Professional Documents
Culture Documents
z
0
~
u
::>
0
w
t, OF CALIFORNIA
et:
AT DAVIS
w
w
z
t,
zw
et:
0
LL
>-
1-
w
u
0 CATALYST: effectiveness factor Cassiere & Carberry
(/')
z
<t:
CURRICULUM: cpm network . Cunningham & Sommerfield
~
et:
LU
CALTECH: polymer program Cohe & Tschoegl
~
<t: POLLUTANT: dispersion Miller & Cadman
LL
0 CATALYSIS: short course Luss & Richardson
z DESIGN: contro l system . Paul
0
Westvaco
299 Park Avenue
New York, N.Y. 10017
WINTER 1973 1
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
INDUSTRIAL SPONSORS: <fits ~ ~ t hatJe donated
/u,~ ~ tJie d . ~ o/ CHEMICAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION d ~ 1973:
C F BRAUN & CO THE 3M COMPANY
DEPARTMENTAL SPONSORS: <Jlie ~ 103 ~ e n u /u;,ae
~ to tJie ~ o/ CHEMICAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION m 1973
University of Akron Lehigh University Princeton University
University of Alberta Loughborough University (England) University of;-J;?µerto·:-Rico
Arizona State University Louisiana Polytechnic Institute Purdue Univei:sity •'f.
University of Arizona Louisiana State University University of Quebec
University of Arkansas University ·of Louisville Queen's University
Auburn University McGill University Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute ,
Brigham Young University McMaster University University of Rhode Island
Bucknell University McNeese State University Rutgers-The State University
University of Calgary University of Maine State University of N. Y. at Buffalo
University of California (Berkeley) Manhattan College Stevens Institute of Technology
University of California, Davis Massachusetts Institute of Technology Syracuse University
University of California (Santa Barbara) University of Massachusetts Technion, Israel
California Institute of Technology University of Michigan Tennessee Technological University
Case-Wes tern Reserve University Michigan State University University of Tennessee
Clarkson College of Technology University of Mississippi Texas A&I University
Clemson University University of Missouri, Rolla University of Texas at Austin
University of Colorado Montana State University Texas A&M University
Colorado School of Mines New York University University of Toledo
Cooper Union University of New Mexico Tufts University
Cornell University University of New Brunswick University of Tulsa
University of Delaware University of New Hampshire University of Utah
University of Detroit University of New South Wales Vanderbilt University
Drexel University North Carolina State University University o'f Virginia
Ecole Polytech, Canada Northwestern University Virginia Polytechnic Institute
University of Florida University of Notre Dame Wayne State University
Georgia Institute of Technology Nova Scotia Technical College Washington University
University of Idaho Ohio University University of Washington
University of Illinois (Urbana) University of Oklahoma University of Waterloo
Illinois Institute of Technology Oklahoma State University West Virginia University
Iowa State University Oregon State University University of Wisconsin
University of Iowa University of Ottawa Worcester Polytechnic Institute
University of Kansas University of Pennsylvania University of Wyoming
Kansas State University Pennsylvania State University Yai~ \b niversity
University of Kentucky University of Pittsburgh University of Windsor
Laval University Polytechnic Institute of Brooklyn
WINTER 1973 3
ti Na educator This article was submitted to GEE by J. M.
Smith of the Chemical Engineering Department
of the University of California at Davis.
WINTER 1973 5
Steve and Suzanne plus
Suzy, Collin Walter, Larry,
Lynn and Jimmy on a
Sunday afternoon outing.
common core courses. A few (very few) polite smaller and less strenuous climbs that abound
conversations regarding course content and level in the valley. The Whitaker boys, Larry and
were always held, but angry debate would more Jimmy, have participated in some small climbs,
accurately describe the discussions about the while the girls, Lynn and Suzy, must wait a few
common core courses. A heavy dose of "slings summers before they can join their brothers on
and arrows" will usually clear ones head, and the rock. Suzanne views this activity benignly
Professor Whitaker's thoughts on fluid mechan- from below, but leads the way when it's time
ics were crystallized in the book, Introduction to take the high country trails.
to Fluid Mechanics, which had its beginnings at In 1964 Davis was a town without a volley-
Northwestern. Although the common core courses ball team, and like a true devotee Steve Whitaker
have essentially disappeared, Professor Whita- organized and coached the UCD Volleyball Club
ker's interest in the undergraduate program has during its early years. After 16 straight defeats
not waned, and an introductory text on heat at the hands of southern California teams, he
transfer is currently being prepared. recognized that coaching was not his game and
he threw his talents in with a group of misfits
Other climbing activities led to an assault on 21,000 from several northern California cities known
ft Mt. Ausangati in Peru and a 28 hour off-route as "Friends of Fred." Friends indeed they were
climb of the East face of Mt. Whitney. not, and the team was known far and wide for
its internal strife if not for its ability · to win
T HE RETURN TO CALIFORNIA also provided Steve
Whitaker the opportunity to renew his ac-
matches. Personal opinions were put aside for the
1970 National AAU Masters (over 35) Volley-
quaintance with the High Sierra where many a ball Championships and the team at last managed
boyhood summer was spent hiking and fishing; to bring home the first place medal. In 1972
however, the population explosion in California everyone was two years older and fourth place
had flooded his favorite haunts and heavier loads was the best that "Friends" could do in the same
had to be carried higher and further to avoid the tournament.
crowds. Charlie Sleicher provided some relief While national competition is a thing of the
with excursions to the Northwest and the spec- past, the local players are still easy pickings.
tacular Ptarmigan Traverse. Other climbing Fran Woods and Steve Whitaker have never lost
activities led to an assault on 21,000 ft Mt.Aus- a coed doubles match on the UCD volleyball sand
angati in Peru (failure occurred at 19,000 ft courts, and lunch time will usually find Jim Hur-
when the tent blew apart), and a 28 hour off- ley (Physics) and Steve Whitaker tenaceously
route climb of the east face of Mt. Whitney. holding the number one court against an array
Springtime will usually find Steve Whitaker of frustrated undergraduates. That too must
sneaking out of his office early on Fridays, pass, but there will always be a bright-eyed
squeezing in three-day week ends with his wife chemical engineering student intent on master-
Suzanne at Yosemite Valley where the "big walls" ing the laws of physics for some good purpose,
are contemplated, but avoided in favor of the and there is much to be done in that domain. D
,,
'!-~
);
So far, it's only a valve. Eight-year-old by our plastics. We were in plastics be-
Janet Hernandez has one. fore most people knew the word. We
It may not be long before a whole make more plastics than anyone else. We
working heart will be made out of plastic. haven't scratched the surface yet.
Men in plastics research at Union Why is a great big company like Union
Carbide are working on the almost im- Carbide so concerned about a little bit of
possible job of designing plastics com- plastic for the body?
patible with the body. Because.
Their most crucial job is making an Beneath our corporate exterior, there
ultra-thin polypropylene fabric for lining beats a heart.
the inside of the heart. A fabric coated
with parylene that will allow human tis-
sue to grow into and around it to keep THE DISCOVERY COMPANY
270 Park Ave,, New York , N .Y. 10017
blood from clotting. •
A plastic heart isn't the only part of
the body were working on. Maybe some-
day there will be a little plastic in all of us.
Right now, weve got you surrounded
TEXAS
J. S. Swearington, John Griswold, W. A. Cunning-
This paper was submitted by the Chemical Engi- ham, and K. A. Kobe. Physically, the Depart-
neering faculty, University of Texas, Austin. mental activities were housed within the Chemis-
try Building until a new building for Chemical
How did chemical engineering get started at Texas? Engineering was authorized and constructed dur-
ing the years immediately preceding the World
The parallelism that exists between the De-
War IL The building, containing 33,000 sq. ft. of
partment of Chemical Engineering at The Uni-
floor space is devoted exclusively to office and
versity of Texas at Austin and the hydrocarbons
laboratory usage.
processing industry of the state is not accidental.
The accrediting program of the AIChE was
Each has complemented the other since before
suspended nationally early in World War II, but
World War I, when the late Dr. E. P. Schoch
this Department was given provisional accredit-
foresaw the need to apply his profound knowledge
ing in 1943, and after the war full accreditation
of chemistry to develop uses for the crude oil
was received and has been retained since that time.
which production was increasing daily. As a re-
sult of Dr. Schoch's direct effort, a degree pro-
How big is your department?
gram leading to the Bachelor's Degree in Chemical
Engineering was authorized by the Regents early Prior to 1935 only 130 bachelors degrees had
in 1916 and the first two degrees were awarded been granted with an average of 8 graduating
in June 1919. Official recognition was given to the seniors per year, but this number jumped to 24
new Department through the changing of Dr. in 1935 and reached a pre-war peak of 54 in 1939.
Schoch's title from "Professor of Physical Chem- With the onset of the war, the normal under-
istry" to "Professor of Chemical Engineering and graduate activities slowed very substantially, but
Physical Chemistry." picked up again in 1947 when 80 degrees were
For almost 20 years Dr. Schoch was the only awarded and reached a peak in 1948 with 105
permanent faculty member, but as the student Bachelor's Degrees. Since that time the average
load became heavier he was given assistance by annual number of B.S. graduates has been ap-
the appointment of full time instructors on a year proximately 60. Total undergraduate enrollment
to year basis. In 1938 Chemical Engineering was is currently about 350 full time students. Gradu-
established as a full Department in the College ate enrollment increased steadily after 1948 until
of Engineering with Dr. E. P. Schoch as Chair- 1965, reaching a level of 50 to 60 full time
man. Among the early faculty members were Drs. students per year.
WINTER 1973 9
realize these objectives, laboratory equipment has
been designed and built for appropriate experi-
ments some of which involve extensive computa-
tion. Efficient techniques have been implemented
to acquire data, put it in the form having the
greatest significance, and present the information
to the student during the laboratory period.
WINTER 1973 11
James E. Stice
Computer assisted instruction, research in engineering
teaching.
Eugene H. Wissler
Properties of aerosol particles, aerosol beams, simulation
of the human thermal system, and non-Newtonian fluids.
Robert P. Popovich
Physiological transport parameters in a patient's artificial
kidney system; extracorporeal treatment of blood to
alleviate major disease states; enzymatatic detoxification
of endogeous and exhogeneous toxins (artificial liver);
pathogenesis and treatment of atheroscelerosis.
David M. Himmelblau
Process analysis and simulation, and system analysis, opti-
mization, stochastic modeling.
Edgar Van Winkle
Joel 0. Hougen
Process dynamics and control system design. Members of the Chemical Engineering faculty
are not only recognized leaders in their individual
John J. McKetta, Jr. areas of expertise, but have been called on to
Phase equilibria, thermodynamic properties and high take positions of leadership in University ad-
pressure P-V-T. ministrative functions, as well as in the AIChE
and other professional organizations, in civic,
Donald R. Paul and other activities of a broad nature. Dr. Mc-
Ketta is a member of the National Academy of
Polymer physics and chemistry. In particular the thermo- Engineering. •
dynamics and transport properties of polymers in bulk
and solution with applications to polymer processing.
Howard F. Rase
Reaction kinetics and catalysis with particular emphasis
on catalyst geometry and specificity, new catalyst develop-
ment and also enzyme model catalysts, process and chemi-
cal reactor design techniques.
Robert S. Schechter
Surface transport phenomena, surface viscosity, elasticity
and diffusion, hydrodynamic stability, and the application
of acids in oil reservoirs.
Hugo Steinfink
Crystal chemistry, magnetic, electrical, and optical prop-
erties of rare earth compounds, crystal chemistry of
silicate-organic complexes. McKetta Steinfink
WINTER 1973 15
APPLICATIONS OF
HETEROGENEOUS CATALYSIS
DAN LUSS and JAMES T. RICHARDSON variety of viewpoints we selected as instructors
University of Houston two industrial and three academic experts. Each
Houston, Texas 77004 lecturer was instructed on the material to be in-
cluded in his section in order to avoid gaps in the
Chemical Engineering Departments provide a coverage and to prevent repetitious discussions
useful service to the industrial community by of certain material. A comprehensive set of notes
offering short courses on topics of current inter- for classroom use was collected from each. These
est. Many universities have found this to be so were reproduced, bound and distributed to each
profitable a utilization of faculty and facilities attendee before the start of the course. The class
that available courses proliferate during the sum- schedule for 1972 is shown in Table 1.
mer months. The most valuable courses are those
which are tailor-made to suit the needs of po-
tential attendees and not the predilections of the
Table 1 - COURSE OUTLINE AND LECTURERS
available faculty.
(Summer 1972)
The Chemical Engineering Department of the
University of Houston organized two short course 1. Catalyst Selection (0.5 day) J. T. Richardson
on the applications of heterogeneous catalysis A. Introduction to catalysis
during the summers of 1971 and 1972. The pro- B. Theories of catalysis
C. Prediction of catalytic properties
gram was so successful that essentially the same
D. Catalytic process development
course is being repeated this year. Other short 2. Catalyst Preparation and applications (1 day) C. L.
courses in catalysis have been presented before Thomas - Sun Oil Company (retired)
at Rice University, Lehigh, Berkeley and Dela- A. General principles
ware. However, our program is sufficiently dif- B. Preparation and use of non-supported catalysts
C. Preparation of catalyst supports
ferent from these others so that it is worthwhile D. Preparation of supported catalysts
to outline the philosophy, organization and logis- E. Proven catalysts and catalytic processes
tics of the course. 3. Catalyst Characterization (0.5 day) J . T. Richardson
There are two types of practitioners in cataly- A. Common mechanical properties
sis-the researchers and the users. A short course B. Measurements of surface area, pore size distribu-
should be organized from the beginning with one tion, acidity, metal surface area, effective diffusi-
vity and dispersion
or the other of these groups in mind. This course C. Survey of instrumental techniques
was aimed at the wide audience of users. These 4. Kinetics, Mechanisms and Experimental Reactors (0.5
individuals have usually a considerable practical day) J. W. Hightower - Rice University
experience in a relatively narrow area but do not A. Theory of adsorption
have a systematic and comprehensive coverage of B. Langmuir Hinshelwood kinetics
C. Discussion of some examples
the theory of catalysis and catalytic r eactor de- D. Comparisons of various experimental reactors
sign. Moreover they usually have little knowledge E . Practical suggestions
of the principles and techniques used by others. 5. Diffusional Effects (0.5 day) D. Luss
We decided upon a "how to" theme~how to A. Isothermal inter and intra-particle diffusional dis-
guise of activity and kinetics
select, prepare, characterize, test and use a cata-
B. Effect of external and internal temperature gradi-
lyst. The program was built around these five ents
points with emphasis on practical implications C. Diffusional disguise of selectivity
and applications of current theory and know how D. Expe,r imental methods of determining these-effects
and not on building an in-depth understanding 6. Poisoning of Catalysts (0.5 day) J. T. Richardson and
of the latest research developments. D. Luss
A. Mechanisms of sintering, poisoning, and fouling
In order to present a comprehensive coverage B. Determination of mechanisms by single pellet
of the subject and to expose the students to a studies
C. Effects of diffusion on poisoning and regeneration HUNTER: (Continued from page 15)
D. Shell progressive non-catalytic gas solid reactions 3) Kiefer, David M., Chenifral and Engineering News,
7. Catalytic Emission Control Devices for Automobiles "Population," Vol. 46, October 14, 1968.
(0.5 day) J. W. Hightower - Rice University 4) Levitt, Arnold, Chemical and Engineering N ews,
A. Federal standards and testing procedures "Pollution; Causes, Costs, Contrnls," Vol. 47, June 9,
B. Engine parametric effects on emissions 1969.
C. Chemistry of control systems 5) Cleaning Ou r Environment (Supplement), "The
D. Choice of possible catalysts Chemical Basis for Action,'' American Chemical
E. Cold start up, poisoning and melting problems Society, Washington, D. C., 1971.
8. Aspects of Catalytic Reactor Engineering (0.5 day) 6) "Second Interim Report," Colorado Environmental
D. Luss Commission, Decemb2r, 1971.
A. Effect of poisoning on operation of catalytic re- 7) Forrester, Jay W., T echnology Review, "Counter-
actors intuitive Behavior of Social Systems,'' Vol. 73, Num-
B. Regeneration of cokes packed reactors ber 3, January, 1971.
C. Design aspects of exothermic reactors 8) Peter, Laurence J., and Hull Raymond, The Peter
D. Sensitivity and stability Principle, Bantam Books, New York, N. Y. 4th
9. Industrial Applications (0.5 day) V. W. Weekman, Jr. Printing, 1970.
Mobil Research and Development Company
A. Modelling techniques of complex processes
B. Modelling of catalytic cracking kinetics Acknowledgements
C. Modelling of a regenerator for catalytic cracking
I would like to acknowledge the work and
processes
D. Modelling of catalytic mufflers suggestions of the other twelve senior assistants
during the past three years; Don Hedden, Craig
An important part of organizing such a course Farmer, Bob Powell, John McMartin, Jim Rob-
is to attract a sufficient number of attendees. The erts, Craig Miller, Ed Heubach, Bill Barker,
publicity for our course consisted primarily of a Chris Harris, Craig Runyan, John Hayes and
brochure, outlining the aims and details of the Steve Hammill. D
WINTER 1973 17
[ej n9 curriculum
The method for reducing curriculum informa- preceding activities category and the courses for
tion as it appears in a university catalog so that which this particular course is a prerequiste fall
it can be accepted by a CPM computer program into the succeeding activities category. If a certain
is quite easy. The individual courses are assigned course is required to be taken in a specified year
activity numbers by which the computer can rec- of study or before a specified time in a program
ognize them. An activity duration whether on a of study, the constraints can be accepted by the
semester, quarter or any other time basis is given CPM program by listing a start time or finish
to each course. The prerequisite courses fill the time for that course.
- - @ ------- - -
10 11
OUARTER NUMBER
Fig. 2 . CPM diagram of chemical engineering curriculum . Critical path activities are connected by heavy lines.
WINTER 1973 19
With this information the CPM pr ogram de- The CPM diagram is helpful in testing time feasibility
t er mines an earliest start time, latest fini sh t ime of proposed curricula and in offering a model which
and slack for each course in the particular cur- can answer some of the questions dealing with
riculum. All of the courses which compr ise t he curricula practicality.
critical path are fixed as to when they must be
• how can diffusional intrusions be detected the solution to which is in terms of overall cata-
in terms of laboratory observables? lytic effectiveness
We acknowledge two regions of diffusional
n•
if
k C
k 0 Cdx
(2)
transport in the typical porous solid catalyzed 0 0
reaction: is
1) Intra phase; diffusion of heat and mass
ri "" tanh(D (3)
within the porous catalyst with simultane-
ous reaction. ,• ~ + r) tanh<l>J
(lli)
m
where
2) Interphase: Diffusion of heat and mass
,- . k L
through boundary layers surrounding the t;, =L / ~ • Ti1ielc Modulus ; (lSi) m "' 7 .. Mass Biot :>: umb e r
catalyst pellet or extrusion. Reaction occurs "
in series with interphase (external) dif- The diffusion affected yield for consecutive re-
fusion. action is also readily analyzed by the undergradu-
ate for isothermal conditions. 2 , 4
The global ( observed) rate is that phrased in However, for nonlinear kinetics and non-iso-
terms of observables. In general, external surface thermal environments, analytical solutions are
and internal concentrations and temperatures are not to be found, and the more sophisticated ap-
beyond direct measurement. So a global rate, R 0 is proximate mathematical treatments are usually
Ro = kxg(Co) " beyond the undergraduate, or if within his grasp,
where kx is a rate coefficient based upon observed the very journey through that mathematical
rate, concentration Co and order a. The intrinsic, jungle may cause the student to lose sight of the
surface catalytic rate is, of course, a complex physics of the problem and the engineering conse-
function of surface concentrations and tempera- quences. A simple alternative exists requiring no
ture. Thus the concept of catalytic effectiveness more than the use of a slide rule, whereby key
(Thiele) was invoked and elaborated to relate the features of the more complex internal diffusion-
n = 1/2 (8)
n•2 lJ
= [ ~ -lJ 2 2Da (9)
0
2
n • --1 11 = , no solution exists (10)
1 + ~o for Da
0
> 1/4
y-
0 0
kc n-1] ..
1-f =
[ s o o
--
k a
f
n
=Da f
o
n
(5 ) ,,,
wl1ere
k C n- 1
Uu
0
=~ = Damk0hler :fombe r
g
WINTER 1973 23
so the experimental rate coefficient kx is kga and 10
the reaction order changes from n to unity. Acti-
vational energy changes from its true value when
Y/ = 1 to a small value characteristic of a mass
transfer coefficient kga,
The students readily realize however that Fig.
1, while instructive, is of little use unless ko is
known a priori to permit computation of Dao,
They soon learn that Fig. 1 is easily re-expressed T/
in terms of observables. Dividing both sides of
equation (11) by kgaC 0
Ro ko n- 1
~ = n ~ C0 = DDa 0 (12)
g O g 0 .1
Hence by replotting Fig. 1 in terms of Y/ vs
Y/ Da0 , we secure Fig. 2 which permits determina-
tion of Y/ from the observed rate R 0 , bulk con-
centration Co and a calculatable transport co-
efficient kga. Fig. 2 also teaches that the ultimate
observed rate is that of bulk mass transport, i.e., 0.001 0,01 0.1 1.0
at Y/ Da0 = 1. Aris* points out that by eq'ns (7-10)
D - _B_g_
and (5) Figure 2 obeys the equation: T/ Co - Cokga
=
s = .<!!! = ~ ,1«-a
Rll klAo - k2Bo
Selectivity ' (21)
Dividing, we secure tb.e point yield dD k2
dli k2
8
0 With no diffusional gradient
- dA = YD = 1 - ~ ¾ (14)
(15) or
...2,... . ~
S (k/k )
(
-( --;;:
A la-a ( 23)
0 2 0
kga(B - B ) • k/, - ki (16)
0
foothermal selectivity alteration is then
and solving for B, then the ratio of rates (yield)
Solving for A in (15) , substituting in (16) s1\ = [ +r-j! 0
(24)
(26)
also
~
C l
=l +Da
atid Da = Da 0 exp t e:( f- 1)] (27)
thl'.?11
thus
t = 1 +
-6H)C] ri
~ Da0 (Le)
2/J (30)
~ p 0
t = l + S ri Da where S = [
0
( - 611) C
pe~
p O
l
~
(Le)
2/3
Ro
and Le is the Lewis number D/a. "I Do.= C0 kQo
The student now chooses a value of e, and {3 Fig. 4. Non-Isothermal External Catalytic Effectiveness in terms of
as fixed. Then for a ser ies of 'Y/ Da0 values (say Observables-First Order, E 20 =
0.001 to the limiting value of unity) , he or she* We see that the chief characteristics of t he
computes t and by equation (29) the Tj -Tj Dao non-isothermal intraphase (internal) effective-
values are obtained. This simple procedure is re- ness factor are displayed by the very easily cal-
,:,y cs, Virginia , there is a co-ed Notre Dame culated external effectiveness behaviour:
WINTER 1973 25
(a) 71 values much greater than unity are the desired solution is
Da + exp 0
found for exothermic reactions. n =..,.,::..o _ __
(1 + Da ) exp 0
(b) the Arrhenius number, E is more import- 0
Which is more conveniently expressed in terms
ant than f3 in determining 71 and
of 71 at any time relative to 7/ss at final steady-
(c) at high values of the modulus 71 falls well state.
below unity. l - 17 _ exp 8 - 1
1 - nss - exp 0
Yield/ selectivity in a non-isothermal atmos-
phere is readily treated. In equations (17) and This equation teaches that the dimensionless
(23), the ratio ki/k2 at surface temperature ap- group kg a r determines the rate of approach to
pears. This ratio relative to its value at bulk steady-state. In the case of the internal effective-
temperature T 0 , is ness in transient, approach to steady-state is gov-
erned by an analogous dimensionless group
8' = p_-r
L2
·- ...¢ e · , ~
WINTER 1973 29
THE POLYMER PROGRAM AT CALTECH
R. E. COHEN AND
N. W. TSCHOEGL
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, California 91109
WINTER 1973 31
With this unusual student-faculty ratio, classes at Caltech are generally small, interpersonal relations are fos-
tered, and course programs and research activities tend to be closely interwoven.
logically complex two-phase polymer systems. ers from industrial R&D laboratories to acquaint
A study was also made of terminal chains and group members with the directions and values
their entanglements in triblock-diblock blends of high-level industrial research and develop-
in which the proportion, length, and distribution ment work. Through the seminars the members
of the terminal chains could be controlled. A of the group meet the inany well-known polymer
study of rubbers consisting of two interpenetrat- scientists who regularly pass through Caltech.
ing networks is expected to begin in the Fall of The seminars contribute to the broadening of
1972. the group's concept of polymer research beyond
Research activities are not restricted to the the study of mechanical properties and rubbers.
Polymer Laboratory. Thus, within Chemical Engi- The seminars also serve as a forum for
neering, Professors W. H. Corcoran and N. W. periodic reporting by members of the group on
Tschoegl collaborate in an effort to assess the the progress of their research. A graduate stu-
effect of mechanical deformations on diffusion dent is expected to present an average of three
through membranes. A joint effort on segmental to four talks per year and in this manner gains
motion by NMR techniques is being planned valuable experience in the art of oral expression
with Professor R. W. Vaughan. Outside of Chem- and communication. Every group member is ex-
ical Engineering, the Polymer Laboratory has pected to be sufficiently familiar with everybody
maintained close contact with Professor W. G. else's research to be able to interact and such
Knauss's group in Aeronautics whose interests interaction is encouraged. This had led to in-
lies in the field of crack propagation and frac- tensive mutual reinforcement of interest and to
ture in · elastomers. Close liaison is also main- cohesion within the group, and has sensitized
tained with the Materials Science group at the group members to the demands and advantages
Institute. Because of its small size, such inter- of the team work so often essential to successful
departmental contacts are easy to maintain at work in industry.
Caltech. The seminar program has been very success-
In the past, both Materials and Chemistry ful and has attracted interest from other groups
students have received Ph.D. or M.S. degrees at Caltech and also from outside the Campus. A
for thesis work done in the Polymer Laboratory. major advantage of the seminars is, however,
Chemistry and Chemical Engineering form a that they are normally restricted to a small
single division at Caltech, and the polymer group of about 15 people to encourage free-
courses attract an increasing number of chemistry wheeling and uninhibited discussion. D
students. Chemistry undergraduates receive cred-
it for undergraduate research performed in the
Laboratory. BOOK REVIEW: (Continued from page 29)
The most commonly used models of atmos- • Vertical Profile at Fixed Downwind Distance
pheric dispersion from continuous sources are
the Gaussian Plume Models (D. B. Turner, To develop a model suitable for analog simu-
Workbook of Atmospheric Dispersion Estimates, lation, the basic dispersion model is first written
U. S. Department of HEW, 1967). For an in- as
X • _ ___,__ _
finite line source such as might be used to simu- (ex + e) (4)
/Tn sin$ a u
z
late automotive emissions on a freeway, the
model has the following analytical form
t
+ REF
X= ~
2
{ - -]
exp t -(z-It) + exp +-
(z - H)2]
- } (1) -a
/2ir sin<j, az u 2 a} _ 2 a/ II
where
H is the effective height at which the emis-
sions occur (meters). 3
WINTER 1973 33
Using Equations (7) and (8), the analog
diagram presented in Figure 1 can be used to
compute x as a function of z for fixed q, <I>, u, <Tz,
and H . Table 1 below details the variables and
Amp l - ex - a/a*
Amp 2 - B - BI B*
Amp 3 - ex(z- H) - ex (z-H) / (ex* (z-H)*)
Amp 5 - ( z- H) - (z-H)/(z-H)*
a:.
z
0
100 200 300 400
>--~- a(Z • OI • {3 IZ• OI COMPOSITE VARIABLE
3
X + 10 X
Equation 4. CONCLUSIONS
Assuming <Tz = ax where a is a constant and
noting that The analog simulation of the dispersion of
atmospheric pollutants has been briefly examined
a ( z•O) = a(z=O ) • exp [ /:.2] , in this paper. It has been shown that the prob-
lem can be used as an effective demonstration
either x or <rz can be used as the independent in order to examine the essential features of at-
variable on the slowly operating circuit. As mospheric dispersion. In addition, the problem
indicated in Figure 3, <Tz and <r.2 are obtained by presents several more difficult scaling problems
integration and a(z = 0) = /3(z = 0) are de- for the student. The analytical nature of the
termined using solution provides, however, a ready check of the
2
d a (z =O ) = !!__ a (z•O)
(10)
simulation and thus the simulation can prove
d CJ 3
z CJ
z to be an effective student problem at several
Initial conditions on Equation (10) are chosen stages of an analog course. D
WINTER 1973 35
McGraw- Hill Presents
COMPUTER-AIDED ANALYSIS IN HEAT tion systems, modeling, communication with ma-
chines, and decision making. Students from all
TRANSFER disciplines are challenged to ask questions about
J. ALAN ADAMS and DAVID F. ROGERS, both science and technology and then guided into de-
of the United States Naval Academy. 1973, 480 veloping the skills necessary to relate technology
pages, $17.00 . to their own experience and communities.
A balanced approach between theory and analy-
sis /application, of that theory is presented for all APPLIED STATISTICAL MECHANICS:
three modes of heat transfer. A thorough de- Thermodynamic and Transport Properties
velopment of the methods for formulating mathe-
matical models in terms of non-dimensional para- of Fluids
meters is stressed. Well documented, interactive THOMAS M. REED and KEITH E. GUBBINS,
computer programs, written in the BASIC pro- both of the University of Florida. McGraw-Hill
gramming language, are an integral part of the Series in Chemical Engineering. 1973, 496 pages,
text - $18.50
With an emphasis on applications, APPLIED
METALLURGICAL THERMODYNAMICS STATISTICAL MECHANICS is an introduction
to the various ways in which statistical thermody-
DAVID R. GASKELL, University of Pennsyl- namics and kinetic theory can be applied to sys-
vania. 1973, 500 pages (tent.), $19.50 (tent.) tems of chemical and engineering interest. Pre-
This new text provides a systematic illustration sented is a fundamental, up-to-date treatment of
of the application of modern thermodynamics to statistical-mechanics with primary interest focus-
the determination of equilibria in metallurgical ed on molecular theory as a basis for correlating
system~. After discussing the basic laws and and predicting physical properties of gases and
introd1cing the ~ecessary thermodynamics func- liquids. Material on recent theoretical approaches
tions, f PPlicatio111 is made to increasingly com- such as perturbation theory and the statistical-
plex systems in :the sequence, reactions between mechanics of nonspherical molecules is included.
gases, reactions between' gases and pure con-
densed phases, .reactions ,between gases and con- AN INTRODUCTION TO ENGINEERING
densed solutions; reactioris in condensed solutions HEAT TRANSFER
and electrochemical reactions.
JOHN R. SIMONSON, The City Univer sity,
PROCESS MODELING, -SIMULATION, AND London. McGraw-Hill S eries in Mechanical Engi-
neer ing. 1973, 244 pages (tent.), $10.50 (tent.)
CONTROL FOR CHEMICAL ENGINEERS With the guidance of this step-by-step introduc-
WILLIAM L. LUYBEN, Lehigh University. Mc- tion to the subject of heat transfer, the student
Graw-Hill Series in Chemical Engineering. 1973, is exposed to almost every aspect taught at the
558 pages, $18.50 undergraduate level in engineering courses. In
Professor Luyben has devoted his book to pre- addition to the British units utilized, the new S.I.
senting only useful, state-of--the-art, applications- units are incorporated into the illustrative ex-
oriented tools and techniques most helpful for amples within the text. For the industrial reader,
understanding and solving practical dynamics the treatment covers the transfer unit approach
and control problems in chemical engineering to heat exchanger design and the electrical analog
systems. Written for the undergraduate student, network approach to radiation problems, as well
this text offers a unified, integrated treatment of as some of the latest empirical equations of con-
mathematical modeling, computer simulation, and vective heat transfer.
process control.
CONSERVATION OF MASS AND ENERGY
MAN AND HIS TECHNOLOGY JOHN C. WHITWELL and RICHARD K.
ENGINEERING CONCEPTS CURRICULUM TONER, both of Princeton University. 1973, 500
PROJECT, State University of New York. 1973, pages (tent.), $12.95 (tent.)
400 pages (tent.), $7.50 (tent.) . A' Casebook of Unique in chemical engineering literature is the
Problems will be available. treatment of degrees of freedom for material and
MAN AND HIS TECHNOLOGY introduces a energy balances. Either chemical or physical pro-
new kind of science for all students in a text cessing elements are handled in a unified manner.
that is fun to read, easy to understand, and bril- The authors have included the first law of thermo-
liant in concept. Unveiled is a humanistic view dynamics, unsteady state mass and energy bal-
of technology and change stressing "technological ances, and all pertinent physical chemistry re-
literacy" and the interaction of society, nature, quired. The modular organization of material
and the man-made world. The' reader is offered offers the instructor a wide choice for his par-
a look inside technology today including informa- ticular syllabus.
WINTER 1973 39
t+)n:I laboratory
DESIGN OF PROCESS CONTROL SYSTEMS
Using Frequency Response
And Analog Simulation Techniques
JOSEPH F. PAUL
San Fernando Valley State College
Northridge, California 91324
THE TIME REQUIRED to design control systems diffuser vanes. The detecting element has a trans-
by analog simulation can be significantly re- fer lag of time constant 1 second. We will neg-
duced if initial approximations are made using lect the time constant of the control valve. The
frequency response methods. The tendency for block diagram of the system is given in Fig. 1.
most engineers is to use only one of the above Note that any controller designed should
techniques, the one with which they are the most reduce the steady-state error to a step input at
familiar. R to an arbitrarily small value, and at the same
The object of this study is to present a method time minimize the effect of the load of less than
which will reduce the time involved in designing 10% and have reasonable stability.
a control scheme for a process control system. For a type zero system excited by a step in-
The method itself combines the use of frequency put the steady-state error is defined as follows
response methods ( Bode diagrams) and time do- A
ess = l+K (1)
main methods (analog computer simulation) to p
give the most efficient design technique. where A = magnitud,e of step, K" = position
error constant defined as lim G (s) as s ~ o.
DEVELOPMENT This steady-state error is ·equal to R-B. What
Tochemical
ILLUSTRATE THE METHOD, let us consider a
process system described by the
we are actually interested in is R-C. However,
since there is unity gain in the feed-back path
B = C in the steady-state. For our system
linear model shown in Fig. 1. The system to be K v = Kc which is the controller gain. Thus the
studied is a spray dryer used to process an emul- steady-state specification will be met by values
sion to obtain a powder. Control may be effected of Kc greater than 9. Let us now choose Kc = 10.
by regulating the feed to the diffuser vanes. The The Bode diagram of the system including
air heater consists of two non-interacting transfer controller gain, using straight line approxima-
lags of time constant 100 seconds each. The tions, is given in Fig. 2. Using proportional con-
drum behaves as three transfer lags of time trol only we would have a slope of -3 at ·cross-
constant 12.5 seconds each, and one distance
velocity lag of 2 seconds. A distance-velocity lag
of 3 seconds exists between changes in air tem-
perature at the heater and its appearance at the
Air
He:ate:r
Orum
e2s C Outlet
~ Temperat ure:
(1 T S)
Dde:cting
Eleme nt
Fig. 1. Linear Model of Chemical Process System. Fig. 2. Bode Diagram of System by straight line approximation.
WINTER 1973 41
lations shows that moving the breakpoint in . . . although simulation is the only method which
either direction will decrease the phase margin. yields exact solutions for models . . ., the use of ..
If we make the breakpoint smaller we have a the straight line Bode diagram gives ball park
higher crossover frequency which yields a small- estimates . . .
er phase margin, and if we make it larger we
are back to the situation of a crossover slope of response by developing a Bode diagram. The
-3. Thus we are at the point of maximum relative next phase was to study the dynamic operating
stability. Therefore the transfer function for the response to changes in set point and load vari-
compensated system is given as ables, and attempt to optimize the design by
varying Kc and y. The dead time was simulated
(3) by a modified fourth order Pade delay circuit.
2 3 The complete set of analog diagrams is given
(1 + .57s) (1 + 12.5s) (1 + s)
THE NEXT STEP WILL BE to simulate the system in the Figs. 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8.
on the analog computer. For this purpose the
EAI-68O analog computer was utilized. The first
phase of the study was to check the frequency
0 .1000, 0.1750,
Fig . 4 . Drum .
0.1 000, 0.1000,
0.8000, P16 0 .8000, P11 0.8000, 0.1000, 0.1750.
0.8000, P20 = 0.8000. P21 0.1000, 0.1 000.
0.8000 These integrators are run at ten times normal speed.
RESULTS
response of the system will be stable but highly although simulation is the only method which
oscillatory. yields exact solutions for models used for control
system design, the use of approximations such
The next step was to test the steady state error
as the straight line Bode diagram gives ball park
due to a step disturbance at the set point. A step
of one volt was applied and the steady state error estimates for the controller constants which are
valuable starting points for the simulation study.
was calculated as 0.098 volt which is within the
specification of 10% The strip chart recording Otherwise, one must hunt at random on the
computer until the optimum values are found,
of the test is shown in Fig. 10.
which can be time consuming and wasteful. In
this particular problem the values found by
the approximate technique turned out to be the
optimum values from the computer study. •
REFERENCES
WINTER 1973 43
PROCESS SYNTHESIS
DALE F. RUDD
University of Wisconsin
Madison, Wisconsin 53706
INTRODUCTION
In the words of Webster, synthesis is "the proper way to approach process development. In
combining of often diverse conceptions into a co- these theories of process development, each syn-
herent whole" and analysis is "an examination thesis step defines an analysis problem the solu-
of a complex, its elements and their relations." tion of which provides data required for further
Synthesis refers to the more inventive aspects of synthesis steps. Further, it became apparent that
engineering and analysis to the more scientific. this organization of alternating synthesis and
Both are required in the development of industrial analysis steps begs the development of educational
processes. material for the early stages of engineering edu-
Since World War II engineering education has cation.
moved strongly towards analysis, with the intro- In this report we examine the development of
duction of courses which analyse individual pro- a first course in engineering in which synthesis
cess operations and phenome,n a. rransport phe- and analysis are taught simultaneously. Elemen-
nomena, unit operations, process control, thermo- tary new principles of process synthesis are com-
dynamics and other engineering science courses bined with the classic analysis techniques of
greatly strengthened engineering education by material and energy balancing. Emphasis is on
showing how things are and how they work. the development of process technology rather than
Unfortunately, there was not a parallel de- on the analysis of existing processes.
velopment in the teaching of synthesis. The teach-
ing of how things ought to be rather than how
RESEARCH IN PROCESS SYNTHESIS
they are. This deficiency has been recognized for
years, but the remedy awaited the development of Research in process synthesis has been ade-
sufficiently general principles about which to or- quately reviewed elsewhere and it would be a
ganize educational material. distraction here to go into any great detail. *
The dominance of engineering science reveals However, a brief discussion of the broad ways of
a natural tilt in the educational landscape towards thinking found in the research literature is neces-
course material which possesses a natural organi- sary to set the stage for the educational develop-
zation. At the University, well organized and ments. This, then, is a most superficial review of
easily taught material rises to the surface. the emerging research leading to principles for
A course in transport phenomena has the the development of the process flow sheet. Three
natural organization of the equations of change, approaches to process synthesis are apparent;
thermodynamics has the first, second and third problem decomposition, evolution and optimiza-
laws, unit operations can be organized about the tion.
various processing operations and so it is with In process synthesis by optimization a cam-
the courses which dominate. This kept synthesis bined design is proposed which is known to be
in the background in spite of the important role redundant, containing process equipment and
synthesis plays in the practice of engineering. material flows in a greater number and diversity
Methods of synthesis were not well organized and than is reasonable. However, somewhere hidden
easily taught, and for this reason synthesis could within the combined process design is an eco-
not rise to the surface. nomically reasonable process. The desired process
In the late 1960's and early 1970's, research tlow sheet is exposed by the methods of mathe-
in process synthesis established the broad out-
lines of this field and it became apparent that a ,:, J. E. Hendry, D. F . Rudd, J . D. Seader, AIChE J .
careful interlacing of synthesis and analysis is a (to appear)
WINTER 1973 45
Engineering of Process Systems . . . research in process synthesis established the
broad outlines of this field and it became apparent
First the students become acquainted with a that a careful interlacing of synthesis and analysis
bit of the history of processing to see how chem- is a proper way to approach process development.
istry is used, how materials are separated and
how economy is reached by the reuse of material
and energy. In class we discuss the recovery of
the students learn to select the reaction sequences which
nitrogen from the atmosphere for use as a ferti-
require for each two molecules of vinyl chloride,
lizer, the conversion of vegetable protein into
meat analog foods for human consumption and a) two molecules of ethylene, one of chlorine and
the treatment of sewage at the South Lake Tahoe oxygen. This reaction path is to generate no by-
plant, the most advanced sewage treatment facility products other than water.
in the world. b) one molecule of ethylene, one of acteylene and one
of chlorine. No by-products are allowed for this
On their own, as home problems, the students path.
prepare a short history of important process
innovations. One project is to report on the events The students also learn the basic principles of eco-
which led from Sir Alexander Fleming's discovery nomic screening of the reaction paths they synthesize.
of penicillin to the massive process development The idea is that the products must be more valuable than
the reactants if a reaction path is to be of any commercial
campaign to provide enough penicillin to accom- interest.
pany the troops during Eisenhower's landing in Home problems include an analysis of the chemistry
Europe. A second project begins with this beer involved in these areas: the recycle of pickling liquor
recipe from "Hints to Brewers," 1702. waste, acrylonirite from propylene, titanium by chlorina-
tion, waste recycle in the solvay process, sodium bicarbon,-
ate by the solvay chemistry, superphosphate fertilizer,
"Thames water, taken up about Greenwich at low leaching copper ores, caustic manufacture the leBlanc
tide, when it is free of all the brackishess of the sea process, soap manufacture, nitrogen fixation, fire retard-
and has in it all the fat and sullage from this great ant production, urea synthesis, and so forth.
city of LondCJn, makes a very strong drink. It will of In summary, the students are acquainted with
itself ferment wonderfully, and after its due purga-
tion and three times stinking, it will be so strong that the chemistry of processing, synthesize alternate
several sea commanders have told me that it has often reaction paths from given chemistry and perform
fuddied their murriners" early economic screening of the chemistry.
and traces the development of the activated sludge Materials Balancing and Species Allocation
process for sewage treatment.
The students get a feel for processing, and Once the chemistry of processing is at hand,
discover the role that the engineer plays in sup- the problem arises of supplying the reactor feeds
plying society's needs for food, water and other and disposing of the reactor effluents. This leads
material items. to the next major subproblem in process synthesis,
species allocation. The purpose of species alloca-
Reaction Path Synthesis tion is to identify the routes that the several
species involved ought to take to support the
The first major subproblem in process syn- chemistry and at the same time lead to the simp-
thesis involves the selection and analysis of the lest separation problems. Given the needs of the
chemistry of processing. The chemistry links the chemistry, we allocate species for easy separation.
products of processing with cheap and readily As a trivial example, suppose we are to manufacture
available materials, and generates wastes and by- sulfur dioxide by the direct oxidation of sulfur. Air and
products with which we must contend. In this sulfur are the reactant sources and pure sulfur dioxide is
course we do not teach chemistry : we teach the needed as the product. A cold inert gas is needed to lower
the reaction temperature. Figure 1 shows two allocations,
assessment of chemical change. one recycling sulfur dioxide as the inert and the other
For example, given these reactions which lead to vinyl using nitrogen as the inert. The one allocation leads to
chloride, the need to separate nitrogen from oxygen, a difficult
problem and the other leads to the separation of sulfur
C2 H 2 + HCl • C2 H 3 Cl dioxide from Jllitrogen, an easy problem. This illustrates
C2 H ,1 + Cl 2 • C2 H 4 Cl 2 how the engineer assesses the nature of separation prob-
C2 H 4 Cl 2 • C2 H 3 Cl + HCl lems and uses this information to impose the proper
2HCI + ½ 0 2 + C2 H _1 • C2 H 4 CJ 2 + H 2 0 material flow on the emerging process flow sheet.
WINTER 1973 47
pressure, size, temperature, and other bulk prop-
erties until after the means of separation has been
established.
2. When possible reduce t he separation load by stream a::
splitting and blending. Here we reduce as much as w
I-
possible the amount of separation to be performed, I-
as is done in the blending of gasolines to each :::i
c..
desired product specifications. en
3. All other things being equal, aim to separate the u"'
more plentiful components early. This reduces the
load on the down stream units.
4. Remove the corrosive and hazardous material early. c=3
The remaining separations can then be done in less
elaborate equipment. a::
w
5. The difficult separations are best saved for last. I-
The extremely expensive separations should not be I-
...J
performed in the presence of material which need c..
not be there. en
6. All other things being equal, shy away from sepa- u"'
rations which require the use of species not norm- c+4 C3
ally present in the processing. This favors separa-
tions driven by the addition or removal of energy, Fig. 2. Sinclair-Koppers Se paration Flowsheet.
such as distillation, over those driven by the addi-
tion and removal of material not normally present Typical home work problems involve the processing
in the processing, such as extraction. of cheese whey, crushed rock screening, high purity beryl-
7. Avoid excursions in temperature and pressure, but liu.m from the oxide, detergent manufacture, ally! chloride
aim high rather than low. In distillation favor the production, the development of screening circuits and an
removal one-by-one of the more volatile· components. examination of mam~ other industrial processes.
This rule derives from the high costs of low tem-
perature and low pressure operation compared to Task Integration
pressure and temperature operation.
8. Favor the removal of products from the least harsh The skelton of the process has been discovered
environment. For example, the final products in a when the processing tasks were defined in the
distillation sequence ought to come from the top previous chapters. Many of these tasks involve
of the towers, rather than the bottoms where de- the addition and removal of energy, and these
gredation may occur.
are costly operations. The last subproblem of pro-
The application of these heuristics to a large cess synthesis introduced is task integration where
extent identifies the separation sections of indus- we free the process as much as possible from the
trial processes. For example, the student examin- purchase of heating and cooling service. We seek
ing Table 1 would arrive at these conclusions. to have one task in the process drive other tasks,
by the integration of their operation.
a) the boiling points of propane (42 ° C) and propy- Before task integration can be attempted, the
lene ( 48 ° C) are very close, as are the boiling points
elementary principles of energy balancing must
of ethane (89 ° C) and ethylene (104 ° C). Thus
the C2 splitter and the C3 splitter ought to be last be presented. We show how the heat energy added
to place the most difficult separations in that posi- to a system and the work done by a system are
tion. related to the enthalpy changes which occur in the
b) to get at the C2 amrl C3 fractions species more material passing through the system. Then, meth-
volatile and less volatile must be removed. We ods of estimating the enthalpy change caused by
favor the removal of the more volatile methane
and hydrogen to raise the temperature of coolant temperature change, phase change, and chemical
needed to drive subsequent distillations. This will change are presented. This gives the quantitative
reduce utilities costs substantially. background required for the understanding of the
c) the ethylene and propylene ought to be tower top energy management principles to be discussed .
products to insure the removal of degradation pro- We show how energy management principles
ducts.
are used to supply heat to endothermic reactions,
These heuristics explain the gross features of the to remove heat from exothermic reaction, and to
Sinclair-Koppers process the flow sheet of which is shown utilize the energy of product recovery. For ex-
in Figure 2. ample, the endothermic reaction of calcining lime-
This kind of heuristic reasoning leads to an under-
standing of the separation sections of a wide variety of
stone can be driven by matching it with an exo-
processes. thermic reaction, the combustion of coal : the be-
MCD
Cl2-DEC
MCD
lem in task integration discussed in this chapter. DCD
DCD
HC\"CLl
'
. ~ca:-0:
Hz S"'
~ -c'
HCL,CL2
OCO MCO
WINTER 1973 51
ticularly HCl, causes very high equipment and utility Science aims to analyse natural phenomena, and
costs. The loss of chlorine, as in Flowsheets 1 and 2 engineering aims synthesize from natural phen-
makes the profit for this process dependent on reactor
omena preferred situations. For example, while
conversion and chlorine cost.
Flowsheet 5 shows the same· independence of conver- it may be sufficient for a scientist to develop an
sion as Flowsheet 3. The profit is less due to solvent costs understanding of the phenomena of ice formation,
and the additional separator. the engineer ought to be concerned with use of his
A profit nearly as high as that for Flowsheet 3 is ob- knowledge in the development, say, of an artifact
tained for Flowsheet 6. Flowsheet 6 utilizes water to
which economically can produce fresh water from
remove hydrogen chloride from the vapors leaving the
phase separator. Wet chlorine returning to the reactor the sea by freezing.
inlet is dried by contacting concentrated sulfuric acid. The dominance of science oriented courses in
The low cost of the solvent, water, and the fact that the undergraduate education is caused by the very
water need not be regenerated make this alternative very important role analysis has in engineering, and is
attractive. However, the corrosive nature of the hydrogen
also caused by the availability of well organized
chloride-water mixture and the sulfuric acid-water mix-
ture require more expensive materials of construction. and carefully planned text material in these areas.
The danger of water entering the reactor must also be The natural organization of methods of analysis
considered. If the reactor and separ.a tors are constructed lends itself to course development and text prepa-
of carbon steel, any traces of water in the presence of ration.
the hydrogen chloride reaction product would lead to
rapid failure of these units due to corrosion.
The absence of the organizing influence of
Flowsheet 6 has a higher profit than Flowsheet 3 at basic principles of synthesis is possibly the major
low conversion. This because of the large amounts of reason why analysis tended to dominate education.
decane solvent required in Flowsheet 3 for low chlorine It remains to be seen if the course described will
conversions. bring the proper balance between analysis and
Flowsheets 7 and 8 are the special cases when con-
synthesis in engineering education. •
version is complete. Flowsheet 7 has the advantage of
only requiring two separators and no recycle. The high
conversions using stoichiometric feed ratios lead how- LETTERS: (Continued from page 3)
ever, to the production of large amounts of DCD. Hence,
the profit for this alternative is low. A little checking has revealed that the non-zero value
Flowsheet 8 represents the situation when large ex- is the result of a reformulation of steam table data pub~
cesses of decane are utilized. Complete conversion of lished by the ASME in 1967.1 Recognizing that a stable
chlorine is achieved, hence no separation is required for liquid-vapor equilibr ium can't exist below the triple point
its recycle. A small amount of DCD appears in the temperature of 32.018° F, the reference conditions were
product. These advantages are offset by the costs asso- changed so as to assign the value zero to the entropy
ciated with the separation and recycling of large amounts and internal energy of the saturated liquid phase at the
of decane. triple point. This, of course, forces the asso~iated enthalpy
In summary, three regions, exist when comparing the to be (Pv) units greater or about 0.0003 Btu/ Ihm. One
eight flowsheets over wide ranges of conversion. At low can certainly estimate the conditions for the metastable
conversions process Flowsheet 6, which utilizes water as vapor-liquid equilibrium at precisely 32° F through simple
a means to separate HCI and chlorine, is best. At inte·r - extrapolation and obtain values of about - 0.0181 Btu/ lbm
mediate conversion levels, process Flowsheet 3 is best. and -0.0178 Btu/lbm, respectively, for the internal energy
Process 3 utilizes the feed and recycle decane as a solvent and enthalpy of the liquid phase The error in the Com-
for absorbing chlorine from the waste hydrogen chloride bustion Engineering tables, then, is the omission of the
stream. For high levels of conversion, process Flowsheet minus sign together, perhaps, with out spelling out the
1, which discards unconverted chlorine, is optimal. convention not stating (as does the refer ence above) that
the first entry in the saturation table corresponds rigor-
CONCLUSION ously to a metastable state. At least one recently published
text 2 on chemical engineering thermodynamics has copied
An essential difference between the aims of this error, but the new edition of "Steam Tables" by
education in science and in engineering ought not Keenan, Keyes, et al, 3 does note both the negative values
and metastability below the triple point.
be lost. Herbert A. Simon states in the Sciences Kenneth R. Jolls
of the Artificial Iowa State University
Historically and traditionally, it has been the task of
the science disciplines to teach about natural things: 1. "Thermodynamic and Transport Properties of
how they are and how they work. It has been the Steam," American Society of Mechanical Engineers (1967).
task of the engineering schools to teach about arti- 2. Balzhiser, R. E., M. R. Samuels and J. D. Eliassen,
ficial things: how to make artifacts that have the de- "Chemical Engineering Thermodynamics," Prentice-Hall,
sired properties and how to design. . . . Everyone Inc (1972).
designs who devises courses of action aimed at chang- 3. Keenan, J. H ., F. G. Keyes, P. G. Hill and J. G.
ing situations into preferred ones. Moore, "Steam Tables," John Wiley & sons, Inc. (1969).
They're Sun Oil recruiters . other kind of blind . It's just that in see Earl Pearce , Ernie Harvey,
You might meet one of them our work, color or race or religion or Joe Pew or Harley Andrews. Your
face-to -face in a campus job sex (within certain limitations) Placement Director will know when
interview. · doesn't have anytfi ing to do with it. they 'll be on campus .
If you do , they 'll tell you straight Then about the industry. Sure , For more information , or a copy
about the petroleum industry, Sun there 's some pollution , but we 're of our Career Guide , write SUN OIL
Oil Company and job opportunities . working and spending like sin to COMPANY, Human Resources Dept.
Any other way, and you took a minimize it. We 're also necessary. CED, 1608 Walnut Street,
job with Sun , you probably wouldn 't Without gas , oil and grease for fuel , Philadelphia , Pa . 1 9 1 0 3 ~
stay very long . power and lubrication America
Take Ernie (he 's black) . He 'll tell would be in a mess. SUNOCO
.
you being black doesn 't make very Another point. Ou r industry is
much difference at Sun . He could responsible for nearly 1 ½ million
An Equal Opportunity
suggest that sometimes it helps , jobs . That 's a lot of opportunity. Employer MI F
citing the recent action of placing 25 So-if you 've got the urge to
million dollars of grnup insurance get into petroleum, and want to
with an all-black company. check out one of the industry's
Sun's not color-blind , or any exciting, progressive companies ,
energy
The energy to keep straining toward your chosen goal-and even
as you attain it, look forward to the ones beyond .
The energy to explore, evaluate, create , bring needed changes.
Energy to burn, figuratively - that wealth possessed by the
young , in mind no less than body.
Energy to burn , literally, because ideas-freedom , equality, well-being ,
conservation of our natural environment-must be turned into
realities-food , shelter, warmth , access, econom ic independence
and the physical means to accomplish our goals.
Atlantic Richfield is an energy company-in all these ways. One of the
nation 's thirty leading industrial corporations, and one of the
ten companies producing most of our energy needs. A company that
is forward-looking in management. Imaginative in organization and
operation . Open to fresh thinking . Responsible in outlook.
While our spec ific requirements continually change, we typically
offer opportunities to financial and systems analysts, accountants,
auditors, engineers, geologists, geophysicists, sales representatives,
agronomists and programmers.
We invite your interest. See our represen tative on campus or your
Placement Director.
AtlanticRichfieldCompany
An equal opportunity employer M/F.
<•