Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I
Introduction the classical Chinese texts, and does not fit neatly into
nterstitial cystitis (IC) is a chronic inflammation a single TCM syndrome. It is frequently diagnosed by
of the bladder wall. It is a debilitating condition practitioners as damp‑heat in the Bladder and treated
that can affect many areas of a person’s life and in the same way as bacterial cystitis. The confusion
cause a great deal of emotional stress. It is sometimes between bacterial cystitis and interstitial cystitis can
referred to as chronic urethral syndrome (CUS) or also often lead practitioners to prescribe incorrect
painful bladder syndrome (PBS), although IC is now lifestyle advice that makes the condition worse.
the medically accepted term. There are an estimated For example, many patients are told by their health
400,000 people in the UK with IC, 90 per cent of professionals to drink copious amounts of cranberry
whom are female. All age groups can be affected, juice, as they have heard this is good for cystitis. This
from children to the elderly, but it most commonly well‑meaning advice is likely to worsen symptoms of
affects people between 20 and 50 years of age (COB IC in most patients.
Foundation Handbook, 2008). This study attempts to investigate the causative
There is no universally-recognised clinical factors involved in IC and look for commonalities
definition of interstitial cystitis (Imamov et al., 2007). between patients’ symptoms. It investigates the
No laboratory tests or biopsy results are considered effects of IC on a patient’s life and the effectiveness
confirmatory, and diagnosis is therefore by exclusion. of acupuncture in its treatment. The study uses case
The symptoms are urinary frequency, urgency and histories and patient data from the practice of Toni
usually pain. There are many Western medical Tucker, a U.K.‑based practitioner who specialises in
treatments for IC because no single treatment has the treatment of IC. It is hoped that this research will
proved successful for everyone. A drug that reduces help practitioners develop a deeper understanding of
one patient’s symptoms may have no effect on another IC, so that they can experience greater clinical success
patient. There is no known cure for IC. with this difficult condition.
There are few studies of the effectiveness of
acupuncture in treating IC. Those that do exist show IC and Western medicine
positive results, and cases have been documented of To make a diagnosis of IC the first thing that is ruled out
patients whose symptoms were so severe that they is a bacterial urinary tract infection (UTI). If there are
had been scheduled to have their bladders removed, repeated episodes of symptoms without the presence
and yet were cured of IC with acupuncture treatment of bacteria a cystoscopy is usually performed to rule
(Tucker, 2004). out bladder stones or tumours and make a diagnosis
The problem with treating IC with acupuncture lies of IC. In some patients there are small lesions on the
in the complexity of the diagnosis. IC is not described in wall of the bladder called Hunner’s Ulcers, although
Journal of Chinese Medicine • Number 94 • October 2010 An Investigation into the Treatment of Interstitial Cystitis with Acupuncture 27
this is only true for around 10 per cent of IC patients success and only work in a small percentage of patients.
(whose IC is most severe), and therefore is not a reliable For example the drug Elmiron, the only drug specifically
diagnostic criterion. developed for IC, has been found to reduce symptoms of
Symptoms of IC can be caused by radiation therapy urgency and pain by 50 per cent, but only in 32 per cent of
for cancer or from spinal injuries. However, this paper patients (Nickel, 2005). Other drugs have similar, or lower,
discusses the most common type of IC which has no success rates. Some patients try all the various treatments
known biomedical aetiology. The main theories in Western only to find that none relieve their symptoms. Many of
medicine regarding the aetiology and pathomechanisms the drugs have serious side effects, for example Elmiron
involved in IC are as follows: can cause liver problems, nausea, dizziness and hair loss.
• The glycosaminoglycan (GAG) layer that lines the In some cases patients are prescribed long periods of
bladder and protects the underlying membranes from antibiotics.
urine becomes damaged either from infection, radiation
therapy, surgery or other unknown agent. IC and Chinese medicine
• A low level of bacteria, undetectable by urine test, causes From a TCM perspective IC tends to be categorised as
inflammation of the lining of the bladder. Patients are a mixed pattern, involving either full or empty heat or
often given long courses of antibiotics, which rarely dampness and an underlying deficiency of the Spleen and
improve the condition. This suggests either that there are or Kidneys. Many cases of IC, however, are of a purely
no bacteria, that the bacteria are resistant to antibiotics, deficient nature. Maciocia (2008) lists the main patterns
or that the bacteria have embedded into the bladder associated with IC as follows:
wall where the antibiotics cannot reach them.
• A viral infection attacks and causes damage to the • Spleen qi and Kidney yang deficiency with yin fire
bladder. • Spleen qi and Kidney yang deficiency with dampness
• The body attacks itself in an autoimmune process. This • Spleen qi and Kidney yang deficiency with qi
pathomechanism is supported by the fact that many stagnation
patients with IC have allergies (to food, chemicals, • Spleen qi and Kidney yang deficiency with blood stasis
pollen etc.), and generally have oversensitive immune • Kidney yin deficiency with empty heat
systems. This view is supported by some urologists
and immunologists: ‘Based on clinical presentations, Tucker (2004) adds more patterns to this list:
epidemiology, pathology and laboratory findings and
treatment response, there is an important correlation • Deficiency of zheng qi/Spleen – Lung vacuity
among interstitial cystitis and rheumatic, autoimmune • Stagnation of Liver qi and Liver stagnant fire
and chronic inflammatory diseases.’ (Lorenzo and • Spleen qi sinking/Spleen vacuity
Gómez, 2004). Van de Merwe (2007) also supports • Stomach and Spleen vacuity cold
this view: ‘No data support a direct causal role of • Bi syndrome, blockage and interference with circulation
autoimmune reactivity in the pathogenesis of interstitial of qi and blood in the channels and collaterals, caused
cystitis. Indirect evidence, however, does support a by injury to the lower spine and structures of the pelvic
possible autoimmune nature of interstitial cystitis, such floor
as the strong female preponderance and the clinical • General disharmony amongst the zangfu
association between interstitial cystitis and other
known autoimmune diseases within patients and their Generally the Spleen is considered of vital importance
families.’ in IC. Li Dong Yuan’s Treatise on the Spleen and Stomach
discusses how pathology of the Spleen and Stomach can be
There are several medical treatments for IC: analgesics responsible for many diseases. In the following quotation
(such as paracetamol, tramadol and gabapentin), muscle he explains how a weak Spleen can lead to dampness and
relaxants, antihistamines (such as Atarax) and drugs that heat in the lower jiao:
repair the GAG layer of the bladder such as Elmiron and
Cystistat. These are administered either in tablet form, or ‘One function of the Spleen is to control water liquids in
in the case of drugs such as Cystistat, installed directly into the body, moving and transforming these. If the Spleen Qi
the bladder via catheter. In extreme cases where the patient becomes vacuous and weak and thus cannot move and
is in extreme pain the bladder is surgically removed, transform water liquids, these may gather and transform
although this is considered a last resort. Antidepressants into dampness. This dampness may hinder the free flow
are also sometimes prescribed, for example amitriptyline, of yang Qi … the yang Qi backs up and transforms into
which has analgesic and sedative benefits that some depressive heat … dampness, being turbid and heavy
patients find helpful. percolates downward to the lower burner.’ (in Flaws,
Western medical treatments for IC have had limited 2007)
28 An Investigation into the Treatment of Interstitial Cystitis with Acupuncture Journal of Chinese Medicine • Number 94 • October 2010
In addition, if the Spleen qi and yang are deficient, wei qi cent of respondents rated acupuncture as bringing them a
becomes weakened and pathogens can easily invade the 75 to 100 per cent recovery (see Fig. 1). This is in sharp
body. One function of the Spleen is to raise qi. If the Spleen contrast to their rating of Western medicine, which 45 per
is weak this raising function can be impaired, causing cent of respondents reported as bringing no recovery at
symptoms of urinary urgency and frequency. all. Although this study has limitations in terms of scale
TCM has long recognised that the Small Intestine has and methodology, this is clearly a very positive indication
a specific effect on the Bladder. It has been noted that for acupuncture’s effectiveness in treating this condition.
negative emotional states can cause Heart pathologies
such as Heart fire, which can spread to the Bladder via its What level of recovery has acupuncture brought you?
What level of recovery has Western medicine brought you?
paired organ in the Taiyang, the Small Intestine (Tucker, 60%
2004). Brizman (2007) suggests that pathology in the small
intestine is responsible for many chronic diseases. She 50%
Percentage of respondents
causes microbes, including bacteria and fungi, to travel
40%
(higher if at least 12 treatments were given). It appears that experienced several of the trigger factors mentioned in
urgency and pain are slightly more successfully treated Figure 4 prior to the onset of IC (see Figure 5). Extreme
than frequency and nocturia. stress together with infection (from either a virus or
bacteria) are both known to cause a shift in the immune
system that predisposes a person to inflammation and
If you suffer from the following how would you rate their severity? mast cell production (Elenkov, 2007; Plotnikoff, 2006;
1=mild, 5=severe
Theoharides, 2001; Romagnani, 1999).
4.5 4.5
4.3
4.1 Did you experience any of the following prior to the onset of IC?
Bacterial infection
64%
2.3 of the bladder
2.1 2.1 2.1
43%
Extreme stress or shock
On reading the completed questionnaires it was shocking Fig 4: Possible trigger factors of respondents’ IC
to discover how ill some patients had been prior to their (percentage of respondents)
acupuncture treatment. One patient had been on a waiting
list to have her bladder removed and came to acupuncture
as a last resort. Through a combination of dietary changes Spontaneous / cause unknown 18%
and acupuncture she managed to rid herself of all
symptoms of IC. This was not an isolated case and many
At least 1 82%
respondents felt abandoned by Western medicine. Most At least 2 50%
of the patients that came for acupuncture treatment were At least 3 36%
at their wits’ end, having undergone invasive and painful
procedures and drug treatment with little ‑ if any ‑ success. At least 4 18%
Consequently one could consider these respondents to be At least 5 0%
at the more severe and chronic end of the IC spectrum.
Figure 4 shows that 64 per cent of patients reported
a bacterial infection prior to the onset of their IC. Most Fig. 5: Number of identified factors present prior to onset of
were repeatedly prescribed antibiotics, which from a IC (percentage of respondents)
TCM perspective can suppress symptoms and drive the
pathogen deeper into the body, whilst at the same time Fig. 6 shows foods that respondents’ found to exacerbate
creating dampness. The properties of antibiotics are both their IC symptoms. The worst foods appear to be citrus
cold and damp and can therefore suppress yang and injure fruits, wine and tomatoes. Figure 7 shows the percentage
the Spleen, further perpetuating a cycle of poor health. It of other conditions experienced by respondents, in
is also possible that these patients were misdiagnosed as addition to IC. It shows a large percentage of respondents
having a UTI when in fact it was the onset of the IC. with immune‑related conditions, suggesting that these
conditions are over‑represented in IC patients compared
The stress factor to the wider population. As can be seen from the graph,
In our study almost half (43 per cent) of the patients the incidence of IBS, food allergies, sinusitis and colitis
reported extreme stress or shock prior to the onset of IC. It seems to be significantly higher in people with IC than in
is possible that stress or shock causes a shift in the immune the general population.
system that creates a propensity towards inflammation. Back pain also seems to be particularly associated with
In TCM terms stress may weaken the Spleen, Kidneys and IC, although it is not clear whether the pain originates
Lung, disrupting wei qi and allowing an external pathogen from an injury ‑ and is therefore related to nerve damage
(i.e. microbe) to take hold. Many of the respondents had ‑ or from a form of fibromyalgia ‑ which would indicate
30 An Investigation into the Treatment of Interstitial Cystitis with Acupuncture Journal of Chinese Medicine • Number 94 • October 2010
If you have food allergies, which are the trigger foods? Back pain 82%
Sinusitis 50%
Citrus fruit and juices 39% 29%
Chemical allergies 43%
Rheumatoid arthritis 18%
Coffee 32% 21%
Endometriosis 14%
Spicy food 7% Crohn’s disease 4%
Ulcerative colitis 4%
Tea 21% 18%
32% 32%
Fig. 7: Other conditions reported by respondents in
Wine
addition to IC (percentage of respondents)
Yeast 14% 21%
Often
14%
Other Sometimes
At least 1 100%
At least 2 89%
Fig. 6: Problematic foods amongst IC patients (percentage
At least 3 82%
of respondents)
At least 4 75%
immune dysfunction. It is interesting that in TCM terms the At least 5 46%
Bladder channel runs up the back. Our research supports At least 6 32%
the theory that IC patients have more immunological At least 7 21%
conditions than people in the general population (see
At least 8 11%
Figure 8). Three quarters of IC patients in this study had
At least 9
at least four immune‑related conditions and a third had 4%
six conditions. This supports the author’s theory that IC At least 10 0%
is part of a wider immunological imbalance, rather than
merely a condition affecting the bladder in isolation. Fig. 8: Number of respondents suffering multiple
immunological conditions (percentage of respondents)
Discussion
The authors’ preliminary conclusion regarding the cause Implications for practice
of IC based on this study is that a combination of infection This study raises points that are important for clinical
and stress/shock sets in motion a cascade of physiological practice:
changes in the bladder. This results in damage to the GAG
lining of the bladder and the production of mast cells. Stress
The damaged GAG layer means that there is no longer Stress has been shown to have a negative effect on the
any protection from acid, so that molecules of food and immune and digestive systems by both Western and
drink can irritate and inflame the bladder, causing further Chinese medicine. Clinical studies by Lutgendorf (2001)
inflammation and immune reaction. This means that IC is and Rothrock (2001) both found that psychological
not just a bladder condition, but is a disease involving the stress caused symptoms of IC in humans and animals.
digestive system – amongst other systems in the body. Immunological research by Stojanovich and Marisavljevich
This study indicates that acupuncture can treat not only (2008) link autoimmune diseases to stress. Our study
the physical symptoms of IC but also the emotional state suggests that stress or shock was a trigger of IC in many
of the patient. Three quarters of respondents reported that of the respondents. Identifying whether stress or shock
acupuncture had helped them emotionally. It is unclear is a causative factor for a particular patient may help to
how big an effect this had on their physical symptoms. determine the appropriate treatment strategy. Unravelling
It may be the case that the physiological changes that the emotional impact of any trauma and making sure that
occur in IC also have their roots in emotional stress or the patient has properly dealt with it is therefore a vital
trauma, and that treating the emotional side starts to undo factor in recovery from IC. Counselling may therefore be a
physiological damage. Whichever comes first – the stress necessary part of an IC treatment programme.
or the physical symptoms ‑ it is clear that patients with IC
are often very upset and that anything that can help the Diet
condition become more bearable is of value to them. Diet is becoming recognised as an important factor in
Journal of Chinese Medicine • Number 94 • October 2010 An Investigation into the Treatment of Interstitial Cystitis with Acupuncture 31
References Lutgendorf, S., Kreder, K., Rothrock, N., disease”. Autoimmune Review, 7,
Ratliff, T., Zimmerman, B., (2001). “A 209‑13
Anon (2008). The Interstitial Cystitis and laboratory stress model for examining
Painful Bladder Syndrome Handbook, Teahon, K., Smethurst, P., Levi, A., Menzies,
stress and symptomatology in interstitial I., (1992). “Intestinal Permeability in
Birmingham, UK. cystitis patients”, Urology, 57, 122. Patients With Crohn’s Disease and Their
Elenkov, I (2002). “Systemic Stress‑Induced Maciocia, G (2008). The Practice of Chinese First Degree Relatives”. Gut, 33, 320‑3
Th2 Shift and its Clinical Implications”. Medicine. Churchill Livingstone, UK.
International Review of Neurobiology, Theoharides, T., Kempuraj, D., Sant, G
52, 163‑186. Maciocia, G (1983). Urinary Diseases. Journal (2001). “Mast Cell Involvement in
of Chinese Medicine, 13. Interstitial Cystitis: A Review of Human
Imamov, O., Yakimchuk, K., Morani, and Experimental Evidence”. Urology,
A., Schwend, T., Wada‑Hiraike, O., Meddings, J (2008). “The Significance of
the Gut Barrier in Disease”. Gut, 57, 57, 47‑55.
Razumov, S., Warner, M., Gustafsson,
J (2007). “Estrogen receptor‑deficient 438‑440. Tucker, T (2004). “The Treatment of
female mice develop a bladder phenotype Nickel, J (2004). “Interstitial Cystitis: A Interstitial Cystitis by Acupuncture”.
resembling human Interstitial cystitis”. Chronic Pelvic Pain Syndrome”. Medical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 75, 38‑44.
PNAS, 104 (23). Clinics of North America, 8(2). Van de Merwe, J (2007). “Interstitial cystitis
Iwakabea, K., Shimadaa, M., Ohtaa, A., Plotnikoff, N., Faith, R., Murgo, A., Good, and systemic autoimmune diseases”.
Yahataa, T., Ohmia, Y., Habua, S., R (2006). Cytokines: Stress and Immunity, Nature Clinical Practice Urology, 4,
Nishimuraa, T (1998). “The restraint Second Edition. USA: CRC Publishing. 484‑91
stress drives a shift in Th1/Th2 balance Romagnani, S (1999). “Th1/Th2 cells”. Yuan, LD (2007). Li Dong Yuans Treatise on the
toward Th2‑dominant immunity in Inflammatory Bowel Disease, 4, 285‑94. Spleen and Stomach: A Translation of the Pi
mice”. Immunology, 62, 39‑43. Wei Lun. Translated from Mandarin by
Rothrock, N., Lutgendorf, S., Kreder, K., Bob Flaws, Boulder: Blue Poppy Press.
Jinsheng, H (2005). “Acupuncture Treatment Ratliff, T., Zimmerman, B (2001). “Daily
of Frequent Urination” Translated Stress and Symptom Exacerbation in Yuelai, C (2002). “The Anatomical Physiology
from Mandarin by Yu Min, Journal Interstitial Cystitis Patients”. Urology, and Clinical Application of the Points
of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 25, 57, 122. Huiyang and Zhonglushu”. Translated
238‑240. from Mandarin by Ye Huan. Journal
Shorter, B., Lesser, M., Moldwin, R., Kushner, of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 22,
Lorenzo, G., Gómez, C (2004). L (2007). “Effect of Comestibles on
“Physiopathologic relationship between 180‑2.
Symptoms of Interstitial Cystitis”. Adult
interstitial cystitis and rheumatic, Urology, 178 (1), 145‑152.
autoimmune, and chronic inflammatory
Stojanovich, L., Marisavljevich, D (2008).
diseases”, Archive of Spanish Urology,
“Stress as a trigger of autoimmune
57, 25‑34.
european journal
◆ is theme based
Subscriptions
UK: £20, Europe: £21, Overseas: £26 (Air), USA: $59,
Students: £15. Overseas orders must be paid in
of oriental medicine