Taiwan Democracy: The China's Challenge - A Study on Taiwan's External

Threat and Political Tolerance

Olegario, Jamjan S.
Politics and Governance of Southeast Asian Countries
24 October 2021

Abstract
Taiwan has gotten passing marks with respect to holding clean choices and getting
political opportunities. Everybody intensely maintains famous government on a crucial level and
everything considered underwrites the island's system basically. Concerning execution,
regardless, the political system doesn't do as such well. This is mostly an immediate consequence
of a lot of essential factors. Picking the president and lawmaking body on a majoritarian premise
develops a degree of polarization and frustrates the creation of technique compromises.
Irregularly, social and political powers attempt to circumvent the establishments of specialist
government through mass battles. They can frustrate what they conflict with anyway can't deal
with the issues that actuated their action regardless. Taiwan's economy is creating; adolescents
need business openings; the general population is developing; and the pace of birth is particularly
low. The most troublesome issue is CHINA and its cravings with respect to Taiwan. Hence, the
stakes for Taiwan's larger part leads framework are high. A failure to perform well would be a
misfortune. The finding of this survey will have huge methodology ideas for Taiwan's young
larger part runs framework and will moreover hold basic theoretical repercussions for the
examination of political versatility under dangers.

Introduction
Taiwan's arrangement of encounters is stacked up with both trouble and
accomplishments, and the makers of this arrangement of encounters are people of Taiwan.
Throughout late numerous years, we have beaten trouble and worldwide separation to achieve
one of current political history's best changes. The crucial components of this achievement have
been constancy, virtuoso, rationale, and a headstrong refusal to give up. Understanding both the
touchy generally speaking impact in the area and the necessity for help, the Taiwanese
understand that sensible joint exertion is routinely better contrasted with being disorderly or
daring and that an excitement to help is better contrasted with endeavoring to actuate or compel a
system on others. While people of Taiwan have not for the most part refined arrangement, later
some time, a total person has emerged. Through our relationship with the rest of the world, we
have held characteristics that we have made our own, mixing them with neighboring practices to
make a liberal, moderate solicitation and one more sensation of being Taiwanese.
At the center of this character is our embrace of larger part manages framework,
reflecting a choice that the Taiwanese made and combat for following a really long time of
dictator rule. At the point when the Taiwanese had made that choice, there was no recollecting.
Deficient anyway it may be, democratic government has transformed into a nonnegotiable piece
of what our personality is.
A fundamental piece of this democratic government is a firm conviction that the destiny
of Taiwan is to be picked by the Taiwanese through implies. Though Taiwanese to a great extent
fluctuate in their sensation of what definitively this future should look like, we are participated in
our commitment to famous government and the characteristics and establishments that grant us
to fight back against outside attempts to break up our character and alter the way of life we
esteem. The phenomenal larger piece of us sees vote based framework as the best sort of
government for Taiwan and will do what is vital to ensure it. Those feelings are attempted every
day, at this point there is no doubt that people would rise should the genuine presence of Taiwan
be under risk.
This survey will furthermore enlighten how the new inward and external plan
impediments and methodology instruments going toward an emerging focus power impact its
optional systems and decisions. Technique makers in Taiwan are obliged by the country's local
democratization just as by China's political conditions. These issues push the Taiwanese to
layout systems planned to address troubles from China by considering the changing political
situation in the Chinese setting as regards its democratic advancement and thereafter accepting
reasonable measures. They furthermore face new procedure restrictions both inside through the
voices of going against local vested gatherings and somewhat through strain from China, on
which the Taiwanese economy is ending up being logically dependent. Democratization and
money related improvement have filled in as astounding instruments of attentiveness for the
Taiwanese government, yet they have moreover curbed the autonomy of its worldwide technique
as a middle power. This restricted autonomy shows that under normally interfacing inside and
outside conditions, focus powers find methods of using distinctive global procedure instruments
and that the bosses executing these plans show freedom while moreover battling with hindrances.

Review of Related Literature

Researchers of international relations have zeroed in on center abilities to clarify the
awkwardness in the force of nations and the attributes and jobs of the international strategy of
states with differing levels of force. In this investigation of Taiwan introduced in the
accompanying segment shows how Taiwan turned into a center power through democratization
and financial advancement in its uncommon security climate of overpowering military danger
from China and how such inward changes furnished global strategy leaders with new
international strategy instruments and imperatives.

Security Dangers and Political Turn of events

The outside military danger confronting Taiwan negatively affected Taiwan's political
advancement by achieving interior militarization or, as such, the development of a post state.
During Chiang Kai-Shek's dictator rule, the primary objective was to reestablish military power
and fabricate an army installation in Taiwan to battle the socialist system in the central area
(McBeath, 1979). The public safety emergency set off by the danger from Socialist China
engaged the KMT system to utilize the military and police powers, just as other security
associations, as political means to guarantee political security. Homegrown political protection
from the system was effectively vilified and afterward curbed as a deceptive demonstration
submitted in agreement with the CCP in the central area. The security danger from China
defended the Taiwanese government's creation and upkeep of solid coercive state associations,
which assumed exhaustive parts including the concealment of the vote-based development
(Martin et al, 2006). Strangely, be that as it may, the detachment from the central area and the
security danger from China additionally affected the democratization of Taiwan. Obviously, the
popularity-based races allowed at the neighborhood and common levels during the tyrant time
frame in Taiwan had constraints. An institutional game plan was likewise set up to guarantee
regular power changes by permitting these authorities just two terms (Mattlin, 2011).
Taiwan has developed into a popular government wherein the two significant ideological
groups vie for seats in the state council. Meanwhile, Taiwan saw three serene shifts in power the
KMT and the DPP, hence exhibiting that the nation's majority rules system, which depends on
cutthroat party governmental issues, is entering a phase of solidification (Rigger, 2014).
The undeniable democratization of Taiwan was the aftereffect of Taiwan's essential
undertakings and approaches pointed toward accumulating the help and acknowledgment of the
worldwide local area by recognizing the country from China. This outcome can be credited to the
strain on the Taiwanese decision elites to show the worldwide local area, particularly the US,
that Taiwan was unique in relation to tyrant China (deLisle, 2014).
The democratization-related political and planned choices made by strategy producers in
the point of view of cross-waterway dealings added to the democratization of Taiwan in a
genuinely tranquil and moderate way through the hierarchical undertakings of Chiang Ching-
Kuo and other decision elites with their arrangement with the elites on the rival side. Later this
fruitful democratization, Taiwan entered a phase set apart by the union of a vote based political
framework that obviously separated Taiwan from China.
Security Dangers and Monetary Turn of events
A veritable external military risk, especially in a security environment depicted by
reliable receptiveness to possible military attacks with respect to a confined nation, most
certainly prompts incredibly military spending (Deger and Smith, 1983). Taiwan has an
outrageous watchman monetary arrangement to protect itself from China. Though this
gatekeeper to-Gross domestic product extent widely decreased during the 2000s, the extent was
higher than that of China over the span of later seemingly forever adjacent to during the 1990s.
The strategic risk from China has contributed distinctly to Taiwan's money related improvement
by giving Taiwan the motivation for monetary progression to its strategic capacities against
China, upgraded by system assesses that achieve quick monetary advancement through state-
drove industrialization. The KMT framework achieved monetary improvement by propelling
state-drove industrialization subject to the developmental state model during the 1960s-1980s.
Monetary nationalism and the persuading need to observe the financially more exceptional China
made it useful for the KMT framework to set up an accommodating state-business relationship
propelling item drove industrialization and quick money related turn of events (Swim, 1990).
Taiwan's money related headway can moreover be credited to the country's gathering of
ware organized monetary procedures and the US's security techniques against the socialist
collusion in the security environment during 1945 Virus Ward time. Key for the achievement of
Taiwan's item arranged methodology was the US's occupation in the Virus War security
environment. This system helped Taiwan with achieving its state-drove, exchange arranged
industrialization. To sum up, paying little mind to the hostile effects of the division and the
security risk from China on Taiwan's legislative issues and economy, Taiwan has achieved
democratization and monetary new development. The need to build up the country's material
capacities to be "militarily like China" determinedly added to Taiwan's monetary development,
and the fundamental ought to be "politically not in the slightest degree like China" to obtain the
assistance of the overall neighborhood isolating itself from China added to Taiwan's popularity-
based movement and normalization.
Emergency in Discretionary Acknowledgment
Taiwan's worldwide procedure pivoted around growing the country's adversary of
socialist accomplices, chipping away at its relationship with the America, holding China back
from joining the UN, and forestalling countries that stayed aware of optional relations with
Taiwan from trading positions and seeing China taking everything into account. Taiwan
endeavored to convince the overall neighborhood it was the sole certifiable lawmaking body of
the Chinese country. At the point when the socialist government was up in China, each socialist
country permitted China mollifying affirmation. In any case, a few non-socialist countries saw
China. This situation by the non-socialist countries can be credited to the generally hostile
attitude toward China because of its commitment in the Korean Conflict and the Virus War and
the US's adversary of socialist system toward China (Wang, 1990).
The number of countries staying aware of political relations with Taiwan fell distinctly
during this decade from 71 of each 1970 to 24 out of 1979, while the number of countries setting
up essential relations with China basically extended from 48 out of 1970 to 117 out of 1979. This
result was mostly achieved by Taiwan's unyielding methodology of describing countries going
into placating relations with China as undermining countries and cutting power joins with them
according to the brand name "not living individually with the Socialist framework under a
comparative sky." On the other hand, China pulled in various countries as optional accessories
by moving away from the firm politeness of strong guidelines, for instance, "threatening to
Western imperialism," "against private undertaking," and "worldwide socialist bombshell," and
coordinating toward versatile and utilitarian political techniques. In this way, Taiwan lost its
status in the UN in 1971. Japan and America set up political relations with China in 1972 and
1978, independently, in this way completing their affirmation of Taiwan (Wang, 1990).
Taiwan's optional presence in the worldwide neighborhood on declining. Taiwan couldn't
divert into a person from overall affiliations, the investment of which relies upon state power,
because of its lack of an UN seat and China's adherence to the "One China" system. Yet most
critical powers other than China had set up casual relations with Taiwan, Taiwan's specialists
defied limits in speaking with high-situating new specialists during their position visits to distant
countries, winding up in an astounding circumstance of staying aware of simply casual relations
through evident new specialists (Chen, 2016).
With incalculable countries cutting off appeasing ties with Taiwan inside a short period,
Taiwan attempted system changes to prevent further disasters and successfully looked out
political ties. It made some separation from its firm optional strategy, which had set off countries
to end their affirmation of Taiwan and go into connects with China during the 1970s, and took
the place that the country could stay aware of key relations, or develop new political relations,
with countries that had set up mollifying relations with China. In any case, this system change
couldn't dial back the example of changing optional associates from Taiwan to China (Hughes,
1994).
Getting Conciliatory Help
To compensate for the shortcoming rising up out of the shortfall of optional affirmation
in the overall neighborhood, used a strategy of building financial relations with potential and
genuine political accomplices. Taiwan's monetary accomplishment has provided the country with
a huge instrument of worldwide methodology. In the last piece of the 1980s and mid-1990s,
Taiwan gave tremendous extension new manual for past socialist countries. Various countries,
similar to Hungary and Poland, opened working environments in Taipei to do official
undertakings nonchalantly (Lee, 1993).
The Taiwanese government further uplifted its undertakings to hinder political separation
and expand its essential effect through unique gifts not solely to individual countries in Asia,
Africa, and South America yet notwithstanding unique worldwide affiliations. Taiwan offered
overall manual for stickup with affiliations or to convince states to cut off relations with China, a
preparation suggested as "dollar attentiveness" (Rich, 2019). For example, in the pre-summer of
1988, the Taiwanese government raised a US$ 10 billion progression save for the improvement
of Underdeveloped nations (Wang, 1990). In 1991, the public authority gave the US$ 150
million "Resource for the Financial and Social Advancement of Focal America" to the Focal
American Bank for Monetary Improvement to get interest in the bank subsequently. This
endeavor enabled Taiwan to develop political relations with the Bahamas, Belize, Grenada,
Nicaragua, Focal African Republic, Liberia, and Niger (Lee, 1993). To help its relationship with
its essential accomplices, especially those in Focal America, Taiwan in like manner gave military
assistance, adventure, and even gifts of weaponry and plane to countries with which it stayed
aware of formal relations (Rich et al, 2018).
China has extended its undertakings to separate Taiwan cautiously by utilizing strong
money circumspection, which raises a fundamental test to Taiwan. Taiwanese recommendations
of worldwide assistance are likely not going to be adequate to avoid incidents of its appeasing
accomplices since China will offer greater and more broad assistance packs than those Taiwan
had commonly given. China supposedly offered US$ 500 million to bring the Solomon Islands
into doing a switch in 2019 (Chen, 2019). An assistant of China Railroad Gathering denoted a
US$ 825 million concurrence with the Solomon Islands for a gold-mining project around a
similar time the country traded its affirmation system (Rich, 2019; Wen, 2019; Myers et al,
2019).
Seeing the shortcomings of using material capacity to match China for optional
affirmation, Taiwan has hoped to utilize regularizing technique for global methodology. Exactly
when the Solomon Islands and Kiribati changed their essential associations with China, Taiwan's
International concerns ensured that "China's camouflage of Taiwan in the overall field can't
change the evident reality of Taiwan's quality nor it compel the Taiwanese people into neglecting
their vote based and free way of life" (Myers et al, 2019). Taiwan endeavors to support its
temptation for various countries through reasonable characteristics to support its public
wellbeing by gaining the assistance of the overall neighborhood. Technique makers in Taiwan
attempt to adequately apply their political method of using vote-based guidelines as a global
procedure instrument reliant upon local democratization to the country's optional relations,
especially with the US and Western countries.

Body and Analysis

Taiwan emerges as a middle power using the anchors of democratization and monetary
headway in a security environment put aside by a strong and consistent military risk. The
assessment additionally recognized the characteristics of the worldwide methodology executed
by Taiwan as an emerging focus power by focusing in on the methodology instruments available
to and the prerequisites looked by its game plan designers. Meandering from the customary
position that a troublesome security environment as a strong external peril horribly impacts
political and monetary development, Taiwan fairly won in its change into a middle power, as
such appearance that dangers to security can in like manner well effect democratization and
financial progression. Taiwan's worldwide procedure weapons have been brushed by its
ceaseless enemy—China. By testing into Taiwan's worldwide procedure as a middle power, this
survey uncovered that monetary turn of events and political improvement advance the use of
material limits and guidelines as instruments for pursuing distinctive worldwide technique
targets in worldwide authoritative issues.
Regardless the way that monetary new development and democratization make the power
for a state to rise as a middle power, they in like manner limit a state's autonomy and power new
local and overall necessities on approach makers. These issues reveal association among inside
and external necessities. Taiwan's local democratization and China's policy driven issues, for
instance, the Tiananmen Square battles in 1989 and the Hong Kong displays in 2019, have arisen
as late deterrents that move global system makers in Taiwan to diagram moves toward that
enable the country to oversee China. These methodologies are grounded in a thought about the
movements to China's vote-based headway. Procedure makers in Taiwan similarly face new
inside approach necessities from local vested gatherings, whose debate is related to Taiwan's
monetary course of action toward China, and external constraints as pressure from China, on
which the Taiwanese economy dynamically depends. Democratization and monetary headway
have filled in as astounding placating measures for the Taiwanese government, but they have
also obliged the freedom of Taiwan's worldwide technique as a middle power.
The restricted autonomy in Taiwan shows that pinpointing the characteristics of
worldwide technique and understanding the improvement of a middle power require examining
significant local and worldwide qualities and the interchanges between these points. The
country's worldwide technique is impacted by various components, similar to the level of money
related new development and democratization in the country, the political and monetary traits of
battling countries, and the material and managing characteristics of the worldwide neighborhood.
Taiwan's worldwide methodology is especially impacted by countries and worldwide affiliations
that offer global procedure parts zeroed in on by the Taiwanese, as optional affirmation and
advancement. Global system makers are limited by arising local hardships and by the
development and norms of overall administrative issues. In any case, the undertakings and
achievements of system makers to develop and build up the instruments that are useful for
completing global technique (e.g., materials and principles) show the presence of an autonomy
that prepares for extending the scope of global procedure instruments utilized by Taiwan and the
destinations that it attempts to get from the overall society.
The record of Taiwan is one of adaptability—of a country keeping up with greater part
rule, moderate characteristics while going up against a consistent test to its existence. Our
thriving is an exhibition of not actually permanently set up expert of larger part governs
framework, depicted by incredible organization and straightforwardness, can achieve.
Nonetheless, the storyline of Taiwan isn't simply with respect to the upkeep of our own
popularity-based way of life. It is in like manner about the strength and familiarity with specific
assumptions Taiwan brings to attempts to protect the consistent quality of the space and the
world. Through troublesome work and mental determination, the 23.5 million people of Taiwan
have won with respect to making a spot for themselves in the worldwide local area territory.
Taiwan's refusal to give up, its industrious embrace of democratic government, and its
commitment to go probably as a trustworthy accomplice are presently pushing the rest of the
world to reexamine its value as a liberal majority rule framework on the forefronts of one more
struggle of methods of reasoning. As countries dynamically see the risk that the CCP presents,
they should fathom the advantage of working with Taiwan. Likewise, they should review that
assuming Taiwan some way or another ended up falling, the outcomes would be disastrous for
regional congruity and the popularity-based association structure. It would signal that in the
present overall test of characteristics, oppression enjoys the upper hand over larger part rule
government.
Beijing has never abandoned its cravings toward Taiwan. However, following a long time
of twofold digit interest in the Chinese military, and expansionist direct across the Taiwan
Waterway and in including ocean areas, Beijing is overriding its commitment to a peaceful
objective with an unyieldingly intense position. Beginning around 2020, Individuals' Freedom
Armed force plane and vessels have remarkably extended their activity in the Taiwan Waterway,
with for all intents and purposes consistently interferences into Taiwan's southern air security
recognizing verification zone, similarly as coincidental crossing points of the inferred center line
between the island and the Chinese focal region (which runs along the focal point of the stream,
from the upper east near Japan's fringe islands toward the southwest near Hong Kong).
Taiwan is totally devoted to working with other regional performers to ensure strength. In
Walk 2021, for example, Taiwan and the US denoted a notification of understanding on the
establishment of a coast watch working social affair. This working social affair will additionally
foster correspondence and information splitting between the U.S. besides, Taiwanese coast
screens, while in like manner working with more significant participation on shared objections,
for instance, saving maritime resources and diminishing unlawful, unreported, and unregulated
fishing. Such an arrangement should fill in as a springboard for more critical composed exertion
on nonmilitary issues with various associates in the Asia-Pacific.
Taiwan has furthermore dispatched a movement of drives to modernize and patch up its
military, to be more prepared for both present and future hardships. Regardless interests in
customary stages, for instance, fight plane, Taiwan has made hearty interests in upside down
limits, including adaptable land-based antiship journey rockets. We will kick off the Full-scale
Guard Preparation Office in 2022, a strategic change intended to ensure that an overall arranged
and extraordinary military hold power stays as a stronger support for the standard military
powers. Such drives are planned to expand Taiwan's certainty and preparation and to hail that we
will bear our piece of the weight and don't underrate our security accessories' assistance.
Taiwan's undertakings to add to nearby security don't end there. We are totally devoted to
cooperating with our neighbors to hinder outfitted conflict in the East China and South China
Oceans, similarly as in the Taiwan Waterway. Taiwan lies along the essential island chain, which
runs from northern Japan to Borneo; should this line be broken persuasively, the results would
upset worldwide trade and debilitate the entire western Pacific. Thusly, a failure to monitor
Taiwan would not solely be shocking for the Taiwanese; it would disturb a security plan that
enjoys thought about peace and excellent monetary headway in the area for quite a while.
Taiwan doesn't respect for military go head-to-head. It expects serene, consistent,
obvious, and ordinarily beneficial simultaneousness with its neighbors. However, on the spoiled
chance that its greater part controls framework and way of life are sabotaged, Taiwan will do
whatever it takes to secure itself.
A context-oriented examination on Taiwan can be an early phase for understanding the
extensiveness and identity of the worldwide procedure executed by focus powers. Further close
to relevant examinations should similarly be focused on the common attributes and differences
among the worldwide systems of focus powers and the causes and conditions related with such
shared characteristics and differentiations.

Conclusion
 As noted, intra-and between party parts, stand-up battle, orders, and populism reflect
dissatisfaction with the introduction of Taiwan's plan of specialist well known government. This
isn't uncommon to Taiwan, clearly. Diverse popularity-based frameworks share this show
brokenness, including the US. Taiwan faces an assortment of procedure issues, some coming
from its being an undeniable level economy and developing society. The public power spending
plan should somehow allot meager resources among monetary earnestness, advantages, and
defend. On energy security, chitchats over conflicting requirements, ensuring supply for
gathering, lessening normal pollution, finding the right mix between oil-based commodities and
renewables, confining release of nursery gasses, and keeping energy costs low, have impeded
itemizing of an acceptable course of action.
China's game plan yearnings add a momentous and significant difficult situation.
Conversation’s decay over the amount China includes a risk; what mix of comfort, self-
confirmation, anticipation, and plan with the US is legitimate; what which means of Taiwan's
legal status is appropriate; how to help a conscious methodology later some time; and how to
ensure satisfactory resources and political assistance for the procedure took on. It is a welcome
improvement that a movement of true choices has sustained the understanding supporting a
cautious, the same old thing technique, at this point the misrepresented method for managing
public discussion of the China challenge limits real discussion of the issues being referred to.
Thus, inconvenient issues don't helpfully yield straightforward game plans, but an open yet
isolated political system makes it much harder.
In any case the passing marks that Taiwan's popularity-based system consistently gets for
its political race circumstance and protection of political opportunities, it ought to be reviewed
considering the methodology hardships it faces and what is being referred to. High stakes
increase the prerequisite for common execution. Likewise, really, the PRC's longings for Taiwan
powers a high-stakes challenge for the island's bosses and its family. The outcome will likely
portray the island's somewhat long future.
This examination of Taiwan's spellbound and majoritarian structure and the way that
somewhat a couple of occupants have discussed their mistake with specialist vote put together
framework suggests that with respect to the outrageous issues, everyone could be unmistakably
overhauled by its picked administrators. That declaration isn't planned to berate their individual,
yet rather to feature arrangements of the system that make it harder for them to deal with the
outrageous issues. That a majoritarian structure overrepresents the bigger part and
underrepresents the minority doesn't work with compromise, particularly when the minority
party is weak. The chronicled scenery of the KMT's past tyrant rule, memories of which really
shape the political perception of the more settled age, fills polarization. There is an essential
individual to the island's political brokenness.
Taiwan had acquired from issues in dealing with the SARS plague of 2003. Also, the
power of the Tsai association was consolidated, real, and clear. People from everyone, who had
been related to use covers when they get a cold, didn't need official impact to do a comparative
when it went to the Coronavirus. People from the LY didn't politicize the issue, perhaps
considering the way that they understood the stakes. To lay it out simply, the political
organization, the technocracy, administrators, and general society collaborated to make an
admirable result. All concerned appreciated the stakes of frustration.
Taiwan's hidden deterrents to extraordinary methodology execution are not adequately
fixed. Any choice rather than majoritarianism would remain flawed, and it would require a set up
amendment to put together. In the event that there is a method of reducing the current division, it
apparently will require the tops of the two philosophical gatherings as far as possible on their
resistance: in assessing the possibility of procedure issues, particularly in regards to China; in
working harder to deliver compromises to determine those issues; and in saving the overall
dilemma political culture. This leave plan gives off an impression of being unrealistic, given the
steady, interparty struggle over the China issue. In any case, the stakes included are astoundingly
high and the cost of disillusionment would be not kidding. Assuming tireless political battle
makes an arrangement system decision unfathomable, a decision has been made at any rate.
Accomplishing Taiwan's vote-based advancement thirty years earlier was far from basic,
but it gave inhabitants a say on their future that they had never had. Inconvenient as the current
methodology hardships are, it would be an incident assuming that the course of action of
specialist government couldn't chart a decent way ahead for people the system should serve.

Sources:
Asian Development Bank. 2019. Fact Sheet. Accessed at https://www.adb.org/
publications/series/fact-sheets (23 October, 2021).
Lee, W. 1993. Taiwan’s Foreign Aid Policy. Asian Affairs: An American Review 20(1).
Mattlin, M. 2011. Politicized Society: The Long Shadow of Taiwan’s One-Party Legacy.
Copenhagen: Nordic Institute of Asian Studies.
Myers, S. et al. 2020. China Looms over Taiwan’s Election, Giving a Boost to the Incumbent.
NY Times (January 8).
Olson, E. 2001. Taiwan Is Cleared for Membership in WTO. NY Times (September 19).
Rich, T et al. 2018. Does Taiwan Need International Recognition? Asia Dialogue (March 12).
Rigger, S. 2014. Political Parties and Identity Politics in Taiwan. Stanford: Stanford University
Press.