Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3 minute read
April 2021
The Water Break Test as a Surface Measurement
Gauge
Author: Brighton Science
Topics: Surface Science, Bonding & Sealing Processes
The water break test is a common way for manufacturers to test the surface
cleanliness of metals. Compared to other legacy cleanliness tests, it is relatively
simple to perform, however, the results rely almost entirely on the subjective eye of
the person performing the test.
contaminants, the water can introduce contaminants to the surface and can lead to
inaccurate test results.
IoT and leveraging the power of data is transforming the way manufacturers collect
and analyze test results. Water break tests are not well suited for manufacturers who
are seeking to gain actionable, traceable and quantitative test results about surface
quality. Data-driven process control requires sophisticated testing methodologies that
can seamlessly capture all relevant surface analytics data.
The ASTM-F22 Handbook sets the standard for water break tests. To perform a test, a
material is dipped into water and withdrawn vertically. In some instances, the water is
sprayed or poured onto the surface. The technician performing the test visually
evaluates the behavior of the water on the surface. The technician’s analysis is
subjective.
For strong, reliable adhesion, a material needs to have a high surface energy in order
to be chemically attractive to the adhesion, paint, ink or other coating that will be
applied to it. A clean surface generally has high energy and, in the case of the water
break test, should result in the water sliding off the surface in an unbroken sheet. If
the surface is clean the water will spread out due to its attraction to the surface. The
reaction of the water to the surface can strongly correlate to adhesion ability. Water is
an excellent indicator of surface energy but when applied in a subjective, difficult to
control manner, as it is in the water break test, the results aren’t suitable for process
control in the modern manufacturing process.
Water break tests are used primarily for metals to identify the presence of
contaminants on incoming raw materials or after surface processes, such as etching,
https://www.brighton-science.com/blog/the-water-break-test-as-a-surface-measurement-gauge 2/6
11/23/2022 The Water Break Test as a Surface Measurement Gauge
Drying time is another constraint of the water break test. A significant amount of time
needs to be allocated for the part to dry after the test. This can include a manual wipe
of the part or a baking process — either process can transfer contaminants or alter
the surface chemistry of the part in an unintended way.
Although technicians can be trained regarding how to conduct a water break test,
there are no definitive pass/fail standards for the water break test. This leaves test
results vulnerable to inconsistent standards both within a company and throughout
specific industries. This highly subjective test does not support the rigorous accuracy
needs required in tightly controlled manufacturing industries.
A lack of test sensitivity is another weakness of the water break test. Although a
surface may appear clean visually, it could actually be contaminated. Multiple tests on
the same surface can yield conflicting results. False positives, that indicate the
surface is clean when it is actually contaminated, are quite common with this test.
The Surface Analyst has the ability to measure any surface or surface orientation,
regardless of shape, size, geometry or roughness. Unlike a water break test that
https://www.brighton-science.com/blog/the-water-break-test-as-a-surface-measurement-gauge 3/6
11/23/2022 The Water Break Test as a Surface Measurement Gauge
Results of the water contact angle measurement are available instantly so action can
be taken immediately if contamination is detected. The automatic calculation of
contact angle removes operator subjectivity. The Surface Analyst measures on a
cleanliness scale as opposed to a binary go/no go result. Measurements taken with
the Surface Analyst can more closely map out a surface's characteristics.
Manufacturers can know precise contamination levels and contamination locations.
To find out more about an alternative to the water break test, download the
"Manufacturer's Roadmap to Eliminating Adhesion Issues in Production" eBook. This
guide gives clear insight into eliminating guesswork around adhesion so
manufacturers can achieve consistent and successful results.
https://www.brighton-science.com/blog/the-water-break-test-as-a-surface-measurement-gauge 4/6
11/23/2022 The Water Break Test as a Surface Measurement Gauge
Related Posts
Read
Read
https://www.brighton-science.com/blog/the-water-break-test-as-a-surface-measurement-gauge 5/6
11/23/2022 The Water Break Test as a Surface Measurement Gauge
Read
Expertise
Solutions
Industries
Knowledge
Blog
Contact Us
Shop
Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Press Enquiries
ISO 9001:2015 Certification
© 2022 Brighton Science. All rights reserved.
https://www.brighton-science.com/blog/the-water-break-test-as-a-surface-measurement-gauge 6/6