Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IT Doesn't Matter
IT Doesn't Matter
Session-1
Menti.com 56 07 306
Introduction
What N. Carr did not say in his article "IT Doesn't
Matter.”
There is no need of IT
Section A
Introduction
1968 – Ted Hoff, Intel Engineer, discovered a way to put circuits
for computer processing on a silicon chip.
Today CEOs often talk about strategic value of IT, and have even created
the CIO senior leader position in many organizations.
The premise of the reading article is that IT has become a commodity that is a
business essential and management should focus on risk management in lieu of
trying to achieve scarce competitive advantages.
Technology as a Competitive Advantage
• Proprietary Technology
Defined as a technology that can be owned actually or effectively by one
company.
Example: Pharmaceutical Company: Patent on Compound
• Infrastructural Technology
Defined as technology that can not be protected and in contrast to
proprietary technology is worth more to the economy as a whole when
shared
Example: Railroad or Electricity
• Market Changes
in addition to improving operations dramatic broad market changes occur due to
infrastructural technology.
Example: Railroads in the mid1800s
• The Trap
Executives make a mistake and assume that these advantages are
sustainable when they are brief due to the technology becoming broadly
adopted.
• IT has all the characteristics of a infrastructural
technology.
–it is a transport mechanism – carries digital information.
–it has more value when shared than when used in isolation.
• Standardization
each stage in the evolution of IT has increased the standardization and
homogenization.
“Highly replicable – the most pure commodity – bytes of data.”
Nicholas G. Carr
Greatest IT Risk?
•Overspending…
–As costs fall, new capabilities rise and business increases reliance
on IT companies continue to invest resources towards large
investments from big hardware and software suppliers.
IT doesn’t matter.
“The commoditization of IT and its competitive
advantage.”
Richard Hunter
Marianne Broadbent
Mark McDonald
“Now that some of the IT mystique has been eliminated,
corporate IT has to play by the same rules as everyone else.”
Letter from Bruce Skaistis
“IT never mattered. What matters are the people who invent
technologies and who deploy and use them.”
Letter from Mark S. Lewis
“IT is not the headline, it certainly matters (just like kidneys) because
the work systems cannot operate without IT.”
Letter from Steven Alter
IT matters.
• What is the role of IT?
• What are IT strategies?
• What should CEO/CIO focus on?
• etc.
Your Mandate
In The Coming Days as Being Manager
You will not debate but definitely will put
your mandate on:
IT matters a Lot
IT doesn’t matter
The Five Digital Forces
• The past provides valuable insights about how to
adapt to the present wave of disruptive technologies
and inventive business models.
• While history can be a valuable guide, digital forces
are at work reshaping the industry in new ways.
• The convergence of information goods, powerful
computing devices, and inexpensive digital
communication is changing business and society
through five digital forces:
• globalization, Millenialization, prosumerization,
business virtualization, and platformization
Globalization Millennialization of consumers
• reshapes the nature of supply and demand. the resulting digitally-centric lifestyle, has
• As artificial barriers disappear, consumers turned consumers into producers,
enjoy a new world of choice no longer empowered individuals to share their voices
limited by geographic borders. and influence others, and transformed the
• benefit from larger markets and global way people evaluate and consume products
sourcing, while concurrently protecting and services – whether digital or physical.
challenges from foreign competitors.
Business virtualization
Prosumerization • empowers firms to focus on their core
brought about by shrinking costs and the strengths by partnering with outside firms
increasing quality of the tools needed to create that can better execute other business
saleable information products, has lowered the processes.
break-even point for producers and given birth • virtualization can reduce costs, increase
to low-overhead startups that can compete agility, and boost quality by moving some
directly with capital-intensive (and sometimes process steps to companies that excel in
debt-burdened) incumbents. those specific functions.
Digital platforms
• the systems of engagement through which critical pieces of the value chain are delivered.
• technology-mediated networks provide the interface that brings together suppliers,
customers, and third parties into a mutually-reinforcing synergy.
• replacing traditional middlemen and can often serve to level the playing field by granting
small players and new entrants access to formerly closed markets.
• Managers need a set of stable strategic tools for
navigating through the tempestuous changes
caused by the confluence of globalization,
Millennialization, prosumerization, virtualization,
and the rise of digital platforms.
Firms who spend more of their total IT spend on new initiatives (dashed box) had statistically
significantly higher industry adjusted growth and margins – MIT CISR study, July 2008 (95 firms).
Firms Have an IT Portfolio with Four Asset Classes
• Transactional IT: automates processes, cuts costs or increases the
volume of business a firm can conduct per unit cost, e.g., order
processing, bank cash withdrawal, billing, accounting and other
repetitive transaction processing functions
• Informational IT: provides information for managing, accounting,
reporting and communicating internally and with customers,
suppliers and regulators, e.g., decision support, accounting,
planning, control, sales analysis, customer relationship and Cyber
security (IT Act 2000)/Sarbanes-Oxley reporting systems
• Strategic IT: supports entry into a new market, development of new
products or capabilities, and innovative implementations of IT.
Example: Expert systems/AI based systems/ATMs
• Infrastructure IT: provides the foundation of shared IT services
(both technical and human) used by multiple applications, e.g.,
servers, networks, laptops, shared customer databases, help desk,
application development
• A project may be any combination of all four.
Rethinking IT as an Investment Portfolio — Four
Different Asset Classes
Tracking the Impact of Information
Technology Investments
Source: P. Weill & M. Broadbent, Leveraging the New Infrastructure: How market leaders capitalize on IT, Harvard
Business School Press, June 1998.
The Four IT Asset Classes Have Different
Risk Return Profiles
How IT creates value –understanding through
Enterprise Architecture – Maturity Stages
• Enterprise Architecture is no static, one-time issue. As a company’s
business undergoes changes, an enterprise architecture needs to get adapted
as well.
• The journey starts with the business silo architecture.
• Therein companies primarily make IT investments to meet local business
needs.
• Passing through the two other stages, which are often called “standardized
technology” and “optimized core”, the journey ultimately leads to the
business modularity stage (enterprise SOA).
• It is quite obvious that this evolution of the enterprise architecture
implicates changes within the organization, especially of the role of the
enterprise architect.
Ref: Ross, Jeanne W.; Weill, Peter; Robertson, David C.: Enterprise Architecture as a Strategy. Havard Business
School Press. August 1, 2006
Information Systems and the
Competitive Advantage
Session 1-2
Associate Professor-
IT & Systems
Outline
• How are information systems transforming business?
and why are they so essential for running and managing a business
today? – Recap
Customer
An increasingly service
Networked through
Social Media
World
• Technology
– Cloud computing
– Big data and the Internet of Things (IoT)
– Mobile digital platform
• Management
– Online collaboration and social networking software
– Business intelligence
– Virtual meetings
What’s New In Management Information Systems (2 of 2)
• Organizations
– Social business
– Telework/now work from home/online learning
– Co-creation of business value
Globalization Challenges and Opportunities: A Flattened World
Operational
excellence
New products,
Survival services, and
business models
MIS and
Business
Customer and
Competitive supplier
advantage intimacy
Improved
decision making
Strategic Business Objectives of Information
Systems
• Firms invest heavily in information systems to
achieve six strategic business objectives:
1. Operational excellence
2. New products, services, and business models
3. Customer and supplier intimacy
4. Improved decision making
5. Competitive advantage
6. Survival
Operational Excellence
• Information system
– Set of interrelated components
– Collect, process, store, and distribute information
– Support decision making, coordination, and
control
• Information vs. data
– Data are streams of raw facts
– Information is data shaped into meaningful form
Figure 1.3: Data and Information
What Is an Information System? (2 of 3)
• Feedback
– Output is returned to appropriate members of
organization to help evaluate or correct input
stage
• Computer/computer program vs. information
system
– Computers and software are technical foundation
and tools, similar to the material and tools used to
build a house
Figure 1.4: Functions of an Information System
Dimensions of Information Systems
• Organizations
• Management
• Technology
Figure 1.5: Information Systems Are More Than
Computers
Dimensions of Information Systems:
Organizations (1 of 2)
• Hierarchy of authority, responsibility
– Senior management
– Middle management
– Operational management
– Knowledge workers
– Data workers
– Production or service workers
Figure 1.6: Levels in a Firm
Dimensions of Information Systems:
Organizations (2 of 2)
• Separation of business functions
– Sales and marketing
– Human resources
– Finance and accounting
– Manufacturing and production
• Unique business processes
• Unique business culture
• Organizational politics
Dimensions of Information Systems:
Management
• Managers set organizational strategy for
responding to business challenges
• In addition, managers must act creatively
– Creation of new products and services
– Occasionally re-creating the organization
Dimensions of Information Systems: Technology
• Complementary assets
– Examples of organizational assets
• Appropriate business model
• Efficient business processes
– Examples of managerial assets
• Incentives for management innovation
• Teamwork and collaborative work environments
– Examples of social assets
• The Internet and telecommunications infrastructure
• Technology standards
➢ A MIS is:
• Integrated user-machine system
• For providing information
• To support the operation,management, analysis and
decision making functions
• In an organisation
➢ This system utilises
• Computer h/w & s/w
• Manual procedures
• Models for analysis, planning, control and decisions
making &
• A database
85
Conclusion