Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FEATURE
As seen in
Plant Engineering
Magazine
By Nick Agius
This paper provides information and solutions for millwrights and maintenance engineers working with fans and
blowers. The author, through his extensive experience in the field and his interaction with maintenance personnel,
has been able to identify and develop some unique ways of solving these problems. Plant engineers who write
specifications for fans and blowers should review this paper.
SAF and SAFD Housings Due to its shallow lubrication reservoir, the SNH style is
Selecting the correct housing is most critical. The most popular really only suited for grease service although the pillow block
pillow block styles for fans and blowers are the SAF and SAFD manufacturers state that this block is made for either grease or oil.
housings. In Canada, the SAFD is the more common of the two. Occasionally, end users have tried to convert from grease to oil on
Both styles were developed in North America. Although both the SNH housing. The results have been unsuccessful. The small
designs are able to accommodate oil lubrication, the SAFD has a lubrication reservoir creates a problem when using a standard
larger lubrication reservoir for shaft sizes greater than 3 1/4˝. This sight glass in the drain holes. The actual static oil level is not much
makes the SAFD superior for fans and blowers. Also, the SAFD has higher than the center line of the drain hole. This causes a problem
a ductile body, which makes it the first choice for fan service. See because the brass block at the base of the sight glass gets in the way
Figure 1. of the actual oil level. Drain holes are not standard on the SNH,
so they have to be field drilled. The one way the SNH block would
work with oil is if a re-circulating oil system was utilized.
The SNH contact style seal is not well suited for fan service and
will cause problems for fan and blower applications. This standard
“G” type contact lip seal causes too much heat at higher speeds.
On one high-speed fan application at a sodium chlorate plant, the
temperature was lowered on the SNH pillow block from 60°C to
40°C. The success was attributed to a seal upgrade. Instead of using
the standard “G” type contact lip seal, the JM Clipper labyrinth,
non-contact seal was installed, which will be covered in more detail
on page 10.
The reason why the SNH pillow block finds its way onto fan
applications is that it is priced lower than the SAFD. Because of
this, fan OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) will supply
Both styles are equipped with standard aluminum labyrinth the SNH in an attempt to reduce costs and make their overall
seals that are suited for fans because of the non-contact design. package more attractive to purchase. End users should review new
This style of seal is ideal for running at higher speeds of 1800 and equipment being supplied to ensure that the correct pillow block
3600 RPM. If this standard labyrinth design came with an O-ring styles are specified from the start. By having the proper pillow block
in the inner bore it would be a much better design. As of June housing specified, you will lower operating costs down the road.
1999, SKF has upgraded its LER design to that of a LOR design
with an O-ring on the inner bore of the seal. The inner O-ring is SNL Housings
particularly useful when the end user decides to use oil instead of The SKF Company introduced the SNL housing to supersede
grease because the O-ring will seal along the shaft. This sealing the SNH block. All dimensions and parts remain the same as the
concept will be discussed in more detail on page 10 under the SNH. In fact, besides the color, it is hard to tell them apart. SKF
heading “Special Labyrinth Seals for Pillow Blocks.” made some internal changes that would be of interest to the end
users. It would have been beneficial for SKF to take advantage of the
design change to deepen the lubrication reservoir. This would have
allowed the end user to convert SNH and SNL blocks from grease to
oil on high-speed fan applications without external oil systems.
1. Fit the existing housing (at the time Cooper made a bearing
to fit SAFD housings but they since discontinued that
bearing design so now the Cooper bearing would need its
own housing)
2. Float axially within the bearing and not depend on the outer
ring to float in the housing
They are ideally suited for use on most centrifugal pumps, How It Works...
however the author strongly questions their use on most styles of At the heart of the system is the Oil Mist generator, in which
pillow block housings. They can be used on the Dodge Sleeveoil oil is atomized by high-velocity air. See Figure 13.
Pillow Block as long as you install the oiler into the drain hole
directly under the shaft and not in the existing sight glass hole.
The existing sight glass hole is designed for a bulls-eye sight glass.
The idea of the bulls-eye sight glass is that the oil level, by design,
should be at the middle. If you try to use an automatic oiler in the
same hole, it is impossible to adjust the level low enough. This is
why the complaint that is heard is Dodge Sleeveoils have poor seals
and that they leak oil. This problem can be eliminated if you use
the oiler in the correct position.
Another option is to install the Trico “Watchdog” in the sight
glass hole. See Figure 12. This Trico oiler is designed for bulls-eye
type oiler systems and has many other uses in the petrochemical
marketplace, especially on pumps and gear boxes. The Watchdog
oiler is a closed system design that eliminates contamination Baffles intercept large particles and return them to the
getting in through the oiler. reservoir. The remaining, smoke-like suspension of minute oil
The problem with automatic oilers (on SAFD and SNH particles in the air is distributed through pipes, tubes and hoses at
housings) is that the actual dynamic oil level is not the same as the low pressure and velocity.
static oil level when the shaft is turning. Depending upon which The mist flow is metered to each lubrication point by an
side of the housing the oiler is positioned on, it will either give application fitting. There are three main types of fittings used:
too much oil at start up or it will allow the oil level to sink too low Mist, Spray and Condensing. See Figure 14.
before the oiler releases oil, which might be too late.
Nick has published an extensive Technical Angular Contact Crossover Catalog which
has received international recognition.
He would like to acknowledge the following people whose assistance helped put this paper together:
This Fan and Blower Bearing technical paper has been published by Plant Engineering magazine
and IDI magazine.
ALBERTA AB74 6202 54th Ave BRITISH COLUMBIA BC88 101-30444 Great Northern Ave
Drayton Valley AB, T7A 1S1 Abbotsford BC, V2T 6Y6
AB01 236 36th St 780.542.4814 BC21 8985 Fraserwood Crt 604.556.0716
N. Lethbridge AB, T1H 3Z7 Dallas Lambe Burnaby BC, V5J 5E8 Jeff Hockin
403.327.1571 dallas.lambe@motioncanada.com 604.637.2860 jeff.hockin@motioncanada.com
Rod Machtmes Jeff Hockin
rod.machtmes@motioncanada.com AB77 2714 5th St jeff.hockin@motioncanada.com BC89 2860 C Hwy 16, PO Box
Nisku AB, T9E 0H1 1109
AB03 16-4155 75th Ave SE 780.955.7494 BC27 517C Industrial Road D Houston BC, V0J 1Z0
Calgary AB, T2C 2K8 George Shields Cranbrook BC, V1C 6R8 250.845.3308
403.236.5581 george.shields@motioncanada.com 250.426.8060 Chris Berry
Ken Spring Aaron Jones chris.berry@motioncanada.com
ken.spring@motioncanada.com AB83 5803 63rd Ave aaron.jones1@motioncanada.com
Lloydminster AB, T9V 3C3
AB05 5736 59th St 780.875.2399 BC44 1-2001 Hartley Ave MANITOBA
Edmonton AB, T6B 3C3 Jennifer Schmitz Coquitlam BC, V3K 6Z3
780.465.0821 jschmitz@csinet.ca 604.927.5800 MB20 1-1411 Richmond Ave E
Mike Lemieux Jeff Hockin Brandon MB, R7A 7A3
mike.lemieux@motioncanada.com AB84 2 Silver Sage Rd, Box 512 jeff.hockin@motioncanada.com 204.725.1419
Brooks AB, T1R 1B5 Anna Spence
AB15 321 Macdonald Cres 403.501.3888 BC46 10703 89th Ave anna.spence@motioncanada.com
Fort McMurray AB, T9H 4B7 Tammy Shannon Fort St John BC, V1J 5S8
780.743.5504 tammy.shannon@motioncanada.com 250.787.0656 MB21 1-75 Meridian Dr
Ross Jenkins Darcy Krutkevich Winnipeg MB, R2R 2V9
ross.jenkins@motioncanada.com AB91 CanGlobal – 901 17th Ave darcy.krutkevich@motioncanada.com 204.694.0050
Nisku AB, T9E 0G4 Greg Moore
AB39 3-7730 Edgar Industrial Crt 780.955.7009 BC65 101-880 Great St greg.moore@motioncanada.com
Red Deer AB, T4P 4E2 Nathan Legresky Prince George BC, V2N 5R7
403.343.6733 nathan.legresky@motioncanada.com 250.563.0452
Andrew Spindor Rob Mulyk NEW BRUNSWICK
andrew.spindor@motioncanada.com rob.mulyk@motioncanada.com
NB01 138 Main St
Hartland NB, E7P 2M5
AB51 128A North St BC67 162 Third St
506.375.4441
Hinton AB, T7V 1S8 Kitimat BC, V8C 2H5
Robert Tompkins
780.865.7976 250.632.7107
robert.tompkins@motioncanada.com
Dallas Lambe Steve Sutherland
dallas.lambe@motioncanada.com steve.sutherland@motioncanada.com
NB03 270 Baig Blvd, Unit A-3
Moncton NB, E1E 1C8
AB52 101-8402 112th St BC68 1405 River St
506.859.4345
Grande Prairie AB, T8V 5X4 Kamloops BC, V2C 1Z1
Robert Tompkins
780.814.5933 250.372.9518
robert.tompkins@motioncanada.com
Darcy Krutkevich Rob Wiens
darcy.krutkevich@motioncanada.com rob.wiens@motioncanada.com
NEWFOUNDLAND ON11 B-5448 Timberlea Blvd QUEBEC QC30 5-6755, boul Choquette
Mississauga ON, L4W 2T7 St-Hyacinthe QC, J2S 8L2
NF01 32 2nd Ave, PO Box 629 905.695.7878 QC01 330, av Avro 450.774.3050
Wabush NF, A0R 1B0 Jeffrey Diggle Pointe-Claire QC, H9R 5W5 Claude Bourdon
709.282.5085 jeffrey.diggle@motioncanada.com 514.459.3316 claude.bourdon@motioncanada.com
Louis Tremblay Alain Giroux
louis.tremblay@motioncanada.com ON16 220 Adam St alain.giroux@motioncanada.com QC31 430, rue des Artisans
Belleville ON, K8N 5S4 Rimouski QC, G5M 1A3
613.966.1923 QC03 6155, rue Corbeil 418.725.3750
NOVA SCOTIA Dan Johnston Trois-Rivières QC, G8Z 4P8 Reginald Poirier
dan.johnston@motioncanada.com 819.374.2788 reginald.poirier@motioncanada.com
NS01 4-50 Akerley Blvd Lyne Levesque
Dartmouth NS, B3B 1R8 lyne.levesque@motioncanada.com
ON17 16-333 California Ave
902.468.3231 SASKATCHEWAN
Brockville ON, K6V 5V5
Robert Fredericks QC04 495, av Noël
613.342.8894
robert.fredericks@motioncanada.com Sept-Îles QC, G4R 1M1 SK01 40-3903 Arthur Rose Ave
Randy Morrison
randy.morrison@motioncanada.com 418.962.3232 Saskatoon SK, S7P 0C8
NS02 77 Park St Louis Tremblay 306.931.7771
New Glasgow NS, B2H 5B7 louis.tremblay@motioncanada.com Bob Thomas
ON19 1656 Woodward Dr
902.755.3540 bob.thomas@motioncanada.com
Ottawa ON, K2C 3R8
Robert Fredericks QC08 1272, rue de Lanaudière
613.723.6200
robert.fredericks@motioncanada.com Joliette QC, J6E 3P2 SK02 411 Park St
Manfred Wegner
manfred.wegner@motioncanada.com 450.759.6343 Regina SK, S4N 5B2
Alain Giroux 306.721.7233
ONTARIO Randy Greenman
ON25 2-1060 Lorne St alain.giroux@motioncanada.com
Sudbury ON, P3C 4R9 randy.greenman@motioncanada.com
ON02 510 Weber St N
Waterloo ON, N2L 4E9 705.671.0000 QC09 3000, rue Einstein
Brent Richer Québec QC, G1X 4B3 SK21 523 Hwy 3
519.884.1220
brent.richer@motioncanada.com 418.657.3000 Hudson Bay SK, S0E 0Y0
Pete Dietrich
Bertin Doiron 306.865.2245
pete.dietrich@motioncanada.com
ON27 3-33 Colonization Ave bertin.doiron@motioncanada.com Bob Thomas
Dryden ON, P8N 2L8 bob.thomas@motioncanada.com
ON04 5-15911 Robin’s Hill Rd
London ON, N5V 0A5 807.223.3928 QC10 87, rue des Routiers
519.681.5800 Heather Hoffstrom Saguenay QC, G7H 5B1
Jeffrey Maxwell heather.hoffstrom@motioncanada.com 418.696.1221
jeffrey.maxwell@motioncanada.com Carl Simard
ON33 8-3761 Victoria Park Ave carl.simard@motioncanada.com
ON05 1355 Confederation St Scarborough ON, M1W 3S2
Sarnia ON, N7S 4T2 905.695.7878 QC20 1685, rte Marie-Victorin
519.332.4500 Jeffrey Diggle Sorel-Tracy QC, J3R 4R4
John Mellor jeffrey.diggle@motioncanada.com 450.742.3749
john.mellor@motioncanada.com Marc Veronneau
marc.veronneau@motioncanada.com
ON06 650 Woodlawn Rd W,
Units 13 and 14 QC24 4235, boul Industriel
Guelph ON, N1K 1B8 Sherbrooke QC, J1L 2S7
519.763.0710 819.563.5732
Steve Pieterse Stephen Corriveau
stephen.corriveau@motioncanada.com
steve.pieterse@motioncanada.com
Our local sales and service specialists are experts in application and
technical support, providing the parts and the know-how you need
to stay up and running.
Motion Shop
Motion Branch
Motion DC
Call. 800-526-9328
Click. www.MotionCanada.com
Visit. Over 50 Locations