Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Paper 2do Corte Ingles
Paper 2do Corte Ingles
Abstract: A field site was established in 1993 near Newcasile, Australia, as part of a long-terrn study into expansive soil bchavior. The
primary objectives in establishiog the site were to collect high quality data with which to check curren! design methods for lightly loaded
building foundations and to develop improved understandiog of the physical processes that drive unsaturatcd expansive soil bchavior. The
site was instrumeoted to allow measurcment of soil water content, soil moisture suction, and ground movement to depths of 3 m. The sito
was provided with two ground covers to simulate moisture boundary conditions due to the presence of typical structures. This papcr
presents sorne of the more importan! findings from the 7 years of data acquired so far. These ioclude a qualitative assessment of the overall
site behavior, and quantitative ob crvations of the range of total suction and water contcnt changes with deplh, the depth to which moisturc
cbanges occur, and the cootributions lo surface movement from ground movemenl al various depths. The shapc of a mound developcd
beneath a flexible cover oo an initially dry site is examined, and the effects of a large tree on moisturc changes are reponed.
lntroduction elson and Miller (1992), and Fredlund and Rahardjo (1993).
The outcorne of much of the Australian rcsearch was an Aus-
Shrinking and swelliog of unsaturated expansivo clays in re- tralian standard for the design of rcsidential slabs and footings
sponse lo water content change is a worldwide phenomenon. 11 is (A 2870 1996). The standard was first publishcd in 1986 and has
one of the most commoo geotechnical causes of damage to resi- fouod wide use in ali states for routine foundation design. Al-
dential buildings (Jones and Holtz 1973; Krohn and Slossen 1980; though it covers foundation design for any geotcchnical condi-
Freernan et al. 1991). In Australia, expansive soils are widely tions, it places particular emphasis on design for expansivo soil
distributed. Richards et al. (1983) estimated that 20% of the sur- si tes.
facc soils of Australia can be classified as expansivo. In Iact, six The rigorous engineering design of foundations on cxpansive
out of eight of Australia's largest cities are significanlly affected soil sites is a complex problem that requires a good understanding
by clay foundatioo soils, which realize a significan! proportioo of of expansive unsaturated soil bchavior, structural response, soil
their expansivo potential. structure interaction, and a largc quantity of site-spccific data.
Research into expansive soil behavior has been carried out in Many aspects of the above are poorly handled in currcnt practico,
Australia sincc the late 1950s, most ootably by the Common- and a general design approach that involves fully coupled unsat-
wcalth cientific and Industrial Research Organization (C !RO) urated moisture Ilow, soil volume changc, and soil-structurc in-
Division of Soils (see, e.g., Aitchison 1965; Walsh 1978; Holland teraction has proved difficult to achievc. The primary objectivc of
and Richards 1982) and the Universities of Adelaide and outh the Maryland field study is to collect high qualiry field data that
Australia (Mitchell 1984; Cameroo 1989). Similar rescarch initia- can be used to check currcnt design methods for building foun-
tives have also been undertaken around the world, with many of dations. A secondary aim is to develop improvcd undcrstanding of
the outcomes of these studies contained in a series of expansive Lhe physical processes that drivc reactive soil behavior. With this
and unsaturated soils conference proceediogs since 1965. lnterest- information it is hopcd that more rcliable, sophisticatcd models of
iogly, there is a scarcity of research findiogs on expan ive clay expansivo soil behavior can be developcd.
soils in the international jouroal literature. The most accessible A complete prcsentation of the outcomes of thc Maryland ex-
data oo expansive soils continuo to be lirnited lo national founda- pansive soils project is beyond thc scope of this papcr. Cense-
tion practice standards and landmark texts such as Chen (1988), quenlly, thc aims of this papcr are limited to the following: a brief
description the Maryland expansive soils field site, and rcsults
1Senior Lecturer, Dcpt. of Civil, Surveying and Environrnental and discussion for sorne of aspccts of expansivo foundation be-
Engineering, The Univ. of Newcastle, Callagban, NSW 2308. Australia. havior that are important in expansivo soil foundation practico.
2Assoeiate Professor, Dept. of Civil, Surveying and Environmental
�
·�
500mm
¿2SMPa concrete
0.2mm polythcne ahecting
/{31:IYcg)
t
/ SOmm sand laycr
300mm4-
• ncutron probc tubc N "\ 300m;:;u:: 100mm 300mm)J- lOm X lOm
stiffcncd raft stab
\
SOOmm ct>S, 200mm e/e mesh 3x cl>12, 410MPa stecl
boundary
fcnce
. • •• •• •DI
•
. . TDR
duialarca
•
•
.
. . • . ººº••
• • • • • • • ••
�· .. .
SL61 •• • • • ••
08
O
ººº.
D lt
•
)( 0 X O ,e)( )C
••• • o o • • • ••
,C X 1CIOt
• •
o
• NP4 � º.r.e•'°:ÑP11 • • • ••
••• • • • ••
wcather ••
station •
mctrcs
o 10
of data to assess design recommendations; predicted regional faceous clays (Engel 1966). A rock typc refcrrcd to as laminitc,
population growth that could lead to development of extensive consisting of thinly laminatcd fine sandstone and dark siltstone
arcas of potentially expansivo soil; and a growing expcctation in laycrs, is characteristic of the Dempsey Forrnation and is identi-
thc community that houscs coostructed using modero tcchnology ficd at depth throughout the site (Fityus 1999).
and modero materials should suffer liule or no clamage from any The gcotcchnical profilc for the soil found at the sitc is shown
cause. in Fig, 2. The average soil profilc can be described as 250 mm of
The Maryland site was sclected for this study bccause it is silty clay topsoil underlain by high plasticity clay to a depth of
typical of maoy new and existing residential housing estates on approximately 12 m, then mcdium plastic silty clay with sorne
the eastern seaboard of Australia, where seasonally induced
relict rock structure to approximately 1.8 m, where rock structurc
ground surface movemcot of between 40 and 70 mm causes sig- becomes consistent, with highly to extremely weathered siltstone
nificant distrcss in oldcr and poorly cngioeered resideotial struc-
turcs. The Maryland site lies within a corridor of open space encountercd below 25 m. Soil typc changes are gradational, with
which has been carmarked for extcnsive residential dcvelopmcnt no distinct !ayer bouodarics evident below the base of the topsoil.
betwecn 1990 and 2010. fig. 2 also shows profilcs of Allerberg limits, partido sizc, linear
shrinkagc, cation exchangc capacity (CEC) and shrink-swell
index (I ss: see the Appendix). Fig. 3 shows the variation in un-
5/te Condltions corrected swelling pressurc with respcct to the initial water con-
The Maryland site lies approximately 160 km north of Sydney, 10 tent. The soil activity, defined as the plasticity index divided by
km west of the city of ewcastle, and sorne 800 m northwest of the percentage of clay, is approximately 0.9. The site classifica-
the suburb of Maryland. The region has a tempcrate, near coastal lion for expansivity (based on predicted open ground movement
climate with an annual rainfall typically between 1,000 and 1,200 for the site following AS 2870.1 (1996) is H (i.e., "highly reac-
mm pcr year. A detailed plan of the site is shown in Fig. 1. The tive" with predicted movemcnt in the range of 40-70 mm). This
site is approximately 80 mX25 m and is covered with a low is consistent with data obtained in adjacent áreas of the suburb of
running kikuyu grass. ll has a Jarge eucalyptus tree (a forest red Maryland during gcotcchnical investigations for housing (Taylor
gum) at the western end. The site has a uniform surface gradient 1993) wherc, of 14 sites testcd, 3 werc classified as M ("moder-
of 25° that dips south by southcast toward an castem extremity of
ately reactive" with movemcnt of 20-40 mm), 10 as H and onc
an alluvium fillcd Oood plain sorne 300 m away. Drainage is
as E ("extremely reactive" with movement cxceedíng 70 mm).
predominantly by surface runoff.
The expansive soils al the field site consist of residual silty
clays of high plasticity. The sitc is assessed to be underlain by the 5/te Arrangement
Dempsey Formation within the Permian Tomago Coa! Measures,
which is known lo consist mainly of shales, mudstones, and silt- The site arrangement was dcsigned lo provide data on scveral
stones with subordinate sandstones, thin coa! searns, and tuf- important aspects of expansive soils siles including the following:
-
(CL) sandy silty CLAY, (topsoíl)
.
K
;. •.. �.
X
I>
o.s
(OI) CLAY, high plasticity, pale orangc-brown) X + - ...... 1
lx><
X l
k
: + • I t',
X X X
bccoming
.e nñottfed "¡iaie browñigrey with SOIDC ºred-orañge.
0 + • kl)
+
•
) i><
staining and ironstone gravels )( 1)
.
.....'
.s
(CL-CH) silty Cl.AY, medium to high
plasticity, palc grcy-brown with sorne iron
X .¡ • l ��
staining (sorne residual rock structurc) •
- 1,:)
k
SlLTY CI.AY/ EXTREMELY WEATHERED
�( SILTSTONE brown grey, laminatcd
•
.
2.5 HJGHLY WEATiiERED SILTSTONE
Jight and dark grey laminations
3.0
3.5
d X
+
plastic limit
liquid limit
4
1 1
O 2S SO 15 14 15 16 O 20 40 60 80 100 O 5 JO IS 20 O 5 10 15 20 2S O J 2 3 4 S 6 7
• The magnitude and variability of changes in water content, To this end a field site was planned at which instrumentation
changes in suction and ground movement, at various depths, in could be installed and monitored for a long period. The field site
open arcas on a site; was designed with reference to similar field studies which have
• The effects of trees on soil water content changes and ground been conducted in the past, both in Australia {e.g., Holland and
movement; Lawrence 1980; Coffey and Partners 1985; Cameron 1989) and
• The effects that {impervious) raft slabs have on moisture Ilow overseas (e.g., de Bruijn 1965; Freeman et al. 1991; Pellissier
and the subsequent effects on ground movement and the de- 1992; Wray 1992). Features of the site are shown in Fig. l and
velopmenl of mound sbapes in two and three dimensions; they include
• The interaction between reinforced concrete stiffened raft • Open ground arcas where water content and suction changes
slabs and expansive clay foundation soils, and the reduction in and surface and subsurface movement could be monitored;
ground movement whicb results from slab stiffness and struc- • An area adjacent to a large tree, where water content changes
tural load; and and surface and subsurface movement could be monitored;
• An assessment of the role of climate in driving ali of the above • A "flexible" impervious cover to simulate a perfectly flexible
over a number of seasons. stiffened raft slab with edge beams, instrumented to allow sub-
surface water contcnt changes and surface and subsurface
movcment to be monitored; and
�600 • A reinforced concrete stiffencd raft slab with two parallel
a 500
l:!
edges loaded to simulate a transmitted roof load, instrumented
to allow subsurfacc water content changes and surface and
�
:::,
400
í\ subsurface movement to be monitored.
p.
CA)
:E 300
\ \ Thc 10.6 mX 10.6 m flexible cover was comprised of a soil
filled HDPE plastic envelope (three layers), constructed in situ
-¡¡
\ \ with the same spatial cbaracteristics as a nonnally stiffened raft
� 200 slab (i.e., with finite thickness and down-tumed edgc beams). Tbe
13
� 100
ir--._ r-, surface was covcred with a 50-mm layer of silica sand to protcct
the plastic sheeting against UV degradation and weathering.
8 � tx Tbc 10 mXlO m reinforccd concrete slab was 100-mm thick,
g o with integrally cast edge and center stiffening beams 300-mm
o 5 10 15 20 25 30 wide and 500-mm decp. Thc slab was reinforced with 8-mm
initial water content (%) weldcd mesh (200-mm centers in both directions) and thc stiffen-
ing beams were cach reinforced with three deformed bars of
Flg. 3. Uncorrected swell prcssurc for Maryland clay
12-mm diameter.
JOURNAL OF GEOTECHNICAL ANO GEOENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING <C> ASCE / JULY 2004 / 689
wioter summcr wmter summer winter sumrner winter
1994 1996
date
Flg. 4. Comparison of local daily temperature, rainfall, and ground movement at Maryland field site
crude indication of loss of soil moisrure), rainfall (a crudc indi- • Notwithstanding the above, rainfall appears to have a domi-
cation of the gain of soil moisture), and ground movement. A nant effect on short-term ground movement. Since the tem-
comparison of these quantities is presented in Fig. 4. perature pattems are relatively consistent, it would seem that
Many significant observations can be made based on the data any summer should have the potential to produce severe
presented in Fig. 4. These include the following. shrinkage movement. In sorne years these are realized (1993 to
• Toe Maryland soil profile exists predomínantly in a wetter/ 1994, 1997 to 1998), yet in other years they are not (1998 to
expanded statc (about 70% of the time) and is in transition 1999). Whether or not movement is realized is controlled by
berween wet and dry states at other times. the sumrner rainfall; when it occurs frequently, shrinkage is
• Toe ground surface leve! has often remained steady at high averted (1998 to 1999). when it occurs sporadically or sud-
values during the study, suggesting that maxirnurn, wet-tirne denly, shrinkage is dramatieally reversed (1993 to 1994).
ground levels have beco observed. In contrast, the ground
leve! was not observed to remain at low values for any period
So// Moisture and Suction Changes in Open Areas
of time, with sudden, rainfall induced heave appearing to take
place before steady mínimum levels can be established. This Laboratory deterrninations of gravimetric soil water content and
suggests that the mínimum dry-time ground levels, and hcncc soil suction valucs were made on many occasions throughout the
maximum overall ground movement, have not been obscrved srudy, including occasions of more sevcre wet and dry soil con-
in the 7-year observation period. ditions. These were made using freshly augured soil samples
l. There is a strong pauern in the temperature record showing taken from boreholes in the vicinity of the control. Total suction
an annual cycle. measurements were made in the laboratory using a transistor psy-
2. Tbere is a weaker, but relatively persistcnt, pattem in the chrometer and filler paper techniques. Toe measured values are
observed ground movement, on an approxirnately annual shown in Figs. 5(a and b). The following observations can be
cycle. made.
3. There is no obviously consisten! pattem in the rainfall • In both cases, the variation in measured values can reasonably
record. be approximated as linearly decreasing with depth (below the
• These observations suggcst that conditions that produce loss of topsoil: log seale for suction), although there are local anoma-
rnoisture have the dominant effect on long-term ground move- lies at sorne depths.
mcnt cycles. Consider, for cxample, summer 1993 to 1994, • The variation in gravimetric water content is between 13 and
where low rainfall at the end of 1993, in thc hcight of summer, 23% in the topsoil, and between 20 and 34% in the top of the
corresponded to relatively severe ground shrinkage movement. clay layer.
In contrast, a similarly low rainfall late in the wintcr of 1995 • The variation in total suction is betwcen 3.2 and 52 pF (160
coincided with little or no ground shrinkage, becausc water and 16,000 kPa) in the topsoil, and between about 3.5 and 5.0
loss from the site was likcly to havc been much lower. pF (320 and 10,000 kPa) in the top of the clay layer.
�·...
;,·
.e: l.l � ) �X .e: 1.2 1---+--f---t�
c..
.g -i.s X transistor psychrometer '
t I fr 1.4 1---+-t---t---t
"O
• In both cases variation in measured values is observcd over Envelopes of water content derived from the neuron probe that
time at depths of up to 2.0 m. However, the magnitude of thc represen! the extreme observations at various depths are com-
variation is gcnerally small bclow about 1.3 m in the total pared in Fig. 6 for open ground, the ccnter of a cover, adjacent to
suction rcsults and 1.6 m in the gravimctric water conteot re- a tree. The profiles shown reprcsent the upper and lower enve-
sults, lopes of ali readings taken at each depth during thc project. ínter-
mediare values were omitted for clarity. The followiog observa-
Effect of Trees and Covers tioos were made.
A simple assessment of the effects of trces and covers can be • Ali three envelopcs reflect the same basic shape characteris-
made by compariog the in situ soil water cooteot profiles taken at tics, which are similar to those of the gravimetric water coo-
appropriate locatioos duriog the study. tent data in Fig. 5(b). Most obvious are thc different bchaviors
0.00
._
�
-->-
�
-- .
1"111
_::-¡
i:
,, ,-,
- -- -- � i<.,
�
] ,. - �- -t-�t-i-· -..... � t
.
•
;
0.50 X dry extreme
� (corrected)
t
1 i
� � • wet extreme
� (corrected)
++measured extremes
)
r
1.00
I� � � (uncorrected)
�(·
_.
t
• �
.¡ �
H
...
H J
�
.. .....
i
2.00
�; �
!lit l-1
:��
-1
2.50
fl�
l 47 readings 1 21 readings .. 116 readings '
3.00
O 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 O 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 O 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
moisture content (volurnetric, %)
a) NPl 1: open ground b) NP7: under tree e) NP4: centre of ground cover
Fig. 6. Comparison of cbanges in volumetnc water cootent cbaoge for different field condiuons
I=:-
Range of vertical movement for ali 30 open ground 1 1 1
47-75 1 1 ...__ control (open)
surface markers � 1 1
-t- 2.5 t- flc,ublecover
1 !
-20-10 O JO 20 30 40 SO O 10 20 30 40 SO 60
observed above and below a depth of about 03 m. Above 03 •) muimun movcmcnts b) muimum range of w,rucal IDOVCITJCRII
rdaUYC to trutw h<lgllt (mm)
m, the topsoil expcriences wide variations in water content,
but at lower overall values. Below 0.3 rn, the expansive clay
Flg. 7. Ground movemcnt envelopes with respect to depth for open
soils experience relatively smaller water content changes, but ground area and thc center of the flexible cover
at higher values. There are severa! rcasons for this. First, the
neutron probe measures the average water content in a
"sphere" of soil, of variable diameter (depending upon the
water content) betwecn 100 and 200 mm (Li et al. 2001). For both sites have experienced moveroent of 8 mm which oc-
readings taken at depths of less than 100 mm sorne of this curred at depths in exccss of 3 ro. Examination of Fig. 4,
volume may not include soil and, hence, the values will be however, reveals that the consistent movement for soils at
low. Second, the topsoil contains rouch less clay than the clay deptbs of 25 and 3 m have, on average, coroprised a slight
soil, so the water content values it can achieve are lower. heaving movement of only 2-3 mm, and the few deviations
Third, the topsoil supports a healthy cover of grasses which that exceed this value are somewhat random and anomaJous.
are able to extraer rooisture to relatively low levels. This discrepancy betwcen Figs. 4 and 7 suggests that ground
• Tbe roaximum water content change at dcpth in the open level measurements are prone to random error of up to :::!:3
ground arca becomes very sroall at about 1.4 rn, and is esscn- mm.
tially O at about 1.6 m. This, too, is consisten! with the obser- • Taking this error into account, it is apparent that most of the
vations madc for the gravimetric water content values. soil movernent takes place above a depth somcwhere betweeo
• The máximum water content change at dcpth adjaccnt to the 15 and 2 m.
tree also becoroes very small at about 1.4 m, but then appears • For both thc open ground and covered arcas, most of the
to remain ata small, but consistent, valuc to a depth of around movement is realized in the upper 1 ro of the soil profile. lo
25 ro. This is consistent with the expectation that large trees the open grouod arca, about 50% of thc movement is realized
are able to extend the active depth. in the clay betwcen thc base of the topsoil at about 03 m and
• The maximum water content change beneath the center of the a depth of 0.75 rn; 80% is rcalized between the topsoil and a
flexible cover is very small and confined to the upper 0.4 m. depth of 1 m. This behavior is consisten! with the larger
Toe equilibrium moisture distribution below this depth shows chaoges in water content and suctioo occurring at shallower
a consistent decrease with the depth, probably due to gradually levels (Figs. 5(a and b)], and the greater expansive potential of
developed differences in soil texture. soils at shallower depths (Fig. 2).
• Rclative to the ground levcls which prevailed at the time of
Ground Movement ficld site cornmissioning, both arcas have recorded more heave
than shrinkagc. This is consisten! with an observation that the
Details of the recorded open ground movement are presented in site was relativcly dry when established.
Table 1. The results indicate that there is considerable variability • The covercd arca has rccorded a center heave of about 35 mm
in the open ground movement realized across the site, but movc- that occurs mostly betwcen the base of the topsoil at 0.3 m and
ment is generally within the range of 47-75 mm. While such a depth of about 0.5 m. This seems to be larger than might be
movement is likely to be considerably suppressed by the presence expected for only 0.2 m of clay soil, particularly when the
of a stiffened, loaded foundation, it has the potcntial to produce water content changes indicated in Fig. 6(c) are considered.
significant differential movement and corresponding structural 1t is also interesting to consider the relative contributioo to
distress within a lightly loaded residential structure if adequate surface movement made by the upper 0.5 m of soil in the open
foundations are not provided. This validatcs the selection of the and covered arcas, in which it is evideot that about 20 mm is
Maryland site for a field study of expansive soils behavior. rcalized beneath the cover, while 9 mm is realized in the open
Ground movement envelopes with respect to depth are shown ground. At first glance, it rnight be suspected that the soil bencath
for an open ground control area and for the center of the flexible the cover is more reactive than that in the open ground area, but
cover in Fig. 7. Fig. 7(a) shows the máximum recorded movemeot an examination of construction details revcals that around 0.15 m
at various deptbs relative to an initial ground height, while Fig. of topsoil was removed prior to constructing the cover, which
7(b) shows the total range of movement. Note that the plots of now comprises only 50 mm of sand. Thus, up to 0.15 m of topsoil
movements with respect to time for the open ground (NPI 1) arca was removed from the typical sitc profilc, so that the upper 05 m
are those shown in Fig. 4. Importan! obscrvations are the follow- of soil beneath the cover now comprises 03-035 m of the most
ing. cxpansive clay in thc profile. This should be compared with thc
• 1t is apparent from Fig. 7 that both locations have experienced uppcr 0.5 m beneath the open ground which comprises only 0.2-
significant movement during the study. Fig. 7(b) suggests that 025 m of expansivo clay.
692 / JOURNAL OF GEOTECHNICAL ANO GEOENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING © ASCE / JULY 2004
....cr¡'..-
\
w.. � -..... 'b E /> <, ::.i • Undcr ali climatic conditions, thc mound shapes have a prorni-
""··�>cf·=�,-,;:�v / �--
\
/' \-:::. i,>-:. / <, nent dish shapc across thc top, bctwcen thc edge bcams, Toe
.b) ............ ,: , <, net result of this is that thc ccntcr-heavc mounds have an odd
<, \,: <, -- .• / /
.... ¡ ......... - b) • ./ / compounded shape, where the highest points on the mound líe
,:
\¡, ... 1) . \, ......
just within thc cdgc bcams.
�------- ¡ _.. _ -----T'- ...,. _
• The unusual mound shapc is further complicated by low points
that coincide with the edge beams. These are explained in a
. •>· ·. \
• ; 1112194 • • • • •) • wy, prt 1997 ' ' way similar to the unexpectedly large undcrcover movement
• 8/4198 .... • 'C) • W)', - 1997 discussed earlier. However, in this case, there is a reduction in
•••• ; 191!!193 ------ .. comtructcd
the depth of expansive clay in the soil profile due to its re-
816195--b)- -.prtl997 ·... �
2219199--cl)- ---1997 moval through excavation for the edge beams.
17
n 32 37 42 • The mound shapc appcars to be asymmctric. Sorne of this
dulancc from nee (m) effect is possibly duc to sorne slight asymmetry in the relative
Fig. 8. Profile of mound across the cover (W lo E) positions of the ground surface movcmcnt blocks and the
cover. Mostly, the asymmetry is considered to be a retlection
of the variation which is cvident in the ground surface move-
Mound Profi/es ment which occurs in the open ground arcas.
Fig. 8 shows that there is a gradual convergence of the ground
One of the main aims of tbe Maryland study was to observe the level bcncath the cover to sorne final equilibrium height, although
shape characteristics of the center-heave or cdge-heave mounds the rate of convergence is unclcar. It is clarified in Fig. 9 which
which occur after an impervious ground cover is constructed. Re- plots the ground lcvcl with Lime for the centcr of the cover and for
inforced concrete slab designs for expansive soils siles can be four points at the centcr of the edges, just insidc the edge beams.
undertaken using a so-called "beam on mound" analysis {Walsh Key observations include the following.
and Cameroo 1977) if tbe extreme mound shapes beneath a cover • The edges rise more quickly and attain their final heaved Jevel
can be accurately estimated. in 5 to 6 years.
Fig. 8 shows east-west mound profiles measured on four dif- • The center rises more slowly and is still rising slowly after 7
fereot occasions in time following constructioo. In considering years, although the majority of the heave has occurred within 4
Fig. 8. it should again be noted that the cover was constructed at years. It is intcrcsting to note this when considering the mound
a Lime of relalive dryness. Key obscrvalions include the Iollow- profiles in Fig. 8, whcre curves (a) and {b) occurred within this
ing. 4-year period, and (e) and (d) occurred thcreafter.
• Ground movemcnt beyond the cover is seen to undergo re-
peated shrinkagc and hcave due seasonal cyclcs. Movement
beneath the cover is consistent heaving, as the inilially dry soil Discussion and Conclusions
slowly becomes wct and approaches an equilibrium water con-
tent. These two behaviors seem almost independent of each The Maryland expansive soils project has produccd a large quan-
other, with the edge beam marking the boundary between tity of informalion which has allowed the phenomena associated
tbem. wilh expansive soils foundations to be better understood. It will
• Under dry climatic conditions, thc mound shape is dominantly facilitatc the development of more refincd expansivc soils foun-
center heave, with a long-term total mound height of around dation models into the future.
55 mm [curve (e)]. This condition is likely to be most severe An importan! outcome of the field monitoring work is confir-
after a long Lime when the covered soil has auained equilib- mation that in situ mcasurement of soil suction is a difficult task
rium wetness and can swell no further. that has a strong likelihood of unreliable results for the methods
• Under wet conditions, there is only weak development of an asscssed. This outcome is consistent with the recently published
edge-hcave mound, which is more likely to be most severe if findings of Harrison and Blight (2000).
the dry site wcre to be inundated by hcavy rain just alter The observalion that the sito soils in thc study arca tend to
construclion. remain predominantly in a "heaved" state is also an important
--- -
.-.. 45
!40 - .
- - .- - - - . - - - .... � -...............
- :..:-:- -
fi 35 . - . . . .,,--:-: _ f-:-:-,r� .........-------=--
fi> 30
. ..··:,;..:..:..:.. t:2---..,. ...- -- -- ---- ,........:::.---
� 25
] 20
!.
-�
-- - i;o,::Y
--
SlA9
sus- - -
centre
NW edge -
,,� "
·13 15 SL53------ NE edge 1-
JOURNAL OF GEOTECHNICAL ANO GEOENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING <e ASCE / JULY 2004 / 693
,,11ll111111., \! hilé �uch ,he hd111vinr 1111{1ht be cxpcc,ctl 011 thc ll.is,�
H ycar11, ullhough 1hc wclling wa" m,,.,úy complew after 11boot 4
,11 hx•ul expcncnce gul11cd iwc, time, il is u sne charnclcri�ltc th•u
°'
h not .'�·11Ul upp..11 •111 q1m11tifiublc without uvnllahlc long tcr;n
ycurH. ll amx:M• that wctling bcncath lhc covercd area í• not
si¡n11lcuntly uffcclcd by tlry clímatc cvenL'I, 1Juggc�1Jng that the
llulu I he result [rom thi,; rure, Ion� term ,111t1y i11 particulnrl ctlgc hcums havc a Hignific-Jnl controlling cffcct on lateral move-
u, •ful to cnuble moro imJ1rcc1 mcthod'i ol time tic xnd • belu y mcnt of moi�lurc from thc ctlgc" of covcrff.
llll º"CS\llll!lll lo he • 1 • I Clll IUV
cvu lllllctl • 1-or examptc McKccn ·1ntl
Jllhll�\lll ( 1990) 'ill""C\tC''
r,r,
ll l l , , '
u III u e 1mt111c index cullcd lhc 'l'horn
' Aoknowlodgmonta
•
thwuho 1m11s1t11 ind • ,.., , MI) (n . .
1orn1hw11110 191IB) might serve us 'I his rc,carch was supportcd by thc Mine Subsídence Board of
,111 lndlcutor ni the u nlve dcplh 'l'he l'MI .
• ts u mensure of 1 1 ie Ncw South Wales, 1hc Au�Lr.tlían ReM:arch Council, and Robert
lontt 1 c1111 '•vcnty ol ,1 locul cllmare, dctermined Irom culeulauon
. Carr ami A�sociatcs l'ty. Lttl. ·¡ he writcr.i would also like to thank
of "111.cr �1lu11cc which cmploys estlmatcs ol ruinfull und cvapo thc revicwers of this work for Lhcír wísdom and dilígence.
lr11n�p11u11on pot ntiol ob111incd Irom local climatic rccords. ll can
he contourcd over a reglen, in valúes bctwecn obout -100 anti Appendlx: Shrlnk-Swell lndex Test
+ 100 A 1x1,i1h e valúe indicares a net, long 1cn11 moisture sur (AS 1289 7.1.1 1992)
plus ('.1 t�rcdominuncu of wet condltlons), whercas a negativo Thc :,hrink-swcll rntlcx has bccn Lhe mosl commonJy employed
vatue indicnt ·� u long tcrm rnoisture dcflcit (u prcdominanee of tohoratory· bascd mcasurc of 1hc expansivo potcntial of ciar �Is
dry eonditions), A vulu of zcro indicmcs a moisture balance. in Australia for thc past 15 ycars. Ground movcmcnt prcd1ct1ons
From ' ork hy ri1yu,; et al. (1998). which sought to dcvclop bascd on 1he rcsults of shrink swell tests are generally successful
th.-. principlo for thc l luntcr Vallcy región of Australia, thc ·¡ MI (Camcron 1989). Shrink-swcll test results have a cocfficient of
for Murylund is cstimatcd al +25, suggcsring thut thc arca should variation of ahout 25% and havc bccn consídcred sufficienlly re-
b prone to a sligh; to modcruto long tcrm moisture surplus, This liablc for adoplion into evcryday Australian practice for Lhe dc-
b consistcm with tho observation thal soil heave predominares, sign of foundations for lighlly loadcd, residential !>LrUCtures
Thi� work wu extended 10 produce an estimare of the active (Walsh and Cameron 1997).
dcpth for Marylund of bctwcen 1.6 and 1.7 m, lt is slightly largor Thc shrink \well tcsl (AS 1289 7.1.l 1992) comprises both
thun thc vuluc indicatcd by the suction measured (1.3 m) but shrinkagc and swelling test components, carriod out on compan-
consistcnt with thc valuc of 1.6 m indicatcd by thc gravimctric ion soil samples, initially at lheir field waler conlents. Tbc core
and neutrón p be water contcnt measurcmcnts and the valuc of shrinkagc componen! involves, first, air drying, and then oven
l .'i 2 m indicutcd by the ground movemcnt mcasurcmcnts. ll drying of an unrestrained, undisturbed, 50-mm coro sample. Toe
suggcsts that the TMI could he used as a rcliablc prcdictor of thc swell componenl involves a simple oedomeler Lest in which the
a tivc dcpth in this región. undisturbcd sample is seaLed under a nominal 25-k.Pa load beforc
Bolh thc water contcnt and suction data suggcst that a linear being inundated wilh distilled waler and allowed to swcll until the
variation in suction with respect lo dcpth is a good approximation. soil saturates. hrinkage strain (e..,) and swell strain (esw) are
l lowcver, the chango in suction reali1.cd al thc surfaec is closc to mcasurcd in Lhc respective Lcsts, and combined lo give a swelling
2.0 pr, excceding the suggestcd valuc of 1.5 pF given in AS 2870 (shrink-swcll) indcx, J.,, according to
(1996).
The above rcsults suggcst thal the dcsign suclion changcs sug (1)
gesLctl by A 2870 (1996) in the calculation of open ground
movcmcnt (givcn carlicr, and based on anecdola.l cvidence) are, in Thc numerator of lhis exprcssion is an estimale of the nel volu-
facl, nol entircly appropriate for the widcr Newcastlc rcgion. The metric strain belwccn the conditions of oven dry and saturatcd.
rcsults of t.his Mudy suggcst tJmt lhe active depth should be decpcr Thc divisor of 2. applicd to the swell componenl, is to account for
and the surfacc suction change larger, which would lead to an lhe effccts of la1ernl confinement, and usod lo estimate equivalent
incrcase in the prcdictcd surfacc movcment valucs. When thc rec swell strain undcr condilions of no lateral confinernenl. The suil-
ommended valuc of A 2870 are uscd, the prcdic1ed ground ability of lhe valuc of 2 was assessed for two contrasling clay
movcment for Maryland is 41 mm, which is a significant undcr- soils in a detailed laboratory study by Fityus and Welbourne
estimation of the measurcd values of between 47 and 75 mm (1996), and fouod to be appropriate for the purpose inlended.
(Fityus 1999). The observations from Lhis study thus facililate an Tho denominalor of l.8 in Eq. (l) is an eslimate of lhe offec-
improvcmcnt to current local prnclicc. tive rango of change in suction that corrcsponds to a chango in
The water content change obscrvations adjaccnl lo the treo soil volume as lhe water content changes between the states of
would seem to indicate that the prcsence of the tree rcsults in an oven dry and saturntion. It is in units of pF, dofined as Iog nega-
incrc.1se in thc active depth. However, thc water contenl changc tive (free onergy pcr unit volume of water), and approximated by
below 1.6 m is so small that this outcome cannol coafidenúy be log negativo (hydraulic head in centimeters), or by 1 +log(suclion
slatcd as a fim1 conclu ion. Thc results do suggest that thc water in k.Pa).
conlent change cnvclopc in trce-affectcd arcas cannot be approxi- The shrink-swcll approach provides a real physical assess-
matcd as lincarly varying with the depth Lhroughout an incrcased ment of expansivo potential, wilhout requiriag measurement of
a tivc deplh. soil suction. The assumptions of chango in suction and lateral
Rcsults from ú1e flexible cover inclicatc lhat the critical mound restraint effccts, which are employcd in the procedure, are able Lo
shapc in this case is a centcr-hcave mound which is likcly lo be give repealable prccliction results, which are largely independent
mosl severo during a dry pcriod, a long time after construction. of the water content of the samples wben teslcd.
fhis situation is strongly influenccd by lhe dry condilions which
prcvailcd al the time of construction. References
The mound has an unusual compound shapc, with a pro- Aitchison, G. D., ed. (1965). "Moisture equilibria and moisturc changes
nounccd dish fcaturc across the lop of lhe mound, betwoen lhc in soils bcnealh covcred arcas." S),np., in press, Butterworths, Syd-
edgc bcams. Wetting of lhe covered rcgion is still continuing after ney, Australia.