Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter - 4.curriculum Implementation
Chapter - 4.curriculum Implementation
OVERVIEW
Introduction
ACTIVITY
Read the newspaper report at the beginning of the chapter and answer the
following questions
1. What are some suggestions proposed for making homework fun and
meaningful?
2. Do you agree with the statement that teachers should not ‘spoon-feed’ but
rather be ‘guides to learning’ ? Why?
3. Give other suggestions for making homework meaningful and fun.
It should be realised that a particular curriculum change may not exactly fit
according to the five categories given. But, the categories are general enough to help
you plan change and arrange resources to bring about the change. However, you should
be aware that change is not synonymous with improvement and you might decide that
change should not be undertaken.
SELF-TEST
3) What are the five types of curriculum change listed by
McNeil. Give examples of each category other than those
given in the text.
4) Identify other categories of curriculum change which you have
come across but does not fit into those given above.
Resistance to Change
As mentioned earlier, bringing about change is not an easy task. There are many
barriers to the successful implementation of a curriculum. If you are given the job of
implementing a curriculum, whether it be in the school system, college, university or
training center, you will encounter people resisting change. Keep things as they are!.
Many people think that it is easier to keep things as they are. We often hear people say,
“If it is not broken, why fix it”. People are happy with the current situation in their
institution and feel that the change suggested will not meet the objectives of the school,
college or training centre. The status quo tends to be maintained when the persons
introducing change are themselves not clear as to the intent and what is required of the
new programme. To make matters worse, the implementation of the programme is
poorly planned.
Teachers who are to implement the curriculum frequently view change as
meaning more work. An addition to their already overloaded schedule and there is no
extra money or reward for the extra work they have to put in. Also, they view new
curriculum programmes will require them to learn new teaching skills and competencies
which will mean attending courses and seminars. It has also been found that teachers or
practitioners tend to reject pedagogical practices or teaching methods that challenge
what they are currently doing. They are reluctant to change or modify their current
instructional strategies and understandings of classroom practice.
Why People Resist Change?
Let us examine in more detail why people resist change. By knowing why
people resist change, it may be possible to plan more effective strategies to overcome
resistance and improve receptivity to change. Persons charged with the implementation
of a curriculum must understand how people react to change and how to encourage them
to be receptive to change. Fundamentally, there are seven reasons why people resist
change (Harvey, 1990; Woldring, 1999; Lippitt, 1966).
a) People resist because they do not understand – they simply do not follow
what is being introduced. They do not understand where they are going. They
are not clear as to what is required of them.
Overcome:
The key is ‘communication’. You have to explain to them “Why”. You have to
answer the Why, What, When, How and Where questions. Remember the
effectiveness of a communication is not the ‘message sent’ but of the ‘message
received’
b) People resist because of lack of ownership – Individuals will not accept change
if they consider it coming from outside their institution. Unfortunately, most
curriculum reform efforts are initiated from the outside whether it be at the
national, state or district level.
Overcome:
You have to convince teachers that even though it comes from the outside, their
view and opinions have been considered at the planning and design stages of
curriculum development. You will have to involve teachers in exploring the
relevance of the new curriculum and give them the freedom to explore the new
skills needed for utilizing or implementing the curriculum and to learn together
with their colleagues. This will get them to feel that they are an important part of
the curriculum implementation process.
SELF-TEST
1) Why do people resist change?
2) Suggest other reasons why people resist change.
ACTIVITY
1) What are some of the reasons given for poor implementation of the local
curriculum content (LCC)?
2) To what extent is such flexibility is given to teachers in your country?
People Involved in Curriculum Implementation
Teachers
Without doubt, the most important person in the curriculum implementation
process is the teacher. With their knowledge, experience and competencies, teachers
are central to any curriculum improvement effort. Regardless of which philosophical
belief the education system is based on, there is no denying that teachers influence
students’ learning. Better teachers foster better learning. Teachers are most
knowledgeable about the practice of teaching and are responsible for introducing the
curriculum in the classroom.
The key to getting teachers committed to an innovation is to enhance their
knowledge of the programme. This means teachers will need be training and workshops
have to be organised for professional development. Unfortunately, in any curriculum
implementation process not all teachers will have the benefit of such exposure. There
are just too many teachers and insufficient funds to go around. The most common
approach is to have one-day workshops given by experts with the lecture method being
the dominant pedagogical strategy. To get teachers to implement a new curriculum
requires a paradigm shift. Among the many extrinsic factors identified that may impede
curriculum change are resource adequacy, time, school ethos and professional support.
The intrinsic factors are; professional knowledge, professional adequacy and
professional interest and motivation. (see Table 4.1).
Hence, professional development of teachers is as an important factor
contributing to the success of curriculum implementation. To what extent have teacher
education programmes required prospective teachers to study curriculum development?
Some view teachers as technicians and as such do not include curriculum development
in their teacher education programmes. [Did you study curriculum development in your
training as a teacher?] Certainly an adequate education of teachers must include
curriculum development (both the theory and the work of curriculum development) if
teaching is to be a profession and if educational opportunities for learners are really to
be improved.
Factors Description
Adequacy of equipment, facilities and general
Adequacy of resources resources required of implementing the new
curriculum
[source: Edgar Friendenberg, Coming of Age in America. New York: Random House]
Students
There is a tendency among curriculum implementers to ignore the role of
students as agents of change. Increasingly, there is the realisation that even primary
school children can contribute to meaningful change.
Principals
Principals are key to the success of the implementation process in a school. They
require in-depth knowledge of the planned change and of the implementation process.
The must be committed to the change and be able to employ a variety of leadership
strategies to meet the needs of teachers. These strategies might include: being accessible
and openly willing to communicate with others involves in the process, building on the
strengths available in the staff, providing professional development opportunities for
staff, providing outside expertise when required, being willing to take risks; and being
positive about the planned change and using this optimism to motivate others.
ACTIVITY
England’ National Curriculum for Secondary Schools
The law requires that all maintained schools provide for all pupils a balanced
and broadly based curriculum which provides for all pupils to learn and achieve;
promotes students’ spiritual, moral, cultural, mental and physical development;
prepares students for the opportunities, responsibilities and experiences of adult life.
The following subjects must be taught:
English
Mathematics
Science
Design and Technology
Information and Communication
Technology
History
[Source: Key Stage 3 National Strategy: Designing the Key Stage 3 Curriculum, Department for
Education and Skills. England.]
LEARNING CONTENT
GOALS
LEARNING ASSESSMENT
EXPERIENCES TASKS
Teaching Learning
Methods Activities
These three approaches may be extreme, but there are some teachers
who fall into one of these categories. These teachers may not follow the
curriculum or follow the plan in general terms. All three approaches may
not specify the instructional objective or learning outcomes students are
expected to accomplish. In most cases, teachers adopt an eclectic
approach, i.e. they combine one or more methods.
Instructional objectives or learning outcomes are statements indicating
what you want students to know, to do and to value after having
completed a lesson. Why instructional objectives? Instructional objectives:
make it clear to teachers what changes they want student to
achieve
help in choosing the appropriate learning experiences to achieve
the changes or learning desired
inform students of what is expected of them
indicate what will be important in assessing the lesson
Key Terms
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:
2. “In the last 100 years, only two institutions have not changed very much;
namely, religious institutions and the school”.
a) To what extent do you agree with the statement regarding schools?”.
b) Why do you think schools have been slow to change?
READINGS