
to a low carbon Corporate Bond ESG Leaders Climate Change
Corporate Bond Corporate Bond
economy
ESG Carbon ESG Carbon ESG Carbon
A - AA -10% A -30%
Stranded MSCI Global MSCI Global MSCI World
asset risk Alternative Green Building Women’s
Better Energy Leadership
Portfolio?
MSCI ESG Indexes and Analytics utilize information from, but are not provided by, MSCI ESG Research LLC.
Information Classification: GENERAL 21
Communicate on progress and outcomes
Technology Opportunities
+2.67% +3.51% -0.84%
VERY VERY Climate VaR
HIGH MODERATE LOW
HIGH LOW Physical Climate
-1.58% -2.78% 1.20%
VaR (Aggressive)
-7.7% 155.6
less than
current
portfolio
Current Alternate
portfolio Portfolio
Leadership in Leadership in
Climate Data & Analytics Climate Indexes
Climate Data Provider to 16 of the #1 Climate Index Provider by Equity
World’s Top 20 Asset Managers6 Assets Linked to its Climate Indexes8
700+ Climate Change Metrics,
Covering 10,000+ Issuers7 London
Stockholm
Potsdam
Toronto
Frankfurt
Chicago Boston
Geneva
San Francisco Seoul
New York Tokyo
Paris
Beijing
Shanghai
#1 ESG Data and Research Provider 4 #1 ESG Index Provider by Equity ETF
Assets Linked to its ESG Indexes3
1,900+ MSCI ESG Research Clients5 Cape Town
Globally with Coverage of 14,800+ $106B Linked to Equity ESG Assets3 Sydney
Issuers and 650,000+ Securities 70% of Equity ESG ETF Flows as of Q4’203
1 Through MSCI legacy companies KLD, Innovest, IRRC, and GMI Ratings; 2 Source MSCI Inc. as of February 2021; 3 Data based on Refinitiv Universe as of December 2020, only primary listings, and not cross-listings; 4 UBS
Report published 2/16/2020 “Is the ESG Data and Services TAM Expanding? Who is Capitalizing on the Trend?” -Survey data from 35 Mutual funds, 18 hedge funds, 9 pension funds, 63 Wealth Management (High Net Worth),
and 48 Long-only institutional investors. ; 5 To calculate the number of clients, we use the shipping address of the ultimate customer utilizing the product, which counts affiliates, user locations or business units within a
single organization as separate clients; 6 MSCI ESG Research’s climate solutions are used by 16 of the top 20 world’s largest Asset Managers as determined by Willis Towers Watson report “The world’s largest 500 asset
managers, Joint study with Pensions & Investments.” AUM and rankings calculated as of December 2019. Report published October 2020; 7 Source: MSCI ESG Research as of February 2021
8 Data as of 30th September 2020, based on eVestment for Institutional funds, Morningstar for Retail funds and Refinitiv Universe for ETFs
Required Company’s
Emission Green Revenue Heavy
DERIVED DATA Extreme Projected
Reduction 2030 Precipitation &
heat and cold Intensities at
at 2030 Projections snowfall
2030
Fundamental data: revenues at SIC/country level, Enterprise Value, WACC, profit margins
Coverage: More than 10,400 companies including large, mid and small cap developed and emerging market equities, as well as Investment Grade, high yield and emerging market fixed income issuers*; 198
countries for select / relevant metrics. *Facilities location is not fully exposed to clients.
Information Classification: GENERAL 24
Visualizing Investment Data @ MSCI.com
Top 5 Sustainable Global Progress Towards the
The Truth Behind 5 ESG Myths
Investing Questions Paris Agreement And
More!
25
Information Classification: GENERAL
Growth of ESG Investing
*Note : ETF Data based on Refinitiv Universe as of December 2020; only primary listings, and not cross-listings
Information Classification: GENERAL 26
About MSCI
MSCI is a leading provider of critical decision support tools and services for the
global investment community. With over 50 years of expertise in research, data
and technology, we power better investment decisions by enabling clients to
understand and analyze key drivers of risk and return and confidently build more
effective portfolios. We create industry-leading research-enhanced solutions that
clients use to gain insight into and improve transparency across the investment
process. To learn more, please visit www.msci.com.
Atlanta + 1 404 551 3212 Frankfurt + 49 69 133 859 00 China South 10800 152 1032 *
Boston + 1 617 532 0920 Geneva + 41 22 817 9777 Hong Kong + 852 2844 9333
Chicago + 1 312 675 0545 London + 44 20 7618 2222 Mumbai + 91 22 6784 9160
Monterrey + 52 81 1253 4020 Milan + 39 02 5849 0415 Seoul 00798 8521 3392 *
New York + 1 212 804 3901 Paris 0800 91 59 17 * Singapore 800 852 3749 *
The process for submitting a formal index complaint can be found on the index regulation page of MSCI’s website at:
https://www.msci.com/index-regulation.
Information Classification: GENERAL 29