Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Source: https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2021/06/soros-backed-sheriff-penzone-
maricopa-county-board-wouldnt-turn-router-data-az-senate-audit-now-likely-facing-
contempt-charges-another-case/
Header:
Text:
https://www.azfamily.com/2022/11/09/maricopa-county-sheriff-paul-penzone-found-
contempt-same-racial-profiling-case-joe-arpaio/
Arpaio was found in both civil and criminal contempt for disobeying a
2011 order to stop his traffic patrols that targeted immigrants. He was
spared a possible jail sentence when his misdemeanor conviction was
pardoned by then-President Donald Trump in 2017. His defiance in
the profiling case contributed significantly to his defeat after 24 years
in office. The sheriff’s office was found in 2013 to have racially
profiled Latinos in Arpaio’s immigration patrols.
The verdict led to two court-ordered overhauls of the agency, one on
its traffic enforcement division and another on its internal affairs
operation, which under Arpaio had been criticized for biased decision-
making and shielding sheriff’s officials from accountability. The court
stripped the sheriff’s office of some of its autonomy over internal
affairs.
The attorneys who have pressed the profiling case against the sheriff’s
office had requested contempt proceedings against Penzone, saying
the length of the internal investigations has resulted in lost evidence
that makes it more likely that officer misconduct won’t be confronted.
They also said failing to investigate internal complaints on a timely
basis harms the class of Hispanics covered by the profiling lawsuit
because officers can continue interacting with them while the
investigations are pending. A court-appointed official who oversees
the sheriff’s office and has criticized Penzone for failing to fill new
internal affairs staff positions that were already budgeted by the
county has said the slowness in completing the investigations was
unacceptable for both members of the public who make complaints
and officers awaiting the findings.
Civil rights attorney Benjamin Taylor said, “They need to get their act
together and clean up the office immediately. Sheriff Penzone has had
6 years...Sheriff Joe was accused of pulling people over illegally.
People who were driving down the street were being pulled over
because of the color of their skin. Mostly people he assumed were
undocumented.”
Taylor said that he believes Penzone hasn’t shown the judge and the
community that he’s overcome the former sheriff’s legacy, despite
that he believes Penzone wants to do so. “Because of of lack of
resources, because of speed, it hasn’t been done,” Taylor said. “The
judge has the power in contempt--and it’s an extreme example--but a
judge could hold you in contempt and throw you in jail.”
In the past, Penzone has said his office made warnings several years
ago about the growing caseload, but its suggestions for confronting the
problem were rejected by court officials and opposing lawyers. In his
latest order, Snow barred the sheriff’s office from reducing staffing
levels in internal affairs while the backlog remains in effect and
threatened fines if the agency fails to fill seven vacant positions for
sworn officers or civilian investigators in internal affairs within 60
days.
The amount of the fine hasn’t yet been specified. But the judge said if
any of the posts are left vacant, the sheriff’s office will face a fine
three times the amount of an internal affairs sergeant’s annual salary
for each vacancy. The sheriff’s office is required to provide that salary
figure to the court within two weeks. Even though Arpaio’s
immigration patrols ended nine years ago – and the brash lawman was
voted out of office nearly six years ago -- taxpayers in metro Phoenix
have paid eight-figure bills every year since 2015 in the case that
challenged his crackdowns.
Taxpayers have paid $207 million in compliance and legal costs in the
profiling case over the last 14 years. Another $28 million is expected
to be spent on the case by the summer of 2023, according to county
records.
The overwhelming majority of the spending goes toward hiring
employees to help meet the court’s requirements. The court-ordered
changes also included new training for deputies on making
constitutional traffic stops, establishing a warning system to identify
problematic behavior, and equipping deputies with body-worn
cameras. Despite the money spent and efforts made to overhaul the
agency’s traffic enforcement operations, the sheriff’s office continues
to face criticism for its treatment of Hispanic drivers.
A court-ordered study of the agency’s traffic stops in 2021 concluded
that stops of Hispanic drivers were more likely to last longer and
result in searches or arrests than those of white drivers. The report
echoed some of the same conclusions from past traffic enforcement
studies aimed at identifying signs of racial bias in stops.
*READ the tweet here:
https://twitter.com/mcsoaz/status/1590479723922362370?
s=20&t=84HJmb0V8SbC_SK0cP75hw
THE BACKSTORY….
Link:
https://pebblecreekpost.com/democratic-clubs-first-zoom-meeting-welcomes-
sheriff-paul-penzone/
Sheriff Paul Penzone spoke with the PebbleCreek Democratic Club during their July meeting.
Alisa Moore
Maricopa County Sheriff Paul Penzone was the speaker for the PebbleCreek (PC) Democratic
Club’s inaugural Zoom meeting. The Sheriff is running for re-election and given the protests and
moves to change law enforcement budgets, responsibilities, and oversight, the club could not have
hosted a timelier or more interesting speaker.
Sheriff Penzone defeated Joe Arpaio in 2016, with a mandate to clean up the sheriff’s office. Two
related federal court orders had been in place since 2013 that ruled that the Maricopa County
Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) had systematically violated the rights of Latinos for years by racially profiling
Hispanic drivers. As a result, Sheriff Penzone had two immediate obligations related to those orders:
to implement and document compliance with those orders, and to reduce the lawsuits that were
commonplace to stop the unacceptable waste of taxpayer dollars. The settlement of lawsuits from
the Arpaio years, their related expenses, and the necessary changes in the department, including
hiring staff, will have cost the taxpayers of Maricopa County over $178 million dollars by mid-2021.
Under Sheriff Penzone’s leadership, the MCSO is committed to a mission of ethical, effective, and
impactful law enforcement and public safety. They are also focused on programs and initiatives to
help promote partnerships and trust between their office and our communities. For instance, MCSO
now regularly conducts upwards of 50 community outreach events each month across the county.
The MCSO is the primary or supporting law enforcement agency for a population of more than four
million residents operating in the fourth largest county in America. MCSO’s jails process and house
all felony and most misdemeanor inmates for Maricopa County, in excess of 100,000 intakes
annually.
Sheriff Penzone oversees an annual budget of nearly $400 million dollars. Through effective
management, in his first year, Sheriff Penzone created a $20 million budget surplus, returning $9
million to Maricopa County and reinvesting the rest into MCSO.
Sheriff Penzone and his team have created a number of programs to reduce drug abuse and
recidivism, including the MOSAIC Program, a seven-week program working to break the
incarceration cycle with medium to high risk inmates. The program currently shows a 20% reduction
in recidivism among participants who have already completed the program, helping lower the crime
rate, saving money in detention housing, and transforming inmates into productive citizens who go
on to build stronger communities.
Paul has a combined 30 years of law enforcement and public safety experience, including a
distinguished 21-year career with the Phoenix Police Department, with seven years dedicated to
solving cold cases and apprehending dangerous fugitives.
The PC Dem Club’s next meeting is Aug. 6 by Zoom. The Men’s Breakfast also meets by Zoom.
Look for details in upcoming emails.