Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Capstone Project Report Format
Capstone Project Report Format
Bachelor of Technology
In
Mechanical Engineering
By
Aman Chandulal Movalia
16BME0114
May, 2020
2
DECLARATION
Place : Vellore
Date : 18th May 2020
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the thesis entitled “Design and Manufacturing of an Electric
Thrust Powered VTOL Miniaturized Rocket” submitted by Aman Movalia (16BME0114),
School of Mechanical Engineering, VIT, for the award of the degree of Bachelor of
Technology in Mechanical Engineering, is a record of bonafide work carried out by him /
her under my supervision during the period, 01. 12. 2018 to 30.04.2019, as per the VIT code
of academic and research ethics.
The contents of this report have not been submitted and will not be submitted either in
part or in full, for the award of any other degree or diploma in this institute or any other
institute or university. The thesis fulfills the requirements and regulations of the University
and in my opinion meets the necessary standards for submission.
Place : Vellore
Date : 18th May 2020 Signature of the Guide
Acknowledgements
We would like to express our gratitude to Dr. Mallikarjuna Reddy, Head of Department –
Design and Automation, School of Mechanical Engineering, VIT University, Vellore for his
effective guidance throughout our efforts for the development of the project and successful
delivery of the project objectives. The work could not have been competed without the
suggestions and valuable tips given by him. He encouraged us to study and collect enough
material on the subject and helped clear doubts that came along. His constant encouragement
and regular check on the progress enabled us to complete the work in time.
We would also like to express our gratitude to the DIGIMAN Lab - ALM Building for their
immense support and help in providing the 3D printed components used in the project. Our
project would certainly have not been finished without their help and guidance.
Besides, some technical details enlisted in this report have been taken directly from certain
works that have been enlisted in the references provided.
Last but not the least, the timely completion of the project could not have been possible
without the moral support extended by our families, friends.
Executive Summary
The project is about designing and manufacturing a thrust vectoring system for model
rockets, thus allowing a Vertical Take-Off and Landing (VTOL) approach. Due to the smaller
scale of rocket, electric thrust system will act as the propulsion system. On-board sensors and
computing systems will act as the guidance control for the rocket. All the telemetry data will
be wirelessly transmitted to a ground control station (GCS). The guidance system can be
manually controlled via GCS or it can be automated. The rocket will be able to perform
autonomous flights with the help of onboard computing systems according to a pre-
determined flight plan. Many types of payloads can be attached with the rocket including
sensors, cargo, cameras etc. Once the takeoff will be detected, thrust vectoring is activated,
in-flight abort is armed and high frequency data logging begins. The rocket will be
manufactured majorly with Depron foam, balsa wood sticks and carbon fiber composites.
Due to the VTOL approach of the rocket, it has the capability of automatic Take-Off and
Landing which has a very wide use of applications, such as logistics delivery, aerial
photography, inspections, STEM activities and many more.
6
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements......................................................................................................4
Executive Summary.....................................................................................................5
List of Figures..............................................................................................................8
List of Tables..............................................................................................................10
List of Abbreviations.................................................................................................11
1 Introduction.............................................................................................................12
1.1 Objective....................................................................................................12
1.2 Motivation..................................................................................................12
1.3 Background................................................................................................12
3.3.1 Motor............................................................................................24
3.3.3 Propeller.......................................................................................27
3.5.1 Overview.......................................................................................29
5.1 Schedule.....................................................................................................47
5.2 Milestones..................................................................................................47
6. Project Demonstrations.........................................................................................47
7. Cost Analysis..........................................................................................................47
8. Summary................................................................................................................47
9. References...............................................................................................................50
8
List of Figures
List of Tables
Table 3 Milestones 41
List of Abbreviations
1. Introduction
1.1. Objective
With the upcoming advancements brought up in the field of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
(UAV), safety and efficiency has become an important priority. More and more aerodynamic
designs are introduced to increase efficiency of the vehicles. Hence, the main objective of the
project is to introduce a UAV in the shape of a rocket, which is electrically propelled with the
help of motors. The rocket will be able to take-off and land on the surface vertically in a
VTOL fashion. The rocket will have a payload bay where the payload according to the
application can be placed which can then carry out the respective task. Another objective of
the project will be the autonomous execution of the rocket on a pre-determined Flight Plan.
The rocket will be scheduled to land at a particular defined landing zone as a part of the
autonomous execution.
1.2. Motivation
1.3. Background
S. Nonaka, H. Ogawa and Y. Inatani at the Institute of Space and Astronautical Science
Sagamihara, researched upon aerodynamic design considerations on vertical landing vehicles.
The paper focused on the nose design considerations during take-off and landing. Two
different types of landing approach were introduced – Nose Entry and Base Entry. The body
consists of a blunted nose of radius, a fore cone of half-apex angle, a cylindrical section, and
an aft cone of aft angle. Static stability conditions of the vehicle at trim is one of the most
important requirements for the ballistic reentry. The stability and trim depend on the position
of the center of gravity CG and center of pressure CP. In reality, however, it may be difficult
to achieve the stability in nose entry because the VTOL characteristics of the vehicle drive
the CG to be further back toward the base where the engines systems are located. As the CG
for a nose entry vehicle should be typically found at a point between 55 and 65 % of body
13
length in order to meet static stability, the CG must be positioned near the nose to obtain high
stability at trim. If such CG positioning is possible by system arrangements, the stability
during not only the descent phase but also ascent one will be kept since the long cylindrical
section tends to move the CP position toward the base, the suitable length of the cylindrical
section may improve the stability.
Figure 1.1
Schematic of Entry Concepts for VTOL Rocket
Yoshifumi Inatani and Yoshihiro Naruo at the Institute of Space and Astronautical Science,
Sagamihara, researched upon a fully reusable rocket vehicle that is proposed to demonstrate
good operability characteristics both on the ground and in flight. A number of performance-
related innovations are needed for future space transportation systems such as fully reusable
launch vehicles. High-performance engines and super-lightweight materials and structures are
the technologies needed to be ready to build these future vehicles. In addition to these
technical challenges, it is necessary for the flight and the ground operations of these advanced
vehicles to be closer to those of aircraft. The first goals of the vehicle were to achieve full
reusability and enhanced operability and to demonstrate the benefits of good reusability.
ding rocket
14
Figure 1.3
Ductile Fan Structure of ORBOT
15
Our project focuses on a new type of UAV – Monocopter. The Monocopter is equipped
inside a rocket for including a payload bay for various applications such as logistics delivery,
aerial photography, inspections, STEM activities and many more. The rocket consists of three
main parts – Nose, Fuselage and Tail. There are two thrust vectoring system situated at the
nose and tail of the rocket.
Figure 2.1
Rocket Components
There are two Thrust Vectoring Systems – Tail Thrust Vectoring System (TTVS) at tail and
Attitutde Control Thrust Vectoring System (ACTVS) at nose.
TTVS consists of two big brushless electric motors which will act as the main
source of thrust production. The electric motors used are Emax 3515 650KV
4S – 6S brushless motor. The two motors will be attached co-axially two
produce enough thrust for propelling the rocket for flight. There are four
movable tail fins attached at the bottom which will vector the thrust and
produce movements along the three axes – pitch, roll and yaw. These four fins
will be actuated by standard servos and will move according to the required
attitude of the rocket for the flight plan.
Figure 2.2
Rocket Control
16
3. TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS
3.1 Rocket
Figure 3.1
Rocket Body Components
3.2.1 Motor
Graphs:
3000 30
2500 25
2000 20
1500 15
Thrust Current
1000 10
500 5
0 0
5 20 35 45 60 75 90
Throttle (%) Throttle (%)
Figure 3.3 Thrust v/s Time Figure 3.4 Current v/s Time
700
12000
600
10000
500
8000
400
6000 Power
RPM 300
4000
200
2000 100
0 0
5 20 35 45 60 75 90 5 20 35 45 60 75 90
Throttle (%) Throttle (%)
Figure 3.5 RPM v/s Time Figure 3.6 Power v/s Time
Features:
Using Multintegrated circuitopter special program, fast
throttle response, betters all kinds of open source
software.
Throttle signal line is twisted wire to reduce crosstalk within the transmission signal
generated by the copper, so that more steady flight.
Supports refresh rates up to 621Hz throttle signal, harmonious with various flight controllers.
(Note: the throttle signal over 500Hz are all non-standard throttle signal)
Using MOSFET special driver integrated circuit, its operation and stability far surpass the
driving circuit with discrete components built.
3.2.3 Propeller
There are two coaxial motors on which the
carbon fiber propellers are mounted. The
propeller has a diameter of 13 inches and
pitch of magnitude 4 inches. The propeller
has a mounting hole of 7.7 mm.
Small, lightweight.
Specifications:
Frequency Range: 902 – 928 MHz (USA) / 915 – 928 MHz (Australia)
Output Power: 1W (+30dBm), controllable in 1dB steps ( +/- 1dB @ <20dBm, +/- 0.5dB
>=20dBm typical )
Air Data transfer rates: 4, 8, 16, 19, 24, 32, 48, 64, 96, 128, 192 and 250 kbit/sec ( User
selectable, 64k default )
UART data transfer rates: 2400, 4800, 9600, 19200, 38400, 57600, 115200 baud ( User
selectable, 57600 default )
Receive Sensitivity: >121 dBm at low data rates, high data rates (TBA)
Power Supply: +5 V nominal, (+3.5 V min, +5.5 V max), ~800 mA peak at maximum power
Temp. Range: -40 to +85 degree C
Features:
Specifications:
o Processor:
o Sensors:
o Interfaces:
Figure 3.14
Power Module
3.3.1 Motor
In order to control the attitude of the rocket, provide
trajectory corrections and preventing the rocket from
tipping over, four brushless motors are attached at the
nose of the rocket. The motors used are Emax Eco 2306
2400KV brushless motor. EMAX's ECO series focuses
on quality, affordable motors that are lightweight but
still remain durable. They are lightweight due to their
new bell design and still very durable due to the new
larger 9mm bearing.
This 2306 sized motor features a strengthened steel
hollow shaft, multi-strand windings for performance,
shaft screw, and larger 9x4mm bearings. Figure 3.15
Emax Eco Motor
25
Features
EZO bearing 9mm ODx4mm ID
Steel shaft
Dual anodizing
16x16mm hole pattern
Multi-strand copper winding
115mm 20 AWG silicone wire
Specifications
Framework: 12N14P
Length: 30.2mm
Diameter: 27.7mm
No. of cells: 3-4s 2300-2700kv range
Propeller: 5" - 6"
Light Weight: 28.3g (W/O Silicone Wire)
Prop adapter: M5
Bearing Shaft: 4mm
Shaft Thread: CW (Clock Wise)
Graphs:
1400 30
1200 35000 500
25 Figur
1000 30000
20 400
800 25000
Thrust 15
600 20000 300 Current
RPM
400 10 Power
15000
200
200 5
10000
0 100
0 25 50 75 100 5000 0
0 25 50 75 100
Throttle (%) 0 Throttle
0
0 25 50 (%)75
0 100
25 50 75 100
Figure 3.16 Thrust v/s F
Throttle
26
FC Specifications:
Target : OMNIBUSF4SD
BEC : 3.3V/5V/12V
Built-in OSD, user can adjust OSD parameters via Betaflight configurator
Support PPM / PWM / SBUS
Port : USB / Boot / PWM / PPM / SBUS / 12V Camera / 12V VTX / LED / Buzzer / ISP
ESC Specifications:
3.3.3 Propeller
The propeller will be mounted on the motor to produce thrust for controlling the attitude of
the rocket. The propeller has high pitch characteristic so that it can produce high thrust with
high RPM. Propeller used is DalProp T5040 V2 in the nose of the rocket. DalProp T5040 V2
tri-Blades CW CCW Propeller is generally used for Micro Quadcopters; each propeller has
excellent balance, low vibration. It is marked unbroken, high quality material, it is flexible
27
Specifications:
Length: 5 inch
Pitch: 4 inch
Material: PC (Poly Carbonate)
Weight: 5.3g
Hub ID Diameter: 5.02mm
Hub Thickness: 7.95mm
Adapter Rings: no
Color: Yellow Figure 3.21 5 inch Propeller
The 4S 14.8V 75c 1300mAh Lipo battery pack is a great choice for many small UAVs which
require high discharge rates. This battery packs a ton of power in a compact form factor,
giving high flight time and power required on the rocket. Tattu batteries provide high quality,
reliable power for your UAVs.
Specifications:
Capacity: 1300mAh
Voltage: 14.8V
Max Continuous Discharge: 75C
Max Burst Discharge: 150C
Weight: 154g
Dimensions: 75*35*30 mm
Balance Plug: JST-XH
Discharge Plug: XT-60
Charge Rate: 1-3C Recommended, 5C Max
Figure 3.22 4S Secondary
Features: Battery
Stable automatic stacking technology makes the single cell capacity able to reach
22000mAh.
The most strict single cell capacity, voltage, resistance, discharge curve matching process.
Superior Japan and Korea Lithium Polymer raw materials.
Almost 200Wh/kg energy density.
At least 150 times cycle life.
radio controlled model aircraft. Extending this setup with a laptop or tablet computer, data
and video telemetry, and aerials, creates what is effectively a Ground Control Station.
3.5.1 Overview
Mission Planner is a full-featured ground station application for the ArduPilot open source
29
autopilot project. This page contains information on the background of Mission Planner and
the organization of this site.
For the rocket, the home position is set as the location where the vehicle was armed. This
means if you execute an RTL, it will return to the location where it was armed, so it is armed
at the location which is safe for landing or a rally point is used to setup an alternative return
point.
Types of Commands
There are several different types of commands that can be used within missions:
Navigation commands are used to control the movement of the vehicle, including takeoff,
moving to and around waypoints, changing altitude, and landing.
DO command is for auxiliary functions and do not affect the vehicle’s position (for
example, setting the camera trigger distance, or setting a servo value).
Condition commands are used to delay DO commands until some condition is met, for
example the UAV reaches a certain altitude or distance from the waypoint.
Rally Points
property and a system running in RTL mode may very likely be in a state that merits extreme
caution! It is also possible that the flight plan is large enough that should the aircraft enter
RTL mode it is undesirable to traverse all the way back to the point of takeoff. Hence,
Mission Planner supports rally points. Should the rocket enter RTL and Rally Points have
been defined then it will proceed to the closest Rally Point, rather than proceeding to the
Home position. Rocket will then loiter at that location, and then perform an automated
landing there.
Limitations
1) Short mission legs: If the mission has closely spaced waypoints and the requested rewind
distance is greater than the distance covered by the last six waypoints that have been passed,
then the vehicle will resume on the ‘oldest’ waypoint stored.
2) Spline waypoints: This feature will work with spline waypoints. However, the accuracy
of the resume distance will be diminished as the distance calculation is based on a straight
line between navigation command locations.
Compass Calibration
Vehicle is held in the air and rotated it so that each side (front, back, left, right, top and
bottom) points down towards the earth for a few seconds in turn. Consider a full 360-degree
turn with each turn pointing a different direction of the vehicle to the ground. It will result in
6 full turns plus possibly some additional time and turns to confirm the calibration or retry if
it initially does not pass.
33
Accelerometer Calibration
Mission Planner will prompt you to place the vehicle each calibration position. Press any key
to indicate that the autopilot is in position and then proceed to the next orientation.
The calibration positions are: level, on right side, left side, nose down, nose up and on its
back.
RC transmitters allow the pilot to set the flight mode, control the
vehicle’s movement and orientation and also turn on/off auxiliary
functions (i.e. raising and lowering landing gear etc.). RC Calibration
involves capturing each RC input channel’s minimum, maximum and
“trim” values so that ArduPilot can correctly interpret the input.
Figure 3.31 Transmitter
Mission Planner will show a summary of the calibration data. Normal values are around 1100
for minimum and 1900 for maximum.
In order to test out the strength of the model and designing the rocket CAD model,
Solidworks is used. Different parts have been designed on Solidworks such as Tail Base,
Motor Battery Base, Nose, Fuselage and many more.
Figure 4.4
Figure 4.3
Tail Thrust Fins
Thrust Motor Base
Figure 4.6
Figure 4.5
TTVS Battery Base
ACTVS Battery Base
37
The structural integral parts of the rocket will be manufactured by additive manufacturing –
3D printing with PLA+ material which has the tensile strength of 57.8MPa and 1.3GPa.
Apart from the 3D printed parts, materials such as balsa wood, carbon fiber rods, and carbon
fiber parts.
Introduction:
Process:
Fused filament fabrication (FFF), also known under the trademarked term fused deposition
modeling (FDM), derives from automatic polymeric foil hot air welding system, hot-melt
gluing and automatic gasket deposition. In fused deposition modeling, the model or part is
produced by extruding small beads or streams of material which harden immediately to form
layers. A filament of thermoplastic or other low melting point material or mixture is fed into
an extrusion nozzle head (3D printer extruder), where the filament is heated to its melting
temperature and extruded onto a build table. More recently, fused pellet deposition (or fused
particle deposition) has been developed, where particles or pellets of plastic replace the need
to use filament. The nozzle head heats the material and turns the flow on and off.
Typically stepper motors or servo motors are employed to move the extrusion head and adjust
the flow. The printer usually has 3 axes of motion. A computer-aided manufacturing (CAM)
software package is used to generate the G-Code that is sent to a microcontroller which
controls the motors. Plastic is the most common material for such printing. Various polymers
may be used, including acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS), polycarbonate (PC), polylactic
acid (PLA), high-density polyethylene (HDPE), PC/ABS, polyphenylsulfone (PPSU)
and high impact polystyrene (HIPS). In general, the polymer is in the form of a filament
fabricated from virgin resins. There are multiple projects in the open-sourced community
aimed at processing post-consumer plastic waste into filament. These involve machines used
to shred and extrude the plastic material into filament such as recyclebots. Additionally,
fluoropolymers such as PTFE tubing are used in the process due to the material's ability to
withstand high temperatures. This ability is especially useful in transferring filaments.
Material:
38
Polylactic Acid (PLA) ranks as one of the most popular materials for 3D printing, particularly
FDM. Its ease of use and minimal warping issues make PLA filaments the perfect starting
point for 3D printing. PLA is also one of the most environmentally-friendly 3D printing
materials and, unlike ABS, is biodegradable. Among other PLA advantages are also its low
cost and a wide assortment of colors and blends. However, the brittleness of the material
makes PLA more suitable for non-functional prototyping, decorative and low-stress
applications.
Variety of color and blending options: PLA is easily pigmented and comes in a diverse range
of colors and blends. The material can also be mixed with wood, carbon and even metal,
whilst pigments can also be added t to get luminescent or glittery filaments. This makes the
choice of PLA blends virtually endless.
Easy post-processing: PLA prints can be easily sanded, polished and painted, allowing for an
improved surface finish with relatively little effort. You can also drill, mill and glue PLA
parts — but be careful not to melt the part. To prevent melting your PLA part, simply keep
the process slow and the tools cold (you can achieve this with water, WD-40 or proper
cutting fluid).
Biodegradable: PLA is an eco-friendly material, as it is biodegradable, non-toxic and also
requires less energy to 3D print and emits fewer greenhouse gases than petroleum-based
materials. Compared to petroleum-based thermoplastics, which take thousands of years to
break down, PLA parts can typically (naturally) break down within a few years, or even
months.
PLA has low heat resistance, and therefore cannot be used for high temperature applications.
In high temperatures, PLA can rapidly deform, especially if under stress.
39
While PLA containers are food safe when not 3D printed, PLA is not food safe when 3D
printed. This is because the 3D printing process creates tiny gaps and pores between the
layers of your print. These gaps tend to keep moisture and bits of food, leading to a build-up
of bacteria and mold.
When heated, PLA filament is prone to oozing, meaning that your printer’s extruder can leak
out a lot of plastic when moving between segments of a print. This creates strings between
the separate areas of your part, which can result in a flawed print. A cooling fan is therefore
required to prevent this issue.
Figure 4.14 L/D v/s Angle of Attack Figure 4.15 Cm v/s Angle of Attack
41
achieve higher L/D, causes to increase a drag loss during ascent flight, that is, worse the
launch characteristic performance. Moreover, the fineness ratio relates to weight efficiency
Therefore, the fineness ratio of vehicle and the ballistic factor must be carefully chosen in
accordance with the mission requirements. Figure 4.13 shows one of the desirable shapes
obtained from the trade-off studies to achieve high L/D for nose and base entries. The
fineness ratios for the nose and base entry vehicles are 3.725 and 1.931, respectively. These
L/D characteristics with respect to angle of attack between 0 and 180 degrees are shown in
Fig 4.14.
42
5.1 Schedule
5.2 Milestones
Table 3: Milestones
No. Milestone Name Milestone Description Timeline
Week no.
1 Research on Literature Establishment of the literature gap 1-4
through research on previous papers
2 Design of rocket Solidworks 2019 to be used for the 5-6
design of rocket. Estimation of
Centre of Gravity and Centre of
Pressure to be done by the CAD
model.
3 Manufacturing of Rocket Ribs Hot Wire Cutting Techniques to be 7-8
used for manufacturing Rocket Ribs
for increasing the overall strength
and rigidity of the rocket.
4 Additive Manufacturing Primary Motor Mount is to 3D 9-10
printed with PLA material for high
strength. Motor mount is to be
integrated with carbon fibre rod and
plates on which two motors are
mounted co-axially. The motor
mounts for Nose Thrust Vectoring
System are 3D printed to maintain
aerodynamic structure and rigidity.
5 Rocket Assembly Epoxy and Fibreglass cloth are used 11-12
to reinforce the Depron sheets and
balsa wood sticks. The rocket fins are
integrated with the balsa wood sticks
to ensure their endurance in case of
rough landings. Adequate ducts are
made for mounting electronics. The
battery bay is secured and reinforced
43
6. Project Demonstrations
No.
The rocket has a flight computer that records and measures different characteristics like
altitude, attitude, vibrations, battery consumed etc. This data is sent via serial communication
through a communication module RFD900+. This module transmits the data at 915MHz at a
baud rate of 57500. The module has a range of 30kms so all the data is transmitted to the
Ground Control System (GCS).
Figure 4.20
e Yaw Attitude v/s Time
Figure 4.25 Groundspeed v/s Time Figure 4.26 Airspeed consumed v/s Time
48
7. Cost Analysis
e
50
8. Summary
The completion of project provided many insights in the field of Unmanned Aerial Systems.
The aerodynamic capabilities, technical aspects, autonomous flight control, communication
systems and ground control systems are some of the attributes of the project that were
developed during its development. The project achieved its goal, mainly of attaining a VTOL
Flight. The guidance control of the rocket was carried by onboard sensors and computing
systems. The Ground Control Station with the help of Mission Planner was used properly to
control all the aspects of the rocket and telemetry data was displayed and recorded at the
GCS. All the telemetry data will be wirelessly transmitted to a ground control station (GCS).
The guidance system can be manually controlled via GCS or it can be automated. The rocket
performed autonomous flights with the help of onboard computing systems according to a
pre-determined flight plan. The rocket is manufactured majorly with Depron foam, balsa
wood sticks and carbon fiber composites. Due to the VTOL approach of the rocket, it has the
capability of automatic Take-Off and Landing which has a very wide use of applications,
such as logistics delivery, aerial photography, inspections, STEM activities and many more.
51
9. References
[1] Yoshifumi Inatani, Yoshihiro Naruo and Koich Yonemoto, 2001. Concept and
Preliminary Flight Testing of a Fully Reusable Rocket Vehicle. Journal of Spacecraft
and Rockets, Vol. 38, No. 1.
[4] Manas Kumar Das, P. Muthu Kumar and A. Anitha, 2017. ORBOT – An efficient and
Intelligent Mono Copter. IEEE International Conference on Circuits and Systems
(ICCS).
[5] Inatani, Y., Naruo, Y., and Yamada, T., “A Concept of Reusable Sounding Rocket with
Enhanced Maneuverability and Operability,” Proceedings of the 20th International
Symposium on Space Technology and Science, International Symposium on Space
Technology and Science, Tokyo, 1996, pp. 1165–1170.
[6] Cook, S. A., "X-33 Reusable Launch Vehicle Structural Technologies," AIAA Paper 96-
4563, 1996.
[7] Gaubatz, W., Nowland, D., Charette, R., Leonard, B., Schweikle, D., Smiljanic, R.,
Dumbacher, D. and Sponable, L., C., J., "Summary Report on the Delta Clipper -
Experimental Flight Demonstration Programs," IAF-97-V.3.08,1997