Professional Documents
Culture Documents
University Carbon Footprint
University Carbon Footprint
net/publication/324625701
CITATIONS READS
31 2,359
4 authors, including:
Prem Solanki
Carnegie Mellon University
15 PUBLICATIONS 108 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Vikrant Bhakar on 23 April 2018.
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 69 (2018) 475 – 480
25th CIRP Life Cycle Engineering (LCE) Conference, 30 April ± 2 May 2018, Copenhagen, Denmark
Abstract
This paper presents carbon footprint of Birla Institute of Technology and Science Pilani (BITS Pilani), Pilani campus, India using
the life cycle analysis (LCA). The direct emissions of university owned facilities, indirect energy emissions of purchased electricity,
heat or steam, and other indirect emissions, which are the outcomes of university activities but controlled by other organizations
have been considered for the greenhouse gas emissions. Various emissions are modelled in Umberto NXT Universal software
using ISO 14064 standards. It has been found that the contribution of indirect emissions is 99%. This study highlights the need of
formulating policies to reduce such emissions. The results have been compared with the other university results available in the
literature.
© 201
© 2017The The Authors.
Authors. Published
Published by Elsevier
by Elsevier B.V.
B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 25th CIRP Life Cycle Engineering (LCE) Conference.
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 25th CIRP Life Cycle Engineering (LCE) Conference
Keywords: Carbon Footprint, Direct and indirect emissions, BITS Pilani university campus, Life cycle analysis
2212-8271 © 201 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 25th CIRP Life Cycle Engineering (LCE) Conference
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2017.11.111
476 Kuldip Singh Sangwan et al. / Procedia CIRP 69 (2018) 475 – 480
Montfort University, UK [15]; Yale University (Yale Uni.), 2.4. Norwegian University of Technology and Science
USA [16]; etc. But in case of Indian institutes of higher (NTNU)
education, this kind of initiative is yet to be undertaken. The
present study is conducted to measure carbon footprint of an This study analyzes the carbon footprint of NTNU using
Indian university campus, which can be a base model for other EEIO methodology. Data for EEIO modeling is taken from the
institutes of higher education to follow. Jabbour [17] also institute records and it is divided into 120 EEIO sectors.
opines that universities have considerable impact on the Equipment and services are contributing 19% each in the total
environment in terms of GHG emissions. Thus, it is important CF. Consumables and services are contributing 11% and 5%
to monitor and evaluate the GHG emissions of the higher respectively followed by travel which is 16%, and other
educational institutes to achieve the goal towards sustainable emissions are approximately 10%. Further, the department
development. If you do not assess, you will not know. If you do wise comparison was made and it was found that the faculty of
not know, you cannot control. If you cannot control, you cannot humanities and social sciences generates less CF than the
improve. The objective of this study is to improve (reduce) the faculty of engineering [14].
carbon footprint of Indian universities.
2.5. De Montfort University, UK
2. Existing studies on GHG quantification and monitoring
This study is based on GHG protocol of World Resource
Several universities across the world have assessed their Institute (WRI)/World Business Council for Sustainable
GHG emissions. However, only few of them have provided Development (WBCSD). Direct and indirect emissions from
quantitative data which can be easily compared. Six such fossil fuel are considered in scope 1 and 2, indirect emissions
university studies are reviewed here. Most of these studies use from procurement, travelling, commuting and other sources are
ISO 14064 standard for assessment. The meaning and scope considered in scope 3 of the protocol. Scope 3 contributes 79%
classification under ISO 14064 are given in Fig. 1. in the total CF, where the major contributor was procurement
(48%), which contributes 38% of the total emissions. The scope
2.1. Universities of Leeds, UK definition used in this study is similar to ISO 14064-I (ISO,
2006), for GHG emissions quantification, reporting and
An environmentally extended input output (EEIO) analysis removal at organizational level [15].
has been used to estimate the carbon footprint (CF) of
procurements, capital goods, waste, energy, leased assets, 2.6. Yale University (Yale Uni.), USA
transport, purchased goods and services. Repeated semi
structured interviews were conducted with the procurement The study of Yale University incorporates the economic
staff of university to get the required data. Scope 3 emissions input - output- LCA (EIO-LCA) for quantifying the GHG
are around 51% of the total emissions, whereas Scope 1 and emissions in three scopes. Direct emissions were considered in
scope 2 are 18% and 31% respectively [11]. scope 1, university fleet and electricity were considered in
scope 2, and other indirect emissions (i.e. air travel,
2.2. University of Illinois, Chicago (UIC) commuting, etc.) were accounted in scope 3 of the study. The
energy purchase (36%), construction (27%), air travel (2.4%),
In the estimation of GHG emissions from 2004 to 2008, it food and beverages (1.5%), engineering services (1.4%),
was found that in 2008 the most impacting emissions were due laboratory supplies (1.1%) and software (1%) were found to
to building (83%) followed by commuting (16%), and waste generate 70% of the total CF [16].
(1%). The power plant, with cogeneration facility, generated
63% of the total GHG emissions followed by purchased 3. Materials and methods
electricity (17%). UIC also utilized the GHG protocol defined
by World Resource Institute (WRI)/ World Business Council In this study, GHG protocol of ISO 14064 [18] is utilized
for Sustainable Development (WBCSD)(WRI), 2004) [12]. for estimation of the total CO2 emissions with three scope
definitions. Each scope is further subdivided into different
2.3. University of Cape Town (UCT) South Africa categories as shown in Fig. 1. An LCA approach is used to
quantify the emissions using Umberto NXT universal software
This assessment is divided in three parts, campus energy [19] and Ecoinvent v3.0 database [20]. The study collected data
emissions, transport emissions, and goods & services from various sources within the university campus for the
emissions. In this study, if the data specific to South Africa was academic year 2014-2015 (August 2014 to July 2015). Offline
unavailable then Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change survey among the students, non-teaching staff, and faculty
(IPCC) emissions factors and relevant literature were used to members was conducted to collect data for travel, commuting,
estimate the CF. Electricity used in whole university accounts and food habits. 187 students, 47 faculty members, and 60 non-
for 81% of the total CF emissions. The carbon footprint per teaching staff responded to these surveys. Other consumption
student is 3.2 tons CO2-eq for the defined scope [13]. and procurement data was collected from various
organizational authorities within the institute. The data for food
emissions has been taken from a published article on carbon
emissions of Indian food items by Pathak et al. [5]. The detailed
Kuldip Singh Sangwan et al. / Procedia CIRP 69 (2018) 475 – 480 477
explanation of data collection is provided in Table 1 and section the basis of ISO 14064 standard. Data for inventory analysis
3.4. The ISO 14064 & LCA methodology used for the study is were collected in different phases.
given next. In first phase an offline survey was conducted across the
campus to collect the commuting and business travel data. In
3.1. BITS Pilani, Pilani campus this survey, data were collect from students, teaching staff, and
non-teaching by conducting semi-structured interviews.
BITS Pilani, Pilani campus is situated in the semi-arid Procurement data of the campus were collected using the
region of north-west India. The summer temperatures reach up records of central purchasing unit (CPU). In the record sheets
to 50°C between May and July, while winter temperatures of CPU, data were segregated in chemicals, electric and
reach sub-zero levels. The nearest airport is 200 km in New electronic components, reprography (printing and media unit of
Delhi and the nearest railway station is 23 km. University the campus), glassware, electrical components, and capital
inhabitants often have to make road journeys for personal and goods categories. In the record sheets of chemicals 1894 entries
business travels. The average population of the campus for the were found but after careful examination of the data it was
study time was 5699 consisting 3,452 students, 316 teaching found that similar chemicals purchased from different vendors
staff and 588 non-teaching staff, and rest are PhD students, are recorded as different chemicals. This duplicity was
family members, and guests. The total campus area is 328 acres removed and finally 129 separate chemicals were used for the
(400 ha); its developed area is 49 acres (20 ha), of which inventory. Similarly, duplicity was removed in other categories
60,769 square meters (15.016 acres) is used for the academic also. The total items modeled in LCA are: 24 electronics
buildings. The campus has 11,245 square meters components, 15 computers and peripheral, 31 capitals goods
(121,040 sq. ft.) of classrooms and 7,069 square meters items, 55 items from maintenance store, and 83 items from
(76,090 sq. ft.) of laboratories. The institute has fourteen central workshop. Inventory analyses data of refrigerant
hostels for male students and one large hostel for female consumption (used in air-conditioner, water cooler and
students. refrigerators) were taken from purchase records of the estate
maintenance unit of the campus. The above explained
3.2. Goal and scope definition inventory analysis covers most of the scope 3 model. For the
inventory analysis of water use and its treatment under scope
The present study aims to estimate the GHG emissions of 3, data were taken from an existing study carried out in the
the BITS Pilani university campus for the academic year 2014- campus [21]. A study for estimation of waste generated in
2015 (August 2014 to July 2015). various departments and buildings is carried out. Various
wastes generated within the campus including organic, metal,
Direct emissions ± Emissions from facilities glass, paper, and plastics were segregated from the collection
Scope 1 within its organizational boundaries
trucks to measure the quantity of each type, and this process is
repeated for 5 to 6 times in summer as well as in winter for
Energy indirect emissions ± Emissions from the
Scope 2 imported electricity, heat or steam consumed by
more accuracy in estimation. The data collection sources are
the organization provided in Table 1 of the study.
Annual glassware purchased Flask, beaker etc. CPU specific information. Primary and secondary data sources are
Annual upstream transport Material and equipment Offline survey compiled together for the material flow modelling and LCA.
transportation to campus
Annual food emissions Vegetarian and non-vegetarian Offline survey 3.4. Emissions factors
food (existing study emission)
*Estate management unit (EMU), #Centralized purchasing unit (CPU) The use of various Ecoinvent datasets to account the
The inventory analysis of the activities under scope 1 was emissions from three different scopes are discussed in Table 2.
done through record sheets of the transport services division Since the availability of data for Indian conditions is low,
[22] and estate management unit [23]. Inventory analysis of globally valid data is preferred throughout. If such data is not
scope 2 was performed for purchased electricity using the available, European data is considered.
service provider purchase bills.
Table 2. Use of Ecoinvent dataset & end-of-life options for three scopes
The organizational boundaries considered for the study
Category Use of dataset
covers: institute academic buildings (consists of 3 faculty
Scope 1
divisions and a new lecture theatre complex used for lectures Fuel used in Campus Ecoinvent dataset for burning of diesel and petrol in
and practical laboratories including office space for faculty and Fleet, and other internal combustion engines
departmental activities), central engineering workshop, library, services
Scope 2
institute facilities centers (i.e. student activity center, health Imported electricity Ecoinvent dataset for Indian electricity mix
club, sports complex, swimming pool, medical center, Scope 3
supermarket, faculty and staff housing, street lights, water Waste Ecoinvent dataset for incinerations of dry waste like
paper, tree leaves, reuse of organic waste for feeding
supply network, student hostels (14 hostels for male students
animal (like pig), landfill dataset from Ecoinvent for rest
and a bigger hostel for female students), seven student messes, of the waste
maintenance department, special kitchen and bakery, and a Computer accessories Ecoinvent dataset for production of computer
guest house. accessories and treatment transitions according to WEEE
Capital goods Ecoinvent dataset for capital goods by dividing them in
Whereas the operational boundaries of the presents study their main components and modelling togethers in form
includes: scope 1 ± direct emissions from burning of fossil fuel of sub-components and materials
in electric generator sets and campus fleet (cars, tractors, Chemicals Chemical data from Ecoinvent
Electronics and Modelling electronic components, few of electronic
ambulance, etc.); scope 2 ± indirect energy emissions of electrical products components which are not available in dataset, they are
imported electricity from state electricity board; scope 3 ± other assumed to be electronic components unspecified
indirect emissions consists of: commuting and business travel Commuting and Modelling of transportation in passenger kilometre in all
business travel modes: car (petrol and diesel both; shared and single
by faculty, staff, and students of the BITS Pilani, Pilani campus occupancy both), bus, train, two wheelers, aircraft
(i.e. commuting of students between home and university domestic, and aircraft intercontinental
FDPSXVIDFXOW\DQGVWDII¶VFRPPXWLQJIURPKRPHWRRIILFHDQG Refrigerants Amount of refrigerants consumed using Ecoinvent
vice versa, visit to attend scientific conferences, seminars, and dataset
Workshop Modelled through Ecoinvent separately in weight or
workshops within India and abroad), transportation of procurements volume: Metal products (tools, metal rods, pipes, wires,
products, materials, and capital goods; papers used within etc.), wood (including saw wood, plyboard, etc.),
institute for answers sheets, questions papers, notices, circulars, polishing material (paint, sand, varnish, etc.); also
treatment transitions for waste metals chips and scraps.
teaching notes, lab manuals, curriculum booklets, and many Water consumption Ecoinvent activities for Water withdrawal and storage,
more material used in both printed and unprinted form; various distribution, and treatment
wastes generated within the campus including organic, metal, Glassware Ecoinvent dataset activities by accounting weight and
types of different glassware
glass, paper, and plastics; food emissions are estimated using a Upstream transport Ecoinvent dataset in metric ton Km of lorry and train
published study and survey data of food habits; refrigerants Food emissions Data of Kg CO2 Eq. for different food items from
used for air conditioners and refrigerators within the campus published literature [5]
(excluding individual owned); institute procurements: consists
of chemicals, electrical and electronics components, glassware 3.5. Impact Assessment
DQG SODVWLFZDUH FDSLWDO JRRGV LH HTXLSPHQW¶V DQG VHWXSV
purchased for scientific laboratories and other usages in the For the carbon footprint assessment of BITS Pilani
institute); workshop procurements to meet the engineering University campus, the well-known Intergovernmental Panel
services need of the campus and for project and training works on Climate Change (IPCC) [24] is used. The global warming
of the students, also fabrication of metals and wooden products potential (GWP) with a time horizon of one hundred years is
used within the institute facilities; products and materials evaluated.
required by maintenance department of the institute for
repairing, refurbishments, and other installations comes mainly 4. Results and Discussion
under construction and maintenance.
Inventory analysis of the rest of activities was carried out The subsection 4.1 illustrates the carbon footprint results of
using estimations of the amount/quantity of material used or the BITS Pilani, university campus and subsection 4.2 provides
either by actual dimensions or weight measurement wherever a comparative analysis of the present study results with results
possible. Secondary data sources i.e. (web, manuals, brochures of carbon footprint assessment from other universities.
etc.) were also considered for more material and product
Kuldip Singh Sangwan et al. / Procedia CIRP 69 (2018) 475 – 480 479
4.1. Carbon footprint results of BITS Pilani, university time than the normal working hours. Secondly, the CO 2
campus emissions from the Indian electricity mix is high because coal
based electricity has large share (around 60%) in total
A detailed and extensive consumption based carbon electricity production of India [25].
footprint of BITS Pilani campus was evaluated. Fig. 2 shows a
Health club Academic building
breakdown of the different sources of GHG emissions Services Maintenance
classified as Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3 emissions. Results Student hostel & mess Faculty Housing
show a total of 16500 t CO2 eq. (metric tons of CO2 equivalent) Carbon emissions
of GHG emissions. 50% of GHG emissions are from scope 2 2000 8.0
electricity generation and 48.9 % GHG emissions are from 7.0
scope 3 sources. The rest 1.1 % emissions are the scope 1 GHG
Electricity in MWh
owned facilities like diesel-electric generator sets and vehicles.
5.0
68% of scope 3 emissions are travel related emissions, 12 %
emissions are from the food consumption by the inhabitants of 1000 4.0
the campus and 10% emissions are from the annual
3.0
procurements in the workshop. The detailed distribution of
scope 3 emissions are shown in Fig. 3. 500 2.0
1.0
16000
0 0.0
14000
2013 2014 2015
12000
CO2 Eq (in tons)
8000
Fig. 4 illustrates the electricity consumption by the different
6000 units. Whereas the energy consumption per student is approx.
4000 1574 Kwh and CO2 footprint per student due to electricity
consumption is 2219 Kg CO2 eq. the analysis of the energy
2000
consumption over past years shows that the energy requirement
0 is growing steadily over years (as shown in Fig. 4). This
Scope 1 Scope 2 Scope 3 Total
increase in electricity consumption over the years due to the
expansion of the campus has increased the GHG emissions
Fig. 2. Carbon emissions for all three scopes for the BITS Pilani from the Scope 2 electricity generation. Therefore, preventive
measures are required at university level to optimize the energy
usage of various consumers within the university campus to
Glasswares lessen the environmental burden.
Upstream Transport
Computer access.
Chemicals 4.2. Comparison of carbon footprint among other universities
Water used
Electronics and electrical Next a comparative analysis of studies from other
Food - Teachers
Capital goods universities across the globe is performed. The studies
Commuting others addressing full consumption based footprints are compared
Food - others with the current study. De Montfort University (DeMU),
Refrigerants
Waste University of Cape town (UCT) and Norwegian University of
Commuting Faculty Science and Technology (NTNU) results provide full
Food - Students consumption data. Table 3 shows a comparative study of some
Enrgineering workshop
Commuting students of the parameters important for evaluating the greenhouse gas
1 10 100 1000 10000
emissions of the universities. It is interesting to know that the
Tons of CO2 eq.
carbon footprint (CF) (in Kg CO2 Eq.) per student for Indian
university campus and NTNU are comparable, which is around
Fig. 3. Greenhouse gas emissions details for scope 3 4.6 tons of CO2 equivalent per year per student.
Whereas that of De Montfort University and university of
The electricity consumption is divided by the different Cape town is 1.13 and 3.6 tons of CO2 equivalent per year per
buildings in the campus ± Institute buildings, staff quarters, student respectively. The total carbon footprint of the Indian
student hostels and messes. university campus is less due to less number of the students and
It is observed that university campus buildings have high staff. The carbon footprint per square meter of the developed
energy consumption mainly because it is a residential campus, area for BITS Pilani university is 12.01 tons of CO2 eq.
and faculty members and students use the facilities for longer
480 Kuldip Singh Sangwan et al. / Procedia CIRP 69 (2018) 475 – 480