You are on page 1of 14

Publication List by Subject (with abstracts) : Abhishek Banerjee

1 List of Publications 1

2 Publications in Algebraic Geometry & Categorical Algebra 4


2.1 Schemes and symmetric monoidal categories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2.2 Categorical algebra and Homological algebra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
2.3 Tensor triangular geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
2.4 Bivariant Chow groups and Saito’s filtration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

3 Publications in Noncommutative Geometry 9


3.1 Modular Hecke operators of Connes and Moscovici . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
3.2 Hochschild and Cyclic homology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

4 Publications on other topics 12

§1 List of Publications
[ 49 ] Two criteria for locally noetherian Grothendieck categories: Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra
(Accepted).
[ 48 ] (with S. Kour) On measurings of algebras over operads and homology theories: Algebraic & Geo-
metric Topology (Accepted).

[ 47 ] (with M. Balodi and S. Ray) Entwined modules over linear categories and Galois extensions: Israel
Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 241, 623–692 (2021).
[ 46 ] On Noetherian schemes over (C, ⊗, 1) and the category of quasi-coherent sheaves: Indiana Uni-
versity Mathematics Journal, Vol. 70 (2021), 81–119.

[ 45 ] F I-modules over preadditive categories and torsion theories: Journal of Pure and Applied Alge-
bra, Vol. 225 (2021), 106595.
[ 44 ] (with M. Balodi and A. Naolekar) BV-operators and the secondary Hochschild complex: C. R. Math.
Acad. Sci. Paris, Vol. 358 (2020) no. 11-12, pp. 1239-1258.
[ 43 ] (with M. Balodi and S. Ray) Cohomology of modules over H-categories and co-H-categories: Cana-
dian Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 72, No. 5, 1352–1385, (2020).
[ 42 ] Spectra as universal objects in categories of supports: Banach Center Publications, Vol. 120,
53–69 (2020).
[ 41 ] (with S. Kour) (A, δ)-modules, Hochschild homology and higher derivations: Annali di Matematica
Pura ed Applicata, Vol. 198, No. 5 (2019) 1781–1802.
[ 40 ] On differential torsion theories and rings with several objects: Canadian Mathematical Bul-
letin, Vol. 62, No. 4 (2019) 703–714.
[ 39 ] Completions of monoid objects and descent results: Journal of Algebra, Vol. 507, 362–399 (2018).
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ 38 ] Modular Hecke Algebras over Möbius Categories: Journal of Geometry and Physics (Special Volume for
Alain Connes’ 70th Birthday), Vol. 131, 23–40 (2018).
[ 37 ] Quasimodular Hecke algebras and Hopf actions: Journal of Noncommutative Geometry, Vol. 12, No.3
(2018) 1041–1080.
[ 36 ] A topological nullstellensatz for tensor triangulated categories: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris,
Vol. 356, No. 4, 365–375 (2018).
[ 35 ] On Auslander’s formula and cohereditary torsion pairs: Communications in Contemporary Mathe-
matics, Vol. 20, No. 6, Paper no. 1750071 (2018).
[ 34 ] Closure operators in abelian categories and spectral spaces: Theory and Applications of cate-
gories, Vol. 32, No. 20, 719–735 (2017).
[ 33 ] Noetherian schemes over abelian symmetric monoidal categories: International Journal of Mathe-
matics, Vol. 28, No. 7, Paper No. 1750051, 34 pp. (2017).
[ 32 ] On some spectral spaces associated to tensor triangulated categories: Arch. Math. (Basel), Vol.
108, No. 6, 581–591 (2017).
[ 31 ] Monoidal semifilters and arrays of prime ideals: Fund. Math., Vol. 237, No. 3, 281–296 (2017).
[ 30 ] Realizations of pairs and Oka families in tensor triangulated categories: European Journal of
Mathematics, Vol. 2, No. 3, 760–797 (2016).
[ 29 ] Some remarks on a theorem of Bergman: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci Paris, Vol. 354, No. 7, 665–670 (2016).
[ 28 ] Homologie de Hochschild et espaces algébriques: Math. Scand., Vol. 118, No. 1, 33–42 (2016).
[ 27 ] Schemes over symmetric monoidal categories and torsion theories: Journal of Pure and Applied
Algebra, Vol. 220, No. 9, 3017–3047 (2016).
[ 26 ] Une note sur les dérivations localement nilpotentes dans les catégories monoı̈dales
symétriques: Bulletin of the Belgian Mathematical Society, Vol. 23, No. 1, 151–160 (2016).
[ 25 ] Schémas sur les catégories abéliennes monoı̈dales symétriques et faisceaux
quasi-cohérents: Journal of Algebra, Vol. 423, 148–176. (2015).
[ 24 ] Nearby cycles and the Dold-Kan correspondence : Communications in Algebra, Vol. 43, No. 12, 5362–
5371 (2015).
[ 23 ] Action de Hopf sur les opérateurs de Hecke modulaires tordus: Journal of Noncommutative Geom-
etry, Vol. 9, No. 4 (2015), 1155–1173.
[ 22 ] Extensions de la filtration de Saito: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci Paris, Vol. 352 , No. 5, 377–382. (2014)
[ 21 ] Les motifs de Tate et les opérateurs de périodicité de Connes: Ann. Math. Blaise Pascal, Vol.
21, No.1, 1–23 (2014).
[ 20 ] Localization of monoid objects and Hochschild homology: Communications in Algebra, Vol. 42, No.
10, 4548–4558. (2014).
[ 19 ] On the Lie transformation algebra of monoids in symmetric monoidal categories: Rend. Sem.
Mat. Univ. Padova, Vol. 131, 151–157 (2014).

2
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ 18 ] Bivariant Chow groups and the topology of envelopes: Topology and its applications, Vol. 160, No.
1, 230–240 (2013).
[ 17 ] Connes-Karoubi long exact sequence for Fréchet sheaves: Münster Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 6,
167–179 (2013).

[ 16 ] Hecke Operators on Line bundles over Modular Curves: Journal of Number Theory, Vol 132, No. 4,
714–734. (2012).
[ 15 ] Affine Group Schemes over Symmetric Monoidal Categories: Pacific Journal of Mathematics Vol. 255
(2012), No. 1, 25–40 (2012).
[ 14 ] Centre of Monoids, centralisers and localisation: Communications in Algebra, Vol 40, No. 11,
3975–3993 (2012).
[ 13 ] Derived Schemes and the Field with one element: Journal de Mathématiques Pures et Appliquées Vol
97, No. 3, 189–203 (2012).
[ 12 ] Lifting of model structures to fibred categories: Homology, Homotopy and Applications, Vol. 13.
No. 2, 1–17 (2011).
[ 11 ] Higher Bivariant Chow Groups and Motivic Filtrations: Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. Vol. 363, No. 11,
5943–5969. (2011).
[ 10 ] The relative Picard Functor on Schemes over a symmetric monoidal category: Bulletin des Sci-
ences Mathematiques Vol. 135, 400–419 (2011).

[ 9 ] Hopf Action and Rankin-Cohen Brackets on an Archimedean Complex: Journal of Noncommutative Ge-
ometry Vol. 5, No. 3, 401–421. (2011).
[ 8 ] Zeta Functions of certain noncommutative algebras: Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci. Vol. 87,
No. 4, 51–55, (2011).

[ 7 ] A note on product structures on Hochschild homology of schemes: Colloquium Mathematicum Vol.


123, No. 2, 233–238. (2011).
[ 6 ] Higher Derivations and Hochschild Homology: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Soc. R. Can. Vol. 33, No. 2,
33–43. (2011).

[ 5 ] Nearby Cycles and Periodicity in Cyclic Homology: In: Noncommutative Geometry, Arithmetic
and Related Topics: Proceedings of the 21st JAMI Conference, pp. 1–30 Johns Hopkins University Press (2011).
[ 4 ] Hopf Cyclic Cohomology and Biderivations: Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., Vol. 138, No. 6, 1929–1939,
(2010).
[ 3 ] Cartan Homotopy Formulae and the Bivariant Hochschild Complex: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris, Vol.
347, No. 17-18, pp 997-1000, (2009).
[ 2 ] A Note on Regularity Properties with respect to Ideals: Communications in Algebra, Vol. 36, No.
3, pp 1067–1077, (2008).
[ 1 ] Unique Factorization and Ring Extensions: International Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics, Vol.
26, No.4, pp 457–464, (2006).

3
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

Other Publications (As an undergraduate student at Indian Statistical Institute)


• Noetherian Rings, Dimension and Chain conditions: American Journal of Undergraduate Research, Vol 4,
No. 3 (2005).
• Exactness, Tor and Flat modules over a Commutative Ring: American Journal of Undergraduate Research,
Vol 3, No. 3 (2004).

§2 Publications in Algebraic Geometry & Categorical Algebra

§ 2.1 Schemes and symmetric monoidal categories


[ AG 2.1.11 ] On Noetherian schemes over (C, ⊗, 1) and the category of quasi-coherent sheaves: Indi-
ana University Mathematics Journal, Vol. 70 (2021), 81–119.
Abstract: Let (C, ⊗, 1) be an abelian symmetric monoidal category satisfying certain conditions and let X be a
scheme over (C, ⊗, 1) in the sense of Toën and Vaquié. In this paper we show that when X is quasi-compact and
semi-separated, any quasi-coherent sheaf on X may be expressed as a directed colimit of its finitely generated quasi-
coherent submodules. Thereafter, we introduce a notion of “field objects” in (C, ⊗, 1) that satisfy several properties
similar to those of fields in usual commutative algebra. Finally we show that the points of a Noetherian, quasi-
compact and semi-separated scheme X over such a field object K in (C, ⊗, 1) can be recovered from certain kinds of
functors between categories of quasi-coherent sheaves. The latter is a partial generalization of some recent results of
Brandenburg and Chirvasitu.
[ AG 2.1.10 ] Completions of monoid objects and descent results: Journal of Algebra, Vol. 507, 362–399
(2018).
Abstract: Let (C, ⊗, 1) be an abelian closed symmetric monoidal category satisfying certain conditions. The purpose
of this paper is to prove three descent results for schemes over (C, ⊗, 1) that are not necessarily Noetherian.
[ AG 2.1.9 ] Noetherian schemes over abelian symmetric monoidal categories: International Journal of
Mathematics, Vol. 28, No. 7, Paper No. 1750051, 34 pp. (2017).
Abstract: In this paper, we develop basic results of algebraic geometry over abelian symmetric monoidal categories.
Let A be a commutative monoid object in an abelian symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1) satisfying certain
conditions and let E(A) = HomA−M od (A, A). If the subobjects of A satisfy a certain compactness property, we say
that A is Noetherian. We study the localisation of A with respect to any s ∈ E(A) and define the quotient A/I
of A with respect to any ideal I ⊆ E(A). We use this to develop appropriate analogues of the basic notions from
usual algebraic geometry (such as Noetherian schemes, irreducible, integral and reduced schemes, function field, the
local ring at the generic point of a closed subscheme, etc) for schemes over (C, ⊗, 1) . Our notion of a scheme over
a symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1) is that of Toën and Vaquié.
[ AG 2.1.8 ] Schemes over symmetric monoidal categories and torsion theories: Journal of Pure and Ap-
plied Algebra, Vol. 220, No. 9, 3017–3047 (2016).

Abstract: Let (C, ⊗, 1) be an abelian symmetric monoidal category satisfying certain conditions and let X be a
scheme over (C, ⊗, 1) in the sense of Toën and Vaquié. In this paper, we construct torsion theories on the categories
OX − M od and QCoh(X) respectively of OX -modules and quasi-coherent sheaves on X, when X is Noetherian
and integral over (C, ⊗, 1). Thereafter, we study these torsion theories with respect to the quasi-coherator QX :
OX − M od −→ QCoh(X) that is right adjoint to the inclusion iX : QCoh(X) −→ OX − M od. Finally, we obtain
an alternative description of the quasi-coherator QX (F) as a subsheaf of F, when F ∈ OX − M od satisfies certain
conditions. Along the way, we present further results on the notions of “Noetherian” and “integral” for schemes over
(C, ⊗, 1) that we believe to be of independent interest.

4
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ AG 2.1.7 ] Schémas sur les catégories abéliennes monoı̈dales symétriques et faisceaux


quasi-cohérents: Journal of Algebra, Vol. 423, 148–176. (2015).
Résumé: Soit X un schéma sur une catégorie abélienne monoı̈dale symétrique (C, ⊗, 1) vérifiant certaines con-
ditions. Dans cet article, nous développons la théorie de la catégorie dérivée D(OX − QCoh) des faisceaux quasi-
cohérents sur X (où X n’est pas nécessairement noethérien). En particulier, nous montrons les deux résultats suivants
sur la catégorie D(OX − QCoh): (1) La catégorie D(OX − QCoh) est munie d’un produit tensoriel dérivé et un hom
interne et (2) Soit ∆(X) la plus petite sous-catégorie triangulée contenant tous les objets j∗ M• , où j : U −→ X est
une immersion ouverte avec U affine et M• ∈ D(OU − QCoh). Alors, ∆(X) = D(OX − QCoh).
Abstract: Let X be a scheme over an abelian symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1) satisfying certain conditions.
In this article, we develop the theory of the derived category D(OX − QCoh) of quasi-coherent sheaves on X (where
X is not necessarily noetherian). In particular, we show the following two results: (1) The category D(OX − QCoh)
carries a derived tensor product and contains internal hom objects and (2) Let ∆(X) be the smallest triangulated
subcategory of D(OX − QCoh) containing all the objects j∗ M• , where j : U −→ X is an open immersion with U
affine and M• ∈ D(OU − QCoh). Then, ∆(X) = D(OX − QCoh).
[ AG 2.1.6 ] Les motifs de Tate et les opérateurs de périodicité de Connes: Ann. Math
Blaise Pascal, Vol. 21, No. 1, 1–23 (2014).

Résumé: Dans cet article, nous définissons une catégorie M g otC des motifs sur une catégorie monoı̈dale symmétrique
(C, ⊗, 1) vérifiant certaines hypothèses. Le rôle des espaces sur (C, ⊗, 1) est joué par les monoı̈des (pas necéssairement
commutatif) dans C. Pour définir les morphismes dans M g otC , nous utilisons les classes dans les groupes d’homologie
d’une théorie cyclique bivariante. Le but est de montrer que les opérateurs de périodicité de Connes induissent les
morphismes M ⊗ T⊗2 −→ M dans M g otC , où T est le motif de Tate dans M g otC .
Abstract: In this paper, we define a category M g otC of motives over a symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1) satis-
fying certain conditions. The role of spaces over (C, ⊗, 1) is played by monoid objects (not necessarily commutative)
in C. To define morphisms in the category M g otC , we use classes in bivariant cyclic homology groups. The purpose
is to show that the Connes periodicity operators induce morphisms M ⊗ T⊗2 −→ M in M g otC , where T is the Tate
motive in M otC .
g

[ AG 2.1.5 ] Localization of monoid objects and Hochschild homology: Communications in Algebra, Vol.
42, No. 10, 4548–4558 (2014).
Abstract: Let A be a (not necessarily commutative) monoid object in an abelian symmetric monoidal category
(C, ⊗, 1) satisfying certain conditions. In this paper, we continue our study of the localization MS of any A-module
M with respect to a subset S ⊆ HomA−Bimod (A, A) that is closed under composition. In particular, we prove the
following theorem: if P is an A-bimodule such that P is symmetric as a bimodule over the center Z(A) of A, we
have isomorphisms HH∗ (A, P )S ∼ = HH∗ (A, PS ) ∼ = HH∗ (AS , PS ) of Hochschild homology groups.
[ AG 2.1.4 ] Affine Group Schemes over Symmetric Monoidal Categories: Pacific Journal of Mathematics
Vol. 255 (2012), No. 1, 25–40 (2012).

Abstract: A well known result of Deligne shows that an affine commutative group scheme of rank r is annihilated
by its rank. The purpose of this paper is to extend this result to affine group schemes over symmetric monoidal
categories.
[ AG 2.1.3 ] Centre of monoids, centralisers and localisation: Communications in Algebra Vol 40, No.
11, 3975–3993 (2012).

5
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

Abstract: Given a monoid object A in a symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1), we associate a commutative monoid
z(A) := HomA−Bimod (A, A), which we refer to as the set of central elements of A. If A has a centre Z(A) in C,
we describe an isomorphism z(A) = HomA−Bimod (A, A) ∼ = HomZ(A)−M od (Z(A), Z(A)). When C is closed and
complete, we show that every subset S ⊆ HomA−M od (A, A) has a centraliser ZA (S) which is a Z(A)-algebra and
under certain conditions, we show that ZA (HomA−M od (A, A)) = Z(A). Further, for any multiplicatively closed set
S ⊆ z(A), we define the localisation MS of any right A-module M with respect to S and show that several properties
of classical localisation extend to this context.
[ AG 2.1.2 ] Derived Schemes and the Field with one element: Journal de Mathématiques Pures et Ap-
pliquées Vol 97, No. 3, 189–203 (2012).
Abstract: The purpose of this paper is to define derived schemes over F1 , the “field with one element”. More
generally, we define our derived algebraic geometry over a symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1) by adapting the
constructions of Lurie. In particular, the derived schemes over F1 are obtained by choosing C to be the category of
sets. For an arbitrary derived scheme X = (X , O) over C, we also construct a “Picard group” and show that the
Picard group is abelian. Further, when G is a (commutative and cocommutative) “Hopf object” that plays the role
of abelian groups in an arbitrary symmetric monoidal category C, we show that there exists an “equivariant version”
of the derived schemes over C. We also suggest a topological counterpart for the construction of F1 -derived schemes,
which we refer to as T1 (k)-derived schemes, k being an algebraically closed field. This is motivated by the fact that
the S-modules in the category of schemes over k are the topological counterpart for Z-modules.
[ AG 2.1.1 ] The relative Picard Functor on Schemes over a symmetric monoidal category: Bulletin des
Sciences Mathématiques. Vol. 135, 400–419 (2011).
Abstract: We consider schemes (X, OX ) over an abelian closed symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1). Our aim is
to extend a theorem of Kleiman on the relative Picard functor to schemes over (C, ⊗, 1). For this purpose, we also
develop some basic theory on quasi-coherent modules on schemes (X, OX ) over C. Another of the interesting aspects
is to find suitable substitutes for key notions in ordinary algebraic geometry (and commutative algebra) such as the
Noetherian condition, affine morphisms, quasi-compact morphisms, separated morphisms, morphisms of finite type
etc.

§ 2.2 Categorical algebra and Homological algebra


[ AG 2.2.10 ] Two criteria for locally noetherian Grothendieck categories: Journal of Pure and Ap-
plied Algebra (Accepted).
Abstract: We give two criteria for a Grothendieck category to be locally noetherian. The first of these is in terms
of direct sum decompositions into uniform components. The second is related to the existence of finitely injective
objects that cannot be expressed as a direct sum of injectives.
[ AG 2.2.9 ] (with S. Kour) On measurings of algebras over operads and homology theories: Algebraic &
Geometric Topology (Accepted).
Abstract: The notion of a measuring coalgebra, introduced by Sweedler, induces generalized maps between algebras.
We begin by studying maps on Hochschild homology induced by measuring coalgebras. We then develop a notion
of measuring coalgebra between Lie algebras and use it to obtain maps on Lie algebra homology. Further, these
measurings between Lie algebras satisfy nice adjoint like properties with respect to universal enveloping algebras.
More generally, we develop the notion of measuring coalgebras for algebras over any operad O. In case O is a binary
and quadratic operad, we show that a measuring of O-algebras leads to maps on operadic homology. In general, for
any operad O in vector spaces over a field K, we construct universal measuring coalgebras to show that the category
of O-algebras is enriched over K-coalgebras. We develop measuring comodules and universal measuring comodules

6
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

for this theory. We also relate these to measurings of the universal enveloping algebra UO (A) of an O-algebra A and
the modules over it. Finally, we describe the Sweedler product C B A of a coalgebra C and an O-algebra A. The
object C B A is universal among O-algebras that arise as targets of C-measurings starting from A.
[ AG 2.2.8 ] (with M. Balodi and S. Ray) Entwined modules over linear categories and Galois extensions:
Israel Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 241, 623–692 (2021).

Abstract: In this paper, we study modules over quotient spaces of certain categorified fiber bundles. These are
understood as modules over entwining structures involving a small K-linear category D and a K-coalgebra C. We
obtain Frobenius and separability conditions for functors on entwined modules. We also introduce the notion of a
C-Galois extension E ⊆ D of categories. Under suitable conditions, we show that entwined modules over a C-Galois
extension may be described as modules over the subcategory E of C-coinvariants of D.

[ AG 2.2.7 ] F I-modules over preadditive categories and torsion theories: Journal of Pure and Applied
Algebra, Vol. 225 (2021), 106595.
Abstract: We work with F I-modules over a small preadditive category R, viewed as a ring with several objects.
Our aim is to study torsion theories for F I-modules. We are especially interested in torsion theories on finitely
generated F I-modules and the category of what we call “shift finitely generated” F I-modules. We also apply these
methods to study inductive descriptions of F I-modules over R.
[ AG 2.2.6 ] (with M. Balodi and S. Ray) Cohomology of modules over H-categories and
co-H-categories: Canadian Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 72, No. 5, 1352–1385 (2020).
Abstract: Let H be a Hopf algebra. We consider H-equivariant modules over a Hopf module category C as modules
over the smash extension C#H. We construct Grothendieck spectral sequences for the cohomologies as well as
the H-locally finite cohomologies of these objects. We also introduce relative (D, H)-Hopf modules over a Hopf
comodule category D. These generalize relative (A, H)-Hopf modules over an H-comodule algebra A. We construct
Grothendieck spectral sequences for their cohomologies by using their rational Hom objects and higher derived
functors of coinvariants.

[ AG 2.2.5 ] On differential torsion theories and rings with several objects: Canadian Mathematical
Bulletin, Vol. 62, No. 4 (2019) 703–714.
Abstract: Let R be a small preadditive category, viewed as a ‘ring with several objects.’ A right R-module is an
additive functor from Rop to the category Ab of abelian groups. We show that every hereditary torsion theory on
the category (Rop , Ab) of right R-modules must be differential.

[ AG 2.2.4 ] On Auslander’s formula and cohereditary torsion pairs: Communications in Contemporary


Mathematics, Vol. 20, No. 6, Paper no. 1750071 (2018).
Abstract: For a small abelian category C, Auslander’s formula allows us to express C as a quotient of the category
mod − C of coherent functors on C. We consider an abelian category with the added structure of a cohereditary
torsion pair τ = (T , F). We prove versions of Auslander’s formula for the torsion free class F of C, for the derived
torsion free class Db (F) of the triangulated category Db (C) as well as the induced torsion free class in the ind-category
Ind − C of C. Further, for a given regular cardinal α, we also consider the category modα − C of α-presentable
objects in the functor category F un(Cop , Ab). Then, under certain conditions, we show that the torsion free class
F can be recovered as a subquotient of modα − C.
[ AG 2.2.3 ] Closure operators in abelian categories and spectral spaces: Theory and Applications of
categories, Vol. 32, No. 20, 719–735 (2017).

7
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

Abstract: We give several new ways of constructing spectral spaces starting with objects in abelian categories
satisfying certain conditions which apply, in particular, to Grothendieck categories. For this, we consider the spaces
of invariants of closure operators acting on subobjects of a given object. The key to our results is a newly discovered
criterion of Finocchiaro that uses ultrafilters to identify spectral spaces along with subbases of quasi-compact open
sets.
[ AG 2.2.2 ] Some remarks on a theorem of Bergman: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris, Vol. 354, No. 7, 665–670
(2016).
Abstract: We extend a result of Bergman to show that any object in an arbitrary Grothendieck category may be
expressed as an inverse limit of injectives. We also study inverse systems of κ-injective objects, where κ is an infinite
regular cardinal.
[ AG 2.2.1 ] Lifting of model structures to fibred categories: Homology, Homotopy and Applications,
Vol. 13. No. 2, 1–17 (2011).
Abstract: A fibred category consists of a functor p : N −→ M between categories N and M such that objects of
N may be “pulled back along any arrow of M”. Fibred categories, which first appeared in SGA-I, can be used to
describe a large class of objects, such as the category of presheaves over a given category or the category of vector
bundles over topological spaces. Given a fibred category p : N −→ M and a model structure on the “base category”
M, we show that there exists a lifting of the model structure on M to a model structure on N. We will refer to such
a system as a “fibred model category” and give several examples of such structures. We show that, under certain
conditions, right homotopies of maps in the base category M may be lifted to right homotopic maps in the fibred
category. We also show that these lifted model structures are well behaved with respect to Quillen adjunctions and
Quillen equivalences. Finally, we show that if N and M carry compatible closed monoidal structures and the functor
p commutes with colimits, then a Quillen bifunctor on M lifts to a Quillen bifunctor on N.

§ 2.3 Tensor triangular geometry


[ AG 2.3.3 ] A topological nullstellensatz for tensor triangulated categories: C. R. Math. Acad.
Sci. Paris. Vol. 356, No. 4, 365–375 (2018).
Abstract: Let Spec(T) be the spectrum of a tensor triangulated category (T, ⊗, 1). We show that there is a
homeomorphism between the spectral space of radical thick tensor ideals in (T, ⊗, 1) and the collection of open
subsets of Spec(T) in inverse topology. In fact, we prove a more general result in terms of supports on (T, ⊗, 1) and
work by combining methods from commutative algebra, topology and tensor triangular geometry.
Résumé: Soit Spec(T) le spectre d’une catégorie triangulée tensorielle (T, ⊗, 1) et notons par Spec(T)inv la topologie
inverse sur Spec(T). Nous montrons qu’on dispose d’un homeomorphisme entre l’espace spectral des idéaux radicaux
de (T, ⊗, 1) et l’espace des sous-ensembles ouverts de Spec(T)inv . En fait, nous obtenons un résulat plus général en
termes des données de support sur (T, ⊗, 1) en utilisant des idées provenant d’algèbre commutative, de topologie et
de géométrie triangulée tensorielle.
[ AG 2.3.2 ] On some spectral spaces associated to tensor triangulated categories: Arch. Math. (Basel),
Vol. 108, No. 6, 581–591 (2017).
Abstract: We consider a closure operator c of finite type on the space SM od(M) of thick K-submodules of a
triangulated category M that is a module over a tensor triangulated category (K, ⊗, 1). Our purpose is to show
that the space SM odc (M) of fixed points of the operator c is a spectral space that also carries the structure of a
topological monoid.
[ AG 2.3.1 ] Realizations of pairs and Oka families in tensor triangulated categories: European
Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 2, No. 3, 760–797 (2016).

8
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

Abstract: In this paper, we apply some methods from ring theory to the framework of prime ideals in tensor
triangulated categories developed by Balmer. Given a thick tensor ideal A and a multiplicatively closed family S
of objects in a tensor triangulated category (C, ⊗, 1), we say that a prime ideal P realizes (A, S) if P ⊇ A and
P ∩ S = φ. Analogous to the results of Bergman with ordinary rings, we show how to construct a realization of a
family {(Ai , Si )}i∈I of such pairs indexed by a finite chain I, i.e., a collection {Pi }i∈I of prime ideals such that each
Pi realizes (Ai , Si ) and Pi ⊆ Pj for each i ≤ j in I. Thereafter we obtain conditions on a family F of thick tensor
ideals of (C, ⊗, 1) so that any ideal that is maximal with respect to not being contained in F must be prime. This
extends the Prime Ideal Principle of Lam and Reyes from commutative algebra. We also combine these methods to
consider realizations of templates {(Ai , Fi )}i∈I where each Ai is a thick tensor ideal and each Fi is a family of thick
tensor ideals that is also a monoidal semifilter.

§ 2.4 Bivariant Chow groups and Saito’s filtration


[ AG 2.4.3 ] Extensions de la filtration de Saito: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci Paris, Vol. 352, No. 5, 377–382
(2014).
Résumé: Nous étendons la filtration de Saito aux groupes de Chow d’un morphisme représentable de préfaisceaux
sur SchC , la catégorie de schémas sur C. De plus, pour un préfaisceau sur la catégorie de schémas lisses et projectifs
sur C, nous définissons ses groupes de Chow supérieurs et leurs filtrations.
Abstract: We extend Saito’s filtration to the Chow groups of a representable morphism of presheaves on SchC , the
category of schemes over C. Moreover, for a presheaf on the category of smooth and projective schemes over C, we
define its higher Chow groups along with their filtrations.
[ AG 2.4.2 ] Bivariant Chow groups and the topology of envelopes: Topology and its applications, Vol.
160, No. 1, 230–240 (2013).
Abstract: Let K be an algebraically closed field and let SchK denote the category of schemes over K. Our objective
is to extend the operational Chow theory to presheaves (of sets) on SchK . More generally, we introduce bivariant
Chow groups CH p (f : F −→ G), p ∈ Z for a representable morphism of presheaves on SchK . These are then studied
with the help of the topology of envelopes on SchK .
[ AG 2.4.1 ] Higher Bivariant Chow Groups and Motivic Filtrations: Transactions of the American Math-
ematical Society Vol. 363, No. 11, 5943–5969. (2011).
Abstract: The purpose of this paper is twofold: first, we extend Saito’s filtration on Chow groups, which is a
candidate for the conjectural Bloch Beilinson filtration on the Chow groups of a smooth projective variety, from
Chow groups to the Bivariant Chow groups. In order to do this, we construct cycle class maps from the Bivariant
Chow groups to Bivariant Cohomology groups. Secondly, we use our methods to define a bivariant version of Bloch’s
higher Chow groups.

§3 Publications in Noncommutative Geometry

§ 3.1 Modular Hecke operators of Connes and Moscovici


[ NCG 3.1.5 ] Modular Hecke Algebras over Möbius Categories: Journal of Geometry and Physics (Special
Volume for Alain Connes’ 70th Birthday), Vol. 131, 23–40 (2018).
Abstract: We extend the modular Hecke operators of Connes and Moscovici by taking values in the modular
incidence algebra M[C] over a Möbius category C. Here M is the ‘modular tower’ consisting of all modular forms
of all weights across all levels. We construct multiple product structures on the collection A(Γ)[C] of modular Hecke

9
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

operators of level Γ over C, where Γ is a principal congruence subgroup. These product structures are then shown to
be well behaved with respect to Hopf actions on A(Γ)[C]. While A(Γ)[C] already carries an action of the Hopf algebra
H1 of codimension 1-foliations, the noncommutativity of the modular incidence algebra M[C] allows us to construct
additional operators on A(Γ)[C]. The use of Möbius categories provides a single framework for describing modular
Hecke operators taking values in various rings: from formal power series rings over M to arithmetic functions over M
and algebras of upper triangular matrices with entries in M. Moreover, we use functors between Möbius categories
to study relations between various modular Hecke algebras.
[ NCG 3.1.4 ] Quasimodular Hecke algebras and Hopf actions: Journal of Noncommutative Geometry, Vol.
12, No. 3, (2018), 1041–1080.
Abstract: Let Γ = Γ(N ) be a principal congruence subgroup of SL2 (Z). In this paper, we extend the theory of
modular Hecke algebras due to Connes and Moscovici to define the algebra Q(Γ) of quasimodular Hecke operators
of level Γ. Then, Q(Γ) carries an action of “the Hopf algebra H1 of codimension 1 foliations” that also acts on the
modular Hecke algebra A(Γ) of Connes and Moscovici. However, in the case of quasimodular forms, we have several
new operators acting on the quasimodular Hecke algebra Q(Γ). Further, for each σ ∈ SL2 (Z), we introduce the
collection Qσ (Γ) of quasimodular Hecke operators of level Γ twisted by σ. Then, Qσ (Γ) is a right Q(Γ)-module and
is endowed with a pairing ( , ) : Qσ (Γ) ⊗ Qσ (Γ) −→ Qσ (Γ). We show that there is a “Hopf action” of a certain
Hopf algebra h1 on the pairing on Qσ (Γ). Finally, for any σ ∈ SL 2 (Z), 
we consider operators acting between the
1 m
levels of the graded module Qσ (Γ) = ⊕ Qσ(m) (Γ), where σ(m) = · σ for any m ∈ Z. The pairing on Qσ (Γ)
m∈Z 0 1
can be extended to a graded pairing on Qσ (Γ) and we show that there is a Hopf action of a larger Hopf algebra
hZ ⊇ h1 on the pairing on Qσ (Γ).
[ NCG 3.1.3 ] Action de Hopf sur les opérateurs de Hecke modulaires tordus: Journal of Noncommuta-
tive Geometry, Vol. 9, No. 4 (2015), 1155–1173.
Résumé: Soit Γ ⊆ SL2 (Z) un sous-groupe principal de congruence. Pour chaque σ ∈ SL2 (Z), nous introduisons
l’ensemble Aσ (Γ) des opérateurs de Hecke modulaires tordus par σ. Alors, Aσ (Γ) est un A(Γ)-module à droite, où
A(Γ) est l’algèbre des opérateurs de Hecke modulaires introduite par Connes et Moscovici. En utilisant l’action d’une
algèbre de Hopf h0 sur Aσ (Γ), nous définissons les crochets de Rankin-Cohen réduits sur Aσ (Γ). De plus, Aσ (Γ) est
muni d’une action de H1 , où H1 est l’algèbre de Hopf des feuilletages de codimension 1. Enfin, nous considérons les
opérateurs entre les niveaux Aσ (Γ), σ ∈ SL2 (Z). Nous montrons que l’action de ces opérateurs peut être exprimée
en termes d’une algèbre de Hopf hZ .
Abstract: Let Γ ⊆ SL2 (Z) be a principal congruence subgroup. For each σ ∈ SL2 (Z), we introduce the collection
Aσ (Γ) of modular Hecke operators twisted by σ. Then, Aσ (Γ) is a right A(Γ)-module, where A(Γ) is the modular
Hecke algebra introduced by Connes and Moscovici. Using the action of a Hopf algebra h0 on Aσ (Γ), we define
reduced Rankin-Cohen brackets on Aσ (Γ). Moreover Aσ (Γ) carries an action of H1 , where H1 is the Hopf algebra
of foliations of codimension 1. Finally, we consider operators between the levels Aσ (Γ), σ ∈ SL2 (Z). We show that
the action of these operators can be expressed in terms of a Hopf algebra hZ .
[ NCG 3.1.2 ] Hecke operators on Line bundles over Modular Curves: Journal of Number Theory, Vol.
132, No. 4, 714–734. (2012)
Abstract: Given a congruence subgroup Γ = Γ(M ) ⊆ SL2 (Z), Connes and Moscovici have introduced a modular
Hecke algebra A(Γ) that incorporates both the pointwise multiplicative structure of modular forms and the action
of the classical Hecke operators. It is well known that a Γ-modular form g of weight k may be desrcibed as a global
section of the k-th tensor power of a certain line bundle p(Γ) : L(Γ) −→ Γ\H. The purpose of this paper is to develop
a theory of modular Hecke algebras for Hecke correspondences between the line bundles L(Γ) that lift the classical
Hecke correspondences between modular curves Γ\H.

10
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ NCG 3.1.1 ] Hopf Action and Rankin-Cohen Brackets on an Archimedean Complex: Journal of Noncom-
mutative Geometry Vol. 5, No. 3, 401–421. (2011).
Abstract: The Hopf algebra H1 of “codimension 1 foliations”, generated by operators X, Y and δn , n ≥ 1, satisfying
certain conditions, was introduced by Connes and Moscovici who showed that, for any congruence subgroup Γ of
SL2 (Z), the action of H1 on the “modular Hecke algebra” A(Γ) captures classical operators on modular forms. In
this paper, we show that the action of H1 captures the monodromy and Frobenius actions on a certain module B∗ (Γ)
that arises from the archimedean complex of Consani. The object B∗ (Γ) replaces the modular Hecke algebra A(Γ)
in our theory. We also introduce a “restricted” version B∗r (Γ) of the module B∗ (Γ) on which the operators δn , n ≥ 1
of the Hopf algebra H1 act as zero. Thereafter, we construct Rankin-Cohen brackets of all orders on B∗r (Γ).

§ 3.2 Hochschild and Cyclic homology


[ NCG 3.2.8 ] (with M. Balodi and A. Naolekar) BV-operators and the secondary Hochschild complex: C.
R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris, Vol. 358 (2020) no. 11-12, pp. 1239-1258.
Abstract: We introduce the notion of a BV-operator ∆ = {∆n : V n −→ V n−1 }n≥0 on a homotopy G-algebra V •
such that the Gerstenhaber bracket on H(V • ) is determined by ∆ in a manner similar to the BV-formalism. As an
application, we produce a BV-operator on the cochain complex defining the secondary Hochschild cohomology of a
symmetric algebra A over a commutative algebra B. In this case, we also show that the operator ƥ corresponds to
Connes’ operator.

[ NCG 3.2.7 ] (with S. Kour) (A, δ)-modules, Hochschild homology and higher derivations: Annali di
Matematica Pura ed Applicata, Vol. 198, No. 5 (2019) 1781–1802.
Abstract: In this paper, we develop the theory of modules over (A, δ), where A is an algebra and δ : A −→ A is a
derivation. Our approach is heavily influenced by Lie derivative operators in noncommutative geometry, which make
the Hochschild homologies HH• (A) of A into a module over (A, δ). We also consider modules over (A, ∆), where
∆ = {∆n }n≥0 is a higher derivation on A. Further, we obtain a Cartan homotopy formula for an arbitrary higher
derivation on A.

[ NCG 3.2.6 ] Homologie de Hochschild et espaces algébriques: Math. Scand., Vol. 118, No. 1, 33–42
(2016).
Résumé: Le but de cet article est de définir les homologies de Hochschild et les homologies cycliques d’un espace
algébrique X. Nous considérons deux définitions de l’homologie de Hochschild et nous montrons que ces définitions
sont les mêmes en cas d’un espace algébrique séparé. De plus, nous construisons un produit shuffle sur les homologies
de Hochschild de X. Enfin, nous montrons qu’on a un appariement entre les homologies et les cohomologies de
Hochschild de X.
Abstract: The purpose of this article is to define the Hochschild and cyclic homologies of an algebraic space X.
We consider two definitions of Hochschild homology of X and show that these definitions coincide in the case of a
separated algebraic space. Moreover, we construct a shuffle product on the Hochschild homologies of X. Finally, we
show that one has a pairing between the Hochschild homologies and cohomologies of X.
[ NCG 3.2.5 ] A note on product structures on Hochschild homology of schemes: Colloquium Mathe-
maticum. Vol. 123. No. 2, 233–238. (2011).
Abstract: We extend the definition of Hochschild and cyclic homologies of a scheme over a commutative ring k
to define the Hochschild homologies HH∗ (X/S) and cyclic homologies HC∗ (X/S) of a scheme X with respect to
an arbitrary base scheme S. Our main purpose is to study product structures on the Hochschild homology groups
HH∗ (X/S). In particular, we show that HH∗ (X/S) = ⊕n∈Z HHn (X/S) carries the structure of a graded algebra.

11
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ NCG 3.2.4 ] Higher Derivations and Hochschild Homology: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Soc. R. Can. Vol. 33,
No. 2, 33–43. (2011).
Abstract: Let K be a commutative ring and let A be a K-algebra. A K-linear derivation D on A induces a morphism
LD on the Hochschild and cyclic homologies of A, which is the analogue of the Lie derivative in noncommutative
geometry. In this paper, we extend this to higher (or Hasse-Schmidt) derivations on A.

[ NCG 3.2.3 ] Nearby Cycles and Periodicity in Cylic Homology: In: Noncommutative Geometry, Arith-
metic and Related Topics: Proceedings of the 21st JAMI Conference, pp. 1–30, Johns Hopkins University Press
(2011).
Abstract: In this paper, we consider an algebraic degeneration of a variety over a disc and its archimedean coun-
terpart, which involves the fibre at infinity of an arithmetic variety. Furthermore, the monodromy operator in the
case of the disc has an archimedean counterpart and we show that, the monodromy operator (resp. its archimedean
counterpart) may be seen as corresponding to the periodicity operator in cyclic homology (resp. cyclic cohomology).
In the former case, we work with the periodicity on the cyclic (hyper)homology of a sheaf of differential operators.
In the latter case, we work with the periodicity in the cyclic cohomology of the ring of differential operators. Finally,
we use our understanding to construct an archimedean counterpart of the complex of nearby cycles.

[ NCG 3.2.2 ] Hopf Cyclic Cohomology and Biderivations: Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., Vol. 138, No. 6,
1929–1939, (2010).

Abstract: Hopf cyclic cohomology HC(δ,σ) (H) for a Hopf algebra H with respect to a modular pair in involution
(δ, σ) was introduced by Connes and Moscovici. By a biderivation D on a Hopf algebra H, we shall mean a
linear map that satisfies the axioms for both a derivation and a coderivation on H. Given a biderivation D on a
∗ ∗
Hopf algebra, we define, under certain conditions, a map LD : HC(δ,σ) (H) −→ HC(δ,σ) (H). We give examples of
such maps for the quantized universal enveloping algebra Uh (g) of a simple Lie algebra g. When H is irreducible,
cocommutative and equipped with a character δ such that (δ, 1) is a modular pair in involution, we define “inner

biderivations” and use these to produce a left H-module structure on HC(δ,1) (H). Finally, we show that every
∗ ∗
morphism LD : HC(δ,1) (H) −→ HC(δ,1) (H) induced by a biderivation D on such a Hopf algebra H can be realized
as a morphism induced by an inner biderivation by embedding H into a larger Hopf algebra H[D].

[ NCG 3.2.1 ] Cartan Homotopy Formulae and the Bivariant Hochschild Complex: C. R. Math. Acad. Sci.
Paris, Vol. 347, No. 17-18, pp 997-1000, (2009).
Abstract: The formula LD = [eD + ED , b + B] on the normalized Hochschild complex is the standard replacement
in noncommutative geometry for the classical Cartan homotopy formula. In this paper, we extend this formula to
the normalized bivariant Hochschild complex.

§4 Publications on other topics


[ MISC 4.9 ] Spectra as universal objects in categories of supports: Banach Center Publications, Vol.
120, 53–69 (2020).
Abstract: Many years ago, André Joyal outlined a method of describing the Zariski spectrum Spec(R) of a com-
mutative ring R in a manner that makes no reference to prime ideals of R. In Joyal’s approach, the spectrum is
not a topological space, but a distributive lattice that satisfies a certain universal property. Recently, this approach
has been shown to be very fruitful in understanding other spectra, such as the spectrum of a tensor triangulated
category. In this paper, we take a similar method to describe as universal objects several other ‘spectrum like spaces’
that arise in commutative algebra and noncommutative algebraic geometry.

12
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ MISC 4.8 ] Monoidal semifilters and arrays of prime ideals: Fund. Math. Vol. 237, No. 3, 281–296
(2017).
Abstract: Let R be a commutative ring. If A ⊆ R is an ideal and F is a monoidal semifilter of ideals in R, we say
that a prime ideal P is a realization of (A, F) if P ⊇ A and P ∈ / F. We give if and only if conditions for the existence
of a realization of a family {(At , Ft )}t∈T of such pairs indexed by a finite rooted tree T . We also apply our results
to trees of prime ideals outside a given monoidal semifilter in a tensor product of algebras.
[ MISC 4.7 ] Une note sur les dérivations localement nilpotentes dans les catégories
monoı̈dales symétriques: Bulletin of the Belgian Mathematical Society, Vol. 23, No. 1, 151–160 (2016).
Résumé: Dans cet article, nous construisons le morphisme exponentiel eD : A −→ A associé à une dérivation
localement nilpotente D sur un monoı̈de A dans une catégorie monoı̈dale symétrique. De plus, nous montrons que
le noyau de D coı̈ncide avec le sous-objet de A fixé par eD . Enfin, nous étudions comme on peut prolonger une
dérivation localement nilpotente sur A à sa localisation AS , où S ⊆ HomA−M od (A, A) est un sous-ensemble stable
par multiplication.
Abstract: In this paper, we construct the exponential morphism eD : A −→ A associated to a locally nilpotent
derivation D on a monoid A in a symmetric monoidal category. Further, we show that the kernel of D is identical
to the subobject of A invariant under eD . Finally, we study how to extend a locally nilpotent derivation on A to its
localization AS , where S ⊆ HomA−M od (A, A) is a multiplicatively closed subset.

[ MISC 4.6 ] Nearby cycles and the Dold-Kan correspondence : Communications in Algebra, Vol. 43, No.
12, 5362–5371 (2015).
Abstract: The purpose of this paper is to develop the formalism of nearby cycles for simplicial sheaves of abelian
groups. In doing so, we utilize the cohomology groups of simplicial sheaves introduced by Brown and Gersten. A
key role in our constructions is played by the Dold-Kan correspondence.

[ MISC 4.5 ] On the Lie transformation algebra of monoids in symmetric monoidal categories: Rend.
Sem. Mat. Univ. Padova, Vol. 131, 151–157 (2014).
Abstract: We define the Lie transformation algebra of a (not necessarily associative) monoid object A in a C-linear
symmetric monoidal category (C, ⊗, 1). When A is associative and satisfies certain conditions, we describe explicity
the Lie transformation algebra and inner derivations of A. Additionally, we also show that derivations preserve the
nucleus of the monoid A.
[ MISC 4.4 ] Connes-Karoubi long exact sequence for Fréchet sheaves: Münster Journal of Mathematics,
Vol. 6, 167–179 (2013).
Abstract: In this paper, we prove a long exact sequence involving the algebraic, topological and relative K-theory
groups for a sheaf of Fréchet algebras or ultrametric Banach algebras on a scheme X under certain conditions. This
extends to sheaves the construction due to A. Connes and M. Karoubi of the relative K-theory group K∗rel (A) and
the associated K-theory long exact sequence for a Fréchet algebra A. In doing so, we make use of the generalized
sheaf cohomology for simplicial sheaves developed by Brown and Gersten.
[ MISC 4.3 ] Zeta Functions of certain noncommutative algebras: Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci.
Vol. 87. No. 4, 51–55. (2011).
Abstract: For a fixed prime l ∈ Z, we consider zeta functions for certain types of (not necessarily commutative)
algebras over the completion Ql of Q and show that they satisfy several properties analogous to those of the usual
Hasse-Weil zeta function of an algebraic variety over a finite field.

13
Publications : Abhishek Banerjee (contd.)

[ MISC 4.2 ] A Note on Regularity Properties with respect to Ideals: Communications in Algebra, Vol.
36, No. 3, pp 1067–1077, (2008).
Abstract: In this paper, we study the regularity properties of elements of a ring with respect to a given ideal I.
As expected, several concepts that are equivalent in the case of I = R turn out to be distinct for a general ideal I
and we consider the relations between these properties. In particular, we replace the set of units U (R) of the ring R
by the set UI (R) = {u|uI = Iu = I} and use these relative units to obtain generalizations of notions such as stable
range and unit-regularity. We also see that on assuming the set of relative units to have no zero divisors, we can
obtain several new results.
[ MISC 4.1 ] Unique Factorization and Ring Extensions: International Journal of Pure and Applied Math-
ematics, Vol. 26, No.4, pp 457–464, (2006).

Abstract: Let R denote a Noetherian integral domain and let K(R) be the field of fractions of R. We refer to a
Noetherian overring S of R, R ⊆ S ⊆ K(R) as an essential factor extension of R if (1) every prime element of R
remains prime in S; (2) for every prime element q of S there exist a prime element p of R and a unit u of S such that
q = up; and (3) if R 6= S, some non-unit of R becomes a unit in S. Then, we show that R is a unique factorization
domain if and only if R has no proper essential factor extensions.

14

You might also like