Professional Documents
Culture Documents
R a d i o f req u e n c y
Macrene Alexiades, MD, PhDa,b,*
KEYWORDS
Microneedle Radiofrequency Skin laxity
KEY POINTS
Patient demand for nonsurgical alternatives to targeting skin laxity and rhytids have given rise to the
advent of microneedle radiofrequency (RF), which provides direct in situ delivery, impedance mea-
surements, temperature measurements, energy delivery controls, and targeting of various skin
depths to achieve desired clinical outcomes.
Microneedle RF is a breakthrough that controls penetration depth and delivery to specified temper-
atures and impedance measurements, which ensure significantly improved efficacy in the treat-
ment of mild-to-moderate rhytids and skin laxity of the face, neck, and cellulite and laxity on
other body sites.
Combining microneedle RF with dermal fillers and neuromodulators may be used to further improve
clinical outcomes and achieve high patient satisfaction.
the body, with minimal recovery and rare risk of dibular redundancy, and neck platysmal strands.
side effects or complications.2–4 Loss of elasticity and recoil are clinical findings.
a
Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA; b University of Athens Sygros Hospital,
Athens, Greece
* Dermatology and Laser Surgery Center of New York, 955 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10028.
E-mail address: email@nyderm.org
This 4-point grading scale has been extensively tested and used for evaluating laser-based and energy-based cosmetic treatments.
Data from Refs.2–6
Microneedle Radiofrequency 11
Although body skin laxity lacks a validated neocollagenesis and neoelastogenesis, which
grading scale, the relative firmness of body skin correlate with clinical rhytid and laxity reduction.
has been assessed by the presence or absence RF is in the 3-kHz to 24-GHz frequency range
of surface irregularities.2–6 Skin laxity on the and, when delivered as an oscillating electrical
body similarly presents with rhytids, lack of recoil, current, it induces collisions between charged
folds upon flexion, linear undulations, and poor atoms and molecules in tissue, generating
texture. Cellulite grading scales have been variably heat.14 The penetration depth of RF is inversely
tested and used.4 proportional to frequency; lower RF frequencies
penetrate more deeply when applied to the skin
PATHOGENESIS surface. Heat is generated from the resistance of
tissue components to the movement of charged
The dermal matrix of connective tissue confers the and polar molecules within the oscillating RF field.
properties of elasticity, recoil, and tensile strength. This resistance, termed impedance, generates
The properties of elasticity and resilience are heat relative to the amount of current and time,
attributed to the elastic fiber system, which con- converting electrical current to thermal energy.
fers the deformability and passive recoil of tissue.
Collagen fibers provide tensile strength while hyal- SUBTYPES
uronic acid provides turgor and skin moisture. In
diseases characterized by alterations in elastic fi- RF devices may be classified as noninvasive and
bers, the skin is loose and sagging with a loss of minimally invasive, the latter being delivered by
recoil, elasticity, and resilience.6–10 Elastic fiber microneedles or probes. RF may be classified ac-
mutations, deficiency, degradation, or alteration cording to electrode configuration: monopolar RF
result in reduced skin elasticity and increased uses a single electrode and a grounding pad; uni-
skin laxity, which may be reversed through stimu- polar RF is via antenna transmission; bipolar and
lation of neoelastogenesis.6–10 By contrast, loss of tripolar RF use multiple electrodes in the hand-
collagen is more closely associated with rhytid for- piece tip whereby the current traverses the skin
mation. During the aging process, collagen and via a closed circuit. The penetration depth of multi-
elastin synthesis decrease, and elastin fibers are polar RF when delivered on the skin surface is
degraded through sun exposure starting in the approximately one-half the distance between the
third decade of life. electrodes. Microneedle RF delivery bypasses
Heat denaturation of collagen and dermal these barriers and delivers energy directly into
structures has been shown to induce histologic the dermis and subcutis. The singular break-
dermal remodeling and clinical laxity reduction.11 through of the first microneedle RF device (Pro-
In work by the author, it was discovered that found; Candela Medical, Wayland, MA) is that it
collagen greater than 70 C, which results in fully uses thermistors in the electrode needle tips,
denatured collagen, is associated with poorer allowing real-time feedback of both impedance
clinical outcomes; in contrast, intradermal tem- and temperature.2–4,13
peratures of 62 C to 67 C, which are associated The penetration depth depends on delivery
with partially denatured collagen, result in supe- mode (skin surface, needle-based, or probe-
rior clinical efficacy in rhytid and laxity reduction. based), electrode configuration (monopolar or
The author has thus theorized that heat-induced multipolar), tissue type (skin, fat), and the fre-
partially denatured collagens reveal RGD quency of the current. Structures with higher con-
sequences that via a signaling cascade result in ductivity and impedance generate more heat: fat,
induction of neocollagenesis and neoelastogen- bone, and dry skin have low conductivities such
esis.11 The neocollagenesis process has been that current flows around rather than through
demonstrated to take up to 12 months following these structures; hydrated skin possesses high
treatment and correlates with progressive clinical electrical conductivity via the effects of water
improvement. dipole moment, thus allowing greater penetration
of current. Improved results are observed with
coupling fluid.
MECHANISM OF ACTION
Monopolar Radiofrequency
RF delivery to the skin creates thermal, mechani-
cal, and biochemical effects that induce dermal Clinical study results from monopolar RF treat-
remodeling. The increases in collagen, elastin, ment were first reported in 2003 by the author’s
and hyaluronic acid increase volume and improve group for the jowls and neck, and by Fitzpatrick
the elastic properties of the skin.12,13 RF and colleagues for the periorbital area.14,15 The
delivers controlled thermal injury that induces original single-pass, high-energy method was later
12 Alexiades
gauge, manufacturing, and refinements in the pro- baseline and the surgical patients were judged to
tocol to optimize clinical outcomes. Single-use have a 49% improvement from baseline laxity
treatment cartridges deliver 5 pairs of indepen- grades, or a 0.46 versus 1.20 laxity grade reduc-
dently controlled, 32-gauge, bipolar 250-mm tion, respectively. The laxity grade reduction result
microneedles spaced 1.25 mm apart; each needle from a single microneedle RF treatment was 37%
pair is independently sensed and powered by the that of a surgical facelift.2 In the subsequent multi-
RF generator. The proximal 3 mm of the 6-mm center clinical trial and multiarm studies of target
needle is insulated to protect the superficial dermal temperatures ranging from 52 C to 78 C,
portion of the skin during treatment while the distal the author and colleagues discovered that temper-
3-mm length is exposed to allow electrical current ature of 67 C in their cohort resulted in maximal
flow between needle pairs to generate 3-dimen- neocollagenesis, neoelastogenesis, and hyaluron-
sional zones of thermal effects in the target. The ic acid production, and correlated clinically with
dermal handpiece is at a 25 angle so that the maximal rhytid and laxity reduction and a 100%
tips of the needles are at a 2-mm depth from the response rate.3 Higher and lower target tempera-
epidermis. As current flows between each needle tures demonstrated less efficacy. The findings us-
pair, fractionated zones (one between each pair) ing needle-delivered RF support the theory that
of thermal injury are situated in the dermis 2 mm partially denatured collagen is more effective at
from the surface of the skin. Epidermal cooling is triggering a strong wound-healing response.3
achieved via an integrated thermokinetic cooling Fig. 2 shows 2 sets of “before” and “after” photo-
bar on the applicator. Intradermal targeting is graphs following a single microneedle RF treat-
ensured by impedance measurements in the nee- ment (Profound, Candela). Arrows indicate
dle tips and software, ensuring firing within a spec- findings of laxity at baseline including jowls and
ified impedance range. A target temperature is submental laxity at baseline, and significant reduc-
selected by the user and energy is delivered until tion of jowls and submental laxity with restoration
the target temperature is attained and energy of mandibular definition on follow-up after a single
titrated to maintain precise target temperature for treatment. Similar skin-tightening effects were
a selected pulse duration. The subcutaneous observed on body skin laxity when the subcutane-
handpiece delivers bipolar RF pulses using 5 pairs ous handpiece was used to treat cellulite.4 When
of microneedle electrodes deployed into the treating with microneedle RF on the body skin, a
dermis at an angle of 75 with the exposed portion reduction in linear undulations and textural irregu-
extending from 3.9 to 5.8 mm beneath the skin larities was observed.
surface (Profound Sub-Q; Syneron Candela). Numerous needle-delivered bipolar RF devices
Zones of thermal injury with real-time temperature have been developed. One device allows for
monitoring using temperature sensors in each adjustable needle depths to 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0
electrode tip maintain a preselected target tem- and 3.5 mm (Infini; Lutronic, Billerica, MA). The
perature regardless of varying skin conditions device offers a 49-needle tip (10 mm 10 mm,
and improve consistency between patients. 7 7 needles) and a 16-needle tip
The author’s group compared baseline and 3- to (5 mm 5 mm, 4 4 needles). The microneedles
6-month follow-up photographs of 15 patients are surgical stainless-steel gold-coated for con-
who underwent skin tightening using a micronee- ductivity and then double coated with an insu-
dle RF device with those of 6 patients who had un- lating silicon compound, except for the distal
dergone rhytidectomy.2 The RF-device patients 300-mm tip. The needles have a diameter of
were judged to have a 16% improvement from 200 mm and point diameter of 20 mm. The
Fig. 2. Microneedle RF clinical outcomes showing 2 sets of before (A) and after (B) photographs following a sin-
gle microneedle RF treatment (Profound, Candela).
14 Alexiades
insulation restricts the active area of the micro- neck, and cellulite and laxity on other body sites.
needle electrodes to the tip, and there is no elec- Although surgical face lifting remains the gold
trothermal damage delivered to the epidermis. standard, microneedle RF provides a clinically
Clinical trials have demonstrated wrinkle reduc- meaningful alternative for those who wish to avoid
tion following treatment with this device, with surgery or who have a milder condition.
clinician-assessed overall efficacy and patient Combining microneedle RF with dermal fillers
satisfaction index similar at from 80.7% to and neuromodulators may be used to further
88.9% and 81.3% to 85.9%.27 Although the sys- improve clinical outcomes and achieve high pa-
tem lacks real-time temperature feedback, a tient satisfaction.
recent improvement has incorporated imped-
ance measurements (Genius, Lutronic). DISCLOSURE
Another bipolar microneedle RF device (Inten-
sif; EndyMed Medical, Caesarea, Israel) includes Dr. Alexiades serves on the Medical Advisory
25 noninsulated gold-plated microneedle elec- Board of Candela and has received research
trodes 300 mm in diameter at the base, gradually grants from Candela, Cutera, Allergan, and
tapering to a sharp edge.28 Penetration depth of Biofrontera.
up to 3.5 mm may be administered at 0.1-mm
digitally controlled increments. Maximal power REFERENCES
is 25 W with a maximal pulse duration of 200 -
milliseconds. The electrical impedance differ- 1. American Society for Dermatologic Surgery (ASDS)
ence between the epidermis (high) and the 2015 Consumer Survey on cosmetic dermatologic
dermis (low) ensures RF flow through the dermis. procedures. Data were collected from 7,315 con-
The RF emission delivered throughout the sumers through a blind online survey in spring
length of the needle results in effective coagula- 2015. Available at: https://www.asds.net/Portals/0/
tion with minimal or no bleeding, and dermal PDF/consumer-survey-2015-infographic.pdf.
heating.28 2. Alexiades-Armenakas M, Rosenberg D, Renton B,
Another microneedle bipolar RF device (Frac- et al. Blinded, randomized quantitative grading
tora; Invasix, Lake Forest, CA) administers comparison of minimally-invasive fractional radiofre-
1 MHz to RF-conducting needles, alternating quency and surgical facelift for the treatment of skin
current with 2 long side electrodes. The hand- laxity. Arch Dermatol 2010;146(4):396–405.
piece cartridges come as 600-mm or 3000-mm 3. Alexiades-Armenakas M, Sarnoff D, Gotkin R, et al.
long needles, which are 200 300 mm wide at Multi-center clinical study and review of fractional
the base, for mid-dermal and deep dermal or ablative co2 laser resurfacing for the treatment of
subdermal delivery, respectively.29 The mid- rhytides, photoaging, scars and striae. J Drugs Der-
dermal delivers 60 microneedles while the full matol 2011;10(4):352–62.
dermal or deep dermal/subdermal handpiece 4. Alexiades M, Munavalli G, Goldberg D, et al. Pro-
contains 24 uncoated or coated needles, respec- spective multicenter clinical trial of a temperature-
tively. The handpiece is loaded to the Fractora controlled subcutaneous microneedle fractional
platform (also applicable to InMode or BodyTite bipolar RF system for the treatment of cellulite. Der-
platforms; Invasix/InMode MD, Israel). The de- matol Surg 2018;44(10):1262–71.
vice has been reported to result in significant 5. Alexiades-Armenakas M. A quantitative and
improvement in acne and acne scars.29 comprehensive grading scale for rhytides, laxity
and photoaging. J Drugs Dermatol 2006;5(8):808–9.
SUMMARY 6. Alexiades-Armenakas MR, Dover JS, Arndt KA. The
spectrum of laser skin resurfacing: non-ablative,
Patient demand for nonsurgical alternatives to tar- fractional and ablative laser resurfacing. J Am
geting skin laxity and rhytids have given rise to the Acad Dermatol 2008;58(5):719–37 [quiz: 738–40].
advent of microneedle RF, which provides direct in 7. El-Domyati M, Attia S, Saleh F, et al. Intrinsic aging
situ delivery, impedance measurements, tempera- vs. photoaging: a comparative histopathological,
ture measurements, energy delivery controls, and immunohistochemical, and ultrastructural study of
targeting of various skin depths to achieve desired skin. Exp Dermatol 2002;11:398–405.
clinical outcomes. Microneedle RF is a break- 8. Kielty CM, Sherratt MJ, Shuttleworth CA. Elastic fi-
through that controls penetration depth and deliv- bres. J Cell Sci 2002;115:2817–28.
ery to specified temperatures and impedance 9. Lewis KG, Bercovitch L, Dill SW, et al. Acquired dis-
measurements, which ensure significantly orders of elastic tissue: part I. Increased elastic tis-
improved efficacy in the treatment of mild-to- sue and solar elastotic syndromes. J Am Acad
moderate rhytids and skin laxity of the face and Dermatol 2004;51:1–21.
Microneedle Radiofrequency 15
10. Lewis KG, Bercovitch L, Dill SW, et al. Acquired dis- 21. Alexiades-Armenakas MR, Dover JS, Arndt KA.
orders of elastic tissue: part II. decreased elastic tis- Unipolar RF treatment to improve the appearance
sue. J Am Acad Dermatol 2004;51:165–85. of cellulite. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2008;10(3):
11. Alexiades M, Berube D. Randomized, blinded, 148–53.
3-arm clinical trial assessing optimal temperature 22. Doshi SN, Alster TS. Combined diode laser and RF
and duration for treatment with minimally invasive energy for rhytides and skin laxity: investigation of
fractional RF. Dermatol Surg 2015;41(5):623–32. a novel device. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2005;7:11–5.
12. Alexiades-Armenakas M. Aging facial skin: infrared 23. Sadick NS, Alexiades-Armenakas M, Bitter P Jr,
broad band light technologies. Facial Plast Surg et al. Enhanced full-face skin rejuvenation using syn-
Clin North Am 2011;19(2):361–70. chronous intense pulsed optical and conducted bi-
13. Willey A, Kilmer S, Newman J, et al. Elastometry and polar RF energy (ELOS): introducing selective
clinical results after bipolar radiofrequency treat- radiophotothermolysis. J Eur Acad Dermatol Vene-
ment of skin. Dermatol Surg 2010;36(6):877–84. reol 2005;4:181–6.
14. Jacobson LG, Alexiades-Armenakas MR,
24. Alexiades-Armenakas M. Rhytides, laxity, and pho-
Bernstein L, et al. Treatment of nasolabial folds
toaging treated with a combination of RF, diode
and jowls with a non-invasive RF device. Arch Der-
laser, and pulsed light and assessed with a compre-
matol 2003;139(10):1313–20.
hensive grading scale. J Drugs Dermatol 2006;5(8):
15. Fitzpatrick R, Geronemus R, Goldberg D, et al. Multi-
731–8.
center study of noninvasive RF for periorbital tissue
25. Yu CS, Yeung CK, Shek SY, et al. Combined infrared
tightening. Lasers Surg Med 2003;33:232–42.
light and bipolar RF for skin tightening in Asians. La-
16. Sugawara J, Kou S, Kokubo K, et al. Application for
sers Surg Med 2007;39(6):471–5.
lower facial fat reduction and tightening by static
26. Gold MH, Goldman MP, Rao J, et al. Treatment of
type monopolar 1-MHz radio frequency for body
wrinkles and elastosis using vacuum-assisted bipo-
contouring. Lasers Surg Med 2017;49(8):750–5.
lar RF heating of the dermis. Dermatol Surg 2007;33:
17. Taub AF, Tucker RD, Palange A. Facial tightening
300–9.
with an advanced 4-MHz monopolar RF device.
J Drugs Dermatol 2012;11(11):1288–94. 27. Calderhead RG, Goo BL, Lauro F, et al. The clinical
18. Key DJ. Integration of thermal imaging with subsur- efficacy and safety of microneedling fractional RF in
face RF thermistor heating for the purpose of skin the treatment of facial wrinkles: a multicenter study
tightening and contour improvement: a retrospective with the infini system in 499 patients 2013. white
review of clinical efficacy. J Drugs Dermatol 2014; paper. Available at: us.aesthetic.lutronic.com.
13(12):1485–9. 28. Gold M, Taylor M, Rothaus K, et al. Non-insulated
19. Friedman DJ, Gilead LT. The use of hybrid RF device smooth motion, micro-needles RF. Lasers Surg
for the treatment of rhytides and lax skin. Dermatol Med 2016;48(8):727–33.
Surg 2007;33:543–55. 29. Dayan E, Chia C, Burns AJ, Theodorou S. Adjust-
20. Alexiades-Armenakas MR, Dover JS, Arndt KA. Uni- able depth fractional radiofrequency combined
polar vs. bipolar RF treatment of rhytides and laxity with bipolar radiofrequency: a minimally invasive
using a mobile painless delivery method. Lasers combination treatment for skin laxity. Aesthet Surg
Surg Med 2008;40(7):446–53. J 2019;39(Supplement_3):S112–9.