Person A won a legal battle against person B and is now free from the liability imputed against

him. Nevertheless, person A paid person B. Thus, what has been voluntarily delivered or paid
cannot be reclaimed anymore.

Person A pays person B’s tuition without the knowledge of person B. Nevertheless, person B
reimburses person A. Therefore, person B cannot recover what has already to person B.

Without the consent of her parents, person A, a minor, worked as a waitress for a local
restaurant. She was already commissioned for one week’s worth of service. Upon realizing that
Person A was underaged, the owner fired person A. And out of conscience, Person A gave
back her earnings. Person A cannot, therefore, retrieve what she has already given back to the
owner.

A child, without the knowledge of his guardian, bought an expensive shoe from his local
shoemaker. The guardian or the child, therefore, cannot demand a refund given that the
shoemaker has already spent his commission in good faith.

Deceased Person A left a will that states the division of his properties to his five children.
However, his will was not enacted due to errors in the payment process. One of the five children
paid for the settlements. Thus, their payments are valid and cannot be recovered.