Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PLAINTIFF,
vs.
28 U.S.C. § 1367
NOW COME the Plaintiff ANUCHA BROWNE SANDERS and the Defendants
MADISON SQUARE GARDEN, L.P., ISIAH LORD THOMAS III, and JAMES L. DOLAN,
through the undersigned attorneys, and respectfully submit this Proposed Pretrial Conference
Order Pursuant to Local Civil Rule 16(d) for the Court’s consideration.
A pretrial hearing was held in this case on November 8, 2022, wherein the following proceedings
Plaintiffs:
Defendants:
Alithia C. Acosta
Paul Kancuzewski
1332(a)(1), because the plaintiff and defendants are citizens of different states and the amount in
controversy exceeds $75,000. Jurisdiction of this Court is also proper under Title VII, 42 U.S.C.
§ 2000e-5(f)(3), and 28 U.S.C. § 1331. The Court additionally has supplemental jurisdiction over
the Executive Law and the Administrative Code claims pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1367.
3. PLEADINGS: The following pleadings (with the modifications contained in this order)
have been allowed: complaint (as amended November 10, 2006) on behalf of the plaintiff;
answer on behalf of defendants to each complaint. The answers filed to the original complaints
A. Plaintiff:
A. Anucha Browne Sanders began her employment with Madison Square Garden (“MSG”)
in November 2000 as a marketing executive for the New York “Knicks”, a National
was to market the Knicks’ team brand; she was also responsible for the media and
Browne Sanders was hired by Stephen Mills, MSG’s Executive Vice-President for
Franchise Operations. She reported to Mills, who had primary responsibility for
evaluating her job performance and recommending any promotions and salary
adjustments.
B. On March 11, 2002, Mills was promoted to President, MSG Sports Team Operations. On
that same date, Brown Sanders was promoted to Senior Vice-President, Marketing
Business Operations, making her the only female member of the Knicks’ senior
management team and one of the most powerful female executives in pro sports in the
United States. Her responsibilities were increased: she became responsible for the day-to-
day management of the business side of the Knick’s front office; she served as the team’s
chief marketing officer, and she acted as the primary liaison between the Knicks and the
NBA; and she oversaw all of the Knick’s business activities and revenue streams,
C. In this new role, Browne Sanders continued to report to Mills. In her performance
reviews for 2002 and 2003, Browne Sanders received an overall rating of “5”, the highest
ranking on a 1 to 5 scale.
D. On December 22, 2003, Mr. Isaiah Thomas was hired as President of Basketball
Operations. He was given a multi-year contract until July 2007 and became part of
MSG’s Office of the Chairman, a five-member group of MSG’s most senior managers
led by James L. Dolan, MSG’s Chairman, and President and Chief Executive Officer of
Cablevision, the parent company of the Madison Square Garden and the Knicks. In this
position, Thomas was responsible for overseeing the coaches, players, and other Knicks
team personnel at the MSG Training Center located in New York. Thomas’ office was at
did not directly report to Thomas, she was reported to him and was responsible for
difficulties at work. Thomas humiliated her with sexual comments, profanity, and
unwanted touching.
F. Speaking directly to her, Thomas repeatedly referred to Browne Sanders as a “bitch” and
complained to Mills on multiple occasions about Thomas’ conduct, and she told Thomas
that he should act like a professional and to treat her with respect.
G. On March 23, 2004, Frank Murphy, a Senior Vice President of Basketball Operations,
came into Brown Sanders’ office to discuss player appearances. While Brown Sanders
was sitting at her desk, Murphy stood over her and started yelling at her: “I don’t like the
way I’ve been treated here for two years, and now you are going to pay.” He referred to
her as a “fucking bitch”. Browne Sanders told him to leave her office and called Thomas
their conversation, Thomas told Brown Sanders, “I’ll fucking handle it.”
H. Browne Sanders met with Mills and Thomas to discuss this conflict. Browne Sanders was
told by Mills to accommodate Thomas; she was told that this was his working style, as
well as things like, “Oh, that's just the way Isiah is.”
I. During the 2003-04 season, the Knicks qualified for the playoffs with a39–43 record but
J. In October 2004, Thomas asked Petra Pope, the head of the Knick’s cheerleaders, to go
into the referees’ locker room before the game and “make them happy.” Pope informed
Browne Sanders of this, which Pope explained she understood to mean that she was
being told to flirt with the referees. Pope told Browne Sanders that this was not the first
time that Thomas had asked her to do it, that she was uncomfortable with Thomas’
instructions and that she did not want to continue doing it. Browne Sanders reported this
to Mills.
K. After a Knick’s game on December 29, 2004, Thomas embraced Browne Sanders, who
pulled away. She walked away upset and passed Jeff Nix, the Knick’s Assistant Manager,
in the hallway. He caught up to her and asked her what was wrong. She told Nix that
Thomas had just told her that he was “in love” with her and compared his feelings to the
movie Love and Basketball.1 He told Browne Sanders to report the incident and she
L. In the early part of 2005, Brown Sanders received a performance evaluation for the
calendar year 2004. Mills assigned Browne Sanders an overall performance rating of 4 on
Brown Sanders received a bonus of $76,000.00, which represented over 35% of her 2004
salary. On April 6, 2005, she received an adjustment in her salary which raised her annual
base salary from approximately $213,000 to $250,000; this raise was retroactive to
January 1, 2005.
M. The Knicks ended their 2004-05 season with a 33–49 record and out of playoff
contention.
N. On May 11, 2005, Browne Sanders met with Peter Olsen, an MSG consultant who Mills
asked to help Thomas build his organization. Among other things, Mills specifically
asked Olsen to speak with Thomas about the use of “locker room language” in the
1 Love & Basketball is a 2000 American romantic drama film starring Omar Epps and Sanaa Lathan. The film tells
the story of Quincy McCall (Epps) and Monica Wright (Lathan), two next-door neighbors in Los Angeles,
California who are pursuing their basketball careers before eventually falling for each other.
workplace. During the meeting, Browne Sanders told Olsen that Thomas had said to her
that he was in love with her. She also told Olsen that Thomas should be given sexual
harassment training.
O. During the summer of 2005, Stephon Marbury, a player on the Knicks, called Dan
Hassan Gonsalves, a cousin of Marbury’s who Browne Sanders had been ordered to hire.
During the conversation, Marbury referred to Browne Sanders as a “black bitch” and
stated about Browne Sanders “fuck that black bitch, she ain’t shit and we’ll see what
happens this year.” Gladstone memorialized this conversation in an email that he sent to
Browne Sanders. Even though Browne Sanders forwarded this email to Mills, he did
P. On October 30, 2005, at a Knick’s practice open to fans, Thomas said, in Browne
Sanders’ presence, that she was “beautiful”, that she was “easy on the eyes”, that it was
“distracting to work with someone who was so attractive”, and that he was “not getting
any love from her.” These unwelcome comments, which humiliated Browne Sanders,
Q. In late November 2005, members of Browne Sander’s staff told her that Gonsalves was
making inappropriate and graphic comments of a sexual nature to female members of her
staff. In one example, a staff member told Browne Sanders that Gonsalves had said to
her, “I want you to fuck me. When are you coming to my apartment?” and had sent her a
text message that read “When can I stick it in.” Another member of Browne Sanders’
staff told her that, while she was an MGS intern, Marbury had had sexual relations with
her in his car when she was drunk and “out of it;” she said it was consensual but
explained to Browne Sanders that she felt that she could not say no because of who
Marbury was. Although Browne Sanders had previously discussed Gonsalves’ and
Marbury’s conduct with Mills, she also took it up with John Moran, MGS’s Vice
for violating MSG’s sexual harassment policy with relation to his graphic and
inappropriate comments to Browne Sanders’ staff. However, neither Moran nor anyone
else at MSG investigated Marbury’s derogatory and sexual comments about Browne
Sanders or his conduct with respect to the intern, who continued to work in her staff. At
this time, Browne Sanders was threatened by Thomas that he would spread rumors of her
having an affair with Nix if she continued to pursue sexual harassment claims.
Sanders, placed his arm on her shoulder and attempted to kiss her on the cheek. When
Browne Sanders pulled away and did not allow him to kiss her, Thomas said to her, “No
love today?” The next day, Browne Sanders sent an email to Mills detailing this incident.
S. On December 22, 2005, counsel for Browne Sanders met with counsel for MSG. At that
meeting, Browne Sanders’s counsel stated that Browne Sanders had been subject to
sexual harassment and provided information regarding her claims. Shortly after that
complaint. She was informed that, while the investigation was pending, she would be
prohibited from coming into her office or to Madison Square Garden. However, the
individuals that she had accused of harassment, including Thomas, were allowed to
continue working.
T. MSG’s internal investigation was concluded on January 13, 2006. The outcome of the
investigation stated that that “most of Browne Sanders’ allegations were not confirmed,”
and stated that Browne Sanders had exhibited a “poor relationship and difficulty
interacting with Mills and other members of MSG management,” and that Browne
management style.”
sessions with a qualified expert in order to sensitize him further with regards to the
concerns that his conduct could raise in a corporate environment and in light of company
policy.” On that same date, counsel for MSG informed counsel for Browne Sanders that
the investigation into her allegations had been completed and that her allegations were
not supported. MSG’s counsel also said that MSG had decided to “separate” Browne
Sanders effective immediately and that Browne Sander’s attorney should inform her of
her dismissal. The decision to fire Browne Sanders was made by Dolan. Dolan fired
Browne Sanders without consulting counsel, without talking to her supervisor, or reading
V. On January 24, 2006, Browne Sanders filed this action. MGS and Thomas, through their
attorneys, made statements to the press claiming that Browne Sanders claims were
“fabricated and outrageous” and that they constituted a “blatant attempt … to get a large
sum of money from MSG by taking advantage of the celebrity status of our client.
“Because of these statements and more like them issued by MSG and Thomas, Browne
Sanders had a tremendous amount of difficulty finding employment after she was fired.
She finally obtained a contract with a non-profit organization, making less than half of
what she had earned at MSG, At the end of the 2005–06 season, the Knicks had the
W. On June 22, 2006, the Knicks fired their coach, and Dolan replaced him with Thomas.
They ended the 2006-07 season with a 33–49 record. The Knicks went on to post an
eighth consecutive losing season in 2008 and tied the franchise mark for their worst
Basketball Operations. Two weeks later, Thomas was fired as head coach. During his
tenure as head coach of the Knicks, Thomas posted an overall winning percentage
X. Browne Sanders seeks compensatory damages for emotional distress and mental resulting
from the hostile work environment described herein, as well front, and back pay for being
fired in retaliation for asserting her rights. She also seeks punitive damages against the
defendants.
Plaintiff seeks 10 million dollars in punitive damages for allowing a hostile work
environment because of her sex, suffering sexual harassment, and ignoring plaintiff’s complaints
of discrimination, Madison Square Garden and Isaiah Lord Thomas III discriminated against
plaintiff in the terms and conditions of her employment on the basis of her sex in violation of:
1. The New York State Human Rights Law, New York Executive Law § 296 et seq, the
Administrative Code of the City of New York § 8-107 et seq, and Title VII, Title VII
of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42 U.S.C. § 2000e et seq.; and
2. MSG and Thomas acting intentionally with malice and/or reckless indifference to
Plaintiff also seeks 6 million dollars for defendants’ retaliation, forcing plaintiff to stop
working and terminating plaintiff employment. Madison Square Garden retaliated against
plaintiff in the terms and conditions of her employment for opposing unlawful employment
1. The New York State Human Rights Law, New York Executive Law § 296 et seq, the
Administrative Code of the City of New York § 8-107 et seq, and Title VII, Title VII
of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42 U.S.C. § 2000e et seq.; and
2. Plaintiff is now suffering and will continue to suffer irreparable injury and monetary
and retaliatory treatment of her, reputational damage, and all earnings she would have received
but for defendants' discriminatory and retaliatory treatment, including, but not limited to, wages,
Y. Defendants
The position of Defendants is that the sexual harassment investigation showed that Mrs.
Browne Sanders’ allegations were unsupported, and that MSG had decided to fire Browne
Sanders because she was unable to function effectively in her position, she had poor interactions
with MSG's senior management and the organization could not function effectively if she
Defendant
Madison Square Garden contends that Mrs. Sanders was fired by the following acts: (1)
interfere with an ongoing investigation into her alleged accusation of sexual harassment; (2)
requested six (6) million dollars in order to remain silent in an attempt to bribe upper
management of Madison Square Garden; (3) had difficulty with the financial aspects of her
endeavors to the point she received retraining; and (4) she stated to Mr. Mills she was quitting
her job and was told she could remain in her current position until she found another job.
Mrs. Anucha Browne Sanders began working for MSG in 2000 as the Knicks' Vice President
of Marketing. In the spring of 2002, Browne Sanders was promoted to Senior Vice President,
Marketing and Business Operations. In that role, Browne Sanders reported to Steve Mills,
On December 22, 2003, Thomas was named President of Basketball Operations for the
Knicks. On February 20, 2004, many of the Knicks players went out to celebrate Marbury's
birthday and stayed out late. On February 21, 2004, the Knicks held a community
relations/marketing event that was organized by Browne Sanders and attended by many of the
Knicks' players. On or about the time of the events described in the preceding paragraph, the
the harassment and discrimination claims that Browne Sanders alleged, soon after MSG
commenced an investigation.
On January 19, 2006, counsel for MSG called counsel for Browne Sanders and said that
MSG had completed its investigation of Browne Sanders' discrimination and harassment
complaint. After the result of the investigation MSG's counsel decided to "separate" Browne
Dispute
1. Ms. Anucha Browne Sanders began her employment with Madison Square
Garden (MSG) in November 2000 as a marketing executive for the New York “Knicks”,
2. Her primary responsibility was to market the Knicks’ team brand; responsible for
the media and communications programs of the team, game presentation, and events
management. Browne Sanders was hired by Stephen Mills, MSG’s Executive Vice-
4. Stephen Mills primary responsibility was to evaluate her job performance and
6. She was member of the MSG senior management team and one of the most
7. Her responsibilities were the day-to-day management of the marketing side of the
Knicks’ front office; she served as the team’s chief marketing officer, and she acted as
the primary liaison between the Knicks and the NBA; and she oversaw all of the Knicks’
8. Ms. Browne Sanders continued to report to Mills and her performance reviews for
2002 and 2003 received an overall rating of “5”, the highest ranking on a 1 to 5 scale.
9. On December 22, 2003, Mr. Isaiah Thomas was hired as President of Basketball
Operations.
10. Mr. Thomas became part of MSG’s Office of the Chairman, a five-member
group of MSG’s most senior managers led by James L. Dolan, MSG’s Chairman, and
President and Chief Executive Officer of Cablevision, the parent company of the
11. Mr. Thomas responsibilities were overseeing the coaches, players, and other
Knicks team personnel at the MSG Training Center located in New York. (Ex).
12. Mr. Thomas’ office was at MSG’s headquarters in Manhattan, where Browne
Sanders worked.
discuss a conflict between her and Mr. Thomas over their respective job responsibilities.
After a Knicks’ game on December 29, 2004, Thomas embraced Browne Sanders, who
pulled away. She addressed the incident with Jeff Nix, the Knicks’ Assistant Manager, in
the hallway.
15. In first trimester of 2005, Brown Sanders received a performance evaluation for
16. In that evaluation performance, Mr. Mills assigned Browne Sanders an overall
17. In February 2005, Brown Sanders received a bonus of $76,000.00, over 35% of
18. On April 6, 2005, Ms. Sanders received an adjustment in her salary which raised
her annual base salary from approximately $213,000 to $250,000; this raise was
19. On May 11, 2005, Browne Sanders met with Peter Olsen, an MSG consultant who
20. Mr. Mills specifically asked Olsen to speak with Thomas about the use of “locker
21. Olsen recommended that all employees should receive sexual harassment training.
22. On October 30, 2005, at a Knicks’ practice open to fans, Thomas said, in Browne
Sanders’ presence, that she was “beautiful”, that she was “easy on the eyes”, that it was
“distracting to work with someone who was so attractive”, and that he was “not getting
Marbury had had consensual sexual relations with her in his car.
24. Ms. Browne Sanders discussed Marbury’s conduct with Mills and with Mr. John
Browne Sanders, placed his arm on her shoulder and attempted to kiss her on the cheek.
Ms. Browne Sanders pulled away and did not allow him to kiss her. Mr. Thomas said to
her, “No love today?” The next day, Browne Sanders sent an email to Mills detailing this
26. On December 22, 2005, a counsel for Browne Sanders met with counsel for MSG.
At that meeting, Browne Sanders’s counsel stated that Browne Sanders had been subject
27. After the meeting with Ms. Sanders counsel, MGS began an internal investigation
28. Ms. Sanders was instructed not to utilize her office in Madison Square Garden
while the investigation was ongoing but was allowed to continue working at another
office place.
29. Mr. Thomas was allowed to continue working while the investigation while it was
being conducted.
31. The outcome of the investigation stated that that “most of Browne Sanders’
relationship and difficulty interacting with Mills and other members of MSG
management,” and that Ms. Sanders and Thomas had a “number of business
33. On January 19, 2006, MGS’s General Counsel drafted a memorandum addressed
34. The memorandum recommended that Thomas receive “one-on-one sessions with
a qualified expert in order to sensitize him further with regards to the concerns that his
35. On January 19, 2006, counsel for MSG informed counsel for Browne Sanders that
the investigation into her allegations had been completed and that her allegations were
not supported. MSG’s counsel also stated that MSG had decided to “separate” Browne
Sanders effective immediately and that Browne Sander’s attorney should inform her of
her dismissal.
7. Witnesses
A. Plaintiff’s witnesses
1) Mrs. Anucha Browne-Sanders – Will testify as to the hostile work environment and
sexual harassment against her by MSG employees that led to the retaliation from
2) Mr. Jonathan Schindel – Will testify that he Attest to observing inadequate comments
3) Mr. Stephon Marbury – Will testify to the name calling towards Mrs. Browne and
4) Robert Levy – Will testify that he Attest to observing inadequate comments Thomas
5) Mr. Jeffrey Nix – Will testify of tension between Mrs. Browne and Mr. Thomas as
Here identify all witnesses and summarize their testimony in one line.
B. Plaintiff Case-in-Chief
Direct Examination
1) Mr. Stephen Mills – will testify as to the hiring of Mrs. Browne Sanders, her
4) Karin Bucholz –
5) John Moran –
Here identify all witnesses and summarize their testimony in one line.
D. Defendants’ Case-in-Chief
Direct Examination
8. Exhibits
Plaintiff(s):
5- Email from Anucha Brown to John Moran with carbon copy (“cc”) to Steve Mills
6- Email from Gary Wrinkler to Anucha Brown from Dec. 13, 2005, at 12:31PM.
Defendant(s):
1- Employment Contract.
Copies of listed exhibits must be provided to opposing counsel and any pro se party no
later than 30 days before trial. The objections contemplated by Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(3) shall be
filed with the clerk and served by hand delivery or facsimile no later than 14 days after the
9. The plaintiff(s) shall file a trial brief with the court on or before November 5, 2022. The
defendant(s) shall file a trial brief with the court on or before November 5, 2012.
10. If a jury trial: The parties are ORDERED to file any requested voir dire questions and
any proposed jury instruction, together with citations of law thereon, ON OR BEFORE TWO
THE COURT ON MOTION OF EITHER PARTY. Trial counsels are DIRECTED to review
the jury questionnaire used in this court and to avoid any duplication of matters addressed therein
11. All exhibits shall be marked prior to trial with labels which are available from the clerk's
office. In addition to the original exhibits marked for introduction, each party shall have
available copies of each photo-statically reproducible exhibit as follows: (1) one copy for each
opposing party, and (2) one copy for the court which shall be contained in a notebook with each
exhibit tabbed in the order which counsel expects to introduce the exhibit.
12. It is ORDERED that all of the allowances and agreements contained in this order be, and
the same are hereby, binding upon all parties in this case unless this order is hereafter modified
by the court.
MADISON SQUARE GARDEN, L.P., ISIAH LORD THOMAS III, and JAMES L. DOLAN,
respectfully request from this Honorable Court that it adopt this Proposed Pretrial Conference
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED.
DATED this 10th day of November 2022.
BY THE COURT:
___________________________
APPROVED:
P.O. Box 2999 Sect Cobo Station P.O. Box 1340 Ashford Ave. Station
jose.acevedo@lex.inter.edu alithia.acosta@lex.inter.edu
/s/ Giselle M. Rios Nieves /s/ Paul Kanczuzewski
giselle.rios@lex.inter.edu paul.kanczuzewski@lex.inter.edu
natalie.trinidad@lex.inter.edu jose.rivmelendez@lex.inter.edu
jean.bermudez@lex.inter.edu jean.vizcarrondo@lex.inter.edu