Professional Documents
Culture Documents
U.S. history told as a single story, a narrative of nation building built on the
notion of progress.
A single U.S. experience (cfr. The Melting Pot)
Dismissal of facts, peoples, that did not conform to this narrative
Stereotyped Representation
“If you begin to look at American history from a Native American point of view, lots of things look different. The whole ‘noble’ history of American
expansion – which I remember in high school making me proud, as I looked on the map that the teacher put up there showing how we grew --
‘grew’ as if it were a biological thing, just ‘natural’ in our genes to grow – from this straggling bunch of colonies along the Atlantic across to the
Pacific.
In 1863, the very time that the Emancipation Proclamation had just been issued, an Army out in Utah was massacring a Shoshone tribe of
peaceful Indians to get that territory. In 1864, another massacre [took place] at Sand Creek, Colorado. Now, in how many historical accounts of the
Civil War do we learn about that?[ ….] If we don’t want … to repeat those horrors, then it seems to me that it’s absolutely necessary … to get away
from that nationalistic narrow white male elite point of view which is given to us in our history books.” (Howard Zinn, "A People's...")
Traditional Accounts
Omission, invisibility
Stereotyped representation
o Homogeneous group
o Savage
o Inarticulate: Westerns
DISTORTION
A process that takes place when people from outside a particular culture take elements of another culture in a way that is objectionable to that
group.
(Sociologist James O. Young qtd. in Dunbar-Ortiz and Gilio-Whitaker, ‘All the Real Indians Died Off’…)
Demands that Indian mascots be dropped from schools and sports teams.
2015: California 1st state to ban “Redskins” as a mascot name in public schools
Urban Outfitters: Navajo lawsuit for using the word “Navajo” for underwear and flasks
NATIVE AMERICANS 2
“The discovery of America [was one of] the two greatest and most important events recorded in the history of mankind”
Estimates about human settlement of the Americas IROQUOIS: ancestor fell from the sky
(70,000 b.p. – 12,000 b.p.)*
EVIDENCES
-Geology
-Vegetation
-Written records
-Pictographs
-Calendars on buffalo robes
-Oral traditions
Ice Age
20,000 years ago: Fisrt human crossings
Polytheistic religions
An Ecological Sense
Culture Areas
CORN
A summer crop. NO more than 20-30 days without water – complex irrigation systems
Herbal medicine
“The most striking feature of Native American society at the time the Europeans arrived was its sheer diversity. Each group had its own political
system and set of religious beliefs, and North America was home to literally hundreds of mutually unintelligible languages. Indians had no
sense of ‘America’ as a continent or hemisphere. They did not think of themselves as a single unified people, an idea invented by Europeans
and only many years later adopted by Indians themselves. Indian identity centered on the immediate social group-a tribe, village, chiefdom, or
confederacy. When Europeans first arrived, many Indians saw them as simply one group among many. Their first thought was how to use the
newcomers to enhance their standing in relation to other native peoples, rather than to unite against them. The sharp dichotomy between
Indians and ‘white’ persons did not emerge until later in the colonial era” (Foner, Eric. Give Me Liberty. 8)
NATIVE AMERICANS 3
NATIVE AMERICAN ORAL TRADITIONS
ORAL LITERATURE
o PRAYER: A REQUEST
o SONG: A DESCRIPTION
STORIES
PASSED DOWN FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION
o CULTURAL BACKGROUND OF COMMUNITIES
o NO NOTION OF AUTHORSHIP
o NATURAL PHENOMENON
o THE ORIGIN OF HUMANS
o THE CUSTOMS & RELIGIOUS RIGHTS OF A PEOPLE
o EVENTS BEYOND PEOPLE’S CONTROL
FUNCTION
LAUTER, PAUL, EDITOR. THE HEATH ANTHOLOGY OF AMERICAN LITERATURE. HEATH AND COMPANY, 1994. VOL. 1 & 2.
PIONEERING IN INCLUDING “NATIVE AMERICAN ORAL LITERATURES”
o HEATH ANTHOLOGY
LOUISE ERDRICH
LOVE MEDICINE (1984), THE BEET QUEEN (1986), TRACKS (1988), THE BINGO
PALACE (1994), AND TALES OF BURNING LOVE(1997), THE LAST REPORT ON
THE MIRACLES AT LITTLE NO HORSE (2001), FOUR SOULS (2004)
"THE RED CONVERTIBLE" (SHORT STORY)
CONTEMPORARY ISSUES
LAND
“INDIANS SAW LAND, THE BASIS OF ECONOMIC LIFE FOR BOTH HUNTING
AND FARMING SOCIETIES, AS A COMMON RESOURCE, NOT AN ECONOMIC
COMMODITY…FEW IF ANY INDIAN SOCIETIES WERE FAMILIAR WITH THE
IDEA OF A FENCED-OFF PIECE OF LAND BELONGING FOREVER TO A SINGLE
INDIVIDUAL OR FAMILY. THERE WAS NO MARKET IN REAL STATE BEFORE
THE COMING OF EUROPEANS. NOR WERE INDIANS DEVOTED TO THE
ACCUMULATION OF WEALTH AND MATERIAL GOODS” (FONER 10).
EARLY VOICES:
THE INDIANS HAD NOT ACTUALLY ”USED” THE
LAND; THEY COULD NOT CLAIM IT
MYTH 16 INDIAN CASINOS
MYTH 18: ALCOHOLISM
UNIT 3: COLONIZATION
Colonization, Otherness, Construction of Narratives
Religious element
Material interest
o Thomas More Utopia 1516. (account of an Incan empire in Peru)- there exists alternative organizations.
“White”
End 16th c
France
More respectful attitude:
Learning the language of the natives
Did not seek extermination or displacement of tribes
Established alliances with native tribes against the English
Cartier (1530s)
o Eastern Canada
Verrazano (c.1524)
o North Carolina, reached New York (cfr. Verrazano Bridge btw Staten
Island and Brooklyn)
DUTCH
Henry Hudson (Dutch East India Company)
o “
Broadway ( brot weg) a hunting way
“From the earliest narratives, dreams of overwhelming whole races and conquering cities of stupendous wealth commingle with dreams of saving
souls from eternal perdition. Such aspirations reflect what can be called a multinational competition for dominance and possession, not only of
particular isolated spaces but of entire peoples and ways of life” (Carla Mulford, “Cultures in Contact: Voices from the Imperial Frontier,” Heath
Anthology, 110-115, Vol.1.)
For 8 years: lived with different tribes after surviving a Spanish expedition of “La Florida”
First-hand observer (cfr. De las Casas)
“Captivity Narrative”
Construction of the other
Proto-anthropologist
Mary Rowlandson
“The Narrative of the Captivity and the Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson" (1682)
sense of fear and revulsion of the wilderness and her Indian captors
”The main lure for emigrants from England to the New World was not so much riches
in gold and silver as the promise of Independence that followed from owning land.
Economic freedom and the possibility of passing it on to one’s children attracted the
largest number of English colonists” (Foner, Give Me Liberty! An American History,
59)
FROM THE START: SELF-GOVERNMENT
•Progressive transformation into ROYAL COLONIES (by mid 18thc)
•–Direct rule by the Monarchy
–Governors appointed by the crown
SPONSORS
•Crown: hard-pressed for funds
•The Virginia Co.
–A private business
–Shareholders (merchants, aristocrats, members of Parliament)
•Settlers: men
–Whats does this reveal about the interest of the Company?
•Not an interest in establishing a functional society (Zinn, Foner)
•Early history of the settlement:
•
–Not promising
–Changing leadership
–High death rate
–Expected riches like those found by Spain, did not materialize
PROBLEMS
•Mosquitoes: swamp with malaria-carrying mosquitoes
•Winter: diseases, running short of provisions
•By the end 1607: half the initial population
JOHN SMITH
–Soldier, leadership (freed himself from captivity while fighting in Turkey)
–Strict discipline, “iron rule”
–Powhatans: Corn and Tobacco
SURVIVAL OF COLONY
•Promotion of migration
–50 acres of land awarded to any colonist who paid for his own or another’s passage
(Foner 59)
TOBACCO
•1616: JOHN ROLFE + PLANTERS learn how to raise tobacco
•Popular for smoking in England and Europe.
•Long cultivated in the West Indies
•Initially:
•King James I denounced smoking as “a custom loathsome to the eye, hateful to the
nose, harmful to the brain, [and] dangerous to the lungs” (Qtd. In Taylor, 134)
•Eventually:
–Accepts. The crown derives large gains from taxing tobacco imports
•Addictive: consumers would pay high prices to satisfy their craving.
•Long, hot, humid growing season.
–Crop thrives in Virginia, not in England.
•By 1638: Virginia is the main supplier of tobacco to Europe.
EFFECTS
•LAND
–Wars with native americans
•LABOR
–Indentured servants
•Surrender their freedom (5-/ years)
•In Exchange for passage + freedom dues (land, clothes)
–Slaves (1619)
See Foner pp.60-61
•Colonists force a treaty on Native Americans
–Subordination to the colony
–Required to move westwards
–Not allowed to enter areas of European settlement
–Progressive expansion of of European settlers
PLYMOUTH and MASSACHUSETTS, NEW ENGLAND (CLASS 17/11/2020)
MIGRATION 1620
1620: The Mayflower. “The Pilgrim Fathers”
o Plymouth
o Historical controversy over destination (Permission from London Co. To settle in
Virginia)
[See Loewen: Chapter 3 “The Truth About the First Thanksgiving”]
Background:
o Colonizers: they could pay their own way across the Atlantic. The
“middling sorts”.
Small property holders: farmers, shopkeepers, skilled artisans
PLYMOUTH COLONY
James I: persecution of radical Puritans + threat of poverty in England
1621
o John Winthrop “To create a city upon a hill” (Sermon "A Model of
Christian Charity“, on board the Arbella)
o American dream
1630-31: Hungry winter
Afterwards:
o colonists raise enough food to sustain themselves and new emigrants.
. Expansion into the interior
"When the Pilgrims came to New England, they too were coming not to vacant land but to territory inhabited by tribes of Indians. The governor of
the Massachusetts Bay Colony, John Winthrop, created the excuse to take Indian land by declaring the area legally a 'vacuum.' The Indians, he
said, had not 'subdued' the land, and therefore had only a 'natural' right to it, but not a 'civil right.' A 'natural right' did not have legal standing" (Zinn
13).
"The Puritans also appealed to the Bible… 'Ask of me, and I shall give thee, the heathen for thine inheritance, and the uttermost parts of the earth
for thy possession.' And to justify their use of force to take the land, they cited Romans 13:2: 'Whosoever therefore resisteth the power, resisteth
the ordinance of God: and they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation." (Zinn 14)
Composition of population
Unusually homogeneous colonial population and culture: free, white, and transplanted English
PURITANISM 2
Narratives
"When the Pilgrims came to New England, they too were coming not to vacant land but to territory inhabited by tribes of Indians. The governor of
the Massachusetts Bay Colony, John Winthrop, created the excuse to take Indian land by declaring the area legally a 'vacuum.' The Indians, he
said, had not 'subdued' the land, and therefore had only a 'natural' right to it, but not a 'civil right.' A 'natural right' did not have legal standing" (Zinn
13).
"The Puritans also appealed to the Bible… 'Ask of me, and I shall give thee, the heathen for thine inheritance, and the uttermost parts of the earth
for thy possession.' And to justify their use of force to take the land, they cited Romans 13:2: 'Whosoever therefore resisteth the power, resisteth
the ordinance of God: and they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation." (Zinn 14)
PURITANISM
Puritans:
Common Belief:
DOCTRINE CALVINISM
Human beings: innately sinful/depraved
-SALVATION
-ETERNAL HELLFIRE
Who chooses?
’
God s hand present everywhere (cfr. J. Winthrop’s “Journal”)
vices prohibited
Development
o SECULARIZATION
“The United States government’s support of slavery was based on an overpowering practicality. In 1790, a thousand tons of cotton were being
produced every year in the South. By 1860, it was a million. A system harried by slave rebellions and conspiracies (…Nat Turner, 1831) developed
a network of controls in the southern states, backed by the laws, courts, armed forces, and race prejudice of the nation’s political leaders.” (Zinn
167)
o Human beings can be properly classified acc. to skin color (later development)
[… be it enacted and declared by this Grand Assembly if any slave resist his master (or other but his master’s order correcting him) and by the
extremity of the correction should chance to die, that his death shall not be accounted a felony, but the master (or that other person appointed by
the master to punish him) be acquitted from molestation, since it cannot be presumed that premeditated malice (which alone makes murder a
felony) should induce any man to destroy his own estate.
Slavery: for life + slaves can replace themselves. Child born in slavery belongs to master.
WHY?
RAIDING THE INTERIOR
TRADE
Why is this fact relevant?
Who?
captured in war
Time
Initial capture ----- to -----barracoon: possibly up to 4 months while waiting for a slaver (ship that carries slaves)
TRANSPORTATION
"As the slaves come down from the inland country, they are put into booth or prison [barracoons] ...near the beach, and when the Europeans are
to receive them, they are brought out onto a large plain, where the ship's surgeons examine every part of everyone of them, to the smallest
member, men and women being stark naked... Such as are allowed good and sound are set on one side...marked on the breast with a red-hot
iron, imprinting the mark of the French, English, or Dutch companies...The branded slaves after this are returned to their former booths where they
await shipment, sometimes 10-15 days...” (Benjamin Quarles, The Negro in the Making of America)
WHY NAKED?
Proliferation of disease
No weaponry on board
Ships overcrowded.
Space
"On the ships the space allowed a slave was confined to the amount of deck in which he could lie down, and the decks were so narrow as to
permit just enough height for the slave to crawl out to the upper deck at feeding time” (Quarles).
"The hazards of nature were not as vexing as the behavior of the slaves. Some committed suicide by managing to jump through the netting that
had been rigged around the ship to prevent that very step. Others seemed to have lost the will to live. To guard against such suicidal melancholy,
a ceremony known as 'dancing the slaves' was practiced: they were forced to jump up and down to the tune of the fiddle, harp, or bagpipes. A
slave who tried to go on a hunger strike was forcibly fed, by means of a 'mouth-opener' containing live coals” (Quarles).
Spoon-fashion
Vulnerability of Women
Sexual violence
Harriet Ann Jacobs, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl (1861, published under Linda Brent)
Mutinies?
Some
The “Amistad” (1808 Transatlantic slave trade banned in Britain and the U.S.)
Most: were lost at sea, did not know how to redirect the vessel.
Cfr. Herman Melville “Benito Cereno”, Capt Amasa Delano (unreliable narrator)
o Those in power (white, male planters and rulers) find ways to protect their interests
SLAVERY
American colonies
o Racial hatred
o Lifelong
o Morally devastating
Africa
large planters
numerous lesser planters
Tenant Farmers
convicts, indentured servants
slaves
SLAVERY IN THE NORTH
Slaves:
o Worked in farms, in artisan shops, loading and unloading ships, personal servants
Intricate system of control as more and more slaves populate the colonies
Disunity:
Hierarchy:
Sexual abuse
Break up of families
o Network of people; help and shelter to runaway slaves from the South
Renderings
o “
the Declaration of Independence
”
o the process towards independence
Features
Revolution in thought:
REASON at the center of the universe.
Human beings can control their destiny
GOD is replaced by reason as the source of explanation
Preceded by Scientific and Philosophical revolution – establish roots
o Newton (1643-1727)
Gravitation
Universe moves according to natural laws
Philosophical
o Descartes (1596-1650)
Rationalism, “cogito ergo sum”
Political Thought
John Locke (1632-1704)
o Theory of Natural Rights: Life, Liberty, Property
o
Responsibility of the State: to protect them
Rousseau (1712-1778)
o “The Social Contract” (1762)
A contract
Individual free to cancel this contract
Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790)
wealthy,a man
and healthy,
wise
Founded a fire
club, a hospital,co.,” a debating
a libray,..
Outstanding scientist
oLightning rod
oThe franklin stove
A cast-iron heating stove
shaped like a fireplace but employing metal baffles to increase its heating
efficiency; used to warm, farmhouses and homes for more than 250 years
American ambassador to France (secured military aid from France during Am.
Rev.)
Negotiated final treaty
Characteristics
Service to God ---- service to Society
o Practical aspect
Improvement through reason.
Articulates American ideals (+Emerson):
power of the individual
The American Dream: rise to prominence from obscurity
Edwards (1703-58)
o Against vices, “social evils”, making money
o Emotional appeal + fear
1741 “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” (Sermon)
o Horrors of hell
o All kinds of details
o God is fearsome, ferocious, delights in suffering
“There is nothing that keeps wicked men at any one moment out of hell, but the mere pleasure of God…His arbitrary Will, restrained
by no obligations, hindered by no manner of difficulty
”
“... ‘There is nothing that keeps wicked men at any one moment out of hell, but the mere pleasure of God,’ By the mere pleasure of
God, I mean His sovereign pleasure, His arbitrary will, restrained by no obligations, hindered by no manner of difficulty...
”
“Yea, God is a deal more angry with great numbers that are now on earth: yea, doubtless, with many that are now in this
congregation, who it may be are at ease, than He is with many of those who are now in the flames of hell.”
“The bow of God’s wrath is bent, and the arrow made ready on the string, and justice bends the arrow at your heart, and strains the
bow, and it is nothing but the mere pleasure of God, and that of an angry God, without any promise or obligation at all, that keeps the arrow one
moment from being made drunk with your blood.”
“The God that holds you over the pit of hell, much as one holds a spider or some loathsome insect over the fire, abhors you, and is
dreadfully provoked: His wrath towards you burns like fire; He looks upon you as worthy of nothing else but to be cast into the fire”
“And though He will know that you cannot bear the weight of omnipotence treading upon you, yet He will not regard that, but He will crush you
under His feet without mercy; He will crush out your blood, and make it fly and it shall be sprinkled on His garments, so as to stain all His raiment.
He will not only hate you, but He will have you in the utmost contempt: no place shall be thought fit for you, but under His feet to be trodden down
as the mire of the streets”
Effects
Key role in the revolutionary process: Colonies’ first Mass Movement (sense of unity)
“The Declaration of Independence” 4th July 1776 (CLASS 11/01/2021)
•Thomas Jefferson + a committee of 5
•Emblem of freedom
•Rights and potential of the individual
•Universal impact; inspiration for later revolutions
•ASSERTION of the right of revolution
•18th c interests for the individual
•Cfr. Puritans/belief in a new country
TAXATION